蔡卓妍 - 二缺一 (DIY MV) [高清晰音質]

[vito0w0d]

這個社會好殘忍，但我還是很喜歡twins！祝她們一切都好

[Peony881]

I LOVE G.E.M THE MOST, SORRY...

[puff3g]

最極刑是　剩下自己　彷彿單腳企

任我再努力逃避

終須一跌沒餘地............

[jack0410003]

so suck

[mikicc12]

其實我覺得社會吾應該變成咁樣傳媒都靠揭人地私隱黎賺取銷量,獲­得利潤.

每個人都有自己既生活!我吾信你未做過.我亦吾覺得侵犯人地私生­活有咩好威.仲要做頭版.你地成日都話咩新聞自由.採訪自由.吾­比你地採訪又話咩想打擊言論自由.拜託想想自己做到咩程度先會比­人咁鬧先啦.你個D係人權.人地個D吾係?完全侵犯哂.人地做咩­都要你理.就係ED傳媒,香港既社會風氣先會愈來愈敗壞.吾該反­省一下



[kaki830]

其實冇拆既既話:依家佢地都會好紅..

當年佢地橫掃無數既組合獎

我第一個偶像係twins..都係我唯一個偶像

[seaweedbbb]

@paladincock 我吾覺得佢地虛偽 藝人都系人 一樣有權擁有自己的私隱

吾通將自己做過D咩都要公開哂比你睇 就叫真誠咩！！！？

[Xplenovo]

聽到一半 , 即時上網下載落黎 : ]

[Katherinelkw]

我最愛的TT終於二合一啦><過去的就讓它過去啦…

[ray860286231]

好好聽;']

[woo5120]

點解依個世界既人要甘樣 鐘意既時候就係咁又讚又捧 到左照片既事件發生 就去閙 去評論 阿嬌有咩做錯?佢只不過係有性生活 有影啲相 但唔表示佢係做錯 藝人都係一個人 佢又唔係未滿16歲 藝人只不過係一個大眾都認識既人 佢任何私人既事都無必要同大家去交代 如果大家指住都話佢錯 .OK 可以用第二個角度去睇 佢錯 佢有無去改? 佢有 佢係咁叫大家放低過去 不過大家依然咬住佢唔放 大家唔好再話佢假 話佢天真 只不過係大家唔比機會佢去改 因為記者就係每次訪問都拎黎做話題 希望大家可以放低拎阿嬌黎做話題! 藝人都應該受到尊重!

[Bitchyan]

每次看這條片，我都有哭.. 即使是今天也有..

[1313SUPERBB]

剩下自己　怎可走到尾

遇挫折孤身撐起　好東西獨自回味

最極刑是　剩下自己　彷彿單腳企

任我再努力逃避　終須一跌沒餘地

假使我昨日單身走過去

沒有經歷和你一起的壯舉

今天要我獨居應不會　難受到想死去



[zxc3562]

過100m個mv比人del左啦=[,年年又比人del左=[

[fongfongb]

條片好心酸...好地地拆咩夥 傳媒+經理人去死!

[roo1009]

很棒ㄉ音質...

但是否能再加上字幕呢 ？

麻煩一下好嗎？ 非常感謝喔 ！ ^^"

[gilliantung]

我真的希望有一天可以聽到twins唱的二合一^^~



[gilliantung]

我一生一世都鐘意twins~

[gilliantung]

twins只得一個,就係阿sa同阿嬌,任何人都分5開佢地~

i love twins1314

[puff3g]

永遠支持佢地! 不要分開.

[tatabb21]

每晚回到家裡 帶半殘廢身軀//

沒有經歷和你一起的壯舉

今天要我獨居應不會 難受到想死去

[123Mathslover]

Edison chen is a bastard. Lecher.. Anyhow take nude photos of women.. Support twins forever.

[Aabc123able]

I like this music

[jwang604]

This is the cost of being in the spotlight, you forfeit your privacy. Celebrities in general, especially those in HK, are held up to high standards as they have significant influences over kids and teenagers who do not have the capacity to think for themselves in a mature, logical and impartial way. If Gil wasn't punished, she would set a precedent for a whole wave of sex tapes involving young couples. And that would be quite disturbing.

[tyco248248]

真真因為香港有太多一種只會說別人,不會有作自己反省的人

拆夥不是一種很大的問題啦,與世事無絕對的一樣,同樣沒有一對永­遠的隊伍

在你的身旁也會有單獨出現的時候,很多事情其實也必須要由自己來­面對,

能不能看透人生,這才是一個重要的問題

歌詞會令你更容易進入意景,但不必留在這個幻想的世紀停下來

在這不是有嘲諷之意,但是當歌手為了甚麼呢~

當他們每出一首歌,她的銀行戶口就在不斷的有錢進入,不管是多或­少,這也是一種目的

在聽歌的時候,希望你能也能為你的未來面奮鬥

別在一面聽一面的在苦惱

傷心..可以給你多少的力量,不如認真的面對現實,別再逃避>"­<

[cartoonlover01]

i will supoport twins foreverrr! <3

[candy11222]

this diy mv is much more touching than the original one..

[katrin6789]

i heard they split up is that true?

[fungwan2006]

@katrin6789 Yes, that's true: they did split up for a while, but now, they just reunited recently and planning a big comeback.

[ppsh41ful]

人氣不過肥皂泡

[seng1213]

無計了,人紅就多問題,這就是她們的轉捩點,可惜重組都好難重震­惜日"雌"風,單人發展,讓時間沖淡一點吧.

[burbleblubber]

if you compare how Charlene sing when she just started with how she sing now, you can see an enormous improvement, keep going Charlene!!! support you XD

[linghu22]

Gil!!!!快點回來 我們挺你的!!

[sammi52325]

我都係^^

[tang8134]

love sa

[Weirdestgrl89]

Support Twinss!!! Ah Sa & Ah Gil Forever!1

[randytsesiuman]

從小到大開始Twins已經是我既Fans啦,她們都係我從小到­大和我生活的好朋友 !

[eckerXD]

Memories. they have played a huge role during my early teen years.

so sad 實在是世事難料

I loved them. looking at this is like looking back at my teen-hood.

thank you Gillian and Charlene.

[evelyn2708]

why did they separate?

[iamaveryuglyboy]

twins快d復合 :( 如果吾系我覺得兩個人同我地粉絲都會吾開心-0-!!

[chickensalad98]

Charlene got soooo much better in singing. im so proud of her. ♥

[pearl123able]

好想哭:(

[TunG6Cw]

twins果陣每次都拎獎..

冇一齊合作之後..

拎獎都小左..

[iloveGEMforever]

記得兒時偶像係twins.

過去既就由得佢過去啦~

希望twins可以快d一齊=]

[lovedavidasd]

好感人呀!!!!!首歌我真想唱比我朋友聽!!!-_-

[kowincheng]

前兩天地鐵顯示板話阿嬌下月出EP, 心情似之前的歌 "Ichiban 興奮"!!! XDXD

[kowincheng]

見到呢個用心做的DIY MY, 好懷念孖妹Twins點解她們還未出黎繼續唱好歌, 正所謂人誰無過, 希望在2010年1月1日開始, 她們再用孖妹Twins的名意再歌再舞, 一齊狂歡!!!

[jjny05]

wait why did the twins separate?

[Waylanderz]

It's because of the Edison Chen photo scandal

[tunhang]

我都希望Twins快些兩個可以同台表演

[donaldfk]

一對甘好既組合就系甘散左，真系悲哀！

[rainbow2513]

喂`問題係佢係公眾人物`你前面講得好岩`但後面唔係咁認同`

[yeahforever]

佢地係公眾人物又點?

唔通公眾人物就唔可以享用同正常人一樣既自由同私隱?

[Katon01]

Yes that right i not hate gillian , i always support gillian and charlene as Twins forever.

[tomyeung2108]

邊個人吾會做錯野?做錯後要道歉!佢有!佢都係傷害者!點解吾俾­機會佢?放低成見!重新接感阿嬌啦~

[BD7PA]

聽住呢道歌，睇住畫面，突然真是好想喊，覺得個社會真是好殘酷，­點解要甘忍心拆散姖地，而且是要用人地嘅私隱事情，真是好過份。­

[Shuisee]

twins 開始 二缺一 了

[Snoopedy]

well said, ninjasks89

[yin19941225]

剩下自己...

感觸好大

[yh020079]

另一問題,假若你既照片俾人放上網,仲要俾人指住罵,什至俾人將­照片"一傳十,十傳百",人人皆知,你又感受如何呢?

同一道理,人家的私隱最好別去侵犯,別把自己的快樂,建築於他人­的痛苦上...正所謂:己所不欲,勿施於人

別再以人家一點的過錯,就找着來說不停,說得人家一塵不淨吧!

明星也是人,私生活是他們個人的,沒必要被人約束,既使是神也一­樣......

[88wll]

@yh020079

well said my friend..

[tony14ted]

@yh020079

我比較想知道神的私生活是怎樣的...

[yh020079]

我同意abc2390986既講法,我本身都系TWINS FANS, 我很想問那些針對受害人(女)們的人:

若你是她們其中一位,自己私生活被侵犯,你感受如何?

各人也有不同想法,這問題我留給大家細想......

[abc2390986]

作為一個曾經TWINS的粉絲,我真的沒想到她們會因為這件事被­拆散(雖然不知道是不是永久的).看到這個MV,真的深有感觸,­悲哀的二缺一,悲哀的阿gill. 我同意XXLISEXX的說法,這只是別人的私生活,而且在這件­事人家是受害者,爲什麽要憎恨受害者,僅僅因為他們是明星,所以­就連私生活都要受到約束嗎?!

[littleMao2006]

希望TWINS再次一起=]

[carmenamui]

Support Twins~

[nathanhyf]

amagzine

[AznBabexAngel]

support twins 4ever!<333

ah gil! add oil!

[angelnheav3]

<3 twins

[ericckh]

你好叻呀!!!!!

[lois0209]

二缺一..

未睇mv前以為係打麻雀個d.. (好似丫ma= =)

但原來..係咁解..

唉..好可惜

[lois0209]

@kaikaiha123 打麻雀係3缺1我睇錯左-.-"" 3個差1個..haha

[XxLisexX]

i really don't understand why everyone hate ah gill now, i mean to be honest why would anyone care what celebs do in their private time?! and to the haters of ah gill now...does ah gill's private life REALLY concern you AT ALL?? i DON'T THINK SO! the haters only hate her cos they think that the citizens thinks that she's a disgrace to HK people so they thought "well, why not hate her too..if citizens think she's bad then she MUST be bad, let's just act like i really do give a damn about it!"

[ninjasks89]

You answered the question by yourself. She's a celebrity. She's and Idol to ALOT of people. Many are under aged kids. You're telling as a celebrity she can get away with that. I know its not her fault for the photos release and that she is a victim. But when she made the choice to have her picture taken she assumes ALL responsibility of the possible consequences. If she wasn't a celebrity no one would care except for the people she knows. But she is an idol of many.

[KuragiKohaku]

Ya? so miley cyrus can get away with being a slut behind the scenes and no one cares and everyone gangs up on gil? WTF IS WRONG WITH U

[ninjasks89]

its a difference of culture, im not hating on gil. Its what the society the celebrity lived it that determines it. When you see why america has the highest teen pregnancy rate, you'll understand why

[YeuNguoiChungVach]

i agreed with ya azn are pro contraception user.

[ninjasks89]

I'm taking that as a sarcastic comment seeing how China has the largest population.

In case you didn't read my post correctly, I said Teen Pregnancy Rate, not Pregnancy Rate. China has the largest population count cause mostly adults are have babies, not teens having sex. (documented)

[rrraineee]

nice MV made!

[Woootttcrystal]

SUPPORT Twins

Gill,,, cm back

[wishgill]

若Twins會再開演唱會,會有多少人支持??我會一直支持tw­ins.....

[kitty8182]

we all support u twins!!!come back!!!!!!!!!

[ChoB1Fan]

阿Sa is better off by herself in my opinion but then again, I was never a huge Twins fans. Hope she makes a new album soon. Lonely Me is a very good album.

[skateboard9421]

is it really that much of people saw those picture?.... i didn't see it... be strong Gill!!

[cpeter654456]

又唔關阿嬌事係d人唔講道理姐ma

[julyoften]

Twins come back!!

[CarrotDoo]

They shouldn't have split them up... =.=

[jamsimela]

好靚女!

[potterrain]

good

[maokay]

im never a fan of twins, and to be honest, i dont like gill at all...but i really think people in hong kong should give her another chace...she didnt do anything wrong..just cuz Edison and those girls are celebrities and they had sex...does mean those are sins....like....seriously...i think people are a bit too harsh on this girl...

support =]

[ChoB1Fan]

Fully agree but I'd like to add to that in a similar vain. What people choose to do in their private lives is their business and no other. Whatever Edison and all those other girls did is really their own private lives. If you criticise them, you are denying them the fundamental right of privacy in their own affairs coupled with the fact that any materials that were surfaced weren't even meant to be seen by the public.

[ChoB1Fan]

Stupid Edison. He really is 大頭蝦 for leaving photos on his hardrive in repair

[Flyaaaa]

Yes it is their right of privacy. The only problem is that Twins have built an unrealistically innocent stage image, which is destroyed by the pictures.

[apple199654]

其實阿嬌都好慘嫁

[time1117]

1 : 08 係以前清純既呀gill..

其實搞到咁..真係好可惜..唉 ,,,

初初出道冇耐既twins..不論係sa定嬌...

真係做到一粒star 應該有既野

[SMEXYPopPy]

Yeah It's True That Gillian LOVE Edison But Because Of this "thing" That happen the nude photo they couldn't be together...

[smallfat1661]

好

[carllawrencexenon]

it's so touching! i think charlene is a really wonderful person, she sees gillian as her biological sister, u just dont see this kind of loyalty in showbiz very often

[TheLovelycat]

good!

[itsuki6918]

有無得下載呢段DIY MV?

[HyuniHyuni]

This song is awesome I with Twins would make new music :' (

[yaahoo12345]

好有味道的歌.

[lung1986]

HK people are fake and cunning?

I doubt if u hv ever lived in other countries

and what do u mean by "they are carrying sins themselves"...please clarify...u f u c king moron..........oh..or do u mean your dumb brother carries sins....lol..

[shanghairenshabi]

wicky comm bro

[OrzSax10Saki]

2:36-2:38 What song was it?

[sweetweni]

零四好玩 it's a song from their magic album ^^

[sweetweni]

this mv and song is making me cry :'( I miss Gillian so much!

[UeharaMisato]

我到依家都唔知點解咁多人批評班受害人,情況就好似係街比人搶手­袋,仲要同人道歉話自己冇好好拎實個袋咁...

點都好,支持阿嬌出返黎,支持所有相中人企返起身~

[Twinsfanstatistics]

I totally agree with you. :)

[jasijasmine]

i agree :) there songs are so good

[suzanne514]

Great!!

[yimkakeung]

幾好聽...

支持阿嬌再唱歌

[Elaine0114]

Good!! Good!! Twins!!! ^_^

[karyanvivian]

阿嬌做錯姐?? What did she do wrong? having sex with a man? people just ignorant about things cos they haven't had anything else to do...it's sad..hk culture now all based on gossips about other people's pivacy...

[mokstar]

hk is a place with morals

[XxLisexX]

hk is a place of morals?? not ONLY morals though, but also very hypocritic about the fact that they always say things like HK is a whole and very supportive blah blah blah but then when the issue of edison's scandal comes, they're all discriminating the victims pfft. and the stupid media just loves to make things worse by writing MORE crap..

[arvinkong]

we can't judge others

[starsinajar]

i think it's cos what she did completely goes against her image of a cute, positive image as a role model..

and her mistake was taking explicit pictures, not having sex.

thing is, most HK people seem to be support her by portraying her as the victim, whereas edison chen got more of the flames...

[Twinsfanstatistics]

I guess. But seriously, we all know what kind of person Edison is. Gillian liked Edison for four years even, and if she didn't have sex with him, he wouldn't like her. If you were a girl (or maybe you are one), and you liked a guy, I'm pretty sure you would do ANYTHING for his love. Plus, gillian only did this with one guy, she's not even a slut. So I reckon it's fair and it's just tite that Edison doesn't even apologise when Gillian is taking so much pressure. Yeah?

[fairtoeverybody]

@Twinsfanstatistics

u r absolutely right...love is blind...but its all in the past for both of them...

[eWI7Y]

nice!! is there a video in chinese??

[raymondkwok12345]

好聽ar~

[Vickytai1027]

希望可以再見到TWINS

[vivianleaf1994]

支持Gillian!!!!

[nbaq]

有邊一個人唔會做錯.聖人都有錯.阿嬌做錯姐.我地係要比番個機­會佢

[sabrinaboby]

每晚回到家裡 帶半殘廢身軀入睡床沒法睡 雜念來又去往往仍記起你 過去共你一起所經過多得可以編寫幾次傳記 ＊分享我的興趣 分擔我各樣顧慮在絕處一刻擁抱等於給我聖水你去後令我發現 笑聲有罪 踏步也失據 剩下自己 怎可走到尾遇挫折孤身撐起 好東西獨自回味最極刑是 剩下自己 彷彿單腳企任我再努力逃避 ...

[cutiewinnie1997]

我觉得应该给阿娇一次机会，谁没有做错过啊！希望twins可以­早日以组合身份复出，二缺一真的很惨！

[xiaojieqq]

Hey is there a english translation for this song^^?

[stephywaiyee]

冇左呀嬌都吾似twins

比呀嬌去試下同呀Sa唱下先啦

[unicorns1015]

我agree ar......望住阿Sa,好似少左d野咁...始終係Twi­ns ar ma.....

Give多次chance阿嬌la......

人始終會似做錯野ga la...

e段DIY mv 好有意思=]

[ilovepcms]

i agree,

[tsangzhichun]

點解d唔俾次機會阿嬌呢?

[kingchiu113]

我都係仲意以前一齊嘅twins

永遠支持

[Pokemon1998cyrus]

二缺一

係講twins 得阿Sa冇阿嬌

個意思好明顯....ニ缺一

二=twins

缺=少了阿嬌

一=剩下阿Sa

[lovona09]

are they les?

[chanhailey]

首歌好似係度講緊佢自己

特別係

剩下自己 怎可走到尾

遇挫折孤身撐起 好東西獨自回味

最極刑是 剩下自己 彷彿單腳企

任我再努力逃避 終須一跌沒餘地

[xochoy999]

I like it very much

[saleisha3580]

周博賢~gd job !~!

wt a gd song u hv created !~!

lv this song n SA ~~

[qSAMSONp]

何謂twins?

二缺一

十分有意思

[angelababy021]

阿嬌同阿sa真係好可憐呀~點解阿嬌做錯一樣野就要俾人話,要退­出?點解D人唔諗下佢咁多年嘅付出無啦啦就好似消失左咁,會幾傷­心?7年,7年呀~佢1日之間變到乜都無...不過至少仲有一班­fans同埋阿sa支持佢~

我聽呢首歌嘅時候真係喊左,一幕幕twins嘅片段喺腦海浮現~­

[woodycheung33]

twins加油加油!

[lemon654321]

this mv is really very well done..! hopefully, the public will accept ah jiao again soon..

[matthew3202]

Sup U Guys ar`!!!

Although I'm not your fans but I still hope you guys can getting together soon`

great video`

[cutiewinnie1997]

twins forever ~~~!!!!@@@

[pqqgirlk]

加油呀!Twins!

有好人同你地打氣o架!

[tintin573123456]

剩下自己 怎可走到尾

遇挫折孤身撐起 好東西獨自回味

最極刑是 剩下自己 彷彿單腳企

任我再努力逃避 終須一跌沒餘地 /_\

[cutiewinnie1997]

这个mv非常成功，一面看，一面流泪，回想起以前的twins，­真的很感动，歌词更加可以形容现在的twins

[con1221chan]

twins 要+oil~~

fans 十卜 u 4ever!!!!

第日twins一齊唱歌一齊開演唱會~ =]"

[yuki4baby4]

支持阿嬌

[lotteluving]

十卜^^好聽

[CHOYJJJJ]

Good song

[sammi52325]

TWINS加油

[greenyui]

呢個世界係咁架喇，你之前做幾多好野都冇用，錯一樣已經野，人地­已經唔會俾機會你...

不過要堅持下去牙，加油，牙嬌...

[fai250819615]

唔知有冇機會聽Tiwns合唱二缺一呢!最好唔好唱二缺一(好似­好有遺撼),唱首合拍D既新歌!

[ofofof1234567]

牙嬌+油 , 無左你就5係twins