read "the rape of nanking" by iris chang. these scenes are historically accurate. this was rape and murder on a colossal scale, and performed by the common soldiery. there was no one great madman; they were all devils.
The Chinese soldiers were cornered and threw away military uniforms in Nanking. Then they deprived Chinese inhabitants of plain clothes .Thus the Chinese soldiers violated the international law "Hague Convention on land warfare " as the plain-clothes soldiers . In other words they became no civilians but illegal terrorists.Therefore they were sentenced to death.
The Chinese plain-clothes soldiers that had the ability to shoot Japanese soldiers,were very dangerous .The Chinese terrorists' conducts endangered the rule of the war and Chinese citizens. They weren't soldiers but war criminals.Therefore, they were not protected in Hague Convention.
(Part2)The majority of women were raped and some were brutally killed. Only around 60 Japanese civilians survived, but much of the city was destroyed in the fighting. This massacre was occurred in July 1937, which means before the so-called Nanking Massacre. How much Chinese killing way of the Tungchow Mutiny is similar to the so-called Nanking Massacre?
The Nanking Massacre was born from Chinese imaginations and created by Kuomintang of China.
(Part1)The Tungchow Mutiny (Chinese: 通州事件) was an assault on Japanese civilians and troops by East Hopei Army in Tungchow, China on 29 July 1937. Shortly after the Marco Polo Bridge Incident that marked the official beginning of the Second Sino-Japanese War. 250 civilian residents of Tungchow were killed in the uprising (predominantly Japanese reserves, including police and ethnic Korean-Japanese).
(Part2)Moreover, China paid some foreigners to write false stories in newspaper articles and a book. Chinese victims couldn’t receive any medical treatment for they had no money. Chinese injured wanted to get treatments in hospital and Chiang Kai-shek wanted to have many victims who were hurt by the Japanese because Chiang wanted to appeal the Japanese false brutally acts to the world.
(Part1)How can Japanese admit the wrong history such as the Nanking Massacre? No evidence of the Nanking Massacre. The Nanking population was increased after Japan controlled the city. Many witnesses confessed they had not watched any crime scenes about Nanking Massacre. Chinese government reported the documents written on the number of dead bodies were 20,000, which number was the same number of Chinese soldiers. Also China fabricated 143 pictures of the Nanking Massacre.
killing is killing japan is guilty for mass murder so is china so is brittain, germany,russa, USA every country in that war kill civialains on mass and each plays stupid when asked
(Part1)According to Summary report on the Investigation of Japanese war crimes committed in Nanking, prepared by the Procurator of the District Court in Nanking, to prepare for the IMTFE, the KMT set up the Nanking Investigation Committee for Antagonists Crime on November 7, 1945, and appealed to the Chinese public to report Japanese Army's crimes. It was reported, however, that few responded to the crimes committed by Japanese Army
(Part2) and some refused to testify or to deny the massacre occurred when they were asked for details.Then, the KMT reluctantly submitted the tentative report to the IMTFE on January 20, 1946. Except for one testimony made by a man named Lu Su, no other evidence of massacre by the Japanese Army was available, besides burial records.
Although around 2:04 is purely an exaggeration, it is still for sure that the Japanese military had executed many prisoners and civilians as well.
I'm not going to discuss the "numbers" of how many people were killed in Nanking (Japanese claim around 30,000+ while Chinese figures have said 300,000+), but we cannot deny that we still had killed a LOT of people.
It's been decades after that ordeal, I hope that both sides become much better friends (I know that isn't easy but... just a hope).
The Japanese killed many Chinese people? I don’t think so. John Rabe sent a letter of appreciation to the commander of Japanese army on Dec. 14 1937. This is the letter. 「Dear Sirs. We express our appreciation to your artillery’s praiseworthy act of having not attacked the safety zone and for becoming able to communicate with you (commander Matsui) about the future plan for supporting Chinese citizens in the same area. 」 (Stenography No.210).
@undertakerRach That's a school or church size safety zone. how about what happened out of the zone? How can you explain the photos, the says of the survives? Even the Jap solidiers confess what happened. Now, you still try to cover it?!
@Luckybobnumber4 Part1)The 'Nanking Massacre' in which the Prosecution claims the 'massacre of 300,000', has never been so proved. However, any other unjustifiable killings by Japanese troops are regarded as punishable war crimes during the battles against the Chinese Army, and these should be processed under the international humanitarian law. On the other hand, in case of Germany, they were not fighting the war against the Jewish people.
@Luckybobnumber4 (Part2) The large-scale slaughters targeting all the Jewish people, including the killings of Jewish people who had German citizenship, committed by the Nazi Germany were systematically planned killings based on the specific ethnic ideology which had no direct connection with the war. Those killings were, indeed, the 'crimes against humanity', and those crimes are fundamentally different from the 'war crimes' which the Japanese troops were said to have committed.
@Luckybobnumber4 (Part3) Not only so, Japanese must say that there existed the crucial fact that the then Japanese government sternly refused the persecution policy against the Jewish people which the Nazi Germany was implementing, even though Japan had amicable relations with Germany by means of concluding the Anti-Comintern Pact during that time when the battle of Nanking occurred.
@Luckybobnumber4 (Part4)In December 1938, almost one year after the battle of Nanking, the Japanese Government decided the policy that 'based on the spirit of racial equality which we have insisted on for many years, we will treat the Jewish people with fairness, in the same manner as we treat other foreigners and we will not take special measures to reject them.
@undertakerRach Bullcrap. They may not have attached artillery-wise or anything but they sure did other messed up sh*t. Did u not just view the video???
@74Amaterasu The Nanking Massacre was a false story which was just a rumor creating by China. If the Chinese say the massacre was true story, they should show conclusive evidence. I have written so many Chinese people, but nobody has written the evidence. Nanking believers have appealed the story is true to the world, but it is not indefinite. Moreover, some evidence such as pictures and videos was created by China.
How people can believe the story without evidence?
@undertakerRach At the same time, evidence can be fabricated, erased, or tapered with. This event occurred on a massive scale and there is evidence, you just need to look for it. So many people have accounts about this happening. And how do you know if this is really propaganda? All governments have some form of propaganda.
Would you accuse the Jewish people and government their story on the Holocaust was propaganda? There is evidence they were tortured, killed and the Jewish say it happened.
@74Amaterasu (Part1)I am accusing Nazi as the same as Japan accused German before. Nazi were not fighting the war against the Jewish people. The large-scale slaughters targeting all the Jewish people, including the killings of Jewish people who had German citizenship, committed by the Nazi Germany were systematically planned killings based on the specific ethnic ideology which had no direct connection with the war. Those killings were, indeed, the 'crimes against humanity',///
@74Amaterasu (Part2)/// and those crimes are fundamentally different from the 'war crimes' which the Japanese troops were said to have committed. Not only so, Japanese must say that there existed the crucial fact that the then Japanese government sternly refused the persecution policy against the Jewish people which the Nazi was implementing, even though Japan had amicable relations with Germany by means of concluding the Anti-Comintern Pact during that time when the battle of Nanking occurred.
@74Amaterasu (Part3)In December 1938, almost one year after the battle of Nanking, the Japanese Government decided the policy that 'based on the spirit of racial equality which we have insisted on for many years, we will treat the Jewish people with fairness, in the same manner as we treat other foreigners and we will not take special measures to reject them.
@74Amaterasu (Part4)Chinese people think the Japanese war crime and Nazi crimes in the same category, but the Nanking Massacre was a false charge. This case show how much they have not learned right history.
I am not your baby sitter, so please study right history and write your comments. Shame on you.
A photo has displayed at the Nanking Massacre Museum. The caption said, "The Japanese rounded up thousands of women. Most of them were gang raped or forced into military prostitution. But this photo appeared in the Asahi Graph, a weekly photo journal, published in Japan on Nov 10, 1937, about one month before Nanking battle. The explanation says, "A group of women and children from the Rising Sun Village returning from the fields, guarded by our soldiers." China loves fabricating pictures.
@undertakerRach FABRICATING ur fucking ass, ur fuck ,, r u chinese? u fucking shit, if u don't no anything, shut ur fuck up, i ll kill u , u shit bitch, fuck !
@F (Part1)The 228 Massacre was an anti-government uprising in Taiwan that began on February 27, 1947 and was violently suppressed by the Kuomintang (KMT) government. Before the 228 massacre was broke out, the mood of the crowd, which had already been harboring many feelings of frustration from KMT rule, reached breaking point. The KMT troops who came from mainland China were highly undisciplined, looting, stealing, and contributing to the overall breakdown of infrastructure and public services.
@FRANK22131 (Part2)Estimates of the number of deaths vary from ten thousand to thirty thousand or more. According to the New York Times on March 29, 1947, an American said, gTroops from China arrived at Taiwan on March 7 and indulged in three days of indiscriminate killing and looting. For a time everyone seen on the streets was shot at, homes were broken into and occupants killed. In the poorer sections the streets were said to have been littered with dead.
@FRANK22131 (Part3)There were instances of beheadings and mutilation of bodies, and women were raped.h This is the Chinese inherent characteristics. The Nanking Massacre might have been have caused by KMT soldiers. In fact, R.J Rummel claims that Chinese peasants often had no less to fear from their own soldiers than they did from the Japanese. Moreover, KMT soldiers in the Nanking castle in their mad rush to discard their military uniforms and put on civilian clothes.
@FRANK22131 (Part4)In a number of incidents, killed civilians to obtain their clothing in Nanking city in 1937 before the Japanese troops entered to the Nanking castle. James Espy, the vice American Council at Nanking, reported to the American Embassy. Go back to the 228 massacre story, Chen Yi, the ROC authorities, had jailed or killed all the leading Taiwanese organizers he could identify and catch.
@FRANK22131 (Part5)His troops executed between 3,000 and 4,000 people. Chen Yi was later quoted by TIME magazine in April 7, 1947 as saying: "It took the Japs 51 years to dominate this island. I expect to take about five years to re-educate the people so they will be happier with Chinese administration." This fact shows they were mind controlled by the Chinese government? The Nanking Massacre was a fake story. In fact, Chinese school kids have learned anti-Japanese education.
@undertakerRach ：u shot the Fuck up ... fuck u ! i want to ask u? r u a chinese? em ?does japanese killed chinese people or not? did they came to our country to kill to rob? so please shut u fuck up,,, u fucker,,,!i don't no u, but if i c u , im sure i ll kill u myself, u fuck !
I despise the liberals who gloss over these atrocities committed by Japan and focus instead on Japan being the victim of our firebombing/A-Bombs. Japan deserved everything it got...and should've gotten more.
Notice how everyone thinks movies from china is always propaganda no matter what it is,whether its a romantic or war movie, they just straight up declare it to be some kind of chinese propaganda,yet,they buy into movies like ryan or such and think it is the most touching stroy ever made, and believe their governments are the honest-lincolns who care for nothing but its people....LOL peace to all no hates, and respect
@Alsemenor Because there is a reason why you study books. If teachers can just tell you all the knowledge, books wouldnt exist, would it? Why should I tell you something I spent so much time studying for?
@HowYaDoingMon To prove your point more valuable. Cursing the Chinese and brag about how you will massacer them dont really make you, neither your opinion, so valuable.
@HowYaDoingMon I am not trolling at all. the video is about how the Japanese are bruutaly slaughtering Chinese prisoners! And you come here and start talking about how the Taiwanese will slaughter the chinese. It seems like trolling to me. Just because i think that your opinions and arguments are invalid do not make me a troll!
@JLOStudios not that im siding japan for this argument...but taiwanese r actually a little bit positive towards jap than any other asian countries since japan innovated the tech in taiwan. that's wat i heard from my taiwanese friends
@SuperVNMan hey little boy,read your history book(s) again, if you had ever studied it. Vietnamese has Chinese ancestors. your ancestors must be mad at u for calling them a dog now. how 'filial' you are. Oh yeah, at least Chinese like me can spell English words properly and have load more manners than u people. Fancy calling people dogs when you are no better.
When Japan's government refuses to atone and offer to pay for crimes of WWII, they also hide from crimes to their own people. For example Fukujima nuclear explosion was not disclosed to their own people. Lie to us once, maybe forgive but not forget, lie to me twice, YOU shall never forget - EVER!
(Part4)Lewis S. C. Smythe, professor of Nanking University investigated the population with the help of many Chinese staffs on February 1938. He wrote a report which shows the population of Nanking was 250,000 or 270,000 as of the end of March 1938. The Nanking City Administrative Office of the Nanking Restoration Government, which was established on March 28, 1938, registered 277,000 inhabitants. Japanese soldiers killed 300,000 Chinese people in Nanking city?
(Part3) For TSZC, it was absolutely necessary to know the accurate number of people in order to distribute food to those refugees. After the Japanese victory and occupation took place, TSZC in its document dated on December 17, and in subsequent documents, consistently recognized this number. Afterwards how did the population of Nanking change? TSZC documents read that in January 1938 the population was 250,000.
(Part2)As the result, there were no people within the castle except in the Safety Zone. John Rabe, the Safety Zone Committee (TSZC) member, wrote in his diary in Dec 10, when the Nanking battle began, the Nanking population was 200,000. TSZC described in the Document No.9 dated in Dec 17, "On the 13th when the Japanese entered the city, we had nearly all the civilian population in the Safety Zone, so the number 200,000 is no doubt.
(Part1)Chinese government has claimed Japanese soldiers killed 300,000 Chinese civilians while the Japanese were staying in Nanking city in China. After the Japanese occupation, did the population of Nanking decrease by more than 300,000? Let’s look at many historical records. On Dec 8,1937， Tang Sheng-zhi, who was Chinese commander, warned that all the noncombatants should assemble in the Safety Zone, and the citizens rushed into the Safety Zone for the safety.
the Nanking's dialect(nanking native speaking language ) now is totally not the same as in 1937, because the people who spoke Nanking dialect that time were killed. The ancester of the people live in Nanking now were migrated from other parts of Jiangsu province, so the real Nanking native language has disappeared. If Nanking Massacre is fake, why a dialect disappeared?
My Grandfather is a Proud Chinese who fought and killed 9 japanese men even though they ambushed his squad unit in world war 2 I am proud to be called his grandson after what the japanese did to us but i love japanese people
Its all in past now.... we should not harbor HATE because of what has happened in the past... all we can do now is stop the chain of hate and pray it wont ever happen again in the future.
@stockpicker1966 China isn't actually the world's "no 1" economic power. Its economy is still slightly larger than half the size of the American economy.
The Chinese boy soldiers were very cruel during Second Sino-Japanese War. Japanese POW were burned at the stake by the Chinese boy soldiers in Shanghai.
@SOVIETasTheINVADER That's true and everyone has done terrible things in the past, but do you really think what the Japanese did justifies as anything?
Yeah this was because of Japan's world domination plan, because they racist to everyone else! So thankfully, their population is decreasing because of them being racist to everyone else in the world.
It is said where the Russians broke the back of the German army, the Chinese broke the back of the Japanes army, not the americans. Nothing against the Americans but they mostly fought garrison troops not their elite troops, with the exception of Guadacanal. The British beat the Japanese 15th army in Burma.
(Part3)In February, as the Osaka Asahi Shinbun reported, the Japanese military arrested eleven hiding Chinese soldiers who had committed numerous atrocities in Nanking, speaking Japanese and wearing counterfeit of Japanese translator's armband to pose as Japanese. After they were caught, conspicuous cases of rape, looting and other atrocities did not take place. The Chinese have accused Japan about the rape crimes during the war. However, these crimes were definitely caused by the Chinese.
(Part2)About two weeks later, as mentioned in the New York Times on January 4, 1938, Vautrin and other Ginling College professors got to know that the Chinese officers harbored by them had repeatedly raped in the Nanking Safety Zone and then blamed Japanese soldiers for their attacks. The New York Times reported, “(the) American professors…were seriously embarrassed to discover (it).” So would Rabe and McCallum have been.
(Part1)Minnie Vautrin, a professor at the college, wrote 100 girls were raped by Japanese soldiers in her diary on Dec 16, 1937. Also, John Rabe, the leader of the Nanking Safety Zone, wrote in 17th that 1,000 women and girls are said to have been raped last night. James McCallum, a medical doctor in Nanking, wrote about rape crimes in his diary in 19th. However, these cases of rape were what these Westerners heard about from Chinese people.
(Part2)If the 'Nanking Massacre, had actually existed, there might have been some motivation. Indeed it was an argument of motivation that the Prosecution never tried to dispute so far. The Japanese had no 'policy to exterminate the Chinese'. The Prosecution explained that the motive was to threaten Chinese people. But no evidences were shown to prove it.
(Part1)no Japanese high officials had ever become aware of the 'Nanking Massacre'.In those days Japan had no motive for conducting the mass killing of the Chinese citizens. In Germany, the holocaust, which might be frequently compared with the so-called 'Nanking Massacre' recently, was driven from a 'dominant motive' under the 'policy for extermination of Jewish people'.
@yomommacello - 1. Some Japanese found admirably and did not surrender. Others acted extremely dishonorably like in this case. 2. Japan has been very reluctant to admit its crimes during WWII.
@yomommacello every nation that goes for war should be ashamed of itself because there is no reason for the usage of weapons against other life.But i think these killings also like the german did or the russians is or was usual to controll the countries people.Furthermore japan said its soldiers like hitler did too chinese people are men of 2nd class like a race thats not worth to live.THis may not an excuse but i hope u can see that things like that happen if war starts so lets keep away fromit
read "the rape of nanking" by iris chang. these scenes are historically accurate. this was rape and murder on a colossal scale, and performed by the common soldiery. there was no one great madman; they were all devils.
moonbeamchaos 3 days ago
The Chinese soldiers were cornered and threw away military uniforms in Nanking. Then they deprived Chinese inhabitants of plain clothes .Thus the Chinese soldiers violated the international law "Hague Convention on land warfare " as the plain-clothes soldiers . In other words they became no civilians but illegal terrorists.Therefore they were sentenced to death.
SOVIETasTheINVADER 5 days ago
@SOVIETasTheINVADER Your an idiot HAHAHAHAHAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAAAAAAAAAA
metaflux2 5 days ago
The Chinese plain-clothes soldiers that had the ability to shoot Japanese soldiers,were very dangerous .The Chinese terrorists' conducts endangered the rule of the war and Chinese citizens. They weren't soldiers but war criminals.Therefore, they were not protected in Hague Convention.
SOVIETasTheINVADER 5 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(Part2)The majority of women were raped and some were brutally killed. Only around 60 Japanese civilians survived, but much of the city was destroyed in the fighting. This massacre was occurred in July 1937, which means before the so-called Nanking Massacre. How much Chinese killing way of the Tungchow Mutiny is similar to the so-called Nanking Massacre?
The Nanking Massacre was born from Chinese imaginations and created by Kuomintang of China.
undertakerRach 6 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(Part1)The Tungchow Mutiny (Chinese: 通州事件) was an assault on Japanese civilians and troops by East Hopei Army in Tungchow, China on 29 July 1937. Shortly after the Marco Polo Bridge Incident that marked the official beginning of the Second Sino-Japanese War. 250 civilian residents of Tungchow were killed in the uprising (predominantly Japanese reserves, including police and ethnic Korean-Japanese).
undertakerRach 6 days ago
(Part3) Chiang wanted the Chinese people to say they were injured by the Japanese. That’s why; the Chinese claimed “we were injured by Japanese.
How can people believe the massacre was caused by Japanese?
undertakerRach 2 weeks ago
@undertakerRach i wish i have your job..
xxlap2xx 6 days ago
(Part2)Moreover, China paid some foreigners to write false stories in newspaper articles and a book. Chinese victims couldn’t receive any medical treatment for they had no money. Chinese injured wanted to get treatments in hospital and Chiang Kai-shek wanted to have many victims who were hurt by the Japanese because Chiang wanted to appeal the Japanese false brutally acts to the world.
undertakerRach 2 weeks ago
(Part1)How can Japanese admit the wrong history such as the Nanking Massacre? No evidence of the Nanking Massacre. The Nanking population was increased after Japan controlled the city. Many witnesses confessed they had not watched any crime scenes about Nanking Massacre. Chinese government reported the documents written on the number of dead bodies were 20,000, which number was the same number of Chinese soldiers. Also China fabricated 143 pictures of the Nanking Massacre.
undertakerRach 2 weeks ago
killing is killing japan is guilty for mass murder so is china so is brittain, germany,russa, USA every country in that war kill civialains on mass and each plays stupid when asked
mrhedgepig 1 month ago
Shit just got real.
MisterHeizenberg 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
日本人是狗
Japanese is a DOG
k23000000 1 month ago
Napoleon Bonaparte once said of China, "Let her sleep, for when she wakes, she will shake the world."
bunnyrabbit008 2 months ago
(Part1)According to Summary report on the Investigation of Japanese war crimes committed in Nanking, prepared by the Procurator of the District Court in Nanking, to prepare for the IMTFE, the KMT set up the Nanking Investigation Committee for Antagonists Crime on November 7, 1945, and appealed to the Chinese public to report Japanese Army's crimes. It was reported, however, that few responded to the crimes committed by Japanese Army
kaito8209 2 months ago
(Part2) and some refused to testify or to deny the massacre occurred when they were asked for details.Then, the KMT reluctantly submitted the tentative report to the IMTFE on January 20, 1946. Except for one testimony made by a man named Lu Su, no other evidence of massacre by the Japanese Army was available, besides burial records.
東京裁判における南京大虐殺関連のレポートを読んでみると、おもしろいことが解ってくる。1945年11月、中国側は東京裁判に向けて日本人の蛮行証拠を集めるなどの準備をやり始めた。
しかし、当初それらの証拠は集まらないばかりか、虐殺行為を否定するものまでいた。その後何とかして集めたのはLu Suという中国人のみの証言であったのだ。
kaito8209 2 months ago
Although around 2:04 is purely an exaggeration, it is still for sure that the Japanese military had executed many prisoners and civilians as well.
I'm not going to discuss the "numbers" of how many people were killed in Nanking (Japanese claim around 30,000+ while Chinese figures have said 300,000+), but we cannot deny that we still had killed a LOT of people.
It's been decades after that ordeal, I hope that both sides become much better friends (I know that isn't easy but... just a hope).
YoshiEatsWasabi 2 months ago in playlist IuliCata85 さんのその他の動画
The Japanese killed many Chinese people? I don’t think so. John Rabe sent a letter of appreciation to the commander of Japanese army on Dec. 14 1937. This is the letter. 「Dear Sirs. We express our appreciation to your artillery’s praiseworthy act of having not attacked the safety zone and for becoming able to communicate with you (commander Matsui) about the future plan for supporting Chinese citizens in the same area. 」 (Stenography No.210).
undertakerRach 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@undertakerRach That's a school or church size safety zone. how about what happened out of the zone? How can you explain the photos, the says of the survives? Even the Jap solidiers confess what happened. Now, you still try to cover it?!
justicelogic 1 month ago
@undertakerRach
Right, just like the Nazi denied of mistreating the Jews, only escorting them into concentration camps for detaining purpose.
Luckybobnumber4 1 month ago
@Luckybobnumber4 Part1)The 'Nanking Massacre' in which the Prosecution claims the 'massacre of 300,000', has never been so proved. However, any other unjustifiable killings by Japanese troops are regarded as punishable war crimes during the battles against the Chinese Army, and these should be processed under the international humanitarian law. On the other hand, in case of Germany, they were not fighting the war against the Jewish people.
undertakerRach 1 month ago
@Luckybobnumber4 (Part2) The large-scale slaughters targeting all the Jewish people, including the killings of Jewish people who had German citizenship, committed by the Nazi Germany were systematically planned killings based on the specific ethnic ideology which had no direct connection with the war. Those killings were, indeed, the 'crimes against humanity', and those crimes are fundamentally different from the 'war crimes' which the Japanese troops were said to have committed.
undertakerRach 1 month ago
@Luckybobnumber4 (Part3) Not only so, Japanese must say that there existed the crucial fact that the then Japanese government sternly refused the persecution policy against the Jewish people which the Nazi Germany was implementing, even though Japan had amicable relations with Germany by means of concluding the Anti-Comintern Pact during that time when the battle of Nanking occurred.
undertakerRach 1 month ago
@Luckybobnumber4 (Part4)In December 1938, almost one year after the battle of Nanking, the Japanese Government decided the policy that 'based on the spirit of racial equality which we have insisted on for many years, we will treat the Jewish people with fairness, in the same manner as we treat other foreigners and we will not take special measures to reject them.
You should study first and write comments.
undertakerRach 1 month ago
@undertakerRach Bullcrap. They may not have attached artillery-wise or anything but they sure did other messed up sh*t. Did u not just view the video???
74Amaterasu 1 month ago
@74Amaterasu The Nanking Massacre was a false story which was just a rumor creating by China. If the Chinese say the massacre was true story, they should show conclusive evidence. I have written so many Chinese people, but nobody has written the evidence. Nanking believers have appealed the story is true to the world, but it is not indefinite. Moreover, some evidence such as pictures and videos was created by China.
How people can believe the story without evidence?
undertakerRach 1 month ago
@undertakerRach At the same time, evidence can be fabricated, erased, or tapered with. This event occurred on a massive scale and there is evidence, you just need to look for it. So many people have accounts about this happening. And how do you know if this is really propaganda? All governments have some form of propaganda.
Would you accuse the Jewish people and government their story on the Holocaust was propaganda? There is evidence they were tortured, killed and the Jewish say it happened.
74Amaterasu 1 month ago
@74Amaterasu (Part1)I am accusing Nazi as the same as Japan accused German before. Nazi were not fighting the war against the Jewish people. The large-scale slaughters targeting all the Jewish people, including the killings of Jewish people who had German citizenship, committed by the Nazi Germany were systematically planned killings based on the specific ethnic ideology which had no direct connection with the war. Those killings were, indeed, the 'crimes against humanity',///
undertakerRach 1 month ago
@74Amaterasu (Part2)/// and those crimes are fundamentally different from the 'war crimes' which the Japanese troops were said to have committed. Not only so, Japanese must say that there existed the crucial fact that the then Japanese government sternly refused the persecution policy against the Jewish people which the Nazi was implementing, even though Japan had amicable relations with Germany by means of concluding the Anti-Comintern Pact during that time when the battle of Nanking occurred.
undertakerRach 1 month ago
@74Amaterasu (Part3)In December 1938, almost one year after the battle of Nanking, the Japanese Government decided the policy that 'based on the spirit of racial equality which we have insisted on for many years, we will treat the Jewish people with fairness, in the same manner as we treat other foreigners and we will not take special measures to reject them.
undertakerRach 1 month ago
@74Amaterasu (Part4)Chinese people think the Japanese war crime and Nazi crimes in the same category, but the Nanking Massacre was a false charge. This case show how much they have not learned right history.
I am not your baby sitter, so please study right history and write your comments. Shame on you.
undertakerRach 1 month ago
@undertakerRach so are you going to say what happened to the Jews is false?
74Amaterasu 1 month ago
sặc bọn Japan giết nhiêu người china thê . ac đọc thật. họ thât la đáng thương
tanhoangtu1 2 months ago
A photo has displayed at the Nanking Massacre Museum. The caption said, "The Japanese rounded up thousands of women. Most of them were gang raped or forced into military prostitution. But this photo appeared in the Asahi Graph, a weekly photo journal, published in Japan on Nov 10, 1937, about one month before Nanking battle. The explanation says, "A group of women and children from the Rising Sun Village returning from the fields, guarded by our soldiers." China loves fabricating pictures.
undertakerRach 2 months ago
@undertakerRach FABRICATING ur fucking ass, ur fuck ,, r u chinese? u fucking shit, if u don't no anything, shut ur fuck up, i ll kill u , u shit bitch, fuck !
FRANK22131 6 days ago
@FRANK22131 How?
undertakerRach 6 days ago
@F (Part1)The 228 Massacre was an anti-government uprising in Taiwan that began on February 27, 1947 and was violently suppressed by the Kuomintang (KMT) government. Before the 228 massacre was broke out, the mood of the crowd, which had already been harboring many feelings of frustration from KMT rule, reached breaking point. The KMT troops who came from mainland China were highly undisciplined, looting, stealing, and contributing to the overall breakdown of infrastructure and public services.
undertakerRach 6 days ago
@FRANK22131 (Part2)Estimates of the number of deaths vary from ten thousand to thirty thousand or more. According to the New York Times on March 29, 1947, an American said, gTroops from China arrived at Taiwan on March 7 and indulged in three days of indiscriminate killing and looting. For a time everyone seen on the streets was shot at, homes were broken into and occupants killed. In the poorer sections the streets were said to have been littered with dead.
undertakerRach 6 days ago
@FRANK22131 (Part3)There were instances of beheadings and mutilation of bodies, and women were raped.h This is the Chinese inherent characteristics. The Nanking Massacre might have been have caused by KMT soldiers. In fact, R.J Rummel claims that Chinese peasants often had no less to fear from their own soldiers than they did from the Japanese. Moreover, KMT soldiers in the Nanking castle in their mad rush to discard their military uniforms and put on civilian clothes.
undertakerRach 6 days ago
@FRANK22131 (Part4)In a number of incidents, killed civilians to obtain their clothing in Nanking city in 1937 before the Japanese troops entered to the Nanking castle. James Espy, the vice American Council at Nanking, reported to the American Embassy. Go back to the 228 massacre story, Chen Yi, the ROC authorities, had jailed or killed all the leading Taiwanese organizers he could identify and catch.
undertakerRach 6 days ago
@FRANK22131 (Part5)His troops executed between 3,000 and 4,000 people. Chen Yi was later quoted by TIME magazine in April 7, 1947 as saying: "It took the Japs 51 years to dominate this island. I expect to take about five years to re-educate the people so they will be happier with Chinese administration." This fact shows they were mind controlled by the Chinese government? The Nanking Massacre was a fake story. In fact, Chinese school kids have learned anti-Japanese education.
undertakerRach 6 days ago
@undertakerRach ：u shot the Fuck up ... fuck u ! i want to ask u? r u a chinese? em ?does japanese killed chinese people or not? did they came to our country to kill to rob? so please shut u fuck up,,, u fucker,,,!i don't no u, but if i c u , im sure i ll kill u myself, u fuck !
FRANK22131 6 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
" This is a made-up story. Nonsense! fuck China! "
That it is!
FuckCHNCommunist 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
For reference... Fiction,All and Nonsense
ttp://tamezou.tripod.com/nanking/alleged/
FuckCHNCommunist 3 months ago
Одни мартышки перебили других. :)))))))
TheSamael1972 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is a made-up story. Nonsense! fuck China!
jq6uhb 3 months ago
I despise the liberals who gloss over these atrocities committed by Japan and focus instead on Japan being the victim of our firebombing/A-Bombs. Japan deserved everything it got...and should've gotten more.
Springbok295 3 months ago
@Springbok295 what are you talking about liberals? Im a liberal and I dont think those a-bombs were big enough.
xOrion89x 3 months ago
Notice how everyone thinks movies from china is always propaganda no matter what it is,whether its a romantic or war movie, they just straight up declare it to be some kind of chinese propaganda,yet,they buy into movies like ryan or such and think it is the most touching stroy ever made, and believe their governments are the honest-lincolns who care for nothing but its people....LOL peace to all no hates, and respect
Jake4595 3 months ago 15
@Jake4595 1 day ,1 day ,, Japanese ll pay for everything for what they did in China!!!
FRANK22131 6 days ago
long live china
Slagar1000 3 months ago
what happened to the children at 7:00 :\
DaAsianArtist 3 months ago
Fuck chinese dogs. We Taiwanese will massacre them when we get the chance.
HowYaDoingMon 4 months ago
@HowYaDoingMon what did they do to you?
themultiplayer1 3 months ago
@HowYaDoingMon Dude what the poop hopefully u ment the japs
JLOStudios 3 months ago
@JLOStudios Japs also. But Chinese come first. Oh not all chinese, i mean just communists.
HowYaDoingMon 3 months ago
@HowYaDoingMon And why that? You are left in peace right now, you people from Taiwan. Be grateful for that.
Alsemenor 3 months ago
@Alsemenor Be grateful of what? We owe the Communists nothing.
HowYaDoingMon 3 months ago
@HowYaDoingMon Maybe not, but they havent invaded you yet. So, be happy because of that. And why do you hate the communists so much?
Alsemenor 3 months ago
@Alsemenor Be happy? You have no idea what they already done to us for the last two decades, ok? Go read a book before questioning me.
HowYaDoingMon 3 months ago
@HowYaDoingMon I ask you. Tell me.
Alsemenor 3 months ago
@Alsemenor Go read. Its good for you.
HowYaDoingMon 3 months ago
@HowYaDoingMon Why is it hard to tell me? Maybe you just cant explain it, and rely on other sources to tell the things you think is the truth?
Alsemenor 3 months ago
@Alsemenor Because there is a reason why you study books. If teachers can just tell you all the knowledge, books wouldnt exist, would it? Why should I tell you something I spent so much time studying for?
HowYaDoingMon 3 months ago
@HowYaDoingMon To prove your point more valuable. Cursing the Chinese and brag about how you will massacer them dont really make you, neither your opinion, so valuable.
Alsemenor 3 months ago
@Alsemenor when did i give a damn about being more valuable? lol, are you just trying to troll here?
HowYaDoingMon 3 months ago
@HowYaDoingMon I am not trolling at all. the video is about how the Japanese are bruutaly slaughtering Chinese prisoners! And you come here and start talking about how the Taiwanese will slaughter the chinese. It seems like trolling to me. Just because i think that your opinions and arguments are invalid do not make me a troll!
Alsemenor 3 months ago
@JLOStudios not that im siding japan for this argument...but taiwanese r actually a little bit positive towards jap than any other asian countries since japan innovated the tech in taiwan. that's wat i heard from my taiwanese friends
rorschachnite121 3 months ago
@rorschachnite121 oh ok
JLOStudios 3 months ago
Respond to this video... whats with this huge conversation i started up
JLOStudios 3 months ago
@HowYaDoingMon Oh yes i know what you mean now yes yes....
JLOStudios 3 months ago
Imperial Japan>China
UnstoppableDestiny 4 months ago
I'm from Nanjing, and my gramps is a survivor of the war.
wanxinmike 4 months ago
can u show me this book ?
SuperVNMan 4 months ago
THE SOUNDS OF HE DOG . HAHAHA CHINESE
SuperVNMan 4 months ago
@SuperVNMan hey little boy,read your history book(s) again, if you had ever studied it. Vietnamese has Chinese ancestors. your ancestors must be mad at u for calling them a dog now. how 'filial' you are. Oh yeah, at least Chinese like me can spell English words properly and have load more manners than u people. Fancy calling people dogs when you are no better.
stahitlinlerrednaz 4 months ago
When Japan's government refuses to atone and offer to pay for crimes of WWII, they also hide from crimes to their own people. For example Fukujima nuclear explosion was not disclosed to their own people. Lie to us once, maybe forgive but not forget, lie to me twice, YOU shall never forget - EVER!
OnePeopleOneChina 4 months ago
what goes around comes around aka Earthquake tsunami haa
saag888 4 months ago
支那人はどこまで歴史をでっち上げれば気が済むんだ？
やってることが朝鮮人と同じだぞ？
大中華たる悠久の歴史があるのなら恥を知れ恥を。
Itirinjin 4 months ago
@Itirinjin
Still, a little Japneis refuse to face the truth. But unfortunately, truth hurts.
=)))
maomao667 4 months ago
@Itirinjin あなたの父のアメリカのお尻に、ふしだら雌を舐めてください。
MilkAnime 3 months ago
Korea feels the pain what china went through.....
lilaznthug510 4 months ago
@lilaznthug510 actually korea felt the most pain compared to china...we've been pretty much done the same thing for more than 40 yrs..
rorschachnite121 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why Chinese government paid money to Harold Timperley for writing book What War Means which was written about so-called the Nanking Massacre?
norinkara59 5 months ago
(Part4)Lewis S. C. Smythe, professor of Nanking University investigated the population with the help of many Chinese staffs on February 1938. He wrote a report which shows the population of Nanking was 250,000 or 270,000 as of the end of March 1938. The Nanking City Administrative Office of the Nanking Restoration Government, which was established on March 28, 1938, registered 277,000 inhabitants. Japanese soldiers killed 300,000 Chinese people in Nanking city?
undertakerRach 5 months ago
@undertakerRach You may dispute minor statistics, but fact remains - JAPAN INVADED CHINA!
Have you ever asked yourself WHY Japan was EVER in China?
OnePeopleOneChina 4 months ago
@OnePeopleOneChina Why China shoot a gun to the Japanese camp first?
Do you know the Second United Front?
You should study first and write your comment.
undertakerRach 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(Part3) For TSZC, it was absolutely necessary to know the accurate number of people in order to distribute food to those refugees. After the Japanese victory and occupation took place, TSZC in its document dated on December 17, and in subsequent documents, consistently recognized this number. Afterwards how did the population of Nanking change? TSZC documents read that in January 1938 the population was 250,000.
undertakerRach 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(Part2)As the result, there were no people within the castle except in the Safety Zone. John Rabe, the Safety Zone Committee (TSZC) member, wrote in his diary in Dec 10, when the Nanking battle began, the Nanking population was 200,000. TSZC described in the Document No.9 dated in Dec 17, "On the 13th when the Japanese entered the city, we had nearly all the civilian population in the Safety Zone, so the number 200,000 is no doubt.
undertakerRach 5 months ago
(Part1)Chinese government has claimed Japanese soldiers killed 300,000 Chinese civilians while the Japanese were staying in Nanking city in China. After the Japanese occupation, did the population of Nanking decrease by more than 300,000? Let’s look at many historical records. On Dec 8,1937， Tang Sheng-zhi, who was Chinese commander, warned that all the noncombatants should assemble in the Safety Zone, and the citizens rushed into the Safety Zone for the safety.
undertakerRach 5 months ago
the Nanking's dialect(nanking native speaking language ) now is totally not the same as in 1937, because the people who spoke Nanking dialect that time were killed. The ancester of the people live in Nanking now were migrated from other parts of Jiangsu province, so the real Nanking native language has disappeared. If Nanking Massacre is fake, why a dialect disappeared?
mount922 5 months ago
Comment removed
mount922 5 months ago
the japans r really friendly people give sweets 2 kids
sterlingmenthol77 5 months ago
Soviet was help chinese :))
tienluat 5 months ago
My Grandfather is a Proud Chinese who fought and killed 9 japanese men even though they ambushed his squad unit in world war 2 I am proud to be called his grandson after what the japanese did to us but i love japanese people
shadowninja8246 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Show me your conclusive evidence about the Nanking Massacre.
哪里尸体30万？为什么许多中国人民回到南京后，日本占领了城市？
なぜ南京市には30万の死体がないの? なぜ日本軍が占領した南京市に中国人がたくさん戻ってきたの?
Where were 300,000 of dead bodies? Why many Chinese people came back to Nanking after Japanese occupied the city?
undertakerRach 6 months ago
Rape scene is fake of CCP.
"The Alleged Nanking Massacre : Japan's rebuttal to China's forged claims"on Amazon in USA
watch?v=qBWxti63Xcw
SOVIETasTheINVADER 6 months ago
Its all in past now.... we should not harbor HATE because of what has happened in the past... all we can do now is stop the chain of hate and pray it wont ever happen again in the future.
MyHiryu101 6 months ago
@MyHiryu101 can't accept it, they should feel what they felt!!!
punksryan 6 months ago
Comment removed
MyHiryu101 6 months ago
I think the scene of the soldiers execution was the most touching moment of the movie.
"China shall not perish" they cried out loud in the last moment of their lives.
So, it did not perish...
It became word's no 1 economic power, well surpassing Japan!!!
Their sucrifice wasn't in vain after all...
stockpicker1966 6 months ago
@stockpicker1966 China isn't actually the world's "no 1" economic power. Its economy is still slightly larger than half the size of the American economy.
Wolfe2469 3 months ago
The Chinese boy soldiers were very cruel during Second Sino-Japanese War. Japanese POW were burned at the stake by the Chinese boy soldiers in Shanghai.
SOVIETasTheINVADER 7 months ago
@SOVIETasTheINVADER As well they should for all the murdering they did. Fuck em.
mountainstandardtime 7 months ago
@SOVIETasTheINVADER That's true and everyone has done terrible things in the past, but do you really think what the Japanese did justifies as anything?
Nitoryuu 6 months ago
rubbish japan army in ww2!
russia68 7 months ago
japanese are no less than hitler
asn711 1 year ago
Yeah this was because of Japan's world domination plan, because they racist to everyone else! So thankfully, their population is decreasing because of them being racist to everyone else in the world.
testerrocksroblox 1 year ago
@testerrocksroblox so are the KKK and they don't seem to be going away
49mozzer 11 months ago
It is said where the Russians broke the back of the German army, the Chinese broke the back of the Japanes army, not the americans. Nothing against the Americans but they mostly fought garrison troops not their elite troops, with the exception of Guadacanal. The British beat the Japanese 15th army in Burma.
species6339 1 year ago
This goes against the japanese text books that say "japanese sodiers acted orderly and respectfuly"
Japan should be ashamed of itself and confess what they did in WW2 was wrong.
yomommacello 1 year ago 30
@yomommacello This movie IS NOT A FICTION !!!! Watch the last part ! At the end !!! You will understand !
IuliCata85 1 year ago 11
This has been flagged as spam show
(Part3)In February, as the Osaka Asahi Shinbun reported, the Japanese military arrested eleven hiding Chinese soldiers who had committed numerous atrocities in Nanking, speaking Japanese and wearing counterfeit of Japanese translator's armband to pose as Japanese. After they were caught, conspicuous cases of rape, looting and other atrocities did not take place. The Chinese have accused Japan about the rape crimes during the war. However, these crimes were definitely caused by the Chinese.
kaito8209 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@IuliCata85
(Part2)About two weeks later, as mentioned in the New York Times on January 4, 1938, Vautrin and other Ginling College professors got to know that the Chinese officers harbored by them had repeatedly raped in the Nanking Safety Zone and then blamed Japanese soldiers for their attacks. The New York Times reported, “(the) American professors…were seriously embarrassed to discover (it).” So would Rabe and McCallum have been.
kaito8209 8 months ago
@IuliCata85
(Part1)Minnie Vautrin, a professor at the college, wrote 100 girls were raped by Japanese soldiers in her diary on Dec 16, 1937. Also, John Rabe, the leader of the Nanking Safety Zone, wrote in 17th that 1,000 women and girls are said to have been raped last night. James McCallum, a medical doctor in Nanking, wrote about rape crimes in his diary in 19th. However, these cases of rape were what these Westerners heard about from Chinese people.
kaito8209 8 months ago
@yomommacello
(Part2)If the 'Nanking Massacre, had actually existed, there might have been some motivation. Indeed it was an argument of motivation that the Prosecution never tried to dispute so far. The Japanese had no 'policy to exterminate the Chinese'. The Prosecution explained that the motive was to threaten Chinese people. But no evidences were shown to prove it.
kaito8209 8 months ago
@yomommacello
日本軍には、南京市民の大虐殺の動機も計画もなかった。
(Part1)no Japanese high officials had ever become aware of the 'Nanking Massacre'.In those days Japan had no motive for conducting the mass killing of the Chinese citizens. In Germany, the holocaust, which might be frequently compared with the so-called 'Nanking Massacre' recently, was driven from a 'dominant motive' under the 'policy for extermination of Jewish people'.
kaito8209 8 months ago
@yomommacello - 1. Some Japanese found admirably and did not surrender. Others acted extremely dishonorably like in this case. 2. Japan has been very reluctant to admit its crimes during WWII.
mariotrooper1000 7 months ago
@yomommacello They were brainwashed they respected there emperer
taigokai 5 months ago
@yomommacello every nation that goes for war should be ashamed of itself because there is no reason for the usage of weapons against other life.But i think these killings also like the german did or the russians is or was usual to controll the countries people.Furthermore japan said its soldiers like hitler did too chinese people are men of 2nd class like a race thats not worth to live.THis may not an excuse but i hope u can see that things like that happen if war starts so lets keep away fromit
TheVincebob 5 months ago
@yomommacello - They are NOT ...... they have no shame in killing Chinese. Unless they are forced to do so which the West are not willing make them!
Charaht 5 months ago
@yomommacello Yeah they respectully followed their orders...to massacre thousands of nationalist soldiers.
DrKorn5 4 months ago
my chinese ancestry cries out to those brave men and women of the war.
paddyspoint2 1 year ago 20
@paddyspoint2 Fuck japs for that they'd done for China :(
XtremeNasism666 4 months ago
brilliant vid series
mav3r1ck69 1 year ago 3