no, i'm pretty sure its live. u can def hear a few missed notes here and there...like 1.31 and 1.34...hooky usually plays his bass like a lead guitar high on the neck and lower notes are sometimes a recording or a synth...so there could be a recorded aspect of this performance...but the rest is live, im pretty sure.
barney's singing is a signature of the new order sound...frankly, i'd take his off key singing over any "in tune" mega pop boy band type of crap any day of the week.
i agree, it's barney's singing that endears you to new order. it's makes the lyrics sound so much more sincere. they are self taught musicians that have battled against all odds and have influenced countless bands - fact.
muy buen tema che!!!
locuratronic 1 year ago
Barney learning to sing... pretty interesting!
Too bad they split up right after this... :-S
UncleAstaroth 1 year ago
Really good live version of this song. Matches up with the studio rather well in terms of quality of sound.
Thanks for posting this, Spotnick2!
goatboy91587 2 years ago
@goatboy91587
quality of sound on the youtube?lol
but great video anyway. Thanks a lot
avtush 1 year ago
so much better live...and the studio version is amazing!
sameerpatel105 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sorry , This sounds like playback...
szarak81 3 years ago
no, i'm pretty sure its live. u can def hear a few missed notes here and there...like 1.31 and 1.34...hooky usually plays his bass like a lead guitar high on the neck and lower notes are sometimes a recording or a synth...so there could be a recorded aspect of this performance...but the rest is live, im pretty sure.
jjaek 3 years ago 2
This is definitely live, I can hear the difference and there's a HEY! in there.
canuck21 3 years ago 2
I thnk is half / half
Abbastraea 2 years ago
@szarak81 how the fuck is it play back?
5clone 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
get rid of the singer and you have a good tune the singer is fucking shit realy is fucked a good song up..
woodytel45 3 years ago
it sounds better on the track but generally they always sing worse when performing live
cammyeaston2 3 years ago
get rid of the singer and you wouldnt have the song, moron.
electricmoonmonkey 3 years ago 5
barney's singing is a signature of the new order sound...frankly, i'd take his off key singing over any "in tune" mega pop boy band type of crap any day of the week.
jjaek 3 years ago 7
i agree, it's barney's singing that endears you to new order. it's makes the lyrics sound so much more sincere. they are self taught musicians that have battled against all odds and have influenced countless bands - fact.
chrisdunleavy 3 years ago 7
me encanta
leoberutti 3 years ago
1:49.. hey now what you doing bernard.. great song!
urbano83 3 years ago 3
Great Song!
panditabanks 3 years ago
sumner's got whiskers!
nothenryg 3 years ago
thx for posting. but, audio is a little delayed from vision.
kenwoods29 4 years ago