Chopin Fantasie Impromptu ショパン 幻想即興曲 11 Year Old sawako

[raimuraito59]

うまいですね。

最初、ちょっとゆっくりだったかな？

でもいい感じです。

小さいときの姉を思い出しました。

姉も10歳で弾いていました。

[sekine1118]

僕も11歳でひけるようになりました！」



[ami836]

重いきがする

主題があんま聞こえない

[yamakengogo]

＞ami836

piano　Lesson Diary

子供の演奏に何がいいたいんかい？

ボケ！失せんかい

[Pianda]

@yamakengogo

[fiddeandevil]

I wish that i would have learned to do something like this :(

well i guess I'll just keep wasting my life on youtube xD

[ionklau]

sher gutt

[1112ryota]

スタインウェイとか・・・ｗｗｗ

[papagena1234]

踏みすぎているというより、深く踏んでしまっているという状態に­見えます。

多分、グランドピアノに慣れていないのではないかとも。

音は間違ったとしても、おおむね仕上がっていて、後の仕上げを上­手く指導して貰えれば凄く良くなると思います。

[joyjoyjoy21]

ペダル踏みすぎ

音が濁ってる

指が転がってる

[ykpatr]

Piąteczka,CONGRATULATIONS very good Chopin play.

[sonoromana00]

スタンウェイでショパンを弾きになる１１歳のお嬢さん。お上手で­すね。溜息が出ます。

[chopin9378]

このお子様の他曲を聴いてみましたが

ものすごい速さで成長なさってる事が

わかりました。

音大付属の子だったんですね。

期待できそう。

[chopin9378]

piano Lesson Diaryと書かれてますよね。

譜読みが終わってすぐの録音ではないのかな？

ペダルも踏みっぱなしの状態であることから

それが伺えます。

日記として譜読みの段階から成長を追って

アップなさるおつもりだったのでは？

誰がどうみても、それくらいの事は

想像できます。中傷に目がくらむ人以外は！

[33699992]

微妙...

俺が11歳の頃はもっとうまく弾けてた...

今じゃどうか(ry

塚、スターリンウェイじゃん...

そこがすげぇ...

[nakagti02]

>animaruyokotyo140

>key111229

Did you read the title?

「幻想即興曲／ショパン 11 Year Old sawako piano Lesson Diary」

>animaruyokotyo140

>key111229

who can read music but can't hear it.

[animaruyokotyo140]

ただ弾いてるって感じ。

[Pferdekopfnebel]

smooth move-good basis

try to change the intonation in different parts

have a look at yundi li's performance doesn't mean i want to compare you to him-that wouldn't be fair;-)

[key111229]

一節一節に気持ちがこもっていません。

上手いけど、心には響かないです。

[tomokioh]

１１歳ですよ。。。

[sdthird10]

my father is the CEO of samsung

[athanahtos]

ADAGIO CANTABILE!!

[sdthird10]

thats too fast man

[samuelfool]

starting G# octave in left hand is semibreve, so you don't staccato it, just hold it longer, ok?? And I have notice your tempo speed not very clear...many miss note... practice more...ok??

[fffabiofff]

good

[Karascow]

do you know "adagio cantabile"?

[bluhdstool]

the middle song after the big finger work is too fast

[shinryu44]

you could slow down a bit. Also the accent on the pinky isnt that clear.

[HanlinSG]

I have came up with my own interpretation of this piece.

check it out man.

[samwisedude]

I am looking at it right now, I have trills written in mine

[Kphyl]

nicely done!

[hogam]

very smooth hand movement..wish i had that..

[blkwing15]

Very Nicely Played, awesome piece

[ckcat]

i feel second part is too fast ?

[Achtelnote]

for eleven years is good,but im absolute sure it could be so much better.some things could be repared immediatly without practicing a lot.

it would be good to change sometimes the pedal :) for example.but the best you can do is to change your teacher immediately.i think you are one of his best pupils and he likes to have you,but he ruins you.

[mojjao2]

I don't understand thunder1909 ...I know she was slow...but..was well played...clear notes...clean..obviously..with time she will became faster...she played well ¬¬

[Chopin1986]

I'm learing this wonderful piece right now and some parts are very hard to play... so, respect! I think, what's really important is to play the piece correct and not fast... the speed will come afterwards!

So, once again... a great job!

[kamel232]

All of you who make annoying comments of the performance of this piece are jealous people that will never play like he or she does. Learn to value the effort of this pianist and don't be so fucking jealous.

[hueycharn]

very well played.^_^

[suellio]

Doesn't not seem like she has 11 years...

Or its just a fat 11 years kid? :D

[dreammmshello]

why do you have to be so mean? you cant even say their name, i bet you cant play this so what gives you the right to be so HORRIBLE and then put a smiley face? blerrrrrrr

[dreammmshello]

why do you have to be so mean? you cant even see their face, i bet you cant play this so what gives you the right to be so HORRIBLE and then put a smiley face? blerrrrrrr makes me sick

[dreammmshello]

shup fat papparazzi can u play the piano? i sugest you go and become an advertiser you stuck up fat head

[lichwake]

Your superfluid pianissimo makes me want to vomit. Sorry, I'm not a kind critic—please re-learn the piano from scratch. If you think you've injected "passion" into this piece, then please take up another hobby, e.g. advertising.

[thunder1909]

Nobody judges music on effort. They judge it on the MUSIC. She didn't have to take such a hard opus either, because she FAILED it.

[thunder1909]

I am not saying the performer is bad, im saying she has no hope playing this impromptu well at this age. The performance WAS horrendous, with minimal thought put into it. Just listen to the middle part. You call that Chopin? I am would like to be able to say something good about this performance, but there is nothing good....yet. For 11 years old it's definetly good, but age doesn't matter, the music does. Good playing sounds thesame in a 40 year old as it does in an 11 year old. So does bad.

[Dreyman2]

Excellent job, especially for someone of your age!

[thunder1909]

That was horrendous. Absoluely terrible. I will not even begin to list the things that are wrong with your playing. Please, do not attempt something you have no hope of playing well.

[BrianGriffin88]

she is not a professional so...don't judge her as if she was...it's a bit unfair

[thunder1909]

I am not judging the performer, but rather the performance. I do not call her a bad pianist, I am just saying she played this Impromptu very badly. If you learn a piece, it is meant to be learned RIGHT, no matter how hard it is. If you cannot learn it correctly (such as this case), then take something easier. If she maybe played something for her skill level, I would of praised her in that. Once again, the performer isn't bad, the performance is.

[mitsay]

So beautiful

Good work

[muffinbanana1]

you shouldnt listen to anyones comments.

I think it's beautiful and you know it.

[austinkim000]

pedal's toooooo much, and the middle is waaaaaay to fast!

[daandwars]

Very good. Don't be rushed by what everyone says about the tempo, just play as you like it.

Nice work.

Sugoi ii desyou, Sawako-kun! Sore kara hayai honto ni irimasen. Arigatou & Gambatte kudasai.

[FloridaKeys1234]

yes it is faster, but i it is amazing, i know yundi li version, but you play it with so much emotion, i feel it.

Speed is not important!!!!!!!!1

[Tisycoaster]

Isnt it fster? But i think its beautiful =)

[bobbymarywalsh]

the pedal is a bit mutch

but very good other wize

love that piece !!!!!!!!

[ikemaster9]

The pedal is pretty heavy and the tempo is too even in the middle (well everywhere else too, but the middle is where you can . Other than that it's not too bad.

[roosta0013]

when I am that good I have the right to slag off your playing :), but I feel that you should use the pedal more in the first section so the notes blend into each other. Largo section too fast. Otherwise excellent and congratulations in learning such a complex piece so well!

[organman52]

I know I'm being picky here, but the 1st 16th note on the 4th beat of measure 12 should be A sharp - it is still in force from earlier in the measure. Also, you might consider using less pedal - it's often too blurry.

[metalmario765]

try slowing down in the middle, otherwise good job

[Byah1985]

The things missing from the performance are ones that will be restored with time and continued, passionate practice. I could say maturity, but that leaves the concept of 'age;' really, you'll know when that is better than anyone else. Beyond that - great work!

[rlcuda]

Congratulations on your inevitable super-successful musical career!

[HalfAssPictures]

I'm in awe

[newerpilot18]

Beautiful, very nice work. I just picked this piece up today. Dont listen to the gay comments, people are just jealous... and Steinway is the Only way to play. =},

[srcnx]

bad

[sagerj36]

You must be deaf. My rendition could be considered bad. Not hers. You offer no constructive criticism either.

[HalfAssPictures]

lets see you play like that

[thunder1909]

LOL I totally agree with you if she's (or he) is trying to become the best, but if she's just doing it for a hobby, it's amazing. If she isn't... she (or he) should quit piano.

[TheFlyingPurpleHippo]

Prehaps a bit faster, and she should let the pedal go a bit more. Middle section is rushed. Still, at 11 thats pretty damn good.

[DualThunder]

i agree with what people are saying... but at the age of 11 how can you express those deep emotions that music such as Chopin's has to offer? this suggests that too many teachers give their students pieces they are mentally ready for. Shes only 11, and she's playing a seriously difficult piece of music. Physically and mentally she hasnt got it yet..

[Shofilof]

i agree, but it is well done anyway

[pianochick1]

You're on the right track with this piece! Sounds beautiful.

[kairrie]

wow

[skaterboy75798]

yeah you should try listening to Yundi's version to get all your timing right. Like "jade" said the largo must be slow and have feeling. But nice job anyways.

[lnhleung]

I suggest Stanislav Bunin's version

[jademage]

the largo part must be slower and play in a romantic manner...try it! u can do it!

[wilsocn]

Good job. I actually sorta like the tempo you are playing this at.

[Meclisto]

she doesn't even slow down anywhere.

And she holds her pedol way too long !

[samwisedude]

There are several trills in the piece...in the slower middle section.

[liszt85]

What trills are you talking about?! There are no trills in the score.

[lawbigduck]

he play it like baroque music =.=

[nzlove]

hehe Sawako would make "him" a she...

[Notcoldsoup]

sawako is a girl name. any name in japanese with -ko is a girl, well, almost every name.

[SuperSZ]

It is good in a way to see a child who can play this VERY VERY GOOD, but not 'perect' as that chinese 7 year old kidd. I feel like a complete retard when I think 'oh shit, I play a 7 year old song' considering my age xD.

5/5 bye

[1dala]

pretty good for a kid

[juliaCSL]

the trills are abit different... her style! good job on this and nice piano you have there.

[efraimov]

speed speed ??????????

[wmi10]

omg a steinway ç_ç

[PianoCriticsKiller]

I also LOVE your trills. I wish I could do them. I have so much trouble with trills. Your trills are awesome!

In case you're wondering, I'm a girl.

Keep up the excellent work!

^-^

[PianoCriticsKiller]

I just looked at her channel and she's a cute little girl.

WELL DONE! You are a little genius, and I hope you become rich and famous by your beautiful piano playing! Keep up the excellent work!

I love how you play now, and I know you'll only get better in the future.

Enjoy, little darling!

^o^

[PianoCriticsKiller]

As someone else put it: This is NOT a piano competition, and no one needs your uneducated stupid advice! NONE of you qualify to be judges.

LOSERS!

[PianoCriticsKiller]

All of you are forgetting that the pianist is only 11! You are so overly critical and complaining and moaning over an 11 year old who played and posted one of Chopin's more difficult pieces, instead of being encouraging and complimenting on how brilliantly an 11 year old accomplished this. You ALL sound so JEALOUS with envy! lol lol lol

What a bunch of moron, idiot LOSERS all of you are! You ALL SUCK!

[jesuislepluscool]

You are too slow and play more with your heart and do more legato. You are good but sometime you play a little too fast

[PianoCriticsKiller]

jesuislepluscool - You're a moron. First you said she plays too slow. Then you say she plays too fast. Make up your freak'n mind you mindless buffoon!

And too legato won't sound as impeccable as she sounds.  She's a little genius so shut the F up!

[jademage]

play with your heart, the largo part should be played slower with feelings in your touch

[PianoCriticsKiller]

jademage - I'm sure his qualified piano teacher will tell him how to play and he doesn't need your opinion. Piano playing is a matter of taste. why don't you let us hear YOUR perfect version as a sample of your critisim?

[PianoCriticsKiller]

criticism. (correction)

Is anyone going to "complain" that I misspelled the word "criticism?"

I bet most of you are Americans.  That's all they know how to do, and they have everything! Such INgrates.

[Saverosso]

you still need more training

[PianoCriticsKiller]

Saverosso - He/She is only 11, you effen moron! This little genius will have LOTS of training! WHY can't you say something positive, like how difficult this piece is and how wonderfully he/she is playing it at age 11? Because you're effening JEALOUS because you can't play like this!

[Sadnesssinger]

u're so amazing ^^ ganbare oii~~ ♥

[lucylu1229]

I'm playing this piece too (I'm also 11) and I play it a little faster. I think you can work on your dynamics in all sections, and make the notes a little clearer. Also, I think the slow part is WAY too fast!!! There should be more rubato in it, so that the audience can sense the beauty of the piece. With some work though, you will be able to play very beautifully!!! (Sorry if you think I am criticizing, it's just my opinion.)

[kolfky]

overdid the sustain a bit, but beside that it's incredible that you can play this piece!!

[PianoCriticsKiller]

You darn right it's incredible! And I'm sure this 11 year old has a teacher and doesn't need your 2 cents: "overdid the sustain a bit."

You just can't be satisfied unless it's just perfect right? Can YOU Play it perfectly? If not, then shut up!

[ConcertGrandSteinway]

Awesome!

[yundili12345]

horrible mucho pedal

[PianoCriticsKiller]

yundili12345 - Let me hear YOUR version with less pedal. If you don't have one, then cierre el jode arriba!

You are just JEALOUS because this 11 year old can play so beautifully, and you CAN'T!

This person is only 11! He/She is a genius!

[MileyMadness]

its good but i think it slows down in the middle

[PianoCriticsKiller]

MileyMadness - And that's the only thing you can comment on? You noticed a "little" slowing down in the middle? You're just LOOKING for anything to complain about! This perosn is only 11 and can play this difficult piece. He/She is a GENIUS and you can't handle it because you're JEALOUS!

[kuromiko669]

it's just constructive criticism.

now, you have a right to complain if people

are saying things like,"l0l! u suck!1!"

and just because someone is giving advice, it doesn't mean that they are jealous.

[001026]

play the middle bit slower with more expression ;)

[PianoCriticsKiller]

001026 - Let me hear YOU play it slower with more expression.;)

He/She is on 11. I bet He/She plays better than you do NOW, IF you can play at all.

Shut up and admire this little genius. I'm sure he has a QUALIFIED teacher to critique him/her, and doesn't need your stupid UNqualified advice. So shut up and just appreciate the superb performance.

[lukey7650]

great legs and great music :) do you have a friendster account? amazing talent ...

[lukey7650]

great legs and great music :) do you have a friendster account? amazing talent ...

[CosmosMayee]

If im were u,my family will fell very proud of me :D Congrats!Keep on the good work.But are you Chinsese??

[scandalfittmonger]

Better then playing it so fast it doesn't matter if you miss a tone or two. Well done.

[Admirka]

jaj dász gefélt mír nihhhhhttt...

[chopcup]

can u pls tell me what finger to use on the first C# in the right hand, 3 or 4?

[synthyaro]

Finger 4 definitely.

[otntcmsii]

u r playing awesome!so clear...

[Bolagna123]

I fink the song is meant to be a wee bit faster than this but hey it was good.. Better than me anyway xD And yeah.. the middle slows down alot

[PianoCriticsKiller]

I only agree with your statement:

"Better than me anyway"

If you can't do better, then shut the F up, moron.

[GossenTarzan]

It's great! I've been playing for nine years but it's to fast for me :S... The only wrong you do is that the middle part is supposed to be played slowlier and more smooth, and please slow down in the ending, are you stressed or something?

[PianoCriticsKiller]

GossenTarzan - No, the pianist is not stressing. The pianist is only 11. And this is played beautifully! You are such a moron if you expect perfection from anyone; especially, an 11 year old. I'm 16 and I know that! You've been playing longer and you can't even Play this piece, you said. Then you should be on your knees to how wonderfully this 11 year old can play what you can't after 9 years!

[GossenTarzan]

I didn't say i didn't like it and that he/she couldn't play well. I just say that there are some things that this person could do better. For exemple add some feelings to it and maybe not use the pedal so much...

In that part where you say "I'm 16 and I know that"; What do what to say with that? (BTW I'm 16 too...)

[PianoCriticsKiller]

11 years old don't show feeling yet. She'll learn in time. Just respect all her time and efforts put into this difficult piece. Just the fact she can play it so well should be appreciated.

Have to go! Late for school. It's 7:30AM here, mate.

[asslaslades]

Your Kunfu most be good!

[kuromiko669]

how do you know they dont show feeling?

just asking....