I don't care whether his voice is gonna change or not in future, at least he is a true artist, with lots of passion in singing... many HK and Taiwan artists don't have this kind of quality... What they have is just sing with zero passion, but nothing special...
honestly...i am quite disturbed by his gesture....i dunno...he has a great voice for sure...but the voice is a voice of a "she" and plus his "girlie type" of gesture....wt makes it even more delusional is his really boy face ...it gives u a feeling of a "3 BUD Cheung"..umum...
wow this kid is great!!! he is so talented..but i hope his voice will change to a man voice when he grows older and keep singing for us..! but still should go to school!
趕快把握多唱一點歌!!變聲了就沒機會了><
mimi5214332 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
很多人說徐傑有天籟童聲
但是我覺得他的歌聲只是像女生
他唱歌,我覺得,他的歌聲沒有那種自然,天真...的感覺
聽他唱歌時,我只是覺得,他好像很想當一個"女歌手" 而已
dolphinangelchiyukun 2 weeks ago
Very nice smart boy.How can you sing so great like that.!!! Love you
natokute2150 4 months ago
有錢堪賺趕快賺, 莫待不紅空嘆氣..
johnnalai 5 months ago
最喜歡這種雌雄莫辨的聲音<3
KaWaYi10KB 7 months ago
在唱的時候,他只有11歲,不夠氣這種廢話不應該用在他身上吧。聽不就好了,不爽就別聽啊。
lawls1231 8 months ago 4
希望徐杰變聲後依然好聽
iamcathyt 8 months ago
請問徐傑他現在幾歲?
wtt0302 9 months ago
@wtt0302 他是98年的,現在快13歲了~變聲期
iamcathyt 8 months ago
区甘高分 罗力威都顶唔顺
ronaldhulk 1 year ago
如果話佢不夠氣 唱到後段斷斷續續我又覺得不太明顯
我反而覺得小朋友唱低音時 還差一點 聽他唱 會呼吸的痛 就更加明顯
但他唱歌整體說都很不錯 感情豐富
hang0011 1 year ago
how? i ve been watching him for hours trying to understand how ?
please to me how ?
how could he be so good ? at this age ?
nhatvinh 1 year ago
I don't care whether his voice is gonna change or not in future, at least he is a true artist, with lots of passion in singing... many HK and Taiwan artists don't have this kind of quality... What they have is just sing with zero passion, but nothing special...
AdamLikesCarrie 1 year ago
Amazing
cyber365 1 year ago
唱的真好,声音甜美,柔美深情!多棒的孩子啊!好久没有听到这么甜美的声音了啊!想想当初邓丽君出道也很早啊,不会邓丽君投胎转世了吧,转成男孩子了!再忆邓丽君!
helenwang123 1 year ago
厉害,太美了,声音太有魅力了!真棒!加油啊!
helenwang123 1 year ago
不管未来怎样, 祝福小朋友!
或者幸福最重要,唱歌给自己听,给朋友听,都很好!
做歌星不一定幸福!
taijicheng 1 year ago 2
勁呀!
dingdangdingdang1 1 year ago
超好聽.v.
jamiejodie5d11 1 year ago
wow,,,his musicality is incredible. I am proud bro. You will have a bright future as a singer.
wikct2 1 year ago
技巧和感情的渲染能力,并不会随着变声而消失
只要好好保护嗓子,即使变声期后也能唱出天籁之音
btkingU 1 year ago 5
佢唱得好好好好聽呀!!
讚好!!
cmychung 2 years ago
如果這男孩子在十年後也是這樣唱女生的歌,你的感覺將會怎樣??
youguystube 2 years ago 18
很多男生唱女生的歌,也有很多女生唱男生的歌。
RItyoutune 2 years ago 16
@RItyoutune 差就差在唱得好與壞。
rakushirakushi 2 weeks ago
十年後就沒什麼感覺,因為到時候已經見怪不怪,只是現在還有點民智未開!
b413920000 2 years ago
@youguystube
甚麼叫做男生的歌 甚麼又叫做女生的歌 ?
音域比較高就代表女生的歌 ? 比較低就叫做男生的歌嘛 ?
Daisy70200 1 year ago
@Daisy70200 哈哈!『音域』只有寬及窄之分,沒有高低男女之分。請你先弄清楚甚麼是『音域』吧!男生跟女生在各方面肯定是+分不同,各有長短,否則人類便不需要有兩種不同性別!這是很基本的事實,與潮流無關! 有些人男女不分,行為打扮不男不女,這是他們的選擇,但使人反胃又是自然的反應。
youguystube 1 year ago
@youguystube 不可能啦 ~ 变音啦
vinsinmo 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
天籟啊! 真好聽!
formosaofloveocean 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
想想你們11歲在幹嘛 再來批評
加油好嗎!
pkpk80120 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
天籁童声,好聽極了
pregatedidio 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
雖然佢把聲好女仔,不過唱得幾好呀,不竟係小朋友,唔係話人係娘娘腔啦,香港大把人係男生女相啦,個啲咪仲恐怖。
kelvin80kelvin 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
批評徐杰的人唔諗下11歲已經唱到呢種技巧同聲線已經好勁咩.比起好多人已經厲害了
如果唔係超偶點解佢會pk贏miu
yanwing38 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
先不说他唱的女声听众喜不喜欢,人家11岁就已经有这样的歌唱技巧,难道不应该佩服一下?过多的负面评价根本没有必要,一个小孩子需要的是包容与欣赏。
AngelPlusDavid 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我很欣賞這裡的"批評"評語會被給予正分,很好,我通常在別的影片批評都會被很多人給予負分,哀也!
他的技巧我不予評論,我只想說我很討厭男仔唱成女人聲的(比起娘娘腔更恐怖)
sealgign 2 years ago 130
This comment has received too many negative votes show
天上有天人上有人徐杰超厲害喔
W1313iY 2 years ago
這主持人不是包皮嗎
blitzday 2 years ago 5
對呀!
stone2rock 2 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
小時了了大未必佳
hammerfffff 2 years ago 92
the kid sings like the original soundtrack.. very natural, flawless no breathing sounds.. and all that
Naorichan 2 years ago
ho wing sum doesnt deserve that high of a score..she went off key so bad... and her pronounciation is poor
Naorichan 2 years ago 5
OMG
andrew1993leekaho 2 years ago
我暫時覺得佢唱得好過趙展彤, 但真的十分擔心變咗聲之後天籟童音會冇咗!
joechampion 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
以佢嘅功力
keep住到大個
好難唱得差過趙展彤
4296661 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
徐杰好勁
cutierainbow 2 years ago
如果佢係女仔就好la,把聲好好听ar!!第時到佢變聲,咁好听的聲就無左lu..可惜..
bluecowcow 2 years ago 24
@bluecowcow 可能他到了17~18 声音变帅了 等待奇迹出现
vinsinmo 1 month ago
0178佢老母細細個無童貞就真,,,^^唔小過佢佢都唔知自己身體禁好,,,如果大家認同,勾多些向上個隻手指符號啦,,呵呵
SUPERTIGER12345678 2 years ago 8
估唔到佢都得罪埋cherry0178呢條友
ok9988774 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
無哂童真 !
cherry0178 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
佢d高音好清 好舒服
grandc43954 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
全首歌唱得好斷, 技巧和台風有待改進
alankwlee 2 years ago
Comment removed
hnsmiuchi 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
你不可以這樣說, 就算歌唱老師也不定唱得好, 我不知道你看過多少歌唱比賽, 年紀比他小唱得好大有人在, 你曾否看過前香港殘酷一丁三屆台主莫凱謙, 他當時只有10歲, 但是技巧和台風都做得比較好. 當然我只是說他唱"月亮..."比較差, 其他歌曲他真是唱得很好, very good !!!
alankwlee 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
我覺得這首歌唱的很棒口氣輕重音都恰到好處^^"
hnsmiuchi 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
其實我說過, 唔知點解我的評語被人删除了,
無錯, 前段聲音開得很好, 但是整首歌很多句都唱得很斷, 例如"你問^我愛你有^多深", "月亮代^表我的心","已經打動我的^心","深深的一^段情","敎我思念到^如今", 過門後更呈現息氣不穏現象, 不夠氣.
alankwlee 2 years ago 74
This comment has received too many negative votes show
唱歌不是唸經唱歌跟說話都會有斷句這是唱歌的口氣說話的口氣唱歌不一定要從頭到尾一氣呵成唱到底吧
hnsmiuchi 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
這是意境的問題
不過畢竟要個小孩把氣hold完整句也是十分困難的
4296661 2 years ago
@alankwlee 小朋友唔識運氣,所以無氣唱。
yadnussyl 1 year ago
@alankwlee 我们喜欢的是纯洁,最重要人们喜欢的是他的真。
我相信他寻找一个好的老师,帮助他音准再好一些,节奏律动再好一些,句子再好一些,断句再好一些,稳定再好一些,如何慢练。不出多少年,又一个“虚假的美丽”诞生了。美只是一个诱饵,更可贵的是真。我们的教育如何在教学的时候不让孩子不要失去对音乐的爱,对正直的爱呢?
zhaoyi26 1 year ago
這個節目如改一改可向職業歌手P K,那就好看得多了,到時那些一線歌手就頭痕了
pi1617 2 years ago 15
無記搶哂d人, 冇明星會上atv
frank007hk 2 years ago
长大后应该像费玉清的嗓音啦
wuqiqi520 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
很女人呀.
MrBenson625 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
honestly...i am quite disturbed by his gesture....i dunno...he has a great voice for sure...but the voice is a voice of a "she" and plus his "girlie type" of gesture....wt makes it even more delusional is his really boy face ...it gives u a feeling of a "3 BUD Cheung"..umum...
cl3ment 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
唔好死得咁难睇咯
etcowling 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
趙展彤真係同佢差十皮
chishun0112 2 years ago
對手拉高自己個分!!富麗同何詠深都係
LeeStone52 2 years ago 8
wow this kid is great!!! he is so talented..but i hope his voice will change to a man voice when he grows older and keep singing for us..! but still should go to school!
rsyak 2 years ago 13
yeah...she didn't deserve it..
the kid is great though :)
evaaaaaaaaaa 2 years ago 14
63.2 is too high for many mistakes!
soramonte 2 years ago 13
agreed, should be below 60
Skylayee 2 years ago 21