@tigerone1970 Are you kidding me?? It's like he's trying to try so hard to sound manly or something. This song was so poignant with the soft sweet whispered vocals and than the contrasting screaming. He ruins everything now
Is it just me does Billy look and act abnormally enthusiatic and energetic here? Not saying he is lifeless on stage generally, but there is alot more swinging guiatrs and dancing here then usual in my opinion lol
that's because the guitar he used while recording this song which gave that specific feedback(mainly because the guitar was cheap) got stolen around 1990 or so. which sucks
Actually, Billy still has it. He also used it to write and record "1979". I read that Billy tried to use it for recording for Teargarden, but for some reason it didn't work. A shame, as that really is a historic guitar in the history of SP...
Ahh yes, you're talking about that video clip that popped up on Kerry Brown's blog, yeah? I seem to remember reading that and the story was that when time came to actually record the song properly, it refused to work. Maybe he did use it after all!
Then again, for years I thought the Mayo guitar was the one James plays in the "Rocket" video until I saw that blog post.
@PantheonLincoln Yeah thats what I was talking about but I guess I didn't get the rest of the story. Oh well. We know its still out there and when Billy finds the right song for it again maybe it will return to us.
Definitely. I feel that way about his music in general, but there's something about the way he executes solos that feels so sublimely organic - his guitar sings with joy and wails with sorrow, bending and writhing in all the right ways and with just the right pace.
@scrolllocknumlock yeah he was actually named "one of the finest and most underrated guitarist of the 90's", by some magazine that was reviewing the song Starla...
@scrolllocknumlock The first time I saw The Smashing Pumpkins, back on the Siamese Dream tour, I had no clue Billy Corgan was anything but a rhythm guitarist. I was blown away at the show when it was him, and not Iha, tearing up the solos.
@raremountainbear same here, except the first time i saw them was on the mellon collie tour, and the song was "an ode to no one." i was blown away. still am ;)
Doesn't sound bored. Just down an octave and no parts where his voice gets "rough". And maybe Billy CAN'T reach that higher octave anymore. Seemed like he had to try even back in 2000 to do it. Im surprised he wouldnt get vocal training to try and expand his range again. It seems like he got tone training but no range training.
Could be just the sound quality of the recording or the acoustics of the venue. The original studio recording on good headphones, even on CD is absolutely stunning. The original sounds simple yet sentimental, fresh and new every time I listen to it- even after right around a decade after the first time I heard this song.
me too and Billy is so cute. He reminds me the singer of an animated band hiting strong here in Italy not being a million dollar production. Search for SWAVE IN THE FUTURE
Billys dress things are just stupid. I still love him though.
19KISStheSKY97 1 week ago
I love the idea of the inverted zero shirt. definitely symbolic somehow
whatCHOCOLATEMILK 1 month ago
He used his star power in the chorus... before the solo... he's a genius.
TheStanfordWhite 1 month ago
i just want to be...
Luckmus 2 months ago
This was easily the best show I have ever been to.
IveGotTrex 3 months ago
Comment removed
jsh020 5 months ago
uummm.....why is billy wearing a long skirt?
cgman04 5 months ago
@cgman04
Because he can.....
MrAngelsReaper 4 months ago
@cgman04 You must be a newer pumpkins fan...
palescale 3 months ago
@cgman04 Because he's the frontman of a very very successful rock band
macsww 2 weeks ago
Billy's voice has actually gotten better with time.
tigerone1970 5 months ago
@tigerone1970 Are you kidding me?? It's like he's trying to try so hard to sound manly or something. This song was so poignant with the soft sweet whispered vocals and than the contrasting screaming. He ruins everything now
TheAvatrolOfficial 5 months ago
Oh....Yeah...I remember these guys.....I especially like the part from 0:00 to 5:22.......
albertinoRRT 6 months ago 4
i was there also
luisonia1218 6 months ago
Is it just me does Billy look and act abnormally enthusiatic and energetic here? Not saying he is lifeless on stage generally, but there is alot more swinging guiatrs and dancing here then usual in my opinion lol
freakboy1992 9 months ago
I wish they played this song on the teargarden tour... its one of my fave by the pumpkins
dimarziotonezone23 1 year ago
@dimarziotonezone23 Well at least they play Hummer one of the best from Siamese Dream. and Eye another song I love too.
nicholsjoshua15 11 months ago
イハは素晴らしい音楽家だ。この曲サイコー!
velvet0522 1 year ago
Comment removed
velvet0522 1 year ago
soundgasmic
norcoatomik 1 year ago
yuuuhhuuu...
TheAkizaki 1 year ago
a Zero shirt in 2008? that's odd lol
MechanicalChrist1 1 year ago
@MechanicalChrist1 i used to wear a zero hoodie around that time..
youknowyourrite1 1 year ago
ha ha! billy looks like an avatar!!
12BIGBAT 1 year ago
Must get that shirt.
ColoredPig 1 year ago
is that moby
newyrat 1 year ago
Billy has THE strangest concert atire
pat90 1 year ago 6
@pat90
iloveit.
darrellvandever 1 year ago
2:32. thank you life!
doors36 1 year ago
sp rocks billy is awesome
zeentje1996 2 years ago
i dont like how it doesnt have the feedback like the recording
125633 2 years ago
that's because the guitar he used while recording this song which gave that specific feedback(mainly because the guitar was cheap) got stolen around 1990 or so. which sucks
LimitedEdition500 2 years ago
@LimitedEdition500
Actually, Billy still has it. He also used it to write and record "1979". I read that Billy tried to use it for recording for Teargarden, but for some reason it didn't work. A shame, as that really is a historic guitar in the history of SP...
PantheonLincoln 8 months ago
@PantheonLincoln I thought he did use it for part of Astral Planes
freakboy1992 8 months ago
@freakboy1992
Ahh yes, you're talking about that video clip that popped up on Kerry Brown's blog, yeah? I seem to remember reading that and the story was that when time came to actually record the song properly, it refused to work. Maybe he did use it after all!
Then again, for years I thought the Mayo guitar was the one James plays in the "Rocket" video until I saw that blog post.
PantheonLincoln 8 months ago
@PantheonLincoln Yeah thats what I was talking about but I guess I didn't get the rest of the story. Oh well. We know its still out there and when Billy finds the right song for it again maybe it will return to us.
freakboy1992 8 months ago
& I love the end of this song so much, it's like a rebellion. :)
fightingfoos 2 years ago 3
Probably my favorite SP song... it has so much energy and the lyrics are beautiful...
fightingfoos 2 years ago
Awsome white ZERO shirt!!!!!!!!!!!! LOVE IT
VictorLooser 2 years ago 18
@VictorLooser Classic.
metalboy27 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Best song ever!!!
skizmsucks23 2 years ago
awesome solo...best live video i've seen of this song
iceykyle 2 years ago
yeah, his solos are something else, i always thought he was sort of underrated in that regard
scrolllocknumlock 2 years ago 18
Definitely. I feel that way about his music in general, but there's something about the way he executes solos that feels so sublimely organic - his guitar sings with joy and wails with sorrow, bending and writhing in all the right ways and with just the right pace.
:)
Affliction17 2 years ago
@scrolllocknumlock sucks how the pumpkins are so underrated..
iceykyle 2 years ago
@iceykyle
That is OK,,,we can enjoy,,,,,,once its mainstream, its ruined.
rkullson1 1 year ago
@scrolllocknumlock yeah he was actually named "one of the finest and most underrated guitarist of the 90's", by some magazine that was reviewing the song Starla...
IamTheScorchedEarth 1 year ago
@scrolllocknumlock The first time I saw The Smashing Pumpkins, back on the Siamese Dream tour, I had no clue Billy Corgan was anything but a rhythm guitarist. I was blown away at the show when it was him, and not Iha, tearing up the solos.
raremountainbear 1 year ago 2
@raremountainbear same here, except the first time i saw them was on the mellon collie tour, and the song was "an ode to no one." i was blown away. still am ;)
briansolo 8 months ago
@raremountainbear Oh yeah, Billy's a much much better guitarist than Iha is. And Iha's pretty damn good.
Corgster shreds!
1979Siamese 7 months ago
fuck thats the first performance that he sings it with emotions since his return
FrxBass 2 years ago
you're joking.... he sounds bland and bored as per usual. no effort.
err0r 2 years ago
Doesn't sound bored. Just down an octave and no parts where his voice gets "rough". And maybe Billy CAN'T reach that higher octave anymore. Seemed like he had to try even back in 2000 to do it. Im surprised he wouldnt get vocal training to try and expand his range again. It seems like he got tone training but no range training.
rohiogerv22 2 years ago
Could be just the sound quality of the recording or the acoustics of the venue. The original studio recording on good headphones, even on CD is absolutely stunning. The original sounds simple yet sentimental, fresh and new every time I listen to it- even after right around a decade after the first time I heard this song.
thejerseydude 2 years ago
I love this song!
sanchosway 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
me too and Billy is so cute. He reminds me the singer of an animated band hiting strong here in Italy not being a million dollar production. Search for SWAVE IN THE FUTURE
TheMRious 2 years ago
When i go to heaven i want to hear the intro from mayonaise... that would be great!!!!
Love the pumpkins!!! Love Billy!!!
mistyzen 3 years ago 4
god bless the pumpkins. loved them since young, still loving them. it's great to hear them play this song still. one of the greatest songs!
apokolips 3 years ago 3
smashing pumpkins
FOREVER!!!
richpon1973 3 years ago 5
arriba pumpkins indeed :)
Joshuac220 3 years ago
Excelente como sieempre, que buena cancion, arriba pumpkins. I was there and it was so incredible.
leoncervantes80 3 years ago
This is great, thanks!
stormy32316 3 years ago