This Was Scottish before the Irish claimed it changed a few word a few notes here and there And now its Irish I dont think so its SCOTTISH and old Gaelic tune hundreds of yrs old... someone added words its and old Air written for the Scottish Fiddle By a Scotsman... :)
@pipergirl12 The song as it is now can only be traced back in print to the US about a century ago however it was a version of a much older British song, probably from Scotland originally but known throughout the island. No doubt it was around in Ireland too but it only became well known in Ireland after Hamish Imlach the Scots folk singer taught the song to Christy Moore.
The comment was sarcastic. Pam2737 commented that she wished Arany didn't have a woman singing it since she thought it was creepy. I disagreed: "Seriously, the song is just fine." Whether sung by a woman to a woman, a woman to a guy, a guy to a woman or a guy to a guy, it doesn't detract from the beauty of the song itself.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
beautiful!! this song is awesome...... but i'd rather if the song could change the "her· parts to "him" it sounds like the singer is singing to another woman, kind of lesbian......that's creepy......apart from that, awesome!!!!
u couldnt get better pictures unbelevable views , track isnt bad either
marlotopdog666 2 days ago
Beautiful photography!
HildegardBirkenstein 2 weeks ago
It is a Scottish song...the author is unknown. The reference...in the original song... to the Clyde is a clear reference to Scotland.
creach58 3 weeks ago
Therehasbeenan 1 month ago
This is an Irish not Scottish song !! ;) but Your cover is really nice !
erundill 1 month ago
This piece is folk music music from IRELAND, not Scotland!
pipergirl12 1 month ago
@pipergirl12 The song as it is now can only be traced back in print to the US about a century ago however it was a version of a much older British song, probably from Scotland originally but known throughout the island. No doubt it was around in Ireland too but it only became well known in Ireland after Hamish Imlach the Scots folk singer taught the song to Christy Moore.
gaconnochie 2 weeks ago
amazing. love it. like a flower in a desert of stone...
Sebastian7908 2 months ago
I wish I could hear songs like this on tv or radio.
xXxRaluChanxXx 2 months ago
What kind of instruments are they using?
Koveena15 2 months ago
Fitting tribute to a classic ballad.
maltavmalta 2 months ago
Is this type of music that called "Folk music"?
paga123456789 3 months ago
Before I die I have to visit Scotland.
dondi2261 3 months ago
cudowne zdjecia,nastrojowa muzyka,czego chciec więcej,super !!!!
52agatony 3 months ago 4
simply gorgeous!!
saluteforever 4 months ago
I would like to thank Jwana for the fantastic Irish Studies lesson which was held by her:)
kiscsaj91 5 months ago
@kovacsandras
The comment was sarcastic. Pam2737 commented that she wished Arany didn't have a woman singing it since she thought it was creepy. I disagreed: "Seriously, the song is just fine." Whether sung by a woman to a woman, a woman to a guy, a guy to a woman or a guy to a guy, it doesn't detract from the beauty of the song itself.
MyrddinwyIIt 6 months ago
@MyrddinwyIIt My fault, never mind.
kovacsandras 6 months ago
TOP! Reallllllllllly epic Song!
My big dream: To visit scotland...
magicsign75 6 months ago 2
Incredibly beautiful natural scenery of Scotland in this video haunts me
hkjazzable 6 months ago
wow ;D
Rysiek804 7 months ago
@pamk2737
Yeah, it IS kinda creepy. Change the words to "he" and "him" and have a guy sing it.
That'd be much more palatable.
Seriously, the song is just fine. Thanks, Arany, for a very moving rendition.
MyrddinwyIIt 7 months ago
@MyrddinwyIIt why is a lesbian interpretation creepy?
kovacsandras 6 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
beautiful!! this song is awesome...... but i'd rather if the song could change the "her· parts to "him" it sounds like the singer is singing to another woman, kind of lesbian......that's creepy......apart from that, awesome!!!!
pam2737 10 months ago
Zoltan is making the world a better place!
OnePavellechev 10 months ago 26
Greetings from Bulgaria! Great Song!
OnePavellechev 10 months ago
Awesome song!
TheAirportdream 10 months ago
this is amazing...voice of Jwana...just speechless
orp26 10 months ago
This wonderful song need's more views! ;)
colakarim 11 months ago
Nagyon szép, már lassan századszor hallgatom végig:) köszönöm
arnajka 11 months ago
hi arany,
lovely tune and yes, your flute playing suites rthe mood.
Braveheart?
j.
djrbfm 11 months ago
Wow
salerio11 11 months ago
Nice pictures too.
TheHaetinger 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
super duper cool
HAMMERHEARTSSB 11 months ago 2
Great and epic song! My appreciation... The most i like the sound of your flutes in youe songs. Very well done :)
fevencil 11 months ago 10