0:09 -1:10 I imagined is what the space battle will be against the final battle against the Reapers in Mass Effect 3...I get the feeling there will be some actual close quarter combat...
This would have been an amazing sequence had it not spent so much time focusing on the Jedis and their personal problems. Hundreds of ships in the fight and you see almost none of the scale of the fleet battle. Most of it is just static background for the main characters to fly around. Stargate, Serenity, Battlestar Galactica, Deep Space 9 even other Star Wars movies have created more impressive scenes.
This is garbage. There are so many better space battles in other movies, like the one in Serenity between the alliance and the reavers, now THAT was a space battle.
i dont care what they say, i see nothing wrong with the CGI of this movie. Although I will always have a problem with the "gravity in space" issue, and the amount of unnecessary CGI in ground scenes. And the bright, colorful lights from the planet thing... hmmm maybe the CGI effect me... never mind. SCREW YOU GL!
Oh god, so terrible. I just love how the animators made Obiwan and Anakin to the exact same little barrel rolls, how cute. Am I the only one who completely hates the space battles in the prequels?
im sorry ive tolerated the new films, but im sick of them now, the acting is terrible because EVERYTHING is bluescreened, it must be very hard to act in that environment!
If you want the best space battle watch the battle of endor!
Furthermore, why exactly would drones communicate verbally when they could do it a million times faster wirelessly? Why do they ask stupid questions when they have enough storage capacity for the equivalent of a million Wikipedias? The drones in Star Wars...not so realistic, no.
So why do they speak the language that their enemies understand instead of the verbal equivalent of a barcode that can't easily be decoded and take a tenth of the time to say? For that matter why don't the communicate wirelessly unless they're being jammed (and they aren't on their own ships, lol). ;)
It saddened me when this scene could have been so, so, so much better than how it happened. Also, how were they really expecting to save a single old man in their one man fighters anyways?
What if Lucas added some more stuff to the action, like more Jedi Starfighters sent to look for the vessel in which Palpatine was located and instead of massive chaos u could actually follow the continuity of the battle instead of just seeind ships get blown up in the background, buzz droid sequence gets annoying really fast.
I remember watching this in the theatre. I actually got goosebumps at the first minute and a half; it felt like the old "magic" of the originals. Then they started talking...
Even though the prequels are crap, the first minute of this movie is good. That's pretty depressing though, when you think about it.
@Mattastic97 idk, I think Ewin McGreigor made a good Obi Wan. Obviously Anakin sucked in the first three mobies, though. "Derp, I'm going to go from being a super emo to a bad ass over the course of 2 movies."
@Mattastic97 idk, I think Ewin McGreigor made a good Obi Wan. Obviously Anakin sucked in the first three movies, though. "Derp, I'm going to go from being a super emo to a bad ass over the course of 2 movies."
Its not about recording something and changing it into sound waves. The fact that is being discussed here is about sound waves in space. There is no sound in space because there is no dense atmosphere to allow sound particles to move.
I agree, but I was looking for a space battle, and based on the title of this clip I expected a space battle, it's misleading and I was really disapointed ... that's why I asked ... where is the space battle, it sure isn't in this video ... :(
the space battle is in the backround, you can barely see it ... if you want to understand what I mean by space battle watch this video: Star Trek Deep Space Nine: Sacrifice of Angels.
So you think the sith who rely on their passion for their strength and "think inwards only about themselves" should win then? 2 jedi craft against all of greviouses ships.. they were sent on a mission like special forces are.
I'm not a big fan of the spinning, roaming camera angles. Makes everything look overly CGI. Compared with the originals the 3 prequels feel rushed, to much reliance on effects and not enough character building. Still entertaining though.
when i first saw this movie, i thought ok... why is that big ship there. But when they flew under, BOOM! BANG!! be-Bu!!!! OMG!! THE PLANET IS UNDER ATTACK!!! AHHHH!!!
This opening sequence is almost as good as the one from the original Star Wars. Sith took me by surprise. It was a good, old-fashioned, rollicking space adventure. Exactly what Star Wars should be.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
LAME movie and LAME space battle. Anything from the Federation versus the Dominion beats this. Of course the Defiant can smack down anything in Star Wars except for a Death Star. And Babylon 5 battles were much more intense than this. NEXT.
Star trek battles were junk and only better than the original star wars battles, this is good stuff. The only thing better than the new star wars battles is Battlestar Galactica.
lol, in Star Trek the explosions are so unrealistic XD if an 2 meters long ship explode, there is an 2 kilometers long explosion and there aren't any fragments. And the most realistic battles are in Batlestar Galactica
I have no idea from star trek, sorry and i also forget ds9 or enterprise and there are fragments... so forget my comment^^ but its looks nicer with fragments^^
This space battle is like a baby toy compared to the Star Trek space battles. These are so unrealistic, and it looks more like a video game....Pfew Pfew Pfew...
hmm, maybe the oxygen in the ships could make the fire/explosions? or even the fact that the ships have different materials that we cant possibly imagine... or maybe George Lucas and every other sci-fi producer 4got about this small fact
ok.. for all those bitching about fire in space (besides, they are in the atmosphere). Think about it, you accept the 'force' and light speed, but you cant get passed fire in space!!!!! OMG!!!
Okay, here's the final count on fire in space. If fire could not ever exist in space....EXPLAIN THE SUN! O.O; lol Yeah, kind of a blatant overkill, but still, if fire couldn't exist in space, then we wouldn't have stars. :)
Yes, but you forget that the plasma in which the sun is fueled is made primarily of elements which include oxygen, hydrogen, and other flammable gases. Fire does not need oxygen so long as it has a catalyst to ignite and burn from.
for the ultimate nerd answer - that gun was fired from a SPHA-T out of the Republic attack cruiser's hangar bay. SPHAT_Ts are those big walking cannons seen at the end of attack of the clones, the ones that shoot down the escaping balls, the ones that yoda tells them to shoot at and shit.
fire can still shoot out into space through a vented blast hole and smoek can exist in space as clouds of vapor, also it can technically not be smoke, but rather the vaporized metal from when a laser hit the hull
Yeah no Sci Film is ever going to be realistic because Hollywood fails to recognise that space is a vaccum. Besides a soundless space battle would be kinda boring
It looked too easy. They were like walking in the park enjoying them selves while everybody else were fighting. They did not even try taking on a "war face". This pushed me out of my sence of "realism" of the battle. Also, the little things like racing missles and doing all other things than actually fighting is so old. Why do they have to use 30 sec outrunning missles, it is used in every air/space battle scene.
All the little details tiped this over to, in my opinion, unrealism.
I did not mean real world realism. The whole concept of Star Wars would not fit then. But, in the movies context I must be able to belive the scenes.
It is just like in an action movie, the car chases are often spectacular, in real life the cars should be destroyed after the first 20 meter long 2 meter high jump, but it is good entertainment.
How ever, if the driver then desides to flip the car up on two wheels and drive up the wall on an large building, jumping of the edge landing on an elevated highway ramp, and then continue driving, the movie looses the fealing of realism in the context the movie is made in.
How "unreal" the scenes can be before it gets stupid would of corse depend on the movies own context and given boundaries.
When R4-D2 lost his head
Obi-Wan: oh, dear
If R2-D2 lost his head
Anakin: NOOOOOOOOOOO0000000ooooooooo!!!!!!!
NickDude555 6 months ago
I hated that he just didn't use the force to just kill the buzz droids
thegreatspanky1 7 months ago
Obi wan: Flying is for droids.
And those missiles are controlled by droids. LOL
starwarsfan196 8 months ago
Why did the missles become......
There is NO WAY IN HELL that can be cost- efficient
mager56723 11 months ago
0:09 -1:10 I imagined is what the space battle will be against the final battle against the Reapers in Mass Effect 3...I get the feeling there will be some actual close quarter combat...
crawford4140 11 months ago
And how did I forget Babylon 5? The battles of Seasons 3 and 4 put this to shame.
SBFloppie 1 year ago
This would have been an amazing sequence had it not spent so much time focusing on the Jedis and their personal problems. Hundreds of ships in the fight and you see almost none of the scale of the fleet battle. Most of it is just static background for the main characters to fly around. Stargate, Serenity, Battlestar Galactica, Deep Space 9 even other Star Wars movies have created more impressive scenes.
SBFloppie 1 year ago
And this is why I love Star Wars.
xxPatheticEmoxx 1 year ago
This was the best of the prequels. After looking at it you know the answer to one question. Who is a bad ass Jedi? Obi Wan is a bad ass Jedi.
Wildcard120 1 year ago
The most thrilling space battle sequence in cinema history!!!
If ROTJ had the benefit of the updated CGI I think it would have put this to shame. This is stil a good battle just suffers from bad acting.
Spawn674 1 year ago
This is garbage. There are so many better space battles in other movies, like the one in Serenity between the alliance and the reavers, now THAT was a space battle.
mtbedwards 1 year ago
I think I watched this film once, will need to again. Lets see if they can deliver battles like this in the MMO game due next 2011!
WebTechGlobal 1 year ago
i dont care what they say, i see nothing wrong with the CGI of this movie. Although I will always have a problem with the "gravity in space" issue, and the amount of unnecessary CGI in ground scenes. And the bright, colorful lights from the planet thing... hmmm maybe the CGI effect me... never mind. SCREW YOU GL!
anubis9109 1 year ago
......im sorry, but ima huge star wars fan, and even so, the space battles in the prequals made me want to cut myself.
insanekillers1232 1 year ago
:33
Oh god, so terrible. I just love how the animators made Obiwan and Anakin to the exact same little barrel rolls, how cute. Am I the only one who completely hates the space battles in the prequels?
patio87 2 years ago
im sorry ive tolerated the new films, but im sick of them now, the acting is terrible because EVERYTHING is bluescreened, it must be very hard to act in that environment!
If you want the best space battle watch the battle of endor!
silycaon 2 years ago
"I'm not leaving without you master."
notmyreality 2 years ago
ey this is a shet the ships are to closer they are space ships no sea ships and they dont have military training
TenienteRJG18071 2 years ago
4:58
its nice how that space wind blows the buzz droid away... ¬_¬
this film suck so bad.
androids saying ouch ouch? wthf? fail.
SCARREDMIND 2 years ago
Ships look like lego lol , they messed these films up so bad.
TheFewzz 2 years ago
with all that R2's been through it's suprising the first time he gets shot is at endor
steele1879 2 years ago
Man, Kenobi seems like a little bitch in this movie.
wolffrankenstein 2 years ago 3
agreed
ctruman 2 years ago
poor r4
firemachinima 2 years ago
why would droids cry out in pain? wtf lol
pamwayahead 2 years ago
Furthermore, why exactly would drones communicate verbally when they could do it a million times faster wirelessly? Why do they ask stupid questions when they have enough storage capacity for the equivalent of a million Wikipedias? The drones in Star Wars...not so realistic, no.
thepsion5 2 years ago
if communication is bad then wireless would kill them. but with verbal they can aviod that
awalcomando 2 years ago
So why do they speak the language that their enemies understand instead of the verbal equivalent of a barcode that can't easily be decoded and take a tenth of the time to say? For that matter why don't the communicate wirelessly unless they're being jammed (and they aren't on their own ships, lol). ;)
thepsion5 2 years ago
in the end its funnyer
igncom1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
That movie is terrible, in fact the whole star wars series is just awful.
Gaius51 2 years ago
It saddened me when this scene could have been so, so, so much better than how it happened. Also, how were they really expecting to save a single old man in their one man fighters anyways?
naraxis 2 years ago
...um...the way they actually did it...
johnkerry7 2 years ago
eah it did sadden me, i'm sure they intended to hi jack a larger ship
ctruman 2 years ago
There's some quite cool shots in this one, but I'd prefer the battle to be the main thing instead of a rescue
Episode 3 probably had a little too much in the way of lightsaber fighting
Usul573 2 years ago
No battle in big-screen history can match the one a few Finnish guys on a shoestring budget did for In the Pirkinning.
WUZLE 2 years ago
Great special effects but overall a complete letdown. No tension. I didn't care who got blown up.
sidoney101 2 years ago
It can't even hold my attention for the full 6 minutes. The acting and chatter is a little flat too.
Adom 2 years ago 3
I only cared about who didn't get blown up. Bad acting should be met with explosions.
vektork 2 years ago 2
What if Lucas added some more stuff to the action, like more Jedi Starfighters sent to look for the vessel in which Palpatine was located and instead of massive chaos u could actually follow the continuity of the battle instead of just seeind ships get blown up in the background, buzz droid sequence gets annoying really fast.
Lostdirector 2 years ago
Wow! At 1:19, if you look in the background. You'll see a republic ship just getting toasted..ouch!
lifevest1 2 years ago
and at 1:22 the same ship has no damage
vektork 2 years ago
They must have the best damn repair team in the fleet! lol
lifevest1 2 years ago
best space battles are in battlestar galactica
xFake21 2 years ago
AHAHAHA, you made my whole freakin day.
Nothing Beats The Star Wars Battle Of Endor.
JAKETHESNAKE1590 2 years ago
BSG Does. And it beats with with a blood soaked flashlight
vektork 2 years ago
I REALLY want to watch BSG, if the space battles really are better than the ones in Stargate, then they must be great
Usul573 2 years ago
u can just watch my bsg vid ;)
xFake21 2 years ago
Thanks, tempting, but I only know a few things about BSG and I'd rather watch the whole thing in HD on my 46'' screen
You gotta admit that would be better than just seeing youtube videos of it
Usul573 2 years ago
well its a series with 4 seasons so it might take some time^^
xFake21 2 years ago
*shrug*
I watched a season of Stargate Atlantis in two days.
Usul573 2 years ago
oO ok have fun :D
xFake21 2 years ago
me 2 lol, 2 seasons
firemachinima 2 years ago
they really fell through with this one, really let me down
ctruman 3 years ago
why the hell he made the droids make those absolutely stupid ridiculous noises when the got "hurt" is beyond me.
it made my want to demand a refund from the cinema when i heard that dross.
also, bab-5 or sg had better space battles.
SCARREDMIND 3 years ago
"The most thrilling space battle sequence in cinema history!!!"
Nah,not by a long shot. The whole battle seems so static, the music is VERY bland and the droids are just stupid.
aribenzane 3 years ago 2
I agree. The special effects are great but the entire scene has the stench of Lucas's writing.
Browless1 2 years ago
begin called a Oddball is now a compliment
jedimusic2 3 years ago
I remember watching this in the theatre. I actually got goosebumps at the first minute and a half; it felt like the old "magic" of the originals. Then they started talking...
Even though the prequels are crap, the first minute of this movie is good. That's pretty depressing though, when you think about it.
Mattastic97 3 years ago 12
Yeah I Know! Me 2! It caught me off guard! There was this star destroyer over the planet and im like.."hmmm..."
. Then two ships come along and im like "Ok.."
Then suddenly they fly under the ship and this monsterous space battle emerges from nowhere and im like "HOLY SHIT!"
lifevest1 2 years ago
@Mattastic97 idk, I think Ewin McGreigor made a good Obi Wan. Obviously Anakin sucked in the first three mobies, though. "Derp, I'm going to go from being a super emo to a bad ass over the course of 2 movies."
Verixus113 6 months ago
@Mattastic97 idk, I think Ewin McGreigor made a good Obi Wan. Obviously Anakin sucked in the first three movies, though. "Derp, I'm going to go from being a super emo to a bad ass over the course of 2 movies."
Verixus113 6 months ago
And btw - you can easily record something in space....ever heard of windows/portholes? Or multi-spectral imaging? Or even plain old scanners?
nom1nom 3 years ago
Its not about recording something and changing it into sound waves. The fact that is being discussed here is about sound waves in space. There is no sound in space because there is no dense atmosphere to allow sound particles to move.
Tzimnewman3 3 years ago 2
There is no sound in space \O_o/
nom1nom 3 years ago 3
Who gives a fuck about no sound in space.
Did you also know that there isnt any CCTV in space either. You retard!
No Sound and No TV Camera.
Tzimnewman3 3 years ago
Classic response - thanks for teh lulz!
nom1nom 3 years ago 3
Oh noe.
You fed the TROLL.
PlusPlusPlus05 3 years ago 4
long live the Star Trek!!! :P
razlika 3 years ago
Star "TREK"? I hope you're joking
silveger 3 years ago
Be glad these videos are still on here. Yes they will be removed soon.
notmyreality 3 years ago
this will be taken off, there is no copyright. you gave no credit.
PurpleArbiter 3 years ago
this will be taken off, therXXXXXXXXX STFU YOU FUCKIN LITTLE WHINER
ikhebeengrotepiemel 3 years ago
false video title
spacexploder 3 years ago
The troops are doing the fighting.. the two jedi are on a mission to save the chancellor.. thats their job
notmyreality 3 years ago
This scene shows anakins devotion to the troops and his master obi wan.
notmyreality 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This space battle is garbage - by far the worst in all of the Star Wars films. If you want a good space battle watch Return of the Jedi.
Zyfe 3 years ago
yeah thats a really shit battle. Idiot little drone things...
wolfarkas 3 years ago
People always complain about every little thing. Don't try to bring everything else down just because it didn't meet your exact specifications.
Timberwolf7585 3 years ago
where is the space battle?
ancient41 3 years ago
In the movie it takes place above Coruscant
silveger 3 years ago
I know where it takes place, what I ment by my question was that this clip doesn't really show a space battle ... it's not what you expect :)
ancient41 3 years ago
Well it SHOWS one, but obi-wan nor anakin doesn't take part in it.
silveger 3 years ago
I agree, but I was looking for a space battle, and based on the title of this clip I expected a space battle, it's misleading and I was really disapointed ... that's why I asked ... where is the space battle, it sure isn't in this video ... :(
ancient41 3 years ago
so how is this not a space battle?
im confused now, yours is one of many comments like this
etherealeyes 3 years ago
the space battle is in the backround, you can barely see it ... if you want to understand what I mean by space battle watch this video: Star Trek Deep Space Nine: Sacrifice of Angels.
ancient41 3 years ago 2
"I'm going to help him out.." "No.. no.. they are doing their job now we can do ours."
daddylonglegs2009 3 years ago
Yea...thats how caring Jedi became after the Sith wars 4000 years before these events, all that taught them nothing.....They deserved to fall.
Plasmon19 3 years ago
So you think the sith who rely on their passion for their strength and "think inwards only about themselves" should win then? 2 jedi craft against all of greviouses ships.. they were sent on a mission like special forces are.
daddylonglegs2009 3 years ago
Na, I was just kidding. Unlike the Sith, the Jedi learn their lessons, as they after and during the events that occurred in the new Jedi Order.
Plasmon19 3 years ago
BOOM! at 1:03
DarkDagger109 3 years ago
1:03 demonstrates the power of the republic, one shot KO!
lifevest1 3 years ago 2
i love the 1:03 shot, it´s the best part, the sound is funny, and the hit is perfect :)
zomgerln 3 years ago
In space there is no sound because there is no air to carry it.
SmallTimeHalo 3 years ago
i know, tell that to the one who made the sound effects, not me.
zomgerln 3 years ago
That was meant to be a reply to someone sorry lol. When Anakin says reverse thrusters there is a podracer sound lol.
SmallTimeHalo 3 years ago
i like how obi wan on 3:41 says "oh dear"
snipperbes 3 years ago
I'm not a big fan of the spinning, roaming camera angles. Makes everything look overly CGI. Compared with the originals the 3 prequels feel rushed, to much reliance on effects and not enough character building. Still entertaining though.
moonfly1 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The Worst space battle sequence in cinema history
LuthorX87 3 years ago
concertchoir3
NO it's not it's the most AWESOME BATTLE SWQUENCE IN CINEMA HISTORY OF THE STAR WARS SAGA!
Concerchoir3 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
dont think you could make any better u dicksucking mother fucker... burn in hell...
L33TFTW 3 years ago
They should have halved Episode 2 and put half of Episode 3 in there... and expanded the last of the movies.
Tanru2000 3 years ago
man the arc 170's are superiority fighters they should lasted alot longer. gotta love em though.
budd2200 3 years ago
Concertchoir3
the arc means aggressivereconnansence
the arc 170 fighters evolve into the X-WINGS!
Concerchoir3 3 years ago
Seems to play a bit fast
erdemhasan 4 years ago
when i first saw this movie, i thought ok... why is that big ship there. But when they flew under, BOOM! BANG!! be-Bu!!!! OMG!! THE PLANET IS UNDER ATTACK!!! AHHHH!!!
lifevest1 4 years ago 2
Impressive visuals, boring-ass battle.
Reavers vs the Alliance in Serenity was a much smaller, much shorter battle sequence but infinitely more interesting and exciting.
koalabrownie 4 years ago 3
yeah it was INTENSE!!
patrickw123456789876 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Lame space battle, focuses way way too much on the two small ships.
Captial ships are where the fun's at.
TehIdiot 4 years ago
True this is the best space battle in cinema history, it comes from a very small list.
ArodWingfoot 4 years ago
hahah the little machines are soo cute
74205Defiant 4 years ago
This opening sequence is almost as good as the one from the original Star Wars. Sith took me by surprise. It was a good, old-fashioned, rollicking space adventure. Exactly what Star Wars should be.
famtortozhika 4 years ago 4
Should be the operative world. There weren't enough star wars in Star Wars.
sizemoreevil 4 years ago
Revenge of the Sith is shit. The prequels never existed, imo. =/
Stormvermin 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
LAME movie and LAME space battle. Anything from the Federation versus the Dominion beats this. Of course the Defiant can smack down anything in Star Wars except for a Death Star. And Babylon 5 battles were much more intense than this. NEXT.
ralphspimp 4 years ago
Star trek battles were junk and only better than the original star wars battles, this is good stuff. The only thing better than the new star wars battles is Battlestar Galactica.
TreeOfWar 4 years ago 4
Sucky movie, but the battles Kick Ass. Hurahh!
sgregg5257 4 years ago
I love Star Wars^^
lol, in Star Trek the explosions are so unrealistic XD if an 2 meters long ship explode, there is an 2 kilometers long explosion and there aren't any fragments. And the most realistic battles are in Batlestar Galactica
moop1789 4 years ago 3
thats because Star Trek ships use matter-antimatter engines,dork
Dalbert342 4 years ago
I have no idea from star trek, sorry and i also forget ds9 or enterprise and there are fragments... so forget my comment^^ but its looks nicer with fragments^^
moop1789 4 years ago
Ohhh,I agree..and am sorry I snaped..but DS9 battle's were pretty awesome
Dalbert342 4 years ago 2
Oh year XD
moop1789 4 years ago
nope, the latest starwars movies and stargate got far superior space battles, star trek is just... sucky..
zomgerln 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Star Wars is Sci-Fi for dumbed down noobs like you.
ralphspimp 4 years ago
stfu
thinkerboy2 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wow, what a comeback! Think of that all by yourself? Now wonder Star Wars attracts brain dead drones like you. haha.
ralphspimp 4 years ago
It's not really Sci-Fi at all. More fantasy than anything else. "Space Opera" if you want the stuff academic term.
pasrachilli 4 years ago
This space battle is like a baby toy compared to the Star Trek space battles. These are so unrealistic, and it looks more like a video game....Pfew Pfew Pfew...
Star Trek is much more realistic than this crap.
Demonfreak88 4 years ago
ITS A TRAP!
lendial 4 years ago
Iwatch star trek movies and they have fiery explosions in space So does Babylon five.Would not be exciting battles in space without them
3piper 4 years ago
ok nerds,,,fire make no sound in space,,no air,,is a vacuum,,,and of yeah,,,this is A MOVIE,,,not real remenber
nico3481 4 years ago
Actually their on the borderline of the planet's atmosphere or that least that's what the commentary said :P
CartoonDiablo 4 years ago
Yes.
DrkRick 4 years ago
thanks. I thought star wars was a documentury about a real space civilization. Thanks for telling me it was fiction.
timbosforporn 4 years ago
I always thought turbo-lasers were very large cannons, not lasers that took a few moments to end. I suppose it's in the name, yes?
6577446 4 years ago
The ships have tons of fuel in them... How about sound?
d3p3ch3mod3 4 years ago
hmm, maybe the oxygen in the ships could make the fire/explosions? or even the fact that the ships have different materials that we cant possibly imagine... or maybe George Lucas and every other sci-fi producer 4got about this small fact
ahhaboom 4 years ago
not every producer 4got about sound in battlestar galacctica there is no sound
EosAdni 3 years ago
galactica is good show.. less cartoonish than star wars.
aleazcazan 3 years ago
don't forget firefly
boris99z3 3 years ago
Is it just me or does the song sound higher than in the DVD?
windfish21 4 years ago
ok.. for all those bitching about fire in space (besides, they are in the atmosphere). Think about it, you accept the 'force' and light speed, but you cant get passed fire in space!!!!! OMG!!!
johnkerry7 4 years ago 7
lol!
windfish21 4 years ago 3
they are in the atmosphere, it says so in the dvd commentaries.
MobiusLeader 4 years ago
Okay, here's the final count on fire in space. If fire could not ever exist in space....EXPLAIN THE SUN! O.O; lol Yeah, kind of a blatant overkill, but still, if fire couldn't exist in space, then we wouldn't have stars. :)
Lancenova 4 years ago
fire requires oxygen which space has none of. The sun is made of plasma, much hotter than fire and a byproduct of fission taking place in its core
lardo1990 4 years ago 2
Yes, but you forget that the plasma in which the sun is fueled is made primarily of elements which include oxygen, hydrogen, and other flammable gases. Fire does not need oxygen so long as it has a catalyst to ignite and burn from.
Lancenova 4 years ago
It is not very realistic!
R055HP 4 years ago
I dunno, I like the battles in Legend of the Galactic Heroes a bit more.
quarterogREBORN 4 years ago
no u idiot its a turbo laser battery
bradas7654 4 years ago
vinbuik is right.
masterofhobbiton 4 years ago
its not called SPHA-T's in the star wars scimatics book they are called a turbolaser battery
bradas7654 4 years ago
You're both right, its just that one of you knows the specific name of the turbolaser battery.
Its like arguing, "no thats not a P-40 its a sub-machine gun!"
DarthComrade 4 years ago
WTF was that gun at 1:02 ?! A mini -deathstar -Laser ? That was badass!
Senfglasleerlecker 4 years ago
for the ultimate nerd answer - that gun was fired from a SPHA-T out of the Republic attack cruiser's hangar bay. SPHAT_Ts are those big walking cannons seen at the end of attack of the clones, the ones that shoot down the escaping balls, the ones that yoda tells them to shoot at and shit.
vinbuik 4 years ago
lol 3:34 obi wan sounds like C3PO when talked to R4D2.
nairda55555 4 years ago
may the force be with you.
nairda55555 4 years ago
One thing irritates me to my very core, this movie did not get a single oscar award...
and yet I feel this scene on its definitely earned every possible nomination! >:(
DarthComrade 4 years ago
This is not exactly space though, they're fighting in Courascant atmosphere.
Hence the smoke and fire...
DarthComrade 4 years ago
fire can still shoot out into space through a vented blast hole and smoek can exist in space as clouds of vapor, also it can technically not be smoke, but rather the vaporized metal from when a laser hit the hull
SpartanKenneth 4 years ago
the siege of coruscant.
nairda55555 4 years ago
star wars vs battle
Riot012 4 years ago
Yeah no Sci Film is ever going to be realistic because Hollywood fails to recognise that space is a vaccum. Besides a soundless space battle would be kinda boring
macca1088 4 years ago
do you know what would happen if something blows up in space. Because I don't know.
Unit545 4 years ago
*cough cough* 2001: A Space Odyssey *cough*
ynxyg 4 years ago
I think it was a safe, even though ridiculous, precation for those in command. :/
Mani231290 4 years ago
It looked too easy. They were like walking in the park enjoying them selves while everybody else were fighting. They did not even try taking on a "war face". This pushed me out of my sence of "realism" of the battle. Also, the little things like racing missles and doing all other things than actually fighting is so old. Why do they have to use 30 sec outrunning missles, it is used in every air/space battle scene.
All the little details tiped this over to, in my opinion, unrealism.
Serpentbane666 4 years ago 2
Spacecraft do't make noise as they "fly".
Realism was never any good.
goofymccoy 4 years ago
I did not mean real world realism. The whole concept of Star Wars would not fit then. But, in the movies context I must be able to belive the scenes.
It is just like in an action movie, the car chases are often spectacular, in real life the cars should be destroyed after the first 20 meter long 2 meter high jump, but it is good entertainment.
Serpentbane666 4 years ago
How ever, if the driver then desides to flip the car up on two wheels and drive up the wall on an large building, jumping of the edge landing on an elevated highway ramp, and then continue driving, the movie looses the fealing of realism in the context the movie is made in.
How "unreal" the scenes can be before it gets stupid would of corse depend on the movies own context and given boundaries.
Serpentbane666 4 years ago
...
Serpentbane666 4 years ago
Ah, suspension of disbelief.
I lost that when I heard the droid's new Mike Tyson voices... So stupid...
goofymccoy 4 years ago
i like the moment at 0:59
Boooom and whoooosh :P
Dazzy160 4 years ago
I liked this scene, but there should have been dogfights like in the book.
michaelferrarif1 4 years ago