Chinese propaganda crap. Most of those photos are obviously old, and of dubious sources. On the other hand, Chinese atrocities in recent years are well documented. China has no moral standing to criticize the Dalai Lama.
I think it's important to be skeptical. I watched this with an open mind, but none of these pictures prove anything. Many insist that something untoward is going on when there was nothing in the content of the picture that actually displayed what the caption claimed. And for the more unpleasant pictures, I could find you hundreds of unpleasant picture from cultures all over the world and make a case that war veteran wounds were the result of something else.
@yuning83 Well that proves it then, doesn't it? Considering the Chinese government has made it illegal for Tibetan scholars and historians to speak anything but the prescribed Chinese side of the story, any 'official' source inside of Tibet that supports the Chinese side of the story has to be taken with a grain of salt.
You're right that propaganda goes both ways, but when an occupation government has made it illegal to discuss Tibetan history in Tibet, you have to consider what that means.
Under Chinese Communist ruled - We have heard that Millions of The Tibetans has been suffering like animals - And there are few of the pictures or video clipsthat people around the world could be able to be seen -
The Chinese who really love Demmoncracy and human rights should support the Tibetan fight for their freedom and releasing their slaves
Ah well, it was pretty easy to figure out the Dalai Lama was a sham, when Richard Gere (and his gerbil), Sharon Stone, and Steven Seagal are supporting him...
I think most Zang ethnic minorities (Tibetans) activists, living outside of their motherland, China and a small number inside China, including a small minority of Western sympathisers have realized that they have lost a lot of respect in the International Communities today. The disruptions of the Olympic Torch, The Beijing Games, The riots in Lhasa, Xizang (Tibet) province of China in March 2008, and many other disruptive demonstrations had been condemn by people worldwide. Peace to the world.
tibet has been part of China since 12th century. deal with the fact that tibet was temporarily colonized by brits in early 1900s.
glad tibet has been reunified with China since 1951. long live tibetan Chinese and other ethnic Chinese. evil movements from dalai cliques and hippies with the supports of the western nations will fail because God and the Buddha are watching carefully.
I have many Chinese history classes at univeristy taught by american professors. I know history well. it's boring that you only think of yourself as brightliant, self-centered you.
tibet has been part of China and will always be so.
See the thing is at least one of us is not very bright and has been brainwashed by China's Central Propaganda Department.
Have you talked to Professor Robert Thurman?
He is an influential and prolific American Buddhist writer. An academic who has authored and edited several books on Tibetan Buddhism. Time chose him as one of the 25 most influential Americans in 1997.
He will get you on the path to sanity, if that is possible.
and i m educated in this history matter so good luck trying to pin point others for being brainwashed when u yourself have not thoroughly understand the history anyway.
The Chinese Communist Party will self destruct. That is very easy to see.
You see there are MANY thugs, goons and morons at the top of the Chinese Communist Party who do not have a brain or they have been brainwashed by their own Central Propaganda Department.
Chinese people are smarter than the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and can see that and they know it is only a matter of time before sanity prevails again.
darn..u are freaking out of your mind, i m talking about ethnicity and history...all u think is anti-gov. perhaps, that is why u learn the wrong freaking history.
yeah...just like how amerikkka had slaves chained...every one can reform correct? even the dalai lama correct? or is it that only amerikkkans can have a change of heart?
Dear Chinese: Before you start asking me to feel sorry for you and all the people that died in the earthquake I want to say that I don't give a damn. You people are killing Tibetans and stealing their land. So I am glad when it comes back to you in the form or an earthquake. I shit on dead Chinese tombs before I donate to you Nazi ethnic cleansers!
From Tibet, to Sudan, to Burma, to North Korea China lies and people die. Free Tibet!
" The Government of the United States has borne in mind the fact that the Chinese Government has long claimed suzerainty over Tibet and that the Chinese constitution lists Tibet among areas constituting the territory of the Republic of China. This Government has at no time raised a question regarding either of these claims."
Foreign Relations of the United States, 1943, China, Department of State, 1957, p.630
If you would actually take your time and search for these information you will find that the link provided in the video is a website created by Michael Parenti, an American Political Science Ph.D.
Let's not talk about if people are favoring Tibet or China, let's just ask yourself, are you educated enough to know the facts of life in Tibet before China "took over"(I really dont know if it should be call take over when a Tibet is in exile
The biggest problem with trying to convince people that Tibetans were unhappy slaves before China invaded is that if you ask Tibetans, they will tell you a different story. There is such a large gap between the Chinese version and the Tibetan version that someone must be lying. So the question is, who is lying?
I believe the Tibetan people (inside and outside Tibet) who overwhelmingly agree: "CHINA LIES!!!"
the funny thing about this video is that it is totally racist. Some of these people just look like ordinary Tibetans, yes they look poor, but that is how Tibetans dressed. For example , the photo of a "36 year old Slave Woman", just looks like a Tibetan Ama-la to me (way older than 36).
These photos are so unconvincing, I could go to China today and take some pictures of old poor farmers and make a video saying that Chinese people are slaves. But I"m not that stupid!
There are many types of Buddhists, and The Dalai Lama and the Tibetan Buddhists are different from what I find the definition of Buddhism to be...if there's no sacrificing, then why the human skull? Tibet has been part of China since the dynasties. There are pictures of not only slavery, but the torture former slaves went through under The Dalai Lama. It has been stated by one former slave that it was "hell on Earth."
Tibet was never part of China. It was part of the Yuan (Mongol) and then the Qing (Manchu) empires. However, the Mongols do not claim Tibet nor to the Manchus. For most of its history Tibet governed itself and no other country has the right to claim it as their own.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Why don't we take a survey of all the Tibetans still alive, and ask them "Would you rather live in China under the rule of the PRC, or would you rather live under the rule of the Dalai Lama". I GUARANTEE that 100% of them will choose the Dalai Lama rather than your fascist regime.
Then consider this.. how many of the old Tibetans are still alive? Who experienced the slavery? Most of the living Tibetan monks today have been there since they were little children, absorbing in everything that Dalai Lama says.
Just so you know. The human skull used in this photo is not from a "sacrificed" slave. In fact, the human skull is a symbol brought from India. It is a buddhist symbol which is meant to remind you of impermanence so you practice compassion. The most important rule of Buddhism is to not harm others, Buddhists do not believe in sacrifice.
I see no proof in this video of slavery. What I see are some old photos taken by the PRC, used over and over for propoganda. The same old crap from Communist China. Here's a tip for you, THE WORLD DOESN'T BELIEVE YOU!
Our grandparents told us the real story of China at that time because they lived it. I will not believe your fabricated history minnozola, lie to yourself if you want, no Chinese will believe you, forget it, you cannot lie to us.
That being the case, what on the earth makes them love Dalai lama and old tibet more then your 'freed tibet" now ?? By showing this stupid photos you can not prove those years traditiona of love and compassion as soceitty of harted and toure....those hand-chopped are photos of Mogols ...not tibetians ...using all power of china you could collect few clips of some bad stuff ....however for
"They" don't love Dalai lama. Only part of the yellow sect of Buddism love him. Among 2 million Tibetan, there are merely 2% who had involved in the protest. What does it suggest? You tell me.
We have had riots here in USA, many beginning when law enforcement attempted to disperse the crowd.[see my video log] Many peaceful protesters will flee when violence starts. When trouble starts, young guns come running, this being a normal warrior nature of young men that hold anger or desire to protect their believes. The majority of people who are comfortable or live in terror will stay away from aggressive behavior. I would say 2% would be very high amount of response.
This apparently is true, but think about it: It's not like the Chinese people are stupid. The Chinese government cannot ban every single website that has things they don't want. Chinese people are able to find information about things on MANY MANY other websites. In addition, there are so many Chinese hackers out there and the amount of Chinese people with relatives outside of the US who send them emails and phone calls? lmao.
SAYING FREE TIBET IS LIKE SAYING UNITED STATES SHOULD BE HAWAII, GUAM ETC.
mabuhayguy 1 month ago
Chinese propaganda crap. Most of those photos are obviously old, and of dubious sources. On the other hand, Chinese atrocities in recent years are well documented. China has no moral standing to criticize the Dalai Lama.
ysidero 6 months ago
I lived during this era and none of this was in Tibet!
moonshots094 6 months ago
I think it's important to be skeptical. I watched this with an open mind, but none of these pictures prove anything. Many insist that something untoward is going on when there was nothing in the content of the picture that actually displayed what the caption claimed. And for the more unpleasant pictures, I could find you hundreds of unpleasant picture from cultures all over the world and make a case that war veteran wounds were the result of something else.
Don't believe everything you see.
MouseAndShiraz 6 months ago
@MouseAndShiraz Especially considering the Chinese government has made their propaganda about Tibet no secret at all.
MouseAndShiraz 6 months ago
@MouseAndShiraz Most of these stuff is from museum in TIbet. And propaganda goes both ways,just remember that.
yuning83 6 months ago
@yuning83 Well that proves it then, doesn't it? Considering the Chinese government has made it illegal for Tibetan scholars and historians to speak anything but the prescribed Chinese side of the story, any 'official' source inside of Tibet that supports the Chinese side of the story has to be taken with a grain of salt.
You're right that propaganda goes both ways, but when an occupation government has made it illegal to discuss Tibetan history in Tibet, you have to consider what that means.
MouseAndShiraz 6 months ago
Under Chinese Communist ruled - We have heard that Millions of The Tibetans has been suffering like animals - And there are few of the pictures or video clipsthat people around the world could be able to be seen -
The Chinese who really love Demmoncracy and human rights should support the Tibetan fight for their freedom and releasing their slaves
LyVanAnh 1 year ago
@LyVanAnh Cheap Chinese Propaganda
hajiamnin 1 year ago
@LyVanAnh Cheap Chinese Propaganda
hajiamnin 1 year ago
Ah well, it was pretty easy to figure out the Dalai Lama was a sham, when Richard Gere (and his gerbil), Sharon Stone, and Steven Seagal are supporting him...
by78 2 years ago
i think the skull and skin part were pretty cool. very creative :)
fakespotter 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I think most Zang ethnic minorities (Tibetans) activists, living outside of their motherland, China and a small number inside China, including a small minority of Western sympathisers have realized that they have lost a lot of respect in the International Communities today. The disruptions of the Olympic Torch, The Beijing Games, The riots in Lhasa, Xizang (Tibet) province of China in March 2008, and many other disruptive demonstrations had been condemn by people worldwide. Peace to the world.
Globalvisual 3 years ago
this fucking slavery must be abolished...but the communist people should not eliminate the religious culture of tibet...
inno1980 3 years ago
Tibet is part of China!!!
pleasantlysurprising 3 years ago
Please watch
Robert Thurman: Tibet Is Not a Part of China—End the Occupation
ChinaKillsNuns 3 years ago
tibet has been part of China since 12th century. deal with the fact that tibet was temporarily colonized by brits in early 1900s.
glad tibet has been reunified with China since 1951. long live tibetan Chinese and other ethnic Chinese. evil movements from dalai cliques and hippies with the supports of the western nations will fail because God and the Buddha are watching carefully.
pleasantlysurprising 3 years ago
Listen to university professors. They know the truth.
Has China's Central Propaganda Department brainwashed you.
ChinaKillsNuns 3 years ago
killsnuns is so brainwashed and misinformed.
I have many Chinese history classes at univeristy taught by american professors. I know history well. it's boring that you only think of yourself as brightliant, self-centered you.
tibet has been part of China and will always be so.
pleasantlysurprising 3 years ago
See the thing is at least one of us is not very bright and has been brainwashed by China's Central Propaganda Department.
Have you talked to Professor Robert Thurman?
He is an influential and prolific American Buddhist writer. An academic who has authored and edited several books on Tibetan Buddhism. Time chose him as one of the 25 most influential Americans in 1997.
He will get you on the path to sanity, if that is possible.
ChinaKillsNuns 3 years ago
american authors often time have hidden agendas.
i know that tibet is part of China.
long live tibetan Chinese!
and i m educated in this history matter so good luck trying to pin point others for being brainwashed when u yourself have not thoroughly understand the history anyway.
pleasantlysurprising 3 years ago
You need to listen better to your history professors.
Do you need a hearing aid?
Tibetans have never thought of themselves as Chinese in any way.
ChinaKillsNuns 3 years ago
you went too far. perhaps, you need brain and soul transplants to be a better human being.
your hatred remarks will be self-destructive.
pleasantlysurprising 3 years ago
Is this going too far?
The Chinese Communist Party will self destruct. That is very easy to see.
You see there are MANY thugs, goons and morons at the top of the Chinese Communist Party who do not have a brain or they have been brainwashed by their own Central Propaganda Department.
Chinese people are smarter than the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and can see that and they know it is only a matter of time before sanity prevails again.
Long live China (and CCP will be gone soon).
ChinaKillsNuns 3 years ago
darn..u are freaking out of your mind, i m talking about ethnicity and history...all u think is anti-gov. perhaps, that is why u learn the wrong freaking history.
u poor soul. may you soul rest in peace.
pleasantlysurprising 3 years ago
i think it is inaccurate...actually it should be during the ming dynasty tibet had a tributary relationship with china...
inno1980 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
read this book: The Snow Lion and the Dragon: China, Tibet, and the Dalai Lama
Written by dr. goldstein, the world known tibet expert, spending almost all his lifetime research on tibet.
Amazon sells this book for 15$
his research may have all you free-tibet fans shocked
magnietuit 3 years ago
yeah...just like how amerikkka had slaves chained...every one can reform correct? even the dalai lama correct? or is it that only amerikkkans can have a change of heart?
mothershitasshole 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Before 1959 in Tibet
no democracy and no Human rights.
like China in 2008.
we are Tibetan
Free Tibet
tibetfreenews 3 years ago
shame on people who free tibet but do not know what tibetan slaves are.
ngan87 3 years ago
hey guys who want to FREE TIBET, is this what u need?
ngan87 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
中国现代奴隶的幕后有什么制度?
占5%的共*党员有什么看法?
*
南方都市报:四川凉山童工在广东的悲惨的奴隶生活
揭秘凉山童工悲惨生活 漂亮女孩易遭强奸
山西奴隶制黑砖窑:21世纪的耻辱
BBC中文网:山西再曝奴隶砖窑被困儿童疑上千
Telegraph:Chinese slave children 'sold like cabbages'
Reuters:China rescues 167 children from slavery
YAPONLUQ 3 years ago
Dear Chinese: Before you start asking me to feel sorry for you and all the people that died in the earthquake I want to say that I don't give a damn. You people are killing Tibetans and stealing their land. So I am glad when it comes back to you in the form or an earthquake. I shit on dead Chinese tombs before I donate to you Nazi ethnic cleansers!
From Tibet, to Sudan, to Burma, to North Korea China lies and people die. Free Tibet!
BhutanBoy1982 3 years ago
" The Government of the United States has borne in mind the fact that the Chinese Government has long claimed suzerainty over Tibet and that the Chinese constitution lists Tibet among areas constituting the territory of the Republic of China. This Government has at no time raised a question regarding either of these claims."
Foreign Relations of the United States, 1943, China, Department of State, 1957, p.630
Leibo07 3 years ago
Stop believing Chinese propaganda or you will die and go to hell with all other commies.
Akiyo12345 3 years ago
i bet chinese guy made this huh?
Chemidolkartibstar 3 years ago
It does seem to be but....
If you would actually take your time and search for these information you will find that the link provided in the video is a website created by Michael Parenti, an American Political Science Ph.D.
Let's not talk about if people are favoring Tibet or China, let's just ask yourself, are you educated enough to know the facts of life in Tibet before China "took over"(I really dont know if it should be call take over when a Tibet is in exile
33291816 3 years ago
醒对宣传或您将是第一反对墙壁
ChoDorje 3 years ago
XD
ignorant da-lie follower
ngan87 3 years ago
The biggest problem with trying to convince people that Tibetans were unhappy slaves before China invaded is that if you ask Tibetans, they will tell you a different story. There is such a large gap between the Chinese version and the Tibetan version that someone must be lying. So the question is, who is lying?
I believe the Tibetan people (inside and outside Tibet) who overwhelmingly agree: "CHINA LIES!!!"
:)
notunreasonable 3 years ago
the funny thing about this video is that it is totally racist. Some of these people just look like ordinary Tibetans, yes they look poor, but that is how Tibetans dressed. For example , the photo of a "36 year old Slave Woman", just looks like a Tibetan Ama-la to me (way older than 36).
These photos are so unconvincing, I could go to China today and take some pictures of old poor farmers and make a video saying that Chinese people are slaves. But I"m not that stupid!
notunreasonable 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what a fox!! u just opened ur account 4 weeks ago ..and as a tibetan...what a looser..U chinese suck
narutosangelz 3 years ago
cockhead like you can't handle the truth, it's not our fault, lmao, now go suck some american cocks for your breakfast.
LifeInAGame 3 years ago
There are many types of Buddhists, and The Dalai Lama and the Tibetan Buddhists are different from what I find the definition of Buddhism to be...if there's no sacrificing, then why the human skull? Tibet has been part of China since the dynasties. There are pictures of not only slavery, but the torture former slaves went through under The Dalai Lama. It has been stated by one former slave that it was "hell on Earth."
chinadollrolo 3 years ago 2
And this is the kind of images will never see in the mainstream.
ShounnenBatto 3 years ago 2
一段达赖对黄教内部的宗教清洗的记录[By Swiss Public TV]
watch?v=n5sOm-uQH9Y
watch?v=Aboblx-0zAs
watch?v=b1dILwsmwCQ
neoy2kcn 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Tibet was never part of China. It was part of the Yuan (Mongol) and then the Qing (Manchu) empires. However, the Mongols do not claim Tibet nor to the Manchus. For most of its history Tibet governed itself and no other country has the right to claim it as their own.
gobitrekker 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
First of all, there is no proof of slavery here.
Second, you don't mention the half million Tibetans that have been murdered under Chinese rule and the destruction of 6000 monasteries.
gobitrekker 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Why don't we take a survey of all the Tibetans still alive, and ask them "Would you rather live in China under the rule of the PRC, or would you rather live under the rule of the Dalai Lama". I GUARANTEE that 100% of them will choose the Dalai Lama rather than your fascist regime.
hellochucknorris 3 years ago
Then consider this.. how many of the old Tibetans are still alive? Who experienced the slavery? Most of the living Tibetan monks today have been there since they were little children, absorbing in everything that Dalai Lama says.
cherrytwi5t 3 years ago 2
Just so you know. The human skull used in this photo is not from a "sacrificed" slave. In fact, the human skull is a symbol brought from India. It is a buddhist symbol which is meant to remind you of impermanence so you practice compassion. The most important rule of Buddhism is to not harm others, Buddhists do not believe in sacrifice.
hellochucknorris 3 years ago
I see no proof in this video of slavery. What I see are some old photos taken by the PRC, used over and over for propoganda. The same old crap from Communist China. Here's a tip for you, THE WORLD DOESN'T BELIEVE YOU!
hellochucknorris 3 years ago
Great, good job for freeing those slaves. Thanks very much. Now after 60 years of occupation I'd say its time for you to go home. Leave Tibet.
gobitrekker 3 years ago
brutality in the past is no excuse for brutality in the present.
xeniastarchild 3 years ago
minozoola, do you really think that we will believe you instead our grandparents??? are you foul??? you cannot lie to Chinese. go to lie westerners.
xieuling 3 years ago
Our grandparents told us the real story of China at that time because they lived it. I will not believe your fabricated history minnozola, lie to yourself if you want, no Chinese will believe you, forget it, you cannot lie to us.
xieuling 3 years ago
What a bunch of crap this video posted by a Chinese agent is. For the real story, see "Cry of the Snow Lion", in 10 parts here on YouTube.
minoozola 3 years ago
That being the case, what on the earth makes them love Dalai lama and old tibet more then your 'freed tibet" now ?? By showing this stupid photos you can not prove those years traditiona of love and compassion as soceitty of harted and toure....those hand-chopped are photos of Mogols ...not tibetians ...using all power of china you could collect few clips of some bad stuff ....however for
nerchung 3 years ago
"They" don't love Dalai lama. Only part of the yellow sect of Buddism love him. Among 2 million Tibetan, there are merely 2% who had involved in the protest. What does it suggest? You tell me.
fluxionist 3 years ago
We have had riots here in USA, many beginning when law enforcement attempted to disperse the crowd.[see my video log] Many peaceful protesters will flee when violence starts. When trouble starts, young guns come running, this being a normal warrior nature of young men that hold anger or desire to protect their believes. The majority of people who are comfortable or live in terror will stay away from aggressive behavior. I would say 2% would be very high amount of response.
Rockborn 3 years ago
The brave ones are protesting, others are still afraid of being put in jail and beaten up by Chinese government!!!
loveandlovemore 3 years ago
China bans and censors the internet from its own people.
thefusilier1000 3 years ago
Check this one : Riot in Tibet: True face of western media
Then you can find the reason why Chinese goverment censers the media.
Tibetan72 3 years ago
AGREE, THOSE STUPID MEDIAS
Engagepower 3 years ago
@thefusilier1000 BECAUSE THE ZIONIST PORN INDUSTRY IS EVIL!
mabuhayguy 1 month ago
China bans and censors the internet from its own people.
thefusilier1000 3 years ago
WESTERN MEDIAS ARE FAKE
Engagepower 3 years ago
This apparently is true, but think about it: It's not like the Chinese people are stupid. The Chinese government cannot ban every single website that has things they don't want. Chinese people are able to find information about things on MANY MANY other websites. In addition, there are so many Chinese hackers out there and the amount of Chinese people with relatives outside of the US who send them emails and phone calls? lmao.
cherrytwi5t 3 years ago 2