Added: 3 years ago
From: Sykorax
Views: 7,649
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (76)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • thanks for an informative analysis

  • Sykorax... you are awesome. This is a very good presentation of your opinions; a perfect marriage of intellect and passion, which I never tire of seeing- especially in fellow Sonic fans.

  • @ryarod Thank you for the support!

  • SUK ON TAHT, MARIO!

  • thank you for not saying stuff like the new sonic games suck,modern sonic is a fag and most of all thank you for saying that sonic 06 don't suck

  • @shadowandluigifan989 Your welcome!

  • have no fear under dog is here :D

  • what do you think of sonic colors?

  • sonic adventure 2 is a 100 times better then sonic 3 & knuckles

  • I thought the voice acting in sonic 06 was much worse than the sonic adventure games!

  • ? hiding in the daRK are u calling sonic gay

  • sonic is somewhat lacking lately but heres hoping generations sets things right

  • The game is not up to date any more its been posted since 2008. Stop our use less posting that its not correct.

  • Best 3D sonic: 1º Sonic Adventure, 2º Sonic Adventure 2

    Best 2D sonic: 1º Sonic the Hedgehog, 2º Sonic & Knuckles

  • Of all the 'top sonic games' videos I've seen, this Is there first one that featured SA2B.And I also don't understand why people dislike SA2 though? All I hear is that "SA2 is where the sonic games started to go down the pipes" and that has to be the most BS. Collectively I think the Adventure series yielded the best 3D Sonic Games. I mean, yeah, the ones now look a hundred times better, but they just don't play as smoothly as they did. Of course, my top 3 are SA1 SA2 and S3&K.

  • @671tch Well people that does seem to dislike SA2 is because of the supposed "alternative gameplay" of shooting and treasure hunting which doesnt belong in a Sonic game apparently. That term used for SA2 going down the pipes was meant as a game being better than SA2 which still today no 3D Sonic game has surpassed that game.

  • metal in cd and sonics sonic spin stayed tru in the movie but the story line didnt.

    nice list though

  • I miss rush serie

  • sonic isn't blinking during the credits...

  • the DC version of SA2 was better than the GC to be honest i like the DC graphics better

  • Very Entertaining

  • I haven't played sa2 and s3&k, but otherwise I think sonic dx is the best sonic game ever (I haven't really played sa1 so I don't really know if there is any differences).

  • sonic unleashed is my favorite game

  • 5:higher on the list.4:neva played.3: neva played.2:number 1!!!!!!!!! 1:number 6ish.

  • in SADX they only put some levels in and keep the good levels out

  • I've never played Sonic CD before because I've never owned a Sega CD. So I'm not sure what to think of it.

  • kickass list! totally agree with S3&K

  • Well, gotta say, for ripping off the Nostalgia Critic, you did it right to the T. Everything about the video is spot on with the NC style. I definitely don't agree with a lot concerning Sonic's reputation, but in terms of sales and actual industry presence, he is going strong. Otherwise he hasn't been doing the hottest recently, I'm afraid.

  • i love your top but for me the best i sonic the hedgehog next gen XD and i hate sonic spinball but the rest is a great top and you could put the sonic unleashed i loe that too for me is the seconde best

  • Sonic Adventure 2 + Dreamcast = the best sonic game youve ever played in sonic history :O dude, the dark chao garden! its like, so friggin awesome!

  • Good list man. I see that the Advance and Rush games were'nt on the list but i guess its fair since i guess you have'nt played them yet and it looks like there are no portable Sonic games on your list.

  • Awesome list!

    My only problem is that I find S3&K, SA2 and CD to be the most overrated Sonic games ever. I like them but they're not as great as everyone says they are.

    But that's just my opinion.

  • i would very very very very very very very very very switch 1 and 2 number 2 was the most best grafic bosses and storyline what can go againest that but thats my opinoin but if u dont like it just face the reason

  • 5:pretty good game, but I have the GC version.

    4:the problem is, I suck hard on it T_T-

    3:agree, overrated by many fans, still a great game.

    2:kickass game.

    1:can't agree more, my 4th best game ever.

    A surprise on the list, theres not Advance or Rush series, great list overall

  • I agree with your No 1

  • agree with every game!

  • His World *.*

  • Is sonic 3 and knuckles that good!

  • i agree with number 1

    but i found the better name for the game is Sonic 3: Tails and Knuckles

    not Sonic 3 and Knuckles :)

  • sonic adventure 2 is my fav and u should of included something about chao world

  • my personal fav is soni unleashe and shadow the hedgehog!!! XD

  • love sonic i mean i watch and have some games of sonic

  • its going to last longer than any of us? that seems kinda creepy... so much for playing all the sonic games :p

  • Why are Sonic Advance Series, Sonic Battle or Sonic Rush Series not in the list??? I mean it are good 2D Sonic Games. BTW, what do you think about Sonic Unleashed and Sonic & the Black Knight right now? Good or bad???

    But i must compliment you about your positiveness. You don't sound frustrated like all those other Hardcore Sonic fans. like: "Sonic Team RUINED SONIC!" or "The New Sonic Games SUCK!". But yeah, Sonic is awesome.

  • I didn't really play the Sonic advanced, Battle, nor Rush enough for them to make it on the list. I whould play them more, but my DS got stolen.

    Sonic Unleashed (PS3/360): Great game.

    S&tBK (Wii): Good, but shallow.

    Thank you very much!

  • I have only the Wii version of Sonic Unleashed. And I am gonna buy Sonic and the Black Knight. I hope.

  • Nice review I would have picked sonic adventure as my 2nd two if you grew up with Sonic its the best game ever, simple, fun and fast

  • you made this look profesional

  • do not agere with 1 3 4 7

  • i thought sa2b was the best. i never played dreamcast :(

  • Both the Dreamcast and Gamecube versions are the same game.

  • yeah, but i heard ppl say the dreamcast was better. i cant figure out why though...

  • Better graphics than DX.

    Camera wasn't as awkward as DX.

    I still love DX though.

    SA1 isn't on PC. :(

  • cool video

    nicely edited

  • Glad we see eye-to-eye on the #1 spot! S3&K is just Sonic at its best.

  • Does Sonic Adventure DX is still great as Sonic Adventure including Sonic Adventure 2 Battle as Sonic Adventure 2???

  • They're the same game. I just prefer the Dreamcast versions.

  • Both Great Games, they hooked me on Sonic, But I prefer the gamecube versions due to cheat coding and research.

  • lol i pretty much agree with ur list

  • I would agree with your list except a few I would definately knock 06 off the list and add Sonic Rush, I would also switch Sonic 1 and 2 around. So: 1. Sonic 3 and Knuckles 2. Sonic Adventure 2 3. Sonic CD 4. Sonic Rush 5. Sonic the Hedgehog 2 6. Sonic Adventure 7. Sonic the Hedgehog 8. Sonic Heroes 9. Shadow the Hedgehog 10. Sonic and the secret rings I have yet to play Unleashed but by what I have seen it will definately be knicking Secret Rings off my list.
  • Sonic Rush Adventure and Sonic Mega Collection plus are my fav Sonic games.

  • I agree with you Sykorax, Sonic 3 and knuckles is amazing! I loved that game as a kid and i still love it now! Talk about a good game!

    By the way, are you looking forward to unleashed?

  • Yes I am!

    I cannot wait to go get my hands on that game.

    It is going to kick ass!

  • sonic 3 & knuckles.bleh.

  • Knux: Hey, Sykorax. Just lettin' you know I watched this. xDDD I love Sonic 3 & Knuckles. O__O That game was freaking awesome - definitely my favorite from the Sega Genesis. (Possibly in part because my favorite character is Knuckles? xD) Also, I wish I'd gotten the chance to play Sonic Adveture 2. O_o There's something wrong about never getting the chance to play that one. xD

  • I like the music at the credits who made that song?

  • Bentley Jones.

  • Or you can call him "Lee Brotherteen."

    He has that name too.

  • sonic adventure 2 is my favorite sonic game of all time!

  • I have every game in your top 11.

    I dont know what order mine would be in but Im defenitly with you that Sonic is best and coolest video game icon.

    I too thought the Genesis was better than the SNES,I still collect games for it. I never even had an SNES.

    I left a comment on part 1 if you didnt notice.

  • That was amazing sykorax! your awesome! dying to see more of your videos! :D

  • Fantastic! Awesome! Great! 500/5 stars! You are the bomb!

  • You did a great job on your top 11 list video. I kind of loved your picks, because even though some games aren't great, but it's worth playing it. And I'm looking forward to the future games as well. ^_^

  • Why does it Say wifi on Sonic Chronicles

  • I don't know.

  • It was going to have WiFi, but Bioware got lazy and cut it.

  • DAMN U BIOWARE *shakes fist in anger*

  • not to be a wise ass, but wasnt Sonic 3D blast Sonics first 3D game?

  • Not exactly.

  • the title said 3D, but it really wasn't his frist REAl 3D game. It was Sonic Adventure

    (Dreamcast).

  • Awesome list! Funny and interesting. I agree, Sonic 3 & Knuckles is indeed the best.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more