Source Engine vs. Gold Source

[Factemius]

This is Half life: Source, not Half life.

[nayster131]

@Factemius how can it be half lfie source with hl2 guns

[gamefan1997]

137 and 137.

Fuck... i hope this isnt the new "arrow in the knee" thing. Ive seen it balenced on 3 videos now...

[glennglog22]

disliked just to balance it

[SuperGameYear]

source engine is best headcrab zombie of hl 1 ys giant

[mrlego611]

Even though I like this vid and everything, I had to dislike to balanace this out

[FapOffToFood]

i broke the balance :D

[Greatdictator]

Time to tip the scales in mah favor

[Kurisuchianu89]

118 vs 118! :D:D

[glennglog22]

somebody dislike this to balance this out

[Xenos7777777]

I have disrupted the balance!

[Thegreenmonkey88]

NOW is balanced by meeeee!!

[Kurisuchianu89]

103 vs 103, I HAVE BROUGHT BALANCE TO THE FORCE! YEAH!

[WeatbixZ]

101 likes and 101 dislikes omg!

[goku1550]

i have distroyed the balance!

[SuperEmoBros]

@Gmister2

"had different weapon models"

Um, they were ported into Half-Life 1 using a modeling program.

[dailyplanet123456]

i balanced it guys so THUMBS UP FOR ME!!!! :DDDDDDD

[gamealogic]

@dailyplanet123456 Thumbsupwhore.

[glennglog22]

JUST KEEP IT BALANCED!

[adliikhwan280]

@4131025 its HL2:EP3 dumbass.

[Gmister2]

@MunchyToast001 Half life was the origional, Half life:SOURCE was given better effects and a higher polygon count (although the difference is quite small between them) this isn't Goldsrc, the graphics where different and the weapons had different models

[J0k3r2010]

someone please balance again.

[cheat12code]

@J0k3r2010

done

[gtachile100]

Now 69 And 69 I Blanced.

[ghostkiller123456789]

I just balanced the like dislike bar, do i get top comment now?

[Ecowildfish]

Hl3 or ep3 or what ever will most likely run on portal 2's new version of source.

[Gmister2]

that's not goldsource, thats the source engine both times

[MunchyToast001]

@Gmister2 Im designing for Source already a long time and :

GoldSource : First version of the Source engine , with a base code of Quake , because it made the first step in valves history of popular series its called GoldSource.

Source : Valves latest engine , purely self-made by Valve. Not using any other code content and supporting latest technology of Gaming , like Particles and Dynamic lights.

[Gmister2]

@MunchyToast001 I know what it is but goldsource isn't in the video, those games are HL2 and HL:S

[MunchyToast001]

@Gmister2 Well wrong again.

HL:S Didnt supported the skins in this video , nor the particles.

If the game would be made in Source, you would see normaly reflecting water and the ground hits same like the other games.

But since it was GoldSRC it had custom HL2 skins in form of .pak files.

And also didnt owned the technology to make transparent water.

Also the explosions are different from Source.

[Gmister2]

@MunchyToast001 have you ever played the origional, GoldSRC cant handle those kind of graphics, it's source both times and you NEED to play the origional

[DIM0RI]

@Gmister2 I've played the original game story couple of times through and I can say that is definitely the original Goldsource. It's probably the HD version of it though since the shotgun is using the HD-sounds which I hate. The best way to see the difference between the game engines, is that the Source engine won't make giblets when a zombie is exploded by remote charge but Goldcourse will.

[glennglog22]

60 likes and 60 dislikes KEEP IT BALANCED!

[MysteriousStrangerxX]

@glennglog22 Now Its 64 and 64

[glennglog22]

@MysteriousStrangerxX now 66 and 66

[97bosko]

@glennglog22 And now 87 and 87:)

[glennglog22]

@97bosko now 91 and 91

[RawrNinjaBurgers]

@glennglog22 month later 108 vs 108

[picorettte]

@glennglog22 yes sir i just balanced it further :p

[patmginipig]

gold source wins!

[RadioactiveBlutonium]

Gold Source wins in : Gibbing, Epicer Shotgun sounds and EPIC CROWBAR ACTION ANIMATION.

Other than that, Source wins.

[MultiAnimals1]

The sounds weren't actually that accurate :\ the guns only have those sounds in a half life remake :(

[x12manny34]

you guys really hate physics dont you?

SOURCE ENGINE FTW

[GeneralSchultz]

Valve the dream of every console player but the reality for the pc player

[956Joeboy]

@GeneralSchultz you said it but this is like the only fps my computer can handle im gonna get a mac mini(bootcamp) or a graphics card

[Briggsman1000]

I hope HL3 or HL2EP3 whatever it will be called will be running on the source engine so my computer can support it

[UnknownGamerX]

which one free?

[Maestroshnitzel]

@UnknownGamerX What do you mean 'free'? The only way you can get the files for either of these engines is to purchase a game that uses them. If that's what you mean by free.

[Maestroshnitzel]

@UnknownGamerX What do you mean 'free'? The only way you can get the files for either of these engines is to purchase a game that uses them. If that's what you mean by free.

[chipaputalaguea]

gold source has better sounds, seriously the gun sounds pretty realistic

[DimaszDSF]

@chipaputalaguea nope, all the sounds and models can be changed as in GoldSource and in Source engine

[kaledranger18]

i like both

[KirbyY15]

i actually prefer the gold source

[why0isnt0this0workin]

Hey is there anyway that I can get these models? How did you port them to GoldSource? Thanks!

[vkyle52]

watch?v=YRfOUBzTiQw

[GTAIndonesia]

LINK FOR MODELS!

[breakerboy365]

Look at it this way, Source is MORE DYNAMIC GRAPHICS and PHYSICS

tada

[HeavySandvichGuy1]

1:27 WTF? HL2 headcrab

[hovsep56]

the best way to see wich one is better on the 1 first on bad frames

on the second good frames

[Piedoom0]

They are both amazing for the time that they were released. Lets keep it to that.

[FelixJohanHagman]

its 49 likes and 49 dislikes, does this mean they are the same?...

[Blaze6108]

There's quite funny feature that goldsource has but source hasn't. In goldsource if you pause The game all sounds stop. With source some sounds and effects keep working even if you pause The game.

[Christophelaures]

GoldScr is not New:it looks like HL1 but Sourcce Engine looks like HL2 and is better

[csmapper58]

@Loquederoguevara12 GOLDSRC! GOLDSRC! GOLDSRC! GOLDSRC! GOLDSRC! GOLDSRC! GOLDSRC! GOLDSRC!

[k3v1nfbr]

guys, valve said they will still use the source engine for the new games :(

[AwesomeRudi51]

42 likes and 42 dislikes. rofl

[NoodleGhost]

Gold source wins because you can run it on practically anything :3

[qiman2]

GOLDSOURCE WINS.

[scruffy688]

You guys are so stupid, GoldSrc is so obviously better.

[TheJoebama]

You don't need physics or ragdolls to make a good game.

[Kulawendin]

@TheJoebama True, but physics or ragdolls can make an already good game better.

[NanosoftRussia]

Half life will probably made on Source Engine 2 with cool graphics, but Valve is not busy with it so need to wait long until it comes.

[Dimbark]

goldsource i sbest -- also, you only compared2 games, not 2 engines.

[G3org3Master]

Remember the joy of seeing for the first time the source engine around 2004 for half life 2. That was epic. It was better than anything else at it's time.

[honestbob456]

i wonder if the gold source engine was developed under half life 1.......

[JimmyCognitti]

Al right, I'm tired of idiotic comments.... I know Source is much more advanced than Gold Source. I made this video just for fun and that's it.

Also, I made this video years ago on my old computer using FRAPS.

End of the story.

[a0001521]

source engine is better than cry engine and unreal 3 engine combined

[G3org3Master]

@a0001521 uuh Im sorry to say, you're wrong.

[a0001521]

@G3org3Master sorry for my retardness

[pixelTRE]

Source engine features better graphics, gold source features better game play mechanics (e.g gun recoil, movement, character world scale).

GOLD SOURCE

[G3org3Master]

@pixelTRE lol look at source's physics and ragdolls... what do you mean goldSrc has better movement? and whats character world scale?

[Kulawendin]

I bet Half-Life 3 is taking so long because they want to introduce a new engine with it.

[rerundadog]

@Kulawendin Doubt it, probley the same as the l4d2 engine (NOT THE SAME AS hl2!)

[rerundadog]

@Kulawendin well its been modified 

[samul242]

@Kulawendin most likly since games are switching from complete ragdoll to a mixture of rig and ragdoll effects.

[coms758]

@Kulawendin They will use Portal2 source.

[gamealogic]

@coms758 -_- *facepalm*

[G3org3Master]

@gamealogic agreed

[gamealogic]

@G3org3Master lol

[gskillyproductions]

@Kulawendin source engine is updated every year, will stay source though.

[SirithHeruwen]

@Kulawendin

No... Because they're not even done with the second game.

But yes if you think that they're doing all those extra episodes to win time.

[TheStonedpope]

@Kulawendin nope thats not it, you have to think big like....they aren't planing making games for a while....

[vkohmoviemaker]

@Kulawendin Half Life 3 was never officially announced

[Kulawendin]

@vkohmoviemaker Learn 2 speculate.

[vkohmoviemaker]

@Kulawendin No. Telling lies is not the kind of thing I would do. There's nothing I should do so don't you command me.

[Kulawendin]

@vkohmoviemaker lolwut

[PowerFusionX]

@Kulawendin Or because they aren't done with the HL2 series yet.

Duh.

[Kulawendin]

@PowerFusionX More like they aren't done with the source engine.

[ledZeppelin7680]

@Kulawendin highly unlikely, valve said they have no intention of creating a new engine, and they prefer to update source engine regularly and keep it up to date.

[Kulawendin]

@ledZeppelin7680 Exactly, the source engine is doing very well for them at the moment which could be why they want to postpone Half-Life 3 and the inevitable new engine that may come with it. There WILL be a new engine at some point, it's just a matter of time.

[ledZeppelin7680]

@Kulawendin but they said they would just keep updating source as time went by, meaning instead of creating a new engine, they add new features to source. and they hadn't even thought about half life 3 yet, the original plan was to have another episodic HL 2 instalment, but doug lombardi said in a recent interview that the next half life release may not be episode 3, to me that sounds like a hint at half life 3, and this interview was done months after valve denied the need for a new engine.

[TheRealDutchOwner]

@Kulawendin, Oh hell no. I don't want a new engine. That we can't use GMod! Just another mayor Source engine update like Portal 2.

[karim20983]

@Kulawendin You mean Half-Life 2: Episode 3

[Kulawendin]

@karim20983 No, that's likely to be on the source engine.

[ibainesy]

@Kulawendin To that comment, of course they're gonna make a new engine for Half life 3... unless you're talking about Episode 3 for Half life 2then i'd say no it's the last game in the series and they want to make it epic.

[behems007]

@Kulawendin Do you think that first game with their new engine will be HL3?! :D I really don't think so... I think that will be like Counter-Strike 2.

[kristallize]

@Kulawendin It's rather looks like Valve making Ep3 Hydra controller-tied.

[B3rgh0rn]

@Kulawendin ofc

[TheHalflife123]

@Kulawendin no valve doesn't make engines they just upgrade old ones like quake engine --> goldsoure --> source and maybe source --> source 2 but its still same quake engine based engine until valve makes totally NEW engine which isn't based on any other engine

[Kulawendin]

@TheHalflife123 That's like saying that Apple doesn't make operating systems, they just upgrade Unix.

[TheHalflife123]

@Kulawendin may be but if you think about it precisely its true. btw have you even seen quake engine's family tree?

[NodachiDaimyo]

@Kulawendin Valve hasn't even finished Episode 3, hold your horses.

[erilyd97]

@NodachiDaimyo They have said that they aren't making any more episodes

[trekhead1]

@Kulawendin it wouldn't surprise me

[erilyd97]

@Kulawendin Dont get your hopes up ... They have stated that they do not have any plans for a new engine :S

[adliikhwan280]

@Kulawendin its not HL3. Its HL2:EP3

[MadCowsGaming]

@Kulawendin no ? souce is too damn epic and irreplaceable

[Stover36]

@Kulawendin Source 2. Native DX11... Man that would be amazing.

[maxrocks1929]

@footieboy50 goldsrc is the engine for Half-life. Source is the engine for half-life 2

[jasper561996]

So here is the result:

Source: Very laggy

GSource: Doesn't lag at all

So I prefer GSource xD

[MeGaEdIIToRMaN]

Source Engine is still better...

[JeydetaJosen]

@MeGaEdIIToRMaN goldscr is a Engine Modifikation from QuakeWorld.. its one of the oldest eninges ever...

[MeGaEdIIToRMaN]

@JeydetaJosen Yes, I know it's older. But why compare Source Engine with Gold Source Engine, when source engine still win's? :)

[JeydetaJosen]

@MeGaEdIIToRMaN :D good question!

[badboyforlife10195]

Whats gold source?

[minnieskater]

this is a joke, right?

[FoobyZeeky]

This is completely unfair. You just ported the Source weapon models to Goldsource. How the hell is that comparing the two engines? You can't compare those two engines anyway. They are over 10 years apart.

[sonicdsfan1]

Whats gold source?

[Crazykevin91]

@sonicdsfan1 because you asked that your turned into a snark!

[sonicdsfan1]

@Crazykevin91 nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

[flashmozzg]

@sonicdsfan1

engine of hl1/cs 1,6 and so on.

[4131025]

@sonicdsfan1 Gold Source = HL1 Engine

[sonicdsfan1]

@4131025 so its the same thing?

[DaMasterSarge]

Ok.

Gold Source:It WAS one of the best engines to exsist till 2001 it will be remembered hugely although its time is over.

Source:Is one of the best engines to exsist although its starting to age its updating.

[EnjoiTheElephant]

GoldSrc had appeal to classic gamers now, and at it's release was almost top notch. The source engine is much more updated with new graphics, etc. Not saying goldsrc was bad, but there isn't really a need for comparison considering their made about 7 years apart

[legolasisahobbo]

old zombies are better it looks like the head crabs are on them not part of them



[themaniacboy]

@legolasisahobbo I don't think so, now it actually looks like the headcrabs hopped on their heads, in goldsource, it looked like glue pasted them together

[legolasisahobbo]

gld src is great but it doesnt have shading really or dynamic shadows (in certain hl2 maps)

[336Roach]

@legolasisahobbo Actually... GoldSrc have dynamic shadows, but they deleted it in the retail version of Half-Life, watch the beta trailer of Half-Life, you see there is dynamic shadows ;)

[legolasisahobbo]

@336Roach Cool but im guessing I said dynamic shading

[LAZrailkapinda]

Lets be honest.. the explosion & water effects on the gold source are horrible.. but it has it's own appeal.. I like it. Source engine wins , newer technology ^^

[LuigiKat11]

I like GoldSrc's graphics better, call me crazy but I like it's style!

[The1337DoomCokie]

Whats gold source?

[Roylonger1]

@The1337DoomCokie the engine HL1, OpFor, BS, and CS run on.

[SRMTHFGLover1]

Half Life 2 FTW

[FlopperMax]

The hl2 engine was created FROM the hl1 engine

[avatarion]

you're just showing weapon models.

[Protomasterexe]

Download link plz.

[OwnageFish]

@Protomasterexe lolwtfbbq

[DaFleegsta]

gold is better gameplay.. cs 1.6 is played more than css, and not just comepetively.. source just has cooler features and better graphics..

[Neptutron]

How do you even compare them, one is old and one is not, they are the same company!

[cstriker45]

the only thing that I have to say about the goldsrc engine is that there is some kind of fog all the time and the water textures are all terrible. about the source engine I have to say that in my computer maybe it is really laggy

[unbrokenjack]

@cstriker45 The fog is needed to make it less laggy - if you have things far away that you can't see, the computer doesn't need to render them, so they're covered by fog.

[csmapper58]

@unbrokenjack I don't mean that. I don't mean the fact that when you get away from something it doesn't render. I mean that in hl1 there is some kind of fog all the time, it's the way you see everything in hl1. and yes, I was cstriker45

[unbrokenjack]

@csmapper58 Ahh okay.

[shawn2007g]

love the shotgun's cocking sound.

[thehumor]

u just compared the half life 2 engine

with half life 1 engine

u cant

is no possible

[illustriousclown]

I was shocked when Half-Life was out. It was a masterpiece in every single point of view.

[misbooon]

ummm i like source engine more (:

[lamthoihai00]

what the name of the game using gold source in video ?

[re4pt0x]

@lamthoihai00 lol it's HL1 with hl2 weapons

[imnotstpid]

well come on, source is obviously going to win, just look at those textures

[philjoybaluyut]

guys stop fighting

and i have a problem why valve didnt make SilverSource RedSource or any engines (ps colors like silver red orange ate etc.)

[TigerMeet2142]

both engine are state of art,

Goldsrc : 1999 and then those 2002 graphics!

Source : 2004 and then those 2008 graphics!

valve is always 4 years better with making engines, come one 2011 and source is still in use for upcoming games

[SuperEmoBros]

Pistol and zombie are a bit different

[111lower]

Both Engines are perfect but I prefer goldsource. :) Best thing on goldsource = Gibs :D

[dottorrent]

@fever309

basically play hl1

[Nicsmovies]

I just wish that I could map gold source with somthing other than hammer

[ThePsychoCrusher89]

goldsrc is better because it looks good at any resolution, source looks like crap if not running at the native resolution of your screen hehe

[AlexStenka]

@ThePsychoCrusher89

your wrong there but ok