thanks for your reply....the point i am trying to make is ,i find it ironic when the muslims try to clame how the bible is corrupted by mentioning the similar type of sources ,but the same doesnt apply to them....
I have never used newspaper articles or TV reports to make judgments about Christianity.
A cursory look at the theology and method salvation proposed in Christianity in enough to show that Christianity does not make sense (at least to me).
That God blamed all of Mankind for a couples sin and was unable to forgive sin so became His Own Son and killed Himself to pay Himself the price of sin (which He had set).
In terms of the corruption of the Bible, the fact that Christendom has not agreed on what the Bible constitutes (the Catholic and Protestant Bibles differing by SEVEN Whole books) is enough of a sign of corruption.
Furthermore look at the Codex Sianaticus (390AD) containing the Epistle of barnabas and the Gospel of the shepherd of Hermes, which are not in any of todays Bibles.
So again the sources of critique are not the same.
You identified the problem here. You made only a 'cursory' inspection of Christian theology.
So, God can just forgive sin, right? He doesn't need the Atonement of Christ? Then why does he need prophets or books? Why not just forgive us all? Fot, you really need to think out the implications of your thoughts before you just go about quoting atheists like Shabir Ally, whose methodology refutes his own belief system.
Prophets are needed to guide the people form amongst them. They need guidance. God does not just forgive, you have to ASK and sincerely REPENT. This is not a concept known to Christians since they live in pompous delusion claiming to have already been atoned for in the merciless slaughter of Gods own Son (God) ...
i am from an arab christian ,and what she wrote is known by the arab world ,but taken as taboo or talking oor menisioning is aganist islamto speak about them.thats why donot you only see dibates with western christians but never with eastern orthodox christians.
Thanks for your comment. What she wrote of course was based upon a Newspaper article about Al-Azhar.
This is not taboo because the people that were talking/discussing about breast-feeding were some Muslim Scholars at Al-Azhar, hence the erroneous fatwa (legal opinion) that was later retracted.
Your point about the debates doesnt make sense, please clarify.
As salamu aleykum. BaarakAllah feek for your effort! Interesting...still gotta watch the next parts. Well, arabic looks more professional and maybe she was just hoping people would take her word for it...being such an "expert" and that they would'nt know what 3azl is:) SubhanAllah, how could Aisha have breastfeeded when she never gave birth anyway?
As salam alikum. your friend seems an Arab Christian and part of an anti-Islamic network! If he is the truth seeker he would be more honest about it. BTW the hadeeth is Sahih (we have nothing to hide or bend the truth). The feeding method is not mentioned, so we could milk it in a cup and offer it.This was a solution to specific problem. The explanation is long.
It is amusing and highly hipocritical your hatred for the natural state of the human male. I suppose you should also require Jesus (pbuh) to shave? Peace, fot
isaiah 7:20 In that day the Lord will use a razor hired from beyond the River -the king of Assyria—to shave your head and the hair of your legs(doesnt say where hes going to stop), and to take off your beards also!(haha is this the job of god?)
Control8806, Yes Jesus(PBUH)is the way and when he left , he sent us the "Anointed one" if u look at the Greek translation it means Mohammed (PBUH) in Arabic, to show the way to God. Peace.
I would like to thank The Christian Iceyyy for representing her faith by abusing and smearing others. Her love and fairness are an example to all. I just feel sorry for her fellow Christians as such an example will only drive many from being like her. Peace, fot
Fotf what are you talking about? Is presenting hadiths abuse and smearing? Perhaps muslims should throw out their hadiths then instead of using them when it suits them...
Of course you know that I am referring to Iceyyy's calling people with the following words as abuse and smearing: "weak man" "NO BALLS" "small man". If you feel that those words are presenting hadith then please do so. As far as iceyyy's and her friends claims go they have been dealt, the abuse is just a continuation of their "method of discussion", which I thank them for. Peace, fot
Iceyyy has removed her response to this 2 part video from part 2 and has now requested me to accept her reponse as a response to part 1. I have done so. Salaam, fot
Yes Sister Yasval, its called the reading-the-roman-transliteration accent. I mean she didnt even know that Fainkihoo is a plural of Nikah. For me that was a clear sign of a lack of Arabic Language understanding. Salaam, fot
Since no one has had any luck getting a Muslim on youtube to denounce the disturbing pattern that shows, once a nation becomes a muslim majority, Islamic theocratic governments become the norm and democracy is seriously curtailed.
So how about addressing this glaring problem with Islam.
If Islamic sharia reigned the world, we would be living in a utopia. Non is more democratic, just, and caring for human rights than Islam. Unfortunately, no example of this exists in the world today.
There are several. But, to make it easy on you, I'll let you define 'theocracy'. Then we'll get into why Islamic theocracy is indeed a 'glaring problem'.
It's funny to read that western converts to Islam like the idea of theocracy. Obviously, you have never had to live under one!
I disagree and I don't like how you have to resort to personal attacks at this point. So it would probably be appreciated by everyone if you can keep from using personal attacks, it makes you look a lot less credible.
he did accept your response a few hours ago now so what are you talking about. you persist to say he did not add your video and he did, and you carry on lying about it, you are the deceiver, sorry
Pure ownage. Great vid. I told her she had this coming. With all of this time they use to deceive, I wonder why they can't simply learn Islam for what it is. It makes no sense.
first you say "cool that you know arabic Mr.gum," and you go on. Mr. Gum refering to me because the word Gum in Arabic is Liban (though that's not why my name is liban) Then you say in the next message "Iiban. it is clear you dont speak arabic," ?? huh? What did you mean my Mr. Gum? ;) and why are you now saying that I don't speak Arabic? lol. you contradict yourself and make up stuff even within our conversation. Get a life!
If I typed too quick for you to understand. In the last post before you accuse me of not knowing arabic you called me Mr. Gum that knows arabic. Gum being "Liban" in Arabic (my name) then in the next message you post to me, you accuse me of not knowing Arabic. Is that all you do? Accuse people that refute you of not knowing the language even though you know they do?
Hi, I speak Arabic and I have read the Alarabia article you mentioned. It seems like you didn't understand it at all.
Did you read the strong refutation by the highest Alazhar authority? that of the Islamic historian Ashraf Abdel-Maksooud? and that of the great Islamic scholar Sheik Jamal Albana? and Sheik Mahar?
Nope you chose to neglect the article's conclusions and invent your own. Very deceptive on your part.
they didn't refute anything, they only said it was just for sahla and no other, if so why they didn't explain that Aisha used it as well (not in person, but she ordered to be done for people to sit with her) ?! why didn't they answer this?
Most Islamic scholars agree that that Hadith is relevant to one single incident. Abou-hodaifa had a young boy (Salim) he adopted as his own son. Islam disallowed adoption afterwards. Then the boy's adoptive mother asked the prophet for a way to keep the boy as family (not Moharam). She was told to breastfeed the boy once and he becomes like her own son.
Since the story is peculiar, because Islam disallowed adoption long time ago, the Hadith is specific to one single instance.
he he he, you moron can't even put a sentence together. And you are mixing up two hathis. The Hadith tabasca talked about is about a little adopted boy, not a grown man. And it was relevant just to that incident.
Your comprehension is weak. No wonder you can't distinguish between what is Jesus's true teachings and what is fabrication by Paul in the Bible. LOL.
little? this little adopted boy was married and he had a beard, would you please read your hadith books before proving for every one that you are the only moron here?!
how can be a little boy married? and hey, the Chapter of Sahih Muslim is Adult breastfeeding -Reda3 Al Kabir رضاع الكبير - NOT young breastfeeding Reda3 Al Sa3'er , you got it? not a little boy not even a boy he was an adult man
That's because they considered everybody over 2 years old (Kabir) and under 2 years of age (Saghir). Are you so desperate to twist the meaning out of context?
Islam disallowed adoption, so that was relevant to Abou-Hodaifa's family alone.
Actually, Sheik Gamal Albana said it was perfectly acceptable back then just not today. So how could the perfect man for all time's be wrong for today? LOL Bett go rethink ev erything mohammad told you to do...
You go figure out who God is. Is he 1 or is he 3? and solve the trinity mathematical mystery: 1 + 1 + 1 = 1. You want to criticize Islam when your entire doctrine doesn't make any sense.
I will comment, on you being a moron. He's calling you a moron, where is the abuse, and smearing? Did he hurt your feelings? Stop crying, and grow up; he didn't insult you harshly, he merely called you, and the Trinity-belief, moronic.
تاسعا: إن كنت لا تعلم شيئا عن اللغة العربية، رجاءً أن تتعلمها قبل أن تدافع عمّا لا تعلم عنه شيئا، فكل ما بالقرآن والحديث من مصائب لن تجدها إلا باللغة العربية، أتمنى لك يوما طيبا، سلام
and is that why you shared christian forums? because they're the only ones that know Arabic in your dilluted mind? Your false claims have been shattered and you just can't come to terms with it. too bad.
you said "and if you don't anything about the arabic language, please learn it before you defend that which you don't know anything about. All that is in the Quran and the Hadith (that are catastrophic) you won't find them but only in the Arabic language. I wish you a good day"
that was a bad translation on your part. Don't you know enough English to translate it properly?
Brother fot already disproved your immature tries at trying to spread lies about Islam. You actually shared links to Christian forums? Not only sites but forums where the likes of you congregate and appease each other. that's weak, very weak.
your brother claim that the hadith is not in the islamic books at all, the links in the christian forums and websites as a guidance to your most famous islamic website al-islam(.)com which is a very good source of islamic catastrophies (hadith & tafsir)
cool that you know arabic Mr.gum, and better you have translated it to your brother fot, because he wouldn't be able to read it for his lack of arabic,and if you really noticed , I have wrote it in English at first then repeated and added it in arabic to prove my theory that Mr. fot doesn't know arabic
sorry for sparking you up like this. You seem unable to control yourself. How about all the false references you gave to ahadith? You're very full of it. And the sad part is that you know it. Stop with the lies and try to express your views without all the nonesense you and your likes make up. how about that for starters?
Saweres, the Sahih Sitta (Six Sahih's) are the six recognised most authentic books of Hadith which is what I was referring to. Of course you being an Arab must already know that, but I suppose it makes it SEEM worse if you claim otherwise, right? Please carry on. Peace, fot
and last thing, ninth: if you don't know any arabic, you better try to learn it before you go on defending what you can't read nor understand , have a nice day , Peace
seventh: this islamic website doesn't provide an english translation of hadith
eighth: the number of hadith differes between arabic and english books because the english translators of hadith were TOO SHY to translate some of the hadiths from the arabic books
sixth: why are you try to deceive people? al-islam(.)com is a very very known famous islamic website, if you opened it you will see the next " Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Ministry of Islamic Affairs, Endowments, Da'wah and Guidance "
which translated : The verse of stoning and of suckling an adult ten times were revealed, and they were (written) on a paper and kept under my bed. When the Messenger of Allah (SAWW.) expired and we were preoccupied with his death, a goat entered and ate away the paper
oh yeah , would you please give me a link of Sunan Ibn Majah translation?!
he he he, "a goat ate away the paper..." have not you heard that's a fabricated hadith? hadith is only our secondary source, the Holy Quran is our first? You Christians got neither. Just some dude, Paul, whom nobody has chosen or elected to be prophet making his own lies and calling them scripture.
so, are you going to burn Sunnan Ibn Majah book now?! and are you very weak in islam to jump into Christianity?! come on , don't run away from your own books, believe in them or throw them into trash :)
Before jumping to some obscure book I have never heard about, let's stick to what is the primary sources of Islam. Holy Quran and Sunna of the prophet (PBUH). I have researched that goat story, and most Islamic scholars laugh at it as a stupid fabrication. Islam too had so many ST Pauls attempting to distort the religion, but their efforts were always in vain. That's why Islam is pure.
It's called Pauline Christianity, because it is based on the teachings of Paul. Paul is somebody who never ever saw, met, talked with, or was in the presence of prophet Jesus (PBUH). But he managed to invent a new religion based on pagan beliefs to mass market it to the pagan Romans.
yes and he convinced nations by the armies under his authority, and the tons of money he was taking from the arabian tribes , like someone I knew, so , would you tell me please how did Paul (PBUH) managed to convince these people then?!
The same way he convinced you to believe that Christianity is what Jesus (PBUH) preached. Jesus, as a messenger of Allah, preached the same message that Abraham and Moses and Mohammed (peace be upon them all) preached. That is Islam. Read your Bible, you won't find one single instance where Jesus claims to be God. But there are plenty where he states to be messenger of God.
The trouble is that you're judging the ancient world with western, modern eyes. A hell of a lot of what was normal in the ancient world would make your hair turn white. Just look at the pharoahs marrying and having kids with their young sisters etc. 200 years ago (or less) the US was doing some pretty fucked up things too.
Absolute rubbish. Muslims use mohammad's behaviour as an excuse for their behaviour today. They claim he was perfect so it must be OK to have sex with kids as long as you 'marry' them. When muslims stop claiming mohammad's behaviour is acceptable by todays standards then mohammad won't be judged by todays standards
Muslim states and the people in them have to obey international law. Those who claim the koran says it's okay to do honour crimes, or whatever else have to face the consequences of their actions.
Little children??? Your entire religion is built around a little girl. Mary (PBUH) was no more than 11 year old when she gave birth to prophet Jesus(PBUH). This is according to your own Christian sources.
And he did it all without resorting to violence and bribery like Mohammad...St Paul (PBUH) is obviously a greater prophet then mohammad. He didnt have to promise his followers rape and theft of their victims before he was listened to.
Who said Paul is a prophet? He doesn't even qualify as a believer. And because of his distortions to prophet Jesus's message, we have morons like yourself still selling lies. Paul is the worst character in history. He truly did the work of Satan.
As to beloved prophet Moahmmed (PBUH), he is prophesied in your own Bible.
Stop sidetracking and explain the trinity concept. I bet you can't. I bet you don't even believe in that nonsense. What do you say? God is 1 or 3? Is 3 equal to 1? Come on mister investigateIslam who can't even put a correct sentence together. Open your eyes to the ultimate truth or shut up and go away.
Aren't you criticizing Islam and calling on people to accept Christianity? Then that's a relevant question. By not answering you starting to look more like a ChikenLady than a Dragonlady.
fourth: Al Arabiya article is about the Fatwa Published by Dr. Ezzat Attya the Professor of Hadith in the Biggest Islamic Uni. in the whole World, Al Azhar Al Sharif , about generalizing adult breastfeeding between muslims
You seemed to be on a roll there--posting hadith number 3424... then 3425, 3426, 3427, ... and then you stopped on 3428! Why didn't you post 3429? And why only post these ahadith on this video rather than the second video? Is it because you were hoping that people would only watch this video and not the second part and see your comments here? Well, in that case, I'll post hadith 3429 which thefotfoundation discussed in the second video!
You seemed to be on a roll there--posting hadith number 3424... then 3425, 3426, 3427, ... and then you stopped on 3428! Why didn't you post 3429? And why only post these ahadith on this video rather than the second video? Is it because you were hoping that people would only watch this video and not the second part and see your comments here? Well, in that case, I'll post hadith 3429 which thefotfoundation discussed in the second video!
"Umm Salama, the wife of Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him), used to say that all wives of Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) disclaimed the idea that one with this type of fosterage (having been suckled after the proper period) should come to them..."
"...and said to 'A'isha: By Allah, we do not find this but a sort of concession given by Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) only for Salim, and no one was ging to be allowed to enter (our houses) with this type of fosterage and we do not subscribe to this view."
first : there are 9 books of Hadith NOT 6, second: the adult breastfeeding is an order from muhammed in an authentic hadith, third: its not a weakness to use arabic links especially its the language of quran, muhammed , allah , and the people in jannah, fourth: who ever claimed that adult breastfeeding is only for sahla? Aisha, muhammed's wife, has used it
you don't have to supplicate to god in arabic. We are to recite the quran in its original arabic because when translated, it ceases to be the word of god.
quran is fake. and corrupt.
do yourself a favor and research on it? and you'll know what i am talking about.
OyonTheAdept 1 year ago
find the truth
jesus save you
islam is nothing more than a mutation of christianity
Christianity is the only true way
SexyManFromIran 3 years ago
how do u come to know that as a fact without a leap of faith?
controlyourownmind 3 years ago
thanks for your reply....the point i am trying to make is ,i find it ironic when the muslims try to clame how the bible is corrupted by mentioning the similar type of sources ,but the same doesnt apply to them....
joints1979 3 years ago
I have never used newspaper articles or TV reports to make judgments about Christianity.
A cursory look at the theology and method salvation proposed in Christianity in enough to show that Christianity does not make sense (at least to me).
That God blamed all of Mankind for a couples sin and was unable to forgive sin so became His Own Son and killed Himself to pay Himself the price of sin (which He had set).
Dont even ask me to talk about the Trinity.
Sources of critique are not the same.
thefotfoundation 3 years ago
In terms of the corruption of the Bible, the fact that Christendom has not agreed on what the Bible constitutes (the Catholic and Protestant Bibles differing by SEVEN Whole books) is enough of a sign of corruption.
Furthermore look at the Codex Sianaticus (390AD) containing the Epistle of barnabas and the Gospel of the shepherd of Hermes, which are not in any of todays Bibles.
So again the sources of critique are not the same.
thefotfoundation 3 years ago
You identified the problem here. You made only a 'cursory' inspection of Christian theology.
So, God can just forgive sin, right? He doesn't need the Atonement of Christ? Then why does he need prophets or books? Why not just forgive us all? Fot, you really need to think out the implications of your thoughts before you just go about quoting atheists like Shabir Ally, whose methodology refutes his own belief system.
LothairOfLorraine 2 years ago
Prophets are needed to guide the people form amongst them. They need guidance. God does not just forgive, you have to ASK and sincerely REPENT. This is not a concept known to Christians since they live in pompous delusion claiming to have already been atoned for in the merciless slaughter of Gods own Son (God) ...
You need to think more deeply
MrGrandDragon 2 years ago
i am from an arab christian ,and what she wrote is known by the arab world ,but taken as taboo or talking oor menisioning is aganist islamto speak about them.thats why donot you only see dibates with western christians but never with eastern orthodox christians.
joints1979 3 years ago
Thanks for your comment. What she wrote of course was based upon a Newspaper article about Al-Azhar.
This is not taboo because the people that were talking/discussing about breast-feeding were some Muslim Scholars at Al-Azhar, hence the erroneous fatwa (legal opinion) that was later retracted.
Your point about the debates doesnt make sense, please clarify.
thefotfoundation 3 years ago
As salamu aleykum. BaarakAllah feek for your effort! Interesting...still gotta watch the next parts. Well, arabic looks more professional and maybe she was just hoping people would take her word for it...being such an "expert" and that they would'nt know what 3azl is:) SubhanAllah, how could Aisha have breastfeeded when she never gave birth anyway?
ummubasma 3 years ago
not by Eisha but her sister .any way this is not the main view
binshamak 3 years ago
As salam alikum. your friend seems an Arab Christian and part of an anti-Islamic network! If he is the truth seeker he would be more honest about it. BTW the hadeeth is Sahih (we have nothing to hide or bend the truth). The feeding method is not mentioned, so we could milk it in a cup and offer it.This was a solution to specific problem. The explanation is long.
binshamak 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
SHAVE!!!!!!!!!!!
Neutralangelofwisdom 4 years ago
It is amusing and highly hipocritical your hatred for the natural state of the human male. I suppose you should also require Jesus (pbuh) to shave? Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it was an advice,and Jesus looked good with a beard...you look like a monkey
Neutralangelofwisdom 4 years ago
neutral... has god for doing that
isaiah 7:20 In that day the Lord will use a razor hired from beyond the River -the king of Assyria—to shave your head and the hair of your legs(doesnt say where hes going to stop), and to take off your beards also!(haha is this the job of god?)
ikweetdani 4 years ago
Neutralangelofwisdom, A shaved man looks like a featherless chicken.
binshamak 4 years ago 3
Neutralangelofwisdom , did Jesus (PBUH) shave? The man is following the footsteps of the prophets.
binshamak 4 years ago
islam is the only way to save our self
terimaankichod 4 years ago
thanks for the wonderful words!
jesus is the way
Control8806 4 years ago
Control8806, Yes Jesus(PBUH)is the way and when he left , he sent us the "Anointed one" if u look at the Greek translation it means Mohammed (PBUH) in Arabic, to show the way to God. Peace.
binshamak 4 years ago
confess your sins to our lord jesus christ and beg for forgivness for your betrayal or face the path of judas. i hope you dont
Control8806 4 years ago
icceyyyyy is so dumb! hahahah.
alisar87 4 years ago
Are you filming from a pharmacy?
dankwilliams 4 years ago 2
lol, yes, after hours of course. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
im interested to know, can u plz tell me what it says about this contraception method? thx
khaleda11 4 years ago
I would like to thank The Christian Iceyyy for representing her faith by abusing and smearing others. Her love and fairness are an example to all. I just feel sorry for her fellow Christians as such an example will only drive many from being like her. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
Fotf what are you talking about? Is presenting hadiths abuse and smearing? Perhaps muslims should throw out their hadiths then instead of using them when it suits them...
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
Of course you know that I am referring to Iceyyy's calling people with the following words as abuse and smearing: "weak man" "NO BALLS" "small man". If you feel that those words are presenting hadith then please do so. As far as iceyyy's and her friends claims go they have been dealt, the abuse is just a continuation of their "method of discussion", which I thank them for. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
iceyyy
Why did you block me? LOL! LOL!
I did not post anything to offend you.
I guess some people can't handle being refuted several times in one day.
iceyyy follow the Prophet Jesus's (P) example and be honest. The truth shall set you free.
Peace
swordfishabe 4 years ago
Iceyyy has removed her response to this 2 part video from part 2 and has now requested me to accept her reponse as a response to part 1. I have done so. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
Iceyyy is not even arab I think, she got an accent when she speaks
YASVAL 4 years ago
Yes Sister Yasval, its called the reading-the-roman-transliteration accent. I mean she didnt even know that Fainkihoo is a plural of Nikah. For me that was a clear sign of a lack of Arabic Language understanding. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
The fotfoundation,
Since no one has had any luck getting a Muslim on youtube to denounce the disturbing pattern that shows, once a nation becomes a muslim majority, Islamic theocratic governments become the norm and democracy is seriously curtailed.
So how about addressing this glaring problem with Islam.
brotherjupiter 4 years ago
If Islamic sharia reigned the world, we would be living in a utopia. Non is more democratic, just, and caring for human rights than Islam. Unfortunately, no example of this exists in the world today.
tabasca36 4 years ago
If the majority want a theocracy, that's democracy... I suppose.
soylentgreen80 4 years ago
Your assuming that there are any Muslim theocracies currently and that I agree that theocracy is a glaring problem.
I see why you may have had that problem with the denouncements.
thefotfoundation 3 years ago
There are several. But, to make it easy on you, I'll let you define 'theocracy'. Then we'll get into why Islamic theocracy is indeed a 'glaring problem'.
It's funny to read that western converts to Islam like the idea of theocracy. Obviously, you have never had to live under one!
LothairOfLorraine 2 years ago
Did christianity teach you to speak like that, this is pathetic.if you want to give a good image of christianity, try to use some good manners
YASVAL 4 years ago
it is obviously on part 2. you knew his response was in 2 parts, stop making excuses
YASVAL 4 years ago
You do realize that Allah and the other fictitious characters spoken of in the Koran have been disproved by 99% of the intelligent World?
Feel free to join reality.
brotherjupiter 4 years ago
Hello,
I disagree and I don't like how you have to resort to personal attacks at this point. So it would probably be appreciated by everyone if you can keep from using personal attacks, it makes you look a lot less credible.
frosama 4 years ago
please watch the reply, youtube(.)com/watch?v=X_WKeLXamYE
Saweres 4 years ago
mashAllah very informative video brother Imran. Selaam Alaykum
powa2live 4 years ago
Wow this video was a good response to your comments and your circles corruption videos. Thanks friend.
isalhia 4 years ago
Wow great response! Mashallah good work brother.
isalhia 4 years ago
BarakhAllahFiKum. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
he did accept your response a few hours ago now so what are you talking about. you persist to say he did not add your video and he did, and you carry on lying about it, you are the deceiver, sorry
YASVAL 4 years ago
Pure ownage. Great vid. I told her she had this coming. With all of this time they use to deceive, I wonder why they can't simply learn Islam for what it is. It makes no sense.
BonsaiSky 4 years ago
BarakhAllaHFiKum Bro. Salaam, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
Lots of lies about islam that people come out with
mannypatel1 4 years ago
the only lies come from muslims.
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
first you say "cool that you know arabic Mr.gum," and you go on. Mr. Gum refering to me because the word Gum in Arabic is Liban (though that's not why my name is liban) Then you say in the next message "Iiban. it is clear you dont speak arabic," ?? huh? What did you mean my Mr. Gum? ;) and why are you now saying that I don't speak Arabic? lol. you contradict yourself and make up stuff even within our conversation. Get a life!
libanlibanliban 4 years ago
If I typed too quick for you to understand. In the last post before you accuse me of not knowing arabic you called me Mr. Gum that knows arabic. Gum being "Liban" in Arabic (my name) then in the next message you post to me, you accuse me of not knowing Arabic. Is that all you do? Accuse people that refute you of not knowing the language even though you know they do?
libanlibanliban 4 years ago
Hi, I speak Arabic and I have read the Alarabia article you mentioned. It seems like you didn't understand it at all.
Did you read the strong refutation by the highest Alazhar authority? that of the Islamic historian Ashraf Abdel-Maksooud? and that of the great Islamic scholar Sheik Jamal Albana? and Sheik Mahar?
Nope you chose to neglect the article's conclusions and invent your own. Very deceptive on your part.
tabasca36 4 years ago
they didn't refute anything, they only said it was just for sahla and no other, if so why they didn't explain that Aisha used it as well (not in person, but she ordered to be done for people to sit with her) ?! why didn't they answer this?
Saweres 4 years ago
Most Islamic scholars agree that that Hadith is relevant to one single incident. Abou-hodaifa had a young boy (Salim) he adopted as his own son. Islam disallowed adoption afterwards. Then the boy's adoptive mother asked the prophet for a way to keep the boy as family (not Moharam). She was told to breastfeed the boy once and he becomes like her own son.
Since the story is peculiar, because Islam disallowed adoption long time ago, the Hadith is specific to one single instance.
tabasca36 4 years ago
young boy??? according to Hadith, that he has a beard and was at have seen Badr, and he was married to her husband's niece!!!!
Saweres 4 years ago
he he he, you moron can't even put a sentence together. And you are mixing up two hathis. The Hadith tabasca talked about is about a little adopted boy, not a grown man. And it was relevant just to that incident.
Your comprehension is weak. No wonder you can't distinguish between what is Jesus's true teachings and what is fabrication by Paul in the Bible. LOL.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
little? this little adopted boy was married and he had a beard, would you please read your hadith books before proving for every one that you are the only moron here?!
Saweres 4 years ago
MK is right, Salim was an adopted boy. Read my explanation above. Peace.
tabasca36 4 years ago
how can be a little boy married? and hey, the Chapter of Sahih Muslim is Adult breastfeeding -Reda3 Al Kabir رضاع الكبير - NOT young breastfeeding Reda3 Al Sa3'er , you got it? not a little boy not even a boy he was an adult man
Saweres 4 years ago
That's because they considered everybody over 2 years old (Kabir) and under 2 years of age (Saghir). Are you so desperate to twist the meaning out of context?
Islam disallowed adoption, so that was relevant to Abou-Hodaifa's family alone.
tabasca36 4 years ago
Actually, Sheik Gamal Albana said it was perfectly acceptable back then just not today. So how could the perfect man for all time's be wrong for today? LOL Bett go rethink ev erything mohammad told you to do...
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
You go figure out who God is. Is he 1 or is he 3? and solve the trinity mathematical mystery: 1 + 1 + 1 = 1. You want to criticize Islam when your entire doctrine doesn't make any sense.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
moslimkid you make an awful lot of assumptions
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
Please, correct my misconceptions. LOL. You can't. Trinity is a moronic stupid concept that makes no sense. Jesus never claimed such absurdities.
I used to be deluded like yourself until I embraced the truth. Islam is the only way to eternal salvation.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
You are such a good muslim kid...you really show islam in a good light lol. I wonder if the muslims will comment on your abuse and smearing...
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
I will comment, on you being a moron. He's calling you a moron, where is the abuse, and smearing? Did he hurt your feelings? Stop crying, and grow up; he didn't insult you harshly, he merely called you, and the Trinity-belief, moronic.
Daboomcroo 4 years ago
تاسعا: إن كنت لا تعلم شيئا عن اللغة العربية، رجاءً أن تتعلمها قبل أن تدافع عمّا لا تعلم عنه شيئا، فكل ما بالقرآن والحديث من مصائب لن تجدها إلا باللغة العربية، أتمنى لك يوما طيبا، سلام
Saweres 4 years ago
and is that why you shared christian forums? because they're the only ones that know Arabic in your dilluted mind? Your false claims have been shattered and you just can't come to terms with it. too bad.
libanlibanliban 4 years ago
as far as translating "ninth"
you said "and if you don't anything about the arabic language, please learn it before you defend that which you don't know anything about. All that is in the Quran and the Hadith (that are catastrophic) you won't find them but only in the Arabic language. I wish you a good day"
that was a bad translation on your part. Don't you know enough English to translate it properly?
libanlibanliban 4 years ago
Brother fot already disproved your immature tries at trying to spread lies about Islam. You actually shared links to Christian forums? Not only sites but forums where the likes of you congregate and appease each other. that's weak, very weak.
libanlibanliban 4 years ago
your brother claim that the hadith is not in the islamic books at all, the links in the christian forums and websites as a guidance to your most famous islamic website al-islam(.)com which is a very good source of islamic catastrophies (hadith & tafsir)
Saweres 4 years ago
actually that was the deception on 'brother fot's' part
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
cool that you know arabic Mr.gum, and better you have translated it to your brother fot, because he wouldn't be able to read it for his lack of arabic,and if you really noticed , I have wrote it in English at first then repeated and added it in arabic to prove my theory that Mr. fot doesn't know arabic
Saweres 4 years ago
sorry for sparking you up like this. You seem unable to control yourself. How about all the false references you gave to ahadith? You're very full of it. And the sad part is that you know it. Stop with the lies and try to express your views without all the nonesense you and your likes make up. how about that for starters?
libanlibanliban 4 years ago
why didn't you try to tell your brother Mr.fot that there NINE books of Hadith NOT Six ??? or do you want me to write them for you in arabic?! lol
Saweres 4 years ago
Saweres, the Sahih Sitta (Six Sahih's) are the six recognised most authentic books of Hadith which is what I was referring to. Of course you being an Arab must already know that, but I suppose it makes it SEEM worse if you claim otherwise, right? Please carry on. Peace, fot
thefotfoundation 4 years ago
and last thing, ninth: if you don't know any arabic, you better try to learn it before you go on defending what you can't read nor understand , have a nice day , Peace
Saweres 4 years ago
seventh: this islamic website doesn't provide an english translation of hadith
eighth: the number of hadith differes between arabic and english books because the english translators of hadith were TOO SHY to translate some of the hadiths from the arabic books
Saweres 4 years ago
sixth: why are you try to deceive people? al-islam(.)com is a very very known famous islamic website, if you opened it you will see the next " Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Ministry of Islamic Affairs, Endowments, Da'wah and Guidance "
Saweres 4 years ago
fifth: hadith(.)al-islam(.)com/Display/Display(.)asp?hnum=1934&doc=5
which translated : The verse of stoning and of suckling an adult ten times were revealed, and they were (written) on a paper and kept under my bed. When the Messenger of Allah (SAWW.) expired and we were preoccupied with his death, a goat entered and ate away the paper
oh yeah , would you please give me a link of Sunan Ibn Majah translation?!
Saweres 4 years ago
he he he, "a goat ate away the paper..." have not you heard that's a fabricated hadith? hadith is only our secondary source, the Holy Quran is our first? You Christians got neither. Just some dude, Paul, whom nobody has chosen or elected to be prophet making his own lies and calling them scripture.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
so, are you going to burn Sunnan Ibn Majah book now?! and are you very weak in islam to jump into Christianity?! come on , don't run away from your own books, believe in them or throw them into trash :)
Saweres 4 years ago
Before jumping to some obscure book I have never heard about, let's stick to what is the primary sources of Islam. Holy Quran and Sunna of the prophet (PBUH). I have researched that goat story, and most Islamic scholars laugh at it as a stupid fabrication. Islam too had so many ST Pauls attempting to distort the religion, but their efforts were always in vain. That's why Islam is pure.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
really? Paul lived more 6 centuries to fabricate the islamic books, that was wonderful LOL, are you for real?
Saweres 4 years ago
It went right over your head. You have got a comprehension problem.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
Christians dont call Paul a prophet, NOBODY elected or chose mohammad to be a prophet (except maybe Satan)
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
do you see Satan enjoining good and forbid evil?!
YASVAL 4 years ago
In the koran? yes he does...but he makes good evil and evil good THAT is a sign of satan!
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
where exactly?
YASVAL 4 years ago
It's called Pauline Christianity, because it is based on the teachings of Paul. Paul is somebody who never ever saw, met, talked with, or was in the presence of prophet Jesus (PBUH). But he managed to invent a new religion based on pagan beliefs to mass market it to the pagan Romans.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
yes and he convinced nations by the armies under his authority, and the tons of money he was taking from the arabian tribes , like someone I knew, so , would you tell me please how did Paul (PBUH) managed to convince these people then?!
Saweres 4 years ago
The same way he convinced you to believe that Christianity is what Jesus (PBUH) preached. Jesus, as a messenger of Allah, preached the same message that Abraham and Moses and Mohammed (peace be upon them all) preached. That is Islam. Read your Bible, you won't find one single instance where Jesus claims to be God. But there are plenty where he states to be messenger of God.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
Jesus never said have sex with little kids, neither did Abraham or Moses...Who is the odd one out here? MOHAMMAD molester of little children.
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
The trouble is that you're judging the ancient world with western, modern eyes. A hell of a lot of what was normal in the ancient world would make your hair turn white. Just look at the pharoahs marrying and having kids with their young sisters etc. 200 years ago (or less) the US was doing some pretty fucked up things too.
soylentgreen80 4 years ago
Absolute rubbish. Muslims use mohammad's behaviour as an excuse for their behaviour today. They claim he was perfect so it must be OK to have sex with kids as long as you 'marry' them. When muslims stop claiming mohammad's behaviour is acceptable by todays standards then mohammad won't be judged by todays standards
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
You are out of bounds you ingrate Arab Christian.
tabasca36 4 years ago
Muslim states and the people in them have to obey international law. Those who claim the koran says it's okay to do honour crimes, or whatever else have to face the consequences of their actions.
soylentgreen80 4 years ago
Little children??? Your entire religion is built around a little girl. Mary (PBUH) was no more than 11 year old when she gave birth to prophet Jesus(PBUH). This is according to your own Christian sources.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
And he did it all without resorting to violence and bribery like Mohammad...St Paul (PBUH) is obviously a greater prophet then mohammad. He didnt have to promise his followers rape and theft of their victims before he was listened to.
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
Who said Paul is a prophet? He doesn't even qualify as a believer. And because of his distortions to prophet Jesus's message, we have morons like yourself still selling lies. Paul is the worst character in history. He truly did the work of Satan.
As to beloved prophet Moahmmed (PBUH), he is prophesied in your own Bible.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
or calling people morons, I wonder if that counts as abuse and smeearing?
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
Stop sidetracking and explain the trinity concept. I bet you can't. I bet you don't even believe in that nonsense. What do you say? God is 1 or 3? Is 3 equal to 1? Come on mister investigateIslam who can't even put a correct sentence together. Open your eyes to the ultimate truth or shut up and go away.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
How am I sidetracking? The trinity was never under discussion as far as im concerned.
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
Aren't you criticizing Islam and calling on people to accept Christianity? Then that's a relevant question. By not answering you starting to look more like a ChikenLady than a Dragonlady.
MoslimKid 4 years ago
fourth: Al Arabiya article is about the Fatwa Published by Dr. Ezzat Attya the Professor of Hadith in the Biggest Islamic Uni. in the whole World, Al Azhar Al Sharif , about generalizing adult breastfeeding between muslims
Saweres 4 years ago
It's amazing how people will lie just to go against Islam...
IslamIs1st 4 years ago
iceyyy,
Rather this video exposed your foolishness!
Peace,
- QDJMan
QDJMan 4 years ago
iceyyy,
You seemed to be on a roll there--posting hadith number 3424... then 3425, 3426, 3427, ... and then you stopped on 3428! Why didn't you post 3429? And why only post these ahadith on this video rather than the second video? Is it because you were hoping that people would only watch this video and not the second part and see your comments here? Well, in that case, I'll post hadith 3429 which thefotfoundation discussed in the second video!
QDJMan 4 years ago
iceyyy,
You seemed to be on a roll there--posting hadith number 3424... then 3425, 3426, 3427, ... and then you stopped on 3428! Why didn't you post 3429? And why only post these ahadith on this video rather than the second video? Is it because you were hoping that people would only watch this video and not the second part and see your comments here? Well, in that case, I'll post hadith 3429 which thefotfoundation discussed in the second video!
QDJMan 4 years ago
Sahih Muslim, Book 008, Number 3429:
"Umm Salama, the wife of Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him), used to say that all wives of Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) disclaimed the idea that one with this type of fosterage (having been suckled after the proper period) should come to them..."
QDJMan 4 years ago
"...and said to 'A'isha: By Allah, we do not find this but a sort of concession given by Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) only for Salim, and no one was ging to be allowed to enter (our houses) with this type of fosterage and we do not subscribe to this view."
Peace,
- QDJMan
QDJMan 4 years ago
Naughty Salama, disagreeing with mohammad AND Aisha
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
Dragonlady66,
Your comment proves your lack of understanding this hadith. This hadith has nothing to do with Salama, but rather the MOTHER OF SALAMA!
Peace,
- QDJMan
QDJMan 4 years ago
first : there are 9 books of Hadith NOT 6, second: the adult breastfeeding is an order from muhammed in an authentic hadith, third: its not a weakness to use arabic links especially its the language of quran, muhammed , allah , and the people in jannah, fourth: who ever claimed that adult breastfeeding is only for sahla? Aisha, muhammed's wife, has used it
Saweres 4 years ago
If she DIDNT post to an Arabic website, you would claim she only links to NON AUTHENTIC english hadiths. Arabic is the only language allah speaks.
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
well...Allah speaks every language, do you think he spoke Arabic to Moses or Jesus?
IslamIs1st 4 years ago
Allah never spoke to Jesus or Moses. If allah can speak every language, why do you HAVE to pray in Arabic?
Dragonlady66 4 years ago
Dragonlady66,
Allah DID speak to Moses.
Peace,
- QDJMan
QDJMan 4 years ago
Dragonlady66,
Allah DID speak to Moses (peace be upon him).
Peace,
- QDJMan
QDJMan 4 years ago
because it is a pure language
YASVAL 4 years ago
you don't have to supplicate to god in arabic. We are to recite the quran in its original arabic because when translated, it ceases to be the word of god.
solls2 4 years ago
i love when people exploit themselves by showing how ignorant they are. hahahah
ok718 4 years ago
lol, iceyy thinks she's clever. she thinks she could quote from a newspaper and get away with it. lol, people like her (on youtube) crack me up
ok718 4 years ago