Amy Macdonald - Mr Brightside [HMV Glasgow Instore]

[XStereotypist]

@Aujaujauj It's called being an alto, you ass. -_-

[Aujaujauj]

What's up with your voice??? Like a transsexual!! Damn u're awful!

[iidynamicsii]

@Aujaujauj It's called non-computer generated talent... Go away and listen to a few popsters for yourself..

[stagefreakmusic]

I was there.. nice to see it again :)

[schokomuffinx3]

schreckliche vergewaltigung eines wunderschönen liedes.!

[Nudel14]

@schokomuffinx3 recht hast du xD

[jazz6582]

love this girl

[fly86m]

Leider eine sehr misslungene Version eines an sich wunderschönen Liedes....! Sehr schade..! :( Aber die 50%-igen Negativ-Kommentare sprechen ja für sich....

[juliaandherpiano]

You don't expect that voice to come from her :) Very unique and confident

juliaandherpianoxx

[ali3ae]

Nice cover. Havent heard it played quite like that before. I tried to cover it but came out with a really chilled out version. you should check out my vids and let me know what you think.

[cityprettyxo5]

very unique voice, as unusual as it may be i think it should definitely be appreciated. :)

[PaulaMC269]

she can try, but nobody can be better than brandon, but still good

[aeroforce1ist]

hooorrible

[aeroforce1ist]

hooorrible

[LookerQQ4]

@garethcarr She was 18 or 19 at the time. Her voice is distinct and beautiful IMOP. Doubt you could come close. The world doesn't need another Winehouse or gaga with gaga's ridiculous shrieking and winehouse's vomit. Amy Macdonald is natural and engaging. She has a spirit and unique sound. I, for one, admire her talent. You, on the other hand, can't hear.

[wolfman19892]

@LookerQQ4 well said , lady gaga is a corporate creation and the all vommiting shit of the world lol ,

amy mcdonald is famous because of her beauty ( don't get me wrong not just as in looks) but a beauty that reflects in everything she does like music and I dunno its just like an aura lol

[garethcarr]

Her voice is awful.

[swanmcswan]

the thing is....... its just not the same song......it doesnt evoke the feelings of the original ..... "remind" me of it, so to say, which many acoustic verisons do........ fair do's for doing it in an original way, but you are playing someone elses song, which by the sounds of it you rly like...... so less 'originality', more paying tribute to it :)

[Kennethstef]

very unique vocals .... not 2 bad tho

[MissSaorise]

I love this version... How many times did I listen to this song by Amy? I don't know:)

[AmyMacDRocks]

Beautiful cover, well done Amy!

[clintonman]

That's one burly voice. Try to tone it down to a more... you know... feminine thing.

[thisishowtolookgood]

you do it dick face

[BladeAndSoul]

You do realise if she makes her voice sound different she doesnt have her unique voice anymore.

This dark sound in her voice is what makes her different from other singers.

Im so sick of lady gaga shit voices everywhere in pop music.

Im so glad amy has made music good with her different voice.

[clintonman]

@BladeAndSoul U butthurt?

[annemiiieee]

Brandon Flowers is the only one who should sing the song!!! sorry amy

[crazycraig150]

I love this version!!!!!!!!!!

[RockAngel68]

Oho she had an awesome voice !!!! This version is so cool !! I saw her in Colmar she's so good live !!!!!!!!

[mcphee1888]

I cant even understand this munter and im from glasgow as well, she sucks big hairy baws!

[revilo178]

then you're an idiot because I do understand this and I'm not even from Britain ;-)

[mcphee1888]

Cause you know the fuckin song you complete tadger. Immigrant cunt!

[revilo178]

I'm not an immigrant u twat. just to put things right.

[revilo178]

to be sure, she doesn't sing in Glaswegian, but (a slight accent nonwithstanding) in standard English. maybe is this your problem?

[mcphee1888]

You Are just babling on about some amount of shite now immigrant, and how can she not sing with a glaswegian accent ya tit when she is from glasgow and clearly talks with the accent, silly wee boy you are man and the comment back about "cunt" totally never made sense man, you sure your not an immigrant?

[revilo178]

there is something called "profile", retard, which shows I'm not an immigrant. but why do I waste my time with you.

[mcphee1888]

Is There really? thank god you told me that or I would have never have known that, that's for being a right smarty pants and pointing that really really interesting point out, Tit!

[GossenGlamour]

oh my god... I like the killers version better :-/

[Buddickory]

She's so good live =)

[icyha0]

wtf?

[richiemayne]

how did this crap get 4 stars?

she's ruined a brilliant song.

[Nhurm]

well she really improved this song

[avvertitemiiii]

FANTASTICA!!!! Grande Amy, quando vieni in Italia? Adoro le tue musiche!!!

[MICKYMILOR1992]

TOMMY REILLY VERSION

[TheHobbit1000]

his version is crap

[LOVExRHCP]

I like it, though the version of the Killers is better! It doesn't really suite her voice, and her accent makes it sound a bit strange...

Don't get me wrong! I really like her and I've got her album, but I just think their version is better...

[gla2005]

her voice make her sound like she's singing some national anthem theme

[AnnelinWT]

The Killers are way better, stupid Amy

[hidemichiXT]

I like her slow tempo.

And she has brilliant voice.

And she's beautiful :)

[StevieNL]

fucking briljant

[AyeYirMa]

omg she's reeeeally killing it

i really like her but this son really doesnt show off the best of her voice or the song :/

[CelesteEyed]

omg.. crap

[GixAGEN]

definitely.

low, straight tone is not suitable for a melody everyone knows by heart

[roelvdm3]

great!

verry good song (just like al the others of her especial L.A.)

[revilo178]

but it's not from her but from the Killers...

[almakg]

i love her, but that low tone, takes away the spice and of the song...

[evade531]

in my humble opinion WAY better than the killers she is talented and is not as big as she should be

[ilakim26]

sucks.

[DJAK1986]

wtf!! is she posessed???

[chiccosanchez]

looolz

[musicforeverx]

not bad.

there are some parts i like

[well742003]

not bad ,,reminds me of morticia..adams..doin it...

[WRevolver]

mmmmmmmmm

[flometzler]

monotonous

[riby28]

WTF

she raped it

son of a......

[kathyyes]

nice song ;) good choise

[pinkxxink]

that's awful ..

[misterpang2]

absolutely f........g awful !!

[revilo178]

Amy has done several covers, among which at least "dancing in the dark" blows the original out of the water. this one doesn't, but it is nice though. there also are better performances of this song by herself to be found on youtube. on the other hand the Killers themselves aren't always that good live; the performance that I deem exceptional and the best ever (T in the Park 2005) is among my favorites.

[revilo178]

This is probably the best performance of this song by Amy:

v=iW_b51DZT-o

[Siiroy]

craaap

[zigornia]

sounds like a drunk scott!!!haha!!!!shes takin the piss!

[powerofbasss]

i like it! i like your accent!

[arfhip]

To be honest i dont like this. She looks like she needs to pee. and i dont like that accent that much, for this song that is. and please. no haters need to reply saying " Ur retarded, and Amy Macdonal owns! " in my opinion she does not.

[revilo178]

"in my opinion she does not [own]"

No, she "rules" ^^

Seriously: everyone is free not to like this cover, and this should be taken for granted even by Amy fans.

off topic: is it just me or does she sing especially slowly when singing instore? does this have something to do with recording technique?

[satty5]

I kinda like this,

I think its cause of her Scottish accent that makes its sound slightly weird! Its different. In a good way.

[chitarrista1988]

this cover sucks

[bimcsi]

no way... just leave it to the killers

[perduaparis]

absolutely brilliant

[punkloverSP6]

I love that version...but the Killers are a bit better

[VenzMeister]

Sorry but your version isn't going anywhere (^^,)

[revilo178]

where is it supposed to "go"?

[beatboy001]

It is  very nice music

[Incredevil]

mhhhh.... mhhhh... this is her style, but i dont like it :( her voice doesnt fit the song.

[raynemaniac]

one word.. ugly.

[puzon133]

She's awesome, she's hot, she's my Idol :D

[revilo178]

Nobody has ot to like this cover but the dickheads who hate on an artist who made 100 concerts in 2008 while they themselves are just sitting in front of the pc and flattening their ass should go and die in a fire. wtf!

[sampr94]

what a wnk cover

she sings like a pissing robot

bring on the killers anyday

one word shite

[goncaloduarte1992]

your voice really sucks -.-'

[stewthemilkfedjew]

Why don't you animals from South America stay down there and watch your Univision?

[GodBlessWinchesters]

I LOVE her cover on this song! I just can stop listen to it.

[xXxmattexxXx]

she suck! the killers is 1000 times better!

[Gruesche]

why is she singing so ... weird ? it doesn't sound like her normal voice

[chiznarlie]

mangled that one

[FunkyChaMoi]

Does someone has the chords she uses ?

[cuove]

The way she said "price i pay" made me cringe.

[boybandmassacre]

hmmmm...its shite!

[vanderfoxe]

d way shes pronouncing d words is all, sounds like her glans are swolen

[maryanx87]

It's not bad but I think she can do it better!

[GraciePupLove]

Ummm..... Ick

[RudolfSchoepke]

She needs a little, but then she begins to roll, over all fantastic

[xRebekahRomance]

Your voice is very unique, its cool (:

Keep it up, screw what everyone is saying.

[Saeniac]

omg..thats bad -.-

[XxXundertheroseXxX]

bad cover.

[dunboynee]

cllllllllllllllllaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaasssssssssssssssss!!!!!

hu do all these ppl leaving bad comments think they are???

they can say what the want if they've sold more singles than her!!

[cuove]

There probably people who think there entitled to their own opinion....oh wait....they ARE....

[dunboynee]

Are you simon cowell????

or do you have a record label??

Then shut the fuck up, You dont know your arse from your mouth

[cuove]

Do you have to have a record label to have an opinion on a song? nope. im tired of people like you who act like u need a degree in music to say u dont like something. and before ustart iv been playin guitar for 9 years so dont stay sayin " oh ur jealous" which is the usual reply from people like you. If u want to talk about this, message me dont just act hard by running ur mouth on comments like this. Message me if u want to actually talk about it.

[BonsisOklahoma]

do you have a record label? i love this version of the song.. but you don't need to be so critical. by the way you are acting, its worse than the person's actual comment. let's keep youtube an honest opinion free place. with courtesy obviously as well.

[revilo178]

BonsisOklahoma, you're damn right.

[greenpluggedtankers]

holy shit. how could you put this song on youtube. ok you suckkk. find a new career. iam sry but your just not good!

[blondiesj]

Thats Just damage to my ears! think we can safetly say her ball's dropped a lon time ago an her family prob call her Uncle amy !

She murdered a good song!!!

[MonsieurLecreaux]

I personaly think it fits well...a marmite like song.

[woofyblue]

ur voice is like, vibrating....u should try a different song, sounds cool tho!

[Brethitmanhart1]

hmm,wondering whether to write this because it will just get aload of thumbs down, but like, she is murdering the song. Vocals are terrible for this song, they don't suit.

And btw, she is so putting on that fucking accent too, it's annoying.

I know theres gonna be amy fans her, but come on her voice does not suit this song and it's a murdering of a legendary song.

[1ripEDcurl]

I think your right - yes it is a legendary song, but why cant amy cover this song in her own way? And I also think that her voice doesn´t siut to the original killers version. But I think it shouldnt´t sound like the orginal version. I like this cover!

[suttony]

seriously her voice is so bad for this song

im not saying that cause shes scottish but cause it completely wrecks a perfectly good song

im sure shes good at singing

but not at this song

leave it to the flowers

[jimmylittleuk]

this lady is a legend!

[apmproductions18018]

the guitar is good but... the voice is a little unsuiting for the song.

[ichliebebill94]

great singer

great song

all is perfect!

[thiagoss7]

So sweet... Good cover.

[daveador]

the guitar is good but... the voice is a little unsuiting for the song.

[xAnnonymusxSingerx]

Its Cool! :D x

She Stays Only An Hour And A Half Away Or Something From Me

[123098mom]

Haha. She does have a cool voice.

I'm not sure about this song TBH though. I don't think it suits her.

Class song though, and she's a class artist.

[Nevy91]

I love her voice,

I love her songs,

I love THE KILLERS

Perfect match!

[Shoesonfoxes]

Oh my fucking god, everyone who says her singing voice is shite should go die in a fire. Seriously I'm scottish and her accent is fucking sexy; she has an amazing voice. It might sound weird because it's not her song.

Her own stuff is strong and fantastic.

I'd like to see you tasteless morons do better.

[maccazord]

im scotish and i think her voice is crap haha

[Brethitmanhart1]

I hate the whole "you couldn't do better" atitude, how do you know that in the first place, it's not like people who aren't famous can't be good singers.

And imo, she is not a good singer because for a girl she has no power in her voice and the tone and accent are a killer, I can understand the perosn that said it makes them feel sick, because it does for me too.

[revilo178]

no power in her voice? o course u are entitled to ur opinion but this is just...

[Anybodiesmusic]

listen to when she sings lines like "price I pay" and "eager eyes"....no power in her voice.

And also, like, why do you assume that everyone who writes a comment you disagree with is not working towards something and just sitting on their ass. Stupid logic

[revilo178]

I never wrote that. being able to read helps sometimes.

[Anybodiesmusic]

"but the dickheads who hate on an artist who made 100 concerts in 2008 while they themselves are just sitting in front of the pc and flattening their ass should go and die in a fire."'

Yup you didn't say that! haha

[revilo178]

There is a little bit of a difference between "stating an opinion I don't agree with" and "hating on someone". honestly, I didn't think it was so difficult.

[bluebleeblahblah]

her singing voice makes me feel sick

[coleloue]

this is a cover of the killers which i think is brillant well done amy.

[jasperduivelke]

wtf! this is awefull

[SirGogan]

she sounds like a girl trying to put a mans voice on... she can sing better than this.

[deboheinze]

It wasn't an insult when I said she sounds like Shakira, and of course I'm free to say whatever I want =)

Now I know who put thumbs down in my comment =P

haha

it's ok there are people who don't like hearing different oppinions =P

[JOANAVB]

british version of shakira

[rockeravril]

che donna!! What a women!! Love her...

[az3ra]

Love it!unique

[bernardmcgough]

pure class sung with emotion

[stelplate]

beautifull woman!

[Triecat]

Blueberrysquash i agree with you completly yes the Killers version is more upbeat but i love this version cos of the fact its slower and people hoo think its naff Amy is a HUGE Killers fan and would not do their song if it was going to be a bad cover!!

[georgitsa1]

i think she sounds better than shakira...go girl!!!!

[deboheinze]

she sounds quite like Shakira

[Skull0Inc]

no, she's scottish. Oh what the hey, whatever you say.

[davelfcfan]

she killed the song

[kLein0Tschassi]

Her voice is too dark, but to sing this song is not easy.

I like her dark voice

[Frozenbloodelf]

WTF this sounds like shit!

[sabitanclip]

bad cover

[rockeravril]

why?????

[monimarta1]

wcale nie zepsułą tej piosenki!!!!!!!! zaspiewala z własną interpretacja :)) jak sie nie podoba zaspiewajcie lepiej!!!!!!

[Owen84uk]

Not that I wanna spark an arguement, but I really think she has killed this song, just as FallOut Boy did. I've heard better covers in my local pub

[Blueberrysquash]

i think shes f*ckin great actually, yea its not her own song, but her voice is fantastic and such passion. how anyone can say this isnt good is beyond me. this girl is great!

[x3ELINE]

mmh, she can do better!

[BubbleOnDrugs]

omg...poor song...I like This Is The Life by Amy but this song...is...not for her!!!

[RyanBrickForce]

fuck, she butchered it! wheres the tune? lol

[FeelingUntouched]

Oh, I didn't even recognice it!

Just because I knew it. And of course, when you listen to the lyrics, but I like The Killers' Version a lot better.

[fern244]

Its bad but Amy says shes a huge fan and wants to work with them soon.

[xsalzx]

dont like it! with that accent coming out so strong aswell!!!!!!

[HP198]

nowhere near as good as the killers!

[TheRegster]

Genuine passion, genuine sincerity - REAL and with feeling....Amy all over! Loved it!

[rezcrash88]

This is great its done with nothing really !! Just listen to the voice .  fantastic.

[sizing]

Wow I thought she was just shit

that is the worst bull shit ive ever heard!

[kanmna]

OMG rthats AWFULL!!! buaaaaaah

[mattitudey2j]

Oh dear GOD this is awful