@sergyu2500 maaan... The best? look at Richard Burns Rally & rFactor, ant try to define yourself what is real SIMULATION :P
oh yes - i almost forgot - you don't have PC - only shit PS3 and GT5 :P
now seriously - GT5 is good game, but shit simulation... GT5 have physics which is mix of sim and arcade, because it's programed to give fun all players - RBR and rF are programed to be the most f*cking realistic simulations in their fields EVER (and to give fun only masochists...) ;]
@Audi134 and thats why GT5 is piece of junk in simulating rallies :P nobody (and nothing) can be good (best?) at everything, because if there is something for everything, that is to say that it is good for nothing :P
ok to all these people that say gt5 is awful. It really isn't. Of course there's things wrong with it but every1 in this god dam world hates everything... I'm happy gt5 came out cuz forza 3 couldn't keep me entertained. Gt5 does EVERYTHING, nascar to go karts to friggin everything honestly you 15 year olds will not appreciate the shit out there... When I was 5 we based everything on pictures and gt5 has some pretty pictures. End of story.
The only thing that dirt 3 has over gt5 is that the visuals seem to create a wonderful atmosphere of grit and rally racing. Otherwise, GT5 is a better game overall
Play both with a good wheel and tell me which one is better. I love both but it is just so obvious that gt5 has it down on realistic handling if you compare. A controller just isnt a good enough comparision
My RX8 handles like a FWD Civic in GT5... why? Cause the game is not a simulator. It was designed for 15 yr old pimple poppers that are waiting to get their Driver license. Its just eye candy, and a racing "facebook".
Dirt 3 is great I just uploaded a video of me failing but it's a more realistic RALLY game notice how I say rally and Shift 2 is more realistic than gt5 it just doesn't have as many cars
@OIF199 You are insane both Shift and Shift 2 are not more realistic then GT5. Cars do not drive through turns like they do on there. As for DiRT3 it's good but they haven't changed the handling much with the wheel from DiRT2. So people using a controller will probably be faster.
@ALLRacingTV Driving a car REALLY fast in real life is very hard. That is why you can't keep a car in a straight 100% line in SHIFT and SHIFT 2 Unleashed
in my opinion you all probably have xbox... and cant play gt5 in my opinion gt5 is probably too hard for you all. in my opinion you have probably not even played gt5. and considering the comments are from before dirt 3 was even out... FAIL
@ALLRacingTV gt5 is awful sorry. i am completely unbiased to forza, dirt, gt5 and i even spent big money on gt5 signature edition but GT is not cool anymore. it is not a simulator no more, forza now has that title. thats just how it is and someday call of duty wont be the best war game anymore too
@MrJoko97 Dirt 3 when it comes to ralle is a lot more realistic. Yes GT5 is a simulation game and yes dirt 3 have implemented some arcade like characteristic but when it comes to the raw physics dirt 3 is more realistic rally, if you ever WRC it doesn't look like GT5, just sayin :P
in my opinion is dirt 3 better because it is a rally game and dirt 3 is like a mix of realistic and arcade and gran turismo 5 is realy great but it is a simulation so if you go for fun go for dirt 3 and if you go for simulation go for gran turismo
in my opinion is dirt 3 better because it is a rally game and dirt 3 is like a mix of realistic and arcade and gran turismo 5 is realy great but it is a simulation so if you go for fun go for dirt 3 and if you go for simulation go for gran turismo
i totally agree with mrjoko97
ouiotzes1 3 weeks ago
ahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahha dirt better simulator???????????????? yes.. if you compare it with tetris :}
ouiotzes1 3 weeks ago
@GJMaster
JakobPTP 1 month ago
DiRT 3 - HELL YEAH!
oh - and 29 people is GT5 fanboys ;]
GJMaster 2 months ago
I say screw this.. I'll just play NFS
Axel1797 2 months ago
fuck GT5 id warther stay with Forza 4
AdamLawrence1992 3 months ago
DIRT 3 ALL DA WAY!!!
ShinichiHatsune123 3 months ago
How can you compare that stupid game against DiRT3...?!
GlideBGM 4 months ago
@GlideBGM You crazy?!GT5 is the best driving simulator on the gaming market!
sergyu2500 3 months ago
Comment removed
GJMaster 2 months ago
Comment removed
GJMaster 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@sergyu2500 maaan... The best? look at Richard Burns Rally & rFactor, ant try to define yourself what is real SIMULATION :P
oh yes - i almost forgot - you don't have PC - only shit PS3 and GT5 :P
now seriously - GT5 is good game, but shit simulation... GT5 have physics which is mix of sim and arcade, because it's programed to give fun all players - RBR and rF are programed to be the most f*cking realistic simulations in their fields EVER (and to give fun only masochists...) ;]
GJMaster 2 months ago
dirt 3 < better...
TheBeyMaster11 4 months ago
@TheBeyMaster11 DiRT 3 > better = D3 is more than better than GT5 (in 'simulating' rallies) ;]
GJMaster 2 months ago
Gran Turismo was made specifically to be as close to real as possible. It wasn't made to be a rally game, but it touched on all aspects of racing...
Audi134 4 months ago
@Audi134 and thats why GT5 is piece of junk in simulating rallies :P nobody (and nothing) can be good (best?) at everything, because if there is something for everything, that is to say that it is good for nothing :P
GJMaster 2 months ago
dirt 3 is better but if gt5 had focesd a littile more but dirt 3 is better because it foces on it and its newer
undercoverhobo67 5 months ago
So, after watching this video and comparing both GT5 and Dirt 3, all I have to say is...WHY THE FUCK DID YOU UPLOAD THIS IN 240P?!!!?!?!?!
Dechristianize90 5 months ago
if dirt 3 is better than gt5, than my white skin is more black than a nigger's.
MasterOfPES 5 months ago
ok to all these people that say gt5 is awful. It really isn't. Of course there's things wrong with it but every1 in this god dam world hates everything... I'm happy gt5 came out cuz forza 3 couldn't keep me entertained. Gt5 does EVERYTHING, nascar to go karts to friggin everything honestly you 15 year olds will not appreciate the shit out there... When I was 5 we based everything on pictures and gt5 has some pretty pictures. End of story.
Animekingification 6 months ago
The only thing that dirt 3 has over gt5 is that the visuals seem to create a wonderful atmosphere of grit and rally racing. Otherwise, GT5 is a better game overall
Dre3mL0rd 6 months ago
Play both with a good wheel and tell me which one is better. I love both but it is just so obvious that gt5 has it down on realistic handling if you compare. A controller just isnt a good enough comparision
garbulky 7 months ago
@Mog087
Had it for 2 weeks, used it only to play Netflix.. then sold with with the copy of GT5.
Go SHIFT2...
rxakt 7 months ago
Next time record with a better potato..jesus christ..
guitarb3ast7x 8 months ago
@Mog087
My RX8 handles like a FWD Civic in GT5... why? Cause the game is not a simulator. It was designed for 15 yr old pimple poppers that are waiting to get their Driver license. Its just eye candy, and a racing "facebook".
No thank you to GT5
rxakt 8 months ago
on gt5 your like always drifting in a corner and on dirt 3 its not like that
but wich is the more arcader because I don't know much about rally
dariohum123 8 months ago
I like both games but prefer GT5. Dirt 3 mechanics blend together and I cant really tell the difference between cars in dirt 3.
ausosupreme 8 months ago
where is the dirt 3 on the right or on the left?
crysis2led 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Physics:
Dirt 3 = Arcade game
GT5 = SIM game (best sim in consoles)
Graphics:
Dirt3 = Good (Cartoon style)
GT5 = Perfect (Photorealistic visuals)
ClerigoGT5 9 months ago
GT5
siankata89 9 months ago
Honda Integra with racing exhaust in GT5 Sounds orgasmic :)
UglyFiveOne 9 months ago
gt5 is a boring game i got dirt 3 the 24th and havnt stop playing it
alogicx 9 months ago
simulatio = fun--> gt5 hands down, just the feeling of the wheel is incredible!
stemargia 9 months ago
Dirt 3 is great I just uploaded a video of me failing but it's a more realistic RALLY game notice how I say rally and Shift 2 is more realistic than gt5 it just doesn't have as many cars
OIF199 9 months ago
@OIF199 You are insane both Shift and Shift 2 are not more realistic then GT5. Cars do not drive through turns like they do on there. As for DiRT3 it's good but they haven't changed the handling much with the wheel from DiRT2. So people using a controller will probably be faster.
ALLRacingTV 9 months ago 6
@ALLRacingTV Driving a car REALLY fast in real life is very hard. That is why you can't keep a car in a straight 100% line in SHIFT and SHIFT 2 Unleashed
noni15081998 6 months ago
@noni15081998
debatable, i can let go of the wheel of my car at 110+ and it still tracks perfectly straight 20 years after it was built
stupidplants 5 months ago
@ALLRacingTV lets face it no one can make a realistic game espescially racing
Eugene12310 6 months ago
@OIF199 you either dont drive in real life or you cant drive for shit!
anttrap321 9 months ago
@OIF199 people who say need for speed is realistic are the first ones to die in speeding accidents
hazzardwantcookies 8 months ago
@OIF199 just shut the fuck up, you should be banned from saying those shitty things
Hasseta 7 months ago
in my opinion you all probably have xbox... and cant play gt5 in my opinion gt5 is probably too hard for you all. in my opinion you have probably not even played gt5. and considering the comments are from before dirt 3 was even out... FAIL
tab1257 9 months ago 3
gt5 has shit sound
swimfreak430 9 months ago
@swimfreak430 On a lot of vehicles yes, but the driving makes up for it specially using a wheel.
ALLRacingTV 9 months ago
@ALLRacingTV gt5 is awful sorry. i am completely unbiased to forza, dirt, gt5 and i even spent big money on gt5 signature edition but GT is not cool anymore. it is not a simulator no more, forza now has that title. thats just how it is and someday call of duty wont be the best war game anymore too
rorym1980 6 months ago
@swimfreak430 Let's just hope they focus more on that in GT6 :P
RidgeRacerLord 9 months ago
@MrJoko97 Dirt 3 when it comes to ralle is a lot more realistic. Yes GT5 is a simulation game and yes dirt 3 have implemented some arcade like characteristic but when it comes to the raw physics dirt 3 is more realistic rally, if you ever WRC it doesn't look like GT5, just sayin :P
oODallyOo 9 months ago
in my opinion is dirt 3 better because it is a rally game and dirt 3 is like a mix of realistic and arcade and gran turismo 5 is realy great but it is a simulation so if you go for fun go for dirt 3 and if you go for simulation go for gran turismo
MrJoko97 10 months ago 21
@MrJoko97
GT5 is not a simulator... in Mario Cart with better graphics. Most unrealistic race "sim" ever.
rxakt 8 months ago
@rxakt yeah sure XD
MrJoko97 8 months ago
@MrJoko97 Correct!
noni15081998 5 months ago
in my opinion is dirt 3 better because it is a rally game and dirt 3 is like a mix of realistic and arcade and gran turismo 5 is realy great but it is a simulation so if you go for fun go for dirt 3 and if you go for simulation go for gran turismo
MrJoko97 10 months ago