I'm not going to lie, calling a spade a spade here. I think religion is bullshit, and more a crutch in fear of their life ending and not being remembered. that's my opinion, but what I came here for was a man that inspired music I want to write and who I grew up with. Johnny Cash.
I stopped outside the church house where the citizens like to sit.
They say they want the kingdom but they don't want God in it.
To me, this line is saying that people pay a lot of attention to their religion's rules, and don't actually follow the teachings of Jesus Christ, or find themselves spiritually connected with God. Amazing song by legendary artists.
Armenia though the lyrics are definately subjective in many ways it is definately a sad song, Johnny Cash it at his best when he's critical, and he's critical of people who are selfish, people who use religion to justify their own means and talks of the experience of searching for the answer. But it's definately not a positive song about society or peoples selfishness.
Armenia though the lyrics are definately subjective in many ways it is definately a sad song, Johnny Cash it at his best when he's critical, and he's critical of people who are selfish, people who use religion to justify their own means and talks of the experience of searching for the answer. But it's definately not a positive song about society or peoples selfishness.
JOHNNY CASH, el màs grande. un mito. una leyenda, que pena que se pierda el tiempo en musicas totalmente vanale. ¡ ¡ GLORIA A TI EN EL CIELO JOHNNY ! !
Not sad, prophecy being fulfilled today! Kind of exciting. He was best friends with Billy Graham remember & got his Doctorate in Bible. This is referencing scripture. Partly Daniel 2.
@Armeniacolombia29 What @shayneby is trying to say is, "religious" people sit outside the churches and proclaim that America is the kingdom of god... but they don't really want god in their "kingdom." They just want some way to justify discriminating against people who are not like them.
The line means that people are content with a safe, complacent faith, at peace with the status quo; that is, they don't want their attitudes/actions to be challenged. It's the same criticism Keirkegaard and MLK had of the established churches of their times. So you don't see why this would sadden someone? No wonder that there are many like you, and so what, but I'm surprised someone as dense as you appear to be would post such a profound song.
@Rutlefan Your religious knowledge is surpassed only by your readiness to judge others. The OP that the uploader was responding to was basically saying it's sad that people in America don't want to be Christian (separation of church and state), which is a far greater misunderstanding of the song than you're projecting onto others.
In any event, you're interpretation is wrong. Per Johnny Cash and U2: "The lyrics describe a man searching for God in a post-Apocalyptic world." So much for your ego
@Armeniacolombia29 I do consider sad having a church were people don't have any intention of listening to God's message, and much less acting like it (meaning loving and accepting your peers, forgiving)...if the intention is just for citizens to sit, well a public park would suffice, I guess what's sad it's that the "church house" that this song refers to gives people the feeling of entitlement to be judgemental since they're "church-going" people, when in reality they're basking in emptiness
@cleo715 I like your interpretation of god's message (loving and accepting your peers, forgiving etc.) but it doesn't fit with what is in the bible. I see in the old testament a god for just the israelites who encourages them to commit genocide on others (the canaanites) and to offer up their own daughters to be raped instead of their guests. The new testament god and the old testament god cannot be reconciled. I agree with your beliefs of tolerance and forgiveness, but I don't think god does.
@Armeniacolombia29 One way of looking at it, even if you're not into worshipping God as a separate entity, is that people are forgetting themselves... forgetting what made their past actions special, even great. Loss of the god within themselves; a loss of sensitivity, humility, self-perspective. What's sad is that any society that is dead in it's heart to these things becomes increasingly a society not worth living in.
Ok. Is that why Shawn McCrany uses it as his team song for his show? Maybe. Well the mormons got it all wrong. Joseph Smith put alot of people in bondage. Amazing! Thanks man.
Excuse me? You really need to get rid of that ego of yours. This songs lyrics are open to interpretation and I shared that the lyrics relate to Mormonism at one point in the song.
@shayneby "The God of the Old Testament is arguably the most unpleasant character in all fiction: jealous and proud of it; a petty, unjust, unforgiving control-freak; a vindictive, bloodthirsty ethnic cleanser; a misogynistic, homophobic, racist, infanticidal, genocidal, filicidal, pestilential, megalomaniacal, sadomasochistic, capriciously malevolent bully."
@Treefrogs2 Actually if you look it up in almost all dictionaries it is along the lines of "fear of, aversion to, or discrimination against homosexuality or homosexuals" -Merriam-Webster.
But that is even the least critical part. Don't worry though, there is no such god of the bible anyways. :)
@elisdewaard1 Oh, like how Abraham was going to sacrifice his own son? Do you think that's a good idea? Would you sacrifice your own son upon an altar if you thought your god told you to do so? And of course you're going to say "But, but, but in the story god sent an angel to stop him!" Still, Abraham was really going to do it. A terrible story, children in this day and age have been killed by events like these.
@mustsyfart2001 You absolutely miss the whole point... The best thing about that historical event was that he was so committed to what God wanted best and trusted in him that he was willing to do anything God asked of him. Of course God stopped him from doing this but how many people today have dedicated their hearts to God as Abraham did? None! That is sad!
@shayneby Prophetic song, talking about America today. Where religious nuts wave the Bible but don't live by it. Where their "holier than thou" attitude does not apply behind their closed doors. Where Jesus looks at us as if we are all the same, but that is not how these folks look at other people of different color, religion or sexual orientation. Sad, indeed.
slickmagic, all the lines with I evoke personalising, up to us whether they apply or conjure up the right picture. For me, "atomic sky" is linked to the dvd "the atomic cafe", apocalyptic pictures there.
true because of the propaganda and atomic bomb and what not, but its so hard to not take what he says and see it and feel it when walking down the street listening to it. try it. go out for a walk and just feel it instead of trying to find the root meaning. it feels better. your right in seeing what maybe the meaning but, i like to just feel it, let it sink real down low and make you feel....angry and all those feeling music gives you.
I like your idea of listening to it while "walking down the street". I live in the country, lake view, in The Netherlands, but I can imagine that with the sky coloured like in "Seven", and being in a particular state of mind in a 21st century megalopolis, it combines to make you feel, well, depressed, but at the same time impressed by the music.
I'm not going to lie, calling a spade a spade here. I think religion is bullshit, and more a crutch in fear of their life ending and not being remembered. that's my opinion, but what I came here for was a man that inspired music I want to write and who I grew up with. Johnny Cash.
Thrashslashedmashedp 5 months ago
This reminds me of Alpine, TX, and west Texas in general. Listened to it a lot for the short time I lived out there. Reminds me of when I was happy.
djbarcode5xyz 5 months ago
Comment removed
MonkeyHunch 6 months ago
Great song, really very inspiring!
Martin1735 8 months ago
I SAY THE KILLERS OR BRANDON FLOWERS COVER THIS!!!!!
ErockWErock 10 months ago
@ErockWErock That would be... AMAZING!!!
Epicentr31 6 months ago
I SAY THE KILLERS OR BRANDON FLOWERS COVER THIS!!!!!
ErockWErock 10 months ago
Cash &U2,what a combination & who'd of thoughtit?
compster48 1 year ago
@compster48
I bloody agree.
mike098456 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I stopped outside the church house where the citizens like to sit.
They say they want the kingdom but they don't want God in it.
To me, this line is saying that people pay a lot of attention to their religion's rules, and don't actually follow the teachings of Jesus Christ, or find themselves spiritually connected with God. Amazing song by legendary artists.
Trocker7 1 year ago
This is a love song, above all other things.
bluescommander 1 year ago
When I first heard this, I actually thought it was Edge singing. XD Hey, I was young and stupid then, didn't know better :P
5AmSuN 1 year ago
Geweldig _O_
Penisbaard 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Armenia though the lyrics are definately subjective in many ways it is definately a sad song, Johnny Cash it at his best when he's critical, and he's critical of people who are selfish, people who use religion to justify their own means and talks of the experience of searching for the answer. But it's definately not a positive song about society or peoples selfishness.
danzab22 1 year ago
Armenia though the lyrics are definately subjective in many ways it is definately a sad song, Johnny Cash it at his best when he's critical, and he's critical of people who are selfish, people who use religion to justify their own means and talks of the experience of searching for the answer. But it's definately not a positive song about society or peoples selfishness.
danzab22 1 year ago
this young Johnny kinda looks like a young Bono....just here tho I guess....must be the hair!
barn524 1 year ago
Comment removed
barn524 1 year ago
this song are full of shit and truth.
MrMelodynelson 1 year ago
none of this is happening lol u gays are just crazy teapartiers lol
thebuzdar 1 year ago
mrgyn...you dont no what yr taklking about F U
ramtwos 1 year ago
@ramtwos
I was talking about how this song was used by a Christian show called "Heart of the matter" that debunks Mormonism.
Mrgyn 1 year ago
HAHAHA SUM ONE SAID HE SING ABOUT MORMONISM HAHAHA OH SHIT THAT FUNNY
st123722 1 year ago
great song
82558061 1 year ago
This song makes me want to lift up my hands and heart and praise the Lord. This should be played in churches.
ArtDog010101 1 year ago
JOHNNY CASH, el màs grande. un mito. una leyenda, que pena que se pierda el tiempo en musicas totalmente vanale. ¡ ¡ GLORIA A TI EN EL CIELO JOHNNY ! !
lasalasg 1 year ago
Johnny Cash another great Irish American Soul...Rock n Roll Johnny we love U2!!
Mr.ReedG, or whatever your silly name is? ...your on the wrong page man!
This is Rock n Roll...and Soul and... whatever? we know it we love it!! Peace & Love...
HitchikersBlues 1 year ago
the AMAZING MR. JOHNNY CASH!!!!!
davieboyplays1 1 year ago
Great song with a beautiful lyric, makes everything feel timeless
XillaCompany 2 years ago
andy loves it. like he loves latin girls
MrReedg 2 years ago
Of course tho, the bible isnt the beginning and end of spirituality.
elcaptainkebab 2 years ago
Not sad, prophecy being fulfilled today! Kind of exciting. He was best friends with Billy Graham remember & got his Doctorate in Bible. This is referencing scripture. Partly Daniel 2.
Jazzydiva29 2 years ago
@1:25 I stopped outside the church house where the citizens like to sit.
They say they want the kingdom but they don't want God in it.
This is what is happening now to America. How Sad
shayneby 2 years ago 14
@shayneby What's sad about it?
Armeniacolombia29 2 years ago 2
Kind of sad that what Johnny cash was singing is what is happening to America now. Listen to the song. Touching lyrics. Don't you see.
shayneby 2 years ago 7
@shayneby Yea I listened to the song a number of times, I wouldn't consider it necessarily a sad thing.
Armeniacolombia29 2 years ago 5
@Armeniacolombia29
thanks for upload dude, I really get a good feeling of my spirituality being lifted and I got choaked up, peace out : )
planes3333 1 year ago
@Armeniacolombia29 What @shayneby is trying to say is, "religious" people sit outside the churches and proclaim that America is the kingdom of god... but they don't really want god in their "kingdom." They just want some way to justify discriminating against people who are not like them.
tangerinespeed0 6 months ago
@Armeniacolombia29
The line means that people are content with a safe, complacent faith, at peace with the status quo; that is, they don't want their attitudes/actions to be challenged. It's the same criticism Keirkegaard and MLK had of the established churches of their times. So you don't see why this would sadden someone? No wonder that there are many like you, and so what, but I'm surprised someone as dense as you appear to be would post such a profound song.
Rutlefan 6 months ago
@Rutlefan Wow what a way to characterize someone you don't know.
Armeniacolombia29 6 months ago
@Rutlefan Your religious knowledge is surpassed only by your readiness to judge others. The OP that the uploader was responding to was basically saying it's sad that people in America don't want to be Christian (separation of church and state), which is a far greater misunderstanding of the song than you're projecting onto others.
In any event, you're interpretation is wrong. Per Johnny Cash and U2: "The lyrics describe a man searching for God in a post-Apocalyptic world." So much for your ego
ZackisDead 5 months ago
@Armeniacolombia29 I do consider sad having a church were people don't have any intention of listening to God's message, and much less acting like it (meaning loving and accepting your peers, forgiving)...if the intention is just for citizens to sit, well a public park would suffice, I guess what's sad it's that the "church house" that this song refers to gives people the feeling of entitlement to be judgemental since they're "church-going" people, when in reality they're basking in emptiness
cleo715 5 months ago
@cleo715 I like your interpretation of god's message (loving and accepting your peers, forgiving etc.) but it doesn't fit with what is in the bible. I see in the old testament a god for just the israelites who encourages them to commit genocide on others (the canaanites) and to offer up their own daughters to be raped instead of their guests. The new testament god and the old testament god cannot be reconciled. I agree with your beliefs of tolerance and forgiveness, but I don't think god does.
MiscellaneousOther 3 weeks ago
@shayneby Mmm. yeah not a sad thing. About time we stopped acting like children.
renix 6 months ago
It's sad. It's joyful. It's beautiful. It's frightening. It's all those things. That's what makes it U2 and Cash.
ArtDog010101 1 year ago
@Armeniacolombia29 One way of looking at it, even if you're not into worshipping God as a separate entity, is that people are forgetting themselves... forgetting what made their past actions special, even great. Loss of the god within themselves; a loss of sensitivity, humility, self-perspective. What's sad is that any society that is dead in it's heart to these things becomes increasingly a society not worth living in.
MediaFilter 1 year ago
Comment removed
TheFirstJedi 1 year ago
@Armeniacolombia29 Damn straight.... we don't need "God" in our kingdom! :)
TheFirstJedi 1 year ago
@shayneby
He is singing about Mormonism.
Mrgyn 1 year ago
@Mrgyn really? How is that? Please explain.
shayneby 1 year ago
@shayneby
It perfectly explains Utah and the Mormons there. They want the Kingdom but they sure as hell don't want the King in it.
Mrgyn 1 year ago
@Mrgyn
Ok. Is that why Shawn McCrany uses it as his team song for his show? Maybe. Well the mormons got it all wrong. Joseph Smith put alot of people in bondage. Amazing! Thanks man.
shayneby 1 year ago
@shayneby
Yeah that's probably why he does. Although the song is also about other things as well.
Mrgyn 1 year ago
@Mrgyn The lyrics describe a man searching for God in a post-Apocalyptic world. HAHAHHAHA HE DOESNT TALK ABOUT MORMONISM AT ALL IN THAT SONG HAHA
st123722 1 year ago
@Mrgyn Hahahaha stupid mormonism XDDD Oh shit that made me crack up AHhahaha Yea and Lady gaga sings about buddism hahaah
st123722 1 year ago
@st123722
Excuse me? You really need to get rid of that ego of yours. This songs lyrics are open to interpretation and I shared that the lyrics relate to Mormonism at one point in the song.
You loud ignoramus.
Mrgyn 1 year ago
@Mrgyn ego hahaha ego mormons have bigger ego then me and no mormonism in that song
st123722 1 year ago
@st123722
I'm not a Mormon. The verse is insulting Mormons.
Mrgyn 1 year ago
@Mrgyn A cobanation of the STDs guanaria, herpes, siphallis and aids
st123722 1 year ago
@Mrgyn hahah
paddykill 1 year ago
@shayneby "The God of the Old Testament is arguably the most unpleasant character in all fiction: jealous and proud of it; a petty, unjust, unforgiving control-freak; a vindictive, bloodthirsty ethnic cleanser; a misogynistic, homophobic, racist, infanticidal, genocidal, filicidal, pestilential, megalomaniacal, sadomasochistic, capriciously malevolent bully."
That god?
mustsyfart2001 1 year ago 4
@mustsyfart2001 "homophobic"- according to the bible god is not homophobic. That word means to "fear"
God in the old testament determined that homosexual acts were detestable and an affront to the good order of creation.
Treefrogs2 1 year ago
@Treefrogs2 Actually if you look it up in almost all dictionaries it is along the lines of "fear of, aversion to, or discrimination against homosexuality or homosexuals" -Merriam-Webster.
But that is even the least critical part. Don't worry though, there is no such god of the bible anyways. :)
mustsyfart2001 1 year ago
@mustsyfart2001
read the bible better, then you see other things... look up the god of ''Moloch''
also read the other part about God, read about the stories of Moses, Abraham etc.
elisdewaard1 11 months ago
@elisdewaard1 Oh, like how Abraham was going to sacrifice his own son? Do you think that's a good idea? Would you sacrifice your own son upon an altar if you thought your god told you to do so? And of course you're going to say "But, but, but in the story god sent an angel to stop him!" Still, Abraham was really going to do it. A terrible story, children in this day and age have been killed by events like these.
mustsyfart2001 9 months ago
@mustsyfart2001 You absolutely miss the whole point... The best thing about that historical event was that he was so committed to what God wanted best and trusted in him that he was willing to do anything God asked of him. Of course God stopped him from doing this but how many people today have dedicated their hearts to God as Abraham did? None! That is sad!
cctman 6 months ago
@shayneby Prophetic song, talking about America today. Where religious nuts wave the Bible but don't live by it. Where their "holier than thou" attitude does not apply behind their closed doors. Where Jesus looks at us as if we are all the same, but that is not how these folks look at other people of different color, religion or sexual orientation. Sad, indeed.
samojednom 1 year ago
@samojednom its more than just "in" america
losdeftones09 9 months ago
@shayneby Not only there. Some other places, such as my hometown. I'm ashamed of it...
AnelIsaac 5 months ago
The Johnny Cash 'Columbo' episode "Swan Song" was a classic. And this is a great, eerie track. Would be nice to hear a totally acoustic version.
jacojahoss 2 years ago
johnn cash wata legend...im 15 and i cant stop listenin 2 his songs.....and this isnt jus a phase
manumcgoo 2 years ago 2
great share! thank you!
jeannevdb 2 years ago
Love it!
TreesTheGreenLove 2 years ago
cool share
KENOEFF 2 years ago
Very cool. Thanks sean for sharing
bigeeezy 2 years ago
Love it! Thanks Cantshaketheblues for the share! 5*
orangewoman671 2 years ago
must EVERY U2 song I hear sound like Bono the vampire is in a stadium?
CDBigShow 2 years ago
I just LOVE this song, i mean the backing is incredible!!
zacsutubeaccount 2 years ago
it's somewhere different for me.
this is one of the saddest songs i've ever heard.
i always find it hard to focus on anything else when this is playing.
those backing vocals are so perfect and devastating.
i've been very curious to hear Bono's version from the Zooropa sessions.
Brian Eno wanted him to release that version instead,
but Bono wanted Johnny's voice.
it's not only perfect for the song,
but it serves as another mask,
like The Fly character or MacPhisto or The Mirrorball Man.
argoninja2112 2 years ago
totally with you, argoninja. Bought this album when seriously down, didn't really help me at that time! So, still this evokes that sadness.
borselva 2 years ago
very true, The best is " I went out walking under an atomic sky"
slickmagic 2 years ago
slickmagic, all the lines with I evoke personalising, up to us whether they apply or conjure up the right picture. For me, "atomic sky" is linked to the dvd "the atomic cafe", apocalyptic pictures there.
borselva 2 years ago
I agree with borselva. Lol
Armeniacolombia29 2 years ago
why?
slickmagic 2 years ago
true because of the propaganda and atomic bomb and what not, but its so hard to not take what he says and see it and feel it when walking down the street listening to it. try it. go out for a walk and just feel it instead of trying to find the root meaning. it feels better. your right in seeing what maybe the meaning but, i like to just feel it, let it sink real down low and make you feel....angry and all those feeling music gives you.
slickmagic 2 years ago
The words(lyrics) are subjective, that's what I believe. Someone might take it spiritual, another metaphorical, another literally, etc.
Armeniacolombia29 2 years ago
I like your idea of listening to it while "walking down the street". I live in the country, lake view, in The Netherlands, but I can imagine that with the sky coloured like in "Seven", and being in a particular state of mind in a 21st century megalopolis, it combines to make you feel, well, depressed, but at the same time impressed by the music.
borselva 2 years ago
Thats Right also. JOHNNY CASH FOREVER! I always thought of this song being about him, in general. Searching for god.
slickmagic 2 years ago
The most inspiring song I ever heard.If this song don't heal ya nothin will.
leiberfrasmilch 2 years ago 14
@leiberfrasmilch
I got some good healing from this song, and from other really big sources ; )
planes3333 1 year ago
@planes3333 Yeah,keep training.Body ,mind and spirit.
leiberfrasmilch 1 year ago
@leiberfrasmilch
thanks
planes3333 1 year ago