metallica vs megadeth

[megadeth1960]

ride the lightning was my favorite song ever of metallicas but i will always prefer holy wars

[Aenskyd]

dude wtf, it's like Dave vs Dave, because that Ride the Lightning riff is written by Dave, and Four Horsemen is written by Dave too

[jediknights71]

wow... it's a Battle of Dave Mustaine's Riffs and a solo from Holy Wars...

thanks to Dave for writing the Mechanix,,, Metallica has something to rip-off...

[undefinedvishesh]

Metallica wins by mammoth!!!

[200nikos]

M E G A D E T H ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

[KingXta93]

Megadeth.

[killingismybusines34]

i think the obvious winner here is ]v[ E G A L L I C A!!!!!!

[rockonabc1]

I just noticed that Mustaine wrote all these four songs. It is Megadeth vs Megadeth. Megadeth wins.

[MrHoopla]

@rockonabc1 He co-wrote RTL. Other than that, yes, he wrote every single song here, even the solo in FH. Which was terribly improvised and ripped apart by Kirk....uch...Listen to how he repeats himself because he can't think of anything else compared to Mustaine as he shreds away!! Talentless shmuck....

[severto00]

MetallicA

[tavarespe]

SAY ONE MUSIC BETTER THAN HANGAR 18,HOLY WARS OR TORNADO OF SOULS??NO THERE,METALLICA FANS!!

[tavarespe]

MEGADETH LIFE STYLE!!

MEGADETH!!...OBEY!!

[guitaraddct94]

This songs we're all written by dave so ...

[MEGADETHTRETH]

Big no no

[Sl4YPe0PlE]

OMG all i hear is Metallica is better , Megadeath is better. SHUT UP! wanna know why there is a rivalry? Because of Dave Mustaine! if he would've stayed with metallica Megadeath and metallica fans wouldn't be beating the crap out of each other. also i must say that is Mustaine didn't come to Megadeath idk if they would as good as they are today and i don't even like Megadeath that much except for Hangar18 and rust In Peace

[vibkstn66]

Canciones de Mustain vs Mas canciones de Mustain , diferencia : Mustain salio de Metallica por sus problemas"" , MEGADETH .(sus solos son geniales)

[Chemicalwarfare84]

MEGADETH!!!!!

[Sl4YPe0PlE]

@Chemicalwarfare84 i love how your youtube name is the name of a Slayer song =)

[sunnyjim98]

MEGATALLICA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[DimitriVHefley]

@sunnyjim98 It's METALLIDETH, if it's anything, but I prefer MEGADETH!!!!!!

[sunnyjim98]

@DimitriVHefley MEGATALLIDETHICATHRAXER!!!!!!!

[Mrfatparakeet1]

dave mustaine wrote most of the riffs at least like a few songs from kill 'em all and a little on from there. To me their best album is ... and justice for all where i think dave had nothing to do with it but more so cliff (correct me if im wrong). As soon as cliff died and mustaine left it wen down hill from there, then they adopted jason and he left cuz he wasnt distributing his feeling through bass ( which i believe produced load n reload) but metallica still has it, just they rnt shown it

[MrTutosXP]

'80: Metallica > Megadeth

'90: Metallica > Megaporonga

'00: Metallica > Megadeth

2011: metallica > slayer > megadeth>antrax

metallica por siempre

[DimitriVHefley]

@MrTutosXP LOL such a moronic comment.

[MrTutosXP]

@DimitriVHefley if you do not like is your problem Defend metallica megadeth like me if you think that you get aa metallica megadeth follow that dream in your dreams that nothing else can happen

[SlaytanicMetalFace]

wel all of these songs are from dave , lol

metallica had some good songs

but megadeth rules man

[doom666kratos]

Metallica Old!

[LotsOfMetalUpYouAss]

Here's an idea!

Shut the hell up, and enjoy both bands!

[servantlol]

I can agree that Megadeth makes better albums now. I mean, United Abominations is easily one of the best metal records of the 00's. Death Magnetic was pretty good though. And to show that I still like Metallica, I even liked St Anger. If you have any insults, bring it on.

[MrAssSlapper]

80s Metallica and Megadeth are pretty close but its pretty obvious whos better after '91 or so

[RedGeneral66]

@MrAssSlapper After Bob Rock shit all over Metallica,Megadeth won the prize

[benitesw321]

aaaah they both suck hahahahaha

[JbrothersNUMBR1fan]

both suck

[ilovepantera97]

@JbrothersNUMBR1fan why are you watching the video then idiot?

[servantlol]

@JbrothersNUMBR1fan Obvious troll is obvious.

[CerebroUlceroso]

Fuck that songs, man! Why dont' "Shortest Straw" "Dyer's Eve" "Damage Inc" "The Frayed Ends Of Sanity" "Fight Fire With Fire"???

[08Cheeseits]

@CerebroUlceroso ikr

[victormlira]

i can't figure why people is always comparing megadeth to metallica. It's obvious that metallica is a huge band because they sold out and in the beginning mustaine was there helping them. Scott Ian in the movie get thrashed sad: "Without mustaine there wouldn't be metallica, without mustaine maybe there wouldn't be thrash metal at all."

[olverasamuel]

those two metallica songs where writen by mustaine haha metallica can SUCK IT 

[lisandroaguantlakd]

'80: Metallica > Megadeth

'90: Megadeth > Metallica

'00: Megadeth > Metallica

[kushal73]

poor choice of songs for comparison

[ZimrayaTV]

Metallica kicks the shit out of megadeth

[cjperkins1]

metallica has 4 legionary and also is more heaver and more intelligent with there songs and got more respect for all metal then megadeth ever did and megadeth has 2 legendary albums and there only a good band last long but metallica will last forever!

[TwiGGSTicK]

@cjperkins1 Metallica More heavy than Megadeth?

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[SasoriMaria]

metallica!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!

[fordfan197]

MEGADETH!!!

[14polaris14]

theres no ''both bands are fucking awesome!!!!!!!!'' button?

[MarcinSauron]

Old Metallica > old Megadeth

New Megadeth > new Metallica

[BogdanP28]

'80 : metallica > megadeth

'90 : megadeth > metallica

[evilchimpmunk566]

@BogdanP28

'00 : megadeth > metallica

[XQriousX]

POINTLESS DISCUSSION LOL.

[bananamankiller777]

Megadeth is more creative but I still find it hard to decide which one is "better".

[o8MetalHead8o]

.........*sighhhhh*

[MunicipalDude]

Megadeth.

[bananamankiller777]

I like Megadeth, but there fanbase is honestly almost as stupid as Slipknots...

[jackjr1000]

@bananamankiller777 your mom is as stupid as slipknot

[bananamankiller777]

@jackjr1000 Thanks for proving my point. Have a nice day.

[AHNorthbound]

@bananamankiller777 mmmm "there fanbase" is stupid? lol

[bananamankiller777]

@AHNorthbound Woops, I'm sorry I made a mistake I'm not perfect and infallible like Dave Mustaine... Thanks for staying relevant though... : /

[AHNorthbound]

@bananamankiller777 I think Dave realizes he's not perfect and I've never met any Megadeth fans who think he's "perfect and infallible". Sounds like you're being hypersensitive.

[bananamankiller777]

@AHNorthbound Sounds like you haven't met many Megadeth fans... I'm done talking to you, I have better ways to spend my time than arguing with 5 year old 35 year olds on youtube.

[AHNorthbound]

@bananamankiller777 Better things to do like chew on crayons?

I've been a fan of both bands since their conception and have met tons of fans on both sides. Just about every one I've met likes BOTH bands. The people who you are obviously talking about are called "fanboys". Both bands have fanboys and while they are annoying here they are really just the minority.

[bananamankiller777]

@AHNorthbound I know I said I wouldn't reply but that statement of yours was just so silly I just couldn't resist.

[AHNorthbound]

@bananamankiller777 Interesting how you are "done talking" yet here you are still acting like a fool.

[bananamankiller777]

@AHNorthbound Again, are you a tard? Did you think of reading ...both of those comments?

[AHNorthbound]

@bananamankiller777 So you're not only an annoying idiot fanboy but you're also a liar. Great job!

[deepfriedchickenhero]

@AHNorthbound The way I see it you're being the fanboy between the two. He didn't even say anything about either band and you just jumped into hypersensitive defense mode, which is... fanboyish.

[AHNorthbound]

@deepfriedchickenhero It is impossible for me to be a "fanboy" because I like both bands. A dunce cap for you as well.

[deepfriedchickenhero]

@AHNorthbound ... Umm, yeah, he said in his first comment that he liked Megadeth... Dunce cap sir?

[AHNorthbound]

@deepfriedchickenhero People who like Megadeth don't say sarcastic and stupid things like "I'm not perfect and infallible like Dave Mustaine". And how is any of this your business?

[deepfriedchickenhero]

@AHNorthbound What does that have to do with not liking Megadeth? I think he was criticizing their fans more than anything. There are many Megadeth fans that do seem to think that.

[AHNorthbound]

@deepfriedchickenhero I doubt if you have ever met any Megadeth fan that believes Dave is "perfect and infallible" (which is redundant). Dave knows he's made mistakes, the fans know he's made mistakes... bananamankiller777's comments are nonsensical. The fans just want Dave to get credit where credit is due.

[deepfriedchickenhero]

@AHNorthbound No. maybe they don't actually say he's perfect, but many of them certainly don't seem to want to acknowledge his mistakes... at least you dropped the whole fanboy thing, he never even mentioned Metallica lol.

[AHNorthbound]

@deepfriedchickenhero All I can tell you is that I've been a fan of both bands for years and have never met anyone like that (not even on YouTube).

Nice to see you dropped the fanboy thing as well.

[deepfriedchickenhero]

@AHNorthbound What do you mean "anyone like that"? I still don't see why you got so mad at him. It all started with him saying Megadeth has a stupid fanbase. I hate to tell you, but this is absolutely true. I've heard everything from Dave invented thrash to Metallica never even was thrash. Obviously none of that is true, yet we hear it every day, and I'm sure he does too. Criticizing Megadeth's fanbase makes one a Metallica fanboy? I'm sorry but their is zero rationallity in that.

[WeeboShepard]

@deepfriedchickenhero Dave did invent thrash metal. he wrote all of the origanal songs on KEA (the others were writtin by james and his fellow bandmates in leather charm), which influenced bands like slayer, exodus and anthrax then he went on to create megadeth and yes i am a megadeth fanboy and most megadeth fans can back up their claims.

[ghettogamer718]

@bananamankiller777 Ugh! Agreed! You criticize one little thing about Megadeth and your labelled a Metallica fanboy even if you don't mention Metallica!

[lewis3265]

Love both bands, but I say old Metallica hands down.

[kingdiamondtheeye]

@lewis3265 too slow not heavy engough

[lewis3265]

@kingdiamondtheeye Metallica's older music is not too slow. Its not any faster or slower than Megadeaths. Metallicas older music is more hard core than Megadeath, but they still rock.

[marianomcastro]

JAJAJAJAJA All song are written by MUSTAINE, MUSTAINE IS GOOD

[hxcmetalheadforlife]

Metallica's new albums are great

Megashit have always sucked

[ThatKrookedVulture]

@hxcmetalheadforlife Are you fckin' kidding me? Metallica will always be one of my favourite metal bands, but Death Megnetic was the most dissapointing metal album of all time. Have you even listened to Megadeth's new album Edngame? I guarentee that no matter how much you prefer Metallica over Megadeth, after you listen to Endgame you'll agree that Endgame completely blows Death Magnetic out of the water. Check it out. You'd have to hate metal to not worship this album

[killer92173]

@ThatKrookedVulture No, St. Anger is worse than Death Magnetic.

[luc00leh]

@ThatKrookedVulture Yeah but still Death Magnetic is a great album! The Judas Kiss!

[ThatKrookedVulture]

@luc00leh Judas Kiss was pretty badass.

[luc00leh]

@ThatKrookedVulture Thats what I mean!

[MrHoopla]

@ThatKrookedVulture 100% agree, Endgame was easily the best album they made since Rust in Piece. Nothing any metal band could come up with will ever compare to it, it's a masterpiece. Instant classic. And Chris Broderick is a freaking musical god. Almost moreso than Dave Mustaine.

[EmilyMcLaren25]

@ThatKrookedVulture I agree that Endgame blows DM outta the water, but you can't seriously say DM was the most disappointing. St. Anger was complete shit, and in my opinion - though it's nt the greatest - DM was a good comeback from St. Anger.

[ThatKrookedVulture]

@EmilyMcLaren25 Yeah I definately agree that Death Magnetic was at least a step up from St. Anger. I hate the fact that Lars doesn't know the difference between a drum set and a pair of trash cans. It's that fucking snare drum!

[roseslashizzyduffste]

cliff burton was the best in metallica.

burton and mustaine are my gods.

[TheMetalhead1311]

The best Metallica lineup would be Mustaine, Hetfield, Ulrich, and Newsted. Thumbs up if you agree.

[luc00leh]

@TheMetalhead1311 Well almost right! Mustaine, Hetfield, Ulrich and ..... Cliff Burton!

[guitardudde1]

mettaladeath

[MRec1124]

The way i see it, there is Megadeth fans and there are Metallica fans but only the true fans who truly respect the bands like them both the same.

[sludgegod666]

You made a Mustaine Vs Mustaine video, so I guess Mustaine wins:)

[06shinoaburame]

dude you cant use those songs from metallica Dave Mustaine wrote them GO DAVE MUSTAINE!!

[ulpdy0]

This isn't a very fair comparison, both of the Metallica songs you used were co-written by Dave.

[desdemona222b]

Mustaine did write most of these riffs. You cannot make an educauted comment on the matter unless you've heard to old Metallica demos from when he was in the band. Metallica stole Dave Mustaine's style, and predicated their enitre band on it.

No Life till Leather noobs

[deadslutbluewater]

@desdemona222b really man, im so glad u were there to no the hardcore truth about it all n pass ur hardcore truth onto all of us

[servantlol]

I love both bands, a lot (I'll even listen to St Anger), but I probably like Megadeth more. lol I made a mix of Megadeth songs and burned them to a CD, and now I have it on repeat in my car. x)

[Thewolfman280]

It's all mustaine choose a metallica song mustaine didn't write

[theDirtySanchez92]

Stop this fight!

There is an army of Justin Bieber fans to fight!

*sign of the hammer*

[santillica]

both wins but fuck people are like metallica comercial and megadeth is not mustaine saids their commercial goddamned a bet some of them are they see a megadeth video some fucktard saids metallica is commercial and too look bad ass they repeat that.

Metallica doesn't suck now thats bullshit the same history some video some fucktard some stupid comment some kid trying to look badass repeat the stupid comment

[kharlos84]

mmm i think trashed went thru differents ways when mustain started Megadeth, so i dont see the point of this video . Both are good specially when both are the god fathers of trashed metal

[Metalthrasher100]

Megadeth are best, metallica is so commercial

[santillica]

@Metalthrasher100 well megadeth do a music video first and they more than metallica so i thinks megadeth is more comercial get your fact

[Roflmaokiller]

ride the lightning vs holy wars -> Holy wars wins

The four Horsemen vs Good Mourning, black friday -> The four horsemen wins

VERDICT: I like both :)

Roflmaokiller over and out

[custardfilleddounut]

both bands are good, but metallica wins because they make masterpieces like fade to balck, one, and nothing else matters. It doesnt matter if mustaine wrote 5 songs for metallica. but hetfields lyrics are more meaningful

[johead22]

@custardfilleddounut metallica has the dumbest lyrics ever, there's nothing deep in a metallica song

[custardfilleddounut]

@johead22 I dont argue but dude have you ever listened to lyrics in a metallica song?

[johead22]

@custardfilleddounut I sure did, I even use to be a metallica fanboy

[thesuperpizzaman]

Eh, Ride the Lightning was Dave's work if I remember. And I choose Megadeth. But both are good...Except the 90's metallica

[MetalOliver]

i gotta say that since 2002 megadeth has been my favorite band and metallica doesn't even take place in my top 10 but still, both are awesome ofc, im just saying this not to get trashed talk by some fanboys.

[xXTheSandman2Xx]

Metallica is overrated but still really good but MEGADETH Rules over Metallica with an Iron Fist ready to lauch the Polaris!!

[angelgym1]

all the songs in this video are written by mustaine -_-

[JohnBlack64]

@angelgym1 yeah i noticed that hahahaha

[Flames262574]

@angelgym1 ride the lightning wasnt dumbshit

[keitharbie]

@Flames262574

You're wrong. Dave. along with Lars, James, and Cliff wrote Ride the Lightning... You can google it if you want to.

[Flames262574]

@keitharbie just the spider chord that was it

[keitharbie]

@Flames262574

You're wrong.

[kingstomman]

@angelgym1 except ride which only have a few of mustaines riffs in it

[ilovepantera97]

@angelgym1 mustaine only made a little of metallicas songs. he did not write any songs

[mseals29]

@angelgym1 WRONG If you think coming up with one riff is writing a song you and every Megadave fan is retarded

[MrTsouras]

both bands are very good

but metallica are better

[JohnBlack64]

@MrTsouras no metallica is much more simplistic and has half of the talent megadeth has

[GillesGerais]

i hate this argument.

ill allways hold megadeth in higher regard than metallica.

what they did during the load days was just inexcusable. total fags they have become.

and if you cant see that then you are obviously ignorant

[Armagon9177]

]\/[ E G A DET ]-[ !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

LOL, even a song on Metallica's side was written by Dave Mustaine.

]\/[ E G A DET ]-[ has a much broader scope. Metallica's experimentation failed with LOAD, while Cryptic Writings was great, Risk sucked but was called Risk because even the band knew that they were playing with fire. LOAD may as well have been called SHIT instead. Metallica lives off of past glory, and none of their new albums post Black album are worth anything. Endgame kicks ass.

[ayyyspeegle]

old metallica beats megadeth. now metallica sucks, but i still love em

[JohnBlack64]

@ayyyspeegle no deth is better haha

[ayyyspeegle]

@JohnBlack64 i love both i just dont like metallicas new shit

[apocolyptic4u]

both bands are my fave ya!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

[myballzzyourchin1]

megadeth.. PERIOD

[rodrigogier]

metallica = commercial noise.

megadeth = best band ever.

[Trendkill4]

Megadeth wins ofc

[SavageDutchman]

InTorment you know that a lot of the riffs of the metallica song you chose where written by Mustaine, so basicly it is like making Mustaine play against himself.

[rodrigogier]

metallica sucks after 1991

commercial band

moneyllica

[666IchHasseMusik666]

slayer is the best

[erisos2]

megadeth is good but METALLICA is way better .megadeth is way too raw just compare the four horseman with the mechanix plus daves singing im not gonna say its horrible definitely not better than james singing ........plus if megadeth is way better than metallica why is dave crying about something that happened over twenty years ago

[JakeKirbieMUSIC]

In My Darkest Hour For Whom the Bell Tolls Opening riff

Dawn Patrol The God That Failed Riff

She-wolf Disposable Heroes Opening riff

When The Call of Ktulu Opening riff

Go to Hell Enter Sandman Riff and lyrics

[JakeKirbieMUSIC]

Ok fags, Metallica did not steal shit

1. dave mustaine was in the band for kill em all so they arent going to re record the whole album

2. he only wrote 6 of the lead guitar tracks

3. 5 on Kill em all, 1 on ride the lightning

The songs without dave mustaine are MUCH MUCH better

and dave mustaine stole tons of metallica's music

ill give u a list and u can compare them yourselves

[Chester1004]

@JakeKirbieMUSIC

You are Metallica fanboy!

He co-wrote 2 songs on Ride the lighting, the song itself and Call of chulhu.

And realize that Mustaine wrote dbest songs on kill em all and lighting.

Plz give me a list and tell me what songs did Dave stole from Metallica.

You do realize Metallica stole his songs as clearly told them they cant use his stuff.

[JakeKirbieMUSIC]

@Chester1004 Actually I love both bands

and they where NOT the best songs

lightning and ktulu are nothing like the kirk hammet songs off Ride

and i never knew u where there when he said that? cause apparently HE NEVER DID.

they didnt steal his music.. HE WAS IN THE BAND

and he didnt take full songs like mechanix, he took riffs, and i did give a list

[Chester1004]

@JakeKirbieMUSIC

Watch Megadeth documentary part 5, there is your proof about stealing his music.

Im still waiting for the list or did you finaly realize that Megadeth doesnt sound nothing like Metallica...

[necrofilic0profago]

metallica is gay as hell

megadeth is one of the bests bands ever

so EPIC FAIL comparing the both bands

[kirenian]

@emileboucher yeah, you're right about the riffs, plus ride the lightning is still a mustaine riff....anyway, this is a stupid battle, because both are good, and if you truly like great music you'd like them both and stop arguing about who's better....thumbs up for metallica, megadeth, and metal!!!!

[fuckingmetalheadbang]

1ª Best Band Ever - METALLICA

2º Best Band Ever - MEGADEATH

[Manectric7]

Well, in the early days, Dave used to give the speed Metallica needed for their songs... When they threw him out, they continued to play like that... so the conclusion is that Megadeth is part of Metallica (since Dave was a member)

and Metallica is part of Dave... So deciding who is the best has no meaning, because both kick ass... but i would say Megadeth!

[yonisinai1]

megadeath is way better than metallica....i think the best thing metallica ever did is throwing dave away ...... :)

[gardinur1]

@yonisinai1 hmmm. i´ve never heard of a band called megadeath

[erisos2]

@yonisinai1 metallica is way better than megadeth....i think the

best thing metallica ever did is throwing dave away......

:)

[OneMustyDog]

justin beiber, now everyone fight

[AngelofApocalipse13]

metallica

WINS

BECAUSE only count the most popular albums of both bands  MASTER OF PUPPETS chew and spit out rust in peace

[Manectric7]

@AngelofApocalipse13

master of puppets is overrated

[erisos2]

@Manectric7 symphony of destruction is overrated

[Manectric7]

@erisos2

yeah, a bit... but it's sure nicer than load and reload...

basically i am a fan of their three first albums, when they used to be completely badass ^m^>

with symphony of destruction, they softened a lot... :/

[KrasiGorinov]

Both of them suck a lot. Actually why do you listen to heavy and trash?...Bad singing, awful drums and banal solos, ugh. Maybe the guitars are making the situation a little better, but they can't help it much. Try metalcore, deathcore, sth. that can make your hearts beat faster.

[skaterdouche4]

@KrasiGorinov metalcore sucks ass and its called thrash metal not trash trash is bfmv emo faggots who think theyre cool cuz they scream and sing like 8 year old girls and deathcore is just noise its all the same banging on drums as fast as u can besides real metal made ur shitty metalcore and deathcore