the schoole of AHLU BAYT produces such briliant minds who have deep understanding of islam
becuase they got the knowlege from the rigth source..imaging ,the PROPHET (sawa) and the IMAMS. am from somali where the people are 100 % sunni and i was when of them ,but people should,t follow faith blindly, we have to do research and use logic and rationaltiy in order to find out the truth, SCHOOL OF AHLU BAYT IS the truth
since when does "ma dhulla sahibukum wa ma ghawa" mean "your messenger doesnt make mistakes nor does he sin"??? is this guy even arabic?...and surat an najm had a CONTEXT...it was about al isra wal miraj...the hypocrits didnt believe that Muhammad PBUH went to the seventh heaven so Allaah revealed "wa ma yantiqu 'an-il hawaa"...typical shi'ah twisting of aayat and hadith to suit their beliefs..Allaah said thatYunus 'alaihi al salaam made a mistake.this concept of infallibility is a christian one
Shia'a Eat their imams shit so they can go to heaven.
Its agreed by many of their scholars. Because they think that the 12 imams are clean and not like ordinary humans. So if they mix it with water and wash their faces with dirt and shit they go to heaven....
For gods sake. List me a religion do this ?? Even Buddhism didnt do it.
Shia'a is the worst part of islam because they pretend to be good but they are much worst. Read books and dont read Youtube because its full of haters.
brothers look whats happening to islam we are disunited and also we are attacking each other when did ahlul sunah wal jamah ever say the prophet made mistakes I am a sunni and I dont believe that
Shias stops propagating Lie about us Sunnis .. we Sunnis never believe Prophet used to make mistakes regarding religion but we say that He peace be upon him could make mistake regarding worldly affairs and this is becoz he was not sent as a carpenter or farmer or businessman or warrior but he was sent as a messenger .. got something?
good speech and very informative. This wahabi, deobandi and salafi so called Salafi islam is not real islam. Google these names and you find out that wahabism started in 1700's in Saudi Arabia. Deobandi belief is movement that began in 1800's in India. True Islam started with preachings of the Prophet at the time of the Prophet's life. The only right path is the one that gives most respect to the Holy Prophet and believes he is infallible throughout his life.
good speech and very informative. This wahabi, deobandi and salafi so called islam is not real islam. Google these names and you find out that wahabism started in 1700's in Saudi Arabia. Deobandi belief is movement that began in 1800's in India. True Islam started with preachings of the Prophet at the time of the Prophet's life. The only right path is the one that gives most respect to the Holy Prophet and believes he is infallible throughout his life.
two narrations of Ahl Sunna who rely on them so heavily : I left two weighty things among you: The book of Allah and My Sunna, And upon you be following of my Tradition and traditions of Guided Khulafa after me do not appear in the books of Shaykheen, Saheeh Bukhari and Muslims meaning the Shaykheen did not consider them to be authentic. And scholars of Jarh wa Ta'deel of the Sunni School themselves consider originators of these two hadeeth to be weak.
@AliAbdurRasheed sahih muslim book-31 hadith-5920 the hadith is not in same way. in that hadith prophet(pbuh) talked about duties to ahlul bayt(pbut) . that is not to give zakkat to them . it is forbidden. not the way shia brother use it.
@AliAbdurRasheed sahih muslim book-31 hadith-5920 the hadith is not in same way. in that hadith prophet(pbuh) talked about duties to ahlul bayt(pbut) . that is not to give zakkat to them . it is forbidden.
in the hadith it is NOT AHLUL BAYT but it is " MY SUNNAH(i.e, WORKS & DEEDS & SAYINGS)" . we must love ahlul bayt but we should be careful how much & what should be their status( infallibility & other things). i hope inshallah we all understand the truth beforre our death and die as true muslims. AMEEN
@pulsarspin I am leaving among you two weighty things: the one being the Book of Allah in which there is right guidance and light, so hold fast to the Book of Allah and adhere to it. He exhorted (us) (to hold fast) to the Book of Allah and then said: The second are the members of my household I remind you (of your duties) to the members of my family.
ACTUALLY the hadith of Rasul (s) says the "Quran and Ahlul bayt" in bukhari, muslim REFER to this lecture on youtube " Suunis Wahabis Salafis.. Wake up by the Truth: without Etrat & Ahlul-Bayt[as] you are all misguided "
ACTUALLY the hadith of Rasul (s) says the "Quran and Ahlul bayt" in bukhari, muslim REFER to this lecture on youtube "Suunis Wahabis Salafis.. Wake up by the Truth: without Etrat & Ahlul-Bayt[as] you are all misguided"
You people are absolutely crazy and your societies are very fanatical and barbaric. Listen to this fucking stupid speaker. He speaks as though god is on his side. He thinks he is clever but he is infact very deluded. All you people do is argue and are ready to kill each other for the slightest infraction. You come to our great western countries and engage in sexual active and corruption. Thomas Jefferson is better than your whole history and fucked up traditions and religion.
May Allah bless the Mujahideen who really follow Muhammad salAllahu 3alaihi wa sallam. And may Allah unite us and guide us, because subhanAllah we need guidance so much.
Please don't bring your hatred here. If you have something meaningful and intelligent to contribute then do it, otherwise go spread your hate somewhere else.
Brother, you are the one who should repent, for slandering and insulting others with hateful words. Where does Islam allow such behavior? Please be reasonable and repectful.
Yes, the Prophets and Messengers made mistakes, but Allaah did not approve of their mistakes; rather, He pointed out their mistakes as a Mercy to them and their ummahs, and He forgave their mistakes and accepted their repentance as a Grace and Mercy, for Allaah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful. This will be clear to anyone who checks out the aayaat of the Qur’aan.
I think this is not a proper place to argue each other. niether its suitable for a lay man. these topics should be dealt in the presence of ulama (the one who knows).
i just want to clear my side(no blaming) that ahl e sunnah belives on considering all sayings of the last messenger (S.A.W.W) never neglecting ahl e bayt and the saying tranfered to us through ahl e bayt.
@gomobo2232 Brother, u heard many times about the left hand and the beard. Now how about refuting his statement that "it is the prophet who guides them...Whereas Quran states: .."laysa alayka hudahum wa lakin-Allaha yahdi may ysha". It is not upon u(prophet(s) to guide them, but Allah guides whom he wills.".So the task of the prophet was only to warn. not to guide. Please dont mix the attributes of Allah with the creation. Only Allah is infallible period!!!!
Bro, you are not understanding what he's saying. he wasn't quoting a specific verse, what he is saying is that the prophet is a guide and example to mankind. Allah is our lord and guides whom he chooses, but those who obey allah are guided through the prophet. How can allah not provide a living example of what we should follow? The speakers entire point is that if prophet is our role-model sent by allah, how can he sin? How is that just?
@mbenks yea because islam is all about growing a beard to be knowledgeable ok mate u can grow ur beard as long and as bushy as u want it wont make u neither knowledgeable nor right so please get a life.
Umar? He said: Messenger of Allah, did you send Abu Huraira with your sandals to gladden anyone he met and who testified that there is no god but Allah, and being assured of it in his heart, with the tidings that he would go to Paradise? He said: Yes. Umar said: Please do it not, for I am afraid that people will trust in it alone; let them go on doing (good) deeds. The Messenger of Allah (PBU) said: Well, let them.
Haha! Somebody PLEASE challenge anything the speaker said. Yes, I know about his hand, but I've heard it 50 times now. Please challenge any of the points he made, this is getting boring!
First of all there is not a single Muslim who says that the Prophet made a mistake in the devine message of Allah (swt). So what is all the fuss about ?
Also what do you say about those who claim that the Prophet failed in teaching his Wives and Companions the best of teaching. The same logic can be applied by saying that since the Prophet failed in teaching the closest people to him then how can he teach Islam to the world !!!
The prphet not only conveys the divine message, but he is the example of how to live by allah's laws. How can he committ injustices and then claim to be our best example? As the Quran says, "the prophet has greater right over the believers than they have over themselves".
Yes there is not doubt the Prophet (peace and blessing of Allah be upon him) is the best example. I have not heard any Muslim accuse the Prophet of doing any injustice....although I have heard some prominent Shia alims claim that the Prophet made a mistake by not telling his followers who would lead after him - now this is clear blasphemy and kufr.
@aduly123 You moron. In Sunni beliefs, they believe the Prophet (pbuh) was a mortal who could be sinful and make mistakes before his prophethood by Allah (swt). How can a man who commit sins or make mistakes be a leader in example to the ummah? Sunnis have it all twisted.
Typical reply from Jahils. We (Ahlul Sunnah wa Jammah) believe that Prophet Muhammed was masoom from making any mistake in the devine message from Allah.
Here is the link if you want to read up more on what the Ahlul Sunnah wa Jammah believe but frankly I doubt it will help you because your thinking is already preprogrammed for you.
@aduly123 Are you illiterate? Educate yourself in Sunni theology. They said that the Prophet (pbuh) was no infallible until his prophethood by Allah (swt). Sunni scholars ever implicate the Prophet (pbuh) making mistakes by forgetting prayers and other nonsense. Sunni sect of Islam is FALSE and the religion of Yazid and Muawiy'ah.
It is you who needs to educate yourself and not blindly follow whatever you are being brainwashed with in your Hussainiyats etc. I wonder from where you got that Sunni sect is the religion of Yazid and Muawiy'ah. Maybe you are follower of Kamal Al Haidari who is known for his lies.
Ahlul Sunnah follow the Quran and authenthic Sunnah of our beloved Prophet Muhammed transmitted to us by his noble Ahlul Bayt (wives, progeny) and prominent Sahabas - may Allah be pleased with them ALL.
@aduly123 u are incorrect his wives were not part of the ahul bayt the people of the cloak are its very plain in bukhari he wrapped in his cloak Fatimah Ali hassan And hussein his wifes are not part of it nor were bakr umar or uthman its not my opnion its in the sunni hadiths the most"athentic" thats who he said were the ahul bayt
Typical reply from Jahils. We (Ahlul Sunnah wa Jammah) believe that Prophet Muhammed was masoom from making any mistake in the devine message from Allah.
Here is the link if you want to read up more on what the Ahlul Sunnah wa Jammah believe but frankly I doubt it will help you because your thinking is already preprogrammed for you.
hmmm... not able to post with links ? Any ideas ....
As to the second question. The prophet did not "fail" at teaching anyone anything. The prophet was a perfect messenger and teacher. Allah says in the Quran, .O Prophet (Muhammad), you cannot give guidance to whom you wish, it is God Who gives guidance to whom He pleases, and He is quite aware of those who are guided.” (28:55-56)." If some chose to disobey the prophet, that is there mistake, It doesn't mean he "failed" to teach them correctly. We must hold fast to the ahlulbayt.
I know for fact that the Prophet did not fail but claims made by this fool and his like can lead to such slander...As for holding fast to the Ahlulbayt, first we need to establish what you mean by "hold fast" ? Then we have to establish who are the Ahlul, in the Arabic language Ahlul Bayt means people of the household and above all are the wives. Then of course we need to establish if this " hold fast " is in accordance to the Quran which leads to alot more questions....
By the way, are you aware of the hadith of the Prohpet warning against eating and dring with left hand if not here it is - “When any one of you eats, let him eat with his right hand, and when he drinks, let him drink with his right hand, because the Satan eats with his left hand and drinks with his left hand.” (Reported by Muslim). I think this should be sufficient proof that we should not listen to such Jahils.
I am surprised with his kind of people who have the audacity to preach about our great Prophet (peace and blessing of Allah be upon him) and do not even follow the Sunnah. Any Muslim child knows that we must use our right hand when eating, drinking. Also must sit when drinking water, not stand and drink.....
Haha! Somebody PLEASE challenge anything the speaker said. Yes, I know about his hand, but I've heard it 50 times now. Please challenge any of the points he made, this is getting boring!
@gomobo2232 it is a reply to your Haha!. The speaker says: "it is the prophet who guides them". But Quran says: It is not upon you to guide them, but Allah guides whom He wills. The task of the prophet is only to warn and give glad tidings....
If find brothers who are harsh to others are the very same one calling other brothers harsh! I'm not shi'a, btw, but do you hear me or MOST of the sunnis on this page calling shi'a names like "these filthy shi'as" or "The shi'as are so intellectual!". There's is no need for labeling or name calling. As Allah says: "...Produce your proof if indeed you are truthful." Just bring forth your evidence. Name calling is not proof that what your saying is true. Let's use our islamic manners.
U must obey the prophet over ur own desires. True so tell this guy to stop shaving ya beard. May Allah guide this man. He has no idea even to what he's sayin. Ppll do not lissen to ppll u do not Noe.
Attn: 6:18 ..."drinking with his left hand"..while sending greeting to the prophet(pbuh). Didn't he teach us to use only right hand when eating and drinking?.. May Allah guide us all and make us all true followers of Muhammad(pbuh) and the righteous predecessors. Ameen.
@gomobo2232 sorry if that made u mad... I just wanted to remind myself and others about this beautiful sunnah of using right hand while eating and/or drinking. As for refuting, no I am not here to refute, i just want to say that i bear witness that none is worthy of worship besides Allah and Muhammad(pbuh) is his messenger. I believe that the only religion acceptable in the sight of Allah is Islam, and that all powers belong to Allah, not to any kind of Imams or awliya...may Allah guide us.amin
@MrMasomenos What powers are these that're being wrongly attributed to the imams? Are you referring to infallibility? If so, keep this in mind. The necessity of successorship after the Prophet is believed among Sunni and Shia. The successor is there to protect the integrity of God's message and serve as a model for how its laws can be followed. Shia believe that the successor was appointed by the Prophet through a divine command and given the role's magnitude, the successor must be infallible.
I am not angry. But we have to be serious about these issues. If people are going to debate about the length of beards and the use of hands when drinking water, we can't have serious discussions. There is one god, muhammad is his messenger, and the ahlulbayt are the guardians of the message against tyrants and stealers of authority.
@gomobo2232: Yes! We have to be serious about following the sunnah. Eating and drinking w/ the right hand IS a serious matter. No aspect of the sunnah is 'not serious.' Maybe, that one time you drank w/ your right hand SOLELY for the sake of Allah may cause you to enter jannah!!!
I'm not saying that these matters are not important in their own right. But if we are going to be discussing the schools of thought in an honest manner then we have to stay on the topic and not create diversions. Very few people who have even commented on this video have even tried to refute what he said. They just talk about his hand! Including you!
@gomobo2232: As Muslims we ought to be people of action, not mere people of speech. A person's action may indicate a person's condition, as is the case here. It's clear that this man is speaking from his desires:
1. He speaks using (flawed) reasoning, without any textual evidence from Qur'an or Sunnah.
2. If he were to look into the tafsir of the surah Abasa it would be clear that it's referring to the Prophet (saws)
3. If not the Prophet, who is the verse referring to then? He doesn't say. Why?
4. Moreover, to assume that our beloved Prophet (saws) is perfect and infallible, is to attribute to him the nature of Allah Himself, for ONLY Allah is perfect. Even the Angels make mistakes: "when your Lord said to the angels, "Indeed, I will make upon the earth a Khalifa." They said, "Will You place upon it one who causes corruption therein and sheds blood, while we declare Your praise and sanctify You?" Allah said, "Indeed, I know that which you do not know." Q2:30
Plus, the Prophet (saws) said himself (in a famous sahih hadith): "ALL the children of Adam make mistakes, and the best of those who make mistakes are those who repent." Is not the Prophet (saws) himself from the children of Adam? Or would you claim that he lied by saying this? All his sins were forgiven, but he did make mistakes.
Remember, that the non-Muslims say that the Prophet wrote the Qur'an himself. So, contrary to the argument of the brother in the video, I find that the fact that the Qur'an critizes the Prophet (saws) is actually PROOF that the Qur'an wasn't written by him (saws). For, why would he make himself look bad? This is actually one of the factors that convinced me that the Qur'an was REVEALED to the Prophet BY God. This factor was important in making me convert to Islam.
@MrMasomenos: VERY GOOD OBSERVATION brother!!! May Allah bless you for catching this. These people are not upon the sunnah; they shave, eat, drink with left hand, and to them, it's no big deal!!!
the verse you stated.. called ayte tatheera.. fits perfect with what ur saying and the verse does have a deep meaning, Inamaa.. Allah ki marzi.. i end here.
These were praised by the Prophet (S): The best of people is my generation, then those who come after them, then those who come after them [Bukhari and Muslim]. The term Salaf applies also to the Scholars of Ahl us-Sunnah wal-Jama'ah after the first three blessed generations who followed their way in belief and practices.
Allah swt has said: Whoever contends with and contradicts the Messenger after guidance has been clearly conveyed to him, and follows a path other than that of the Faithful Believers, We shall leave him in the Path he has chosen and land him in Hell, what an evil destination! [An Nisa 4:115].
As-Salaf us-Salih refers to the first and best three generations of Muslims. They are the Companions of the Prophet (S), their immediate followers (Tabiun), and the followers of the Tabi'in.
so this moron is saying that the prophet didnt frown?
if no then he is rejecting the quran simply the prophet was only a human
but the BEST OF MAN KIND
u love him trough following his ways this dude if he claims he loves prophet how is that he does not have beard? oh wait he has beard but its a so called beard lolz
The speaker is reffering to the surah abbasah. Nowhere in the sura does it explicitly say that the prophet frowned at the man. It said "HE" frowned. Your interpretation is based on hadith. But you must understand that other schools follow other hadith regarding this incident. Our school believes that the surah was revealed about a companion of the prophet who frowned at the man while he was talking to the prophet, the surah came to correct HIM. not our beloved prophet PBUH.
imagine the quran is being reveled to the prophet and how to preach but its criticizing another companion ????
just be honest to urslf and read the whole sura and think about it if u still think that its another sahaba then when u recite sura al fatiha on the prayer make sure u mean it cuz its the sura of guidance
I have read the whole surah. And I can see where you're coming from, but you have to understand that this is merely interpretation of the surah. The Quran is revealed to teach lessons to mankind. When this companion insulted the blind man...it was a lesson for US. Not the prophet.. If you have further doubts read the tafsir of allamah tabatabai about surah ababsah. Here is the link. perhaps you will find it an interesting second opinion
@gomobo2232 You have read the whole Surah right? To whom was this revealed in the first place, the first one amongst Mankind to whom it was revealed? The Companion about whom you are talking about? Or Rasulullah (Salallahu alayhi wa Salam)?
Don't read just the first 2 Ayat. Read on. When Allah speaks using: "Thee" "You"....indeed Allah is speaking to Mankind. But to whom in the first place? The Companion u are claiming these 2 Verses are speaking about? No. Rasulullah (Salallahu alayhi wa Salam
The surah was revealed to the holy prophet PBUH or course, he is allah's messenger. But the surah is talking generally about not thinking lesser of people who are poor, or disadvantaged. Now, who frowned at the blind man? My school of thought believes it was a ummayyad cheiftain who was seeking the counsel of the prophet. The surah was revealed addressing his actions as a lesson for US ALL. How is that so hard to understand?
@gomobo2232 that is not what is hard to understand. What is hard to understand is how you blindly follow your school of thought, while you are Muslim. Furthermore, it is hard to understand why you reject Sahih and Hasan hadiths concerning the revelation of the Verse about Rasulullah (Salallahu alayhi wa Salam) frowning. However, it is easy to understand that you prefer your school of thought over Rasulullah (Salallahu alayhi wa Salam). And your comments reflect just that.
You claim that I blindly follow my school of thought without providing any evidence of that. So by your logic, you also blindly follow your school of thought, and your understanding of this surah is just because that is the only interpretation you've ever know. But that is not a real argument. I will respect you argument based on reason, logic and evidence. Also, not everyone agrees on what is "sahih"...
You claim that I prefer my school of thought "over rasullallah" What does that even mean? All of the schools of thought in islam seek to better understand what the prophet actually said and did. If I think that something falsely is attributed to the prophet and that he never did such a thing....would I not seek to challenge it? of course I would and so would you. But I'm not going to attack you and say you "blindly" follow it. The question should be "what is your evidence?"
Also, you keep listing translations where it says , "the prophet frowned" I ask you respectfully, do you understand Arabic? The transliteration of the actually words is "Abasah wa tawwallah" that means HE frowned and turned away. It doesn't say An-Nabi frowned...or ar-rasool. Can you show me where it says that? That's why you see "the prophet" in parenthesis. this is a general method of interpretation, not direct translation.
I sent a message to your inbox explaining where to find the Tafsir Al-Mizaan online and its study of surah abasah. Allameh Tabatabei wrote a very comprehensive tafsir of this surah. You might find it interesting even if you don't agree. Its good to understand the arguments of different schools, then weigh the evidence and make a conclusion
@misalah What you call hadeeth Saheeh did not came to existant till the year 142 on the permission of Omar bin Abdul Azeez. Your famous Son of Bitch Bukhari was nothing but the lacky of Banu Ommayyeh who fought against the brother of Messenger of Allah and killed his two grand children. He brings more hadeeth from the people who fought against Ahl beit than Ahl beit themselves.
@Irancolor Ahl ul Beit. Go research what Ahl ul Beit means. Ahl ul Beit includes Aysah (radi'Allahu anha), and this is according to the definition which your ayatushaytans provide. Go solve your issue with knowing who Ahl ul Beit is first, before calling the mother of Bukhari (rahimah'Allah) a whore.
And I advise you to stop attributing the actions of some upon others, and go read the Qur'an, go see what Allah has to say concerning such a matter. I invite you to Islam. May Allah guide me and u
i am let's say sunni but i don't want to be in any sect...cause as soon as we name ourselfs something else than Muslims we enter a sect...
a human makes mistakes,even if he is a messenger...this is the prove that only Allah swt is perfect and free from mistakes...
the problem is that shia are to occupied with ahlul bayt and the sunnis are not even mentioning the ahlul bayt,always balblabla abu bakr,umar,but how about ali ra how about the ahlul bayt,they were so pure,Allah give them best jannah
@azir111 why am i hearing blah blah blah from you. sunnis don't talk about it, cuz its black history to them....shit's gonna hit the fan..do your research then we'll talk
@azir111 The messenger of god will never do mistakes. If you know that some one will steal your money or missing your money, would you give your money to him???
@toor20072020 ok i'll start answering from now on, cause you don't use anything from your mind, Allah gave us intellect and free will to choose right from wrong, Allah put logic and Iman in us to worship Him properly,
what you and the other guy is saying is truly only blabla, not me but you and him.
the messenger indeed can do mistakes and we seen this over and over, if he doesn't make mistakes than he is God that's what you're saying, free from error, than he must be god wow?
@azir111: The ignorance of these people is as clear as water; there's no dust on it! Clear! No wonder many of them end up worshiping the Prophet (saws) since they believe him to have been perfect. These people are upon clear baatil!
“Do not over praise me as the Christians have over praised Jesus, the son of Mary. I am only a man. Therefore say: ‘The servant and Messenger of Allâh .’” (Bukhâri)
O Messenger! Proclaim the (message) which has been sent to you from your Rabb.” (Qur’ân 5:67)
“Say: ‘I am but a man like yourselves but the inspiration has come to me, that your God is one God.’” (Qur’ân 18:l10)
Muhammad was the greatest man on earth, last messenger, but not God, he was not perfect.
this speack does not know what the sura the frown is or the story of ayub,, he forgets prophets are human,,, and when they make a mistake in this world allah punishes them in this world by exposing there mistake hence the sura the frown,, so they dnt get punished in this world
Agree 100% that if the prophets make a mistake the religion is out the window. Bilal Philips needs to learn this......Someone who is not perfect can not deliver a perfect religion.
@moman000 Ay Buddy, SO WHAT? We know that the Prophet made mistakes in other aspects of life but Allah (Subhanna Wata ala) did not allow the Prophets to make Mistakes when it come to the Revelation. The Prophet did not speak from himself, he was REVEALING the words of God. I mean, Are Prophets not human too? Its really not hard to understand. Perfection is only an attribute Belonging to Allah. But, when it comes to models to follow, then the Way of the Prophet is the Perfect one to follow...
u should study Quran and not ur bukhari as Quran is right and infallible not ur bukhari just take help of bukhari to understand Quran if u find contradict u should forbid than hadith as Prophet Muhammad hve given sahih hadith not sahih book. study the creation of him and who is Prophet Muhammad and who r u?
Prophet Adam and all Prophets have not ever said that Prophet Muhammad is like themself and u the son of adam is comparing ownself with him?astakferullah
Also if it helps.Everytime and always when the prophet(pbuh) got a new revelation, it was a direct result of the events that happened.Examine closely this incident. This was a direct one, Because the prophet got a revelation right away about it.Not indirect because someone else saw it. A revelation to the direct interaction of the event. Not a unnoticed one some mention here.The Quraysh frowned on everyone? in front of the prophet(pbuh) all the time anyway.This was nothing new at the time.
Be careful too. Hassanain is very good. I like him a lot. But pay attention to his speech. In the very beginning around 20 second video mark he comes out with hard downing of the prophet(pbuh) "he was" and "he was". This is done so you will think this is so bad to consider.This is part of speech class in school. Then he baits you for the come back statement of" How can this be"? So really my brothers absorb only the wise words and think hard for oneself. Research the vessel before you ride on it
In reality it borders Haram and producing division in faith. Maybe I shouldn't be saying Haram full force, but this particular topic balances out Shia and Sunni in opposite directions. Like I said, in a well noted Author, the only one excepted by Saudi religious leaders, found Karen Armstrongs in depth research on the matter solid and concrete. The profit made a small mistake. Some people here are putting this similar to the "Satanic Verses" That is totally different. I just disagree Hassasien
Another issue to point out from Hassasien is that to say a prophet who makes a mistake invalidates his religion. The whole statement for this should never be made in the first place. All the prophets in History have made errors, and conformed to the change. Hassasien should never put this question to our minds. This is wrong to discuss such a statement. Haram. It will lead us to argue. When peace is what is our Jihad for now. So the idea is invalid to discuss. Haram. Masalama
Since when is it Haraam to have a logical discussion about ideas in Islam? I agree that we all need to strive for unity now, as shia, sunni or whatever other school. We are all muslims. But this doesn't mean that we stop asking important questions and helping each other grow in knowledge. Hassanain is making an intellectual argument about the very nature of religion and what makes it valid. That doesn't mean that he is questioning YOUR deen. We need to keep being open minded and ask questions.
Rajoul, in what this subject will help you to get closer to Allah.(SA) . Are you not tirred to brass air. Learn your deen and practise it. Mohammed (sws) came back to his Lord and now you work for you.
To me too Hassasien is amazing. His speech is very very good. May Allah bless him in his speeches. But I must admit. We need to consider the fact that the Prophet (pbuh) was a human being. Every Human has made some errors in life. I do know the Prophet(pbuh) was infallible. No religious mistakes. But There is this one incident where he turned away the blind man to talk too the rich men, and he was told of his mistake by Allah, and this is mentioned in Surah 'Abasa.
obviously you didn't even watch the video where he explains this mid-reading into surah Abasa. That entire understanding of it from the sunni viewpoint is based off of one hadith which claims it was the prophet who turned away. It never says "the prophet turned away" in the Quran. From what our school of thought believes, the verse was in reference to a companion of the prophet who turned away. And the verse came to teach him.
In Karen Armstrongs biography of the Prophet(pbuh) Karen under strict scrutiny in her research of the Prophet(pbuh) points out this mistake as well. Karen is not even Muslim and she is fully excepted author in Saudi circles and praised over her work. Even the mistake of think he was abandoned during the Meccan years. When the prophet(pbuh) said he wasn't going to get any more revelations and thought Allah had abandoned him. The list goes on. Blessed is the prophet(pbuh) he is Human too.
this man saying that the prophet of Allah will never make mistake. how about the prophet Musa 'AS', Dawood 'AS', and Yunos AS? I think he doesn;t know the Qur'an or he is trying 2 suport his believe in 12 pure (ma'soo ) imam, which is a pillar of his faith. if they don't believe so, all of their belief is vein.
It doesn't make any different for us if the prophet made mistake or not.YET, HE IS IN THE EXALTED STANDARD OF CHARACTER in human race.
hatred shows on his face....as if hes making fun of or mocking...good people stay calm and argue reasonably....I dont understand why anyone would be so aggressive when delivering a certain message...but then again...Allah Knows Best...
Growing a Beard, Siwak ,ect are Sunnah. What is Sunnah. Definition : It is the Way of Life of an Individual. He (SAW) lived his life with a Beard, using Siwak, drinking Honey, and the list goes on. Date pollinating is a trivial issue. All The Prophets were Forgiven. They were Human, feeling Weak sometimes, other times strong. Confident one day, not so much on the next. Perfection is an Attribute Belonging only to Allah. Allah never feels weak or dependent. This is untrue for Humans,even Prophets
dont confuse perfection of Allah, to the perfection of Prophets and humans in general.
have you forgotten that humans can be higher than Angels in there level of perfection, with accordance to following Allah's will? if you and I have that chance of having that HIGH of a status, higher than Angels, and we ALL know that Angels are perfect..then how could you say that Prophet Muhammad(SAW) made mistakes?
What about those who claim that the Quran is incomplete and real Quran is with the Imam in Sardab ? This guy first should go and clean the garbage in Shia books before putting false accusation about others.
Go and read Al Kafi and Nahajul Balaga closely and you will see the wonders of nonsense which are attributed to the Prophet and the Imams. I know your so called scholars will their herd of followers but then why not clean the Shia books of such filth and nonsense attributed to the Prophet and the Imam.
you said prophet muhammad(pbuh) gave 2 of his daughters away to bad people..
then why would he(pbuh) have many wives? werent there reasons behind him(pbuh) having different wives? so why do you think he would give away his daughters the way he did?
i'm not here to force-feed people. people can figure it out :O) Inshallah
also, just because their were people next to the Prophet, it does not make them 'good'. because WE have NEVER seen the Prophet, yet we can become good :O)
the schoole of AHLU BAYT produces such briliant minds who have deep understanding of islam
becuase they got the knowlege from the rigth source..imaging ,the PROPHET (sawa) and the IMAMS. am from somali where the people are 100 % sunni and i was when of them ,but people should,t follow faith blindly, we have to do research and use logic and rationaltiy in order to find out the truth, SCHOOL OF AHLU BAYT IS the truth
xuubsiibte 2 months ago
Hajj Hassanain, you ripped right into them once again.
Shi3i4lyf 4 months ago
Bakri'ism is a false cult made by aisha, abu bakr and umar
AishaKafir 4 months ago
since when does "ma dhulla sahibukum wa ma ghawa" mean "your messenger doesnt make mistakes nor does he sin"??? is this guy even arabic?...and surat an najm had a CONTEXT...it was about al isra wal miraj...the hypocrits didnt believe that Muhammad PBUH went to the seventh heaven so Allaah revealed "wa ma yantiqu 'an-il hawaa"...typical shi'ah twisting of aayat and hadith to suit their beliefs..Allaah said thatYunus 'alaihi al salaam made a mistake.this concept of infallibility is a christian one
wesamalshaif 5 months ago
Shia'a Eat their imams shit so they can go to heaven.
Its agreed by many of their scholars. Because they think that the 12 imams are clean and not like ordinary humans. So if they mix it with water and wash their faces with dirt and shit they go to heaven....
For gods sake. List me a religion do this ?? Even Buddhism didnt do it.
Shia'a is the worst part of islam because they pretend to be good but they are much worst. Read books and dont read Youtube because its full of haters.
GanjaSmuggliinG 6 months ago
brothers look whats happening to islam we are disunited and also we are attacking each other when did ahlul sunah wal jamah ever say the prophet made mistakes I am a sunni and I dont believe that
Qur'an 49:12
O ye who believe! avoid suspicion as much (as possible):
for suspicion in some cases is a sin: and spy not on each other nor speak ill of each other behind their backs.
also brother do you have a reference for that hadith you quoted on the ahlul bayt please ?
asalamu alaikum
scorpion32 7 months ago
Shias stops propagating Lie about us Sunnis .. we Sunnis never believe Prophet used to make mistakes regarding religion but we say that He peace be upon him could make mistake regarding worldly affairs and this is becoz he was not sent as a carpenter or farmer or businessman or warrior but he was sent as a messenger .. got something?
decentmary 7 months ago
good speech and very informative. This wahabi, deobandi and salafi so called Salafi islam is not real islam. Google these names and you find out that wahabism started in 1700's in Saudi Arabia. Deobandi belief is movement that began in 1800's in India. True Islam started with preachings of the Prophet at the time of the Prophet's life. The only right path is the one that gives most respect to the Holy Prophet and believes he is infallible throughout his life.
maulvi69 8 months ago
good speech and very informative. This wahabi, deobandi and salafi so called islam is not real islam. Google these names and you find out that wahabism started in 1700's in Saudi Arabia. Deobandi belief is movement that began in 1800's in India. True Islam started with preachings of the Prophet at the time of the Prophet's life. The only right path is the one that gives most respect to the Holy Prophet and believes he is infallible throughout his life.
maulvi69 8 months ago
two narrations of Ahl Sunna who rely on them so heavily : I left two weighty things among you: The book of Allah and My Sunna, And upon you be following of my Tradition and traditions of Guided Khulafa after me do not appear in the books of Shaykheen, Saheeh Bukhari and Muslims meaning the Shaykheen did not consider them to be authentic. And scholars of Jarh wa Ta'deel of the Sunni School themselves consider originators of these two hadeeth to be weak.
121bz 8 months ago
@AliAbdurRasheed sahih muslim book-31 hadith-5920 the hadith is not in same way. in that hadith prophet(pbuh) talked about duties to ahlul bayt(pbut) . that is not to give zakkat to them . it is forbidden. not the way shia brother use it.
pulsarspin 10 months ago 5
@AliAbdurRasheed sahih muslim book-31 hadith-5920 the hadith is not in same way. in that hadith prophet(pbuh) talked about duties to ahlul bayt(pbut) . that is not to give zakkat to them . it is forbidden.
pulsarspin 10 months ago
Comment removed
pulsarspin 10 months ago
Comment removed
pulsarspin 10 months ago
Bruv, wheres your beard? You have no right to preach!!! (Basics)
NasirAlHanbali 11 months ago
in the hadith it is NOT AHLUL BAYT but it is " MY SUNNAH(i.e, WORKS & DEEDS & SAYINGS)" . we must love ahlul bayt but we should be careful how much & what should be their status( infallibility & other things). i hope inshallah we all understand the truth beforre our death and die as true muslims. AMEEN
pulsarspin 11 months ago 2
@pulsarspin Do a little research and Google "Hadith of the two Weighty Things." It's Quran and my family- according to Sooni Hadith books.
mus5599 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@pulsarspin I am leaving among you two weighty things: the one being the Book of Allah in which there is right guidance and light, so hold fast to the Book of Allah and adhere to it. He exhorted (us) (to hold fast) to the Book of Allah and then said: The second are the members of my household I remind you (of your duties) to the members of my family.
Aloosh12 6 months ago
@pulsarspin Hadith of the two weighty things (your own ahl al sunna book)
Aloosh12 6 months ago
ACTUALLY the hadith of Rasul (s) says the "Quran and Ahlul bayt" in bukhari, muslim REFER to this lecture on youtube " Suunis Wahabis Salafis.. Wake up by the Truth: without Etrat & Ahlul-Bayt[as] you are all misguided "
ABOUSTEVE1 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ACTUALLY the hadith of Rasul (s) says the "Quran and Ahlul bayt" in bukhari, muslim REFER to this lecture on youtube "Suunis Wahabis Salafis.. Wake up by the Truth: without Etrat & Ahlul-Bayt[as] you are all misguided"
ABOUSTEVE1 2 months ago
Lannat unto wahabiat....
True kaffir under guise of islam...
01maak 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You people are absolutely crazy and your societies are very fanatical and barbaric. Listen to this fucking stupid speaker. He speaks as though god is on his side. He thinks he is clever but he is infact very deluded. All you people do is argue and are ready to kill each other for the slightest infraction. You come to our great western countries and engage in sexual active and corruption. Thomas Jefferson is better than your whole history and fucked up traditions and religion.
kaligrs 1 year ago
Comment removed
kaligrs 1 year ago
May Allah bless the Mujahideen who really follow Muhammad salAllahu 3alaihi wa sallam. And may Allah unite us and guide us, because subhanAllah we need guidance so much.
wolftch 1 year ago
These words are from a shia mouth.
The only joke is when these monkeys beat them selves, sell their wives and daughters, and curse the companions.
May Allah Burn The Shia Alive Ameen
LearnToReadTheKuran 1 year ago
@LearnToReadTheKuran
People like you are what's wrong with Islam today. You have to akhlaq, you don't talk like a muslim should talk, you sound like an uncivilized beast.
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232
I don't need any manners when I'm talking to monkeys.
LearnToReadTheKuran 1 year ago
@LearnToReadTheKuran
Please don't bring your hatred here. If you have something meaningful and intelligent to contribute then do it, otherwise go spread your hate somewhere else.
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232
Return back to Allah and repent.
LearnToReadTheKuran 1 year ago
@LearnToReadTheKuran
Brother, you are the one who should repent, for slandering and insulting others with hateful words. Where does Islam allow such behavior? Please be reasonable and repectful.
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232
I didn't slander or insult anyone with hateful words. Your a liar.
LearnToReadTheKuran 1 year ago
@LearnToReadTheKuran
When you are calling people monkeys, you are insulting them.
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232
When the shia insult the Sahaba Aleyhem Asaalaam that is what I call insulting !
LearnToReadTheKuran 1 year ago
Comment removed
emadh2 1 year ago
Yes, the Prophets and Messengers made mistakes, but Allaah did not approve of their mistakes; rather, He pointed out their mistakes as a Mercy to them and their ummahs, and He forgave their mistakes and accepted their repentance as a Grace and Mercy, for Allaah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful. This will be clear to anyone who checks out the aayaat of the Qur’aan.
emadh2 1 year ago
asssalam o alaikum brothers
I think this is not a proper place to argue each other. niether its suitable for a lay man. these topics should be dealt in the presence of ulama (the one who knows).
i just want to clear my side(no blaming) that ahl e sunnah belives on considering all sayings of the last messenger (S.A.W.W) never neglecting ahl e bayt and the saying tranfered to us through ahl e bayt.
mizahmed 1 year ago
Why dunt u try following the sunna first? Learn to recite Quran properly. Grow a beard. and talk fact
mbenks 1 year ago
@mbenks
So what are the facts?
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232 Brother, u heard many times about the left hand and the beard. Now how about refuting his statement that "it is the prophet who guides them...Whereas Quran states: .."laysa alayka hudahum wa lakin-Allaha yahdi may ysha". It is not upon u(prophet(s) to guide them, but Allah guides whom he wills.".So the task of the prophet was only to warn. not to guide. Please dont mix the attributes of Allah with the creation. Only Allah is infallible period!!!!
vatandust 1 year ago
@vatandust
Bro, you are not understanding what he's saying. he wasn't quoting a specific verse, what he is saying is that the prophet is a guide and example to mankind. Allah is our lord and guides whom he chooses, but those who obey allah are guided through the prophet. How can allah not provide a living example of what we should follow? The speakers entire point is that if prophet is our role-model sent by allah, how can he sin? How is that just?
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@mbenks Grow a beard? LOL Since when was that made mandatory in Islam? God, the high illiteracy by Sunnis like yourself astound me.
kayhan213 1 year ago
@mbenks yea because islam is all about growing a beard to be knowledgeable ok mate u can grow ur beard as long and as bushy as u want it wont make u neither knowledgeable nor right so please get a life.
boodie619 1 year ago
S.M FAITH # 0050
Umar? He said: Messenger of Allah, did you send Abu Huraira with your sandals to gladden anyone he met and who testified that there is no god but Allah, and being assured of it in his heart, with the tidings that he would go to Paradise? He said: Yes. Umar said: Please do it not, for I am afraid that people will trust in it alone; let them go on doing (good) deeds. The Messenger of Allah (PBU) said: Well, let them.
UMAR TOLD RASULALLAH (SAWA) ,PLEASE DO IT NOT ?
irooni100 1 year ago
Some body should have Explain this subject to the man who was around the rasulallah(SAWA),and became LEADER ?
S.B. FUNERAL 23;447
Thereupon I Umar caught hold of the clothe of Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) and said: Allah's Messenger, are you going to offer prayer?
('Umar added), "Later I astonished at my daring before Allah's Apostle on that day
irooni100 1 year ago
Haha! Somebody PLEASE challenge anything the speaker said. Yes, I know about his hand, but I've heard it 50 times now. Please challenge any of the points he made, this is getting boring!
gomobo2232 1 year ago
Comment removed
aduly123 1 year ago
@gomobo2232
First of all there is not a single Muslim who says that the Prophet made a mistake in the devine message of Allah (swt). So what is all the fuss about ?
Also what do you say about those who claim that the Prophet failed in teaching his Wives and Companions the best of teaching. The same logic can be applied by saying that since the Prophet failed in teaching the closest people to him then how can he teach Islam to the world !!!
aduly123 1 year ago
@aduly123
The prphet not only conveys the divine message, but he is the example of how to live by allah's laws. How can he committ injustices and then claim to be our best example? As the Quran says, "the prophet has greater right over the believers than they have over themselves".
gomobo2232 1 year ago
Comment removed
aduly123 1 year ago
@gomobo2232
Yes there is not doubt the Prophet (peace and blessing of Allah be upon him) is the best example. I have not heard any Muslim accuse the Prophet of doing any injustice....although I have heard some prominent Shia alims claim that the Prophet made a mistake by not telling his followers who would lead after him - now this is clear blasphemy and kufr.
aduly123 1 year ago
@aduly123 You moron. In Sunni beliefs, they believe the Prophet (pbuh) was a mortal who could be sinful and make mistakes before his prophethood by Allah (swt). How can a man who commit sins or make mistakes be a leader in example to the ummah? Sunnis have it all twisted.
kayhan213 1 year ago
Comment removed
aduly123 1 year ago
@kayhan213.
Typical reply from Jahils. We (Ahlul Sunnah wa Jammah) believe that Prophet Muhammed was masoom from making any mistake in the devine message from Allah.
Here is the link if you want to read up more on what the Ahlul Sunnah wa Jammah believe but frankly I doubt it will help you because your thinking is already preprogrammed for you.
Hmmm... not able post with links ? Any ideas....
aduly123 1 year ago
@aduly123 Are you illiterate? Educate yourself in Sunni theology. They said that the Prophet (pbuh) was no infallible until his prophethood by Allah (swt). Sunni scholars ever implicate the Prophet (pbuh) making mistakes by forgetting prayers and other nonsense. Sunni sect of Islam is FALSE and the religion of Yazid and Muawiy'ah.
kayhan213 1 year ago
@kayhan213
It is you who needs to educate yourself and not blindly follow whatever you are being brainwashed with in your Hussainiyats etc. I wonder from where you got that Sunni sect is the religion of Yazid and Muawiy'ah. Maybe you are follower of Kamal Al Haidari who is known for his lies.
Ahlul Sunnah follow the Quran and authenthic Sunnah of our beloved Prophet Muhammed transmitted to us by his noble Ahlul Bayt (wives, progeny) and prominent Sahabas - may Allah be pleased with them ALL.
aduly123 1 year ago
@aduly123 u are incorrect his wives were not part of the ahul bayt the people of the cloak are its very plain in bukhari he wrapped in his cloak Fatimah Ali hassan And hussein his wifes are not part of it nor were bakr umar or uthman its not my opnion its in the sunni hadiths the most"athentic" thats who he said were the ahul bayt
zulfiqar501 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kayhan213
Typical reply from Jahils. We (Ahlul Sunnah wa Jammah) believe that Prophet Muhammed was masoom from making any mistake in the devine message from Allah.
Here is the link if you want to read up more on what the Ahlul Sunnah wa Jammah believe but frankly I doubt it will help you because your thinking is already preprogrammed for you.
hmmm... not able to post with links ? Any ideas ....
aduly123 1 year ago
@gomobo2232 OWNED!
kayhan213 1 year ago
@aduly123
As to the second question. The prophet did not "fail" at teaching anyone anything. The prophet was a perfect messenger and teacher. Allah says in the Quran, .O Prophet (Muhammad), you cannot give guidance to whom you wish, it is God Who gives guidance to whom He pleases, and He is quite aware of those who are guided.” (28:55-56)." If some chose to disobey the prophet, that is there mistake, It doesn't mean he "failed" to teach them correctly. We must hold fast to the ahlulbayt.
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232
I know for fact that the Prophet did not fail but claims made by this fool and his like can lead to such slander...As for holding fast to the Ahlulbayt, first we need to establish what you mean by "hold fast" ? Then we have to establish who are the Ahlul, in the Arabic language Ahlul Bayt means people of the household and above all are the wives. Then of course we need to establish if this " hold fast " is in accordance to the Quran which leads to alot more questions....
aduly123 1 year ago
@gomobo2232
By the way, are you aware of the hadith of the Prohpet warning against eating and dring with left hand if not here it is - “When any one of you eats, let him eat with his right hand, and when he drinks, let him drink with his right hand, because the Satan eats with his left hand and drinks with his left hand.” (Reported by Muslim). I think this should be sufficient proof that we should not listen to such Jahils.
aduly123 1 year ago
I am surprised with his kind of people who have the audacity to preach about our great Prophet (peace and blessing of Allah be upon him) and do not even follow the Sunnah. Any Muslim child knows that we must use our right hand when eating, drinking. Also must sit when drinking water, not stand and drink.....
aduly123 1 year ago
@aduly123
Haha! Somebody PLEASE challenge anything the speaker said. Yes, I know about his hand, but I've heard it 50 times now. Please challenge any of the points he made, this is getting boring!
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232 it is a reply to your Haha!. The speaker says: "it is the prophet who guides them". But Quran says: It is not upon you to guide them, but Allah guides whom He wills. The task of the prophet is only to warn and give glad tidings....
vatandust 1 year ago
HE DRINKS WATER WITH HIS LEFT HAND, THERE YOU GO
Quraniswisdom 1 year ago
@Quraniswisdom
Yes! Let's not refute anything he said. Just look at his hand! Oh the wahhabis are so intellectual!
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232:
If find brothers who are harsh to others are the very same one calling other brothers harsh! I'm not shi'a, btw, but do you hear me or MOST of the sunnis on this page calling shi'a names like "these filthy shi'as" or "The shi'as are so intellectual!". There's is no need for labeling or name calling. As Allah says: "...Produce your proof if indeed you are truthful." Just bring forth your evidence. Name calling is not proof that what your saying is true. Let's use our islamic manners.
HaitianMuslim 1 year ago
@Quraniswisdom
if you look at the video carefully, theres a wedding ring on his right hand and he drinks with his left hand. could the video dimensions be reversed?
MrFazalmahmud 1 year ago
laa ta'kuloo bi shimaal fa inna shaytana ya'kull bi shmaal... shayytaaaannnnnnnnnn!!!!
islamsubmiter 1 year ago
Of course! our prophet(SA) is Ma-asoom
hath84 1 year ago
MASHALLAH
10metrocool 1 year ago
yuck yuck yuck
docakh 1 year ago
U must obey the prophet over ur own desires. True so tell this guy to stop shaving ya beard. May Allah guide this man. He has no idea even to what he's sayin. Ppll do not lissen to ppll u do not Noe.
Anonymous01011 1 year ago
Attn: 6:18 ..."drinking with his left hand"..while sending greeting to the prophet(pbuh). Didn't he teach us to use only right hand when eating and drinking?.. May Allah guide us all and make us all true followers of Muhammad(pbuh) and the righteous predecessors. Ameen.
MrMasomenos 1 year ago 2
@MrMasomenos
Are you going to refute what the speaker is saying, his arguments? Or just call attention to his hand?
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232 sorry if that made u mad... I just wanted to remind myself and others about this beautiful sunnah of using right hand while eating and/or drinking. As for refuting, no I am not here to refute, i just want to say that i bear witness that none is worthy of worship besides Allah and Muhammad(pbuh) is his messenger. I believe that the only religion acceptable in the sight of Allah is Islam, and that all powers belong to Allah, not to any kind of Imams or awliya...may Allah guide us.amin
MrMasomenos 1 year ago 8
@MrMasomenos What powers are these that're being wrongly attributed to the imams? Are you referring to infallibility? If so, keep this in mind. The necessity of successorship after the Prophet is believed among Sunni and Shia. The successor is there to protect the integrity of God's message and serve as a model for how its laws can be followed. Shia believe that the successor was appointed by the Prophet through a divine command and given the role's magnitude, the successor must be infallible.
mo39fhn 1 year ago
@MrMasomenos OMG, not you again!
srexob715 1 year ago
@MrMasomenos
I am not angry. But we have to be serious about these issues. If people are going to debate about the length of beards and the use of hands when drinking water, we can't have serious discussions. There is one god, muhammad is his messenger, and the ahlulbayt are the guardians of the message against tyrants and stealers of authority.
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232: Yes! We have to be serious about following the sunnah. Eating and drinking w/ the right hand IS a serious matter. No aspect of the sunnah is 'not serious.' Maybe, that one time you drank w/ your right hand SOLELY for the sake of Allah may cause you to enter jannah!!!
HaitianMuslim 1 year ago
@HaitianMuslim
I'm not saying that these matters are not important in their own right. But if we are going to be discussing the schools of thought in an honest manner then we have to stay on the topic and not create diversions. Very few people who have even commented on this video have even tried to refute what he said. They just talk about his hand! Including you!
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232: As Muslims we ought to be people of action, not mere people of speech. A person's action may indicate a person's condition, as is the case here. It's clear that this man is speaking from his desires:
1. He speaks using (flawed) reasoning, without any textual evidence from Qur'an or Sunnah.
2. If he were to look into the tafsir of the surah Abasa it would be clear that it's referring to the Prophet (saws)
3. If not the Prophet, who is the verse referring to then? He doesn't say. Why?
HaitianMuslim 1 year ago
@HaitianMuslim:
4. Moreover, to assume that our beloved Prophet (saws) is perfect and infallible, is to attribute to him the nature of Allah Himself, for ONLY Allah is perfect. Even the Angels make mistakes: "when your Lord said to the angels, "Indeed, I will make upon the earth a Khalifa." They said, "Will You place upon it one who causes corruption therein and sheds blood, while we declare Your praise and sanctify You?" Allah said, "Indeed, I know that which you do not know." Q2:30
HaitianMuslim 1 year ago
@HaitianMuslim:
Plus, the Prophet (saws) said himself (in a famous sahih hadith): "ALL the children of Adam make mistakes, and the best of those who make mistakes are those who repent." Is not the Prophet (saws) himself from the children of Adam? Or would you claim that he lied by saying this? All his sins were forgiven, but he did make mistakes.
HaitianMuslim 1 year ago
@gomobo2232:
@HaitianMuslim:
Remember, that the non-Muslims say that the Prophet wrote the Qur'an himself. So, contrary to the argument of the brother in the video, I find that the fact that the Qur'an critizes the Prophet (saws) is actually PROOF that the Qur'an wasn't written by him (saws). For, why would he make himself look bad? This is actually one of the factors that convinced me that the Qur'an was REVEALED to the Prophet BY God. This factor was important in making me convert to Islam.
HaitianMuslim 1 year ago
@HaitianMuslim
Masha-Allah brother, your points are as one would say " to the point ". May Allah keep you stead fast to the deen of Islam.
aduly123 1 year ago
@aduly123: Ameen wa yaaka. Jazzak Allahu Khayran.
HaitianMuslim 1 year ago
@MrMasomenos Could you show me the clear ayat in which we are commanded such a thing.
fucknuaf 1 year ago
@MrMasomenos: VERY GOOD OBSERVATION brother!!! May Allah bless you for catching this. These people are not upon the sunnah; they shave, eat, drink with left hand, and to them, it's no big deal!!!
HaitianMuslim 1 year ago
the verse you stated.. called ayte tatheera.. fits perfect with what ur saying and the verse does have a deep meaning, Inamaa.. Allah ki marzi.. i end here.
SyedShah01 1 year ago
Allah guide this guy inshaAllah.
GUPTABAG 1 year ago
These were praised by the Prophet (S): The best of people is my generation, then those who come after them, then those who come after them [Bukhari and Muslim]. The term Salaf applies also to the Scholars of Ahl us-Sunnah wal-Jama'ah after the first three blessed generations who followed their way in belief and practices.
Siratalmustaqeemuk 1 year ago
Allah swt has said: Whoever contends with and contradicts the Messenger after guidance has been clearly conveyed to him, and follows a path other than that of the Faithful Believers, We shall leave him in the Path he has chosen and land him in Hell, what an evil destination! [An Nisa 4:115].
As-Salaf us-Salih refers to the first and best three generations of Muslims. They are the Companions of the Prophet (S), their immediate followers (Tabiun), and the followers of the Tabi'in.
Siratalmustaqeemuk 1 year ago
amazing!!!
please do follow the prophet ,he use to drink with his right hand and shaytan with his left....
herboriste4youtub 1 year ago
lol what a load of rubbish.
UmmahTube 1 year ago
so this moron is saying that the prophet didnt frown?
if no then he is rejecting the quran simply the prophet was only a human
but the BEST OF MAN KIND
u love him trough following his ways this dude if he claims he loves prophet how is that he does not have beard? oh wait he has beard but its a so called beard lolz
AYEMAQ 1 year ago
@AYEMAQ
The speaker is reffering to the surah abbasah. Nowhere in the sura does it explicitly say that the prophet frowned at the man. It said "HE" frowned. Your interpretation is based on hadith. But you must understand that other schools follow other hadith regarding this incident. Our school believes that the surah was revealed about a companion of the prophet who frowned at the man while he was talking to the prophet, the surah came to correct HIM. not our beloved prophet PBUH.
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232
ya ur scholar right
i think they forgot to read the whole sura
or the context of the sura
imagine the quran is being reveled to the prophet and how to preach but its criticizing another companion ????
just be honest to urslf and read the whole sura and think about it if u still think that its another sahaba then when u recite sura al fatiha on the prayer make sure u mean it cuz its the sura of guidance
AYEMAQ 1 year ago
@AYEMAQ
I have read the whole surah. And I can see where you're coming from, but you have to understand that this is merely interpretation of the surah. The Quran is revealed to teach lessons to mankind. When this companion insulted the blind man...it was a lesson for US. Not the prophet.. If you have further doubts read the tafsir of allamah tabatabai about surah ababsah. Here is the link. perhaps you will find it an interesting second opinion
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232 You have read the whole Surah right? To whom was this revealed in the first place, the first one amongst Mankind to whom it was revealed? The Companion about whom you are talking about? Or Rasulullah (Salallahu alayhi wa Salam)?
Don't read just the first 2 Ayat. Read on. When Allah speaks using: "Thee" "You"....indeed Allah is speaking to Mankind. But to whom in the first place? The Companion u are claiming these 2 Verses are speaking about? No. Rasulullah (Salallahu alayhi wa Salam
misalah 1 year ago
@misalah
The surah was revealed to the holy prophet PBUH or course, he is allah's messenger. But the surah is talking generally about not thinking lesser of people who are poor, or disadvantaged. Now, who frowned at the blind man? My school of thought believes it was a ummayyad cheiftain who was seeking the counsel of the prophet. The surah was revealed addressing his actions as a lesson for US ALL. How is that so hard to understand?
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232 that is not what is hard to understand. What is hard to understand is how you blindly follow your school of thought, while you are Muslim. Furthermore, it is hard to understand why you reject Sahih and Hasan hadiths concerning the revelation of the Verse about Rasulullah (Salallahu alayhi wa Salam) frowning. However, it is easy to understand that you prefer your school of thought over Rasulullah (Salallahu alayhi wa Salam). And your comments reflect just that.
misalah 1 year ago
@misalah
You claim that I blindly follow my school of thought without providing any evidence of that. So by your logic, you also blindly follow your school of thought, and your understanding of this surah is just because that is the only interpretation you've ever know. But that is not a real argument. I will respect you argument based on reason, logic and evidence. Also, not everyone agrees on what is "sahih"...
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@misalah
You claim that I prefer my school of thought "over rasullallah" What does that even mean? All of the schools of thought in islam seek to better understand what the prophet actually said and did. If I think that something falsely is attributed to the prophet and that he never did such a thing....would I not seek to challenge it? of course I would and so would you. But I'm not going to attack you and say you "blindly" follow it. The question should be "what is your evidence?"
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@misalah
Also, you keep listing translations where it says , "the prophet frowned" I ask you respectfully, do you understand Arabic? The transliteration of the actually words is "Abasah wa tawwallah" that means HE frowned and turned away. It doesn't say An-Nabi frowned...or ar-rasool. Can you show me where it says that? That's why you see "the prophet" in parenthesis. this is a general method of interpretation, not direct translation.
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@misalah
I sent a message to your inbox explaining where to find the Tafsir Al-Mizaan online and its study of surah abasah. Allameh Tabatabei wrote a very comprehensive tafsir of this surah. You might find it interesting even if you don't agree. Its good to understand the arguments of different schools, then weigh the evidence and make a conclusion
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@misalah What you call hadeeth Saheeh did not came to existant till the year 142 on the permission of Omar bin Abdul Azeez. Your famous Son of Bitch Bukhari was nothing but the lacky of Banu Ommayyeh who fought against the brother of Messenger of Allah and killed his two grand children. He brings more hadeeth from the people who fought against Ahl beit than Ahl beit themselves.
Irancolor 1 year ago
@Irancolor Ahl ul Beit. Go research what Ahl ul Beit means. Ahl ul Beit includes Aysah (radi'Allahu anha), and this is according to the definition which your ayatushaytans provide. Go solve your issue with knowing who Ahl ul Beit is first, before calling the mother of Bukhari (rahimah'Allah) a whore.
And I advise you to stop attributing the actions of some upon others, and go read the Qur'an, go see what Allah has to say concerning such a matter. I invite you to Islam. May Allah guide me and u
misalah 1 year ago
@AYEMAQ
I sent the link to your inbox
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@AYEMAQ
Can you show me where it says THE PROPHET frowned?
gomobo2232 1 year ago
@gomobo2232
surah 80:1
1. (The Prophet (Peace be upon him)) frowned and turned away,
youtusf ali translation
1: The Prophet frowned and turned away
sahih international translation
1:He frowned and turned away
pickthall
u can check it out in ur own language so u know for sure if sone one says he didnt then dont u think he is out of islam for contradicting quran?
AYEMAQ 1 year ago
Wahhabis and salafis are ASTRAY
We WILL NEVER STOP SAYING "YA RASOOL ALLAH!"
10metrocool 1 year ago
LOL...uneducated
muwaaz 2 years ago
The Prophet s.a.w.s. said: "Do not eat with your left hand, cause satan eats with his left"...
Dear speaker, take his word, and do not eat/drink with your left hand as long as your right one is healthy.
kosofijun 2 years ago
suban allah.
thaiden03 2 years ago
i am let's say sunni but i don't want to be in any sect...cause as soon as we name ourselfs something else than Muslims we enter a sect...
a human makes mistakes,even if he is a messenger...this is the prove that only Allah swt is perfect and free from mistakes...
the problem is that shia are to occupied with ahlul bayt and the sunnis are not even mentioning the ahlul bayt,always balblabla abu bakr,umar,but how about ali ra how about the ahlul bayt,they were so pure,Allah give them best jannah
azir111 2 years ago 3
@azir111 why am i hearing blah blah blah from you. sunnis don't talk about it, cuz its black history to them....shit's gonna hit the fan..do your research then we'll talk
marcstylzzz 1 year ago
@azir111 The messenger of god will never do mistakes. If you know that some one will steal your money or missing your money, would you give your money to him???
Then what about god????
toor20072020 1 year ago
@toor20072020 ok i'll start answering from now on, cause you don't use anything from your mind, Allah gave us intellect and free will to choose right from wrong, Allah put logic and Iman in us to worship Him properly,
what you and the other guy is saying is truly only blabla, not me but you and him.
the messenger indeed can do mistakes and we seen this over and over, if he doesn't make mistakes than he is God that's what you're saying, free from error, than he must be god wow?
think about it
azir111 1 year ago
@azir111: The ignorance of these people is as clear as water; there's no dust on it! Clear! No wonder many of them end up worshiping the Prophet (saws) since they believe him to have been perfect. These people are upon clear baatil!
HaitianMuslim 1 year ago
@HaitianMuslim
“Do not over praise me as the Christians have over praised Jesus, the son of Mary. I am only a man. Therefore say: ‘The servant and Messenger of Allâh .’” (Bukhâri)
O Messenger! Proclaim the (message) which has been sent to you from your Rabb.” (Qur’ân 5:67)
“Say: ‘I am but a man like yourselves but the inspiration has come to me, that your God is one God.’” (Qur’ân 18:l10)
Muhammad was the greatest man on earth, last messenger, but not God, he was not perfect.
azir111 1 year ago
this speack does not know what the sura the frown is or the story of ayub,, he forgets prophets are human,,, and when they make a mistake in this world allah punishes them in this world by exposing there mistake hence the sura the frown,, so they dnt get punished in this world
ramp31 2 years ago
esselamu aleykum
osmanli911 2 years ago
actualy mad(mentaly retarded) person cannot judge any rather he himself understand all r retarded as exactly same u
chalenge i can prove that u r mentaly retarded
AliHaqAli1 2 years ago
Agree 100% that if the prophets make a mistake the religion is out the window. Bilal Philips needs to learn this......Someone who is not perfect can not deliver a perfect religion.
moman000 2 years ago
@moman000 Ay Buddy, SO WHAT? We know that the Prophet made mistakes in other aspects of life but Allah (Subhanna Wata ala) did not allow the Prophets to make Mistakes when it come to the Revelation. The Prophet did not speak from himself, he was REVEALING the words of God. I mean, Are Prophets not human too? Its really not hard to understand. Perfection is only an attribute Belonging to Allah. But, when it comes to models to follow, then the Way of the Prophet is the Perfect one to follow...
BlueCity24 2 years ago
What are these mistakes the prophet made? Please inform me.
moman000 2 years ago
u should study Quran and not ur bukhari as Quran is right and infallible not ur bukhari just take help of bukhari to understand Quran if u find contradict u should forbid than hadith as Prophet Muhammad hve given sahih hadith not sahih book. study the creation of him and who is Prophet Muhammad and who r u?
Prophet Adam and all Prophets have not ever said that Prophet Muhammad is like themself and u the son of adam is comparing ownself with him?astakferullah
AliHaqAli1 2 years ago
Why is this guy dancing up and down while talking...
rmuseud 2 years ago
beware of eloquent speech. Sahih bukhari.
salahaddin2009 2 years ago
Also if it helps.Everytime and always when the prophet(pbuh) got a new revelation, it was a direct result of the events that happened.Examine closely this incident. This was a direct one, Because the prophet got a revelation right away about it.Not indirect because someone else saw it. A revelation to the direct interaction of the event. Not a unnoticed one some mention here.The Quraysh frowned on everyone? in front of the prophet(pbuh) all the time anyway.This was nothing new at the time.
chipmaster86 2 years ago
A sample list of errors that Allah(swt) had corrected the prophet(pbuh) on.
Al-Taubah 9: 43, `Abasa 80: 1 16, Al-Kahaf 18: 23 24.
chipmaster86 2 years ago
Be careful too. Hassanain is very good. I like him a lot. But pay attention to his speech. In the very beginning around 20 second video mark he comes out with hard downing of the prophet(pbuh) "he was" and "he was". This is done so you will think this is so bad to consider.This is part of speech class in school. Then he baits you for the come back statement of" How can this be"? So really my brothers absorb only the wise words and think hard for oneself. Research the vessel before you ride on it
chipmaster86 2 years ago
Comment removed
chipmaster86 2 years ago
In reality it borders Haram and producing division in faith. Maybe I shouldn't be saying Haram full force, but this particular topic balances out Shia and Sunni in opposite directions. Like I said, in a well noted Author, the only one excepted by Saudi religious leaders, found Karen Armstrongs in depth research on the matter solid and concrete. The profit made a small mistake. Some people here are putting this similar to the "Satanic Verses" That is totally different. I just disagree Hassasien
chipmaster86 2 years ago
Another issue to point out from Hassasien is that to say a prophet who makes a mistake invalidates his religion. The whole statement for this should never be made in the first place. All the prophets in History have made errors, and conformed to the change. Hassasien should never put this question to our minds. This is wrong to discuss such a statement. Haram. It will lead us to argue. When peace is what is our Jihad for now. So the idea is invalid to discuss. Haram. Masalama
chipmaster86 2 years ago
Since when is it Haraam to have a logical discussion about ideas in Islam? I agree that we all need to strive for unity now, as shia, sunni or whatever other school. We are all muslims. But this doesn't mean that we stop asking important questions and helping each other grow in knowledge. Hassanain is making an intellectual argument about the very nature of religion and what makes it valid. That doesn't mean that he is questioning YOUR deen. We need to keep being open minded and ask questions.
gomobo2232 2 years ago
Rajoul, in what this subject will help you to get closer to Allah.(SA) . Are you not tirred to brass air. Learn your deen and practise it. Mohammed (sws) came back to his Lord and now you work for you.
rhour7 2 years ago
Quran, Surah 80.
79CE 2 years ago
To me too Hassasien is amazing. His speech is very very good. May Allah bless him in his speeches. But I must admit. We need to consider the fact that the Prophet (pbuh) was a human being. Every Human has made some errors in life. I do know the Prophet(pbuh) was infallible. No religious mistakes. But There is this one incident where he turned away the blind man to talk too the rich men, and he was told of his mistake by Allah, and this is mentioned in Surah 'Abasa.
chipmaster86 2 years ago
obviously you didn't even watch the video where he explains this mid-reading into surah Abasa. That entire understanding of it from the sunni viewpoint is based off of one hadith which claims it was the prophet who turned away. It never says "the prophet turned away" in the Quran. From what our school of thought believes, the verse was in reference to a companion of the prophet who turned away. And the verse came to teach him.
gomobo2232 2 years ago
In Karen Armstrongs biography of the Prophet(pbuh) Karen under strict scrutiny in her research of the Prophet(pbuh) points out this mistake as well. Karen is not even Muslim and she is fully excepted author in Saudi circles and praised over her work. Even the mistake of think he was abandoned during the Meccan years. When the prophet(pbuh) said he wasn't going to get any more revelations and thought Allah had abandoned him. The list goes on. Blessed is the prophet(pbuh) he is Human too.
chipmaster86 2 years ago
this man saying that the prophet of Allah will never make mistake. how about the prophet Musa 'AS', Dawood 'AS', and Yunos AS? I think he doesn;t know the Qur'an or he is trying 2 suport his believe in 12 pure (ma'soo ) imam, which is a pillar of his faith. if they don't believe so, all of their belief is vein.
It doesn't make any different for us if the prophet made mistake or not.YET, HE IS IN THE EXALTED STANDARD OF CHARACTER in human race.
sha150680 2 years ago
I wonder which companion that migh be ?
aduly123 2 years ago
hatred shows on his face....as if hes making fun of or mocking...good people stay calm and argue reasonably....I dont understand why anyone would be so aggressive when delivering a certain message...but then again...Allah Knows Best...
MnM8889 2 years ago
Hassanain is AMAZING!
subhanallah!!
valerienanh 2 years ago
haha, thats not the case. thats his style.
FashionBudgetTV 2 years ago
This ignorant think he is smart and talking about prophet like he is talking about his friend and accusing him wrong.
May allah guide us.
asrimostalg 2 years ago
Growing a Beard, Siwak ,ect are Sunnah. What is Sunnah. Definition : It is the Way of Life of an Individual. He (SAW) lived his life with a Beard, using Siwak, drinking Honey, and the list goes on. Date pollinating is a trivial issue. All The Prophets were Forgiven. They were Human, feeling Weak sometimes, other times strong. Confident one day, not so much on the next. Perfection is an Attribute Belonging only to Allah. Allah never feels weak or dependent. This is untrue for Humans,even Prophets
BlueCity24 2 years ago
dont confuse perfection of Allah, to the perfection of Prophets and humans in general.
have you forgotten that humans can be higher than Angels in there level of perfection, with accordance to following Allah's will? if you and I have that chance of having that HIGH of a status, higher than Angels, and we ALL know that Angels are perfect..then how could you say that Prophet Muhammad(SAW) made mistakes?
FashionBudgetTV 2 years ago
What about those who claim that the Quran is incomplete and real Quran is with the Imam in Sardab ? This guy first should go and clean the garbage in Shia books before putting false accusation about others.
aduly123 2 years ago
well go and speak to them.
thats not in the Shia doctrine. i'm just learning, and i have seen lots of mis-information about this sect, and NOW i can see why.
just like the propaganda world-wide is making Islam(in general) look bad..
now, slowly, the trend is ALL about making the Shia sect look bad..makes a person ponder :P
the thing is, is that this brother is defending this religion.
did u not listen to this speech? from 3:08- 3:16. do you know what he is saying?
FashionBudgetTV 2 years ago
Go and read Al Kafi and Nahajul Balaga closely and you will see the wonders of nonsense which are attributed to the Prophet and the Imams. I know your so called scholars will their herd of followers but then why not clean the Shia books of such filth and nonsense attributed to the Prophet and the Imam.
aduly123 2 years ago
this proves that you have no Idea what the Shia sect follow. do you even know the basic principles we follow?
lol
FashionBudgetTV 2 years ago
@FashionBudgetTV yes for one example!!
you dont like hz othman!!
so the prophet s.a.v give 2 of his daughters to someone who is bad for the islam??
so ebu bekir r.a is laying next to muhammed s.a.v but he is also bad for the deen etc etc etc
may allah give us al hidayah
i dont hate no person but i can hate the things someone says or does in the name of allah!!
love and be mad in the name of allah.
Suat611 2 years ago
my brother, why do you think Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) had several wives?
FashionBudgetTV 2 years ago
@FashionBudgetTV
you tell me!!
you are talking like the expert,i dont know!!
Suat611 2 years ago
you said prophet muhammad(pbuh) gave 2 of his daughters away to bad people..
then why would he(pbuh) have many wives? werent there reasons behind him(pbuh) having different wives? so why do you think he would give away his daughters the way he did?
i'm not here to force-feed people. people can figure it out :O) Inshallah
FashionBudgetTV 2 years ago
also, just because their were people next to the Prophet, it does not make them 'good'. because WE have NEVER seen the Prophet, yet we can become good :O)
FashionBudgetTV 2 years ago
thats ilm people like you cant understand!!
sahabe who have seen resulullah s.a.v are blessed with the nur on muhammed s.a.v face!!
whatever we do,we can never be like the sahabe!!
you think the companions of muhammed s.a.v are people like you and me???
may allah give you hidayah!!
Suat611 2 years ago
@Suat611
Does the fact that someone had seen rasullallah (SAWS) mean that they were automatically righteous and unable to commit injustices?
gomobo2232 2 years ago
@gomobo2232
you know im not gonna argue!!
lets just look at ourself!!
,just do the best you can do for the sake of allah brother,and insallah every one that gives sahadah may go to cennah insallah!!
selamun aleykum ve rahmetullah ve berakatuh
Suat611 2 years ago
@Suat611
Insha'allah. Wa Alaikum salaam wa rahmatullahu wa barakatu
gomobo2232 2 years ago