This comment has received too many negative votesshow
carl is a pretentious twat, this song's written about him and he's singing it... bit wierd, i hate this guy, his voice, his face, evrything, the libertines were good, would've been better if carl just stuck to guitar and kept his chubby fucking mouth shut..............
Stop talking about pete and carl just fucking listen to them you cant compare their as good as each other at everything , the way he says ending fitting i think i just jizzed
No, you've got it the wrong way round, just shut me up and blamed it on the brown" now is "So, I got it the wrong way around?If I cut you out it’s because I blamed it on the brown", "You tried to pull the wool, I wasn't feeling too clever. And you take all that they're lending Until you needed mending" now is: "You could’ve pulled the wool, I wasn’t feeling to clever You see if you take all that we’re lending,It doesnt need any mending now."
@desasterz Walden is deff the best guitarist, but they are different types of musicians, you can't really compare them. Peter Wolfe is great though. I think Graham Coxon is amazing too. Adam Ficek is a very talented musician, also, check out his solo work-under the monica: roses, kings, castles, different to the shambles and Peters solo work, very good though.
i am talking at the acoustic guitar playing level. I can't fell the same armony that pete uses in his plays. The note. The small notes between one note and another. Carl just play normal. And the timing in the acoustic is not as in the electric. It must be more armonic.
Its great that Carl finally plays this, although Pete does a great performance when playing this song, Its seems a bit more fitting and emotive when carl plays it
Honestly, I'd take Carl's by a nose. He has more of an ear for music than Pete. Pete's lyrics do tend to be a tad better than Carl's, but only a bit. In their solo stuff, I like the Dirty Pretty Things albums better than the Babyshambles albums. As a whole I think their songs are put together better and are more consistently good, but I like "Fuck Forever" better than any one of the DPT's songs by themselves.
They're both amazing artists, that's that. Now they need to get back together ASAP.
You could definitely say that. In my opinion Paul&Carl are overall better rock musicians, but as artists in general I think Pete&John are more talented. Which is the better then? I honestly can't tell..
Good comparison, I think Pete, like john is the more poetic idealist, whilst i think Carl can write the more catchy riffs with more mass appeal like mcartney did. I mean hey jude is no imagine, but is the more catchy tune.
All in all i think the highs are higher with petes talent but the lows are lower. (again just like John)
Peter by a whisker. Peter is a ghostly presence and Carl is a full on sex god. Loyalty song is my favourite of all time so it has to be Peter. But Truth Begins is right behind. Wheelies etc.
@benbebin well, carl did write this song, but i do still miss pete's part in the performance....but what became of the likely lads is really carl's song, just as pete's is time for heroes
@antileetclub Actually Pete wrote this. With someone else outside of the band but I can't remember who off the top of my head. This is an epic video though. Emotional!
Barat taught Pete how to play guitar, for starters. So your little comment crashes and burns instantly, just on that note.
Pete could never play those riffs like in "Death On The Stairs" while he sings the way Carl does. Carl also sings in key, where as Pete struggles to do so a lot of the time.
It has certainly come a long way since Up The Bracket. This is never more prevalent than on Grace/Wasteland.
Regardless, even in his solo performances he often struggles to remain in key. It's not really a bad thing, because it allows him to put much more emotion into the song, I feel. He makes it work somehow, and that's really all that counts in the end.
ah i met Carl at the afterparty of Dirty Pretty Things in Dublin, great fun! smokin smoke in a karaoke bar til 5am and then to a house party!! good fun!!
every minute i think of the libertines wherever its about the music, or how much i admire carl and pete yet unfortunatly i missed the libertines as i was only 14 when the second album was released. so please can everyone help me in some way to bring them back as it would be pure bliss
Both Pete and Carl are amazing. Get back together now while it still matters, not as some fat middle-aged need the money renuion at the bloody Albert Hall in 20 years time.
i ke wea en a carl con la cancion. dandole conga con la voz de pete... te sale re piola... nunca vas a saber k mierda digo. soy chileno y k chucha. a la mierda! buena musica, se k pronto estaran juntos again jejejej
every time i hear carl and pete sing each others parts of the song when they play it alone, it feels just as sad as the last time i saw it. i wish they'd get back together
"so "I" got it the wrong way round, "I" cut you out coz "I" blamed it on the brown", i think tht carl is tryin to tell people how he feels about the libertines n tht its all his fault, the man is a legend, along with pete! y cant they jst get back together? c'mon boys please work sumthing out :D x
he changes most of pete lyrics
CarEdy23 3 weeks ago
Carl looks a bit like a young Al Pacino :)
harison92 2 months ago 4
I wonder if people who've thumbed up nicococo's comment realize he's saying Barat's performance is crap.
sh0wbiz 3 months ago 5
I just noticed Carl's face reminds me of Jimmy Page's face! :O
mindingosafado 3 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
carl is a pretentious twat, this song's written about him and he's singing it... bit wierd, i hate this guy, his voice, his face, evrything, the libertines were good, would've been better if carl just stuck to guitar and kept his chubby fucking mouth shut..............
MaxxJayy 3 months ago
@MaxxJayy fuck you.
MzMaihem 3 months ago 6
so sad
TheManiacThatIsEd 4 months ago
am crying :)
mangajerry 4 months ago
The way he changes the lyrics really make me sad :(
OHproductionz 5 months ago 6
:(
ivicadzajo 5 months ago
I just wanna hug him, poor guy
alissewonder 6 months ago
Comment removed
MogliandHiggens 7 months ago
Comment removed
AcousticSolo 8 months ago 3
Does he say 'Do we just keep on pretending and hope our love is never ending?' waaah, that's sad...
MrTommyyMac 8 months ago 2
@MrTommyyMac Yeah, I've heard that too, but I thought it was the English accent messing with my head.
alissewonder 6 months ago
the songs vibe change so much when its accoustic
BeduffKidAli 8 months ago
He changed the lyrics so he's talking to pete, "I got it the wrong way round, i cut you out cos I blamed it on the brown"
BritRock93 9 months ago 8
@BritRock93 No I think they changed it since they released it in all the other versions it's always been brown...
world4twins 5 months ago
i love this fucking sad song
metalcrazy9193 10 months ago 3
marvellous.what a songwriter.
whjmg 10 months ago 2
Cette version est très bien evidemment, mais il manque quelque chose, comme chaque fois qu'elle n'est chantée que par l'un des deux libertines....
TheOnlyJimmyJazz 10 months ago
Cette version est très bien evidemment, mais il manque quelque chose, comme chaque fois qu'elle n'est chantée que par l'un des deux libertines....
TheOnlyJimmyJazz 10 months ago
Carl is nothing without Doherty, and Doherty is nothing without Carl, and the 2 guys are nothing without Libertines
j67344726 10 months ago
Carl..absolutley fab xxx
burbleshark 10 months ago
This is the saddest version I've ever heard.
MoiEtMaLapine 11 months ago 4
This is the saddest cover I've ever heard.
MoiEtMaLapine 11 months ago
Rather poor playing I must say.
Monumentum616 11 months ago
I cry every time I hear this song.
lilianafallen 1 year ago
ptm de lo mejor:I
yanteroses 1 year ago
is that ron moody playing that guitar ? he sounds like ron moody in oliver twist very east end whitechapel
lz127graf 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
god he looks so jewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwish and cannot play the guitar properly
lz127graf 1 year ago
@lz127graf You must be such a moron...
Misspotatoe 1 year ago 4
@lz127graf Who cares if he looks Jewish, hes not but what if he does? Are you some kind of braindead retarded Nazi?>
Xiolablu3 9 months ago 2
watch?v=46CNp89_52Y
fondoogle 1 year ago
this just fucking cuts me deep when either carl or pete plays n sings it :'0(
RetroGuy5000 1 year ago
I would have blamed it on the brown too...still, both fucking amazing musicians.
finchy633 1 year ago
Love the heart and of course Carl's classic look and sound.
JDead95 1 year ago
oh bloody wonderful ...
BlondeRocknRoll 1 year ago
his voice is perfect
lyla40s 1 year ago
this version reminds me of billy bragg
WillyWollyWardrobe 1 year ago
Why does he introduce this as You can't stand me?
Ungortable 1 year ago 2
Damn... This is heavy.
JDead95 1 year ago 4
Love it Carl. Come a long way since the Jazz Bar. I blamed it on the brown Lad. Simply the best son. All the best mate.
VampHammer1 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
flanger24banane 1 year ago
carl is my favourite libertine....
6ii1ii9 1 year ago 22
Carls An Amazing Performer Even On His Own.
My 2nd favourite Libertine :)
yetimichael 1 year ago
Carl's too hot to be true
pospolitazuzanna 1 year ago 6
Stop talking about pete and carl just fucking listen to them you cant compare their as good as each other at everything , the way he says ending fitting i think i just jizzed
itsyourpenis 1 year ago 7
C'est nul, je ne vois pas pourquoi il joue ça n'a pas d'intérêt.
67nicococo 1 year ago 11
Mortellement sexy... :)
planetjulie94 1 year ago 2
You can see how tightly he is gripping the guitar at the end of the first chorus... pure emotion. he means every word that he is saying. beautiful.
shwat17 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
"So, I got it the wrong way around?If I cut you out it’s because I blamed it on the brown" His change is heart breaking
xfreakenfiles 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
"So, I got it the wrong way around?If I cut you out it’s because I blamed it on the brown" - the way he changed that broke my heart
xfreakenfiles 1 year ago
No, you've got it the wrong way round, just shut me up and blamed it on the brown" now is "So, I got it the wrong way around?If I cut you out it’s because I blamed it on the brown", "You tried to pull the wool, I wasn't feeling too clever. And you take all that they're lending Until you needed mending" now is: "You could’ve pulled the wool, I wasn’t feeling to clever You see if you take all that we’re lending,It doesnt need any mending now."
Rrrayas 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
carl is a kn*b head luv the way he sings but he wasted petes life the jumped up skaghead petes the fucking man :D
rhiannonnugentx 1 year ago
@rhiannonnugentx erm, as much as a fan i am of pete, what you just said is utter bollocks
ididit11 1 year ago
This video was put on youtube on my 12th birthday!!!! Carl's great and so is Pete. I dream of a permanent Libertines reunion. xOxO
zoeaxoxo 1 year ago
Beautiful sounding guitar,. Think it's the Martin D-28 or is it the Takamine F-360 (Lawsuit era).
Anyway, I like it!
matdelta1 1 year ago
Met Carl last night he is such a nice guy....hi ya!
MsLilianDM 1 year ago
WATCH MY VERSION
DanimalLawlz 1 year ago
is it me or does this song not sound as good without both pete and carl
declanacdc 1 year ago
@declanacdc of course it doesn't. It's still good, but not AS good.
IndieRockGurl 1 year ago
this is heart breaking.
'if i cut you out it's coz i blamed it on the brown'
0Marl 1 year ago 11
love this guy.
N30N94 1 year ago 7
here watch james23678 cover of this it is quality : )
seanbrady180 1 year ago
Comment removed
virvi 1 year ago
He sings " ...and hope our LOVE is never ending" instead of "luck"
Golub812 1 year ago 14
poor carl, he sems lonely without peter
mikamadperson 1 year ago 6
OMG i hadnt seen this one yet! love itttttt
PollyR77 1 year ago
a genius !:D
morpionsuicidaire 1 year ago 3
i creid
piwini 1 year ago
I'm lost for words, he made that so emotional, amazing as ever!
Saracens1st 1 year ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The best musicians Pete's worked with in order
Patrick Waldern
Carl Barrat
Wolfman
Garry Powell
Drew Mc Connel
John Carry
Mick Witnall
desasterz 1 year ago
adam green?
11samwalker 1 year ago
@desasterz Walden is deff the best guitarist, but they are different types of musicians, you can't really compare them. Peter Wolfe is great though. I think Graham Coxon is amazing too. Adam Ficek is a very talented musician, also, check out his solo work-under the monica: roses, kings, castles, different to the shambles and Peters solo work, very good though.
jondesbrow 1 year ago
@desasterz You are a fool if you think Carl isn't top of that list.
If we want to sail the good ship Albion, we NEED Carl and Peter.
Also, you mispelled Carl's surname.
MisterSadistic 1 year ago 3
Goosebumps, and a tear in my eye, all you do is make me cry, a reunion would make me happy indeed, greetings from a lonely Swede.
no1vitskalle 2 years ago 3
fuck, i love him
thesonoflucifer 2 years ago 12
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck, youre gay
VideoKilledYaMum 2 years ago
fuck, youre stupid
thesonoflucifer 2 years ago 6
Carl is a fucking genius
Beckedorff 2 years ago 25
his solo preformances are right up there with petes. wish there was more. great stuff
manhattanishappening 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
it needs to people to sing it
iamtheindyman 2 years ago
Does he introduce this as "You Can't Stand Me"? That cuts me up man. Sad song.
dogsbodyd 2 years ago 98
@dogsbodyd Yeah.They wrote it about each other
Maybsumdayuwillno 1 year ago
I LOVE PETE! if it wasn't 4 him by now i would have never start playing guitar.
JonieAB 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Pete is the best, Carl is good. The libertines 4ever!!!!!
gabyferni 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
correct.
JonieAB 2 years ago
Incorrect.
TheAssandtities 2 years ago 3
i am talking at the acoustic guitar playing level. I can't fell the same armony that pete uses in his plays. The note. The small notes between one note and another. Carl just play normal. And the timing in the acoustic is not as in the electric. It must be more armonic.
JonieAB 2 years ago 4
@JonieAB why the fuck do you keep dropping the h its harmony and harmonic
VideoKilledYaMum 2 years ago 7
@VideoKilledYaMum lol
alistairproductions 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Peter is a drug addict, but sings a lot better.
JonieAB 2 years ago
i don't agree with that. both have beautiful voices
SVLauren 2 years ago 9
yes bau see how Pete flow with the guitar ... its not the same thing.
JonieAB 2 years ago 2
just listen to dirty pretty things, you can´t deny that carl issn´t as brilliant as pete. plus Carl has a better scence for the right key.
SVLauren 2 years ago 8
libertines to headline leeds 2010!!!
stevus111 2 years ago 3
fingers fucking crossed! it would be worth the 200 quid just to see that!!
domb07 2 years ago 4
heavenly
spiderpoodle 2 years ago
ohmygod..how can i have missed this clip..?
one word. amazing.
love you carlos.
JO4KIM 2 years ago 12
Its great that Carl finally plays this, although Pete does a great performance when playing this song, Its seems a bit more fitting and emotive when carl plays it
Arcady6 2 years ago 9
fucking amazing
10tshirts 2 years ago 3
if you could have either pete or carls talent which would u choose? pretty fucking hard question isnt it
dannyboy6907 2 years ago 6
Honestly, I'd take Carl's by a nose. He has more of an ear for music than Pete. Pete's lyrics do tend to be a tad better than Carl's, but only a bit. In their solo stuff, I like the Dirty Pretty Things albums better than the Babyshambles albums. As a whole I think their songs are put together better and are more consistently good, but I like "Fuck Forever" better than any one of the DPT's songs by themselves.
They're both amazing artists, that's that. Now they need to get back together ASAP.
nick4man3 2 years ago 13
It really is like choosing between John and Paul.
Baumannzz 2 years ago 7
You could definitely say that. In my opinion Paul&Carl are overall better rock musicians, but as artists in general I think Pete&John are more talented. Which is the better then? I honestly can't tell..
mazikaze 2 years ago 2
Good comparison, I think Pete, like john is the more poetic idealist, whilst i think Carl can write the more catchy riffs with more mass appeal like mcartney did. I mean hey jude is no imagine, but is the more catchy tune.
All in all i think the highs are higher with petes talent but the lows are lower. (again just like John)
shibby52 2 years ago 4
Peter by a whisker. Peter is a ghostly presence and Carl is a full on sex god. Loyalty song is my favourite of all time so it has to be Peter. But Truth Begins is right behind. Wheelies etc.
tugsandtost 2 years ago 14
Truth Begins is a stupidly good song, have some karma.
callum828 2 years ago
Its like Pete makes the poetry and Carl makes it move, both are superb on their own but incredible when put together,
benbebin 2 years ago 72
@benbebin well, carl did write this song, but i do still miss pete's part in the performance....but what became of the likely lads is really carl's song, just as pete's is time for heroes
antileetclub 1 year ago 2
@antileetclub Actually Pete wrote this. With someone else outside of the band but I can't remember who off the top of my head. This is an epic video though. Emotional!
TeaAndBiscuitsAnyone 1 year ago
@benbebin
The heart needs a soul to live, and a soul can't live without a heart.
Carl's the heart and Peter's the soul.
Neither can survive without the other.
nick4man3 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
barat is sooooo way less talented than pete!
LeoKnock 2 years ago
Bollocks.
Barat taught Pete how to play guitar, for starters. So your little comment crashes and burns instantly, just on that note.
Pete could never play those riffs like in "Death On The Stairs" while he sings the way Carl does. Carl also sings in key, where as Pete struggles to do so a lot of the time.
So more talented? No, not by any means.
Just as important and relevant? Yes. Certainly.
Carl is the heart and Pete is the soul.
That's that.
nick4man3 2 years ago 18
i couldn't have put it better
dannyboy6907 2 years ago
One of the best youtube comments I have ever read but don't underestimate Pete's voice
tugsandtost 2 years ago
It has certainly come a long way since Up The Bracket. This is never more prevalent than on Grace/Wasteland.
Regardless, even in his solo performances he often struggles to remain in key. It's not really a bad thing, because it allows him to put much more emotion into the song, I feel. He makes it work somehow, and that's really all that counts in the end.
nick4man3 2 years ago
Like this?... You may like A Band Called Bert
SallyMyers1991 2 years ago
man this makes me break up a little inside as there is no pete :(
whizwoop 2 years ago 5
this is fucking beautiful!
RobotHell 2 years ago 6
What's the model of his guitar please ?
medmargera 2 years ago
Nice, that he changed the lyrics to "So, I got it the wrong way round" As Pete orginally sang, "no, you've got it the wrong way"
SweetPretendin 2 years ago 14
yeh i liked that
rockfeller2005 2 years ago 3
this is an awesome performance. so heartfelt
iggyp0t 2 years ago 5
Who needs Pete?
I like them both.
JagBetty 2 years ago 2
I fucking need pete!
SkinsIsTheSex 2 years ago 2
who needs pete when we got carl
PabloMoll86 2 years ago 9
other way round!
SkinsIsTheSex 2 years ago
Me!!!! even carl needs Pete!!!!!!
kmylo4 2 years ago 4
Amazing voice
dolliecakes 2 years ago 2
love the lyric changes to show his side, sad
5hits2009 2 years ago 10
i can see, hear and feel carlos' pain when he plays this song, he really loved pete, and still does
tttkkkwok 2 years ago 21
This has been flagged as spam show
hell is full of people like you
00kentt 2 years ago
respect
Dieguinho92 2 years ago
carl is so hot!
cutetoiletwater 2 years ago 18
Carl, you are the man.
ivylibertine 2 years ago 15
Oh, this stuff sounds cool acousticly even if Carl plays it alone!
Magnetofonas 2 years ago 13
Carl and pete was a good alchimy ;)
TheOasisSum41shoW 3 years ago 5
i like how he subtly changed the lyrics
Richie1989A 3 years ago 13
Carl is a better Musician.
Pete is a better Lyricist.
superleenaylor 3 years ago 71
well said
jared20101 3 years ago 6
Totally agree...
But i do prefer carls voice kind of...thuogh they osund best of all together
twocrookedfingers 2 years ago 11
together they are unreal though...perfect combination
riccyq 2 years ago 10
agreed!
SkinsIsTheSex 2 years ago
couldn't agree more
SkinsIsTheSex 2 years ago
@superleenaylor i think that Carl is a better singer, but not musician. But ist just my opinion.
SunInSpirit 1 year ago
i love his voice, it's so addictive
redblazingglory 3 years ago 12
carl is by far the better guitarist even tohough i'm addicted to pete.
at least i can see it the way it is.
Directionsforuse 3 years ago 11
yeah, carl taught pete how to play, pete has always admitted that although he loves to play guitar hes not that great x
SkinsIsTheSex 2 years ago
what the fuck! carl barat is fucking amazin on the guitar!
stevenson92 3 years ago 14
"can see why pete dropped this loser this is like a 15 year old at his guitar lesson "
1)pete didnt "drop" him, he basically got himself kicked out of the band.
2)carls a far better guitarist than pete, and carl actually taught him how to play guitar.
3)fuck off.
arirhomas 3 years ago 32
hahahaha...no need for me to say anything!
perfectly put...without his charm n charisma and carl pete would have been a no one!!
although petes acoustic version of this is better,for me anyway x
sicktodeathdisco 3 years ago 3
carl, (l)
JulliaWar 3 years ago 3
(I was talking to dragonfitter , great vid by the way !)
Imy47 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you carnt think this is good
dragonfitter 3 years ago
ah i met Carl at the afterparty of Dirty Pretty Things in Dublin, great fun! smokin smoke in a karaoke bar til 5am and then to a house party!! good fun!!
MetalmilitantJ 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
can see why pete dropped this loser this is like a 15 year old at his guitar lesson
dragonfitter 3 years ago
this is one of the most stupid comments I ever saw on youtube. Congratulations !
Imy47 3 years ago 9
i agree
ivan9493 3 years ago
Carl Is The Sex ;)
shamblerswife95 3 years ago 10
i love the libertines! xxxxxxxxxxx TRULY AMAZING BAND, FOR EVER x
kimlibertine 3 years ago 6
every minute i think of the libertines wherever its about the music, or how much i admire carl and pete yet unfortunatly i missed the libertines as i was only 14 when the second album was released. so please can everyone help me in some way to bring them back as it would be pure bliss
socialistindiekid 3 years ago 8
"I got it the wrong way round, I blamed it on the brown" thats a really nice touch
fantastic,love carl
BackRockDelta 3 years ago 8
fucking hot and good
haltsmaul8 3 years ago 11
this video brings it all back. all the indie bands after the libertines have been a pale imitation, a muddle of wannabe youths.
willarveschoug 3 years ago 9
Both Pete and Carl are amazing. Get back together now while it still matters, not as some fat middle-aged need the money renuion at the bloody Albert Hall in 20 years time.
Fleadrix 3 years ago 39
Carl Barat is amazing! amazing song xxx
kimlibertine 3 years ago 13
carl and pet were soul m8s when u find the one u know they made wonderfull music i'd love 2 see them back 2gether (one day)
pakmanYAP 3 years ago 14
they fuckin love each other and this vid proves that
you can hear the anger in his voice and you can see desire in his eyes
HE NEEDS THE LIBERTINES
Libertino91 3 years ago 18
not only he needs...
k80p 3 years ago 7
I NEED THE LIBERTINES
SunInYourEyes 3 years ago 17
i ke wea en a carl con la cancion. dandole conga con la voz de pete... te sale re piola... nunca vas a saber k mierda digo. soy chileno y k chucha. a la mierda! buena musica, se k pronto estaran juntos again jejejej
costablus 3 years ago 2
every time i hear carl and pete sing each others parts of the song when they play it alone, it feels just as sad as the last time i saw it. i wish they'd get back together
bottleofabsinth 3 years ago 7
"so "I" got it the wrong way round, "I" cut you out coz "I" blamed it on the brown", i think tht carl is tryin to tell people how he feels about the libertines n tht its all his fault, the man is a legend, along with pete! y cant they jst get back together? c'mon boys please work sumthing out :D x
rfcblackyrfc 3 years ago 5
"if I cut you out, its cos i blamed it on the brown" he aint apologising for anything
jimmylibertine 3 years ago 7