There were so many aspects of the book that were missing in this movie. They left out quite a lot of important parts and even some of my favourite scenes! Made me a little mad, to be honest...
I was really expecting them to have the full version of Snape's worst memory. I was so pissed off that his worst memory was being bullied and not of him calling Lily a mudblood. By not including that they totally screwed up the next two movies.
@Stonymypony I kniw! Having him not say Mudblood screwed everything up! Anyway, moviegoers may not understand it, but book lovers will.. "Always." Haha
The scene with Umbridge in the Forbidden Forest is pretty relevant to who her overall character and behavior throughout the series. It should most definitely have been included.
Sirius' death in this film occurs as if nothing happens.... That momment in the book was sooooo dramatic. They screwed it, that's why the 5th film is the worst out of them all.
@fabo6589 i think it was just showing her overreacting to choking. she is very superstitious and took the precaution of plopping 2 spoonfuls of mashed potatoes on the table before she could resume eating. to keep from getting choked again she instead of eating the potatoes just put the spoon in her drink. in the end her potato plopping method didnt work and she accidently dumped her plate on herself. so the whole thing was just to show how clumsy and superstitioius she is. i hoped this helped.
does anyone know who's the teacher beside trelawney at 00:57?? some people say it's professor sinistra but sinistra is actually black. on harry potter wiki is written that she's probably a recast of sinistra or someone else but the wiki actually says that she's "unidentified "...can anyone help me? lol
@fabo6589 when they were filming umbridges speech, they were probably planning to have a cut scene to trelawney acting insane and not paying attention, to highlight the tension in their relationship i suppose. therefore they asked her to do the whole scene even though they'll only use a couple of seconds of it, because i think shes improvising. i think it probably killed the tension of umbridge's speech which is why they didn't use it in the end.
@mj4eva47 no...i really dont think thats it...shes completely ignoring her for a start, and she hasnt had an opportunity to be intimidated when they havent even spoken to one another yet - none of the staff are. i think shes just being a weirdo.
Professor Trelawny should have said, "i predict you will be out of the defence against the dark arts job by the end of the year." Cause its true. For every defence against the dark arts teacher.
LMAO PROFESSOR TRELAWNY HAS SUCH WEIRD EATING HABITS!!!! :D I thought she was just so absorbed in umbridge's speech that she forgot where her mouth was. then i was like oh, she's so disgusted by her pinkness that she went cookoo :D
i think the dolores umbridge scene in the forest was good it showed how vile she really is...and i like the last scene--but of course i like any scene with ron and hermione :)
8:00 right there, I thought for sure Umbridge was going to confess that she sent the Dementors after Harry at the beginning, just like she did in the book. But she doesn't. I guess they never shot that. So the movies really do leave it up in the air.
I wonder if most of what Trelawny ended up doing in that meal scene was intentional, or if she just made one mess and the rest followed suit, like the domino effect.
at the end, with ron and hermione, there should have been something there, like a conversation or something. and all the scenes was like, o my god they filmed it just to delete it from the movie and all this shit. its stupis
I wanted to know if anyone else remembers seeing this in the cinema/theater and there were a couple of extras: Snapes parents fighting with him looking down and when he is sitting in his bedroom he looks over & kills some flies at the window. I KNOW that was in the film I saw but somehow it is nowhere to be seen now. I don't understand why that would be cut from the DVD/TV versions but who knows?!
10:04 - "Nope. Not coming." "Oh, great! so still a date like we planned. Don't tell Harry we almost forgot about him though. Poor chap..." "S'okay. He'll date my sister next year."
the neville/daiky prophet bitshould have been left in.. along with the little common room scene. in themovies they leave out some of the most defining aspects of life at hogwarts. this was my favorite book and they screwed it up in the movie. THEY LEFT OUT THE HARRY AND CHO DATE SCENE
2 min and 33 sec of pure entertainment. It had me in stiches. Only a great actress as Emma Thompson can make you laugh to the point of felingl your ribs hurt without even talking!
though this is almost the best book of harry potter series, I think this is the worst movie along with half-blood prince (which is also an awesome book) Where's Quidditch? David Yates SUCKS
@AaronRawrz That was a pretty important part in the book, he also says that his grandmother has always stuck sides with dumbledore and If he says you know who Is back then he is. Something like that anyway.
They should have kept in all these scenes! The ones they delete (save the eating one haha) always have some sort of important canon info and are really interesting
@EdgeNVickiefan316 I wouldn't worry about it. I don't see how they could possibly leave that scene out and have the ending make any sense. Unless they completely rewrite it from scratch, which this series so far has been pretty good about not doing.
When she predicts thats umbridge is in grave danger, she weren't lying, lol xx
2armylife 2 months ago
How dare they to cut out draco!!
Mlove1997 2 months ago
aguante la prof trelawney
sevAlways 2 months ago
05:41 and then 08:23 you are in grave danger oh whatever as she screams off wid therandom people
Bobinda123 3 months ago
what is wrong with trelawney in this scene? Its soo funny
GeorgeWeasleyGirl 5 months ago
what is the tune at 3:22
GOLDENDRAGON250 5 months ago
I'm from Norway, and Sybill Trelawney's name in norwegian means Rakel Rummelfiold. xD
smerete 5 months ago
Look! a scene with professor trelawney and harry where she doesn't predict his death....unusual.
Stonymypony 5 months ago
AWW NEVILLE MY BB<3 6:07
mizzsoccachik666 5 months ago
The quallity is bad and you should FEEL bad.
Azimuth95 5 months ago
I see why these scenes were deleted...they suck
markers123 5 months ago
LOL Trelawney
TheLinkZeldaGanon 5 months ago
@zeldaxjesus16 I know, gotta love her :)
JMfan2400 5 months ago
There were so many aspects of the book that were missing in this movie. They left out quite a lot of important parts and even some of my favourite scenes! Made me a little mad, to be honest...
JMfan2400 5 months ago
I was really expecting them to have the full version of Snape's worst memory. I was so pissed off that his worst memory was being bullied and not of him calling Lily a mudblood. By not including that they totally screwed up the next two movies.
Stonymypony 5 months ago 3
@Stonymypony I kniw! Having him not say Mudblood screwed everything up! Anyway, moviegoers may not understand it, but book lovers will.. "Always." Haha
HarryPotterismyhome 5 months ago 3
Lmao Professor Trelawny is so much more entertaining than Umbidge's babbling.
xmysticangelxx 5 months ago 4
The scene with Umbridge in the Forbidden Forest is pretty relevant to who her overall character and behavior throughout the series. It should most definitely have been included.
KateMich12 5 months ago
You know he's loyal when Ron Weasley gives up eating so he can listen to your feelings and complaints. Ron <3
cooktastrophe27 5 months ago 10
Thumbs up if your a huge Harry Potter fan!!!
ip1999 5 months ago 58
@ip1999 If you were clever enough to have read the books then you would know that it's you're.
Azimuth95 5 months ago
Comment removed
ip1999 5 months ago
@Azimuth95, I'm sorry, I usually speak french, and I'm only 85% bilingual. :)
ip1999 5 months ago
@Azimuth95, and by the way, I read the books. :)
ip1999 5 months ago
They should've kept most of these scenes in...
Hawkefilms 5 months ago
Sirius' death in this film occurs as if nothing happens.... That momment in the book was sooooo dramatic. They screwed it, that's why the 5th film is the worst out of them all.
revoltijo11 5 months ago 4
@revoltijo11 agreed
rosepulina 5 months ago
Damn.. I wish Proffessor Trelawny had flicked that white cream stuff at Umbridge... would have been hilarious!
amylee178 5 months ago 11
trelawneys something else. shes just in her own little world.
mrawesome7000 5 months ago 8
@fabo6589 i think it was just showing her overreacting to choking. she is very superstitious and took the precaution of plopping 2 spoonfuls of mashed potatoes on the table before she could resume eating. to keep from getting choked again she instead of eating the potatoes just put the spoon in her drink. in the end her potato plopping method didnt work and she accidently dumped her plate on herself. so the whole thing was just to show how clumsy and superstitioius she is. i hoped this helped.
mrawesome7000 5 months ago
Not even listening to Umbridge. Just wondering what the hell Trelawny is doing.
Shenzei1musical 5 months ago 6
does anyone know who's the teacher beside trelawney at 00:57?? some people say it's professor sinistra but sinistra is actually black. on harry potter wiki is written that she's probably a recast of sinistra or someone else but the wiki actually says that she's "unidentified "...can anyone help me? lol
JunkFoodShirt 5 months ago
The one with Trelawney was a classic! They should have kept it in, it would have made the film!
Hermione3012 5 months ago 5
whats the name of the song at 3:03?
stevensunding 5 months ago
i wish you got to find out what happened to umbridge - i wanted to see her turned into dust :(
likeastarbaby 5 months ago
@fabo6589 when they were filming umbridges speech, they were probably planning to have a cut scene to trelawney acting insane and not paying attention, to highlight the tension in their relationship i suppose. therefore they asked her to do the whole scene even though they'll only use a couple of seconds of it, because i think shes improvising. i think it probably killed the tension of umbridge's speech which is why they didn't use it in the end.
likeastarbaby 5 months ago 8
is trelawney drunk?
likeastarbaby 5 months ago
@likeastarbaby no. she's just intimidated by her
mj4eva47 5 months ago
@mj4eva47 no...i really dont think thats it...shes completely ignoring her for a start, and she hasnt had an opportunity to be intimidated when they havent even spoken to one another yet - none of the staff are. i think shes just being a weirdo.
likeastarbaby 5 months ago
Professor Trelawny should have said, "i predict you will be out of the defence against the dark arts job by the end of the year." Cause its true. For every defence against the dark arts teacher.
Titanicfreak9 6 months ago
I think Trelawney is adorable.
InsignificantDreamer 6 months ago
LMAO PROFESSOR TRELAWNY HAS SUCH WEIRD EATING HABITS!!!! :D I thought she was just so absorbed in umbridge's speech that she forgot where her mouth was. then i was like oh, she's so disgusted by her pinkness that she went cookoo :D
snoopyguardian 6 months ago
LOL
rattakri 6 months ago
LOL Professor Trelawney's so.....funny!!! hahaha :D
Natsumi42 6 months ago
Can someone please explain what was going on in the Trewlawney scene?!?
KahlanPendragon 6 months ago 4
@KahlanPendragon i think it was just meant to show that she's a bit of a nutter really :)
TyneeBafflez 6 months ago
i think the dolores umbridge scene in the forest was good it showed how vile she really is...and i like the last scene--but of course i like any scene with ron and hermione :)
MsRyebread21 6 months ago
The Trelawney scene made me laugh.
kirkman667 6 months ago
the first scene would have killed the entire movie if they kept it.
doworkson123123 6 months ago
8:00 right there, I thought for sure Umbridge was going to confess that she sent the Dementors after Harry at the beginning, just like she did in the book. But she doesn't. I guess they never shot that. So the movies really do leave it up in the air.
Jordacar 6 months ago
Professor Trelawney! <3
soccorgirl36 6 months ago
Professor Trelawny should have enough of "the sight" to see her potatoes falling off of her fork.
blacktwinshelena 6 months ago
i think i see ginny at 02:57
carolinabasto1 6 months ago 3
Professor Trelawney is crazy xD
AshyyLou 6 months ago
The part with Trelawnly at the beginning cracks me up everytime
timmay270 6 months ago 7
lol wtf is up with the first scene
zEquilibrium 6 months ago 10
in my opinion it's a good thing those scenes were deleted.. they werent that great
am47 6 months ago
wtf is up with the first part and professor trelawney trying to eat lol.
Shani16100 6 months ago 25
@Shani16100 rofl :D
bieneFabi 2 months ago
"he who must not be named" disliked this 32 times ;D
MUNOZGANZO 6 months ago
who was that making out>?
TheNatalieDoran 6 months ago
It's funny this was one of my favorite movies but least favorite books.
jamman487 6 months ago
this could have been the best movie..they ruined it.. this was one of the best novels..
xcoollynch 6 months ago
What is Trealny doing at the beginning??
heartemoboiz 6 months ago 8
Why does hermione have blue hair at the end??
readingisbeast 6 months ago
@readingisbeast itss not blue its just the light.
Bubblzization 6 months ago
I wonder if most of what Trelawny ended up doing in that meal scene was intentional, or if she just made one mess and the rest followed suit, like the domino effect.
BathtubWanderer 6 months ago
Oh my god I love trelawney!!!
HarryLivesOn 6 months ago
I love professor trelawny!
emmalii22 6 months ago
was trelawny really there 16 years was she just not in the others before prisoner of askaban because they didnt have her class
Katara7392 6 months ago
@Katara7392 Yeah
migrembe1 6 months ago
@Katara7392 She was there, but they didn't start taking her lessons until POA.
TotallyGraceful 6 months ago
Umbridge isn't in grave danger. She's in GRANGER danger!!
takakuroichi 6 months ago 5
neville is such a bamf.
heidi186m 6 months ago
Trelawney lol! Gotta love her.
Snokinz 6 months ago
Professor Vector ftw!
playmymusicNOW 6 months ago
oh my gosh, proffesor trelawney is hilarious.
zeldaxjesus16 6 months ago 105
5:49 lovely
TARUolento92 6 months ago
That first one is funny with trelawny, but it's distracting from the umbridge speech so I'm glad they got rid of it
fictionprincess213 6 months ago
Oh my gosh will everybody please CHILL OUT about the whole " harry potter was leaked! " thing we get it already! Oh, by the way, nice video (:
Bubbilicious14 6 months ago
@Bubbilicious14 they're bots.
kqcrazii 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Trelawney is such a nut... lol loved her in Prisoner of Azkabhan(sp).
theunknown24113 6 months ago
what
C2Rose 6 months ago
whats goin on with Trelawney in the beginning?
whaleous06 6 months ago
trelawney was so high.
ooDooMKittYoo 6 months ago
oh no, trelawny forgot to eat again
Professorsammich 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
We cannot believe the fact that Harry Potter was l.eaked this soon! My sis and I found the movie at watchharrypotter. us!
MaymeSchweinst 6 months ago
i want to shoot umbridge in the face
tandwfarms 6 months ago 4
at the end, with ron and hermione, there should have been something there, like a conversation or something. and all the scenes was like, o my god they filmed it just to delete it from the movie and all this shit. its stupis
TheHpluvr247 6 months ago
Is there a spell to make umbridge shut up
Micks4Lifee 6 months ago
rifftrax potter
9ataraxia9 6 months ago
2:55 i was wondering when they were going to have something like that (the teenagers kissing in the background)
hangover844 7 months ago 2
That scene between Ron and Harry warms my heart.
maddy3231221 7 months ago
I love Trelawney! XD
nikikitta 7 months ago
1st scenes 2 funny!!!!
luckylucy101011 7 months ago
Where is the scene with Lily and James in Snapes Memory ?
FreeaQiiLiiciious 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I wanted to know if anyone else remembers seeing this in the cinema/theater and there were a couple of extras: Snapes parents fighting with him looking down and when he is sitting in his bedroom he looks over & kills some flies at the window. I KNOW that was in the film I saw but somehow it is nowhere to be seen now. I don't understand why that would be cut from the DVD/TV versions but who knows?!
MsSardonicus 7 months ago
There should've been a wand battle between Harry n Hermoine vs Umbridge, n Umbridge gets owned... HARD!!!
BenDaMan85 7 months ago
what happened to Harry at 9:54?
134679salomelau 7 months ago
@134679salomelau He is sick of Sirius death you know
MagicOdd 5 months ago
LOL!!!what are you doing trelawney?hahah]
skunkzenban 7 months ago 5
They so should have put in that trelawny ( is that how you spell it?) scene :) made me laugh so hard i fell off my chair!!! :D
123greasergirl 7 months ago
10:04 - "Nope. Not coming." "Oh, great! so still a date like we planned. Don't tell Harry we almost forgot about him though. Poor chap..." "S'okay. He'll date my sister next year."
Yelsaew 7 months ago
@Yelsaew LOL
Hootshot112 7 months ago
Thumbs up if you actually checked the background of the real scene of Umbridge's speech to see if Professor Trelawny was actually doing this?
Thechainlard 7 months ago 64
the neville/daiky prophet bitshould have been left in.. along with the little common room scene. in themovies they leave out some of the most defining aspects of life at hogwarts. this was my favorite book and they screwed it up in the movie. THEY LEFT OUT THE HARRY AND CHO DATE SCENE
ecoxxnawtxxego 7 months ago 4
trelawney's scene is funny
andz126 7 months ago
AHAHHAA I love that scene with Trelawney..
Shes choking in here food cause shes so schoked Umbridge had the nerve to interup the great speech of Dumbledore..And shes a little crazy LMAO
mientjeo4 7 months ago
I didn't hear a word of Umbridge's speech. Way to go Trelawney! :D
kandinsky51 7 months ago 4
It would be funny if Umbridge become Death Eater , probably her robe are pink and wear perfume :D
kok989 7 months ago
2 min and 33 sec of pure entertainment. It had me in stiches. Only a great actress as Emma Thompson can make you laugh to the point of felingl your ribs hurt without even talking!
ed6394epp 7 months ago
ROFLSHIFOMCASTCWWTS - rolling on the floor laughing so hard i fell off my chair and started to cry when watching the trelawney section!!
OliviaDoDance 7 months ago
they totally hurt this awesome book! My favorite book in the whole series and they cut it A LOT... *sniff* *sniff*
Erniethecatisawesom 8 months ago
Draco is so cuuute <3
hawaiiixd 8 months ago
@WasabeyBoy Actually, it is "grave" danger, listen closer to it and you will hear it for yourself. So, chanelle2082001 was correct.
firefool123 8 months ago
though this is almost the best book of harry potter series, I think this is the worst movie along with half-blood prince (which is also an awesome book) Where's Quidditch? David Yates SUCKS
Xav36degrees 8 months ago 3
@Xav36degrees I agree, it was actually the longest book yet the shortest movie. The only movie to be less than two hours I believe.
firefool123 8 months ago
Oh, really Neville?
Cancelled your subscription to the Daily Prophet..? that was so good to know.
AaronRawrz 8 months ago 4
@AaronRawrz That was a pretty important part in the book, he also says that his grandmother has always stuck sides with dumbledore and If he says you know who Is back then he is. Something like that anyway.
VeXon101 8 months ago
lol in the book Ron says 'Come on Harry I'm starving!" they are so different in the films :P
PeachieCakes 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thumbs up if you waited for your letter from Hogwarts to come when u were 11
sahul9000 8 months ago
LOL!! wow, Trelawney's blind as a bat!!!
CHRISTIANCOUNTRYGAL 9 months ago
They should have kept in all these scenes! The ones they delete (save the eating one haha) always have some sort of important canon info and are really interesting
CrazyUpsetter 9 months ago 4
Neville : My gran says....
alohachick0909 9 months ago
*sniffle* I miss you Sirius!
supaflyninjagleek20 9 months ago 149
This has been flagged as spam show
the 30 people who disliked this had detention with umbridge
Vbhero817 9 months ago
the 30 people who disliked this had detention with umbridge
Vbhero817 9 months ago 97
@Vbhero817 now its 31 people. quote "i really hate children" 7:12
TheHpluvr247 6 months ago
@Vbhero817 They Must Not Tell Lies...
TheWolfboy007 6 months ago
I've always loved Emma Thompson and the first scene makes me love her more!
I love how the music always intensified as she was going to do comical
Immalittlemuso 9 months ago 2
UMBRIDGE IS SUCH A BITCH! ugh i have never hated a character so muuuuuuch!!!
theEmpress13 9 months ago 4
Why is Trelawney the only one to have food?
sama31655 9 months ago
@sama31655 for comic relief, I'd say...
alfsgirl 9 months ago
trelawney eating was hilarious!!!!!! LOL
catgirlclaire 9 months ago 3
7:40 look what you've done to me! Just amazing:P
ricardo37373737 9 months ago 3
the dialogue with unbrige, harry and hermoine in the forest never happened!
What the hell!
TheFreshman537 9 months ago 2
I HATE UMBRIGE! THE CENTAURS SHOULD HAVE EATEN HER!
TheFreshman537 9 months ago 2
@TheFreshman537
She would have tasted horrible!!! :D
MsVanja1996 9 months ago
They should had shown the Trelawney scene!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Channel05 10 months ago
what's the song at 3.07?
cutekodawsabinila 10 months ago
@cutekodawsabinila Yes! I've tried to find it and I'm getting crazy!! I'll tell you if I know. PLEASE tell me if you already know.
aryarovi9399 6 months ago
Umbridge said "For The Greater Good" but when they filmed this Deathly Hallows still hadn't come out O_O That's strange O_O
TCMRMCfan14 10 months ago 3
@TCMRMCfan14 That isnt JUST a phrase used in deathly hallows its used in everyday life too
Purplemonkeyonabike 10 months ago
@Purplemonkeyonabike Yeah i know, but it just feels kinda strange :S
TCMRMCfan14 10 months ago
@TCMRMCfan14 yeah i get you
Purplemonkeyonabike 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
it will be hillarious if Luna's father starts dating professor Trelawney
Towersita87 10 months ago
Comment removed
Towersita87 10 months ago
ummmm...trelawny?
DrayFan12 10 months ago
@DrayFan12 ??
Purplemonkeyonabike 10 months ago
@Purplemonkeyonabike the...the...the way she was...eating (should i really call it eating?)
DrayFan12 10 months ago
@DrayFan12 oh right, yeah i agree
Purplemonkeyonabike 10 months ago
malfoy never took divination!
saffie1990 10 months ago 5
la pauvre trelawney qui s'étouffe pendant le discours d'ombrage XD
casquettegirl74 10 months ago
GOD I hate umbridge!!! "surely you would've forseen it??" UGH
harrypotter799 10 months ago
LMAO wth is trelawney doing? i know she is eating but even my 3 year old niece isnt as messy as that when she eats lol crazy fool!
funkycjay11 10 months ago
This scene should have made the cut! It made Umbridge's speech much more interesting. Lent it an air of hilarity.
journeyer58 11 months ago
the final scene should have made the cut
IDante1Savage 11 months ago 6
the worst of all the films.
IDante1Savage 11 months ago
lolz at 4:55 u can see malfoy in the backkground
melodie1001 11 months ago
Awsome I wish they kept that firework scene
me2kool4u181 11 months ago
To Umbridge: I see a lifetime of horor, pain, and you being a complete and total bitch for the rest of your miserable existance. Also, life sentence.
UltimateJediMaster 11 months ago 3
In the first scene Trelawny has finally cracked and she hasn't even been sacked yet!
sokkacool 11 months ago 2
i just love how Professor Sinistra look at Professor Trelawney whenever she coughs.. :DDD
00jadeh00 11 months ago 3
i think the first scene of this video is not a "deleted scene," but an alternate scene of dolores umbridge speaking.
Firestar1XXX 11 months ago
Trelawney ftw!!!!
xD
Cullenz4eva 11 months ago 3
Good, these scenes would spoil the whole film. I think these are the worst deleted scenes from the whole series.
MrOkay10 11 months ago
@EdgeNVickiefan316 I wouldn't worry about it. I don't see how they could possibly leave that scene out and have the ending make any sense. Unless they completely rewrite it from scratch, which this series so far has been pretty good about not doing.
DelScorcho11 1 year ago
@EdgeNVickiefan316 a young snape has already been cast for the film, so I think the scene is safe.
DelScorcho11 1 year ago
o.o wtf is going on trelaweney?...Well she's just being herself i suppose...
iluvdrakeandjosh 1 year ago
lol xd professor trelawney is funny
clacla16 1 year ago
Omg Trelawney xDDD Oh my.. *wipes tears in her eyecorner*
Meovah 1 year ago 2
I have to ask: What the hell is going on with Professor Trelawney in that scene?!
ithungers 1 year ago 2
30 people think harry potters boring we should adress them as snivellus
hermionegryffindor90 1 year ago
Where is Grawp????
ChelseaYall 1 year ago
I love Emma Thompson!!! And Neville's a freaking BAMF :)
sullensally 1 year ago 3
Trelawney is sooooo boss. :)
BlackandWhiteScarf 1 year ago
Comment removed
RawrItsCelestee 1 year ago
30 people are Death Eaters.
danceislife311 1 year ago
Trelawney eating made Umbridges speech SO much more interesting, anybody agree?
TheMonkeyMovies 1 year ago 246