علی شریعتی و مغالطات ایشان - قسمت اول

[Ruins13k]

اسلام همینه که میبینی. دنبال چی میگردی ؟!!

[Ruins13k]

احمق کسی است که بخواهد اسلام رو با تعریف ها و تفسیرهای شریعتی و امثال ایشون بشناسه! یه چیزی هست به اسم تاریخ. خود شریعتی هم این تاریخ رو خونده و برداشتش رو نوشته. کسانی که شریعتی شریعتی میکنند؛ میخواهند یه امام دیگه درست کنند. برو بشین تاریخ بخون. کتاب تاریخ طبری 17 جلدی رو بخون. برو بشین نهج البلاغه رو بخون؛ قرآن رو بخون تاریخ اسلام جرجی زیدان رو بخون یا تاریخ بخارایی رو بخون. شریعتی هم، به پیر به پیغمبر همین ها رو خوند. این کتابها هم به فارسی نوشته شدند

[11759tehran]

بدبخت بی سواد کمی مطالعه کن .اگر مجری هم هستی سعی کن با سواد باشی .الان دیگر روزگار روزگار بگو و برو نیست مردم میروند و میگردند و پیدا میکنند و میخوانند و انوقت لعنت میفرستند به اجدادت

[asadirani]

چطور می شود که این اقا از شریعتی گلایه میکند که به عمر وابوبکر حرف می زنی هموطنان سنی نا راحت می شوند اما خودش دائما به علی حمله میکند واصلا نگران هموطنان شیعه نیست.خدایا مغلطه گران را به راست رهنمون شو

[2betoche]

SEFATE KHODETO BE RASTI DAR IN VIDEO BAYAN KARDI LOL

AKHEH KODOM ADAME AGHELI MIYAD HARFE MOHAGHEGHANI KE SALHA DONBALE DIN O MAZHAB RAFTAND VEL KONAND BAD BIYAND TO BA IN CHERT O PERTAT OONJOORI KE MIKHAIE TAFSIR KONI. VAGHEAN MOTEASEFAM KE KHEILI AMSALE TO ZOOR MIZANAND KE ISLAMO AZ BAYN BEBARAND VALI KOOR KHOONDID!

[FARDIN412]

akhe marde nahesabi farge sargarm kardane mardom ba gafangiat va gohe ziadi tar az dahan khordane ra befahm¡¡¡vagan bifarhangi darde bozorgi ast.tora banabarde daliran chekar...

[dayijoon]

Dorus bar ostade fekr va andishe , bahrame moshiri

agar tu iran avaze har akhund , yeki mesle to dashtim,

alan ma ham mesle japon va amrika va alman pishrafteh budim,

va na mesle 1400 sale pishe arabestan.....

[abbasmoad]

This commentator (Bahram Moshiri) is a true ass licker, addicted to licking uncle Sam's ass!!!!!!!!

[iranpop80slover]

Dorood bar Moshiri 

[camino341]

@iranpop80slover dorood bar Moshiri

[r0thb4m0dtafa]

naaaaaaa in aghaye moshiri khodesh khodesho zori ba poll ba har chi to televisin bashe k mardom asan beshnasanesh bad omad gonde gozi kone bara in ke to televisin vaghtesho por kone ,in agha fek mikone shahe :) dochare khod bavari khili ajibi shode lol............

[tubevictor3063]

In mardake bisavad, ba 1 zabane tohin aamize az jense shamloo, say dar kharab kardane baghie dare ta khodesh ro khare mohemmi jelveh bede. Ba in tafavot ke Age shamloo kasi ro kharab mikard inghadr harfesh por omgh bud ke aadam azash motenaffer nemishod vali in mardake oghde ee ,mesdaghe sherie ke mige:

Ey magas arseye giti na jolangahe tost. Boro maghas pa too kafshe amsaale shariati nakon ke to ham ghadde una nisti bache jun.

[moshirinangeiran]

@tubevictor3063 ...IN MARTIKE KHEYLI BEESHARAFE.....

[matooni]

akheh bisavad, to ro be cheh be Dr. Shariati.... boro khejalat bekesh. fekr mikoni hameh mesle tou kharan?

[afshinization]

@matooni

هموطنان عزیز

اگر این فرد(شریعتی) وجود نمیداشت الان ما نصف مشکلات امروزی را نداشتیم

کتابهایش را اگر بخوانید خواهید فهمید که این آقا هم اسلام را به گند کشید هم مغز جوانهای ما با این لحن عقده

[matooni]

doost aziz, ein harfa chiyeh? man 3 ta az ketabhaye Dr. Shariati ro khondam (original publish 1357) va bedoonid keh islami keh Dr. Shariati mishnakht khaili ziba tar az ein chizee hast keh tou iran tarvij mikonan. moshkele keshvare ma islam nist, hokomatemoon hast, va ein do ta ro nabayad eshtebahan yekki begirid.

[babaali69]

faghat yek adam koskesh manande to netavanad rajeb dr. shreati chenin bgoyad.

[behnam557]

هیچ وصله ای به دکتر شریعتی نمی چسبه و شما هم آقای مشیری بهتره برین و منبع اطلاعاتتون رو بر منابع مستند استوار کنین

[Heameh]

@behnam557

ketab shariati ro dareh meekhooneh aziz. kodoom manbe?

[avestak]

reading a word from a book doesnt count as a source! He has multiple fallacies, and uses quote mining here. Try to judge without bias in his favor =)

[alikhoda1]

Mr. Moshiri ! You are not on that level of mine and logic which make you able to talk about an intellectual ! You'd better go and talk to your common audiance on some daily issues ! Not on criticising a siciologist !!!

[mylilbabygirl1]

shoma har chi mikhay begho dar morede shariati..har kas ke kami aghl toye kalash dashte bashe va harfaye turo ba harfaye doctor shariati moghayese kone be vageyat pey mibare ke ki maglate kare!!!

[kuroshe1]

aghaye moshiri, man ba in ke shariati az shie ba kalamat ghuli sakht anham ba ghazafe, ama shobathaye dorost ham dashte shoma sia sefid ziad mibinid, albate mobareze shoma ba khorafate shie ghari ali hast movafagh bashid.

[avestak]

I dont bring my level down to talk to you with your own level of reason but I have to say that from an educated mind's perspective, yourcredibility is zero for not backing up your statements with even one reference. Shame on you for misinforming and disrespecting such figures.

[mayhemjon]

ma nafahmidim in yebar mige ano taleb marde ghodrat mandi bod yebar mige abotaleb bichareh bod pedar ali baba to aslan ano az gosh kobideh mitoni tarjih bedi ke dari in harfaro mizani

[shifteh110]

Mr. Bahram Moshiri: You are a little engineer and too small to assume the role of a historian and an Islamic scholar and allow yourself to review the lectures and writings of the late Dr. Shariati in such a humiliating fashion. Shame on you and the TV that broadcasts your stupid comments and views.

[avestak]

well said

[SuperMasonic]

Mr. Moshiri is reading from Shariati, why is he not ALLOWED to do that? You are not the law to allow or not allow.

If you know something about Islam why don't you refute what Moshiri is saying? All you have to say is: Shariati was a DR and you don't have any RIGHTS to criticize him, well why not?

We all have this right especially when a third rate intellectual such as your Dr. Shariati is wrapping reactionary teachings of Islam and presenting it in "intellectual" paper.

[shifteh110]

Mr. Bahram Moshiri should rule his own territory, i.e., engineering. He reminds me of many Iranians who are no more than fakhri haft kaareh: They want to assume the role of an expert in every field under the sky, from history to Islam; from engineering to literature. Dr. Shariati woke up the Iranian nation from deep sleep and when they woke up he was no longer around. We have to learn to respect those who have made a contribution to our social development. Otherwise we destroy our civilization.

[kafir1917]

couple of facts about thsi shariati:

1) whilst a student in Europe, he was on savak's pay roll, informing of Iranian opposition abroad!

2) He died in London whilst desparately trying to gain Green card visa to USA, whilst constantly bitching about "US imperialism"!

Indeed, a true muslim "thinker" and "Intellectual"!

[Heameh]

@kafir1917

So What? his privacy is your businuss? how about your self? if he is engineer he should not say any thing?

you know what " mast eto bokhor khafeh sho"

[kafir1917]

heameh:

Kheili olaghi, dorost mesle "Dr" shariatit!

If you could read and understand a few lines of text in English, then you'd note that I am not talking about shariati's "private life". I am talking about the sheer hypocricy of this so called intellectual, that while he was bitching about "US imperialism", secretly he was hoping to get a visa to go and live in USA!

But waht is new? they are all the same these so called muslim "intellectuals"! from Yazdi with US passport to Ghotbzadeh.

[Heameh]

kafir1917 - I think you are right , my bad.

man bad motvajjeh shodam loghat shariati ro nadeedam. sorry.

[avestak]

Lol no one takes the right to criticize from him; however, he has no point, no reason as a backup for his argument. If you take any philosophy class, you well see that he has multiple fallacies in his argument.

[moshirinangeiran]

@avestak ...... THANK YOU... MOSHIRI IS WASTING HIS TIME...NO REASONABLE PERSON WOULD BELIEVE HIS NONSENSE WORDS

[torabib]

az in kos kesh inghadr badam miat, bayad daresh zad kharkoseh, ah gosho bala ovordeh , khejalatam nemikesheh ,

[Heameh]

Aghayeh torabib, ba dar zadan moshiri shariati adam hesabi meesheh? na valla . shariati hamoon kesi hast keh meekhast az beesavadi mardon estefadeh koneh , eslam ro beheshoon foroo koneh. keh natoonest.

[akbarabedi]

ریدم به دهنت همین مونده تو بشی مفسر!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­11

[Hessam021]

Aghayoon lotfan kos sher nagin in ketabhayi ke ostad moshiri mikhone chape jomhooriye eslamiye va aghayooni ke migin in agha SHIRE'YE are hast chon haghighat talkhe biyaym va vase yek bar haghighat ro beshnavim bejaye kos sher goftan va zamanike amsale AGHAEYE SHARIATI VA RAHIMPOOR AZGHANDI mishan filsoofe mamlekate iran bebinid dastan ma che ghadr aghab oftadast

[mustafa10497]

bazam in bahram shire ey harf zad!!az in agha manghal o vafoor o begirid,oon vaght bebin age bozorgtarin modafe,e eslam nashod!!!in mardak aslan dar hadd o hodude ezhar nazar raje be ali,pyambar va hatta shari'ati nist!!!

[sararnbw]

جای اینکه تنها بشینی‌ برای خودت بگویی و لذت ببری، یک نفر درست حسابی‌ تو این برنامه بیار و باهاش مناظره کن که ما ببینیم چند مرد حلاجی!

[eleynasr]

ba commenthayee ke inja mibinam ... akhunda hala hala ha hastan saremun :(

[ali404040]

وقتي ميخواد از حضرت علي بد بگه عرب نفهم ميشه شيوخ بالا مرتبه فهميده و با سوادو........

اما وقتي ميخواد از اسلام بد بگه همون شيوخ ميشن سوسمار خور و وحشي...............

اين آقا خودش استاد مغلطه است.

[moshirinangeiran]

@ali404040 ...

..MERCI

MAMNOON AZ COMMENTE KHOOBET

[omidisara2005]

@ali404040 chera chert migi?!!

[ali404040]

اين آقا اصلا در حد و اندازه دكتر علي شريعتي نيست كه بخواد اظهار نظر كنه

[Heameh]

haddo andazaro kee taeen meekoneh meesheh begee?

[pouyaparsaie]

kos sher mibafeh barayeh khodesh

[salimtab]

faghat to rast migi, baghie hame doroogh migan, oonam be jame~e!!! khodesh nemifahme martike chi mige, zeddo naghiz harf mizane

[imperialnq]

ba tavajoh beh vajheh tashabohe didgahe In agha ba shoyoukheh Arab va vahabyouneh az Padshayeh arabestaneh soudi malomeh keh ishan daramadash az kojast vah beh khodfroshi vah dien froshi dar ghebaleh dolarhayeh nafti mashgholand Dr shariati GHABL AZ SHAHADATESH TAKLIFEH IN KELAS AS AGHAYAN RA MOSHAKHAS KARDEHAND (DEENFOROSHAN MOTEMABVEL)

[avestak]

LOL, in agha balad nist hata dorost bahs kone va dalil biare, moatasefam ke hamchin kasi asan to television e ma sohbat kone!

[matooni]

Lotfan dar morede Dr. Moshiri ein joor sohbat nakonin. ein olagh PhD'ish ro tou panchar-giri peykan gerefteh. Moshiri, bia man barat television baz mikonam keh dar moredeh panchar giri sohbat koni.

[pasargad22]

in naghdi ke in agha az shariati mikone dar alam jame shenasi siasi 2 zar nemiarze. mohem in nist ke shariati cheghadar dorugh ya rast gofte mohem ine ke harf shariati be amal tabdil shode be harkat tabdil shode ya na.

[pasargad22]

az brkhurd chap aslami ba rast aslami iran amruz bvjud amade. tez va anti tez sakhte shod va be jamae tazrigh shod. chon dar javame

aghab oftade nabard tabaghati nemitune shekl begire bray tsahob ghodrat dar natije nabard

ideology jay anra migire. va az brkhurd inha

santez bvjud miyad. yani harkat besuy takamol

shorou mishe.

Evolution Starts with Revolution.

SAVAK mamur nadaneste enghlab bud va in goruhay mosalah va sazemanhay chiriki

kheili sakhte khud SAVAK budand.

[pasargad22]

kar shariati in bud ke az din yk ideology besaze bray iran anruz. motenaseb ba farhang iran va jamae iran. ta inja karesh ra kheyli

khub anjam dad va baed az inja ham bayd az sahne kharej mishod ke shod va angilisa ya savak koshtanesh. yk tfkor puside ra be yek maktab tbdil kard. khob az abzari ham ke dasht estfaade kard. adabiyat sokhanrani.

ishan masul sakhtn chap aslami bud va khomeini masul sakhtn rast aslami. khomeini velayat faghih ra avard va amamat morusi ra be amamat antkhabi kard

[mbjupm]

man soalam az in ostade gholabi in ast ke ishan che chize farhang maro ghabool daran dinro, olamaro, daneshmandano, ghahramanane meli va mazhabiro ishoon hatta yeknafar ro ham ghabool nadaran, molavi, sadi, hafez, abuo ali sina, shariati, ... va kheyli digar az shakhsyat haye barjasteye maro berahati zire soal mibaran ta che beresad be pyamber islam va emaman agar daste ishoon bashad fekr nakonam chize bedard bokhori beshe az farhange 3, 4 hezar saleye iran dar ovord

[Catz007]

rast gofti - mardak chert balade faghat bege - shad bash moshiri - zendegi baraye hame payani dare - soraghe to ham khahad amad ezrail - age nayamad ;-)

[Abushahr110]

تا اسلام دشمنان جاهل ن... پرستی چون شما دارد همیشه پیروز است

لطفا ادامه دهید تا نشان دهید که اسلام بر حق است

[rezamashdi]

Bahram Moshiri : yek Koskeshe Tamam Ayar..

Shariati ba tamame eshtebahatash..namash wa rahash hanooz midrakhashad..choon

Regime kasife wa madarghabeie pahlawi ra ba galamash nabood kard..

[shatami]

age yeki bin bichareh ye poli bedeh ke zendegish begarde (ya ye shoghle abromand dasto pa kone) motmaenan injor khodesh ro ba tamame kaayenat dargir nemikone va be hame bado bira nemige, az paighambaro, Imamo, Dr. shariatio, Molavi, ...

[naniva]

shariati was just a dirty,dumb andbackward guy,dogs may shit upon his grave

[rezamashdi]

Fuk you safe mother fucing!!

[fooladsakht]

Khar madare in Islametoono gaeedam baba koskeshaye kiri.

shoma basijia ke az jomhoori eslamio in dinaye kos sher defa mikonin berin kooneto bedin baba.

Koskesha hamatoon mamoorine regyme jomhoorie eshali hastin & vase ye zare teryak khar madaretoono mifrooshin badbakhta.

[mahajoon]

boring

[Nazaninnazi]

Khar madare in Islametoono gaeedam baba koskeshaye kiri.

shoma basijia ke az jomhoori eslamio in dinaye kos sher defa mikonin berin kooneto bedin baba.

Koskesha hamatoon mamoorine regyme jomhoorie eshali hastin & vase ye zare teryak khar madaretoono mifrooshin badbakhta.

[dobaremisazamatvatan]

mardake manghali,ebtedaa dahanat ra beshoor bad rajebe BOZORGAAN harf bezan!!

[fooladsakht]

shomaaha basijihaa o mazhabihaa koonetoon misoozeh dareh efshatoon mikoneh, age be madaretoon fohsh midaad dardetoon nemyoomad chon bighyrat hastyd, shariati ham ye aakhoond bi ammameh bood. tazeh eyn dareh az ketabhaaye khodesh dareh maghlatehaasho mygeh. be jaaye fohsh dadan be harfaash goosh konid taa key mikhayn dar kharate khodetoon bemoonid.

[mahajoon]

ajab bazi vaght ha man fohsh midam baradare 11 salam midonin be man chi mige ,mige vaghti to kam miyari fohsh midi.

[dobaremisazamatvatan]

in mardake naghaad divanast! farib kaare haghighat gorize bisavaad!

[elektrobrother]

in faghat balade naghd kone?

[CYRUS2060]

Shoma ettelaatiha mantegh keh nadarid faghat fohosh midid.islam kasif is down the toilet where it belongs.

[mnfard]

Truly foolish talks from this guy as he pass judgment on issues not in his level to discuss.He obviously displays signs of mind truma in his speeches. God help him

[AleYasin110]

اين مردک مشيري از همه ايراد ميگيره. از پيامبر و امامان بگير تا دکتر شريعتي...

اين يکي از بزرگترين دلايل و نشانه هاي ناداني و ديوانگي اين آدم بي مايه و پر مدعاست.

[CYRUS2060]

islam is dead.the filth of islam is stinking to high heaven.moshiri is one out of millions now.your beloved regime ve islam kasif are down the toilet.

[Neo1370]

what do you know of islam?

for godsake jus think that what do you know about islam? how many times have you read Qoran?

what do you know about islam?(except the craps that this guy says)

and about Dr. Sharyati... he is one of the greatest men that has ever lived on the earth.

He was a Man... and he was damn GOOD! and i am sorry for anyone who cant understand his humanity.

[rbozorgi]

Ensane jahel va zaeef vaghti rahi baraye esbate chizi nadashte bashe, dast be tohin mizane, harfi ke hagh nabashe dar goorestane tarikh chaal mishe. Bahrame moshiri bozorgtarin azab baraye to, batlaghie ke daresh hasti, pas bishtar dasto pa bezan ta bebini noghteye payanet kojast!

[hushi222]

che jakeshe be savadist in Moshiri amali, quromsaq

[shahram32]

kheshthaye avaliye jomhoriye eslami ro shariatiy khaen bonyan gozasht.

[MohammadX101]

i accidently gave you a thumb up, i meant to give you a thumb down

[shahram32]

dafeye degeh havaseto bishtar jam kon

[shahram32]

dafeye degeh havaseto bishtar jam kon

[bkh72]

These moslems are idol-worshipers (Bot-Parast). They worship Mohammad, Ali etc.

Leave alone these people. They are dead and gone. Live your god damn lives. Don't fight on which one is better, ali or omar or abu bakr or whatever, Botparastaan.

[kafir1917]

ridam be ghabre kasife in ali shariatieh khaen

[persian1princes]

doroste ke ali dar khaneye mohammad bozorg shod vali kasi majbooresh nakardeh bood ke dar beyne majlesi ke hame famil boodand ba mohammad vagto mohammad yari khast fagat ali 3 bar dastesho boland koneh. mage hame famil naboodand ba Mohammad.?

[persian1princes]

Age shariati miyoomad europ va mesle tou mother fucker khodesho gom mikard adame dorosti bood? ki hasti tuo ke nazar midi? in avalin bareh ke man harfato gosh mikonam vali hamash be nazaram ahmagane omad.

[naniva]

the time of islam is runing off for IRAN

[hushi222]

Bad bakht pas chera 1/3 donia mosalmonand ? moshkele to besavadist

[BehzadHamedani]

to hushi222: to badbakht bisavadi ba un 1/3 mosalmane ahmaghe dige!

Doroud bar Ostad Moshiri, Doroud bar Ostad Fouladvand

[hushi222]

to degar cheqadr khari ke devanei mesle foladvand osdade tost! khak bar saret ahmaq.

[persian1princes]

shut the fuck up. bisavad. to az eslam chi midooni. shariati ye gahraman bood. adamhayi mesle to aslan nemifahmid chi mikhayd. ya dag mikonid gahi va be shaykha ray midid ya oon vari mishid o kamelan zede eslam.

[mehrann]

1/30 donia mosalmonan 90/100 bisavad mesle toe ahmagh

[hushi222]

IN shayade besavad amali Moshiri chi mege?

[persian1princes]

Hichi baba chize sher migeh

[taghooti]

piss be upon the grave of shariati, name one positive move of this bedouin worshipper.

[abcd0100]

eslamiha az shenidan haghighatha bazi jahashoon dard migire...khodetoon khastin eslam efsha beshe...age dino varede siyasat nemikardin kasi be eslame shoma kari nadasht... berid eslametoono ba dide elmi negah konid ta bebinid hamash kashke...na mohammad peyghambar boode na ghoran az sooye khoda omade...

[ALI12345ALI]

en kieh !! khooleh ? kie hast in ?? esmish chie?? such a stupid guy , i cannot believe those stupid people , still "Barking like a dog "..he looks drunk and drugie.. who are those stupid people , watching air- head tv like that ??

[khoramdin110]

dr shariati was CIA agent in iran.

[sadrazimi]

cheghad khenge, ketabo mikhooneo nemifahme bad mige mani nadare

[houmie]

Cheraa tohin mikonin dustaane aziz? Cheraa in ghadr naaraahat mishin? In aghaa dare az ruye Daghighi o Tabari mikhune unwaght shomaa migin sanadesh ko? Jush nayaar, yek dushe abe sard begir, warame magzet bekhaabe. aghleto be kaar begir, ta'asobo bendaaz dur.

In aslan dar morede Shariaty chize haadi nagoft, cheraa jush awordin? Aslan asle matlabe in bahso gush kardind?

Afsus Afsus ke dindaaraane kale khar na gush midan, na khodeshun ketaab mikhunan.

[nimaomega]

shoma dorough gooyee ke neshasti too ye jaye garm o narm az roo bargi ke behet dadani mikhooni o hatta nemidooni ke dar bareye chi va ki dari harf mizani, va oon vaght Dr shariati tamame zendegish ro ba badbakhti gozaroond ke goore khar hayee mesle to befhamand , bebinand ke doro bareshoon che khabar hast.

[nimaomega]

Dorough goo toyee va oon barnameye sar ta pa dorouughet ke ba poole dolate Bush taghzie mishe baraye tazeife iran va Irani ya doctor shariati ke rasgoyee va haghighat talabie ishoon bood ke baese matrood shodan va terroresh shod?

[alifreedom1]

ki ishan ra terror kard?lotfan agar sandi darid dar ekhtira begozarid.