I choose hilary because she's prettier more sofisticated better life better role model.she doesn't go out and do drugs. I never even thought lindsay was even all that pretty. She has way too many freckles and I never liked red hair .
I prefer Lindsay. At least she always tries to sing LIVE. Even legendary Madonna doesn't sing live all the time. Lindsay's songs are much more emotional, deep and beautiful. She use pop songs and rock music. Hilary Duff is very monotonous plus she copies Lindsay
I prefer Lindsay. Yes, she is trouble girl who takes drugs and alcohol but it doesn't mean that she is bad actress. Her acting impressed me much more than Hilary's. Hilary is always the same.
Lindsay is great singer too. Just give her a chance. She is better singer than most of modern so-called "Superstars"!
i had always thought hilary was the first one with aaron. but, omg, I can understand not fighting over Aaron Carter, but not fighting over BSB? Plz, they are very much catfight material (especially howie and brian. Hello!)
lindsay is the best is so beautifull
lamusicamylife 9 months ago
I choose hilary because she's prettier more sofisticated better life better role model.she doesn't go out and do drugs. I never even thought lindsay was even all that pretty. She has way too many freckles and I never liked red hair .
14128881 1 year ago
this is sick that they were mad at each other and not at the guy who cheated on them -.-
ZielonaLinijka 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I prefer Lindsay. At least she always tries to sing LIVE. Even legendary Madonna doesn't sing live all the time. Lindsay's songs are much more emotional, deep and beautiful. She use pop songs and rock music. Hilary Duff is very monotonous plus she copies Lindsay
ViolaXZ 1 year ago
hILARY dUFF 4ever
TheGjkcity 2 years ago
i love lindsay and hilary is ok
TheFun4u123 2 years ago
Hilary
Kamila15years 2 years ago
hilary is soooooooooooooooo much better and prettier
jlcdiver 2 years ago 2
Hilary's very FAT and ugly! LINDSAY'S THE BEST.
carolbittencour 2 years ago
The only thing LIndsay eats is pills...
PeterDuktig 2 years ago 3
lindsay lohan!!!!!!!!!!!!!
siufung1111 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I prefer Lindsay. Yes, she is trouble girl who takes drugs and alcohol but it doesn't mean that she is bad actress. Her acting impressed me much more than Hilary's. Hilary is always the same.
Lindsay is great singer too. Just give her a chance. She is better singer than most of modern so-called "Superstars"!
Victoria3243 2 years ago
hilary all the WAyyyy she number 1 she is STAR
TheGjkcity 2 years ago 2
just love Hillary duff she is wise
anonjoj 2 years ago
hilary
mrsmoneya 2 years ago
i like Lindsay but Love Hilary is so much better :B
nikowlhd 2 years ago 3
Hilary all the way. I too thought Hilary was with Aaron first. I guess I was wrong
gossipgirl10122 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Lindsay is much better singer and actress
Victoria3243 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hilary Duff is the best
martinashalova 2 years ago 4
HILARY!!!!!!!!!
mandybabe555 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lindsay lohan rocks!
bittersweetlie 2 years ago
Hilary cool
Kamila15years 3 years ago 5
i had always thought hilary was the first one with aaron. but, omg, I can understand not fighting over Aaron Carter, but not fighting over BSB? Plz, they are very much catfight material (especially howie and brian. Hello!)
dbzkataang1 3 years ago 4
I don't really like Chelsea Lately, although I will admit she is pretty.
shadymansoncyrus101 3 years ago 3
yea. she was kind of a bitch in this video. but she's really funny and pretty
yayforsharpies 3 years ago