Voice of an angel! YAY!

[MiladyToxic]

Aw :( poor Matthew...Shakiki...whatever

[PirateKing1256]

How can his voice not BREAK with puberty!?

[volumeblast]

BITCH GOT A PENIS!

[jeese11]

Can you say gay?

[neatchari]

this is why i love gays.

[ghostsshAdow234]

I closed my eyes and pictured a skinny black woman

[gabbygirl131]

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA­H...*wipes tear from eye* AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAAHHAHA­HAHAHAHAHAHA simon's face at :40 LMAO!

[heartluvr54]

Her face @4:43 x3

[IdolReady]

I think it is so sad that when people go into that room who are truly unique and are truly something new and different they get shut down for not trying to shun that difference... it takes a lot of guts to be different and when I see the same type of "unique" and "different" contestants on Idol every year and it makes so sad to see them turn down somebody who truly fits that description... and then to be told so rudely that he wasn't going to make it because of that was the worst part

[EhabAtia1991]

way fat guys have soft voices ?

[tipofmytongue1024]

He maybe transgendered, GO TRANS!! LOVE 'EM!

[joshie92]

this is what justin beiber would sound like in 10 years if he could actually sing.

[BillyAndDeclanFan]

@joshie92 It's actually Justin Bieber and If you're gonna make fun of someone, at least spell his name right...wow

[Ec85bsDc94]

Hahahahahahah XDDDDDDDDDDDDD

[imothep0110]

don't have ball's

[mrspatrickcampbell]

You GOOOOOOOOO Girlllllllllllllllllllllllllll­ll!!!!!!!!

[pvkjell]

THIS IS SO WEIRD... 

[sadface0]

what a freak..

[xXThaBounceXx]

the reactions of the jugdes were EPIC xDDDDDDD

[shanaz091]

he enjoyed the man hug at the end

[OzFreak22]

If he's not gay he should be...and I'm not being hurtful at all

[iMagnific3nt]

Is he gay? Wait, DO I HAVE TO ASK???

[XutaoHuang]

skinny black women lol its a fat white boy XD

[iMagnific3nt]

He took a dick to the mouth too hard and it kinda hit that vocal cord and FUCKED HIM UP!!

[stallionhorse1]

he is so weird and gay

[twiggy695]

Is it a he or a she? or should I call IT instead?

[CrazyFrigginMariah]

LMAO!!!!

[lilpaul045]

in the name of god he got his balls cut off!!!!!!!!!!

[NButera6]

maybe if he got the dick out his mouth hed sound better

[TheJuliusJT]

haha

[Omega1874]

lol don't ever judge a book by its cover. This is hilarious.

[bittercokejjang]

i think he has such an unique voice. wow!

[nictip]

Shows you how dumb the judges are! This guy had a really unique voice and an amazing vocal range, his voice would be well suited to classical music - 'counter tenor' repetoire. But the stoopid judges couldn't say anything remotely positive or intelligent.

[Hordehunted]

I thought he was a lesbian girl...

[silverandteal]

he was fine and probably had this audition licked until the whole "skinny black girl" / "Sha'quiqui" thing... Randy got agitated

[maiz3040]

...that has has has to be fake lmfao!!..:D

[WillJ99999]

i think he's not bad at singing, but i don't think he can be an idol or be famous for being... that, no offense, so it was obviously a tough decision for the judge, but i would reject him also if i were looking for a person who can make money for me and become famous....

[vaginamelt]

halarious

[edhusse]

a skinny black woman?

Sha qui qui.... odd things to say

[tanyatmr]

I was thinking the same thing, I was also insulted!!

[monicabrisingr]

tisk tisk... typical simon....

[becauseimhi420]

his voice would be perfect for like disney movies i think.

[DaniDnJ]

He should be micky mouse

[Aurelieke123]

what's that?

[Eivan10R]

wtf this is just lame.. they said NO cus hes gay? wow

[6ertz]

well wouldn't you that's just way to gay!! At least Adam Lambert didn't act like that.

[kixnit]

THIS IS FANTASTIC.<333333333

[4Blindian4]

Oh my, God... He reminds me of Perez Hilton. Ha....

[electrocutedcat]

who's the fourth judge?

[ErikaDotFive]

it's brandy, I think :X

[cant0stop0time]

my ears hurt :C

[bluesuedeshuze7603]

I feel sorry for him. I'll bet he was picked on relentlessly in school. He can't help he has a high-pitched voice.

[TheHLGGhosts]

Voice of an angel? More like voice of the devil. Im gonna have nightmares now. :p

[mozza145]

HAHAHAHA!!! "Has anyone ever told you, you sound like a woman??" yeah smooth one randy.. and "Matthew or Martha"... krak-up!!!

[ai5H4]

omg.. poor thing ='[

I wanna give him a hug..

he was good tbh I wanna hear more of his voice!

[sslifeguard07]

Haha, i almost died laughing my ass off, if he were a she they woulda let him through, but despite that fact, he's good, a little more work, and he could be great!

[Seagalux]

ha ha,i guess sometimes the voice ends up- in the wrong body ,or maybe not...

[mzmzdedo]

Hahahahahaha , he is half a woman !!!

[jonetine8463]

faggot!! ehe

[principal18]

stupid and irrational bitch!! ehe

[Napuaiolana]

nice! "just like a unicorn"

[MrPwnation]

thats fucked up

[SilexViscus]

Okay guys, yes, most of us, through speculation, can pretty well figure out that he's at least not straight, but give 'em a break. He doesn't have a bad voice, its just not really a male's voice. I feel bad for him, but he'll be okay.

[Moline20]

that scared the shit out me .. thats just fucked up .. im gonna have nightmares

[OMGshNicholas]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

WOW. OMFGsh...

[lediep89]

what a faggot

[axelb84]

lediep89 = fucktard

[lediep89]

ah

it turns out u r also a faggot LMAO

[dmx952]

what a faggot

[Justakid12]

Awwuhh.

Poor guy started crying.

.__.

[elguembursuazo]

aww its so sad when they cry,,but man he sucked..

[KEMOPA]

rofl

[dumitruadox]

G A Y not Y A Y

[Indance]

El joven cantante tiene un gran futuro de todos modos, aqui en México existen otros similares uno se llama Daniel Derio y Von Smith y cantan muy bien y tienen mucho exito Animate amigo sigue tu camino nosotros si compraremos tus discos. Felicidades Congratulation from Guadalajara, Mexico.

[sthesailor]

maybe if he had been a girl they would have let him through

[fma2222]

YAY!

[3wheels3souls]

hes a good singer, but since hes gay he cant go to hollywood! I wish all the gay people in the world would magicaly turn into woman so it would be fair lol, btw im not gay but der is tonz og gay kidz in my school ... -.-

[kcpd2050]

This guy sucked big time. If you think he had a good voice you are tone death.

[browneyeslc]

lol

[inyourfacebilly33]

its obvious he got kicked in the balls before he walked in to sing.

[Marlonblabla]

whahahaha what a gay :P lol xD

he sounds like a woman thats true... that suck so he can't sing lol xD

[TrappyOctober]

what ???

[roughryder5]

LMAO hes gay O.o sorry i had to write that

[streetxmonsters]

Ahahahahahahahahahaha!

[MaaSrii]

but unfair also

[MaaSrii]

faggit

[marleneisFATALITY]

FAIL.

[creon5]

he would be awsome in drag

[internet740]

did u get your balls cut off

[yorkiechick3196]

soo..is he gay? or not??????????

[3wheels3souls]

no duh

[kikikawme]

He would have gotten through if he was a girl

[jackiesevi]

fucken sucks:(

[wantnoodles]

Shakiki!! rofl

[SaxyG]

I love Simon's expression at 0:40 - 0: 42 LOL

[iiAkiru]

Randy and Simon's reactions were likee .. O_O WTF .

[fazilrm]

dear god :|...

[wildpink101]

omfw...lmfbo...wow...

[accidentpronebuddys]

oh. my. fricken. gosh. what was that?! i think im kind of...scared...

[internet740]

did someone cut his balls off o_O no offence hes a good singer if hes a women

[monny287]

Wow....good voice...but...I think I'm a bit frightened.... O.o

[daysleeper58]

what a great singer

[mmcst77027]

holy shit.. a Big Mac has more frigging testosterone than this guy :|

[Omgtheykilledme]

O.O Fail

[rwc20071]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA whata queer fuck

[Fr4Nc012]

he's a fucking girl! ive never seen anything like that

[BREAD12222]

wow shakeke, how sterotypical.

[SaMeT1KiLLeR]

Not a bad voice

For a girl :P

[hollerbacktyler]

AHAHAHA

[yopeaceoutdude]

GROSS

[psykotroniko]

damn !! wtf !!

[lsmile30]

Is he a girl!?

[bogdanike]

cool :P but the problem was he's gay o_O he could get it :P

[nikilalalalala]

he has absolutely no vocal talent at all, he screams. regardless of whether he is gay or not he sounds horrible

[Webarton]

LMFAO what a dumbass

[feld1117]

you know, he's not too bad

[Raven4hunting]

wow...that was....he sounds....wow....

O_O...totally caught me off guard.

[o0blueberrysky0o]

he sounded nice..he should have gone through

[jado818]

He wasn't bad, just not somebody lots of people would buy cds from.

[hgfrjkgfjjj]

Sorry he looked gay,talked like 1 and singed like 1

[adam6555555]

he'd be less gay with a penis in his mouth.....

[ThomsenKA]

haha!

[nguyen1910]

why s he like a unicorn??

[bellaitaliano1]

LMFAO simon's face

[portugalgirl101]

there faces lol lol

[chrmdanglgrl]

that was so wrong just because he has a girl voice and sings really good as a girl doesnt mean he isnt right for american idol

[asbani991]

he can sing, but his voice tune is not very pretty if you focus on it. in my own opinion at least. but I got a feeling that he's trying too much to go high on the note. even tho if he sing normal, He could of. and if he do, he might have better voice I'd guess. (Last part of the note he sang showed this impression to me)

[3wheels3souls]

ya it does, who would hnestly buy his music?? NO1 if he was a girl it would be a different story...

[VintageSunset]

LOL HIS VOICE!!!

[alexdu86utube]

it was an odd tribute.

[Belle19700]

I don't care what anyone says about this guy, he can really sing.

[mcjoing]

lol the description "he's so magical and wonderous. just like a unicorn." HAHAHA!

[BethanyBrowning]

What. The. Heck.

[hazelnut333]

i just clicked on this video, but than i started doing something else while this was going on in the background, and i though: hm, i thought a guy is gonna be singing, but who's is this lovely feminine voice anyway??? And than dadadaaaa! OMG, but they did a little discrimination that i didn't like. I mean his voice is beautiful, so why should the fact that he is gay matter?

[stubbyjoe]

if JUST ONCE, they'd give CONSTRUCTIVE advice rather than self rightious drivel.

Clearly, this boy is very fey, but genuine, so why not do female material? Really why? It could have actually *helped him to be told to bring it down to a more comfortable key so he had more room vocally, and then could nail the higher notes.

I feel like sending him an "antony" cd. whom I'm sure they don't know because their taste is so limited and common.

God bless this boy, it can't be easy being him.

[fillaine]

YEahHH!!waTH thE fuCk,......

[pixystixgirl314]

XD This is funny. Love it though. Ah, how can they do that to their voice? Never quite understood that, but that is just awesome

[Cozy89]

omg this is just pure discrimination.

[Storm23PS3]

Hilarious

[yeahitskatie]

he sounds like ross the intern and kind of looks like him too

[LFRxo828]

omg youre right. BEYOND. BEYOND>

[job1201204]

There is gay, and then there is Uber gay, and this guy is even beyond that!!

[princess202352]

yeah and...whats you point.

[richardpacyisgod]

LOL sneezing panda is a related video.

[markclark5]

my my all these people with prejudices, what century are we living in? Kids got a great voice, and thats all that really should matter. As far as I'm concerned the way he's being treated isn't much better than racism.

[MikeyXLarge]

he's Gay!!!!!

[HxXFromFirstToLastXx]

WHAT A PUFFFFFFFFFFFFFF

[davidcooktributevids]

i think hes a woman...

weird

[javiem007]

his voice is good but the look is very important and he haven't got it

[lollol44]

assholes he surly can sing and should go through the next round

[CrAzYSOOB]

if he was a girl, he would be a good singer

O>O

[ThenextBatista]

Its like......dubbing over his voice.......i wish.

[angelkiss2011]

he sounds like a frekin woman

[uaflagling]

ok so clearly someone cannot hear the pitch problems, he even started singing out of key hello!!

[NeGaTiv3]

amazing voice but oh my god... why you are a BOY!... you most suppose to be a GIRL... for real... :)

[irmahoward]

Ohh my god!!!Those judges suck...there was no reason for them to say no...just because his voice is like a womens voice doesnt mean he doesnt have a good voice, he still has a powerful voice...U GO MATTHEW!!!:D!!!

[redneckn2n]

dude totally, he had an amazing voice.

[lakeshark3000]

Beautiful voice. Next year he should sing the same way and pretend he is a girl so he will go to hollywood.

[crapbagprincess]

I would say GREAT VOICE, WRONG BODY.

[Vlad788]

I would second that. He has an amazing voice, don't get me wrong, but its just in the wrong body as you've said.

[susieecool]

interesting

[soph41190]

WOW kinda weird...but great all the same!

[blinkdude182]

OMG HOMO

[gokart2]

GAY