1:41 and onward is my favorite part of this song. It's nothing like the original, so I consider this a different song altogether, rather than a re-make. Balls to the haters, it's much better if you don't think of it as being the original. Because it isn't.
Why did they change the tune?! WHY?! WHY?! This is my favourite movie ending! It was perfect!!!!!!!! In the words of the Mutant Enemy zombie: Grr. Arg.
It's good up until 1:00. I mean, it's OKAY, but... :/ I prefer the original melody. They kind of went off. Everything before 1:00 is BRILLIANT. I like the little twist they put on the opening, but, damn, can't you stick with what you started with? 1:48 is KINDA okay... I mean... it's just... at that point... I feel lost and pretty pissed, which makes it hard to enjoy the rest. -_-'
@MidnaLoveLinkforever The point of this whole album was to remake all the songs. And that's what they did. I'd like a whole song that sounded like the first minute all the way through, but still..
to me the original version of these songs are for children, i guess they're remade it trying to aim for the teen audience and I think for the most part they're successful :)
I think this is an absolutely amazing song if it was just a stand alone song, but as a cover, i don't like it too much. But it is addicting, and its sung by Shiny Toy Guns.
My favorite duet just got positively butchered. Yeah, it's cute, the way they did it, but the haunting melody that Jack and Sally sang it with just fit them both so perfectly. Especially since the tune originally belonged to "Sally's Song" and the end was turned into this uplifting tone that really settled the soul in knowing they were together. If this duet wasn't a cover of the original, then I'd think it was great, but as it stands... no.
I love this song, it does sort of sound like moulin rouge near the end, but it sounds like a marilyn manson song in the beginning. It's the perfect mix!
That was awesome. Shiny Toy Guns did this song justice, they didn't ruin it at all. The beginning was a little iffy but the end was absolutely perfect!
It would have been amazing IF they had stuck to the original melody. And I don't mean not putting a new spin on it, but at least making it recognisable!
This sounds so mixed up. The first version was more harmonic and melodic. Much more sweet like a love ballad wheras this sounds like something somewhat patriotic.
It's kind of killing the spirit, we can't hear the references to other songs like the original (this is halloween, what's this and Sally's song), they don't respect the melody.
I really liked this one. Overall captured the spirit of the song, but I think they should have taken a bit more time between parts. It just felt a bit rushed.
this song is one of the favorites of every true hart rocker..! But guys i have 1 question..please name me the movie that is about JACK...i dont know how to ask for it in the video club..ty..!
i like this one betta than the one from the movie! its more romanic than anything! well at the end it is!!! lol! the beginning is frigin' alsome! i've always liked screaming music!! lol!
It's not bad. Just different. That's why people do covers. To try to take something familiar in a different direction. For the way they did it, it was very good. But yes, I would prefer to hear the original just cause I'm old school like that.
This whole cd sounds like the modernized version of all the musical numbers. Very interesting. It'd probably be this morbid sounding if made today I think.
Hmm... All I have to say about this song is that it's... interesting. Don't like the beginning, but the part w/ Jack and Sally is wonderfully done. 3.5/5
wow, this and making christmas are the saving graces of this entire album. i don't understand how anyone would have thought in their right minds to have Korn, or Plain White T's cover any of these songs on this album. Even Rise Against doing Making Christmas was a stretch, but it worked. Amy Lee's voice is good, but I just despise her whiny, 13 year old personality towards life and the rest of the bands/singers that covered the rest of the songs just are utter trash imo. whatever good song
This is the best NBC cover album ever, my friend lent it to me. After listening to it all the way through the first time my face was almost blasted off with awesomeness!
SO MANY SPELL FAILS ON THE WORD 'BEGINNING' XDDDDDD it makes me laugh as a grammar nerd :P
azngrl2013 3 months ago in playlist nightmare before christmas playlist 5
XD the beginning reminded me of the smurfs singing thier lalalalalalalalalala..!! song only much creepier!
animeghan 3 months ago
Comment removed
Bleachroxulz 3 months ago in playlist nightmare revisited
Nobody knows how to spell "beginning"?
jags1495 4 months ago in playlist More videos from HydraOverlord 12
this song reminds of *tear falls from eye* my lost paper... D'X
ThePageOfRandomness 4 months ago
Amazing!
goldmegaman1000 4 months ago
Who is this by?
Annmarie8632 4 months ago in playlist More videos from HydraOverlord
@Annmarie8632 Shiny Toy Guns
sk8ercbing 4 months ago in playlist Nightmare revisited
@sk8ercbing thanks
Annmarie8632 4 months ago
i fucking love the begging xDD
TheOurworldhelper 5 months ago
YO the beginnig is mad freakin its disney not hell
MILTONKAPLANIDIS 5 months ago
i dont like the song but the begining is awesome
fullmetalrebel1 6 months ago 7
this is my ringtone... and it went off in class...every one was creeped out until the guatair
gonfftheprince 6 months ago 5
FINALLY! this is the song from the soul eater nightmare credits! no1 ever told meh!
huMusicMonster 7 months ago in playlist Nightmare revisited 2
@huMusicMonster it was in the description, you know that, right? XD
dragonlord5665 6 months ago
@dragonlord5665 description? wats a description? X)
huMusicMonster 6 months ago
i luved the begining, middle, and end :D
SUG4L95 7 months ago 6
By the intro I thought this song was going to be different lol
TombstoneGhost 8 months ago
Jessiescorn@ lol before I read your comment that's what I did :P
iismiiler 8 months ago
Not something to listen to in your bedroom all alone... especially not in the dark :/
jessisnacorn 9 months ago 6
@jessisnacorn Actually, I was doing just that not long ago... 0.0 Zomg, the irony!
KaidaMizuki 8 months ago
awesome song!!! i like this version better!!!xD
xxXemogummiebe4rzXxx 9 months ago 2
the finale was ok but the reprise was better. wish it was longer tho
whitegorilla1993 9 months ago
1:41 and onward is my favorite part of this song. It's nothing like the original, so I consider this a different song altogether, rather than a re-make. Balls to the haters, it's much better if you don't think of it as being the original. Because it isn't.
BendyJenny 10 months ago
Why did they change the tune?! WHY?! WHY?! This is my favourite movie ending! It was perfect!!!!!!!! In the words of the Mutant Enemy zombie: Grr. Arg.
Toddy354 10 months ago 3
I liked the first 00:50 seconds,thats it..... -_-
UltraAwesomeRetards 10 months ago
well im gunna go to jail now... i raped the replay button.
disturbing123456 11 months ago 6
Completely unrecognizable from original. Either a good or bad thing
ericaohmg95 11 months ago
Who is singing this??
Trace3690 11 months ago
@Trace3690 I believe its shiny toy guns
BittersweetKitKat 11 months ago
@BittersweetKitKat Thanks :)
Trace3690 11 months ago
I personally LOVE this cover.
MiseriWay 11 months ago
It's pretty good but not reaching my top 3 favorites.
1. Sally's song
2.Kidnap Sandy Claws
3. Jacks Lament
akiraa1996 1 year ago
The beginning creeped me out but as I listened to it more I started loving it!!!
katy6663 1 year ago 4
I take back what I said about Sally's Song, that is my SECOND favorite track...
THIS is my favorite track. I LOVE SHINEY TOY GUNS AND WHAT THEY DID TO THIS SONG! <3
ScreamxxNobuko 1 year ago
ok, up to about 1:00 it's awesome, and metal-y then 1:01 - 1:41 was kinda dumb, then 1:48 - was AWESOME i w i
DMCRtheShadowFighter 1 year ago 2
i really like this song but people who hate this listend to flyleaf version of what this u be like this is a better song then flyleaf
punkXroxXprincess81 1 year ago
Hehe, when i first heard this i thought they were singing 'Jack's so GAY and he's really GAY' i was like O_O
then i realised they wernt saying that at all [':
GeeGhastly 1 year ago 3
in all honestly i wasnt impressed with this album at all marlyn amy lee and korn were the only reason to listen to it but ehh watever
dammit066 1 year ago 3
shiny toy guns epic :D
12luney 1 year ago
1st minute of it; awesome! the rest of it, awful XP
DMCxLover13 1 year ago
Heck no.
edelricandkidmikk 1 year ago
No.
TheLastLoneWolf 1 year ago
It's good up until 1:00. I mean, it's OKAY, but... :/ I prefer the original melody. They kind of went off. Everything before 1:00 is BRILLIANT. I like the little twist they put on the opening, but, damn, can't you stick with what you started with? 1:48 is KINDA okay... I mean... it's just... at that point... I feel lost and pretty pissed, which makes it hard to enjoy the rest. -_-'
MidnaLoveLinkforever 1 year ago
@MidnaLoveLinkforever The point of this whole album was to remake all the songs. And that's what they did. I'd like a whole song that sounded like the first minute all the way through, but still..
fretburn100 1 year ago 2
I really enjoy the beginning of this song. I wish it kept the tune throughout.
DapperEra 1 year ago
DUUUUUDE I THINK I'M POSSESSED D:
ulquiXgrimm 1 year ago 3
THIS SOUNDS EVIL!!!! IT"S GOING TO KILL ME IN MY SLEEP!!!!
I love that!
TheAnjelHarte 1 year ago 3
makes me wish life was just as beautiful as this song.
firedragoo22 1 year ago
it's good until they mess it up. then i hate it.
KiropLokiIncarnate 1 year ago
Love Shiny toy guns.
giristhebest13 1 year ago
"sounds creepy" lol
pumpkinking98 1 year ago 6
LALALALALALALALALALALALALALALALA!!!
TheEGNStudios 1 year ago 24
Who SIngs this track?
DrillTeam99 1 year ago
@DrillTeam99 shiny toy guns
shane87smith 1 year ago
we're simply meant to be
shane87smith 1 year ago
The eerie christmas music box and whispers saying la la la sound like dead children haunting the living. lol XD
TeddyxBearsxDarling 1 year ago 103
Oh...! It's this song.... I see. Sick.
4SHURelsa 1 year ago
@4SHURelsa my thoughts exactly :3. i still like it, tho
only4fuzzy1 1 year ago
best song on the whole album =D
SuperAcidAngel 1 year ago
I must be the only NBC fan to actually love the duet in the second half. It's cute IMO, and the original is cute too! :D
BethGoth15 1 year ago 5
@BethGoth15 Are you kidding me? that's my main reason to listen to the song! =D =D I ,3 that bit, so sweet! =3
eviedream 1 year ago
@BethGoth15 I knoo! It's adorable lol
SweeneyTodd98 1 year ago
Comment removed
megam48 1 year ago
Love the Movie
Love the CD
BEST MOVIE IN THE WORLD
Darkwolf971 1 year ago 6
who sings this?
xscwablex 1 year ago
@xscwablex Shiny Toy Guns
CreepyDollGirlx5 1 year ago
@CreepyDollGirlx5 thanks!
xscwablex 1 year ago
@xscwablex Yup! ^_^
CreepyDollGirlx5 1 year ago
@xscwablex Shiny Toy Guns.
kamuaibxtches 1 year ago
I really just like the "lalalalalalas"
lizzielollipop816 1 year ago 6
This song is awesome up untill about 1:08 :/
C00kieProductions 1 year ago 4
@C00kieProductions
about 0:55 realy
pililj 1 year ago
they should have done Jak's Lament
invadermary 1 year ago
XD lol, lalala...
invadermary 1 year ago
I only like the first part but the rest changes completely
Daemonologist 1 year ago 2
annnnnd now i can't sleep.
stickdudeking777 1 year ago
lalalalalalalalala.....LALALALALALA!!!! HAHA why do i find that funny?!
molly1002 1 year ago 20
@molly1002 i find it funny too xD
hepioAnn 1 year ago
to me the original version of these songs are for children, i guess they're remade it trying to aim for the teen audience and I think for the most part they're successful :)
ROSE911GUNDAM 1 year ago 6
I love this song sooo much. Its the best!!!!
DareTheDominguez 1 year ago 4
O.O omg i love it....
Nikohost 1 year ago
lalalala lalalala, LALALAALLALAAA!!! LALLLAHHLLAHHLL!!!1!!!
pieguyfry22 1 year ago 3
I think this is an absolutely amazing song if it was just a stand alone song, but as a cover, i don't like it too much. But it is addicting, and its sung by Shiny Toy Guns.
TheShankApotimus 1 year ago
Who is this?? Wow I love their sound
FalseDisposition 1 year ago
My favorite duet just got positively butchered. Yeah, it's cute, the way they did it, but the haunting melody that Jack and Sally sang it with just fit them both so perfectly. Especially since the tune originally belonged to "Sally's Song" and the end was turned into this uplifting tone that really settled the soul in knowing they were together. If this duet wasn't a cover of the original, then I'd think it was great, but as it stands... no.
DottyStreet 1 year ago
I love this song, it does sort of sound like moulin rouge near the end, but it sounds like a marilyn manson song in the beginning. It's the perfect mix!
inuyasha846891 1 year ago
Everything past 50 seconds is terrible
austinfromidiocy 1 year ago
wow this blows butcherd the movie. maybe an alright emo song but nothin on danny
cigaro208 1 year ago
the beginng kicks ass
xXKBkillaxX1 1 year ago
That was awesome. Shiny Toy Guns did this song justice, they didn't ruin it at all. The beginning was a little iffy but the end was absolutely perfect!
DontThrowTheCupcake 1 year ago
begining rules rest of song got raped
tjreeseman 1 year ago
O_o Jack and sally sing it better.
wreathofpalmaria 1 year ago
LOL Who sings this? It sounds like Mulan Rouge!!!!
Nicole Kidman and..that guy!
Cymon3 1 year ago
I JUST LOVE IT! Shiny toy guns made it great 5 stars Yo! I kinda dident like the rest after "In the town of halloween" its meaningless after that
Samlai123 2 years ago 3
I love the beginning
Is so cool
jimena961 2 years ago 9
Not sure about the first half, but the ending is beautiful.
ScottyMcGeester 2 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fuck this version. ORIGINAL ALL THE WAY!!!!!
PyromanicMisfit27 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
holly shit! all emo dies!
darkzing 2 years ago
wow that was actually surprisingly good lol!
JdtKids 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i know
i loved the original movie, and it kindof makes me mad they'd ruin it with alot of the songs, especially this one
they even messed up the beat and tune
kuroikyuketsuki 2 years ago
It would have been amazing IF they had stuck to the original melody. And I don't mean not putting a new spin on it, but at least making it recognisable!
carameltoff 2 years ago 72
@carameltoff Same for some of the others. I like this, but I know what you mean.
no1caresanymore 1 year ago
I like the first version more.
This sounds so mixed up. The first version was more harmonic and melodic. Much more sweet like a love ballad wheras this sounds like something somewhat patriotic.
NgocChau12 2 years ago 7
Don't like this version.
It's kind of killing the spirit, we can't hear the references to other songs like the original (this is halloween, what's this and Sally's song), they don't respect the melody.
UnbirthXXI 2 years ago 8
Shiny Toy Guns + The Nightmare Before Christmas = Pure Amazingness!!! LOVED it!
MassacrePrincess03 2 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
OMG...what did they do to the awesome Danny Elfman version...damn money grabber disney... :-(
FriedChicken6 2 years ago
jacks ok thank god lol love this song espeshaly th bgening of this vershion
skellicopter 2 years ago
I actually prefer the original...
Trey2148 2 years ago 3
omg i love this song! its one of the best song to get stuck in you head ^-^
LittleWaterlily101 2 years ago 6
I really liked this one. Overall captured the spirit of the song, but I think they should have taken a bit more time between parts. It just felt a bit rushed.
pixienymph 2 years ago 2
whoa, it actually kind of freaked me out at first
ca1cifer 2 years ago 3
omg me to
babbs123456789 2 years ago
Love the harmony at the end.
Xynrei 2 years ago 5
Absolutely Lovely, it's very addicting!
sWeEtLyCoRrUpTeD 2 years ago 4
Beautiful reprise...T______T
ShadowClark143 2 years ago
At 1:00 sounds like "Time" by Pink Floyd.
Tentauren 2 years ago
pretty badass man
fb101786 2 years ago
i don't really like shiny toy guns but i like this alot
dahlia533 2 years ago 2
This song is so awsome! I aspeacially like the opening! XD
GolemGuardian 2 years ago 3
I'm addicted to this song!!! LOVE IT SOOOO MUCH!!
Rock2U2Forever 2 years ago 66
LOVE Shiny Toy Guns!!
serenitymclean 2 years ago
aww i always love the ending as creepy as it sounds :)
SweeneyTodd98 2 years ago 5
this song is one of the favorites of every true hart rocker..! But guys i have 1 question..please name me the movie that is about JACK...i dont know how to ask for it in the video club..ty..!
IZaakTheGreek 2 years ago
the movie is called ''the nightmare before christmas''
maithiu 2 years ago
i Effing love this album there is NO track 2 skip !!! But the only thing i don't like is that "oogie boogies song" has no vocals at all -_-'
justafidemyself 2 years ago 2
listen to the "Tiger Army" version
vocal included, and it actually sounds like the original
CrimzonRegret 2 years ago
OMG I friggin love this cover!
i can't even begin to describe its awesomeness <3
love it to the max ;)
haChristy 2 years ago 3
love it!!!!
LuvzHugz 2 years ago
the effin best!
bohemianblueeyes7 2 years ago
la la la la la la..la la la la la la..LA LA LA LA LA LA LA!!!!! i love that part..
gambit2479 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
gambit2479 2 years ago
love it!
TheCokeAddictedWolf6 2 years ago
this is so creepy I love it!
SweetMusicbabii 2 years ago 7
SHINY TOY GUNS! lol i never knew that. i love them
slipknotcupcakes 2 years ago
i like this one betta than the one from the movie! its more romanic than anything! well at the end it is!!! lol! the beginning is frigin' alsome! i've always liked screaming music!! lol!
slaughterkristen 2 years ago
is this everyone off the album together?
youcocksmoker 2 years ago
Wow, this is my fave one that sounds totally different from the original. Very pretty.
Keybord=Epic win :D
WOLFFDEPPSPONGEBOB 2 years ago 2
i love it
kellykat32 2 years ago
i love this version =]
ZiMzNeWIrKeNGiRl 2 years ago
It's not that bad. At least it's interesting. =]
lamppost10 2 years ago
who did this one?
Nixiehatesu2 2 years ago
dude this song is by shiny toy gun i own the cd and i cant ever get enough of any of the songs
psychosematichollow 2 years ago 3
this one's by Shiny Toy Guns
cannibalcupid911 2 years ago
that bad? its not bad at all from what I heard, interesting sounds, awesome intro, wonderful love duet thing going, and a smooth end.
grandsaga 2 years ago
i've heard worse. this honestly isnt THAT bad. it has SOME positive points to it.
foamysworshipper 2 years ago
I don't like the beginning, but apart from that it's really okay. I like the organ and the ending is really sweet.
sunfreckledmoonchild 2 years ago
It's not bad. Just different. That's why people do covers. To try to take something familiar in a different direction. For the way they did it, it was very good. But yes, I would prefer to hear the original just cause I'm old school like that.
DesertWarriorBoy 2 years ago 2
EXACTLY. That's one of the things I like about music; It's always different to other people because of how other people interpret it!
TheGrimRater 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
XO ow my ears are bleeding this sucks
kingman1245 2 years ago
OUCH!!! my ears are bleeding too! u wanna know why? cuz i have to listen to u complain about something amazing!!! bahahaha!! XD
jackskellingtonjojo 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
8===D eat it!!!
kingman1245 2 years ago
Comment removed
jackskellingtonjojo 2 years ago
Yeah real mature.
Crystil17 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i dont like this verison its just yelling its really annoying
PookieBearDaisy 2 years ago
if u actually listened to the whole song, its only the beginning they yell. the rest is actual singing. very good singing, btw.
jackskellingtonjojo 2 years ago 6
Um...IT'S NOT ALL SCREAMING!!!
dragonluver123 2 years ago 3
AWESOME!! <3
halloweenangel13 2 years ago 5
i like the nightmare revisited CD/soundtrack thing because its like disney gone dark xD its awesome
Salidore 2 years ago 9
This whole cd sounds like the modernized version of all the musical numbers. Very interesting. It'd probably be this morbid sounding if made today I think.
Pawkit 2 years ago
1 of the best songs!shiny toy guns or jack and sally the song is still awesome!!
exorsist234 2 years ago
what is this band called like?
dasveit 2 years ago
i like this one but i think "mr. sandy claws" that KoRn redid would have to be my fave.
sorsa1249 2 years ago 2
fuck yes!
mrfizy 2 years ago
God that intro was EPIC.!
cheezhunter 2 years ago 4
luv this song
Junkyty 2 years ago
This is Shiny Toy Guns.
lmpnizkit 2 years ago
Hmm... All I have to say about this song is that it's... interesting. Don't like the beginning, but the part w/ Jack and Sally is wonderfully done. 3.5/5
LePhantomessa 2 years ago
is it me or does 0:15 - 0:24 sound like jenifer tilly :)
VeronicaXMouse 2 years ago
who sings this? cobra starship?
bananaxmeat 2 years ago
nope its shiny toy guns :)
XxgaarasxluverxX 2 years ago
Ehehe, beginning is the best part xD
XxSpottedxShadowxX 2 years ago
Wow, Iike the beginning. and the rest too
MoonlightSkelet0n 2 years ago
wow, this and making christmas are the saving graces of this entire album. i don't understand how anyone would have thought in their right minds to have Korn, or Plain White T's cover any of these songs on this album. Even Rise Against doing Making Christmas was a stretch, but it worked. Amy Lee's voice is good, but I just despise her whiny, 13 year old personality towards life and the rest of the bands/singers that covered the rest of the songs just are utter trash imo. whatever good song
melloncollieromance 2 years ago
Holy crap. This is awesome XD
killagame2006 2 years ago 5
This is the best NBC cover album ever, my friend lent it to me. After listening to it all the way through the first time my face was almost blasted off with awesomeness!
handmiadenofgod 2 years ago
The first time I listened to this I almost pissed my pants at the beginning.
cheezhunter 2 years ago
... SCREAMING IN MY HEAD! Wau.
Glaerdrune 2 years ago
holy friggin shit the beginning creeped the hell out of me
doodoo13ird 2 years ago