The Shakespear of music. I think Ian is probably like the members of Rush. They dont worry about the Hall of Fame. They created a sound all their own and folks enjoyed it.
...from my favorite Tull Album....this is too good to describe....just turn it up! His mom wanted him to learn to play the flute....he wanted to be a rock n roller !....thanks mom!
I read a comment once saying that Ian Andersons music writng style was too complex. Its the complex that makes it great. Especially if your a self- taught muscian--not bad. Tull Definitely sounded like no one else, before or since.
"isn't it just too damn real - one white duck on your wall" -- I don't get it; can anyone interpret? What does the white duck represent? The unavoidable bloodthirstiness implicit in shooting wild birds from the sky in order to subsist, the fact that cruelty is a part of Nature, that the beauty of the Universe is also ruthless? Or that Anderson himself feels like a bird knocked from the sky, fallen from his personal paradise? That he feels alone even with his trophy woman? Help!
@SupernalOne A traditional wall ornament in northern England is/was a set of three porcelain flying ducks, each smaller than the last. They tend to signify a well-established, settled household. If only one remains, "one white duck on your wall", the suggestion is that the household or marriage is has broken up; hence this song. Whether the white duck is the only duck left, or the pale outline where a duck has been removed from the wall, is something to consider.
@SupernalOne I think Anderson was going thru divorce around the time of that album, if I remember correctly. It seems that much of the album reflected introspectively what he was going thru at the time.
By the way--once you make the effort to look--you can spot 3 ducks on the wall in many movies, paintings, etc..
@PinkPurplexity. And in reality butterflies live a short and precarious existence,hardly care free frivolity. A Larks struggle for survival is also no picnic.I know there must be something wrong with me and my brain, i just thought it needed to be said.
Listening to this track makes me feel like a butterfly emerging from its chrysalis, fluttering in the sheer beauty and purity of the music. As it progresses I feel like a Lark flying higher and higher into the sky, my soul and spirit are filled with an all consuming joy. Nothing an no one else exists, my mind is taken to a higher conciousness. The musical genius of Ian Anderson and the other members of Jethro Tull is a wondrous gift to us all.
I love the melancholy feel of the first half of this track. Captures a certain mood like no other song I've heard. I still can't decide which half I prefer, I usually leave it at saying they complement each other perfectly. First half is somber, second half is an injection of humor to lighten things up. Can't beat the lyrics in the second half though, they are Ian at his humorous best.
Tull has SO many ~ This Duck Thing ~ is way up there near the top ~ UN believable what they could do with Rhythms, Pace, any collector must have this one "on their wall".....
A very underrated track! I love the pizziccato strings, like little duckling feet prancing across an ancient hardwood floor of a Scottish cabin on the shore of a loch.
Yowswers!!! This group is just SO good when it comes down to basics. WHY are they not as famous as say CCR or ELP? It is an insane mystery and a travesty. BUT, i am becoming more familiar with them now, to my great edification!!
This is my all time favourite song of all songs ever. I have temporarily lost access to my music so i'm on you tube. Whilst I am here... How could I not comment?
To me this is MY ALL TIME FAVOURITE SONG and has been for at least 5 years.
site:youtube.com GOOGLE> John Joseph O'Brien SAVES HIS WIFE CHERYL FROM SATANISTS says THE HOLY MOTHER of JESUS :-) site:youtube.com OCEANBREEZE and PETEY INVITED John Joseph O'Brien BACK says GOD THE FATHER :-)
ON THE INTERNET AL GORE INVENTED ehehehehe AND GOD WILL GET THE LAST LAUGH AL GORE :-)
GOOGLE > WHAT IS A MINSTREL IN THE GALLERY COOKIE PARKER says THE HOLY MOTHER :-) YOUR IDIOT AWE DUCK POND FUCKED YOU COOKIE PARKER by george bush SAYS THE O'BRIEN GUY :-)
What is the point of comparing one band to another...what a waste of time. It;s as big a waste of time as arguing about it on youtube. What?....oh...doh ! ;)
Being a teenager I've recently discovered the less obvious works of Tull such as this album... each one is unique in its own way. I found this album last week, and it's brilliant!
i listen to this album everyday in the car to work...this broadsword and warchild, this and warchild are my fav albums and the folk trio (sftw, hh, and stormwatch)
I was thinking....this is Celtic and strong that way...and then I thought that any unbroken person or culture is psychedelic ....like Anderson....what is the alternative?...
@Svulla Apparently, Ian Anderson was going through a divorce from his first wife Jennie at the time (she helped him write the words to 'Aqualung'), and 'One White Duck' refers to the opposite of 'having your ducks all in a row' - a reference to the idea that his life seemed to be out of sorts at the time.
"up to my deaf ears in cold breakfast food trays" wow this one must've been written in a hotel room , I guess, "lunch confusion" it sounds like it came right out off the top of the mind. Great!
@ghost1walker they came in Italy, where I live, one week ago! The concerts were 4 or 5 and they were too far for me... And nobody could take me to see them ç_ç i'm only 16 and i can't move alone :(... My dad is so impatient to take me to see a jethro concert!
This is one of the finest Tull albums of them all ... Even though my favorite usually consists of the one I happen to be listening to at the time. So many classics. So much talent. So much Tull...
thanks I've seen tull about 30 time first in 68 at the newport jazz when they were on the same bill as roland kirk they came out an did THIS WAS an took the place by storm ian always said things change don't they no other band can play this most complex music just listen to the cord changes no one comes close and the word the man is a poet
this is best of the best no druming machines just music pure an simple the words alone are special but the music complex an beautiful the man can write don't u think, an they let B.S. in the hall of fame I don't get it an never will
Why it's on your wall, is another matter. Is it perched ON TOP of your wall, or just smacked against it in mid flight, and slipping to the floor slowly?...WHACK....squueeeek....*thud*
Oh I had no idea wha you were saying. I feel retarded. I'm not a huge Tull fan so I didn't really know this song that well. I mean I love their music and I think Ian is a genius, I've just never gotten that into them. I feel really stupid now haha
Well I'm just not as in to the whole progressive rock scene as used to be. And you can't really start becoming a huge fan, it just has to happen, but I'll be checking them out a lot more lately XD
His voice may not have aged well, but at its best it was like an embrace.
jackal59 1 week ago
Beautiful. Ian is a quirky lad, but he could write a good ballad with the best of them. *quack*
zkxb 1 month ago
My God, what a voice he had!
siggisongs1 1 month ago 4
the best line of all is at the end when he says,so there. classic!
amarriz 1 month ago
The Shakespear of music. I think Ian is probably like the members of Rush. They dont worry about the Hall of Fame. They created a sound all their own and folks enjoyed it.
maxquad21 2 months ago 4
@maxquad21 gee, you think?;)
longfootbuddy 1 month ago
...from my favorite Tull Album....this is too good to describe....just turn it up! His mom wanted him to learn to play the flute....he wanted to be a rock n roller !....thanks mom!
SamIamGolden 2 months ago
jaja son todos tuyos estos videos!!! jaja... ojala algun dia los tradujeras asi les llega a todos :)
Faculas1989 3 months ago
@Faculas1989 metete el dedo.
renoraider2 1 month ago
@renoraider2 metetelo vos
Faculas1989 3 weeks ago
I love this song!!!!
Flaggius 3 months ago
I read a comment once saying that Ian Andersons music writng style was too complex. Its the complex that makes it great. Especially if your a self- taught muscian--not bad. Tull Definitely sounded like no one else, before or since.
maxquad21 3 months ago 2
"isn't it just too damn real - one white duck on your wall" -- I don't get it; can anyone interpret? What does the white duck represent? The unavoidable bloodthirstiness implicit in shooting wild birds from the sky in order to subsist, the fact that cruelty is a part of Nature, that the beauty of the Universe is also ruthless? Or that Anderson himself feels like a bird knocked from the sky, fallen from his personal paradise? That he feels alone even with his trophy woman? Help!
SupernalOne 4 months ago
@SupernalOne A traditional wall ornament in northern England is/was a set of three porcelain flying ducks, each smaller than the last. They tend to signify a well-established, settled household. If only one remains, "one white duck on your wall", the suggestion is that the household or marriage is has broken up; hence this song. Whether the white duck is the only duck left, or the pale outline where a duck has been removed from the wall, is something to consider.
stratman123 4 months ago
@stratman123
Thanks - interesting, would never have guessed.
SupernalOne 4 months ago
@SupernalOne I think Anderson was going thru divorce around the time of that album, if I remember correctly. It seems that much of the album reflected introspectively what he was going thru at the time.
By the way--once you make the effort to look--you can spot 3 ducks on the wall in many movies, paintings, etc..
stratman123 4 months ago
brilliant as all. xxxxx love them. jethro tull. i would love to have met ian . me and he same age. getting old now.
lillyputlane1957 4 months ago
@PinkPurplexity. And in reality butterflies live a short and precarious existence,hardly care free frivolity. A Larks struggle for survival is also no picnic.I know there must be something wrong with me and my brain, i just thought it needed to be said.
blahblah2556 4 months ago
Listening to this track makes me feel like a butterfly emerging from its chrysalis, fluttering in the sheer beauty and purity of the music. As it progresses I feel like a Lark flying higher and higher into the sky, my soul and spirit are filled with an all consuming joy. Nothing an no one else exists, my mind is taken to a higher conciousness. The musical genius of Ian Anderson and the other members of Jethro Tull is a wondrous gift to us all.
PinkPurplexity 5 months ago
I love the melancholy feel of the first half of this track. Captures a certain mood like no other song I've heard. I still can't decide which half I prefer, I usually leave it at saying they complement each other perfectly. First half is somber, second half is an injection of humor to lighten things up. Can't beat the lyrics in the second half though, they are Ian at his humorous best.
add2718 5 months ago
Tull has SO many ~ This Duck Thing ~ is way up there near the top ~ UN believable what they could do with Rhythms, Pace, any collector must have this one "on their wall".....
SamIamGolden 5 months ago
A very underrated track! I love the pizziccato strings, like little duckling feet prancing across an ancient hardwood floor of a Scottish cabin on the shore of a loch.
raydenthetullgod 5 months ago
This is my favorite jethro tull song of all time!
gsokol7 5 months ago
Along with Skating Away, my other favorite Tull song of all time. The lyrics hit home with me and the guitar is beautiful!
brokenheart6777 5 months ago
Anderson's voice was in top flight during the MITG sessions. Plus, he is THE finest accoustic guitar player my ears have ever known.
Puseye2 6 months ago 2
one person sucks!
BobbyO11717 6 months ago
Yet another musical masterpiece .....the interplay of Ian and Martin is magnificent.
TheNigelr 8 months ago
@TheNigelr
It's only Anderson. The guitar as well.
Topographer 6 months ago
Yet another musical masterpiece .....
TheNigelr 8 months ago
Yowswers!!! This group is just SO good when it comes down to basics. WHY are they not as famous as say CCR or ELP? It is an insane mystery and a travesty. BUT, i am becoming more familiar with them now, to my great edification!!
HolyMotherofGrid 8 months ago
This is my all time favourite song of all songs ever. I have temporarily lost access to my music so i'm on you tube. Whilst I am here... How could I not comment?
To me this is MY ALL TIME FAVOURITE SONG and has been for at least 5 years.
pikeycowboylover 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
site:youtube.com GOOGLE> John Joseph O'Brien SAVES HIS WIFE CHERYL FROM SATANISTS says THE HOLY MOTHER of JESUS :-) site:youtube.com OCEANBREEZE and PETEY INVITED John Joseph O'Brien BACK says GOD THE FATHER :-)
ON THE INTERNET AL GORE INVENTED ehehehehe AND GOD WILL GET THE LAST LAUGH AL GORE :-)
GOOGLE > WHAT IS A MINSTREL IN THE GALLERY COOKIE PARKER says THE HOLY MOTHER :-) YOUR IDIOT AWE DUCK POND FUCKED YOU COOKIE PARKER by george bush SAYS THE O'BRIEN GUY :-)
TKTRV 9 months ago
Could you please include date of recording and release in your amazing videos, along with more lyrics? Thanks!
Anitrop 9 months ago
Chasing Contentment.
bb4960 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
GOOGLE> A MIRACLE IS AS SIMPLE AS A CORRECT ANSWER says John Joseph O'Brien :-)
\/
GOOGLE> HAVE A MIRACLE AREYOUFOREAL FEDUPAMERICAN :-)
"IT" IS THE END OF AREYOUFOREAL BRAINWASHED WOMEN and BRAINWASHED HOMOSEXUALS :-)
GOD CAN CURE CANCER AND ALL ILLNESS ON PLANET EARTH says John Joseph O'Brien :-)
^
"IT" IS THE END OF AREYOUFOREAL SATANISM ON THE INTERNET :-)
TKTRV 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WHAT IS GOD DOING ON THE QUANTUM LEVEL george bush SAYS JOHN JOSEPH O'BRIEN :-)
GOOGLE > GOD AND JOhn Joseph O'Brien PULL THE BIG ASS HOLE JOKE ON george bush BY COOKIE PARKER :-)
AND SO FUCKIN WHAT IF I'M A BIG FUCKIN ASS HOLE TIMES TWO says ME :-)
^
GOOGLE> AT LEAST I FUCKIN ADMIT "IT" says John Joseph O'Brien :-)
\/
ON THIS PARANORMAL EPISODE OF ONEWHITEDUCK :-)
^
STAY TUNED says ONEWHITEDUCK :-)
TKTRV 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
GOOGLE> YOU ARE BUSTED ON YOUTUBE AREYOUFOREAL says John Joseph O'Brien :-
WHO IS PENISMAN 1976 AREYOUFOREAL says John Joseph O'Brien :-)
@Felly17 PENIS
Penisman1976 3 hours ago
HEY GOD ... MELVIN LOOKS LIKE JIMMY CARTER says ME :-)
AND HIS NOSE LOOKS LIKE A PENIS :-)
GOOGLE> ehehehehehe JIMMY CARTER says ONEWHITEDUCK :-)
CYBER BULLYING is IT REAL FUCK YOU CIA says ONEWHITEDUCK :-) - Page Lummy says Israel will fall strawman New> Thank You Jimmy Carter by bobcatsmoosh
TKTRV 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
JUST TA PISS YOU INTERNET SATANISTS OFF BIG TIME says John Joseph O'Brien :-)
^
GOOGLE > BILLY WIECHMAN and John JOseph O'Brien :-)
\/
WILLIAM WIECHMAN IS A SON OF GOD TOO says THE HOLY MOTHER OF JESUS :-)
^
A GIFT FROM THE CODE TALKERS - 4 visits - Jan 8THIS IS WHAT KIND OF SON OF GOD John Joseph O'Brien IS ;-)
^
eheheheheh WHAT'S THIS AREYOUFOREAL :-)
TKTRV 11 months ago
(0)^10 = nothing at all...
19CACTUS51 11 months ago
What is the point of comparing one band to another...what a waste of time. It;s as big a waste of time as arguing about it on youtube. What?....oh...doh ! ;)
imusbcraz 11 months ago
Being a teenager I've recently discovered the less obvious works of Tull such as this album... each one is unique in its own way. I found this album last week, and it's brilliant!
KnucklesTheEchidna37 1 year ago
i listen to this album everyday in the car to work...this broadsword and warchild, this and warchild are my fav albums and the folk trio (sftw, hh, and stormwatch)
jstarang1 1 year ago 2
I was thinking....this is Celtic and strong that way...and then I thought that any unbroken person or culture is psychedelic ....like Anderson....what is the alternative?...
wrongmonettube 1 year ago
emotion sincerely distilled
Kenentigern7 1 year ago
*.* I loove it (L) Playing it n guitar is the best X3 I love this part!! 0:38
Xolus500 1 year ago
*.* I loove it (L) Playing it n guitar is the best X3
Xolus500 1 year ago
Surreal and heartbreaking all at the same time. A true gem!
Branimir9000 1 year ago 2
Beautiful. But I'm not sure what the lyrics mean.. Anyone got an idea?
Svulla 1 year ago
@Svulla Apparently, Ian Anderson was going through a divorce from his first wife Jennie at the time (she helped him write the words to 'Aqualung'), and 'One White Duck' refers to the opposite of 'having your ducks all in a row' - a reference to the idea that his life seemed to be out of sorts at the time.
craignl 1 year ago 2
@craignl Thank you so much. Now I can enjoy this song more
Svulla 1 year ago
something must be wrong with me and my brain... and my zero to your power of 10 equals nothing at all... wow... good stuff
liledz1 1 year ago
Comment removed
liledz1 1 year ago
your way in is
my way out
tsurumichan 1 year ago
Doesn't get any better then this !!
cooler52er 1 year ago
Brilliant! That's my "Foreskin Conclusion"...
TheKpaxx 1 year ago 2
His Dreams Are for Dreaming, and Best Left That Way
612franklin 1 year ago
"up to my deaf ears in cold breakfast food trays" wow this one must've been written in a hotel room , I guess, "lunch confusion" it sounds like it came right out off the top of the mind. Great!
mcwsearch 1 year ago
Fly away Peter and Fly Away Paul!
MrRastaManDan 1 year ago
English genius !
hieronomy 1 year ago 2
Why does this always make me think of J G Ballards "Concrete Island" ?
Kenentigern7 1 year ago
In my opinion, this song is a bittersweet reminder that image is more important than talent from a societal standpoint.
j4unumber1 1 year ago
An overlooked and underrated Tull album. Got stoned to the "B" side many, many times back in the day.
RevDrWally 1 year ago
@RevDrWally
Rest asured, you were not the only one! We all shared a Baker St muse.
() 10
atthehops 1 year ago
@RevDrWally Been there
cooler52er 1 year ago
@ghost1walker they came in Italy, where I live, one week ago! The concerts were 4 or 5 and they were too far for me... And nobody could take me to see them ç_ç i'm only 16 and i can't move alone :(... My dad is so impatient to take me to see a jethro concert!
makeasmile94 1 year ago
This song is one of the most beautiful for me <3 i love it... in the future, i wish i can see Jethro Tull live!
makeasmile94 1 year ago
@makeasmile94 i truly wish that you'll be able to see them.it's not just a good concert, it an amazing expirience
ghost1walker 1 year ago
This is one of the finest Tull albums of them all ... Even though my favorite usually consists of the one I happen to be listening to at the time. So many classics. So much talent. So much Tull...
kyuss4me 1 year ago
the circumcised cannot jump to foreskinned conclusions
kushisaac 1 year ago
I love how his voice falls down on 1:00 ...
hugodraslik 1 year ago
I F*CKING LOVE IT.
BillySeagull 1 year ago
thanks I've seen tull about 30 time first in 68 at the newport jazz when they were on the same bill as roland kirk they came out an did THIS WAS an took the place by storm ian always said things change don't they no other band can play this most complex music just listen to the cord changes no one comes close and the word the man is a poet
Mr10350 1 year ago
this is best of the best no druming machines just music pure an simple the words alone are special but the music complex an beautiful the man can write don't u think, an they let B.S. in the hall of fame I don't get it an never will
Mr10350 1 year ago
@Mr10350 Mr. Anderson and crew are way too good for the stupid hall of fame.
hyperguy61 1 year ago 5
@hyperguy61 Quite right!
tjrxk7 1 year ago
Acoustic Tull !!!!
mikeciancio1 1 year ago 4
It can't get much better than this.
The5mike5 2 years ago 27
@The5mike5 your right, but the beatles beat this
gsokol7 1 year ago
@gsokol7 im incined to disagree, acoustic tull wraps me up in emotion more than the beatles, more poetic lyrics and complex orchestrations
jstarang1 1 year ago 2
@gsokol7
i ll call it a tie.
tcoudi 9 months ago
@tcoudi sure thing
gsokol7 9 months ago
and my zero to your power of ten equals nothing at all!! That's one of my fav. lines of any jethro tull song!
fourtogomusic 2 years ago 4
Fly away Peter, Fly away!
MrRastaManDan 2 years ago 2
A foul song, but I like it a lot.
dharmamark 2 years ago 4
What a poultry thing to say.
manlyduckling 1 year ago
What a poultry thing to say.
manlyduckling 1 year ago
@manlyduckling You quack me up!
rehtafsedaj777 1 year ago
the second part (2:20) is called "Nothing At All".
what a great song arrangement.
I love the tull ballads, thanks for this.
91Lizardking 2 years ago
drink wine slip on the head phones.....and fkn fall asleep..truly a luv tull.
tigerhorsefield 2 years ago 4
IA has the most perfect acoustic guitar sound. Better than Pete Townsend. This guy knew how he wanted things to sound.
Aash1999 2 years ago 3
Magnificent!
But what's the duck doing on the wall?
Topographer 2 years ago
Quacks? rofl xD
tigerwish 1 year ago
The most beautiful and honest song ever.
ColonelSibthorpe 2 years ago 2
how many whites ducks? And what color are they?
MoPar7055 2 years ago
One...white...just one white duck
Why it's on your wall, is another matter. Is it perched ON TOP of your wall, or just smacked against it in mid flight, and slipping to the floor slowly?...WHACK....squueeeek....*thud*
Only Ian Anderson will ever know.
RaelWander 2 years ago 3
Merci Aqualung1989 pour toute ces superbes chansons de Jethro Tull!
974Po 2 years ago 3
de rien =)
Aqualung1989 2 years ago
@974Po et moi aussi. Thank you.
RockyG1978 7 months ago
One of the best Tull songs.
siggi5153 2 years ago 2
The Minstrel(in The Gallery) Ian...One White Duck (Zero tot he power of ten=nothing at all).....
aqua7cn 2 years ago
music with this content never gets old!
BobbyO11717 2 years ago 3
Google Search · WE CAN'T GET THIS KIND OF ENTERTAINMENT AT HOME says ONEWHITEDUCK ;-)
TKTRV 2 years ago
great hearing all these again
Ayrshirenutter 2 years ago
agreed...
purity of expression
honestly of heart
brilliance of mind
~ we could all strive for such things ! ~
darrrkstarrr1969 2 years ago 9
so good.....
spydermary 2 years ago
I love the solace & solitude of this album.
...Especially this side.
(yes, I'm referring to vinyl,...This music goes way back with me.)
oldedrum 2 years ago
God God, I haven't heard this in so many years.
I've always loved how the song decomposes from a lush ballad to Ian and his lone guitar. So perfect.
Definately the highlight of Mistrel In The Gallery.
Holdenon3 2 years ago 5
Personally, this is my favorite song off of Minstrel In The Gallery.
TheSubstituteGnome 2 years ago 3
the first tull album i ever bought. still hearing earlier stuff for the first time and some real gems out there. brilliant band
newportgwentdragons 2 years ago
this is great songgg... one off theyr best....
Juulihanna 3 years ago
One White Duck / 010 = Nothing At All
paul7703 3 years ago
Comment removed
popomczowzow 2 years ago
that's the whole song title.
paul7703 2 years ago
Oh I had no idea wha you were saying. I feel retarded. I'm not a huge Tull fan so I didn't really know this song that well. I mean I love their music and I think Ian is a genius, I've just never gotten that into them. I feel really stupid now haha
popomczowzow 2 years ago
it's cool dude! why not start being a huge Tull fan now :D
paul7703 2 years ago
Well I'm just not as in to the whole progressive rock scene as used to be. And you can't really start becoming a huge fan, it just has to happen, but I'll be checking them out a lot more lately XD
popomczowzow 2 years ago
my youth ..............
musictheropist 3 years ago
I love the whole album, but this is really the best song...
I like the melody, it makes me happy.
I was born in 1991, so not the year of Jethro Tull, but I have a dad with a good taste for music like this...
Meiquee 3 years ago 2
Thanks Aqualung1989!!!!
amhealy2007 3 years ago 2
There are no words to describe how beautiful this song is.
55802 3 years ago 35
@55802 Right You Are
612franklin 1 year ago
I'll catch a ride on Your violin...strung up Your bow
and I'll float on Your melody - sing Your chorus soft and low
Salud
musicperfumelaughter 3 years ago 3
Gotta love the violin coming in in the background as he sings that line! Awesome!
saberswordsmen1 2 years ago 3
favorit
echooutcph 2 years ago
great song by a great band.
pajjooo 3 years ago 2
absolutly a masterpiece.ian what a treasure.that alot of people havent even heard ,its a shame.
sweetsusan146 3 years ago 3
Beautiful doesn't come close. The string arrangements are sublime
GestureStew 3 years ago