salam: brother u stated in video if we say hindustand so we can not say to all of that people who stay in india "hindu" so same here we can not say to all Afghans that they are afghans. in fact brother u don't have enough information please study much Afghan doesn't mean pashtuns. pashtuns are just a part of people who live in afghanistan and we call all nation all people who talke by different languages afghans. and also the word afghanistan stated by ahmad shah baba not by some one else.
All Tajiks of Afghanistan till creation of Khorasan should name hemselves 'afghanistani' (not 'afghani'! 'Afghani' means 'bekong to Aghans'), instead of 'Afghan'. Because Tajiks are a different nation from Afghans, Tajiks have higher culture and Tajiks have nothing general with Afghans. When, inshaallah, Afghanistan will be renamed into Khorasan or Khorasan will be separated from Afghanistan-Pushtunistan, Tajiks will name themselves Tajiks-Khorasanians.
brother u have to fix ur mind u r just a simple ton.
before abusing others think hundred times.
i also can abuse u but sorry i am an Afghan. the creator of this video i think an uneducated person who doesn't have enough information about history so don't judge about it.
im sorry for you donkeys that u dont have any name in international comunity.afghanistan is for afghans ..hell dozaht is for tajiks..tajikistan is for orignal tajiks and they ll never let you stupid animal
Afghan means a dog and I, too, as a Kabuli Tajik would never associate myself with dog, and Talibs. "Afghanistan" is a phoney name,given by the British.
An honorable hazara, tajik, uzbek, noristani, baloch would identify himself with his ethinc group or as a Khorasani. He shouldnt lower himself to a status of a dog or Afghan or volunterily associate himself with terrorism, taliban, homosexual or suicide bombers that pashtoons or afghans are in southern afghanistan and NWFP of Pakistan.
Well, at least you agree that you are not Afghan, and you agree that any non-Pashtuns are not Afghans. Everything else you said, I don't agree with it, but you have the right to express yourself.
In English speak world, Afghan means dog, afghan hound... i as a tajik do not want to be associated with dog or afghan hound... today afghan stands for taliban, terrorism, homosexuality, suicide bombers, opium cultivator, and smuggler, which uzbek, hazara, tajik in the right state of mind want to be associated to stuff that i mentioned above?
u fuckin idiot..afghan hound is "tazi" which can be found only in afghanistan...when they say afghan hound it means the dog found in afghanistan..u dumbasss!!!
Afghan is an ethnicity NOT a nationality. Check out an encyclopedia and read who Afghans were. You moron, don't call anyone an idiot. This is a discussion, only express your opinion.
u know what seanucd, anyone can write a fuckin encyclopedia like any other book. i'll give you an example. a british encyclopedia called the reign of Amanullah Khan dictatorship while the same encyclopedia claimed Abdur Rahman Khan as the founding father of modern Afghanistan.
fact: Amanullah Khan kicked the british out and declared AFGHAN independence. also fact: abdur Rahman khan sold afghanistan to british. you should know better than anyone that those kind of resources come with biases and personal fuckin beliefs..whatever they like they write...it is us who define who we are...Afghanistan is land of the AFGHANs, regardless of being pashtoon, hazara, uzbek, tajik, turkmen....and what not and dont give me this ethnicity shit.
salam: brother u stated in video if we say hindustand so we can not say to all of that people who stay in india "hindu" so same here we can not say to all Afghans that they are afghans. in fact brother u don't have enough information please study much Afghan doesn't mean pashtuns. pashtuns are just a part of people who live in afghanistan and we call all nation all people who talke by different languages afghans. and also the word afghanistan stated by ahmad shah baba not by some one else.
khyberhemat1 2 years ago
All Tajiks of Afghanistan till creation of Khorasan should name hemselves 'afghanistani' (not 'afghani'! 'Afghani' means 'bekong to Aghans'), instead of 'Afghan'. Because Tajiks are a different nation from Afghans, Tajiks have higher culture and Tajiks have nothing general with Afghans. When, inshaallah, Afghanistan will be renamed into Khorasan or Khorasan will be separated from Afghanistan-Pushtunistan, Tajiks will name themselves Tajiks-Khorasanians.
Afrasiabjan 4 years ago
All YOU AFGHANS ARE STUPID AND IDIOT!!!
Francohouse1999 4 years ago
brother u have to fix ur mind u r just a simple ton.
before abusing others think hundred times.
i also can abuse u but sorry i am an Afghan. the creator of this video i think an uneducated person who doesn't have enough information about history so don't judge about it.
khyberhemat1 2 years ago
im sorry for you donkeys that u dont have any name in international comunity.afghanistan is for afghans ..hell dozaht is for tajiks..tajikistan is for orignal tajiks and they ll never let you stupid animal
hashimkhost 4 years ago
afghan means dog and afghanistani means a citizen of afghanistan. now the choice is yours whether you want to be a citizen of the country or a dog.
PashtonGoySag 5 years ago
Afghan and Afghanistan is the creation of the British. There are Pashtons, but the Afghan thing is phoney and fabrication.
KabulZameen 5 years ago
Afghan means a dog and I, too, as a Kabuli Tajik would never associate myself with dog, and Talibs. "Afghanistan" is a phoney name,given by the British.
KabulZameen 5 years ago
Who is this guys? He is very knowledgeable.
manouchehr78 5 years ago
cool
bbiriya 5 years ago
An honorable hazara, tajik, uzbek, noristani, baloch would identify himself with his ethinc group or as a Khorasani. He shouldnt lower himself to a status of a dog or Afghan or volunterily associate himself with terrorism, taliban, homosexual or suicide bombers that pashtoons or afghans are in southern afghanistan and NWFP of Pakistan.
WaliShah 5 years ago
Well, at least you agree that you are not Afghan, and you agree that any non-Pashtuns are not Afghans. Everything else you said, I don't agree with it, but you have the right to express yourself.
seanucd 5 years ago
In English speak world, Afghan means dog, afghan hound... i as a tajik do not want to be associated with dog or afghan hound... today afghan stands for taliban, terrorism, homosexuality, suicide bombers, opium cultivator, and smuggler, which uzbek, hazara, tajik in the right state of mind want to be associated to stuff that i mentioned above?
WaliShah 5 years ago
u fuckin idiot..afghan hound is "tazi" which can be found only in afghanistan...when they say afghan hound it means the dog found in afghanistan..u dumbasss!!!
sherbachaykaabul 5 years ago
Pashtun = Afghan
Non-Pashtun people of Afghanistan= Afghanistani/Afghani
seanucd 5 years ago
pakiis and iranians call us afghani...we are all AFGHANS...afghani is the money u idiots!!
sherbachaykaabul 5 years ago
Afghan is an ethnicity NOT a nationality. Check out an encyclopedia and read who Afghans were. You moron, don't call anyone an idiot. This is a discussion, only express your opinion.
seanucd 5 years ago
u know what seanucd, anyone can write a fuckin encyclopedia like any other book. i'll give you an example. a british encyclopedia called the reign of Amanullah Khan dictatorship while the same encyclopedia claimed Abdur Rahman Khan as the founding father of modern Afghanistan.
sherbachaykaabul 5 years ago
fact: Amanullah Khan kicked the british out and declared AFGHAN independence. also fact: abdur Rahman khan sold afghanistan to british. you should know better than anyone that those kind of resources come with biases and personal fuckin beliefs..whatever they like they write...it is us who define who we are...Afghanistan is land of the AFGHANs, regardless of being pashtoon, hazara, uzbek, tajik, turkmen....and what not and dont give me this ethnicity shit.
sherbachaykaabul 5 years ago
you're an idiot bro!
Pashtun = one AFGHAN tribe
non-Pashtun people of afghanistan = other AFGHAN tribes
sherbachaykaabul 3 years ago