Added: 3 years ago
From: yaxx217
Views: 93,692
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (111)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ampun rosa fals banget di awal sama di reff, kurang latian/grogi/kesulitan neh

  • So Good!

  • inii lagu umbrella ya???kok dancernya bawa payung,,,,tapi over all,,,saya suka rossa dan afgan.....

  • rossa tumpas di tangan afgan!!....wow so superb!!

  • fals tu rossa ,..

  • memang ga ada ada yang bisa nandingi mariah carey & withney houston kalo nyanyiin lagu ini. tapi saya bisa kasih standing ovation buat rossa & afghan :)

    Besok saya juga masukin video saya deh hahahaha ^^V

  • rossa is having a breeze singing....cos the pitch meets her female pitch.... afgan is the shining one here....

  • teknik nyanyi afgan keren, tapi warna vocal nya yg kurang

  • what a lovely voice

  • afgan oke klw nyanyi inggris.. enak bgt deh ...

  • wah sepertinya saya harus periksa THT segera nih.... saya dengernya kok bagus ya....

  • afgan it's good, rossa not too bad lahh..

  • yang Nari kayak Sakit Ayan.... padahal suasananya udah bagus kayak Konser Megah.. R O S S A you you look like a Barbie, you is the most expensive Diva in Indonesia.

  • duhhh rossa kebanting ama afgan ~.~"

  • yang nari dibelakang ngrusak suasana..

  • Messy in many many parts

    But what I like about this performance is Rossa actually did take those two really high notes that Mariah hit

    Most covers of this incredibly difficult song, the singers don't take those notes

    I wouldn't say this one is a "good" one, but overall it's "worth watching"

  • @isnichoo really high note?? its only F#5 n Bb5 lol, its should be easy for a woman to reach that note as long as she isnt contralto

  • @minalove231 Well what I meant to say was those are really high notes on original key in which Mariah sings to. Most of singers who cover this song tend to avoid those notes, but Rossa hit them although in lower key.

  • Comment removed

  • He sounds better than her in my opinion...

  • wow her dress is so nice!!!

  • Rossa dr dulu emang suaranya kurang bagus..shes pitchy, i dnt like her tone..her dynamics r bad..ughh gak enak didenger. Trus o itu to yg namanya afgan...i like his voice! first time i saw him in an indo movie..his acting was horrible...but i guess thts why he's better known as a singer not actor, huh. Trus bener ini this is the original key..bukan kunci suara cowo...but Afgan sang it good

  • ROSSA OFF banget .... this is not her forte... darn... ruin it

  • ajhurr

    

  • @bhallic24 it is cause the girl not good in guy's notes she is more higher i think

  • i didn't like the part when the girl started singing. this guy owns.

  • lebih bagus agnes drpd rosaa,,, jgn bandingkn afgan dan agnes,,, kn beda karakter suaranya,,, trus afgan ga jelas vokalisasinya,,

  • afgan better than agnes :p

  • Good voice afghan !!! LOVE IT !

  • horrible recording quality : ( 

  • keren abis...........!

    

  • selalu deh milih lagu yg susah. udah terang gak sampe nadanya. tapi di paksain

  • @chomel31 setuju,,, cuma agnes yg bisa

  • menurut gw oke, soalya gue kaga bisa nyanyi

  • dancers!!! please stop dancing there with them.. hahahaha...

  • Bad..peformance....dari rossa

  • i org Malaysia, i suka sangat sama afgan. dia ada kualiti suara yg bagus. tambahan tampan lagi. tetapi lagu ini kurang sesuai dinyanyikan oleh afgan & rossa kerana masing2 ada key yang berbeza. tp aku hargai 1 usaha yang baik. lagi 1, pentas2 acara muzik di indonesia mmg cantik2. kostum2 nya pun menarik. aku suka.

  • Comment removed

  • Rossa wkt awal2 nyanyi, kurang bagus,

    kurang gereget,,, hahah

    tapi wkt udh hampir ujung2 suaranya bagus banget, apalagi kombinasi falsetnya...

    itu luar biasa.

  • to me, its not bad..worth listening...by da way, it's my first time listening afgan singing in english. is there any other songs?

  • you can see Afgan : My Confession @ JavaJazz 2009..

  • You can find many in this channel Afgan singing Ordinary People, My confession, You give me something, If I ain't got You

  • the girl.. more practice please

  • Lagu ni mank TOP Bgt,

    gk salah milih Afgan n Rossa bwt nyanyi'n lagu ni,,,

    bikin merinding....

  • Rossa "nice".........

  • Yg punya suara bagus banyak, yg punya vibrasi bagus banyak, yg jago ngegroove/ improvisasi banyak, yg bisa suara 2 dan falseto juga banyak. TAPI yg punya kombinasi semua itu tidak banyak, dan salah satunya adl AFGAN.

  • Amazing..., i hope he will be legend oneday.., stage yang dibuat rcti emang keren abis terutama yanga sian idol, salut buat tim desainnya..,

  • keren

  • afgan emang mantap abis, ni orang bakal jadi legend neh klo tetep eksis, ini baru namanya penyanyi, bukan yang karbitan kayak sekarang banyak bgt

    Stage yang dibuat rcti emang paling keren..., saluut buat tim desainnya... ( stage asian idol jua keren abis )

  • kerrreeennn ...

  • kereeeeennnn abiiis !!!

  • keren bangettttt

  • gw ga ngrti knapa hampir smua pnyanyi indonesia kalo nyanyi live mesti pake back dancer sgala?...mana dancenya suka ga nyambung ama lagunya lagi....heran....

  • @hashfibaja lol..iye bener...palingan buat kasih lowongan kerjaan sama penari2 itu...secara di indo banyak bgt orang nganggur...

  • wahh bwat gw segini dah keren bgt!1 kan lagu ini susah banget!!

  • harusnya agnes monica sama afgan yg nyanyi ini.

  • like it.. !!!

    yg bkin susah di lagu ini, nada2 tinggi nya tuh.. tp rossa nyampe kok.. maybe emg nada sgini uda plg lmyn bwt dia.. tkutnya nada tingginya gak nyampe ntar.. malah ancur.. :D

  • panggung2 musik di indonesia emang keren2..

  • cara Rossa nyanyi lagu ini kok mirip ama cara agnes yah ? coba bandingin deh ama video agnes nyanyi lagu ini ..

  • suara afgan kerennnnnnnn...seharusnya afgan duet sama agnes monica nyanyiin nih lagu bukan sama rossa..hehe :) !

  • seharusnya gw yang duet ma afgan nyanyiin nih lagu..HAHAHAHa :)) !

  • rossa nyanyinya kurang bagus karena maennya di kunci untuk afgan..

    jd kerendahan buat rossa..

    plus...lagu ini emank susah banget!!!!!

    harus di hargain jg lha orang yg udah usaha nyanyi..

    bukannya dikata"in gitu..

    lagu ini amat sangat susah

  • @pasQual1803 salah. ini main di kunci aslinya. justru afghan ngambil kunci Whitney.. damn that dude. haha..

  • @pasQual1803 kata siapa kuncinya afgan ini kunci lagu aslinya justru.

  • bagus banget afgan bawain nih lagu.. :) tinggi gitu loh nada2 di nih lagu..tapi klo nadanya di matchingnya sama kemampuan suara afgannya sih enak2 aja.. :) ! bagus sih... :)

  • ga kompak!

  • agnes monica bawain ini lagu ini lebih bagus dari rossa,,,liat za videonya!!!

  • wah gilla stagenya megah bgt, acara apa sich nie??? kualitas dunia klo gini caranya he...he...

  • hahaha baguus kereen..

    ngpain pake ngehina tuh bawah?

  • good combination.i notice this melody more to ballad but then not suit to rossa.but,her voice ok..

  • Rossa Ruined Everything...

  • keren"....

  • Pada sok tau kalian semua...sok kasih kasih komen...kaya kalian bisa nyaingin mereka aja..rosa lah di komenin..afgan lah..dasar gembel...bukannya nikmatin videonya..eh...pada kasih komen....belagu kalian.........coba nyanyi..bisa ngga kaya rosa?? bisanya jago kasih komen kekurangan orang terus...

  • setubuh mas mantepp

  • rossa ruined everything mamenn..

    emang dr dulu gw perhatiin rossa tone controlnya ga bagus ni.. setiap nembak nada langsung di improv2, jadi seolah2 pitch, padahal mah goyang2.. argh..

    afgan juga di improv sih, tapi dia main di nada yang bener..dan dia pake teknik nyanyinya.. haha.. sapa lagi ya yang nyanyi pake teknik?

  • Agnes Monica!!! hahaha dia tekniknya the best deh pokoknya.hehehe

  • makasih mbA berta atas masukannya!!!

    rossa

  • AFGAN kereeeeeeeeeen.....!!!!!!!!

  • Its a WAW..

    amazing voice, AFGAN!

    but rossa, oH GOD..pleasee..

  • yes, i agree with u, arossaviolet.

    his voice 'wonderfull'

    mb/mas yaxx217,

    yg dpt dr nokia ga d msukin jg?

    oya biar nmbh bnyk gw sms deh,

    spya dpet d sctv musik award jg.

  • afgan is the best male singer in indonesia i think.!

    am i right?

  • * Most Favorite Male Artist , MTV Indonesia Awards 2008

    * Best Artist of The Year , MTV Indonesia Awards 2008

    * Most Favorite Male Singer, Nickelodeon Indonesian Kid's Choice Awards 2008

    * Penyanyi Solo Pria Terbaik (Best Male Soloist singer), Anugrah Musik Indonesia (AMI) Awards, 2009

  • @arossaviolet rio febrian donk

  • @arossaviolet setujuu

  • @arossaviolet yes I totally agree with you :)

  • alamak afgan best gler

    sy suka,,,

    \(^-^)/

  • PERFECT COLABORATION......

  • you're right,,,,

  • Afgan:

    Nyanyi di range tinggi (ini kunci cewe sebenernya)

    Ngambil selain suara 1 juga suara 2.

    Improvisasi.

    Tapi ga ada yang kedengeran fals dari awal sampe akhir.

    PERFECT !!

  • Nice colaboration.

    Afgan has Great Voice.

    Rossa has Great Voice,too.

    I know Rossa has lil bit fals,but it's okay.

    I know that's hard part.

  • afgan has a good voice.. but rossa, i think she's not really good voice.. her voice little bit fals when she sing this song..

  • hahaha

    agree with you,,

    she made litle bit fals,,

  • iya bener koq rossa fals ya...ga cocok deh nyanyi ini...jenis lagu nya ga cocok bgt deh buat rossa...klo afgan seh bagus koq at least afgan n rossa sm2 bagus koq...cuma jenis lagu nya aja kurang cocok buat rossa

  • Afgan> TOB,

    Rossa> HANCUR sudah.

    *AFGAN : Minta Req DUET lagu ini sm JUDIKA .. diJamin TokCer ..

    OOT > sm Penasaran .. ada gak yg punya link nya AGNEZ MONICA bawa in salah satu lagu nya Mariah Carey yg slow (full version Solo).. gw rasa AGNEZ jg gak berani .. yg one sweet day aja cm sepotong dan itu dia gk brani feat. sm BOYZ II MEN.

  • Memang ga ada yg bisa ngalahin suara Ms tujuh oktaf.. Salute buat Mariah Carey yg nyanyiin lagu ini dg begitu indahnya..

    Buat Teh Ocha :

    Salute udh berani nyanyiin lagu yg susah ini..

    And the result is good enough ^.^

  • afgan is perfect...

    you can go international....

  • Rossa fals...lagu ini memang susah...partnya rossa adl punya Mariah Carey...seandainya Rossa nyanyi dengan gaya uniknya sendiri...akan lebih bagus...sayang banget...Afgan...TOP BGT!!! ngga ada cacat....bravo!!

  • AWESOME AFGAN!

  • acara apaan nih ??

  • kalo ga salah menyambut HUT RCTI ke 20, nama acaranya "wujudkan mimpi Indonesia" acara kyk gini akan ada tiap tgl 24 smp acara puncaknya 24 Agustus nanti

    ^_^

  • suara Afgan OK bgt....enak dengerinnya

    cmn mnrt gw knp kali ini suara Rossa krg OK yach..rada2 "maksain" jd kdgrn rada "cempreng" ^_^ mgkn akn lbh bgs jdnya kalo Afgan nyanyi sendiri

  • gila nih org!suaranyaa!

  • Afgan is the best!!!

  • Hai ...apa kabar nak? kok tambah gemuk dan cabi ya... Lucu deh...see u soon....

  • I lOVe afgannn..

    his voice is soooo wonderful!!!!

  • Afgan did his thg on this performance...i mean mimicking great female singers like mariah and whitney aint easy at all especially if ur male singer...he didnt try to do too much, juz to da limit of his ability...which is why he did an awsum job....

  • Oh this is a really beautiful video from Afgan it is really nice to hear him sing a new song I actually had tears in my eyes when I watched it because it is so beautiful... Thanks for posting this NEW Afgan video my friend

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more