"I'm not quite sure what we're supposed to do...what we're supposed to say, but I can see it's not okay." Who but Bowie or Dylan could write have written a verse that? I guess no one.
when I first heard this, I remember my lips stayed open in wondrous awe from the first to the last note.the entire song felt as if it lasted 2 seconds and as if it had snatched me into a rush to somewhere uncontrollable and of unknown beauty. I was 14 then and I knew not one word of english. but his oblique sincerity was all I was on about, then and ...now.
I've always loved this since I first heard the Space Oddity album - one of the most beautiful and literate love songs ever composed and yet it's hardly ever played on any medium unless your a Bowie fan.
30 years ago I was introduced to this song by someone I loved ... I wrote the words onto a piece of paper because I thought it was like a poem and the other day I rediscovered it and have rediscovered Bowie singing it here for the first time since then ..when I was 18 .. it means a lot to me ..
The one with a HLAFO probably doesn't like China Girl. I mean, what's the point getting involved with a China girl? When she's like 29 she's going to look 50, according to the one with a HLAFO.
This song still has the ability to make me cry, David Bowie is such a genius he can write anythinig he wants. One of the greatest artists ever. I love youxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
the harry potter fan must be going nuts person is stupid, my name is Hermione and I am named after the actress and the person in the book by P.G wodehouse. hermione isnt just a name used by harry potter fans
@310sucks Stfu you cockhead... Learn about music before you have a big fucking mouth... Yes Bowie made absolute crap music, but this was in his later productions.. The first few albums he made are generally considered to have made quite some impact on society en the world of music... Listen to 'Cygnet Commitee' a few times, analyze the texts and tell us what you think of Bowie then..
@310sucks Stfu you cockhead... Learn about music before you have a big fucking mouth... Yes Bowie made absolute crap music, but this was only in his later productions.. The first few albums he made are generally considered to have made quite some impact on society en the world of music... Listen to 'Cygnet Committee' a few times, analyze the texts, the way he plays around with his voice and tell us what you think of Bowie then..
Hi guys, This song is really meaning a lot to me at the moment. I've had a 'break up' and i need this right now to seal the gaping wound. She was hermione like the song. and like the song i feel the sweet harmony it projects. Today is a new day now and yesterday was just school and such. Now i look at the snow and see her face....life is new ...life is special.. LU...XX JR
Hi guys, This song is really meaning a lot to me at the moment. I've had a 'break up' and i need this right now to seal the gaping wound. She was hermione like the song. and like the song i feel the sweet harmony it projects. Today is a new day now and yesterday was just school and such. Now i look at the snow and see her face....life is new ...life is special.. LU...XX JRT
@DanBlabbers - People have been listen to the old ricky gervais radio tapes - where he plays this song like every week - thats how i found out about it atleast
God, that last chord - I came up with it by accident one day and was looking for uses of it in songs. It's a really dissonant chord, leaving you feeling like the song isn't over yet...
Apples and oranges Chimps and baboons Man-moths and munchies and gormless cartoons Round heads and weirdness And foodage and ants Ghosts, flies and condoms And tits, cocks and Kants Manchester, England A horse in a house A congress tart, pieclets And a monkey-balled mouse Wonder, amazement, Depression and spleen And wet trouser sickdays In Pilkie convene
Only a Bowie fan would have heard this song....whidh is a shame because it is the most beautiful love song I have ever heard - truly Bowie at his best.......Thank you for putting it on :)
Oh well, he's got Iman now so i'm sure he's very happy. I bet Hermione regrets ever leaving him though! Serves her right, you'd have to be crazy NOT to want him
THE most amazing Bowie song.
ellenmeilee 4 days ago
"I'm not quite sure what we're supposed to do...what we're supposed to say, but I can see it's not okay." Who but Bowie or Dylan could write have written a verse that? I guess no one.
chingchangchongfly 1 week ago
Ricky, Karl, and Steve brought me here too!
christopherjames2011 2 weeks ago
when I first heard this, I remember my lips stayed open in wondrous awe from the first to the last note.the entire song felt as if it lasted 2 seconds and as if it had snatched me into a rush to somewhere uncontrollable and of unknown beauty. I was 14 then and I knew not one word of english. but his oblique sincerity was all I was on about, then and ...now.
hirogerthisisme 2 weeks ago
head like a fucking orange
russgrant100 3 weeks ago
I've always loved this since I first heard the Space Oddity album - one of the most beautiful and literate love songs ever composed and yet it's hardly ever played on any medium unless your a Bowie fan.
PHOENIXIMMORTAL777 4 weeks ago
C'mon guys, this song is older than harry potter
TheCufremartin 1 month ago
30 years ago I was introduced to this song by someone I loved ... I wrote the words onto a piece of paper because I thought it was like a poem and the other day I rediscovered it and have rediscovered Bowie singing it here for the first time since then ..when I was 18 .. it means a lot to me ..
djpursg 1 month ago
love this !
manicContrebasse 1 month ago
Ooh, Chimpanzee that!
tenaciouszep 3 months ago 4
'They say your life is going very well,
They say you sparkle like a different girl'
i love that lyric
Sabbath12345 3 months ago
hermione was beautiful she was one of bowie's first loves and broke his heart.
dlfunky1 3 months ago
Gervais has an extraordinary taste in music, hasn't he?
DasNutellamaedchen 4 months ago 6
Here because of Ricky Gervais as well >.>
ohsheeshyallblah 4 months ago 11
Harry Potter Hermione is hot. I'd tap that booty.
melovetorun 4 months ago
I was looking for a DHr story and this appeared. o.o
sourpatchkid2117 5 months ago
Wow, I love this song, his voice, the acustic sound, the lyrics... So good Daves!
ferdinandsouz 5 months ago
I CANT believe Ricky, Steve and Karl got us all here like this. lol
TheShawnSolo 5 months ago 49
@TheShawnSolo True...until now I'd only heard the last 2 seconds lol :)
cuntylishus 5 months ago
@TheShawnSolo yep ;D
helloman2332 1 month ago
Im not the only one that was sent here by ricky gervais then
Mikeyvts 6 months ago 9
@TheBumblingIdiots Hmm, that sounds familiar.
liwiathan 6 months ago
The one with a HLAFO probably doesn't like China Girl. I mean, what's the point getting involved with a China girl? When she's like 29 she's going to look 50, according to the one with a HLAFO.
Rosvolainen 6 months ago
@Rosvolainen Thinking about it, in this context I guess it would be more appropriate to call him the one with HLACM (hair like a China man).
Rosvolainen 6 months ago
@TheBumblingIdiots Oh?
What does he write?
liwiathan 6 months ago
I wish he could write a letter to me :'(
davidbowierocksilove 6 months ago in playlist Mix of Favorite Songs :)
was this song after they broke up?
LestHeBecomeAmonster 6 months ago
Bowie has a voice to match his beauty.
MissDeliza 7 months ago
This song is beautiful.
I regret those 14 years of my life that I didn't give Bowie a chance.
ytsirkmai483 7 months ago 2
This song is too much beautiful to last only 2.35
CeleCarota 7 months ago
@CeleCarota You're absolutely right. We just have to settle with that by listening to it on repeat
FillTheGaps 7 months ago
@CeleCarota keep going back to the beginning start it again if you do it enough pleasure would last an eternity
just feeling melancholic tonight
fatterelvis 7 months ago
you can really tell Syd Barrett inspired him
GilmourRelic 7 months ago 3
One if the best ways of spending 2:35 mins of my life I can think of.
jcfw 7 months ago 2
Ricky Gervais.
logic3d 8 months ago 7
Combines my two big loves. Harry Potter and David Bowie :)
dano0zZz 8 months ago
I found this song and "price I pay" by Billy Bragg from listening to the old xfm shows
NZbroncos 8 months ago
@NZbroncos Ditto, although stay away from 'a union is a fine and glorious political system'.
BGH122 8 months ago
This song still has the ability to make me cry, David Bowie is such a genius he can write anythinig he wants. One of the greatest artists ever. I love youxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
baby1cham 8 months ago 2
the harry potter fan must be going nuts person is stupid, my name is Hermione and I am named after the actress and the person in the book by P.G wodehouse. hermione isnt just a name used by harry potter fans
actingcrazy123 8 months ago
@actingcrazy123 yea, fuck off harry potter nerds.
deltansix 7 months ago
@deltansix Grow up.
liwiathan 6 months ago
@actingcrazy123 Who is P.G. Wodehouse?
What actress?
liwiathan 6 months ago
Yep, I also know of this song thanks to Ricky Gervais.
ChristopherDone 9 months ago
who would have thought bowie was such a fan of harry potter
TheDami1969 9 months ago
@TheDami1969 This song was referenced in a Harry Potter fanstory.
liwiathan 6 months ago
But did you ever call my name
Just by mistake?
I'm not quite sure what I'm supposed to do
So I'll just write some love to you
TuSeiSpecialee 9 months ago 2
I met Hermione.
eyfatboy 10 months ago
No wonder Gervais loves it. Sounds like the sort of crap David Brent would write.
310sucks 10 months ago
@310sucks yes you suck, but in a pink fluffy bunny kind of way. In a poor poor pathetic ignorant way. So we cry for your sad life
BaalZobel 10 months ago
@310sucks Stfu you cockhead... Learn about music before you have a big fucking mouth... Yes Bowie made absolute crap music, but this was in his later productions.. The first few albums he made are generally considered to have made quite some impact on society en the world of music... Listen to 'Cygnet Commitee' a few times, analyze the texts and tell us what you think of Bowie then..
TTFLS 10 months ago
@310sucks Stfu you cockhead... Learn about music before you have a big fucking mouth... Yes Bowie made absolute crap music, but this was only in his later productions.. The first few albums he made are generally considered to have made quite some impact on society en the world of music... Listen to 'Cygnet Committee' a few times, analyze the texts, the way he plays around with his voice and tell us what you think of Bowie then..
TTFLS 10 months ago
@310sucks I'm just gonna guess that was a very successful troll. Any other assumption causes painful cognitive dissonance.
skabbonica 10 months ago
Karl, you're an idiot, play a record.
ZefWaddy 11 months ago 8
As Ricky Gervais would say, the "beautiest" of songs ever written
baljot1231 11 months ago
hermione was gorgeous.not much but she has something that make her interesting.may be her cat eyes
kjsh987 11 months ago
@kjsh987 "gorgeous.not" :)
Pastor9764 11 months ago
1.think of your crush
2.make a heart with your hands
3.then kiss your hands while still making the heart
4.then put the heart where your real heart is
5.tomorrow your crush will ask you out
6.this will only work if you post this to your favorite love song
smotherboy001 1 year ago
@smotherboy001 7. then fuck off
FourGirlRumba 10 months ago
The Harry Potter fan must be going nuts!
liwiathan 1 year ago 45
@liwiathan lol!
THEprincessFirefly 6 months ago
@THEprincessFirefly Thanks! A lot of "people" are saying mean things.
liwiathan 6 months ago
@liwiathan welcome! it was a very funny comment
THEprincessFirefly 6 months ago
@liwiathan I'M GOING FUCKING NUTS!!!
xSobhan 6 months ago
I was on an Outward Bound program and they leave you on a small island for 3 days.Anyway,I sang this song aloud to my girl back home.
MrThinwhiteduke1 1 year ago
I love you Banafsheh, and I miss you so much.
mrtyles 1 year ago
this was me and my girls fav song we split up 10 years ago stayd frends then she passd away three months ago age 42 this is for my burn xx
jupitorman 1 year ago
@jupitorman .... Sorry to hear that fella.
GUNNAHZ70 1 year ago
@jupitorman i am so sorry... I don't know what else to say...
ProfToke420 11 months ago
He has done so very much, but did he ever write anything so beautiful and heartfelt?
sfb211 1 year ago 2
LMAO Does anyone else see this as Ron singing about Hermione? hahahahaha
iDeathEater 1 year ago
@iDeathEater
no because david bowie rules but harry potter sucks (realllllly sucks!) :P
jamesgerrardart 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hi guys, This song is really meaning a lot to me at the moment. I've had a 'break up' and i need this right now to seal the gaping wound. She was hermione like the song. and like the song i feel the sweet harmony it projects. Today is a new day now and yesterday was just school and such. Now i look at the snow and see her face....life is new ...life is special.. LU...XX JR
Katerinaa212 1 year ago
Hi guys, This song is really meaning a lot to me at the moment. I've had a 'break up' and i need this right now to seal the gaping wound. She was hermione like the song. and like the song i feel the sweet harmony it projects. Today is a new day now and yesterday was just school and such. Now i look at the snow and see her face....life is new ...life is special.. LU...XX JRT
Katerinaa212 1 year ago
Can the world fall?
Pcoxy123 1 year ago 5
@Pcoxy123 yes
Katerinaa212 1 year ago
Head like a fucking orange.
ArtypNk 1 year ago 197
@ArtypNk Round headed mank
Ehinesnwi 11 months ago
@ArtypNk ?
DanBlabbers 9 months ago
@DanBlabbers
Reference to Ricky Gervais show. Karl Pilkington has a "head like a fucking orange". It's an inside humour.
ArtypNk 9 months ago
@ArtypNk What does this have to do with this song besides the fact Ricky Gervais is a fan of Bowie?
DanBlabbers 9 months ago
@DanBlabbers
Nothing. It's just an obscure inside humour. Ignore it.
ArtypNk 9 months ago
@DanBlabbers - People have been listen to the old ricky gervais radio tapes - where he plays this song like every week - thats how i found out about it atleast
dan11009 9 months ago 2
@ArtypNk Love it XD
silentben1234 8 months ago
@ArtypNk whats he got to do with it?
HaydnFitzsimons 6 months ago
@ArtypNk Those three made me love Bowie.
Briteeesh 6 months ago 6
@ArtypNk
THIS IS TOO fking awesome!!!!!!!
TheShawnSolo 5 months ago
Karl's like a virus sweeping the web and infiltrating everything RSK have ever expressed an opinion on. FUCKING MONG! :)
whitepanther84 1 year ago 4
haha so funny how many people are brought here from the xfm shows! Head like a fucking orange!
mrfundah 1 year ago 8
The lyrics could stand on their own without any music. Having said that the music would work with out the lyrics. Magic.
Nicomagic6 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Love the song, also, "you thump a monkey, and people go, you thumped a monkey"
themaypole 1 year ago 2
Love the song, also, "you thump a monkey, and people go, you thumped a monkey?!"
themaypole 1 year ago 4
@themaypole haha
mrfundah 1 year ago
Love the song, also, "you thump a monkey, and people go, you thumped a monkey?!"
themaypole 1 year ago
One of many fine songs to appear on the Space Oddity album - can't believe that it is now over 40 years since its release
branymor1 1 year ago 2
It'll get to a point, when were all so ugly, that no-one will have it away, and were just gonna die out
cooperjc8 1 year ago 3
@cooperjc8 chickeeenn you believe it!
charliefarlie20 1 year ago 4
nothing special but very special
itsallcool100 1 year ago
he may be a lover of aliester crowley but
he can write a bloody good song.
TheTrilnp 1 year ago
check out a cover me and my friend made of Letter to hermione :)
myspace.com/ jeanjeanandthejuiceblogs
putte2006 1 year ago
hang on a minute! Who put you in goal!?
charliefarlie20 1 year ago
@charliefarlie20 The great wall goes on for miles....but so does the m6!
cooperjc8 1 year ago
@cooperjc8
'man-moths!?'
charliefarlie20 1 year ago
@charliefarlie20 Did I tell you about the Immune system?
cooperjc8 1 year ago 2
@cooperjc8 what were those things in gremlins called?
charliefarlie20 1 year ago 2
@charliefarlie20 Could the world fall?
cooperjc8 1 year ago 2
@cooperjc8 if its a potato or a nut..its a foodage
charliefarlie20 1 year ago 2
@charliefarlie20 How would I know which one I was?
cooperjc8 1 year ago 2
@cooperjc8 blew it up... never saw the manhole cover again!
charliefarlie20 1 year ago 2
@charliefarlie20 He got the one that was causing trouble, and put it in a wheelie bin
cooperjc8 1 year ago 2
@cooperjc8 there's this airy chinese kid...
charliefarlie20 1 year ago 2
@charliefarlie20 It wasn't like that, it was straight to the point, he was like get ya knickers off
cooperjc8 1 year ago 4
@cooperjc8 if its all about arse, why don't gays like a bit of tit!?
charliefarlie20 1 year ago 3
@charliefarlie20 They just age over night it's like a pear
cooperjc8 1 year ago
@cooperjc8 it was a baby... that had a baby
charliefarlie20 1 year ago 3
@charliefarlie20 Yeah but what is he, is he an artist or a fishmonger
cooperjc8 1 year ago 4
@cooperjc8 she boiled her brain
charliefarlie20 1 year ago 2
@charliefarlie20 Is head was in great condition...it just wasn't attached to his body
cooperjc8 1 year ago 6
@cooperjc8 she ad a problem with er marrow and that, so i thought what's the point in spending time n money on her if shes just gonna die on me.
charliefarlie20 1 year ago 5
@charliefarlie20 No, cause there not my hands either
cooperjc8 1 year ago 3
@cooperjc8 he got so hot his lips fell off!
charliefarlie20 1 year ago 4
I love you Violet.
mrtyles 1 year ago
I like the inconsistent and improvised qualities the vocals have. The high end palmed guitar in the chorus adds a great quality also. Nice.
bassben04 1 year ago
God, that last chord - I came up with it by accident one day and was looking for uses of it in songs. It's a really dissonant chord, leaving you feeling like the song isn't over yet...
Trogdorwillrise 1 year ago
Beautiful song. Bowie's early, pre cut-up lyrics were so good.
electricburlesque 1 year ago
Everything special, not just the song. My all-time Bowie favorite. This version, not the "Bedroom tape" version. I repeat : THIS VERSION!!!
Call me fussy...
djaypee 1 year ago
definitely annoying trying to find this song on youtube and its nothing but harry potter videos -_-
spanky46758 1 year ago
a fave early bowie song. was considered one of his best during the time.
zaynzaynzayn 1 year ago 3
"They put a manhole cover on one (nuclear bomb), blew it up and they never saw that manhole cover again"
mattrusty15 1 year ago 4
aihjah 1 year ago 8
Too many years ago i memorize the words to make a "serenade" to my first lover, still one of the best lovesong ever...
careca56 1 year ago
a great song
adric137 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Worse Than Terrible
lol2614 1 year ago
My first born is named in honor of this work of art x
Canopusify 1 year ago
Only a Bowie fan would have heard this song....whidh is a shame because it is the most beautiful love song I have ever heard - truly Bowie at his best.......Thank you for putting it on :)
shipscuknfuk 1 year ago
@shipscuknfuk I dont think this is a love song...
Holdenmx 1 year ago
@Holdenmx It's about a lost love that he's still pining over. It's a love song of sorts I'd say, although a bitter sweet one.
arabiansanchez 1 year ago
@arabiansanchez so true and bitter sweet is sometimes the best and the most difficult.
2010jamic 1 year ago
great song!
adric137 1 year ago
this was my first love song to my girl frend and wife wno passed away 3 sundays ago, love who you love who you love we ae not here for ever x
jupitorman 1 year ago 3
@jupitorman So true. Sorry for your loss. Music helps, doesn't it?
averilleX 1 year ago
@jupitorman Boo hoo.
aradioactivedonut 5 months ago
"But did you ever call my name
Just by mistake?"
Ntona 1 year ago 3
with the song space oddity and cygnet commitee and this are the best of his album of 1969 SPACE ODDITY
BATTLETOADxONLYONEx 1 year ago 2
LTH is one of the best bowie's song...
it makes me feel sad everytime i listen for it....but is such a great song
pontello3 2 years ago
but did you ever call my name...just by mistake?!
DarkIsis80 2 years ago 4
I care for no one else but you...
and i'm not quiet sure what we are supposed to do
eyesintheroad 2 years ago 2
Beautiful!
Bellasimpson 2 years ago
This is probably my favorite David Bowie song ever.
hotturleduck 2 years ago 18
good song for a first love
THEHITPACK 2 years ago
Fucking amazing! Listening to this on meph ftw!!
groovyweasel 2 years ago
many txs for not ruining it putting images from harry potter.
Gosh how i hate these ppl that think there is only one hermione in the world.
liviacca 2 years ago 3
Bowie in 1969 is already at his best !! And you are right, this simple image is good, no need to focus other than the song itself, a song so amazing,
TheAmbitiousOutsider 2 years ago 2
he sings like an angel...
MusicthirstyGirl90 2 years ago 3
This is a classic that I hope will last forever..Just beautiful!
lildoeidgrl45 2 years ago 4
Oh well, he's got Iman now so i'm sure he's very happy. I bet Hermione regrets ever leaving him though! Serves her right, you'd have to be crazy NOT to want him
bonbon1995 2 years ago 6
@bonbon1995
kinaice 2 years ago
Nothing special???
Kingdra 2 years ago
I think he meant nothing special as in there is no special video, just the song.
grogtgs 2 years ago 3
I wonder if she ever regrets breaking up with him...
JasnoGT 2 years ago 4
Fav bowie tune
pbreton99 2 years ago 6
That is terrible! I hope you find somebody very special.
christinavlad 2 years ago
life saver...
kaatje58 2 years ago 2
Another overlooked Bowie masterpiece. Though I don't like the Space Oddity overall this along with the title track and Freecloud are all brilliant.
metrosfan 2 years ago 5
wow. ive never seen so many nice comments on one youtube vid.
great music brings out the best in humanity it seems.
kablaamee 2 years ago 40
@kablaamee I think that they are pretty easy to find on all David Bowie videos. His fans love him. :-)
naumnn 1 year ago
kablaamee
That's because it's the greatest thing he ever did.
cccustard 1 year ago
@cccustard Cygnet Committee definately gives it some good competition though.
greatunknowableevil 1 year ago
I love how whenever I look up this song, your video is the 1st to pop up. Love you, Daun.
HamburgerHobos 2 years ago
I'm so sorry. I hope you are doing well too.
Proneural 2 years ago 2
Thats always awful to hear. I'm really sorry for that. Music of this kind can invoke such emotion
DaveyKidda 2 years ago
no song has ever described a situation in my life so perfectly.
spookmonster52 2 years ago 2
Beautiful,wonderful, awesome song!
lildoeidgrl45 2 years ago
Thats terrible. I'm so sorry.
I hope you're doing well.
baciamiilculolawl 2 years ago 3
bowie ... the best
bowie ...el mejor
bowie ...forever
bowie...por siempre
bowie... my idol
bowie...mi idolo
aweskerpro 2 years ago 4
the story for this is really sad
but i love it all the same
it actually makes me feel quite melancholy yet i can't stop listerning to it
mangaandskunksrock 2 years ago 3
im 15 and i listen to this. its not just for my mum. :P
sjenitzer 2 years ago 4
I think I started to love English language with these Bowie songs. How wouldn't I! He takes the music that's already in the words.
Signifer82 2 years ago 4