Added: 2 years ago
From: killalevel
Views: 48,359
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (162)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 想給只會批評動畫組的朋友:

    因為現在日本動畫在撥出上已趨近一飽和狀態

    能給予海貓26集的集數已是相當寬容了

    若是在5、6年前的話還好,還有可能可以拉到3季(36~39集­)的撥出時間

    但現在可以挪用到2季的最大集數26集是極限了

    海貓動畫在集數有限的情況下刪減修改還有趕戲是難免

    個人不覺得動畫做得有多差,當然EP4最後這部分是用了趕一點

    但個人認為DEEN不論是在作畫或是聲音表現還有氣氛上都是相當­優秀的

    最後,銀盤也是相當優秀的作品

    希望各位不要再給予製作組批評了

  • TV動畫組請出來謝罪,同人都做的比你們好是怎樣.......­....

  • 甚麼!! 反差!! 態反差了啦!! 我的心融化了 >"<

    

  • 太犯規了..萌到我了

  • 無論是作畫跟音效都是一流水準

    比官方的26集好太多了

  • I really wish this video was subbed in english. But its still awesome.

  • Who made this?O_o but in the anime they were in the rose garden were they supposed to be in the golden land?

  • 嗚嗚嗚嗚嗚

    官方的完全不能比阿,被阿朵嗚嗚嗚

  • Hey DEEN,

    THIS is how it's done.

    Take notes, fucking morons.

    Huge tits and DEENfaces do not compensate for fucking up the adaptation completely in every possible aspect.

  • I like the animation and pacing of these fan-made ones a lot better than DEEN's, but I am a seiyuu tard so missing Ohara Sayaka and Ono Daisuke makes me sad XD

  • 貝雅朵很可愛啊

  • I think I love this one better then the actual one :o

  • 岛上只有战人一个活人,道外无法干涉岛内[我]即将去杀死战人,­[我]不是战人,求[我]是谁(什么)?

  • 官方動畫只有預告做得比較好...

  • 這....這才是海貓阿

  • w-wow this version is just amazing!

    It's much much better than the DEEN version!

    I was really disappointed when I saw ep 26... I expected so much of this episode but you see how it turned out...

    This one's just perfect <3

  • I hope DEEN sees this.

  • I hope they see it and kill bash their heads against the wall for getting outdone by fans >_> oh yes and kill Chiaki Kon while they're at it

  • Please tell me, whats this anime called? :)

  • This anime is named "Umineko no Naku Koro ni", or "When They Cry 3" as it's titled.

    It's a Visual Novel consisting of 8 games, 6 of the games are out as of now. The animated series (1st seaspon) are based on the "question arcs", which are the first 4 games. Lots of people (especially the visual novel readers) criticize the producer (DEEN) for their somewhat bad project. The game is fucking awesome though.

  • Also, this is the fanmade version, arguably better then the DEEN's version.

  • @skullchukka Thanks a lot! ^^

  • When They Cry 4... Higurashi was 3 :D I'd like to see 1 and 2 :( DEEN really messed it up the adaptation was horrible.

  • higurashi no naku koro ni: 1

    higurashi no naku koro ni kai: 2

    umineko no naku koro ni: 3

    umineko no naku koro ni chiru: 4

    :D

  • I alredy said... Higurashi(all of it) is When They Cry 3... Umineko(all of it) is When They Cry 4... I was wondering what the other two are.

  • Higurashi is not only 3. Kuro Puppeh is right.

    Higurashi no naku koro ni: When They Cry

    Higurashi no naku koro ni Kai: When They Cry 2

    Higurashi no naku koro ni Rei: When They Cry 2.5

    Umineko no nako koro ni: WTC 3

    Umineko no nako kiri no Chiru: WTC 4

    Rei is not a season, it's an OVA series, hence the 2.5 title.

    And that is the order for the anime / visual novel series to be read. Not necessarily, but it's the way it was meant.

  • Deen fucked up this series, lots of people were betting on final episode to be epic, which was not.

    This is 20 times better than the DEEN shit.

  • QUOTED FOR TRUTH

  • 要求紅字復述

    今千秋咬破肚臍去死

  • It is undoubted that this fans-made animation is much better than the Deen one (episode 26)....

  • That should be a slap in the face\wake up call for Deen if you ask me. Not that they care >_>

  • 毫無疑問,26集動畫根本就無法跟銀盤相比....

  • @killalevel

    不能同意更多了...這集的貝阿朵賣萌賣到犯規啦!

  • 超一流的質素!!我是動畫社的人,就肯定會挖角!!

  • YEY FOUND IT~!!!!!!!

  • Wow. This is just amazingly fantastic <3

    I wish DEEN could match this. The faces looked off in a couple of side shots, but that's really the only thing that wasn't perfect. Even the dialogue was word for word from the SN.

  • ;___;

    is this subbed?

  • Why yes, in fact, it is.

  • Whoa, this is pretty awesome for being fanmade! I'm used to DEEN's choice for Beatrice, but this one's not bad at all.

    In regards to the actual anime, I like a few of their designs (like Maria without her huge lower lip and Rosa) but the actual animation is...not that great :|

  • Crap. My Chinese sucks and I never ever thought of using it on the Internet but... For this, just once, I'm gonna use my Chinese knowledge!!! AH!!!!

  • lol there is one other version with eng subs on YouTube ^^

  • Yeah... I found it, and was glad that my knowledge on Chinese was not really as bad as I thought... Heh...

  • is after this chapter the ending of the anime O_O?

  • Nice flamewar here. Only the fact that even anime fans can compare this and official anime as two equal works proves that DEEN is making pretty bad job.

  • The reason DEEN is suffering quality is due to this triad: Time | Money | Quality. You can only take 2. This is only 5 minutes of animation, most of it is stills. It's very well done, but there are still problems and look at how long it took.

    DEEN likely wanted to save money and had a timeline to finish it on, so quality suffered. This is common in anime and rather sad.

    I'm still completely wow'd by this animation though, it's a very good adaption of that scene in the VN.

  • Even lack of time cant justify the stupidity of some scenes, forced fanservice completely out of place, bad directing etc... I can name hundred of things that dont depend on time/money as much as they depend on right understanding and respect to source material. Deen lacks both in epic scale.

  • Not to mention that they didnt have to hurry - there are still 3 more episodes to be released. They had plenty of time to plan it properly. Instead they rushed it as much as they could and now they will wait another 3 years before rest of the series will be released and they could adapt it. I hope they will bankrupt before that happens, because the epic lack of profesionality that Deen showed deserves no mercy. Talking about praise is absolutely out of question.

  • Give people who made this video the budget and manpower of Deen and they can make wonders.

  • what is this anime called in english?

  • Umineko no naku koro ni.

    (When the seagulls cry)

  • *Trying VE~RY HARD to ignore the comments down there*

    Seriously amazing doujin, I bet it can even beat some Touhou fan videos (and that's seriously impressive).

    *I give up...*

    Oh sheesh you damn immature brats! Apply the same rule as to every other anime! If you think it sucks, DON'T WATCH IT!

  • You say that with the implication I have watched that shitty adaptation past the first episode.

    I'm just glad that the DVD sales are tanking. Hopefully DEEN abandons it, so Ryu07 can actually get a brain and pick a studio that will at least attempt to be faithful to Chiru.

  • The DVD sales aren't up to standards because we know that the first few episodes are pretty boring, and that the bonuses aren't worth the high price.

    So DEEN is actually to blame for this round. But wishing for it to completely give up is just plain rude. If Ryuukishi thinks that it's too bad for his tastes, he'll back out. Since he hasn't, it's a sign that DEEN still has a bit of potential.

  • That was a really stupid statement.

    "Ohai DEEN, U suck ktnxbai, don't animate my novel anymore." while it is still airing.

    I am to blame, to a certain extent, for expecting anything from DEEN. I KNEW they would fuck it up ,but I didn't expect it to be so bad.

    They just set a new "Worst possible adaptation" record.

  • Immature brats, s/he says... Immature brats.

    Oh, the irony.. Oh, the irony...

    You fail way too much.I don't intend on wasting my time trying to have a conversation with you.

  • Back at'cha with the irony. All I'm saying is that the most direct way not to get mad is to not watch it. It ain't worth your time to watch it if you don't think it's good.

  • When you are too stupid to understand what the hell someone is talking about, what his point is, and why he is saying it, do not butt in on the conversation, k ?

    Besides, boring my ass.The introduction of the novel was fuckawesome.I knew the anime will be complete and utter bullshit, when they decided to drop it.

  • ... I thought you didn't want a converstion? Never mind. I'll just stop arguing or it'll be another page-clogging debate.

  • But wait... Hold on just... Damn I think I'm having a genius moment here...

    I want those scenes animated, and if another studio picks it up and re-animates it down the road(Like FMA Brotherhood) then hooray!

    But that will be highly unlikely with patsys like you, eh?

  • Saying "I told you." would be pretty pointless, since we knew that it would turn out this way.

    I am amused by the EXPERTS that tried to defend DEEN's pile of crap, though.

  • It's kind of sad, in all honesty.

    They were probably simply pessimists in the beginning, but after an overload of reading crap like "ANIME IS SO MUCH BETUR CUZ THERS NO REEDIN BSYDS SUBZ XD" they were corrupted and became anime-defenders.

    If only we could put them out of their misery. If only. :'(

  • It is, but, regrettably, you couldn't expect otherwise.

    I have to agree on that,.

    Anyone, who is so easily susceptible to the opinion of others is nothing more than an blind idiot.

    I'm really anticipating DEEN's miserable failure at the interpretation of Ep.4 Tea Party.

    I hope at least then people realize how much the anime sucks.

  • Oh wait, It would be too late, wouldn't it.

    Haha.

  • Not too late for DEEN to abandon Chiru, and hopefully, down the line we'd get at least a passable adaptation.

  • I pray they do.

    I wonder who'd pick up Chiru, though, and if they'd do a good job.

  • I can't wait for all the flames and snide jokes, but Kyoani.

    The chubby "K-On! ^________^" faces would work for Umineko, assuming they could endure the unimaginable pain of adding noses and not making everyone look like fishes. But DEEN already succeeded at that with Battler, so maybe that can slide.

  • No way, KyoAni would troll for three years, and when the finally announce the "Umineko anime", it's going to be a re-run of DEEN's work.

  • Yeah, I guess you're right.

    Still, I hate DEEN's redesigns.

  • I concur.

    For example, Kanon is one of the most obvious examples.

    He is portrayed as a bishounen in the anime.

    Also, Fish-Battler, Giraffe-Beato, etc.If you look closely, you can see that the basic design for nearly every character is the same, stripping them of their individuality.

    I wonder how and why Ryukishi is tolerating this.

  • Probably because he lives in a cave, so he needs every monie he can get.

  • hey faggot... cool story bro.

  • What's the name of the song in the end?

  • Kin Ino No Bishou by Akiko Shikata

  • Hau-I mean Uuu~Thank you so much!!

  • No problem! b o u o

  • This made me even sadder, as DEEN will never be a 10'th this good.

    Could someone just shove this video up Chiaki Kon's throat, hoping that she would learn one or another thing?

  • I concur.

    Undeniable truth.

  • Though, it is funny how 11 year old retarded fanboy/girls will thumb down all comments, that express dislike towards the anime.

    Then again, who cares.A truth someone does not accept is still truth.

    I wish the people who made this and the drama of the last two chapters of ep4 would do the anime instead.

  • fuk u u elytist h8r!!!

    Yeah, I can barely make a single criticism of the anime without getting thumbed-down.

  • Well, we are at fault to some extent for expecting people, who think that the anime is good, just because in their opinion "OMG Kanon iz so kawaii XDD ^_^" to be able to accept an opinion, different than theirs.

    I wish they would read the goddamn novel and watch this after doing so.

  • but omg dat meenz u hav 2 reed a lot n i dont lyk 2 reed non-fansubz

    You got that right. What's even worse is that the anime's redesigns don't even attempt to be similar to the cartoonish originals. This, on the other hand, does.

  • yea why wud u reed sum stoopid noval when you can watch da anime and its much more kawaii XD

    This is why we can't have nice things.

    Well, that is thereason this wins, and DEEN fails horribly.Even the all-star cast, which features some of my favorite seiyuu can't do their pile of shit any good.

  • Exactly.

    Although the problem with the "All-star cast" is that they messed up horribly with choosing the right voices for the characters. You've heard this groups' fandisk, right?

    Oh yeah, and I can't wait to see if we'll be buried in negatives once the kiddies get out of school.

  • Absolutely true, most of the voices are horribly unfitting and feel so not suitable for the characters that it is annoying.

    People are going around saying how the voices in this are worse than the voices in the anime.

    I call bullshit.

    Ha, you bet.I wouldn't expect otherwise from the butthurt idiots.

  • To be fair, they cut out almost all of the scenes that would have made the voices unfitting.

    Too bad some of the people who played the SN are goddamn apologists and pessimists.

  • Too bad that people are too retarded to actually take into consideration an opinion that differs from their own.

    Anyone who has played the SN, and is not a complete moron could clearly see what we are saying is true.

    I fail to understand how Ryukishi can stand and watch his own creation get so horribly butchered.

  • Protip:Don't bother trying to get a point through, when your grammar and spelling are as horrible as a first grader.

    Another protip: You can interpret the words of someone however the hell you want to, just to make it seem they are wrong, or said something senseless - that does not make you look cool.

  • Funny my grammar and spelling were fine in that. I wasn't the one attacking anyone, yet you go and do that? Nice job bullying there. i interpreted your comments as basically saying if someone had an opposing opinion they were obviously an idiot. Therefore I said something.

  • Also, I didn't ever say that you were wrong about anything. You two are the ones being defensive. I simply said that your both pushing your opinions around as if they are the truth, and anyone opposing them is obviously dumb. Your both just proving how immature you are and frankly its sad.

  • P.P.S: The comma in your first sentence isn't necessary :)

    It's a complete sentence without it.

  • I don't intend on wasting my time, conversing with someone so retarded, that s/he does not even know the difference between your and you're.

    Also, ever heard of something, called an apostrophe?

    If your grammar and spelling were fine, I wouldn't have pointed out that they sucked now, would I.

  • I do apologize for not spell checking You Tube comments. Their not really super srs bzns to me. If I forget an apostrophe or a comma here and there I don't really care.

    And yes you would have, because you obviously can't bring up rebuttals to a point I've made, so you therefore attack someone for something completely unrelated. Even though what I said was not threatening in the least and was simply an opinion that varies from yours. Seems immature to me.

  • Your "logic" is stupid and you suck at English in overall.There are so many things wrong with what you type and how you type it, that it's embarrassing.

    Then again, ur on da intarnetz XDXD whu shud u watch ur gramer any1 who does so shud get a lyfe XD.

    Really, people like you piss me off the most.You should learn to type before expecting someone to take you seriously.

  • Funny how I don't type like that at all, I at least make sure I have some form of sentence structure and spelling is generally okay. Anything other than that seems silly, why would you write like you are writing an English paper in You Tube comments? You proved my point by proving that if I have a varying opinion you have to attack me for something. Very Childish sir.

  • I proved your point by proving? Nice redundancy there.

    You don't need to capitalize "Childish" in that context, and you can't start a sentence with "Very".

    Why can't I write like I am writing an English paper? I find it quite ironic that you're attacking me for having an opinion.

  • Oh yeah, and "text type".

    I'm guessing by your smugness, your ripoffish "/b/ so randum xD" style mentality, and horrible grasp of the English language, that you're a Brazilian.

  • I'm sorry "They're" not "Their". Did it again, but then again it's 5 A.M.

  • You have no excuse for being retarded.

    You fail.Now shut up and leave.

  • Was not giving an excuse sir. You seem very angry, it's sort of amusing. Is it because I am not taking the internet seriously?

  • also ruky sta sux

  • Judging by your spelling and grammar, you're not even old enough to be in the first grade, son.

  • Again, there was nothing wrong with my grammar or spelling . Could neither of you really just not come up with a valid response to a rebuttal? It's sort of funny that you have to result to attacking a 17 year old girl in order to feel cool.

  • It's not a "Rebuttal". You put up your own opinion about the SN, and you didn't expect it to be criticized by people who dislike DEEN's handling of the series?

    You don't need to put a space before your period, your sentence structure is awkward as hell to read through, not to mention I'm sure I could find all sorts of fancy grammar terminologies to describe your other offenses, but I'll leave it at that.

    So you bring up your age in order to guilt trip me, I assume? Sorry, not gonna work.

  • Well, the novel's introduction wasn't kawaii enough, obviously, why can't you feel for her :'(

  • I... I'm sorry.

    I had no idea how shallow she was. :'(

  • By the way, if by some chance you haven't heard the Drama CD adaptation of the last two chapters of Episode 4 done by the same group (though I highly doubt it) , I'd highly recommend it.

  • Indeed I have.

    It was amazing.

  • ...

    Talk about talent...

  • That's what got me to love this Beatos' voice.

    That being said, I must admit I am still praying for a re-covered Happy Maria with Ohara and Yue.

  • No? The anime introduction was boring too, I just sat trough it as bored like I did the novels introduction. I said the first two chapters of the game because they were the only parts that have thus been boring for me. It doesn't help I cant stand Ryushiki's art suppose.

    I agree there are some thing DEEN are doing that make me extremely confused, however I still enjoy the anime as a different medium.

    As I said, I am more of a Higurahsi fan. Loved both the VN's and Anime.

  • >Ryushiki

    >novels

    >cant

    >there are some thing

    >VN's

    Don't "Sir." me.

    Half(Actually, most) of what you say is repetitive nonsense.

    When you don't care about the Umineko game or anime, don't butt in on the conversation.

    Hell, you are even too stupid to know what sarcasm is.

  • I didn't care if you did? That was a the point. I don't even really care that much about the Umineko anime or game, I was always more of a Higurashi fan, and I was simply saying it's silly how you both talk down on people for having a varying opinion. And all you have both done, is prove that point. You both act as if I am raping the English language with text type.

  • "That was a the point"?

  • OMG...é_è just wonderful

    no word.

    Sublime

  • This is so awesome.

    Beato's voice doesn't really suit her, then again maybe I'm just too used to Ohara's (brilliant) performance...Battler sounds great though, very much like Ono. I can't believe how professional the animation looks. Personally I like DEEN's character designs, but their animation has serious QUALITY issues. If only they could do this scene so well when the time comes...wishful thinking, I'm sure. 5 stars.

  • *w* Ditemi cosa si diconooooooo T.T

  • Beatrice's voice is annoying, Battler's is pretty good, sounds like him.

  • DEEN's artwork is better, but this just has way more emotion.

    I hope DEEN can pull this scene off as well as this did!

  • I don't really get it how people can like Giraffe Beato and Fish Battler, as someone once said.

    I personally detest the anime character designs, since they look nothing like what they are supposed to look and feel like different characters.

  • watch?v=juEkoLXXoxo

    Subtitles by geekodot.

  • Tried to put it as Video response, but didn't seem to work.

  • OH MY FREAKING GOD, this was amazingly breathtaking.

    DEEN's shitty excuse of interpretation can't even begin to compare with this.

  • Seconded.

  • Pretty nice, still like DEEN's work a bit better though.

  • Seriously love the art and animation here. Really love Battler's VA too. Beato's.. ehh not so much. But still..

    I hope DEEN does justice to this scene though. Even though I just spoiled myself mucho, it was worth it.. *Q*

  • Eh, DEEN is still better.

    Pretty nice for a fan's doing, though.

  • oh god, the tears....

    why can't DEEN be this good?

  • This is because DEEN think they can solve everything with a LOLHIGURASHIFACE and drop off whatever the fuck they don't feel like adaptating.

    With DEEN, you can never set the bar too low.

    I hope they get the hint and DO NOT fuck up THAT much at animating this, though the possibility that they don't is close to zero.

  • Looking at DEEN's position at the moment they're going to have to do better, since their DVD sales are really poor and that means no Chiru. Hopefully Ryukishi will pick a different studio if that happens though.

  • DVD sales really poor?

    Not big surprise.

    I really hope he does.

    Really.Don't know if I'd be able to withstand seeing them butcher Chiru, too.

  • Then, let's hope the sales won't increase lol

  • Better than DEEN?

    Not big surprise.

  • Subtitles? :<

  • I may be the only one, but i like DEEN art and voice actors better. But, for a fan project, this is amazing.

  • Im uploading subs now if anyone needs it ^^

  • i want subs! :D ty

  • DO WANT! *Q*

  • Waaaaaaah *O*

    That was soooo epic!! x33

    Best Scene ever x33

  • 素晴らしい!!!

  • 1:02 - 1:10

    Oh what could of been...

    For a fan project this is just amazing...

  • Finally! Pure epicness~~

    I wonder...Who is Beato's VA here?

  • it there a download link?

  • Guys, don't be so pessimist..

    This is the most important scene of EP4; I'm sure DEEN will be faithful to the VN if they don't screw up the pace and make the right cuts in EP4..

    Anyway, This fan-made video was great.. I don't like Beato's seiyuu in this one but the animation is really well done..

  • This is easily superior to anything DEEN will give us, I expect them to really mess this scene up since they totally miss the point of just about everything,

  • Fuck yeah, Finally here.

  • Watch how deen fucks this up. brb weeping.

  • Oh god. So, so epic. This is just...perfect. Completely perfect.

  • Thanks for the upload!

    Is this the full version?

  • Fuck yeah.

  • This is so fucking epic, thank you for making this!

  • ...what episode is this...? or is this from the game..?

  • it's fanmade

    the scene should happen in the last episode of animu (first season i mean)

  • The last scene of EP4.

    This is the fan-made movie, not official anime.

  • it's a fanmade animation of the last minutes of the tea party of ep4

  • Whats the Name of this song in the background?

    Love it <3

  • BMG:  生まれてきてくれてありがとう

    artist: dai

  • Thank you so much I have been waiting for this for a long time! This is beautiful and perfect. Again thank you!

  • 這同人真有愛....

  • 再現度好高...

  • 神!!真的太神了阿@@

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more