actually, it is A.N.S.W.E.R. that is a product of the 50s - because it is a front for the KGB-created Workers World Party. Just like RT is a KGB front serving their dictator Putin, with his saggy man-boobs
@wtfjaftw You wondered why all your free market heroes supported dictators? Because free markets require oppression of trade unions and average people. They dont work any other way. Why would a free person accept exploitation? ultimately they wont. So you need guns and rulers. and fascists provide both.
@wtfjaftw Dude, there are no taxes under real communism: big industry is in the hands of democracy. And your investors make all their profits off the work of employees. Work creates wealth - investors arent necessary with democratic control.
@dalellll - dude, there's no wealth under real communism: big industry fails. And you investors don't exist because there's no wealth to invest.
Work doesn't create wealth, PROFIT creates wealth. That's the most basic part of economics 101 you're not getting. You're still living the Marxist delusion that work is magical. Work doesn't create wealth. If it did then I could simply dig a hole and invariably get wealthy. Don't even pretend you know what you're saying because you don't.
@thomaserossi "Big industry" does not fail under real communism - communism is a method for managing big industry. All serious communists advocate nationalising big industry under worker's democratic control. Big industry didn't even fail under Stalinism - a gross distortion of communism. It was, in fact, developed. Russia went from being a 3RD WORLD country to landing probes on Venus.
@thomaserossi Your comment about investors makes me think you don't even understand orthodox economic theory, let alone Marxist economic theory. The "investors" under communism are the "worker's state" - by which i mean a democratically controlled state under which all large scale industry is nationalised. Investment decisions are made democratically by the people who will be impacted by those decisions, rather than by a class of destructive speculators.
@thomaserossi The more i read your comment, the more i realise how little economic theory you have: You don't even know what the word "wealth" means. You said: "PROFIT creates wealth" - Profit doesn't just appear out of nowhere - it is created by work. Work creates products (and no, "digging a hole" for no reason is not "productive work" *rolls eyes*), profit is drawn out of products, work creates profit. Profit is one of the forms of wealth that is created by work. This is BASIC stuff, dude.
@thomaserossi And no, "work creates wealth" is not "Marxist delusion" - it's a basic principle of economics. If Adam Smith were here, he'd slap you upside the head for being so goddamned stupid. SMITH highlighted that fact; Marx just took it to its logical conclusion.
@dalellll - You really are stupid. Work does NOT create wealth. Work can be counter-productive. You're just too indoctrinated to understand this and your Marxist indoctrination has made you stupid. You don't have the believe me. Go ahead and just start digging holes or building things. You're too stupid to figure out that there is no guarantee that EVERYTHING you create will not be useful. That's how fucking braindead you are.
@thomaserossi Seeing as Adam Smith, Karl Marx, and every other competent economist in the history of human civilisation agrees that "work creates wealth", I'm not sure what you think you're gaining by claiming the opposite on a YouTube thread. Go, spread your message to the people! Somehow, you've stumbled on something that all of Western science & philosophy has missed! Why waste your time here? Honestly, to respond to your comment - and I am only doing this for YOUR benefit, because...
@thomaserossi ...because, quite frankly, not a single other human being coming across this thread would consider your words to be anything but nonsense, and nobody on Earth (except for you) apparently needs to have this clarified: of course there is no guarantee that *all* the products of work will create wealth, but all wealth that does exist is the creation of work. Production is the result of work. Profits exist only because somebody worked. Sometimes ...
@thomaserossi ... Sometimes, work will create something useless. (Wow! What a brilliant insight! What other amazing economic insights do you have up your sleeve? If only you had written a book, then I could cherish and learn from it!!) Are you really so freaking stupid? That fact is so obvious, it is beneath mentioning. Yes, work can be done in vain! But work that is not done in vain produces wealth. And all produced wealth is the result of somebody's work. This isnt dogma- its common sense. ffs
@thomaserossi I'm sorry, I'm still truggling with just how inane your comment was. The fact that "work is necessary for production" (that is almost a tautology!), "production is used to create profit" (I don't think any capitalist on Earth would dispute this), and "ergo work creates profits" (1+1=2), is the FUNDAMENTAL reason that Marxists consider capitalism *exploitation*, I can't fathom what was going on in your head when you tried to use it to debate a Marxist. Really, are you posting drunk?
@wtfjaftw Lay off the drugs, buddy. Corporatism is a growth of free market capitalism. And dictators are popular with free market capitalists like Friedman, Hayek, and the lot. "Seriously stop fucking talking" - wow, you must be pretty ashamed of your ideas if you don't think they can stand on their own. You should be. You think owners and managers should be able to live off the work of hard-working people. Sounds pretty cowardly to me.
@wtfjaftw So your ideas are so weak that you have to call people "moron" and say "stop fucking talking", are they? Great work, mate. "Socialism" is not "force without voluntary consent" - socialism is democracy by voluntary consent. The federal reserve, social security, medicare etc are not "socialism" - they are progressive measures - better than a totally free market, but they are not socialism. And dude, my country has a better healthcare system than the USA. You talk a lot of bullshit.
@wtfjaftw You don't even know what socialism is, do you? It's not about "government being an angel" - that's ridiculous. It's about democracy in the workplace, and democracy over the economy. Yes, capitalism creates poverty & social crisis. Ownership of production creates poverty, reduces wages, reduces economic freedom. Free market economists talk a lot of rubbish about beleiving in freedom and "constitutional republics" - in practice they end up supporting fascists, like in Chile and Austria.
@wtfjaftw America has massive numbers of homeless and unemployed, a terrible healthcare system, and it depends on the exploitation and poverty of people overseas. Don't gloat about being a "superpower". America has NEVER "turned to socialism". Capitalism forcefully takes wealth from people to give it into the hands of a rich elite of owners and managers. It's no better than bureaucracy. Real socialism is anti-bureaucracy, anti-Stalin, anti-capitalist.
@wtfjaftw What are you babbling about? I'm a real socialist, thank-you. There are no truly "communist" governments in the world. Every single free-market philosopher has been a supporter of fascist government. Milton Friedman in Chile, Hayek in Austria. Free market capitalism is all about exploiting people, and you can never have true freedom while that is happening. Whever free markets have been introduced, they create poverty and social crisis. It's a concrete fact.
Seton Motley is the exact image of a man protecting the status quo world where the rich rule the world whilst the other 99% run round like landless peasants fighting each other! THIS SHIT HAS TO GO! THE ZEITGEIST MOVEMENT!
and the two guys are just arguing circles around eachother - they aren't even talking about the same exact issue most of the time. their basic dissagreements are on a larger level about global political and social workings. they can't reconcile their perspectives enough to intelligently discuss anything
torture my ass - these people are a bunch of bitches. bradley manning is in the military - he's not a civilian, and the rules for him are different (not that he should be tortured, i'm just saying that he isn't being tortured).
what about people that have betrayed the constution of the united states of america thay are the trators should thay be exicuted. if so then you better arested most of the goverment and 3/4 of our police force in the usa
Brian Becker is a Co-Director of Ramsey Clark's International Action Center (IAC) and a steering committee member of International A.N.S.W.E.R. Both are front groups for the Marxist-Leninist Workers World Party (WWP).
Wow he is a Marxist/Lennonist, whos goal is to destabilize America. This is proof that RT is a propaganda network inside America designed to shape anti american sentiment. I say afain RT is a PROPAGABDA network. Stop eating their CRAP!! WAKE UP!!
@magratmd I, like untold millions of US'ers, was raised in a family taught to hate & fear "COMMUNISTS" - never in their lives having MET a "Communist"! Like YOU! Socialists try to gain rights for workers & make sure everyone has enough to eat & not die from cold! But Alex Jones says RIGHT OF HAVE OPINIONS / BUT NO ORGANIZING! This WORLD REVOLUTION now breaking out is NOT COMMUNISTS; not WORKERS! It is ATOMIZED NET WORLD FAMILY! Breaking through ALL THE PROPAGANDAS - but UNORGANIZED-see Libya now
@PhotonDrive Yea yea, I know the story. Socialist just have ur and the peoples best interest at heart BLAH BLAH BLAH. That is what they have trained u to think with propaganda. It's all good at the beggining but then they turn on u and dominate every facet of ur life. How much health care u can have, what kind of home u have, what kind of job and pay u can have. All the while they enjoy the benefits of being ur ruler at the top. Good little pleb keep belieing. BTW I have met people frm Russia.
@PhotonDrive cont'd So yes I know through first hand reports what communism is like. The rules, codes, regulations and such That dictate how, where, and by what means u are to live. So yes I stand by my assertion that communism is bad. The ideal premis is ok, but when you add the human psyhe to the equation it becomes a dictatorship where the ruling class TELL the rest how to live all the while the ruling class lives in abundant luxury because they can. The same with socialism, maybe not as bad.
@magratmd Yes; the "consensus" seems to be that "Western" Social Democracies are the best choice of the known alternatives? While attending RAINBOW GETHERING events - essentially a family Nature exploration & mating dance, of Amer-Tribal influence - where "consensus" must be UNANIMOUS - we were SPIES ON by the SocDems secret police! While not understanding that CENTRALIZED FUELIST Org. determines their protocols - it was notable their "stronhold" was the PARKING LOT!
@PhotonDrive UH were you trying to make a point. Cause based on your response you sound like you can't keep a straight thought. What were you trying to say????
@magratmd Simple: As long as you have Energy Centralized - with it's profits; you are going to have some form of mass opression. Whether it is a dictatorship, a business "Democracy" with bought polititions; or a majority vote Socialist commitee! More-over ALL of these will try to PERPETUATE obsolete technologies - that they dominate & control! KILLING PROGRESS! (Except for killing means to keep control.) See how Nuked Japan & Libya are just facets of this basic sickness leading to Global Suicide
@STruvia13 Even if ANSWER split from them they still hold the same ideals, and it is obvious he in this video is speaking from a Marxist/Lennonist point of view, bashing the US, and RT still remains a propaganda network dedicated to that Aim. That much should be obvious based on the huge majority of the Videos they and so called reporting that they upload.
@magratmd I don't think you know what a "Marxist/Leninist" - not "Lennonist"; that would be a Beatles fan - point of view is. It's not about "bashing the US", it's seeing where the power is in society, and wanting to change it. (And WWP is not a good example.)
Btw, if the US does something horrible, it needs to be criticised. If you call that "bashing", then there's something screwed up with your morals. There's a history of mass murder and oppression from the US gov. Ignoring it won't fix it.
@dalellll Marxism is an economic and socio-political worldview that contains within it a political ideology for how to change and improve society by implementing socialism. And socialism leads to communism. Also only a very few people are in charge of distributing the wealth. And they are the ones who decide, that is the ruling class decides who gets what.
And I say bashing because this is a propaganda channel designed to foster antiUS and anti Israel sentiment. Period.
@magratmd You were correct right up untill "only a very few people are in charge of distributing the wealth". That's not socialism/communism/Marxism - that's Stalinism, a vulgar, bureaucratic bastardization of Marxism. Stalin had communists sent to labour camps and killed. Socialism is a system where every member of a community has a say in the management & distribution of wealth.
Anti-US-gvmnt and "anti-Israeli-gvmnt sentiment is common sense. You don't need a hidden agenda to hold it.
@dalellll But hwere socialism degrades is when the people disagree on how to deistribute that wealth. Lets face it. In a perfect world socialism may work and sounds good. But in the real world that is all it is, a fantasy. Because when you involve people that is where it goes to hell. Because Johnny will think he deserve more than suzzie and vice versa. That is why capitlism is better because it is based on your own indiidual hard work, you reap what you sow, and get what you give.
@magratmd Not so. Where socialism degraded was where several countries (including the US) invaded Russia over the 1918-1923 period, wiping out huge swathes of the politically aware population, allowing a new class of bureaucrats to rise, murder their communist opponents, and take power away from the democratic soviets.
These events had nothing to do with people disagreeing about wealth distribution.
@magratmd "capitalism ... is based on your own indiidual hard work, you reap what you sow"
Simply not true. Under capitalism, you don't "reap what you sow". You only get a *small proportion* of what you sow - the rest goes into profits & managerial benefits. An elite minority of owners and managers gets the wealth created by the majority. (That's why profits & wages are inversely related.)
The point of socialism is to reverse that, and put democracy in place of profiteering business owners.
@dalellll I HAVE THE ANSWER! I think USA needs a few Generals to start a coup AND to use (when in session) Daisy Cutters on Bohemian Grove The G20 CFR Trilateral Commission The UN Big Bank/Oil CEOs Monsanto KBR Rockefellers Rothchilds Bilderbergs etc. Long list! Do you think that would put a dent in the NWO Agenda? I like the idea of tossing them from choppers over 911 and we applaud as they splat!. More Enjoyable! make it PAY PER VIEW we'd make billions! Close ups as they fall!
@dalellll Look Socialism is doomed to failure where ever it is implemented. Why? Because it promotes lazyness with no incentives. No matter how hard you work you never get any further. Then you pay huge taxes to make everthing equal. Sure the only equality is how miserable everone is. No one is poor no one is rich and no one is happy. Everything is centralized and planned. By who? the State. The state own everything and the state decides everything. Id rather be free, and make my own choices.
@magratmd "Socialism ... promotes lazyness with no incentives." No it doesn't. You work, you get the fair share of rewards for it. Under capitalism, your incentives are all screwed up - you work, and you don't get rewarded for it. Or, if you're a business owner, you do a small amount of work, and get massive rewards for it (taken from the people who did the majority of the work). You call that an incentive to work hard? That's an incentive to screw your employees over, my friend.
@magratmd "Then you pay huge taxes to make everthing equal." Ridiculous. Why would you need to pay "huge taxes"?
"Everything is centralized and planned. By who? the State."
Nope - by the people. That was the very first point I made to you, and you've forgotten it already?
"Id rather be free, and make my own choices. "
Then you should be a socialist. Then you'd get to make decisions in your workplace and your community, instead of having the decisions made by your boss and the government.
@dalellll Cnt'd At least that way I know my position in life is my own fault and not the state. The more the state runs stuff the worst it gets for individuals. Look at the US welfare systems, those people have no incentive to be productive, why because the state pays them to sit on their ass all the while saying they are the victim. See thats what happens in socialism, it dis incentivises hard work and ingenuity. Why do you think The US is the leader of the world in inventions.
@magratmd "At least that way I know my position in life is my own fault and not the state."
Wait, what? Are you saying that it's your fault you're not the CEO of Microsoft? So, if we all only tried hard enough, we'd all get to be the CEO and live in mansions - and it's our fault that we don't? So who would actually do all the work in this capitalist utopia?
Rubbish. Your position isn't "your fault" - it's dictated by the economy. You don't have the choice to become Bill Gates.
@magratmd "The more the state runs stuff the worst it gets for individuals"
Nationalised industries almost always produce more than privatised ones. I could cite tonnes of examples. They do even better when they are democratically run - democratically run by *individuals* with rights. Thats what socialism is.
@magratmd "Why do you think The US is the leader of the world in inventions."
LOL! The US leads in *patents*, not inventions. For example, US drug companies produce thousands of new patents - and very few new drugs. The new drugs are all just minor alterations on old ones so they can make some cash off a new patent.
@dalellll Cuba has terrible poverty and Castro is a billionaire. Communism is about grabbing power and wealth for the state and has no interest in equality or fairness, and never did.
@dalellll cont'd Look at history, most of the modern technology we have came from the US, electricity, phone, lights, cars, airplanes, etc etc etc. And everyone followed us. Because we incentivise these things. Under socialism it does not happen. China steals technology from other nations and then uses it for itself because they have a vast underpayed work force under communism. Socialism leads to equal poverty, tyranny, and failure. It incentivises dependance on the state rather than self.
@magratmd "Because we incentivise these things. Under socialism it does not happen."
That;s just a ridiculous assertion. Is that why Russia, a third-world country, sent probes to Venus - even under the yoke of Stalinist distortion? Is that why they won the space race, became a nuclear power, and the world's 2nd superpower?
They were held back by Stalinism, yes, but they would have been held back even more by capitalism. We can see that today. They're back to the third world.
@magratmd "China steals technology from other nations and then uses it for itself because they have a vast underpayed work force under communism."
China's workforce is largely the victim of Western capitalism. Where do you think the electronics in your computer where made? Where these sold to you by a communist? Of course not. Chinese workers are oppressed as much by capitalist economics as by their backward dictatorship.
@magratmd "Socialism leads to equal poverty, tyranny, and failure."
Stalinism & capitalism both lead to tyranny, poverty and failure. Socialism is the way out of all three of these things. Look at capitalist tyrants (like Pinochet), capitalist poverty (like the entire third world - most of the human race), capitalist failure (like all of the above). Even dictatorial Cuba does better at providing for its population than its capitalist neighbours. With real socialism, it'd do better again.
@magratmd Who care? and Obama is the president of the USA and before him it was Bush, and Bush is not longer news And in 4 year Obama will be out of the White house and USA will have another president...I life will go on. And the poor will no know they are poor, maybe when they are cold or hungry unless someone else tell them that they are poor.
@magratmd Why do you care so much about A.N.S.W.E.R.'s affiliations, and so little about the other speaker? His name is Seton Motley, he's a right-wing "libertarian" - he believes in a kind of anarchy where the poor are thrown to the wolves and the economic benefits of civilisation are rolled back in the interests of a rich elite.
Interesting that you didn't find his political affiliations dubious.
Wow, Can you see the anti american propaganda here. Its amazing. They promote communism as if it were the answer to the worlds problems. What has communism brought to the world, lets see death, oppression, and degradation of freedom. I truly hope people dont by this crap.
@magratmd The American propaganda is the one everyday on TV, I see it with the eyes of a journalist...What about promoting capitalisem and democracy with invation and bombs? what about a country helping one side in another country conflict...I say a country not what country. In GENERAL communist countries do not take side on international conflict as American do...Communist countries do not invade Democratic countries to bring in communisem by force, with airforce, marines and armies.
@MonyMG1959 You might want to look up the creation and expansion of the Soveit Union. Russia actually invaded Afganistan in the 80's and they put down unrest in Chechnya. Hell China has their eye on Taiwan. North Vietmanese wanted to take over the free south. North Korea is very aggressive.
@magratmd Who say communism is the answer? but communisem is the arm use by capitalisem to black mail and for scared tatics to those they do not agree with. But communisem is becaming out of date now, from now on it will terrorisem.
PS - The SHAPE of that first bomb gives Detonator "secret" away. Any Russian Atom scietists looking at film would see that! So why weren't Los Alamos scientists & film-makers EXECUTED for giving Atomic "secrets" away? Down with the criminal "Security" "Secret" NAZI State!
Americans why are you watching this Russian propaganda trash? Russia Today (RT) is no better than Fox news. It's trash. RT receives funds from the Russian government.
Communism has killed 100 million people in the world. Far more than the holocaust.
These people weren't killed for "believing in communism" They were traitors.
@zOMGLaserGunzPewPew they're not communists any more... but yeah its a good question why are americans watching this propaganda channel... my guess is that they feel far ahead of everyone else because they think they know part of a conspiracy which only RT and other show... aka anti american sentiment... hence the usual phrase among them "the media is totally not reporting this only RT and Al Jazeera" when its in the first page of 4 newspapers and in a 30 min segment in 4 news channels...
PERFECT! Today Syria Pres. says CONSPIRACY! OUTSIDE AGITATORS! US bosses: "COMMUNISTS AGITATORS!" Alex Jones: People OK - but NOT OUTSIDE AGITATORS! Listen: MANNING was divulging CRIMES by US Military! CRIMES they Tried to KEEP SECRET, under PAIN OF DEATH! So is GHADDFI! So is ASSAD! ALL of them live in a DREAM WORLD of the PAST! Satilites & iphones are fun; but only for SELLING MORE FUN PRODUCTS? Don't CHANGE anything! Sweep ass-wipes like this Turd into DUSTBIN OF HISTORY! He lies throughteeth
It was not the first time someone got executed for Espionage. What a crock of BS.
The Rosenberg's were executed for giving over the timing system for the detonator. The Soviet's couldn't figure out how to properly time the detonator to actually trigger a fissile reaction.
This passes for news RT? I knew you were slightly Socialist, but FFS this is ridiculous.
@Joe11Blue The US not only got the Detonator FROM THE GERMANS! - But FILMED & WIDELY DISSEMINATED the FIRST BOMB being hauled to TEST SITE! This film is now RIGHT HERE ON YTube! The truth is: THE DUMMIES of US Gov & Military KNEW NOTHING about Atomic Science! Info had been traded INTERNATIONALLY since turn of the 19th century! "We got the Bomb - NOBODY else must get it!" Ignorant killer PIGS! STILL ARE!
@PhotonDrive Wow, lay off the crack. I'm sure that the Physics team that fled Germany because they were Jewish had absolutely nothing to do with building our first atomic weapon. The Manhattan Project never happened, and that everything is just evil if it's American.
Germany didn't even get far enough to realize there was a timing issue. They were still trying to figure out to get enough fissile material.
@Joe11Blue You are mis-informed: 1) No "Jewish team of A-scientists" fled Germany - only individuals! But: 2) GERMAN "Team" of Nazi scientists was KIDNAPPED by US AFTER the war (Bush OSS "Paper Clip" operstion). Since my mother-in-law & first fiancey, both got cancer or died from radiation steming from the Manhatten Project; I feel I have some reason to say "they knew nothing about radiation effects"? Braun's file was CHANGED from "Big Nazi" to "Not Nazi" - by Paper-Bush-Clip-operants, for ex.
@Joe11Blue "The physics TEAM - that were Jewish"! Are you so dumb you don't even know what you write? Your old-hat SMEAR tactics can't get you out of this one Joe Blow!
@PhotonDrive If you had learned to read, then you never would have suggested that I said that the whole team came out of Germany together. Were they a team after they already left Germany? Yes, I alluded to that much, hence the reason I use the term TEAM for them working HERE.
Anyone interested in socialism and fighting for revolutionary change should check out the Party for Socialism and Liberation. The PSL has branches across the country and it is easily the most active revolutionary socialist organization in the United States.
@STruvia13 The only people that join your outfit are the gullible youth and other useful idiots. Which gives no money and no organization. Your funding and direction comes from social elites backed by big government millionaires and billionaires that use you guys like 3 legged donkeys in the jungle. You guys are fools to follow a socialist agenda since you are really working toward your own enslavement.
Motley is harsh but is CORRECT. I am dumbfounded how anyone can call him "psychopathic". Selling nuclear secrets was, at the time, basically the most dangerous act one can do besides dropping an actual nuclear bomb.
I dare say that anyone opposed to their execution is themselves insane.
@StunnedByStupidity Wow! I didn't realize how many of your inbred cousins were on YouTube. Amazing. However, you and none of your "gang" have provided anything more than opinion to support your positions, and that's fine. I'm open to learning, because the truth is important.
As for the "high horse", well, you're not as stupid as you sound. I do see the world from a higher place, and know more about what happened to the Rosenberg's and why, far more than you're entitled to know. Ciao.
@MonyMG1959 KEEP JESUS OUT OF YOUR COMMIE SHIT. It was the communist countries that burnt the churches and raped the nuns. Crosses were FORBIDDEN in the USSR.
@TheNonConformative Why should I keep Christ out of it? Isn't the Catholic chruch under atack in the USA accused of pederastic practices? they are the ones that started the use of the cross...And the Romans soldiers that crucified Christ were only doing without questioning orders. I assume when you say communist you are refering to Russia? as far as I know they were USA ally during WWII, if not for them Germany will be the power to be.
@MonyMG1959 My guess is that YOU know nothing about true communism. The fact is that true communism was never ment to be. It is a fantasy. It was a false promise to get people to give up their freedoms to socialism. No communist speaker every talks just about communism. They say that they must first establish socialism. Then somehow an all powerful socialist dictatorship will simply give way to the sunshine and lollipops promise of communism. And millions actually it to this day. Suckers!!!!
@mickeysears But I know about democracy and capitalisem even if I have not experience with communisem or socialisem, about the last two you can tell me. The only thing I know is that in a democraty country my mother father desapeared after he was acussed of being a communist, my father was put in jail for the same reason and deported, many others have been kill or desappeared in democraty countries just because of their believe...Chile is just and example. So who are the good ones?
@MonyMG1959 And if your going to bring up Jesus, he would have never supported communism/socialism. Jesus supported the weak and asked people to be charitable and treat their fellow man as they themselves would want to be treated. He wouldn't have supported an all powerful government enabled to take wealth from one to give to another. Jesus saw that once allowed, that type of system always ends up in dictatorship where the powerful take from the weak. That was the government Jesus fought against
How about executing Rumsfeld, Cheney, Bush, Blair and Obama for war crimes? And Bernanke, Paulson and others for crimes against humanity? What they have done is beyond repair...
Motley is a psychopathic fascist. He needs to be tested for psychopathy and NEVER allowed to give his evil bigoted opinions on TV again...
BTW EVERY time he is on he just denies anything that is against his position like reality changes because he disagrees with it (HE NEEDS HELP - and yes I am aware psychopaths cannot be treated...) Its like he thinks that by smiling and shaking his head and saying that the world is NOT a sphere it will magically become flat - TYPICAL of the insane rightwing.
Motley should be executed just to prove his point. The truth is people were suffering under those regimes and dropping bombs(even atomic) is not helping them.So don't say that group of people is the enemy because 1 man in that country took over.We all know it is about getting what you want.By any means.That's all.
Regardless of the facts of both cases and anyone's political sympathies:
1. US thrives on histeria and hypocricy - fact!
2. US is the only country that ever dropped nuclear bombs on innocent people - fact!
3. US is the only country that has 1000 military bases, together with it's NATO marionettes tries to circle Russia with NATO bases and hostile regimes, and routinely engages in violent wars of aggression and regime change worldwide - fact!
Brian Becker if communism is so great, why through history people hve been fleeing it? The west Germans never tried to escape to the east, the Haitians, and Dominicans are not fleeing to Cuba, what is wrong?
@Leonnidik "Communism" and "bureaucratic dictatorship" are two very different things. Communism explicitly includes democratic decision-making and openness - things that the USSR, Cuba, China, North Korea all lack.
Your historical point is only half the story - if Castro's Cuba is communist, why do you find so many socialists protesting against it? Why where left-wing communists the very first targets of Stalin's regime? Why do you always see socialists protesting dictatorships?
@Leonnidik Re: "socialist countries". There are no "socialist countries." I said *socialists* protest these regimes. You want a concrete example? Try the Committee for a Worker's International, one of the most widespread communist organisations. The site "chinaworker(dot)info" is for their Hong Kong section, seeking the end of the Chinese Communist Party. They protest the regimes in Cuba, Nth Korea, China, and historically opposed Stalinism before the USSR fell apart.
Well Lenin had the NEP ( new economic policy ) in place .. but i dont think he was pro - markets .
the hole idea of socialism is conekted to the planed economy ... wich is the oposite of the so could "free market econiomy " ... we cant simply leave stuff to some crazy market to figure it out .. we need plans ...
Stalin was a Marxist - Leninist .
you are corekt about the biased information . But if you read more Marx ..you`ll learn to tell it apart
Well, considering that there's convincing evidence of Trotsky having been funded by western mega-banksters, such as Schiff and Warburg, and that the Soviet Union could only survive thereafter by selling-off its oil, gas, gold, lignite, etc. to "western" monied interests ... it should be no surprise that Lenin favored some "capitalism." Oh, and did I mention slave labor in the Soviet Union? See YouTube for:
Typical obnoxious tea bagger trying to lalk over the other guy and dominate the whole conversation. Figures he would want anyone who is a communist to be put to death.
this motley douchebag says that whistleblowers should be executed. when socialists take back the power from corporations and banks in this country fascists like motley will be brought to justice.
well i think socialism and communism, are both stupid, yet i still believe everyone is entitled to their opinion. good debate though i enjoyed it, however i think a third person should have been their a libertarian, because they only gave the socialist and nationalist perspectives.
Mr. Motley, you're an arrogant, self-righteous daft prick. I am ashamed of having people like you in this country. You belong in an asylum, you lunatic.
There is no way to debate the reasons why the Rosenberg were sentenced to death, because it's written down that the reason was treason. I just wonder if the same outcome would be verify if they were, say, French or British spies, thus implying that ideology had no role in the decision...
Kristine made a good point about the death penalty. IF the US want to rescue US spies, should they not trade spies, like in S.A.L.T.?
And it's funny, because at your worst moments of treason and Russian propaganda fuckery, I often think of the Rosenbergs. Take heed, ladies (& gents) of RT'America'...you might just get "Rosenberg'd" too, someday!!
OOH MY GOSHHH.. THEY were NOT killed for 'believing' in communism,..they were executed by the nation for TREASON. shhheeeeeeeeesh RT, . whistle-blowers??....Pfffft!!! what utter-gutter nonsense!.... what a limp wristed argument form the ANSWER guy.. The host triessooo hard to muddy up the waters with Union/class talk... , it was TREASON.. The smart guy does not want to be there obviously. weak RT.
wow rt trying to portraying the vicious commie jew spies which helped the most dreadful terroregime the world has ever seen to aquire nukes like some whistleblowers is a little much ^.^
I disagree with executing Bradley Manning. He only exposed the slimy truth. Brian Becker on the other hand, I'd like to see him on the other side of a revolutionary battlefield. I hope that miserable socialist piece of shit falls down some stairs.
actually, it is A.N.S.W.E.R. that is a product of the 50s - because it is a front for the KGB-created Workers World Party. Just like RT is a KGB front serving their dictator Putin, with his saggy man-boobs
pushups2345 9 months ago
@wtfjaftw You wondered why all your free market heroes supported dictators? Because free markets require oppression of trade unions and average people. They dont work any other way. Why would a free person accept exploitation? ultimately they wont. So you need guns and rulers. and fascists provide both.
dalellll 9 months ago
@wtfjaftw Dude, there are no taxes under real communism: big industry is in the hands of democracy. And your investors make all their profits off the work of employees. Work creates wealth - investors arent necessary with democratic control.
dalellll 9 months ago 2
@dalellll - dude, there's no wealth under real communism: big industry fails. And you investors don't exist because there's no wealth to invest.
Work doesn't create wealth, PROFIT creates wealth. That's the most basic part of economics 101 you're not getting. You're still living the Marxist delusion that work is magical. Work doesn't create wealth. If it did then I could simply dig a hole and invariably get wealthy. Don't even pretend you know what you're saying because you don't.
thomaserossi 9 months ago
@thomaserossi "Big industry" does not fail under real communism - communism is a method for managing big industry. All serious communists advocate nationalising big industry under worker's democratic control. Big industry didn't even fail under Stalinism - a gross distortion of communism. It was, in fact, developed. Russia went from being a 3RD WORLD country to landing probes on Venus.
dalellll 9 months ago 2
@thomaserossi Your comment about investors makes me think you don't even understand orthodox economic theory, let alone Marxist economic theory. The "investors" under communism are the "worker's state" - by which i mean a democratically controlled state under which all large scale industry is nationalised. Investment decisions are made democratically by the people who will be impacted by those decisions, rather than by a class of destructive speculators.
dalellll 9 months ago 2
@thomaserossi The more i read your comment, the more i realise how little economic theory you have: You don't even know what the word "wealth" means. You said: "PROFIT creates wealth" - Profit doesn't just appear out of nowhere - it is created by work. Work creates products (and no, "digging a hole" for no reason is not "productive work" *rolls eyes*), profit is drawn out of products, work creates profit. Profit is one of the forms of wealth that is created by work. This is BASIC stuff, dude.
dalellll 9 months ago 2
@thomaserossi And no, "work creates wealth" is not "Marxist delusion" - it's a basic principle of economics. If Adam Smith were here, he'd slap you upside the head for being so goddamned stupid. SMITH highlighted that fact; Marx just took it to its logical conclusion.
dalellll 9 months ago 2
@dalellll - You really are stupid. Work does NOT create wealth. Work can be counter-productive. You're just too indoctrinated to understand this and your Marxist indoctrination has made you stupid. You don't have the believe me. Go ahead and just start digging holes or building things. You're too stupid to figure out that there is no guarantee that EVERYTHING you create will not be useful. That's how fucking braindead you are.
China's Ghost Cities
You're too indoctrinated to watch that.
thomaserossi 8 months ago
@thomaserossi Seeing as Adam Smith, Karl Marx, and every other competent economist in the history of human civilisation agrees that "work creates wealth", I'm not sure what you think you're gaining by claiming the opposite on a YouTube thread. Go, spread your message to the people! Somehow, you've stumbled on something that all of Western science & philosophy has missed! Why waste your time here? Honestly, to respond to your comment - and I am only doing this for YOUR benefit, because...
dalellll 8 months ago
@thomaserossi ...because, quite frankly, not a single other human being coming across this thread would consider your words to be anything but nonsense, and nobody on Earth (except for you) apparently needs to have this clarified: of course there is no guarantee that *all* the products of work will create wealth, but all wealth that does exist is the creation of work. Production is the result of work. Profits exist only because somebody worked. Sometimes ...
dalellll 8 months ago
@thomaserossi ... Sometimes, work will create something useless. (Wow! What a brilliant insight! What other amazing economic insights do you have up your sleeve? If only you had written a book, then I could cherish and learn from it!!) Are you really so freaking stupid? That fact is so obvious, it is beneath mentioning. Yes, work can be done in vain! But work that is not done in vain produces wealth. And all produced wealth is the result of somebody's work. This isnt dogma- its common sense. ffs
dalellll 8 months ago
@thomaserossi I'm sorry, I'm still truggling with just how inane your comment was. The fact that "work is necessary for production" (that is almost a tautology!), "production is used to create profit" (I don't think any capitalist on Earth would dispute this), and "ergo work creates profits" (1+1=2), is the FUNDAMENTAL reason that Marxists consider capitalism *exploitation*, I can't fathom what was going on in your head when you tried to use it to debate a Marxist. Really, are you posting drunk?
dalellll 9 months ago 2
@wtfjaftw Lay off the drugs, buddy. Corporatism is a growth of free market capitalism. And dictators are popular with free market capitalists like Friedman, Hayek, and the lot. "Seriously stop fucking talking" - wow, you must be pretty ashamed of your ideas if you don't think they can stand on their own. You should be. You think owners and managers should be able to live off the work of hard-working people. Sounds pretty cowardly to me.
dalellll 9 months ago
@wtfjaftw So your ideas are so weak that you have to call people "moron" and say "stop fucking talking", are they? Great work, mate. "Socialism" is not "force without voluntary consent" - socialism is democracy by voluntary consent. The federal reserve, social security, medicare etc are not "socialism" - they are progressive measures - better than a totally free market, but they are not socialism. And dude, my country has a better healthcare system than the USA. You talk a lot of bullshit.
dalellll 9 months ago
@wtfjaftw You don't even know what socialism is, do you? It's not about "government being an angel" - that's ridiculous. It's about democracy in the workplace, and democracy over the economy. Yes, capitalism creates poverty & social crisis. Ownership of production creates poverty, reduces wages, reduces economic freedom. Free market economists talk a lot of rubbish about beleiving in freedom and "constitutional republics" - in practice they end up supporting fascists, like in Chile and Austria.
dalellll 9 months ago
@wtfjaftw America has massive numbers of homeless and unemployed, a terrible healthcare system, and it depends on the exploitation and poverty of people overseas. Don't gloat about being a "superpower". America has NEVER "turned to socialism". Capitalism forcefully takes wealth from people to give it into the hands of a rich elite of owners and managers. It's no better than bureaucracy. Real socialism is anti-bureaucracy, anti-Stalin, anti-capitalist.
dalellll 9 months ago
@wtfjaftw What are you babbling about? I'm a real socialist, thank-you. There are no truly "communist" governments in the world. Every single free-market philosopher has been a supporter of fascist government. Milton Friedman in Chile, Hayek in Austria. Free market capitalism is all about exploiting people, and you can never have true freedom while that is happening. Whever free markets have been introduced, they create poverty and social crisis. It's a concrete fact.
dalellll 9 months ago
THE MURDER OF THE ROSENBURGS IS AN EXAMPLE OF THE CRUALITY OF MANKIND.
dindes100 10 months ago
commie traitors
udical 10 months ago
the entire US gov is a cabal of treasonous jews, there is nothing wrong with liquidating them.
mdssdp 10 months ago
Russia Today and RT America are nothing but Kremlin propaganda puppets with Putin pulling the strings.
MissileD11 10 months ago
its time to bring back MACARTHYISM ,the commies and the nazis and the zionists are running our whole goverment.
dorodini 10 months ago
@dorodini in your case those should be 'purges', as your government is neotrotskist.
protfl 10 months ago
it's really sad proponents of unnecessarily killing people are tolerated
eternallord 11 months ago
We got a want to be commie in the white house until the banking elite schooled him.
MrSuperpat 11 months ago
Seton Motley is the exact image of a man protecting the status quo world where the rich rule the world whilst the other 99% run round like landless peasants fighting each other! THIS SHIT HAS TO GO! THE ZEITGEIST MOVEMENT!
matthewthetuite 11 months ago
@matthewthetuite The answer to 1984 and 2011 is 1776
Conflagration2100 11 months ago
Seton Motley is such a smug bastard
Hammerofthegods86 11 months ago
and the two guys are just arguing circles around eachother - they aren't even talking about the same exact issue most of the time. their basic dissagreements are on a larger level about global political and social workings. they can't reconcile their perspectives enough to intelligently discuss anything
soratsol 11 months ago
torture my ass - these people are a bunch of bitches. bradley manning is in the military - he's not a civilian, and the rules for him are different (not that he should be tortured, i'm just saying that he isn't being tortured).
soratsol 11 months ago
what about people that have betrayed the constution of the united states of america thay are the trators should thay be exicuted. if so then you better arested most of the goverment and 3/4 of our police force in the usa
comesrunning 11 months ago
I think simpley russia's comunist turned into dictatorship. It was a revolution interrupted. What about Cuba?
AmarokSaga 11 months ago
Brian Becker is a Co-Director of Ramsey Clark's International Action Center (IAC) and a steering committee member of International A.N.S.W.E.R. Both are front groups for the Marxist-Leninist Workers World Party (WWP).
Wow he is a Marxist/Lennonist, whos goal is to destabilize America. This is proof that RT is a propaganda network inside America designed to shape anti american sentiment. I say afain RT is a PROPAGABDA network. Stop eating their CRAP!! WAKE UP!!
magratmd 11 months ago
@magratmd I, like untold millions of US'ers, was raised in a family taught to hate & fear "COMMUNISTS" - never in their lives having MET a "Communist"! Like YOU! Socialists try to gain rights for workers & make sure everyone has enough to eat & not die from cold! But Alex Jones says RIGHT OF HAVE OPINIONS / BUT NO ORGANIZING! This WORLD REVOLUTION now breaking out is NOT COMMUNISTS; not WORKERS! It is ATOMIZED NET WORLD FAMILY! Breaking through ALL THE PROPAGANDAS - but UNORGANIZED-see Libya now
PhotonDrive 11 months ago
@PhotonDrive Yea yea, I know the story. Socialist just have ur and the peoples best interest at heart BLAH BLAH BLAH. That is what they have trained u to think with propaganda. It's all good at the beggining but then they turn on u and dominate every facet of ur life. How much health care u can have, what kind of home u have, what kind of job and pay u can have. All the while they enjoy the benefits of being ur ruler at the top. Good little pleb keep belieing. BTW I have met people frm Russia.
magratmd 11 months ago
@PhotonDrive cont'd So yes I know through first hand reports what communism is like. The rules, codes, regulations and such That dictate how, where, and by what means u are to live. So yes I stand by my assertion that communism is bad. The ideal premis is ok, but when you add the human psyhe to the equation it becomes a dictatorship where the ruling class TELL the rest how to live all the while the ruling class lives in abundant luxury because they can. The same with socialism, maybe not as bad.
magratmd 11 months ago
@magratmd Yes; the "consensus" seems to be that "Western" Social Democracies are the best choice of the known alternatives? While attending RAINBOW GETHERING events - essentially a family Nature exploration & mating dance, of Amer-Tribal influence - where "consensus" must be UNANIMOUS - we were SPIES ON by the SocDems secret police! While not understanding that CENTRALIZED FUELIST Org. determines their protocols - it was notable their "stronhold" was the PARKING LOT!
PhotonDrive 10 months ago
@PhotonDrive UH were you trying to make a point. Cause based on your response you sound like you can't keep a straight thought. What were you trying to say????
magratmd 10 months ago
@magratmd Simple: As long as you have Energy Centralized - with it's profits; you are going to have some form of mass opression. Whether it is a dictatorship, a business "Democracy" with bought polititions; or a majority vote Socialist commitee! More-over ALL of these will try to PERPETUATE obsolete technologies - that they dominate & control! KILLING PROGRESS! (Except for killing means to keep control.) See how Nuked Japan & Libya are just facets of this basic sickness leading to Global Suicide
PhotonDrive 10 months ago
@magratmd ANSWER split from the International Action Center a while back. Becker isn't affiliated with the IAC or WWP anymore.
People interested in socialism should check out the Party for Socialism and Liberation.
STruvia13 11 months ago
@STruvia13 Even if ANSWER split from them they still hold the same ideals, and it is obvious he in this video is speaking from a Marxist/Lennonist point of view, bashing the US, and RT still remains a propaganda network dedicated to that Aim. That much should be obvious based on the huge majority of the Videos they and so called reporting that they upload.
magratmd 11 months ago
@magratmd I don't think you know what a "Marxist/Leninist" - not "Lennonist"; that would be a Beatles fan - point of view is. It's not about "bashing the US", it's seeing where the power is in society, and wanting to change it. (And WWP is not a good example.)
Btw, if the US does something horrible, it needs to be criticised. If you call that "bashing", then there's something screwed up with your morals. There's a history of mass murder and oppression from the US gov. Ignoring it won't fix it.
dalellll 11 months ago 2
@dalellll Marxism is an economic and socio-political worldview that contains within it a political ideology for how to change and improve society by implementing socialism. And socialism leads to communism. Also only a very few people are in charge of distributing the wealth. And they are the ones who decide, that is the ruling class decides who gets what.
And I say bashing because this is a propaganda channel designed to foster antiUS and anti Israel sentiment. Period.
magratmd 10 months ago
@magratmd You were correct right up untill "only a very few people are in charge of distributing the wealth". That's not socialism/communism/Marxism - that's Stalinism, a vulgar, bureaucratic bastardization of Marxism. Stalin had communists sent to labour camps and killed. Socialism is a system where every member of a community has a say in the management & distribution of wealth.
Anti-US-gvmnt and "anti-Israeli-gvmnt sentiment is common sense. You don't need a hidden agenda to hold it.
dalellll 10 months ago
@dalellll But hwere socialism degrades is when the people disagree on how to deistribute that wealth. Lets face it. In a perfect world socialism may work and sounds good. But in the real world that is all it is, a fantasy. Because when you involve people that is where it goes to hell. Because Johnny will think he deserve more than suzzie and vice versa. That is why capitlism is better because it is based on your own indiidual hard work, you reap what you sow, and get what you give.
magratmd 10 months ago
@magratmd Not so. Where socialism degraded was where several countries (including the US) invaded Russia over the 1918-1923 period, wiping out huge swathes of the politically aware population, allowing a new class of bureaucrats to rise, murder their communist opponents, and take power away from the democratic soviets.
These events had nothing to do with people disagreeing about wealth distribution.
dalellll 10 months ago
@magratmd "capitalism ... is based on your own indiidual hard work, you reap what you sow"
Simply not true. Under capitalism, you don't "reap what you sow". You only get a *small proportion* of what you sow - the rest goes into profits & managerial benefits. An elite minority of owners and managers gets the wealth created by the majority. (That's why profits & wages are inversely related.)
The point of socialism is to reverse that, and put democracy in place of profiteering business owners.
dalellll 10 months ago
@dalellll I HAVE THE ANSWER! I think USA needs a few Generals to start a coup AND to use (when in session) Daisy Cutters on Bohemian Grove The G20 CFR Trilateral Commission The UN Big Bank/Oil CEOs Monsanto KBR Rockefellers Rothchilds Bilderbergs etc. Long list! Do you think that would put a dent in the NWO Agenda? I like the idea of tossing them from choppers over 911 and we applaud as they splat!. More Enjoyable! make it PAY PER VIEW we'd make billions! Close ups as they fall!
ledaohio 10 months ago
@dalellll Look Socialism is doomed to failure where ever it is implemented. Why? Because it promotes lazyness with no incentives. No matter how hard you work you never get any further. Then you pay huge taxes to make everthing equal. Sure the only equality is how miserable everone is. No one is poor no one is rich and no one is happy. Everything is centralized and planned. By who? the State. The state own everything and the state decides everything. Id rather be free, and make my own choices.
magratmd 10 months ago
@magratmd "Socialism ... promotes lazyness with no incentives." No it doesn't. You work, you get the fair share of rewards for it. Under capitalism, your incentives are all screwed up - you work, and you don't get rewarded for it. Or, if you're a business owner, you do a small amount of work, and get massive rewards for it (taken from the people who did the majority of the work). You call that an incentive to work hard? That's an incentive to screw your employees over, my friend.
dalellll 10 months ago 2
@magratmd "Then you pay huge taxes to make everthing equal." Ridiculous. Why would you need to pay "huge taxes"?
"Everything is centralized and planned. By who? the State."
Nope - by the people. That was the very first point I made to you, and you've forgotten it already?
"Id rather be free, and make my own choices. "
Then you should be a socialist. Then you'd get to make decisions in your workplace and your community, instead of having the decisions made by your boss and the government.
dalellll 10 months ago 2
@dalellll Cnt'd At least that way I know my position in life is my own fault and not the state. The more the state runs stuff the worst it gets for individuals. Look at the US welfare systems, those people have no incentive to be productive, why because the state pays them to sit on their ass all the while saying they are the victim. See thats what happens in socialism, it dis incentivises hard work and ingenuity. Why do you think The US is the leader of the world in inventions.
magratmd 10 months ago
@magratmd "At least that way I know my position in life is my own fault and not the state."
Wait, what? Are you saying that it's your fault you're not the CEO of Microsoft? So, if we all only tried hard enough, we'd all get to be the CEO and live in mansions - and it's our fault that we don't? So who would actually do all the work in this capitalist utopia?
Rubbish. Your position isn't "your fault" - it's dictated by the economy. You don't have the choice to become Bill Gates.
Ridiculous.
dalellll 10 months ago
@magratmd "The more the state runs stuff the worst it gets for individuals"
Nationalised industries almost always produce more than privatised ones. I could cite tonnes of examples. They do even better when they are democratically run - democratically run by *individuals* with rights. Thats what socialism is.
dalellll 10 months ago
@magratmd "Why do you think The US is the leader of the world in inventions."
LOL! The US leads in *patents*, not inventions. For example, US drug companies produce thousands of new patents - and very few new drugs. The new drugs are all just minor alterations on old ones so they can make some cash off a new patent.
dalellll 10 months ago 6
@dalellll Cuba has terrible poverty and Castro is a billionaire. Communism is about grabbing power and wealth for the state and has no interest in equality or fairness, and never did.
warriorprince1010 5 months ago
@dalellll cont'd Look at history, most of the modern technology we have came from the US, electricity, phone, lights, cars, airplanes, etc etc etc. And everyone followed us. Because we incentivise these things. Under socialism it does not happen. China steals technology from other nations and then uses it for itself because they have a vast underpayed work force under communism. Socialism leads to equal poverty, tyranny, and failure. It incentivises dependance on the state rather than self.
magratmd 10 months ago
@magratmd "Because we incentivise these things. Under socialism it does not happen."
That;s just a ridiculous assertion. Is that why Russia, a third-world country, sent probes to Venus - even under the yoke of Stalinist distortion? Is that why they won the space race, became a nuclear power, and the world's 2nd superpower?
They were held back by Stalinism, yes, but they would have been held back even more by capitalism. We can see that today. They're back to the third world.
dalellll 10 months ago
@magratmd "China steals technology from other nations and then uses it for itself because they have a vast underpayed work force under communism."
China's workforce is largely the victim of Western capitalism. Where do you think the electronics in your computer where made? Where these sold to you by a communist? Of course not. Chinese workers are oppressed as much by capitalist economics as by their backward dictatorship.
dalellll 10 months ago
@magratmd "Socialism leads to equal poverty, tyranny, and failure."
Stalinism & capitalism both lead to tyranny, poverty and failure. Socialism is the way out of all three of these things. Look at capitalist tyrants (like Pinochet), capitalist poverty (like the entire third world - most of the human race), capitalist failure (like all of the above). Even dictatorial Cuba does better at providing for its population than its capitalist neighbours. With real socialism, it'd do better again.
dalellll 10 months ago 11
@magratmd Who care? and Obama is the president of the USA and before him it was Bush, and Bush is not longer news And in 4 year Obama will be out of the White house and USA will have another president...I life will go on. And the poor will no know they are poor, maybe when they are cold or hungry unless someone else tell them that they are poor.
MonyMG1959 11 months ago
@magratmd Why do you care so much about A.N.S.W.E.R.'s affiliations, and so little about the other speaker? His name is Seton Motley, he's a right-wing "libertarian" - he believes in a kind of anarchy where the poor are thrown to the wolves and the economic benefits of civilisation are rolled back in the interests of a rich elite.
Interesting that you didn't find his political affiliations dubious.
dalellll 11 months ago
Wow, Can you see the anti american propaganda here. Its amazing. They promote communism as if it were the answer to the worlds problems. What has communism brought to the world, lets see death, oppression, and degradation of freedom. I truly hope people dont by this crap.
magratmd 11 months ago
@magratmd The American propaganda is the one everyday on TV, I see it with the eyes of a journalist...What about promoting capitalisem and democracy with invation and bombs? what about a country helping one side in another country conflict...I say a country not what country. In GENERAL communist countries do not take side on international conflict as American do...Communist countries do not invade Democratic countries to bring in communisem by force, with airforce, marines and armies.
MonyMG1959 11 months ago
@MonyMG1959 You might want to look up the creation and expansion of the Soveit Union. Russia actually invaded Afganistan in the 80's and they put down unrest in Chechnya. Hell China has their eye on Taiwan. North Vietmanese wanted to take over the free south. North Korea is very aggressive.
MrSuperpat 11 months ago
@MrSuperpat Are you telling me that the Libyan rebels today will be the Talibans of the future?
MonyMG1959 11 months ago
@MrSuperpat hahaha, childish naivette.
protfl 10 months ago
@magratmd Who say communism is the answer? but communisem is the arm use by capitalisem to black mail and for scared tatics to those they do not agree with. But communisem is becaming out of date now, from now on it will terrorisem.
MonyMG1959 11 months ago
PS - The SHAPE of that first bomb gives Detonator "secret" away. Any Russian Atom scietists looking at film would see that! So why weren't Los Alamos scientists & film-makers EXECUTED for giving Atomic "secrets" away? Down with the criminal "Security" "Secret" NAZI State!
PhotonDrive 11 months ago
and don't forget they were Jews.
MonyMG1959 11 months ago
Americans why are you watching this Russian propaganda trash? Russia Today (RT) is no better than Fox news. It's trash. RT receives funds from the Russian government.
Communism has killed 100 million people in the world. Far more than the holocaust.
These people weren't killed for "believing in communism" They were traitors.
zOMGLaserGunzPewPew 11 months ago
@zOMGLaserGunzPewPew they're not communists any more... but yeah its a good question why are americans watching this propaganda channel... my guess is that they feel far ahead of everyone else because they think they know part of a conspiracy which only RT and other show... aka anti american sentiment... hence the usual phrase among them "the media is totally not reporting this only RT and Al Jazeera" when its in the first page of 4 newspapers and in a 30 min segment in 4 news channels...
Sexisttroll 11 months ago
PERFECT! Today Syria Pres. says CONSPIRACY! OUTSIDE AGITATORS! US bosses: "COMMUNISTS AGITATORS!" Alex Jones: People OK - but NOT OUTSIDE AGITATORS! Listen: MANNING was divulging CRIMES by US Military! CRIMES they Tried to KEEP SECRET, under PAIN OF DEATH! So is GHADDFI! So is ASSAD! ALL of them live in a DREAM WORLD of the PAST! Satilites & iphones are fun; but only for SELLING MORE FUN PRODUCTS? Don't CHANGE anything! Sweep ass-wipes like this Turd into DUSTBIN OF HISTORY! He lies throughteeth
PhotonDrive 11 months ago
It was not the first time someone got executed for Espionage. What a crock of BS.
The Rosenberg's were executed for giving over the timing system for the detonator. The Soviet's couldn't figure out how to properly time the detonator to actually trigger a fissile reaction.
This passes for news RT? I knew you were slightly Socialist, but FFS this is ridiculous.
Joe11Blue 11 months ago
@Joe11Blue The US not only got the Detonator FROM THE GERMANS! - But FILMED & WIDELY DISSEMINATED the FIRST BOMB being hauled to TEST SITE! This film is now RIGHT HERE ON YTube! The truth is: THE DUMMIES of US Gov & Military KNEW NOTHING about Atomic Science! Info had been traded INTERNATIONALLY since turn of the 19th century! "We got the Bomb - NOBODY else must get it!" Ignorant killer PIGS! STILL ARE!
PhotonDrive 11 months ago
@PhotonDrive Wow, lay off the crack. I'm sure that the Physics team that fled Germany because they were Jewish had absolutely nothing to do with building our first atomic weapon. The Manhattan Project never happened, and that everything is just evil if it's American.
Germany didn't even get far enough to realize there was a timing issue. They were still trying to figure out to get enough fissile material.
Joe11Blue 11 months ago
@Joe11Blue You are mis-informed: 1) No "Jewish team of A-scientists" fled Germany - only individuals! But: 2) GERMAN "Team" of Nazi scientists was KIDNAPPED by US AFTER the war (Bush OSS "Paper Clip" operstion). Since my mother-in-law & first fiancey, both got cancer or died from radiation steming from the Manhatten Project; I feel I have some reason to say "they knew nothing about radiation effects"? Braun's file was CHANGED from "Big Nazi" to "Not Nazi" - by Paper-Bush-Clip-operants, for ex.
PhotonDrive 11 months ago
@PhotonDrive Where did I state it was a Team? Learn to read before you try to puppet your bullshit.
Joe11Blue 11 months ago
@Joe11Blue "The physics TEAM - that were Jewish"! Are you so dumb you don't even know what you write? Your old-hat SMEAR tactics can't get you out of this one Joe Blow!
PhotonDrive 11 months ago
@PhotonDrive If you had learned to read, then you never would have suggested that I said that the whole team came out of Germany together. Were they a team after they already left Germany? Yes, I alluded to that much, hence the reason I use the term TEAM for them working HERE.
LEARN TO READ.
Joe11Blue 11 months ago
Anyone interested in socialism and fighting for revolutionary change should check out the Party for Socialism and Liberation. The PSL has branches across the country and it is easily the most active revolutionary socialist organization in the United States.
STruvia13 11 months ago
@STruvia13 The only people that join your outfit are the gullible youth and other useful idiots. Which gives no money and no organization. Your funding and direction comes from social elites backed by big government millionaires and billionaires that use you guys like 3 legged donkeys in the jungle. You guys are fools to follow a socialist agenda since you are really working toward your own enslavement.
mickeysears 11 months ago
Motley is harsh but is CORRECT. I am dumbfounded how anyone can call him "psychopathic". Selling nuclear secrets was, at the time, basically the most dangerous act one can do besides dropping an actual nuclear bomb.
I dare say that anyone opposed to their execution is themselves insane.
zapproowsdower 11 months ago
jew traitors beeing executed? No tears here.
TheNonConformative 11 months ago
@StunnedByStupidity Wow! I didn't realize how many of your inbred cousins were on YouTube. Amazing. However, you and none of your "gang" have provided anything more than opinion to support your positions, and that's fine. I'm open to learning, because the truth is important.
As for the "high horse", well, you're not as stupid as you sound. I do see the world from a higher place, and know more about what happened to the Rosenberg's and why, far more than you're entitled to know. Ciao.
rjc071 11 months ago
death to communism, fascism , socialism, oligarchy's, dictatorships the NWO etc. etc. LONG LIVE THE REPUBLIC!
ASTVideoFootage 11 months ago
Espionage concerning the most powerful weapon ever developed. I'd say the death penalty was called for.
Tounushi 11 months ago
I <3 Socialism
Gabe2590 11 months ago
@Mr59plexi Actually, nwo = fascism.
DrQuijano 11 months ago
Whenever I hear a conservative say "communism" I cringe at their complete and utter ignorance of what communism means.
DrQuijano 11 months ago 2
Most American do not know nothing about communisem...the filosophy...and they are all againt it or afraid of it...If Jesus could only speak up.
MonyMG1959 11 months ago
@MonyMG1959 KEEP JESUS OUT OF YOUR COMMIE SHIT. It was the communist countries that burnt the churches and raped the nuns. Crosses were FORBIDDEN in the USSR.
Keep the Christ out of it you sucker.
TheNonConformative 11 months ago
@TheNonConformative Why should I keep Christ out of it? Isn't the Catholic chruch under atack in the USA accused of pederastic practices? they are the ones that started the use of the cross...And the Romans soldiers that crucified Christ were only doing without questioning orders. I assume when you say communist you are refering to Russia? as far as I know they were USA ally during WWII, if not for them Germany will be the power to be.
MonyMG1959 11 months ago
@MonyMG1959 My guess is that YOU know nothing about true communism. The fact is that true communism was never ment to be. It is a fantasy. It was a false promise to get people to give up their freedoms to socialism. No communist speaker every talks just about communism. They say that they must first establish socialism. Then somehow an all powerful socialist dictatorship will simply give way to the sunshine and lollipops promise of communism. And millions actually it to this day. Suckers!!!!
mickeysears 11 months ago
@mickeysears But I know about democracy and capitalisem even if I have not experience with communisem or socialisem, about the last two you can tell me. The only thing I know is that in a democraty country my mother father desapeared after he was acussed of being a communist, my father was put in jail for the same reason and deported, many others have been kill or desappeared in democraty countries just because of their believe...Chile is just and example. So who are the good ones?
MonyMG1959 11 months ago
@MonyMG1959 And if your going to bring up Jesus, he would have never supported communism/socialism. Jesus supported the weak and asked people to be charitable and treat their fellow man as they themselves would want to be treated. He wouldn't have supported an all powerful government enabled to take wealth from one to give to another. Jesus saw that once allowed, that type of system always ends up in dictatorship where the powerful take from the weak. That was the government Jesus fought against
mickeysears 11 months ago
@mickeysears the powerful taking from the weak in that case there is not a christian soul in the USA
MonyMG1959 11 months ago
the rosenbergs were traitors and were executed because they committed treason.
WikeddTung 11 months ago
What about the guy that gave it to Israel?
grandmachristine42 11 months ago 14
Commies deserve death
Sturmpionier03 11 months ago
@Sturmpionier03 The FBI job should be only to care about real social problems...child molestation and illegal drugs traffic.
MonyMG1959 11 months ago
CIA and NSA spies should be publicly executed for wasting American Tax payer money.
wanker89 11 months ago
How about executing Rumsfeld, Cheney, Bush, Blair and Obama for war crimes? And Bernanke, Paulson and others for crimes against humanity? What they have done is beyond repair...
TheGreatPenetrator 11 months ago
people just argue cuz they are jewish
HongKongKanto 11 months ago 2
Motley is a psychopathic fascist. He needs to be tested for psychopathy and NEVER allowed to give his evil bigoted opinions on TV again...
BTW EVERY time he is on he just denies anything that is against his position like reality changes because he disagrees with it (HE NEEDS HELP - and yes I am aware psychopaths cannot be treated...) Its like he thinks that by smiling and shaking his head and saying that the world is NOT a sphere it will magically become flat - TYPICAL of the insane rightwing.
StunnedByStupidity 11 months ago
Execute Bush for treason against humanity.
windofthegods 11 months ago 10
The guy on the left is an asshole, and the guy on the right is an idiot.
Didn't like this video at all.
Carljoakimmm 11 months ago
What about Bill Clinton giving nuclear technology to North Korea?
alpidistra 11 months ago 3
Sharing Nuclear secrets, wow thats pretty much the height of treason, they deserved killing.
flake452 11 months ago
Legalize hemp.
gringodeltoro1 11 months ago 3
hang Cheney then
marniespeaks 11 months ago 2
@infosoldier1 i meat that u have some guts son.. u have a powerful stomach..
tERtasdf 11 months ago
Motley should be executed just to prove his point. The truth is people were suffering under those regimes and dropping bombs(even atomic) is not helping them.So don't say that group of people is the enemy because 1 man in that country took over.We all know it is about getting what you want.By any means.That's all.
venyusz01 11 months ago
i think that scum on the right should be executed for his horrendous crimes against humanity.
covertgreen 11 months ago 2
@tkabat1983
Hamilton was a Rothschild agent. That's why you see so many crypto-Zionists promoting him.
LibertaerUeberAlles 11 months ago
More like killed for giving nuclear secrets to the enemy
HerculesRockefellerr 11 months ago 2
Descrimination and persecution in America?! I would have never guess... (Sarcasm).
Ariminua 11 months ago
@umhalil - lol! :D
nameofthepen 11 months ago
Brian, you're always a pleasure to listen to.
Keep up the good work.
RBLA818 11 months ago
@RBLA818 Brian Becker ftw.
Ariminua 11 months ago
Seton dont even beleive in any of his own BS, he only desagree to be different so he has a platform to argue and be invited on TV shows.
luc649 11 months ago
stop inviting seton motley. that guy's an idiot.
iwontupload 11 months ago
Regardless of the facts of both cases and anyone's political sympathies:
1. US thrives on histeria and hypocricy - fact!
2. US is the only country that ever dropped nuclear bombs on innocent people - fact!
3. US is the only country that has 1000 military bases, together with it's NATO marionettes tries to circle Russia with NATO bases and hostile regimes, and routinely engages in violent wars of aggression and regime change worldwide - fact!
And end of discussion!
goldstep999 11 months ago
Fuck socialists and communists kill them all!
jess1up 11 months ago
@jess1up What are you ten?
Ariminua 11 months ago
Comment removed
ubermisogynist 11 months ago
Ha ha...gotta love RT. Calling Zionist spies "whistleblowers". LMAO!!
nameofthepen 11 months ago
Brian Becker if communism is so great, why through history people hve been fleeing it? The west Germans never tried to escape to the east, the Haitians, and Dominicans are not fleeing to Cuba, what is wrong?
Leonnidik 11 months ago
@Leonnidik "Communism" and "bureaucratic dictatorship" are two very different things. Communism explicitly includes democratic decision-making and openness - things that the USSR, Cuba, China, North Korea all lack.
Your historical point is only half the story - if Castro's Cuba is communist, why do you find so many socialists protesting against it? Why where left-wing communists the very first targets of Stalin's regime? Why do you always see socialists protesting dictatorships?
dalellll 11 months ago
@dalellll - Wich socialist countries are protesting fidel castro an North Koreas whatever his name is Jung something.
Leonnidik 11 months ago
@Leonnidik Re: "socialist countries". There are no "socialist countries." I said *socialists* protest these regimes. You want a concrete example? Try the Committee for a Worker's International, one of the most widespread communist organisations. The site "chinaworker(dot)info" is for their Hong Kong section, seeking the end of the Chinese Communist Party. They protest the regimes in Cuba, Nth Korea, China, and historically opposed Stalinism before the USSR fell apart.
dalellll 11 months ago
Comment removed
ubermisogynist 11 months ago
@ubermisogynist
Marxism / Leninism /Stalinism / Maoism is the true path .
China has its sucsess because its still 70 % socialist , planed economy .
only 30 % is market.
Those workers in 30 % are somrtimes mistreated by western corporations ...
the plans for the Atomic bomb . gave an equlizer .
The USSR was a great socialist conter weight .
the humane type of capitalism of the US would be inposible without Soviet Preasure .
HK379 11 months ago
Comment removed
ubermisogynist 11 months ago
@ubermisogynist Your wellcome .
Well Lenin had the NEP ( new economic policy ) in place .. but i dont think he was pro - markets .
the hole idea of socialism is conekted to the planed economy ... wich is the oposite of the so could "free market econiomy " ... we cant simply leave stuff to some crazy market to figure it out .. we need plans ...
Stalin was a Marxist - Leninist .
you are corekt about the biased information . But if you read more Marx ..you`ll learn to tell it apart
HK379 11 months ago
@ubermisogynist
Well, considering that there's convincing evidence of Trotsky having been funded by western mega-banksters, such as Schiff and Warburg, and that the Soviet Union could only survive thereafter by selling-off its oil, gas, gold, lignite, etc. to "western" monied interests ... it should be no surprise that Lenin favored some "capitalism." Oh, and did I mention slave labor in the Soviet Union? See YouTube for:
"Cheka and NKVD"
LibertaerUeberAlles 11 months ago
Typical obnoxious tea bagger trying to lalk over the other guy and dominate the whole conversation. Figures he would want anyone who is a communist to be put to death.
sewbuttns 11 months ago
Is this Teabagger guy the same guy who was saying "ZOMG WE DON'T HAVE THE MONEY!" when he was interviewed about the Wisconsin protests?
Thesterness 11 months ago 2
this motley douchebag says that whistleblowers should be executed. when socialists take back the power from corporations and banks in this country fascists like motley will be brought to justice.
signboyy 11 months ago
this motley douchebag probably dresses up in a nazi uniform in his basement every night by himself
signboyy 11 months ago
the american government gave nazi scientists jobs and executed socialist americans.
american government has been fascist and controlled by banks and corporations since at least world war 2
signboyy 11 months ago 2
well i think socialism and communism, are both stupid, yet i still believe everyone is entitled to their opinion. good debate though i enjoyed it, however i think a third person should have been their a libertarian, because they only gave the socialist and nationalist perspectives.
666Qtip666 11 months ago
Mr. Motley, you're an arrogant, self-righteous daft prick. I am ashamed of having people like you in this country. You belong in an asylum, you lunatic.
MyTube22T 11 months ago
Socialist here.
wilfredotour2 11 months ago
There is no way to debate the reasons why the Rosenberg were sentenced to death, because it's written down that the reason was treason. I just wonder if the same outcome would be verify if they were, say, French or British spies, thus implying that ideology had no role in the decision...
Kristine made a good point about the death penalty. IF the US want to rescue US spies, should they not trade spies, like in S.A.L.T.?
AlexxxCat 11 months ago
Haha, it's OK Seton...take a breath, dude...
And it's funny, because at your worst moments of treason and Russian propaganda fuckery, I often think of the Rosenbergs. Take heed, ladies (& gents) of RT'America'...you might just get "Rosenberg'd" too, someday!!
Y0UT00B3R1 11 months ago
OOH MY GOSHHH.. THEY were NOT killed for 'believing' in communism,..they were executed by the nation for TREASON. shhheeeeeeeeesh RT, . whistle-blowers??....Pfffft!!! what utter-gutter nonsense!.... what a limp wristed argument form the ANSWER guy.. The host triessooo hard to muddy up the waters with Union/class talk... , it was TREASON.. The smart guy does not want to be there obviously. weak RT.
Solon6633 11 months ago 6
@Solon6633, they had no duty of allegiance to the United States. No one does, except for those those working in the military and politicians.
No Treason: The Constitution of No Authority | by Lysander Spooner
watch?v=VYJTWa5v24I
wood9670 11 months ago
@wood9670 --if this is true, i stand corrected... thank you... very informative
Solon6633 11 months ago
Fuck, Dud on the Rights got my vote, Fuck the D Bag in the Glasses , lacks education in my opinion.
iHappyTimeTech 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
At home, we practice communism.
tubetib 11 months ago
communism is a capitalist dictator society.anarchy is the only way.i bow down to nobody
fallenempireoverdrve 11 months ago
hang the corporatist
marniespeaks 11 months ago
wow rt trying to portraying the vicious commie jew spies which helped the most dreadful terroregime the world has ever seen to aquire nukes like some whistleblowers is a little much ^.^
happosai27 11 months ago
I disagree with executing Bradley Manning. He only exposed the slimy truth. Brian Becker on the other hand, I'd like to see him on the other side of a revolutionary battlefield. I hope that miserable socialist piece of shit falls down some stairs.
Grutch 11 months ago 2
I am a proud Socialist come get me bitchez
starkweather444 11 months ago
@starkweather444 The tit you suck on is running out of milk. You will be gone soon enough.
rallycsx 11 months ago
@starkweather444 You should check out the Party for Socialism and Liberation. :)
STruvia13 11 months ago
How about the true spies in Republican party? Working for Israel as duel citizens with one loyalty to Israhell
MadXMax187 11 months ago 2
Is Brian Becker Eric Clapton's son?
IamTheAntiMartyr 11 months ago
We should kill more commies.
Grutch 11 months ago
@Grutch We should kill american captalists.
MarceloRodrigues1 11 months ago