Added: 3 years ago
From: robertoriace
Views: 31,504
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (24)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The live version I believe is soooooo much better!! You can SEE the affection, not just hear it!!!

  • all the singers has their own fans but when you hear the song, just hear with your heart and then you'll find the beauty of the song whoever sing that song. I like every singers who sing from heart. Josh....Celine....David....eve­n me(I am not the singer' but I am the good listener) God bless them all

  • this is a very great christmas song !!

  • People don't read. What minnecoachman was saying was that the ARRANGEMENT of the Groban version is better. Meaning the actual music. He was not saying Groban performs the song better. He actually said Phelps can wail and that he would like to hear Phelps sing the Groban version of the song. That way it would be a good comparison. And, I agree with him. I think Phelps is a better singer but I like the music/arrangement of the Groban version.

  • groban is a light weight ...go watch this song LIVE and tell me groben's is better

  • Im a groban fan, but he doesnt hold a candle to david phelps. David is the GREATEST singer on earth. he's better than andrea bachelli, josh groban, celine dion. you ame it none of them has the ranges that this man posesses.

  • @dilly84 yeah, but i think that it isn't the range that makes him the best, but the way he sings, the passion he puts in his singing!

  • @FloatingNotes yes!!!!

  • He can really wail. I prefer the Josh Groban arrangement. It would be fun to listen to him sing that arrangement of the song.

  • @minnecoachman

    listen to David Phelps's the live version. It's more like Groban's and it lets more of David's opera training show through

  • @metalzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz I've heard the live version - it's still not the Groban version of the song (which has an abbreviated 2nd verse). Sings it very well, just not the version of the song I prefer.

  • Stop comparing people, there both awsome. Just different voices. Clearly they both have been gifted with voice.

  • Merry Christmas!!

  • someone said to listen to this while i was listening to josh groban sayin david phelps is better. Phelps is great but have you heard Groban live? Groban is a thousand times better

  • nope josh groban can't even lit a candle to david phelps' version...David phelps blows josh groban out of the water on this version

  • I don't like the instrumental on this version. I prefer his live version with the beautiful piano part.

  • look for the live version with phepls instead ^^ Far better

  • @Dexfan90

    nah, i don't think much people would agree on that. Phelps, is much much better.

  • oh my gosh, especially the end... goosebumps alllll over

  • god..this gives me chills all over..his voice is SO powerful. i LOVE HIM.

  • This is from joy joy album

  • I love this arrangement....

  • ya his joy joy album had some awesome brass (sometimes a little too much brass) but it had a more classical feel to it, i really really liked it

  • this is from his older Joy Joy album... its not rare or anything

  • thank you for the information!

    :-)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more