Believe me. I am not saying Mariah does not have an amazing voice. just not suited for this song. But that is my opinion only so don't hate me. BTW what the hell is najnahnai saying? Does it have a head injury?
Go to "vs" videos to find out that you're wrong. But yup, that was a neat performance from Celine. Most of the time she sounds like a hook scratching the blackboard. On the contrary, Mariah is like a warm breeze carrying mermaid calls from the ocean :)
Over the years we have all been lied to by many false Religous Leaders and so called prophets. Many things we have been taught are not even in Scripture and millions have swallowed so many lies by these false leaders. If you are a truth seeker please visit the web site which is displayed in our user name and take the time to read some of the articles... You will be very shocked.
There is a great audio there for you to listen to. You will come away asking many questions.
A. The carotid microphone carried her voice, and the humming, in-between vocalizing,
B.You could hear the people in the audience, and new it wasn't a studio recording.
Genuine belted out vocals, and her signature 'Whistle' notes.
Reverb from the church walls acoustics, choir back vocals hitting it just right, and an emotional performance captured in every heart, and shown in the children's faces!
@joecoolsvette, but what about the missed notes and the added notes that are not in the original written version of the song? She totally messes up. Had she sang the song as it was written, note for note, then she might have had a winner. As this stands, Celine has her beaten hands down but neither top the song as the best I have ever heard.
@HolySwordsman1, Well yes but Celine has a better voice for this song, Mariah may go higher but Celine has the traditional voice whilst Mariah has a pop voice.
Well... Both Their Versions are Indeed Awesome, No point arguing. However, Celine's Version Was Very Powerful And Full Of Life & Feeling. However, Mariah Did not Meet Up To That. I Love Mariah As Well And I Love This Version. But Celine's Version Was Also Incredible in my opinion.
Mariah put a gospel style with a jazzy undertone which sounds great. Celine's is more of a smooth classic style. Both are great, but I'm not sure this song needs all that wailing like she continued to do after 2:45.
this is just so amazing! how can anyone have their own rendition of this beautiful song after mariah sang it in her own rendition!! can anybody to that????
very nice! i like her voice and song...cept...not her...not hating or anything...she's just not a favorite of mine...just her song and voice are my favorites...she has a strong great voice!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This is typical of all singing stars. They take a simple and elegant song and try to sex it up, jazz it up and 'over sing it'. This song is perfect sung simply....once they start to add embelishments the song becomes about the singer and nothing about what is in the song. Basically this is a bit of masturbation from Carey.
..Thanks for your reply! You hit the nail on the head: weak and stupid! I can't believe the filthy things that some people will say on Youtube without any shame. I reveals their true class if you ask me.
OMG!! Whomever doesn't see the beauty in her voice about Christ's birth in relation to this song.....something is seriously wrong with you......Just HEAVENLY!! Go Mariah.. Most of us get it!
I absolutely agree with greg. clc does Mariah really matter herself, when she sings about Jesus Christ? I don't think so, even I love her and her talent so much.
Anybody cares at all besides her talent and her voice about what song is for? To praise JESUS CHRIST and He is the One who really matters.
And all those people, including Mariah, making fame, name and money on Christmas songs. Well, it's fine, but we all always should remember, Christ is a must for Christmas.
While Mariah has a great voice she totally ruins my favorite Christmas song by adding all the voice inflections and extra notes that are not in the written version of the song. I know some will say, "She's making it her own," but I don't buy that line. A singers voice alone and how it sounds without the added notes and inflections makes it their own. The best version of this song I've ever heard was sung by the Oakridge Boys. Unfortunately it's not on YouTube.
@clc7618, as a matter of fact they do matter and sang one of the most famous versions of this song, as they read the actual scriptures from the Bible of the birth of Christ between verses in the song. Just because you have never heard of them doesn't mean everyone has never heard of them. But, they truly sang the song for what it is about and didn't ruin it by adding extra notes while missing others. Remember, JESUS is the reason for the season.
Every time I ear some singer singing this song, I think,...... no one can do, what she did at 3:23. Plus, the way all the instruments on this record are playing, specially the solo organ, made this version the best I ever heard. Thanks for posting.
this is the best one ever ``am sorry `` hands down lol ms. mc always giveing her all ``i love her ``merry christmas ``jesus i thank you for life and for keeping me `` and the young lady that's singing this song lol ``
nowadays many singers come,,but still mariah carey proves that she is the only one "diva" in the world...............i agree that beyonce k.,christina a.,rihanna,lady gaga are good singers,,but mariah carey have plenty of awards compare to them!!! ....gogogogo mariah we love you!!!!!
Merry christmas youtubers! I hope you are all safe and healthy! Spread the love and joy! Peace on Earth! Stay safe! I wish the best of luck to you all!
lots of love, merry christmas, happy holidays.... Love the state of North Carolina, USA
Beautiful!!!!! Why doesn't she sing ballads like this anymore?? I loved her when she sang songs like this and Vision of Love. THATS what she was born to sing, not that pop crap...
so nice song the most beautiful i ever hear thx Maraih you have a nice and beautiful voice ,thx to God you used for us .
louisajfp 1 year ago
god..mariah is very beautiful in this vid..i love this version,,2:46 to the end so great..love also the whistle..
MrDjoleen 2 years ago
She looks exceptionally beautiful here. Younger almost o.0 is this an old video? Maybe it is the hair...
ophiel84 2 years ago 2
I agree that ist over the top. I like the LISA LOIS version much more
nottenn 2 years ago
i think its too over the top
ya2121 2 years ago 2
Excellent.
JeudeLyne 2 years ago 2
I have listened to so many versions of this song by various artists, but Mariah's and Celine's are definitely the best
rkhyue 2 years ago 5
jolie dommage que sa crie a la fin...
29Belka 2 years ago
check out my version of o hloy night by mariah carey
leahlovesbrandy 2 years ago
lol she's was singing about christ yet she dressed like that hahaha. So hawt.
HwarangOfFaith 2 years ago
shivers!!!!!
piconcina 2 years ago
Believe me. I am not saying Mariah does not have an amazing voice. just not suited for this song. But that is my opinion only so don't hate me. BTW what the hell is najnahnai saying? Does it have a head injury?
DrewFaron 2 years ago
i love her version!
archieHOHO 2 years ago 3
nanglimbawt akong balahibo...
najnajnai 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This version is "ok". She doesn't have the pipes to sing it like Celine. Not a bad version though.
DrewFaron 2 years ago
Go to "vs" videos to find out that you're wrong. But yup, that was a neat performance from Celine. Most of the time she sounds like a hook scratching the blackboard. On the contrary, Mariah is like a warm breeze carrying mermaid calls from the ocean :)
theTeabag 2 years ago 2
I hate that the video and the song don't match up...Beautiful song though. Always one of my favorites.
SSMayday1 2 years ago
listen to michelle mcmanus version its the best of all brilliant......
hookie007 2 years ago
I cannot believe I am watching this on 3rd January....lol
homaiya 2 years ago
i was just wandering , had she ever sung this live ?
lockritahchicqk10 2 years ago
I Love You MAriah Forever!!!
iZejomarsemic 2 years ago
Oh man, @ 3:25, that is hot. Her facial expressions is so sexy and beautiful.
madkisser915 2 years ago
when was this? 1994?
kupalogs222 2 years ago
too bad she cant sing like this no more
superpower612 2 years ago
She's beautiful. great voice. like this.
joakech1 2 years ago
Her face is so pretty. Its so alive, its responding to every word she sings
hadricalifornia 2 years ago 3
fantastic!
dyanartemis21 2 years ago 2
Wow great voice....and great BREASTS!!
XcoldazzzX 2 years ago
i met her last month in London because of work and she has got massive boobs...she was also wearing a swimming costume thing too...very tight.
homaiya 2 years ago
She was wearing a swimming costume in the winter? O Ok, fart smeller. I mean smart teller
madkisser915 2 years ago
She needs to cover her chest much more than that seriously
syg33142 2 years ago
She used to sing great but she doesn't take care of her self. That is why she sounds horrible Now but she could sing in her day!
emartinez1227 2 years ago
nice dubbed over video.....not. Celine still wins the prize.
hockeyham3 2 years ago
@hockeyham3 agreed
pointypencil1 2 years ago
beautiful, simply beautiful.
fullyautoproductions 2 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
Over the years we have all been lied to by many false Religous Leaders and so called prophets. Many things we have been taught are not even in Scripture and millions have swallowed so many lies by these false leaders. If you are a truth seeker please visit the web site which is displayed in our user name and take the time to read some of the articles... You will be very shocked.
There is a great audio there for you to listen to. You will come away asking many questions.
Blessings
Thanks Ben
2besavedcom 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she cant really sing but its okay
TheNyquashia 2 years ago
ok right. lets see, im celine's fan. of course i said her version is better. durh~ suke sgt gaduh2. hishh
AinArchie 2 years ago
Video contains the studio recording, THAT SUCKS!
The original video had Better Quality, do to:
A. The carotid microphone carried her voice, and the humming, in-between vocalizing,
B.You could hear the people in the audience, and new it wasn't a studio recording.
Genuine belted out vocals, and her signature 'Whistle' notes.
Reverb from the church walls acoustics, choir back vocals hitting it just right, and an emotional performance captured in every heart, and shown in the children's faces!
joecoolsvette 2 years ago
@joecoolsvette, but what about the missed notes and the added notes that are not in the original written version of the song? She totally messes up. Had she sang the song as it was written, note for note, then she might have had a winner. As this stands, Celine has her beaten hands down but neither top the song as the best I have ever heard.
greg8698 2 years ago
the video was too dark i only see mariahs face
Jr629 2 years ago
2:45 - 2:51 makes me wanna cry!!
888MakingItHappen888 2 years ago
beautifully sung
manakorn 2 years ago 2
@ 1:05-1:06 'fall on your knees'
that was when the song breaks, she could have done so much more.......
pearpeas 2 years ago
okay now im going to church
witch26071 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Celine is mutch, mutch better!
robocoppo27 2 years ago
GOOSEBUMPS!! that was truly beautiful..
AppleMasterx 2 years ago 4
@HolySwordsman1, Well yes but Celine has a better voice for this song, Mariah may go higher but Celine has the traditional voice whilst Mariah has a pop voice.
hollehwolleh 2 years ago 3
What great range... Like a Dolphin. LOL
kobetv 2 years ago 4
WHAT KINDA RANGE IS THAT?? unbelievable omg
yougivemesomethinggg 2 years ago
mariah carey is a good singer BUT i think that celine dion song this better by like 1 point.
i give mariah a 9 1/2
i give celine dion a 10
maiya303 2 years ago
lol thats by half a point ahahah, they both have awesome voices would be good to see them do duet
kinkiistyle 2 years ago
goosebumps,,,,
TheNRA4ever 2 years ago
only in celines wildest dreams could she come close to singing like mariah. and in this song ... celine wouldn't even dare to dream it.
idseer 2 years ago 2
Well... Both Their Versions are Indeed Awesome, No point arguing. However, Celine's Version Was Very Powerful And Full Of Life & Feeling. However, Mariah Did not Meet Up To That. I Love Mariah As Well And I Love This Version. But Celine's Version Was Also Incredible in my opinion.
RyanMonray 2 years ago 3
Mariah put a gospel style with a jazzy undertone which sounds great. Celine's is more of a smooth classic style. Both are great, but I'm not sure this song needs all that wailing like she continued to do after 2:45.
htxguy 2 years ago 3
celine dion's is not better! this is THE best version of this song in the world
cezerrr 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Celine is much better
hollehwolleh 2 years ago
never
Gerd1962 2 years ago 2
this is perfectly sung.. why not?
cezerrr 2 years ago
@hollehwolleh they are both good, this is my favorite, but you have to admit, she broke a few glasses in the making of this one.
HolySwordsman1 2 years ago
Can Celine do this?? No she cant
MglsVnGigls 2 years ago 9
Celine's is better =P
sarahmulk 2 years ago
this is just so amazing! how can anyone have their own rendition of this beautiful song after mariah sang it in her own rendition!! can anybody to that????
darchirtroll 2 years ago 3
I sang this on our christmas show in my school! :D i got standing ovations :P
daniio 2 years ago
very nice! i like her voice and song...cept...not her...not hating or anything...she's just not a favorite of mine...just her song and voice are my favorites...she has a strong great voice!
truewy 2 years ago
WOW!!! AWESOME/BEAUTIFUL!!! WOW!!!
Joshualeads 2 years ago 2
woe!
mikoliutoones 2 years ago
it was a nice song.....
navie0330 2 years ago
her chest voice is awesome
qwertyuiopz123 2 years ago
This song was fantastic. I really enjoy it.
crystal3776 2 years ago
Merry xmas everyone.Love this song.
DaKumul 2 years ago
Beautiful version!...used to play this on drums in Church years ago for midnight Xmas mass!
DrumTVShow 2 years ago
merry x-mas!:D
siefkeexD 2 years ago
"God Is Good"..Let His Share Christmas Love into your Live & Enjoy it..Thank You Lord
freditanify 2 years ago
..O Holy Night..when His Grace Christmas Love come into our live.. just believe .. Amazing Grace.
freditanify 2 years ago
Comment removed
AinArchie 2 years ago
This video makes the world shows how peace and love can conquers all!! merry xmas to everyone!
jake022908 2 years ago
When was this vid recorded?
stejoaki 2 years ago
@stejoaki 2000
JPhillippeMusic 2 years ago
Merry Christmas from Philippines!
jonatz17 2 years ago
From Stamford, CT to EVERYBODY and my family in Lima-Peru.
rick34ct 2 years ago
merry christmas to everyone in vosges lorraine france from north yorkshire england
PIGGY789 2 years ago
nashvile tennesse.....hope it was great...U S A !
kroger2005 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Merry Christmas from Romania
calisulea 2 years ago
Merry Christmas from Hungary!
zdombi 2 years ago
merry christmas everybody^^ from holland:)
XxprisjuhxX 2 years ago
its so beautiful<3
XxprisjuhxX 2 years ago
wow
zurdotirado 2 years ago
she'll never find those notes again!!! so sad...sing girl!!!
couturesixfour 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
merry christmas to you all!
kupalogs222 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is typical of all singing stars. They take a simple and elegant song and try to sex it up, jazz it up and 'over sing it'. This song is perfect sung simply....once they start to add embelishments the song becomes about the singer and nothing about what is in the song. Basically this is a bit of masturbation from Carey.
Kina123123 2 years ago
Good comment!
67up32 2 years ago
@Kina123123
nicely said i totally agree
CHICAGOGBM 2 years ago
u have to give it to her though ... she pulls some crazy notes on the way 2 her climax .... most people r glad they came along 4 the ride if u ask me
android093 2 years ago
@Kina123123 You're grouse...your choice of words is very unsuitable for a public site where young people frequent.
Stadsjapie777 2 years ago
hey...dont worry about the weak and stupid....hope you have enjoyed this season....Peace to you and yours.
kroger2005 2 years ago
..Thanks for your reply! You hit the nail on the head: weak and stupid! I can't believe the filthy things that some people will say on Youtube without any shame. I reveals their true class if you ask me.
Stadsjapie777 2 years ago
but YOUTUBE had stopped the version from Celine...so stupid
vmlnc 2 years ago
Celine Dion version is more emotional..
Celine Dion version has 6 985 258 viewers.
janeskoHC 2 years ago
ohh very emotional song:) merry christmas
idefixikek 2 years ago
OMG!!!! Whomever can't see the beauty of this song in relation to Christ's birth.... something is seriously wrong with you!! Go Mariah! Just heavenly
jcastaing 2 years ago 2
OMG!! Whomever doesn't see the beauty in her voice about Christ's birth in relation to this song.....something is seriously wrong with you......Just HEAVENLY!! Go Mariah.. Most of us get it!
jcastaing 2 years ago
Wonderful song. Merry christmas from jakarta Indonesia.
binsarhs2020 2 years ago
wonderfullllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll!!!!!!
OMG
moshispears 2 years ago
Comment removed
jcastaing 2 years ago
I absolutely agree with greg. clc does Mariah really matter herself, when she sings about Jesus Christ? I don't think so, even I love her and her talent so much.
Anybody cares at all besides her talent and her voice about what song is for? To praise JESUS CHRIST and He is the One who really matters.
And all those people, including Mariah, making fame, name and money on Christmas songs. Well, it's fine, but we all always should remember, Christ is a must for Christmas.
Nnichos 2 years ago
Merry Christmas from Dominican Rep!
darckiend 2 years ago
Merry Christmas! from the Philippines
batanglagalag2009 2 years ago
While Mariah has a great voice she totally ruins my favorite Christmas song by adding all the voice inflections and extra notes that are not in the written version of the song. I know some will say, "She's making it her own," but I don't buy that line. A singers voice alone and how it sounds without the added notes and inflections makes it their own. The best version of this song I've ever heard was sung by the Oakridge Boys. Unfortunately it's not on YouTube.
greg8698 2 years ago 3
@greg8698 thats because they dont matter. No one knows them!!!
clc7618 2 years ago
@clc7618, as a matter of fact they do matter and sang one of the most famous versions of this song, as they read the actual scriptures from the Bible of the birth of Christ between verses in the song. Just because you have never heard of them doesn't mean everyone has never heard of them. But, they truly sang the song for what it is about and didn't ruin it by adding extra notes while missing others. Remember, JESUS is the reason for the season.
greg8698 2 years ago
Merry Christmas from BRAZIL
rrattis 2 years ago
She rocks, the best vocal ability hands down!
dpatelable 2 years ago 4
Her vocal agility....nuts! She made it her own. I love how she uses her lower range in the beginning. Merry Xmas Everyone :D
shaunmikex 2 years ago 2
MERRY CHRISTMAS!!! from:New York City
crissangel58 2 years ago 2
And sorry, I forgot to say the choir is amazing!!!
juanchow56 2 years ago 3
Every time I ear some singer singing this song, I think,...... no one can do, what she did at 3:23. Plus, the way all the instruments on this record are playing, specially the solo organ, made this version the best I ever heard. Thanks for posting.
juanchow56 2 years ago 5
I Love It!! Merry Christmas From Virginia
solo5148 2 years ago
PWAPWAN UPWUTIWEN KRISTUS...
MELE KA LIKI MAKA.
MERRY CHRISTMAS.
from the pacific islands...
uterang 2 years ago
Merry Christmas from Paola, Kansas!
ObviouslyOutlissa 2 years ago
this is the best one ever ``am sorry `` hands down lol ms. mc always giveing her all ``i love her ``merry christmas ``jesus i thank you for life and for keeping me `` and the young lady that's singing this song lol ``
dwaynemartinez 2 years ago 2
Merry Christmas from upstate New York!~
yheres 2 years ago
MEERY CHRISTMAS to all!
NORTHERN IRELAND
MrROBO1013 2 years ago
3:23....... Seriously?
Vasilios711 2 years ago
@Vasilios711 Mariah never lets a note in the seventh octave go untouched in her classics foo.....
shaunmikex 2 years ago
Comment removed
Vasilios711 2 years ago
FELIZ NATAL!
Merry Chirstmas from
SOROCABA, BRASIL.
luizotaviopianista 2 years ago
Merry Christmas from Wollongong Australia
gkahlenb 2 years ago
watch?v=O45knCnsdng
Merry Christmas!!
UDES86 2 years ago
Merry Christmas to all ! Ottawa Canada
xtremeshredder 2 years ago
MERRY CHRISTMAS from JAMAICA!!
drilljam 2 years ago
MARR CHRISTMAS FROM NIAGARA FALLS NY
KEEGAN10101 2 years ago
Merry Christmas! Immanuel has come - GOD IS WITH US!
organizedchaos63 2 years ago
FELIZ NATAL!!!
Merry Christmas - From
SOROCABA - BRASIL
luizotaviopianista 2 years ago
FELIZ NATAL!!!
Merry Christmas! From
SOROCABA, BRASIL
luizotaviopianista 2 years ago
MARIAH xmas!!! hahahah....
ty5266 2 years ago
Merry Christmas! This is surely one of the greatest ever performances of the classic Christmas carol - a true reference standard.
pinolobu 2 years ago 2
Merry Christmas
porkerthe2nd 2 years ago
Merry Christmas God Bless Everyone !
altimamoonwalker 2 years ago 2
When exactly was this performance? It looks like 2001 or 2002.
MagniMusicLover 2 years ago
HAPPY HOLIDAYS...everyone :)
MagniMusicLover 2 years ago
merry xmas everyone!!
wbdiva504 2 years ago
she is an amazing singer
lovejonesss 2 years ago 2
Fricken ridiculous singer. Shes amazing.
apoulin08 2 years ago
Feliz Navidad desde Chile...
merahetangata 2 years ago
..Superb as always,...her rendition is the best for female version.....gogogo MC,.we Love you from PhiLippines!!
lhynezable 2 years ago
nowadays many singers come,,but still mariah carey proves that she is the only one "diva" in the world...............i agree that beyonce k.,christina a.,rihanna,lady gaga are good singers,,but mariah carey have plenty of awards compare to them!!! ....gogogogo mariah we love you!!!!!
2009jheff 2 years ago
yeah mariah has lots of awards especially at the grammys, the most prestigious...she got 5 awards out of 21 nominations for the past 20 years...
christina got 4 awards out of 16 nominations in a span of just 10 years...all are vocals related..
do your research before you comment
deuxpyro 2 years ago
Merry Christmas from Germany
LadyKirsche1 2 years ago
but do not get me wrong...im a huge fan of mariah...i like her range and vocal control...i also have her emancipation, e=mc2, and xmas album
deuxpyro 2 years ago
The most talented singer on the planet!!!!!!
ACTIVEPOWERS 2 years ago 3
Awesome!!!
2020abcd 2 years ago
m'ry X'maz to all
Jesus luv us
SuperPhenomenom 2 years ago
The most talented singer on the planet!!!
ACTIVEPOWERS 2 years ago
this so is really bad !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SHiEy123 2 years ago
uhhh MC is the ISH
merry christmas from pittsburgh!
Uwantsummadiz 2 years ago
I prefer the interpretation of Celine. because the interpretation made by celine is more authentic.
Luis (Brazil)
LuisinhoCabral 2 years ago 2
me too!! I like mariah but I cannot stand melisma on every single syllable!
homaiya 2 years ago
The way she sings this captures the spirit of Christmas.
MsDawnflower 2 years ago
merry christmas :)
icykid96 2 years ago
Un f-n believable! Merry Christmas to all!
gndprod 2 years ago
she is da best!!!!!!!!!love dis song
37beka 2 years ago
wonderful, soulful and God bless all ..
snowinmi 2 years ago
she is soooo talented
iluvtomandbill 2 years ago
in five minutes i'm gunna sing this to my family <3
TayaxoxKisses 2 years ago
Merry christmas youtubers! I hope you are all safe and healthy! Spread the love and joy! Peace on Earth! Stay safe! I wish the best of luck to you all!
lots of love, merry christmas, happy holidays.... Love the state of North Carolina, USA
mkw1234567890 2 years ago
Wow!!
Lioneljoe 2 years ago
No one comes close to singing this like Mariah, hope 2010 brings peace and happiness to everyoone. Merry Christmas all.
4Autobarn 2 years ago
Merry Christmas Mariah and all people... Lets remeber to keep this feeling all year! c'mon we can do it ..Merry Christmas.....Leigh 09
LeighFeatherstone 2 years ago
Merry Christmas to all my fellow youtubers out there! and in case i dont sign on for a while have a Happy New Year.
kmcarte10 2 years ago
Beautiful!!!!! Why doesn't she sing ballads like this anymore?? I loved her when she sang songs like this and Vision of Love. THATS what she was born to sing, not that pop crap...
DMiriful 2 years ago
@DMiriful She has an amazing voice, every since her breakdown, I have not m.uch cared for her.
td506 2 years ago
@td506 wat happend at her breakdown
iluvtomandbill 2 years ago
iluvtomandbill , I would say it had something to do with Tommy Mottola amongst other things. Her career went into a doward spiral after Tommy
td506 2 years ago
her unique vocal, especially hitting the high notes is flat out unmatched.
madkisser915 2 years ago 5
melt. face. everytime.
=)
hakunamatata1214 2 years ago
Lord, what happened to her? This is the 'real' Mariah, not the one that is now, wish she'd go back to this one.
BoEmery 2 years ago 4
PERFECT
trumulis852 2 years ago
happy Christmas to all youtube users.
nevcas 2 years ago 4
Impressive, just as high a note as Minnie Ripperton in the 70's song Loving You!
HeTried57 2 years ago