1min 20secs "Talking all the day, with true friends that try to make you stay..." The picture here is of Johnny Halloran on the Box with Lizzy on the Fiddle, taken in Tí Coilí Bar, Galway.
Beautiful Song. So refreshing to see that most of the posts are not about religious hatred and more about the fact that this is one of the best celtic singers ever. His ability to paint beautiful landscapes with his words and fantastic guitar playing knows no ends.
Only started listening to Dick Gaughan's music recently...does he still tour? I'm an Irish student living in Glasgow, songs like this make me miss home!
I am watching and listening to this fine song and its visuals and I am touched and moved by both working so well together. I am Scots-Irish and am glad and proud to experience this post. Blessings to you from the U.S. :{ ) Brian
What a beautiful song and text - so poetic - so full of love - Dick Gaughan is sure one of the best singer/songwriters that have ever lived - I love this song and the pure beauty always brings tears in my eyes
Such an absolutely beautiful song by a brilliant musician, this song touches the deepest depths of my soul, truly beautiful an I can't wait to come home. It also warms my heart to see everyones comments so peaceful rather then the usual YouTube political bickering. God bless Ireland and God bless you all. Rath de Ort.
Scots are Irish immigrants who came over to the mainland and amalgamated with the Picts! We are all one people with one origin and absolutely brilliant music!
Being a true Luke Kelly fan, I ought to like his version better than this one - but they are both absolutely beautiful - and in fact Dick Gaughan has a more traditional way of singing this fantastic song! And I love the guitar in this one!
Well Dick is an immigrant Scot, like so many, and his da' was from "Poor" Co. Mayo, so perhaps that may lend something to your understanding of his love of this song! He is singing from the heart! (I don't think he knows any other way!)
Simply beautiful. I have never heard of this fella before, and I love his voice. If I close my eyes and listen I can hear the ocean and smell the beautiful green countryside. I will be back to see more!
The song was actually writ by Phil Colclough and his wife June, an English couple from Staffordshire.
This version is being song by a Scotsman, the Scots accent is very similar to certain parts of Donegal as we migrated to Scotland for hundreds of years from this part of Ireland.
He was pretty bloody brilliant - as usual. He played some stuff I'd not heard before - some very biting political comment in his songs (which were still relevant to the credit crunch, Donald Trump trying to buy most of Aberdeenshire and political sell out of the 60s and 70s generation), but also old favourites like Song for Ireland, Westlin Winds and The Diggers as well as some lovely instrumental stuff. The venue only holds about 100 people - so it's quite intimate.
I prefer smaller venue's as well, I remember a pub near Angel Tube station I used to go to in the late 80's early 90's and seeing the likes of Martin Simpson and Dick himself. it was great to be able to talk to them after the show.
Thanks for the encouragement...I'd love to see where my Sidney's, Kearns' and Lanes came from. From whence the Sidneys became schooner captains along the Connecticut and New York shore, they say. And in several generations was I. Thanks also for the beautiful video. It's been awhile since I've been so inspired and I'm starting to feel alive again!!
Dick Gaughan is a master in the "Hand Full of Earth" album. Every song is rich, beautiful, powerful and done with artistic soul. If anyone wonders which one DG album to get is, I'd say this.
Beautiful video!!!
Thanks so much! One day I'll see Galway as my ancestors did.
If you haven't been to Ireland before, you will love Galway...fantastic County and the City of Galway itself has a great buzz about the place all the time!...Very friendly people down there so they are!
This brilliant song written by Phil Coulter. Lyn and I sang this at Sidmouth in 1989 to a packed house and you could have heard a pin drop! Fantastic event and fantastic memory...we used to run The Willow Tree on to it as sort of double song set. I was part of Chequered Roots in those days....
I think that was just a typo on charliehaven's part, this song was actually writ by Phil Colclough and his wife June, an English couple from Staffordshire.
I feel privileged to watch and listen to this again, this time after paying close attention to your:
"Father Daughter Mother Son". A close friend recently passed. He was a giant of my times, I told his partner recently: The past is what we made it. The future is what we make it."
It is a rare treat to share the blue where falcons fly with you and Dick.
had the honor to be dick gaughan's support performin in oldenburg/germany. just got back from a tour through australia, where smbdy smashed his guitar. so he was in a pretty bad mood ;O) had dinner with him. really nice guy. thx 4 ur music! chris
This has to be the definitive version of this song.. have heard many, but this one never fails to bring tears to my eyes.... even before I left Ireland!
Hi Luke, I'm grand thanks. Do things go well with thee?
Will be off to see our man DG next month. Saw him at the Celtic Connections festival but he was only doing a few songs as part of the Burns' concert. Still great to see him where he belongs, in front of 5000 people at Royal Concert Hall!
Strangely, he was no less comfortable than playing in front of the 90 folk crammed into a wee room when I last saw him!
Looking for ideas for more DG songs put to pics, any suggestions?
Actually I do...Dicks peerless cover of "Games people play" by Joe South. I lent my copy of "A Different Kind of Love Song" and never got it back so if you have it I think it would be a great track to put up.
Although not a "folk" song as such, I think Dick really puts a lot of passion into the song...one of his best vocals I think!
Enough of the 2 word sentences, I agree, it's so completely different it's worth letting people hear his reinterpretation. I think it'll surprise a few folk!
lovely walk along the Blackhead path round the rocks listenin to the sea crashing on the rocks up the caves i live in Whiteabbey was there just last week went up to the lighthouse !
Westlin winds,tom paines bones,its not what youre born with, song about John Muir,song about "big muddy",cant remember names of others.spoke to him at end and told him I was disappointed he didnt do the workers song or the diggers which are my favourites!
I would go as far as to say that he is better placed than most (for the very reason you have stated) to sing this song than most of my fellow countrymen and women. It may be tantamount to heresy to say this but I find Luke Kelly's version pedestrian at best and Mary Blacks version leaves me cold.
So you're a heretic with a good ear for songcraft!
I listened to Luke's version and have to agree, his phrasing is poor; like he hasn't given any thought to the lyrics. And there's a tad of "Musak" to Mary's. A bit too easy-listening for me.
But the worst offender is The Fureys. Every folk music cliche is employed without care. I still wake up in cold sweats hearing it!
@DonegalRaymie201 Well he didn't have time to be thinking too deeply about the lyrics, he was dead only weeks after recording the song and kept falling asleep while it was being recorded..... no point in trying to compare the respective versions. They're both great so it's really a matter of personal preference. Personally I am hopelessly addicted to Lukes voice so I can't imagine liking anyone elses version of anything better than Luke Kellys!!
Dick himself said that Luke's version of "Freedom Come All Ye",(a song both men recorded), is peerless! And I would have to agree, but Luke's version of this song, is very far from his best work, for the very reasons you mention.
I wouldn't want Luke judged by what turned out to be his Swan Song. On this recording, Dick has my vote for what it's worth.
@DonegalRaymie201 He's not as good vocally as when he was younger, I agree, but I still think it's a very special recording. The story of how it was recorded only adds to that. It's one of my favourites
Thanks for posting. This is a wonderful randition of this song. Dick has a wonderful warm voice and the guitar is beautiful. The pics are truly beautiful as well. Great job!!!!!!
Sure now, that was fate! Enjoy, and if ever you get the chance, go see him live! He's the only true Troubadour I've ever heard! Just captivates an audience with his songcraft! If you aren't blown away by how a true artist can capture you, i'll pay your ticket! Sure, I moved to Scotland to see him perform more!
Nice! Straight into my Ireland Playlist. Nice shots of Ben Bulben, too. Great song and pics. Reminds me of standing on Achill Island and looking out to sea.
Beautiful pics and song! Just that first pic though, it's "Buachilletive Mhor" in Glencoe isn't it? I've climbed it in winter so I think I recognise it!
Well spotted!,Buachaille Etive Mòr (the 'Great Herdsman of Etive').
I had planed to put pictures of Scotland,Ireland and England in this little video, to celebrate the fact that it was writ by an Englishman and sung by a Scotsman. But it would have got cluttered, so I decided not to.
Finally, a nice Irish video without the Green vs Orange bullshit! Protestant or Catholic we're all the same!
ModdingAtMidnight 2 days ago
happy new year every one :'(
adamasdiamandis 3 weeks ago
best song respect!!!!
enigma1096 3 months ago
1min 20secs "Talking all the day, with true friends that try to make you stay..." The picture here is of Johnny Halloran on the Box with Lizzy on the Fiddle, taken in Tí Coilí Bar, Galway.
AonghusMcGinn 4 months ago
Beautiful Song. So refreshing to see that most of the posts are not about religious hatred and more about the fact that this is one of the best celtic singers ever. His ability to paint beautiful landscapes with his words and fantastic guitar playing knows no ends.
gazzaboyhmfc 4 months ago
had the pleasure of meeting this guy superb
andrewquigley18 4 months ago
great song he does a song called Ireland Her Own and can't find it on youtube I hope someone can help?
shoelover25 5 months ago in playlist Easy music
Thanks for posting. I think his version is the best I've ever heard. So much more soul, longing, poignancy than Mary Black's... just sayin...
TheMeemeister 6 months ago
I just bought 3 albums of Dick Caughan for my Scottish husband's Birthday,
to be posted to NZ where we live now....
I can't wait for them to arrive...:-)
Mariekesone 7 months ago
Only started listening to Dick Gaughan's music recently...does he still tour? I'm an Irish student living in Glasgow, songs like this make me miss home!
solus881 8 months ago
@solus881
Pal, I moved to Glasgow to hear DG! Yes he plays, and he never disapoints!
Where are you & do you speak any Gaelic? ( If so I could recommend the best Gaidhlig pubs!)
DonegalRaymie201 8 months ago
I am watching and listening to this fine song and its visuals and I am touched and moved by both working so well together. I am Scots-Irish and am glad and proud to experience this post. Blessings to you from the U.S. :{ ) Brian
Broblem12 8 months ago
I am from Russia, but I like this song!
Aferist0 8 months ago
If all I ever had was a 'Handful of Earth' then this would had made it worthwhile. Regards from NZ.
brownsrd16 9 months ago
Thanks Dickie for all your musical poetry, strong heart and mind, may you be wreathed in blessings <3 love Bb
HEADSUPBERKELEY 10 months ago
What a beautiful song and text - so poetic - so full of love - Dick Gaughan is sure one of the best singer/songwriters that have ever lived - I love this song and the pure beauty always brings tears in my eyes
CrossBonesAlex 11 months ago
Such an absolutely beautiful song by a brilliant musician, this song touches the deepest depths of my soul, truly beautiful an I can't wait to come home. It also warms my heart to see everyones comments so peaceful rather then the usual YouTube political bickering. God bless Ireland and God bless you all. Rath de Ort.
SouthArmaghSniper 1 year ago 2
Mary Black.....Luke Kelly.....and now Dick Gaughan....all WONDERFUL!
lanetemple 1 year ago
this song, my bro. sent me from prison. it changed me. it pierced my heart. thank you Dick Gaughan. masterful.
ToddBoyle 1 year ago
I`m enjoying all your video`s Luke, are these your own photos. I`ve stood at many the same spot. Sláinte.
MrCatstail 1 year ago
THIS SONG MOVES ME . NEED TO GO BACK TO THE HOME LAND. SOON
MrVampiredog 1 year ago
very good, but Mary Black's version is the best
niallwhite1969 1 year ago
Got to be one of the best folksingers, and this is one of the best songs. Thanks for your great voice and unique guitar playing.
mariesnowgoose 1 year ago 2
Ah bueatiful hes in control start to finish!!
martybrooky 1 year ago
I am french and originally from Morocco and salsa teacher!!...but this song is one of my favourite.
I don't know why I love celtic music but this one touch my heart.
I herd it many years ago on the beautifull album "Heart of gaels".
salsaconga 1 year ago 2
Scots are Irish immigrants who came over to the mainland and amalgamated with the Picts! We are all one people with one origin and absolutely brilliant music!
Winterlightsky 1 year ago
the more i hear this man, the more i admire him ~
tribalwind 1 year ago 4
This song really stirs the Celtic blood like no other. God Bless Ireland, Scotland a\nd Wales!
whackfoldeediedo 1 year ago 2
His voice is so good it's unbelievable..
Jengybhoy 1 year ago
Being a true Luke Kelly fan, I ought to like his version better than this one - but they are both absolutely beautiful - and in fact Dick Gaughan has a more traditional way of singing this fantastic song! And I love the guitar in this one!
SAF57 1 year ago 3
@SAF57
Well Dick is an immigrant Scot, like so many, and his da' was from "Poor" Co. Mayo, so perhaps that may lend something to your understanding of his love of this song! He is singing from the heart! (I don't think he knows any other way!)
DonegalRaymie201 1 year ago 3
totally brilliant.. glad i found this
Paddyslippers 1 year ago
i am Irish
koolcat2345 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Thanks, but Dick's version is superb. I found it on Spotify.
dondev54 1 year ago
Why can't I find "Willie o' Winsbury" on YouTube? One of my OMG life changing tunes.!!!
dondev54 1 year ago 2
It doesn't ever get any better than this..
Thanks so much.. i want to come back..
Dick, we are all so much in awe and respect for your voice and your powerful words you write, I love especially the Worker's Song.
Be well and cheers!
bronzeladdy53 2 years ago 3
Scotland and Ireland Forever.
peacefrog1916 2 years ago 15
@peacefrog1916 and the rest of the world!
FENNYMAN 1 year ago
Love the video, great slideshow!!!!!
I really enjoyed the track,
Heartfelt vocals
5************
Terry !!
gherkamum 2 years ago 2
God bless Ireland indeed! From your Celtic brothers in Scotland
sergeantfan 2 years ago 6
Bless all the true Celts in the world my friend.
gdmcdermott 2 years ago 3
Simply beautiful. I have never heard of this fella before, and I love his voice. If I close my eyes and listen I can hear the ocean and smell the beautiful green countryside. I will be back to see more!
Rath Dé ort
God be with you
lavendergalKelly 2 years ago 2
True poetry. Great song and even better musician. Thanks for the post... Any chance of his cover of "Ruby Tuesday"?
intersweat 2 years ago
A lovely, lovely gift, not just to Ireland, but to all who seek peace and a better world with all that is within them.
Thanks all the way from Richmond, California! I wish my response were in the form of a song as profound as this one!
lexinaut 2 years ago 7
lexinaut, your responce was perfect...
lukessummer 2 years ago
The song was actually writ by Phil Colclough and his wife June, an English couple from Staffordshire.
This version is being song by a Scotsman, the Scots accent is very similar to certain parts of Donegal as we migrated to Scotland for hundreds of years from this part of Ireland.
lukessummerguitar 2 years ago 4
He'll be playing in London, Crouch End on Nov 13. Going to see him whoeee!
heliotropezzz333 2 years ago 4
That's tonight then!...Let us know how the concert went helio!
lukessummer 2 years ago
He was pretty bloody brilliant - as usual. He played some stuff I'd not heard before - some very biting political comment in his songs (which were still relevant to the credit crunch, Donald Trump trying to buy most of Aberdeenshire and political sell out of the 60s and 70s generation), but also old favourites like Song for Ireland, Westlin Winds and The Diggers as well as some lovely instrumental stuff. The venue only holds about 100 people - so it's quite intimate.
heliotropezzz333 2 years ago
Sounds like you had a great evening.
I prefer smaller venue's as well, I remember a pub near Angel Tube station I used to go to in the late 80's early 90's and seeing the likes of Martin Simpson and Dick himself. it was great to be able to talk to them after the show.
lukessummer 2 years ago
...Brings a tear...eh?
yippierb 2 years ago
this is beautiful song!
rest in peace Liam ... we miss you!
multioxen2 2 years ago
At 0:12 Scotland :)
Buachaille etive mor, the watcher at Glencoe...
siorapaluk 2 years ago 3
See my reply to DonegalRaymie in an earlier comment.
Well spotted by the way siorpaluk!
lukessummer 2 years ago
Thanks for the encouragement...I'd love to see where my Sidney's, Kearns' and Lanes came from. From whence the Sidneys became schooner captains along the Connecticut and New York shore, they say. And in several generations was I. Thanks also for the beautiful video. It's been awhile since I've been so inspired and I'm starting to feel alive again!!
Cheers.
Lz
loZoneranger560 2 years ago
Dick Gaughan is a master in the "Hand Full of Earth" album. Every song is rich, beautiful, powerful and done with artistic soul. If anyone wonders which one DG album to get is, I'd say this.
Beautiful video!!!
Thanks so much! One day I'll see Galway as my ancestors did.
Cheers.
Lz
loZoneranger560 2 years ago 2
If you haven't been to Ireland before, you will love Galway...fantastic County and the City of Galway itself has a great buzz about the place all the time!...Very friendly people down there so they are!
lukessummer 2 years ago
Galway city was my favorite city in Ireland. For all the reasons that Lukesummer said and more.
catholicrik 2 years ago 3
J'ai les yeux qui me piquent à chaque fois que j'écoute cette merveille.
C'est tellement ça l'Irlande!
lledew 2 years ago
Oui Irlande est magnifique, et c'est la France.
Merci pour le commentaire.
lukessummer 2 years ago
You said Ireland is magnificent and it is France!
heliotropezzz333 2 years ago
I was using a little known French dialect called Donegalese!...Ha ha!!!
lukessummer 2 years ago
Viele Grüße from isle ruegen (germany)
Dick Gaughan ist einer der besten Interpreten des wunderbaren songs for ireland. Danke, Thanks so much!!!
exsaxpommernjung 2 years ago
Und ich danke Ihnen für Ihre höfliche Kommentar. Sie sind in der Tat richtig, Dick Gaughan ist die beste Dolmetscher der irischen Liedern.
lukessummer 2 years ago
This is a wonderful video. The profound hunger for peace is made vivid and beautiful for a world that needs it. Thanks!
lexinaut 2 years ago 2
i love this!!
chappahx 2 years ago
Gaughan wrote this song, didn't he?
-jcr
NSResponder 2 years ago
Ah!...no
lukessummer 2 years ago
This brilliant song written by Phil Coulter. Lyn and I sang this at Sidmouth in 1989 to a packed house and you could have heard a pin drop! Fantastic event and fantastic memory...we used to run The Willow Tree on to it as sort of double song set. I was part of Chequered Roots in those days....
charliedehaven 2 years ago
Did not know it was a Phil Coulter song, that figures, the other one of his that I love is "The town I loved so well" Check it out!
whackfoldeediedo 2 years ago
I think that was just a typo on charliehaven's part, this song was actually writ by Phil Colclough and his wife June, an English couple from Staffordshire.
lukessummer 2 years ago
Thanks for that. I do appreciate it. What a beautiful song.....made even more so being written by a non native!
whackfoldeediedo 2 years ago
irish~english...and proud...!
yedon68 2 years ago
And proud you should be...
lukessummer 2 years ago
It takes a Scot to sing it soooo Beautifullyl
whackfoldeediedo 2 years ago 3
I feel privileged to watch and listen to this again, this time after paying close attention to your:
"Father Daughter Mother Son". A close friend recently passed. He was a giant of my times, I told his partner recently: The past is what we made it. The future is what we make it."
It is a rare treat to share the blue where falcons fly with you and Dick.
RedKruzer 2 years ago 4
Beautiful song. Written by an english schoolteacher
fatherjoxer 2 years ago 2
Homesick now...want a wee dander to Blackhead lighthouse..
Funloverdude 2 years ago
I´m a Scotsman (like Dick Gaughan) but I must say this song really stirs my Celtic blood.
exiledjacobite1 2 years ago 12
I am french and originally from Morocco and salsa teacher!!...but this song is one of my favourite.
I don't know why I love celtic music but this one touch my heart.
I herd it many years ago on the beautifull album "Heart of gaels".
salsaconga 1 year ago
@exiledjacobite1
you beat me to that comment, it really gets me goin. Scotland & Ireland, brother nations.
2dcarr 10 months ago
had the honor to be dick gaughan's support performin in oldenburg/germany. just got back from a tour through australia, where smbdy smashed his guitar. so he was in a pretty bad mood ;O) had dinner with him. really nice guy. thx 4 ur music! chris
christianmachafolk 2 years ago 2
beautifull!
Irish Australian and proud!
i want to go back to Eire =)
Bhouncer 2 years ago 5
I think this is the best version ever.
bs5750 2 years ago 6
thank you chris i needed this.
hope all is well mate.
jimdoyles 2 years ago
perfect guitar, voice and lyrics.
Great
amermo2 2 years ago 4
Beautiful video . . . perfect guitar, voice and lyrics.
Gretsch'n
BluegrassForte 2 years ago 4
Inimitable Gaughan. Long Live Ireland.
ScooterNerd 2 years ago 5
Well said my friend.
lukessummer 2 years ago
His rendition of this song is absolutely the most beautiful.
lookatdoor 2 years ago 3
This has to be the definitive version of this song.. have heard many, but this one never fails to bring tears to my eyes.... even before I left Ireland!
Up Mayo!
daireo 2 years ago 5
I think it is. Gaughan simply does the song better!
DonegalRaymie201 2 years ago 2
Hows things with you this weather Raymie?
lukessummer 2 years ago
Hi Luke, I'm grand thanks. Do things go well with thee?
Will be off to see our man DG next month. Saw him at the Celtic Connections festival but he was only doing a few songs as part of the Burns' concert. Still great to see him where he belongs, in front of 5000 people at Royal Concert Hall!
Strangely, he was no less comfortable than playing in front of the 90 folk crammed into a wee room when I last saw him!
Looking for ideas for more DG songs put to pics, any suggestions?
DonegalRaymie201 2 years ago
Actually I do...Dicks peerless cover of "Games people play" by Joe South. I lent my copy of "A Different Kind of Love Song" and never got it back so if you have it I think it would be a great track to put up.
Although not a "folk" song as such, I think Dick really puts a lot of passion into the song...one of his best vocals I think!
lukessummer 2 years ago
I do. I will. Good shout! My thanks!
Enough of the 2 word sentences, I agree, it's so completely different it's worth letting people hear his reinterpretation. I think it'll surprise a few folk!
Anything for a fellow countyman!
DonegalRaymie201 2 years ago 2
different approach to lukes but still good
lumpogenics 2 years ago
Ha, really love this song, living in Scotland now and missing my home. I come from whitehead which is a part of Blackhead....sigh..
Funloverdude 2 years ago 4
lovely walk along the Blackhead path round the rocks listenin to the sea crashing on the rocks up the caves i live in Whiteabbey was there just last week went up to the lighthouse !
Screwdriverss 2 years ago 2
Precioso video. Fabuloso Gaughan.
Gracias por subirlo.
txpilar 2 years ago 2
Gracias por sus comentarios.
lukessummer 2 years ago
Followed your video response for this one. What a wonderful version
slowerairs 2 years ago 2
Do you play in the Scuttlebugs slowerairs?...It looked like you had a good time on St.Paddy's day!
lukessummer 2 years ago
Yes I am the accordionist with Scuttlebugs. Thank you for your comments .
slowerairs 2 years ago 2
Beautiful video...
Dcashe42 2 years ago 2
Fantastic!!!!
oldblackandwhite 2 years ago
nice pics and nice music ;)
desertrose1972 2 years ago
beautiful land!
ILR55 2 years ago
It certainly is!
lukessummer 2 years ago
Dick Gaughan is a giant of celtic music! Stunning interpretation.
kickatinalong 2 years ago 2
I love this bro,
blessed,
G
chappahx 2 years ago
words and music by Phil and June Colclough
on the 1997 album "Spirit of Ireland"
Gaughan a genius
thanks for posting
MehefinHeulog 2 years ago 2
A work of art in every way. :-) *****
UISTMAN59 2 years ago 3
Beautiful pictures, sceneries and song. Thank you for posting.
Grandma Mary
Fr3derick 2 years ago 4
Saw Dick singing this in Perth y'day night,absolutely spell binding.wow
squidgitmidget 2 years ago 5
Damn it! Didn't know he was playing! What else did he sing?
DonegalRaymie201 2 years ago 3
Westlin winds,tom paines bones,its not what youre born with, song about John Muir,song about "big muddy",cant remember names of others.spoke to him at end and told him I was disappointed he didnt do the workers song or the diggers which are my favourites!
squidgitmidget 2 years ago 3
Beautiful Song with a mesmerising slided show. Favouriting this one.
misspopanoche 2 years ago 3
Great song and beautiful images..
tubelookjohn 2 years ago 3
Thanks John.
lukessummer 2 years ago
Beautiful! ... Thank you.
Andy12A45 2 years ago 3
Incredible photos and my favorite song of all time ... great job, makes me "homeland" sick.
McDaidUSA 2 years ago
Thanks McDaidUSA...
lukessummer 2 years ago
...........beautiful..........
gulgio 3 years ago
Love Mary Black and Lukes version but this is very very good, beautiful deep tonal folk voice and Scottish as well....brill
minstrelbhoy 3 years ago
Well Dick is half Irish and half Highland Gael, so I think he's well placed to do this song justice!
DonegalRaymie201 3 years ago 3
I would go as far as to say that he is better placed than most (for the very reason you have stated) to sing this song than most of my fellow countrymen and women. It may be tantamount to heresy to say this but I find Luke Kelly's version pedestrian at best and Mary Blacks version leaves me cold.
lukessummer 3 years ago
So you're a heretic with a good ear for songcraft!
I listened to Luke's version and have to agree, his phrasing is poor; like he hasn't given any thought to the lyrics. And there's a tad of "Musak" to Mary's. A bit too easy-listening for me.
But the worst offender is The Fureys. Every folk music cliche is employed without care. I still wake up in cold sweats hearing it!
DonegalRaymie201 3 years ago 3
@DonegalRaymie201 Well he didn't have time to be thinking too deeply about the lyrics, he was dead only weeks after recording the song and kept falling asleep while it was being recorded..... no point in trying to compare the respective versions. They're both great so it's really a matter of personal preference. Personally I am hopelessly addicted to Lukes voice so I can't imagine liking anyone elses version of anything better than Luke Kellys!!
tony10396861 9 months ago
@tony10396861
Dick himself said that Luke's version of "Freedom Come All Ye",(a song both men recorded), is peerless! And I would have to agree, but Luke's version of this song, is very far from his best work, for the very reasons you mention.
I wouldn't want Luke judged by what turned out to be his Swan Song. On this recording, Dick has my vote for what it's worth.
DonegalRaymie201 8 months ago
@DonegalRaymie201 He's not as good vocally as when he was younger, I agree, but I still think it's a very special recording. The story of how it was recorded only adds to that. It's one of my favourites
tony10396861 8 months ago
It will be a great day when that last verse comes true.
bigbeninjax 3 years ago 3
Ireland is Beautiful!
Thanks!
arpajlleon 3 years ago
Beautiful song, great video, perfect editing!
Congratulations ...*****
Greetings
José Luis, harpist.
arpajlleon 3 years ago
Those really are some wonderful shots to go with this great song!! Thanks!!*****Duke
TexasHighDef 3 years ago 3
Luke kelly and Dick Gaughan both sing this song amazingly !
Maltier1 3 years ago 5
True...
lukessummer 3 years ago
Stunning images , fantastic version of a song for ireland
howdofolks 3 years ago
As much as I like Luke Kelly singing this, there is something special about this rendition. What poetic lyrics!
whackfoldeediedo 3 years ago 4
For me, personally, this is being sung by some one who really understands the lyrical content and is expressing a true love of Ireland.
lukessummer 3 years ago
First time I saw him it was in Galway, from then on
I just go to see him when ever he is nearby.
And this song will always take me to memory of walking
by sea shore with swans n catamarans in bay of Claddagh.
Some songs n artist like Gaughan, some places they stay in our heart.
Lovely post!
r3VOLt23 3 years ago 3
Love this.
jeana1001 3 years ago 2
Delicate and marvellous music!
loybillyrock 3 years ago 3
Thanks for posting. This is a wonderful randition of this song. Dick has a wonderful warm voice and the guitar is beautiful. The pics are truly beautiful as well. Great job!!!!!!
jellechYLD 3 years ago 3
EXCELLENT!10*
1IrishDannyBoy 3 years ago 2
Please more from Mr. Gaughan!!!
What about "now westlin wind" ???
emdermarketing 3 years ago 3
One of the best renditions of this great sings. The photos are brilliant. *****
UISTMAN59 3 years ago 2
This is one beutiful song.
Your edit matches it.
Congratulations.
rk
at 3:24 (4:34)you gave us more
I believe that Henry Glassie describes Ireland well...especially as to 3:24
RedKruzer 3 years ago 3
Never thought I would find a version of this song to equal Luke Kelly....
I'm off to buy some Dick Gaughan albums
sogreidhm 3 years ago 2
This song is from Dick's album
"Handful of Earth" it includes brilliant renditions of Craigie Hill, Lough Erne;
First Kiss At Parting and Erin Go Bragh!
It is well worth getting.
Thanks for the comment.
lukessummer 3 years ago
Could not believe my luck today. I headed in to town (Dublin) today and got a copy of Kist O'Gold in a second hand music shop
sogreidhm 3 years ago 3
Sure now, that was fate! Enjoy, and if ever you get the chance, go see him live! He's the only true Troubadour I've ever heard! Just captivates an audience with his songcraft! If you aren't blown away by how a true artist can capture you, i'll pay your ticket! Sure, I moved to Scotland to see him perform more!
DonegalRaymie201 3 years ago 3
I just bought it from Amazon for 10- US
RedKruzer 3 years ago 2
thanks for that info. Am getting it tomorrow!!
whackfoldeediedo 3 years ago 2
in min 1:54 you can see a cloud that apears to be a blessing hand, God bless Ireland.
avatarprimus 3 years ago
one of the most beautiful i ever hear. amazing
avatarprimus 3 years ago
Great song & singer. I love the photos too.
ljped 3 years ago
Nice! Straight into my Ireland Playlist. Nice shots of Ben Bulben, too. Great song and pics. Reminds me of standing on Achill Island and looking out to sea.
bigbeninjax 3 years ago 2
Beautiful pics and song! Just that first pic though, it's "Buachilletive Mhor" in Glencoe isn't it? I've climbed it in winter so I think I recognise it!
DonegalRaymie201 3 years ago 4
Well spotted!,Buachaille Etive Mòr (the 'Great Herdsman of Etive').
I had planed to put pictures of Scotland,Ireland and England in this little video, to celebrate the fact that it was writ by an Englishman and sung by a Scotsman. But it would have got cluttered, so I decided not to.
Again!, well spotted!
lukessummer 3 years ago
Thankyou, we do try! It looks a lot better in your pic than when I tried climbing it!
DonegalRaymie201 3 years ago 2
Great photos, lovely soundtrack.
jratt2 3 years ago 2
Nice video man. Erin go Breagh.
wyoming99 3 years ago
Grand. I quite enjoy the guitar tone... Martins simply beautiful. Thanks for posting.
Celticstrat 3 years ago 4
Outstanding!!!
Sawlon 3 years ago 3
Just wonderful... this beautiful song with so lovely images... 0.34 is magic!
A little gem...
5***** and saved to my favourites
Isolde :)
catminima 3 years ago 2
so beautiful!!!
avatarprimus 3 years ago 2