it is very touching song yesterday i watched a video about the hollercaust and that was the baking track was mad world and i nearly cried i love this song
Nothing is wrong with the font... Don't criticize his/her work when you don't know how difficult to an animation in kinetic typography is to make. Great work, very impressive! Please make more!
There is absolutely something wrong with the font, it's not capturing the mood of the song. The important thing about design/graphic design/motion graphics is the idea of communication, and this project could do a better job of it. Additionally, there is nothing wrong with constructive criticism, how else would Grunkie learn? No one is saying that making a video like this is easy (it's also not as hard as you think with AE), they're just offering advice.
If you used a slightly slimmer font, with bleed effects almost like ink I believe. Also when you do a type of video like this there has to be constant movement to keep the persons attention but you did one hell of a good job on this well done.
@foredamusic You like rap music. You're opinion is forever invalid. Anyone can talk fast and put a crappy beat behind it, but music like this actually takes skill, prat ice and musical talent.
This is really good! Be proud! I would suggest, though that the words appearing feels very jarring for such a slow paced song. I would suggest fading them in or something a little calmer.
As many said, wrong font, but otherwise very good, though I'd like to see a little more of the transitions when the text pulls the screen with it to the side instead of just filling the whole thing up. But I guess this isn't the best song for that either.
nice ideas, but the art direction it not good yet. wrong font, the composition often doesnt make sense. the colors are not perfect either. but good for a first project!
@Roghog1414 How do you know which font to choose? Is it just an artistic instinct? Just wondering cause I was thinking about trying my hand at one of these.
@DaSasquatchHobo Haha its def. not instinct, when i was first introduced to the arts I had no idea what a good font/bad font was. I would recommend something more post modern, no comic fonts. Try a sans, or a bold of one of your favorite fonts. I would recommend watching more videos and develop a font taste of your own. Decide which ones you think are bad or not. I enjoy Helvetica alot as well
@Roghog1414 Thanks, that was sound advice. I picked up from the internet that comic sans is abhorred, so I'll stay away from that. Thanks for the tips
good after effects skills, but they didn't really fit the song. i agree with the suggestion below me to use a different, much less bold font. other things to try would be a slower, more fluid, and surreal, almost, flow of words.
Cool video, wrong font choice. The text should NOT be so big and so bold. The movement, effects, and transitions are good, where used. I wish there were a few more of them, and fewer instances where the words simply appear on the screen in time with the singing, as opposed to interpretively behaving like the sentence or word would indicate.
I am making one of my own, but i need to know how you get the radial gradient background... it seems simple because a lot of typography videos have it, but i just cant figure out how to do it. please help. (i'm using after effects of course)
@sharpmarker108 you can also make a new adjustment layer, make a elliptical mask, invert that, add effect>color correction>curves and boost the contrast. feather the mask afterwards to create the ramp. it seems difficult, but you have more influence on colour and shape of the gradient.
very good .. its one of my favorite songs.. i think i would have liked to have seen it in a different font but i still like it :) thanks for your hard work
okay, I'm back with some advice instead of just being an ass... like I usually am. The font is pretty bad, something less bulky would be nice, if for some reason you choose just one font, play with the italic, bold kerning etc, if HELP! Try making the transitions between words less choppy, more organic if you will. Don't focus so much on how you position the text so you have a certain "slide". Try to build around a word instead of building with words. Also you should look into some other colors.
This is a great song, and a great first typography. Can I ask, what font is this? It looked kind of like impact at first, but it just doesn't look like a standard font, little differences. I like it.
I like it, but it doesn't really seem to take anything from the song but the words. If I were watching it with the sound off, I wouldn't know what the song felt like, you know?
Very creative, I can tell this must have taken a lot of time and effort. My only critique would be that the bold font choice and some of the quick transitions don't fit the mood of this slow, sad song. Still a very well done piece. :)
Hey check out my kinetic typography animation as well. Its also done for a school assignment using After Effects. The objective was to use a short voice over from a movie.
wow, this is the first vid that has been a full song that i've seen tonight... or rather this morning. XD
my god, i don't know where to start with this. First off i guess, amazing song to choose. Such a deep and morose song, and your different effects did a very good job with it. the effects with Faces, and sorrow's transition to tomorrow are very amazing. only critique from me would have been to make Dying at 2:22 to flicker out completely.
Wow, it's fantastic! I especially love the way you treated the different emotions in the song and applied the transparent effects to portray the fading quality of the singers voice. The color choices are really perfect for the song too and the whole scheme is really effective, especially once you use the red to cause the "dying" type stand out. This is definitely one of the best I've seen here.
I just discovered this whole typography thing after following a link on digg for the still alive song. as a frustrated graphic designer have to say I really enjoy it. For some strange reason reminds me off old Soviet Union poster art or Blue Note record covers. 'bout time we had a decent internet meme. Anyone recommend any good dedicated sites? Lovely video BTW
it is very touching song yesterday i watched a video about the hollercaust and that was the baking track was mad world and i nearly cried i love this song
acbriony4 1 day ago
Nothing is wrong with the font... Don't criticize his/her work when you don't know how difficult to an animation in kinetic typography is to make. Great work, very impressive! Please make more!
SixStringsofFury 1 month ago
@SixStringsofFury
There is absolutely something wrong with the font, it's not capturing the mood of the song. The important thing about design/graphic design/motion graphics is the idea of communication, and this project could do a better job of it. Additionally, there is nothing wrong with constructive criticism, how else would Grunkie learn? No one is saying that making a video like this is easy (it's also not as hard as you think with AE), they're just offering advice.
chrischang127 1 month ago
@SixStringsofFury
Have you ever even seen good kinetic typography/motion graphics?
chrischang127 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
amillion replays!!! 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00 0:00
123thecooldood 2 months ago
thumbs up if this is the best song ever
dhrumilable 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
shut the fuck off and enjoy!
malosomalik5674 4 months ago
what program is this?
theiflord192 4 months ago
If you used a slightly slimmer font, with bleed effects almost like ink I believe. Also when you do a type of video like this there has to be constant movement to keep the persons attention but you did one hell of a good job on this well done.
Misinterpretationn 6 months ago 2
Well done. I agree with efernalgumby.
TheTrueShinobi 7 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
crap song cool video
foredamusic 8 months ago
@foredamusic what the hell is wrong with you?
SkaterSofa 6 months ago 3
@foredamusic You like rap music. You're opinion is forever invalid. Anyone can talk fast and put a crappy beat behind it, but music like this actually takes skill, prat ice and musical talent.
SickShortMovies 6 months ago 3
This is really good! Be proud! I would suggest, though that the words appearing feels very jarring for such a slow paced song. I would suggest fading them in or something a little calmer.
hawkteflon 9 months ago
how many titles you add to this project?
MrElminTH 9 months ago
loved when the i fell off or "died" wish i knew how to do things like this
sprinklerrboi54 10 months ago
@sprinklerrboi54 then why dont you learn =]
this is after effects. plenty of tutorials online
SkipFour 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Nice vid!
I made a cover of this song, if you want you can watch it on my channel :)
thanks
livethelifeyoulike 10 months ago
nicely donee <3
toeroxursox 11 months ago
all songs need to be done in Kinetic Typography, would be so beast .
FREEstylerFTW 1 year ago 3
great work! i love typography..... :D
NlkOlVy 1 year ago
great vid man! i love kinetic typography :)
cankarales 1 year ago
great job, 1 of the best on youtube!
3DMotionArtist 1 year ago
Hey,great work. Can you help me a bit by telling me the software i can use for kinematic typography? will appreciate it a lot mate!
digitallydenied 1 year ago
@digitallydenied
Adobe After Effects CS4 or CS5
FrameFactoryFlims 1 year ago
I like all the animations etc. but I think the text you used is much too thick for such a smooth song
ProtoGenocid 1 year ago
at 00:26 it says i love you!
SoccerGirl0170 1 year ago
Im stunned, great
4Polfag 1 year ago
Nicely done, I liked the flow a lot . Try varying the font when you get to the chorus or at least "Mad World". Good work for a class project!
kmikl 1 year ago
Did you keyframe animate this?
endocomar93 1 year ago
good try
asassin606 1 year ago
Very nice!! :)
Padfoot8701 1 year ago
i just watched it for the second time..awesome song and typo..
gokranjan 1 year ago
I love this. o; <3
iRockerzProductionz 1 year ago
sweet
lukaszb44 1 year ago
that was absolutely amazing. i will actually castrate the 26 people that clicked dislike :@
HullGaming 1 year ago
amazing :D
xXReFleXGaming 1 year ago
As many said, wrong font, but otherwise very good, though I'd like to see a little more of the transitions when the text pulls the screen with it to the side instead of just filling the whole thing up. But I guess this isn't the best song for that either.
MorpH2k 1 year ago
I find it kinda funny that the M pushed the I....
VampTheDuck 1 year ago
Did you lay out in illustrator first?
loodakid 1 year ago
Every lyrics video should be like this. Lol :D
xSayzRawr 1 year ago
This is just.. out there:)
CrazedxCookie 1 year ago
I have to say that this is one, if not the, best piece of Kinetic Typography I have seen...
rockette1991 1 year ago
I was happy, now I am not, thanks....
BenTheMagnifice 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out my Kinetic Typography video about "Elevator Etiquette" on my page. Trustme you'll enjoy it.
ARTUNBOUND 1 year ago
AWESOME. :D
TheLyricsPlease 1 year ago
Looks really good, just turn on some motion blur. It's a bit jarring to the eyes. Very good job!
hawkteflon 1 year ago
nice ideas, but the art direction it not good yet. wrong font, the composition often doesnt make sense. the colors are not perfect either. but good for a first project!
jenm1988 1 year ago
This song would scare me when I was little, it still kinda does.
WearingOff 1 year ago 2
Dude, I absolutely LOVE that song and you just made it better... Props. (Y)
CathyMacars 1 year ago
What did you use to make this? After effects?
WeThePersons 1 year ago
Great song, though a little depressig.
BreaktheChainsofFate 1 year ago
This is beautiful. Excellent work.
ShufflerAmethyst 1 year ago
This is from Donnie Darko!!
Best song!
ProfessionallyMe 1 year ago
classy
creepy46 1 year ago
first attempt! no shit... beats my first attempt... then again i learned from an 8min youtube tut. still its FAR from perfect but i like it :)
jaw1987cchs 1 year ago
loved it!!
purpleninja1724 1 year ago
THIS IS ON BAD COMPANY!!
123456789rofltime 1 year ago
It's not perfect, but it works for me. Very entertaining.
AudioPulp 1 year ago
i think its timed alright
but the camera movements seem jerky
good video though
sinak12345 1 year ago
the speeds are slightly off for the song same with the effects
volopok 2 years ago
very nice, wrong font though
Roghog1414 2 years ago 26
@Roghog1414 How do you know which font to choose? Is it just an artistic instinct? Just wondering cause I was thinking about trying my hand at one of these.
DaSasquatchHobo 1 year ago
@DaSasquatchHobo Haha its def. not instinct, when i was first introduced to the arts I had no idea what a good font/bad font was. I would recommend something more post modern, no comic fonts. Try a sans, or a bold of one of your favorite fonts. I would recommend watching more videos and develop a font taste of your own. Decide which ones you think are bad or not. I enjoy Helvetica alot as well
Roghog1414 1 year ago
@Roghog1414 Thanks, that was sound advice. I picked up from the internet that comic sans is abhorred, so I'll stay away from that. Thanks for the tips
DaSasquatchHobo 1 year ago
good after effects skills, but they didn't really fit the song. i agree with the suggestion below me to use a different, much less bold font. other things to try would be a slower, more fluid, and surreal, almost, flow of words.
InNosMachinaris 2 years ago 4
Cool video, wrong font choice. The text should NOT be so big and so bold. The movement, effects, and transitions are good, where used. I wish there were a few more of them, and fewer instances where the words simply appear on the screen in time with the singing, as opposed to interpretively behaving like the sentence or word would indicate.
efernalgumby 2 years ago 50
Nice!
Bizargh 2 years ago
great typography video!
I am making one of my own, but i need to know how you get the radial gradient background... it seems simple because a lot of typography videos have it, but i just cant figure out how to do it. please help. (i'm using after effects of course)
sharpmarker108 2 years ago
create it using photoshop, and just import the file.
There are workarounds!
Kirilltraceur 2 years ago
Layer
New Solid
Effect
Generate
Ramp
Change it from linear to radial in the effects panel
JoshuaWelborne 2 years ago
@sharpmarker108 you can also make a new adjustment layer, make a elliptical mask, invert that, add effect>color correction>curves and boost the contrast. feather the mask afterwards to create the ramp. it seems difficult, but you have more influence on colour and shape of the gradient.
paddyrapp 2 years ago
@sharpmarker108 Effects < Generate < Ramp
MyLifeIsRiley 1 year ago
Well done.
The text was a bit big in places but that can be scaled down.
Seemed well planned, nice timing on 'camera' moves, also my favorite parts were with the pictures too.
Youtoober22 2 years ago
The LARGE text is too over bearing for the song. Also you should of used more than one font. cool to look at though.
Nombre12 2 years ago
this is such an interesting video to watch, because the typography gets so markedly better from beginning to end. great job!
drschreaber 2 years ago 2
the author of this piece of kitetics typography clearly didn't feel the song.
.
text is too big. however, there were some nice parts. overally a disappointment, because i just love the song.
Karlsonas17 2 years ago
these are neat :)
kamikazestrwbry 2 years ago
Genius!! Really got the sense of the heaviness with the typo used and the crowding in/out of life. Depressing but poinient.
italotter 2 years ago
Happy birthday part is the bessst!
artichokeschmoke 2 years ago
Vaya!!!
Que ingenio para hacer el video. EXCELENTE!!!
PackoGL 2 years ago
Why does this song always make me cry?
Zeaky0arteest 2 years ago
because u have no balls
cjwolf2011 2 years ago
No shit, I'm a girl haha.
Zeaky0arteest 2 years ago
POINT MADE! haha
cjwolf2011 2 years ago
not really...
Zeaky0arteest 2 years ago
then get off the comp and back in the kitchen
cjwolf2011 2 years ago
Sure thing, would you like a sandwich while I'm in there?
Zeaky0arteest 2 years ago
yes turkey no crust
cjwolf2011 2 years ago
With what kind of chips?...and a drink too I'm sure.
Zeaky0arteest 2 years ago
no chips just mountain dew and hurry up
cjwolf2011 2 years ago
because the vibrations it makes gives your brain have a sense of sad with deep tones and depressing lyrics. :)
nurseman8 2 years ago
I think the font was a good choice. Though the letters were blocky, they fit together rather well.
getinmyhead 2 years ago
very good .. its one of my favorite songs.. i think i would have liked to have seen it in a different font but i still like it :) thanks for your hard work
mzkittymeow79 2 years ago
the version doesnt matter much, it can be done with both.
xblast196 2 years ago
i bet this would of taken him at least 3 days
Pyr0fr3ak666 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I support ppl gettin' their creativity on, but fuck man, this is plain bad :( it makes me cry :( and it's not the song trust me!
bendoverjunior 2 years ago
Cmon seriously?
Dude, That's fucked up.
It wasn't even bad, I mean, not a fucking masterpiece, but It's the guy's first time.
You insulted him pretty bad without giving any criticism. (And on that point I must say to the creator, more font selection would be nice)
jcole60brit 2 years ago
okay, I'm back with some advice instead of just being an ass... like I usually am. The font is pretty bad, something less bulky would be nice, if for some reason you choose just one font, play with the italic, bold kerning etc, if HELP! Try making the transitions between words less choppy, more organic if you will. Don't focus so much on how you position the text so you have a certain "slide". Try to build around a word instead of building with words. Also you should look into some other colors.
bendoverjunior 2 years ago
Masterpiece.
MasterX456 2 years ago
You could do this in CS3. I did a Kinetic Typography project for class. Check it out on my page sometime if you like.
sizers 2 years ago
AWESOME! Great job!
sizers 2 years ago
This is a great song, and a great first typography. Can I ask, what font is this? It looked kind of like impact at first, but it just doesn't look like a standard font, little differences. I like it.
dnRoystonDotCom 2 years ago
what did you use to make this?
GothicHorror10 2 years ago
The description says it was after an After Effects class, so that would be my guess
dnRoystonDotCom 2 years ago
Awesome song, awesome kinetic typography.
number48 2 years ago
Dude thanks you soo much for this video, favorite song yo and the animation just makes its so much better
toxicityxlkx 2 years ago
I thought this was great.. very well done.
and I didnt think the bold typeface took away from the music at all.
xlyricallies 2 years ago
This song was originally done by tears for fears
mindlesskill78 2 years ago
good call
Anicetos510 2 years ago
Yes, yes it was. But this version is done by Gary Jules. If this was the Tears for Fears version, that would of been in the title.
Grunkie 2 years ago 74
This has been flagged as spam show
@Grunkie Hey,great work. Can you help me a bit by telling me the software i can use for kinematic typography? will appreciate it a lot mate!
digitallydenied 1 year ago
this version is better though, tff needed to slow it down some like gary jules does.
don't get me wrong, i love tears for fears.
hayleysquared 2 years ago
I really love music typography like this one
but you should really release another version with just blur on and smooth keyframes
(click the last keyframe and hit F9 Its so worth it)
DonT get me wrong its absolute great work there
just some tips to make your fans happy^^
paddyrapp 2 years ago 13
Will totally try that out. Thanks for the tip.
Grunkie 2 years ago
Ignore the haters, its a very decent piece.
fuckyounakedbluejean 2 years ago
This is too literal... plus the typeface doesn't really reflect the mood of the song...
Hax9 2 years ago
bad design...the bold typeface doesn't reflect Gary Jules somber voice nor the tone of the music...
who ever taught you motion theory should be fired...
paintball626 2 years ago
I like it, but it doesn't really seem to take anything from the song but the words. If I were watching it with the sound off, I wouldn't know what the song felt like, you know?
prismacolored 2 years ago
you obvisouly dont understand that it based off the typography not the music
Audard 2 years ago
This guy is totally correct; he's demonstrating typography effects, not music. Very well done FX!
BecauseWeCanFilms 2 years ago
Excellent! 5 star rating!
LivingDeadGirl1981 2 years ago
great job!
nevertheless i find it a bit to turbulent adn worrisome.
andreiowski 2 years ago
Very creative, I can tell this must have taken a lot of time and effort. My only critique would be that the bold font choice and some of the quick transitions don't fit the mood of this slow, sad song. Still a very well done piece. :)
ScaredPorcupine 2 years ago 3
0.0
DHREAVER 2 years ago
beautiful
MyPinkElephants 2 years ago
i love it!
lisaaanne91 2 years ago
you shouldn't make it your goal to constantly fill up the white space.
artcast 2 years ago 4
um, not by Gary Jules, but by Tears for Fears.
Gary covered it for Donnie Darko, or before maybe.
maniacafrodisiac 2 years ago
This is the Gary Jules version.
dunrieth 2 years ago
o_O
yes? i already said that..?
maniacafrodisiac 2 years ago
I know eh?
adamgomori90 2 years ago
hey, I have an idea, let's criticize people for the most insignificant things!
apocalypse223 2 years ago
i like tears for fears better lol
BrowniePhailurez 2 years ago
hey how were you able to post the song? I made a lso a typography to a song but i couldnt put i bc of the rights, please let me know. Thanks
hispanicmonkey68 2 years ago
Have you online lessons with adobe after effects?
rromashuka 2 years ago
Well done m8 ;)
But the Text is sometimes a little bit asynchron to the music...
gtaspider 2 years ago
T_T so sad an true, reminds me of my self, beautiful song, great animation
Menasaurusrex 3 years ago
great song, great animation!
LoveUsagi 3 years ago
Hey check out my kinetic typography animation as well. Its also done for a school assignment using After Effects. The objective was to use a short voice over from a movie.
Do check it out!
Beneanas 3 years ago
What program did you use?
Mortecai12 3 years ago
I used Illustrator and After Effects
Grunkie 3 years ago
Love it!
newsblog 3 years ago
wow, this is the first vid that has been a full song that i've seen tonight... or rather this morning. XD
my god, i don't know where to start with this. First off i guess, amazing song to choose. Such a deep and morose song, and your different effects did a very good job with it. the effects with Faces, and sorrow's transition to tomorrow are very amazing. only critique from me would have been to make Dying at 2:22 to flicker out completely.
if you didn't get an A, there is no justice! XD
Idene90 3 years ago
this song is just too damn sad. good job though
epiphoneaddict 3 years ago
i mean in an emotional way, not a pathetic way. just to clarify
epiphoneaddict 3 years ago
i know what you mean mac. but still, there is a certain appeal in sad songs. X)
Idene90 3 years ago
How did you make this?
MirrorMask111 3 years ago
You're so talented. What font/s is/are that?
donkey2626 3 years ago
one of the best sympathizing type treatments to tone of content.
cheers.
simply17fred 3 years ago
Donnie Darko 2 in 2009
Midifez 3 years ago
S. Darko
ummwut 3 years ago
Wow, it's fantastic! I especially love the way you treated the different emotions in the song and applied the transparent effects to portray the fading quality of the singers voice. The color choices are really perfect for the song too and the whole scheme is really effective, especially once you use the red to cause the "dying" type stand out. This is definitely one of the best I've seen here.
Skriptki77y 3 years ago
very cool and good for a 1st time project and not just for a first timer... its just perfect! 5/5
battlefielder2 3 years ago
I just discovered this whole typography thing after following a link on digg for the still alive song. as a frustrated graphic designer have to say I really enjoy it. For some strange reason reminds me off old Soviet Union poster art or Blue Note record covers. 'bout time we had a decent internet meme. Anyone recommend any good dedicated sites? Lovely video BTW
gezblair 3 years ago 3
nice!
tormentedbUrn 3 years ago
Good stuff
DirectorRico 3 years ago
This just makes me wanna fight Locust. In a good way.
MattG1215 3 years ago 2
i really love this. :)
gahbeez 3 years ago