Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (295)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I just keep finding more and more songs that Kara has written. I really didn't like her, but realizing how many songs she has written and how good of a singer she is has made me gain a ton of respect for her

  • Good but def not better than kelly. No one can sing it better than kelly. :)

  • honestly no one gives her enough credit and taking her off the judging panel was a huge mistake on american idol's part. she was the only judge that actually deliberately made sense when she judged and her advice was spot on every single time. she would know since she wrote half of the hits that you hear on the radio.

  • I love her

  • you know how Kara can easily imitate other artists? here she sounds similar to Kelly, and she can also do the voices of P!nk and other talented people.

    being able to imitate others shows talent. take charice, 18 year old filipino singer who can imitate everyone, like Justin bieber and stuff.

  • Rele good but not better than Kelly... Thats impossible

  • wow way better than clarkson..

  • She is so amazing! She is one of the judges on AI that accually know what they are talking about and have expirence in the music industry.

  • OMG! I like it! Kara is like super massively talented! 

  • OH WOW!!!!!

    ill be honest she has grown on me since her 1st season on AI

    and if ellen hadnt come in she'd be my fav judge.

  • She did persue a singing career and made an album years ago, but it never went anywhere, so that's why she has stuck to writing songs. She said it's a matter of being in the right place at the right time to be a successful singer.

    She probably would have better luck now that she is well known.

  • we can also thank her for good girls go bad!!!

  • @babehkate REALLY?! :O

  • i love kara and would do anything to meet her she can sing so amazingly<33333

  • Kara needs to put out an album, she can sing!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @crystarrrr more info about her music on wikipedia Kara_DioGuardi_discography

  • Comment removed

  • wow, she's really good...I wonder what Simon would say

  • @rolfene Uhm, she is a judge on Idol.. So Simon knows her and dont nee to say anything lol.

  • Kara is like one of the best song writers I know! If you don't count all like Queen, Beatles guys, she has written soo many awesome songs!!! I adore her and she's my songwriter idol!

  • kara is so talented!

  • nice! be sure to check out my kara dioguardi cover!

  • if you have a pop cd then open it and look at the person who wrote the songs and you will see kara's name lol.......shes written almost every song

  • its difficult for her keeping the entonation.she needs to see a vocal trainer

  • Incredible! So talented!

  • ,,, and insanely hot!!!

  • wait....she wrote this? brilliant song. THe best song yet, though, for KC especially, was "Miss Independent".

  • she is a gr8 singer!!

  • it pays well be a writter/producer. You don't have to tour, keep up appearances, and promote all the time and you still keep getting in those royalty checks.

    There's lots of incredible pop writers out there who do have serious performing talent; such as Carole King and David Foster. Kara is fortunate enough to have it in the looks department as well, so I would not too surprised if she does come with a record after being famous on American Idol.

  • homegirl can sang!!

  • I Love Kara Dioguardi.

  • I searched in my iTunes: Kara DioGuardi, although I didn't have any songs that she sang in iTunes. So then it came like a lots of songs and I was like, wtf? she isn't singing them. So I went to info and saw that SHE had WRITTEN THEM ! And I fell in love with her work and downloaded her songs that she had sung because I love her voice and now I have 6 songs in iTunes that she sings, and i listen to them when I go to sleep :] LOVE YOU KARA !

  • I remember when she was a contestant on American Idol

  • I lovee Kara. Always have.. always will.. fav. singer by far ! I think she should make her own CD of all the songs shes written for people and sing them herself! :)

  • its live even kelly sings off live who doesn't? be around by kara is great. she is more of a writer but she sings well so she deserves to judge.

  • she's the greatest, way better than kelly !!!!

  • Yeah...no...

  • @amazingcameron great yes .. but better than kelly !!

    i dont think so

  • "The song 'Walk Away' was written by Kara and Chantal Kreviazuk for Kelly Clarkson " There were a few others who wrote on this song, one being kelly clarkson.

  • She's pretty close to matching Kelly Clarkson's voice, I almost thought she WAS Kelly Clarkson xD

  • Wow. She's absolutely amazing. Why haven't I heard of her before?? I want to hear more from her. Her voice gives me chills.

  • Kara has a grat voice and more then that she is really a serious songwriter I mean listen to terrifed,she sings that one better then anyone else I have heard... I never even heard of her before idol. Was she known as a songwriter prior?

  • @Imkeepinon yes she actually was :) If you go and look through artists' lyric books her name pops up often. I think you'd be surprised to see how many people she's written with and how many hits she has. She's been a huge inspiration to me for a few years now <3

  • @Imkeepinon yeah im pretty sure tats how she got on tere, se as wrtitten for so many people who were on idol, and even some of the "winning songs"

  • She sounds a little country at times...I dig it ;-) I like both hers and Kelly's version....great song!!!

  • AWSOME!!!!! she IS AMAZING!!!!

  • Geez, she sounds incredible!

  • wow! Better than Kelly Clarkson!She should really sing her own such! Incredible that before Idol I´ve never heard of her!

    great!

  • who's Daphne Darling?

  • cool. i didnt know she wrote this song. i still of course prefer kellys version (cuz shes one of my idols!) but this is pretty good.

  • I like.....I like...

  • I LOVE HER voice =) LOVELY how she riffs

  • I had no idear that Kara was a singer and that she has written so many incredible songs. Whoa...

    This girl is massively talented...

  • @pyramid924 Most of the time, songwriters need to pitch the song, in order to do so, they must sing it.

  • @pyramid924 yeah kara is an amazing song writer

  • i think i like her singing this better then Kelly Clarkson!

  • She's so good. I was blown away.., Didn't expect her to sound so wonderful...

  • Listen to her "Taking Chances" which she wrote for Celine Dion.

  • she's really good. Is that paul shaffer?

  • The bald guy? That's Jeff Cohen.

  • i like her version

  • kara she could sing good i never use to like her but im starting to like her shes awsome

  • Oh God she CAN sing.......

  • wow she is very very talented looking at all she she has written who shes written for and her voice is ver good but I LOVE KELLY so am biased towards preferring Kelly's version Still VERY GOOD tho x

  • @etnkltre I agree Paula is drunk most of the time but I love Paula soo much.... and Kara I love her at first I wasn't so sure but she is great I am upset the Paula wont be on the show it just wont be the same.... and plus without Paula the connection ppl made between her and Simon will be lost which will make the show a little boring.

  • I THINK SHE SINGS IT BETTER KELLY:)

  • At least you only think she does, but she's not. Awesome singer and songwriter, but Kelly Clarkson is better vocal wise.

  • @nonshalan I agree a hundred percent. Anyone has potential to posess great vocals but the thing and reality is that you can Find thousands of Kara Diogaurdi's all over the globe and only a few like Kelly Clarkson who are just brilliant singers and vocal gheniuses. To even say Kara has a better voice is just not likely do to music theory. She has a nice, but when it comes to Kelly, Come on it's freaking Kelly Clarkson! She has one of the most versitile voices and can sing any song. I agree 100%.

  • @EpicFailPersin You make Kelly Clarkson out to be this virtuoso in singing, which she is not, kelly has pipes no doubt... a little underrated maybe, but she is not a vocal genius, and certainly not the only one who has those type of chops.

  • @RibBlake

    Well if I raised the bar too high for Kelly Clarkson I do not think that's impossible. Kelly Clarkson has one of the best voices out of all singers. Not the best voice, but one of the best voices. I say she is a vocal genius because not everyone can hit high notes without even practicing. And in the middle of a live performance she is always planning note-for-note what she will do next and she nails it. She does not know her limit and she goes over it and still sounds amazing.

  • i agree!

  • shes got a fucking awesome voice... wow.

  • I think she has a good voice, writes good songs and is very pretty too.

  • Umm she sounds good but kelly sings it so much better...

  • I agree 100%

  • Awesome! She has a pretty good voice!

  • Not bad!

  • man she's good

  • jeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeez she's good

  • Even though Kara annoys me as a judge, she seems like the one person that truly merits to be judging potential new talent. Even though she wasn't that famous before she has proven herself as an talented songwriter (i love "walk away") apart from "no boundaries" LOLL.

  • dose anyone have the full rocording from start to finish

  • Kara's version is good I would rather her version then Kelly's I don't like Kara that much but we have to be honest shes annoying on AI but the girl can sing

  • She's annoying on American Idol?? Are you serious. She's actually one of the judges that's actually honest and sincere and actually makes sense when she speaks. unlike Paula, who is despicably annoying and blatantly drunk half the time.

  • I sooo agree... maybe people reacted too much from the bikini girl thing.

  • Compared to Paula and Randy I might agree with that. But I think Simon made since and was sincere before she came along.

    (She is a great singer though)

  • @theykilledthemusic paula abdul is not drunk on american so shut up and you dont even no mama paula and shes not annoying unlike kara dioguarshit

  • @AprilLovesPaula oh wow that was so clever...

  • I couldnt agree with you more.

  • you're saying kara is way better than kelly becuase it's acoustic..if kelly sings this in an acoustic way, SHE IS MORE FANTASTIC!!

  • she sounds really good

  • kara just showed tht u dont mess with a person who wrote platnum songs and say there not great frankly katrina was not good enough singer did u hear her when she went on the american idol stage in the bikini katrina has songs on utube they arent tht great her songs r more degrating to people instead of helping people i wish them both luck

  • she has a fantastic voice!

  • :S how can you think she has a better voice than kelly?

  • i think kara sings it waay better then kelly!!!!!!!!

  • i love this song, i didn't know she wrote this song...wow she is great....

  • i like that version better than the kelly version.

  • BondiBJ: You talk as though it was Kara's idea to do that...lol. It's television. Idol had her do it for the laughs, in the same way they show all the WORST singers during auditions. It's just part of the show.

  • If Katrina Had any class she would not have shown up in a bikni Trying to get the male judges to giver her a yes for her body and not bacause of her voice. Kara did try to help katrina during the auditions by saying that was too big of a song for her type of voice but katrina was disrespectful and said like you could do better and kara did

  • i agree she is amazing :O

  • shes really good

  • Hi, I love her voice! Does anybody know if there exists a CD with HER singing?

  • No, none of her bands became big with her singing so she gave up on trying to be famous for singing she writes now... xD

  • There are a few songs available on iTunes with her singing with her band Platinum Weird.

  • Yeah a band called Platinum Weird had a CD out in 2006 called "Make Believe". She was the lead singer.

    Apparently they've got a self-titled record coming out in the future. As to when, its still in "TBA" status.

  • WOW go Kara! she has a really good voice!

  • That last comment was a reply to BondiBJ who was confusing Kara with Paula

  • actually i think both judges are amazing but my friends all think that kara is stuck up... but i have no idea because i don't think so

  • kara is a good song writer and i think a good vocalist too

  • Awesome. She has an amazing voice.

  • wow!

  • Kara has a hot bikini body

  • Wow, BondiBJ... are you gonna post a negative comment on every Kara video? Talk about ego... if you can't stand her so much, why are you bothering to go to all of her songs? BTW... it's pretty corny and very unoriginal to copy and paste the same lame comment on multiple videos... get a life and stop being a hater! Kara is extremely talented, successful and beautiful to boot! Wish I could be so "boring"...

  • If you call that beauty, I am afraid what you think isn't?

  • She does not need attention, she is one of the hottest song writers in the industry, everyone that is anyone has work with her. Maybe you should check out website, before you speak!

  • Thats why I am saying she should stay a writer, but now she wants the limelight obviously. Thats what I mean by her being needy for attention, the stage!

  • She is a good singer so get a life and stop talking about her? Is that really all you have to do? I get that you express your opinion, seriously ur annoying.

  • If you don't like Kara, then why are you watching a video of her on youtube, and taking the time to post your opinion? If you don't like someone then don't watch their stuff, and don't ruin it for the people that enjoy watching videos of her.

  • Paula is corny, so 30 years ago! Paula is so into getting herself exposed, its so obvious no one paid attention to her before Idol and now Paula wants Idol to make her famous...Paula's old fashioned and boring! Her style is like 20 years ago! and her comments on Idol are so annoying! Paula always tries to comment so much so that the camera stays on her longer, the others do not do that, they are not as needy...

  • Paula.... She never got comment of her own, always copying/agreeing with another co-idol judge. Her face always look oily (poor dear) and her fashion statement are just plain boring and old. :(

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Kara could have chosen not to degrade Katrina. Katrina is obviously a naive girl with no exposure & experience, but nooo Kara had to compete...That was lame if they scripted it, Kara could have done the generous thing & helped Katrina sing, instead of compete with her...Kara is 17 years older then Katrina? It would have been classier if Kara helped Katrina with a duet instead...The whole thing was embarrassing to watch a grown women do that to a kid! I'm sorry, I found it tasteless & cheesy...

  • Ok, that's your opinion about it, nobody really cares about it, because this video = for Kara fans. It's a bit pathetic that you type up the same useless feedback on every Kara Video you can find. You shoundn't take it seriously, if Kara really wanted to hurt her, she'd just knuckle her in the mouth, it was a duet, it wasn't supposed to be a threat, just for the fans. Lol, acting like a kid. You may grow out of your size, but you can never stop being immature [: even Paula has her moments.

  • ????

  • And to me, it's quite tasteless and cheesy that you spend your weekends typing up such threatoning messages to people who LIKE Kara.

  • she wrote like so many songs for many hit artists like christina aguilera,celine dion,and kelly clarkson,she has an amazing voice and writes amazing songs

  • wow she is sooo much better than all the american idols put together! wow i would but her cd for real

  • She probably likes the background scene better, but personally I have more respect for the writers than the singers. But those that are singers and songwriters? Love love love them.

  • Shes so awesome, I would much rather hear her singing her own songs than having her pimp them out to all these other artists that cant write there own stuff. She can write, shes beautiful, and she can sing. I dont see why she doesnt get more exposure!!

  • I totally agree!!! She is unfreakinbelievable!!!

  • pretty

  • i didn't know she wrote that song!! woah

  • wow!!!! she shouldnt have wrote this for kelly, she should have sang it herself wow! she has a great voice!

  • Kara you are AMAZING!!! PERFORM!!!!! I'd pay so much to her in concert!!!

  • It was perfect when Kara showed up bikini girl last night! It helped people who had never heard her sing get a little taste of what a huge talent she is. And it showed how really stupid and untalented bikini girl was. That girl looked like a huge fool! It was great.

  • she wrote it you idiot!!!!!!!! How much of "HER OWN" does it get?????

  • maybe get your own stuff means she would like for her to make an album or be more out there like on the radio.. we know she is a writer.. but you dont hear you sing... so calling someone an idiot only proves you are the true idiot..

  • hahaha!

  • She wrote it.

  • WE LOVE YOU KARA!!! COME BACK..

  • Karas credits are huge look her up. Also its her voice on the camp rock stuff mostly not that kid Demi Lavato.

  • Damn she was hot on Idol tonight! Poor bikini girl!

  • She was amazing tonight! I knew she was a song writer so she had to kinda know how to sing but that was like OMG!!! WOW! She can SANG!!!!

  • she is a very talented person (even if she is kind annoying at points in american idol) and OMg it was soo funny @ the American idol w/ bikini girl... Yeah

  • OMG she is so amazizing!

  • She's good. Kelly sings it better though.

  • wow...sound like kelly clarkson....well somehow

  • Kara is a better vocalist than most of the artists she writes for.

  • Agreed. I'd love to see her have her OWN album.

  • Are you serious? American Idol WILL return next year. It's America's number 1 TV show ffs. Wow, you're too stupid to go to UF.

  • "there might not be a American idol 9 because of her" lol riiiiight.

  • wow awesome. she has really good pipes and has written so many amazing songs. how come you never became a singer i would so like to hear you sing on idol oen day

  • WOW. Didn't expect her to be so good.

  • she is a great singer and a brilliant songwriter!!!!

  • that song is perfect for her real

    pop-spintosoprano

    i loove it

  • why doees she give her sonngs awaay?

  • because she likes the writing aspect of it, nad probly because its this amazzing feeling when you hear your song on the radio, and you know that thats your song. and maybe she dosnt want to be the one singing it.

  • because she is a song writer? duh...

  • if she only know how to count..

  • Kara, 3 words for you: That was artistry!!

    I really like it, very original, does any one have full version of this? please upload..

  • ive got three words for ya kara.. that was great

  • cool i wish kara would sing on idol then randy could play bass too!