@theREALhaiaix3 And I did buy this song because I heard it on Youtube by one of the most under-appreciated bands in history and for a great cause. Thank you uploader, you are a part of a solution that can also be a problem. Luckily, your actions do not sway the pendulum in either direction for that is the job of your listeners.
That's exactly what you're doing. The only thing you buy when you buy an album, especially these days with official digital downloads, is the ability to listen to the music on demand. If someone wants to listen to the music without paying for it, they can use your video. It undermines the entire concept of a recording as a product.
That being said, I'd never heard of this charity or band before ten minutes ago.
@lolsillymadchristian if someone wants to donate to charity, this isn't going to stop them. i think it's pathetic that people have now come to equate browsing youtube (or even downloading from itunes) and owning a collection of music. what undermines the concept of recordings as products is "digital downloads."
@pce81z People were pirating long before anyone offered official digital downloads because they felt entitled to anything that could possibly be sent over the internet for free.
I don't see how a digital download could undermine the concept of a recording as a product anyway when the thing being offered for download is the product. The problem is inbreds saying "I aint payin 4 no FILES" and then stealing them. Or listening to them on Youtube.
@lolsillymadchristian what i mean is that an mp3 or any other file of which a million copies can freely be made is not a real or proper product. downloading them by any means is not owning a product nor is it stealing a product, nor is it stealing anything at all.
I agree with Manatositesigure, you should probably take this down honestly.. It's kinda disrespectful to the charity. If people want this song, they should buy the extremely inexpensive album.
@Milkthief It's not like I'm giving the song away here, it's here for people to view. It's entirely up to them whether or not they want to purchase the song or not. It's not like this video is giving it away.
@Milkthief With all due respect, anyone that wants to support Japan through purchasing this track will do it regardless of whether or not it's hosted on YouTube. Not to mention the description says to download it, like Chaibiss said, it's up to the user and this video in no way affects someone's decision to do so... quite the opposite, as it's alerting people to the cause. I'm a Coaltar of the Deepers fan and I had no idea this song existed until now, so don't undermine its effectiveness.
I'm not going to buy this song because I can listen to it here on youtube.
theREALhaiaix3 5 months ago
@theREALhaiaix3 And I did buy this song because I heard it on Youtube by one of the most under-appreciated bands in history and for a great cause. Thank you uploader, you are a part of a solution that can also be a problem. Luckily, your actions do not sway the pendulum in either direction for that is the job of your listeners.
slushymermaid666 1 month ago
"It's not like I'm giving the song away here"
That's exactly what you're doing. The only thing you buy when you buy an album, especially these days with official digital downloads, is the ability to listen to the music on demand. If someone wants to listen to the music without paying for it, they can use your video. It undermines the entire concept of a recording as a product.
That being said, I'd never heard of this charity or band before ten minutes ago.
lolsillymadchristian 5 months ago
@lolsillymadchristian if someone wants to donate to charity, this isn't going to stop them. i think it's pathetic that people have now come to equate browsing youtube (or even downloading from itunes) and owning a collection of music. what undermines the concept of recordings as products is "digital downloads."
pce81z 4 months ago
@pce81z People were pirating long before anyone offered official digital downloads because they felt entitled to anything that could possibly be sent over the internet for free.
I don't see how a digital download could undermine the concept of a recording as a product anyway when the thing being offered for download is the product. The problem is inbreds saying "I aint payin 4 no FILES" and then stealing them. Or listening to them on Youtube.
lolsillymadchristian 4 months ago
@lolsillymadchristian what i mean is that an mp3 or any other file of which a million copies can freely be made is not a real or proper product. downloading them by any means is not owning a product nor is it stealing a product, nor is it stealing anything at all.
pce81z 4 months ago
@pce81z So in other words you admit to being part of the problem. Thanks, that was easy.
lolsillymadchristian 4 months ago
@lolsillymadchristian nope.
pce81z 4 months ago
I hope you don't remove this video because of this guy; I would block him for the incessant nagging, personally.
Renulph 7 months ago
@Renulph Nah, I wasn't intending to even if the pestering continued.
Chaibiss 7 months ago
I agree with Manatositesigure, you should probably take this down honestly.. It's kinda disrespectful to the charity. If people want this song, they should buy the extremely inexpensive album.
Milkthief 7 months ago
@Milkthief It's not like I'm giving the song away here, it's here for people to view. It's entirely up to them whether or not they want to purchase the song or not. It's not like this video is giving it away.
Chaibiss 7 months ago 4
@Chaibiss なるほど。あなたの考えはわかりました。
あなたの他の投稿動画は私自身の好みにも合っていて好きです。
いろんな人に好きな音楽を聴いてもらうのは悪影響ではなく、むしろそのアーティストの宣伝効果になり良い影響をおよぼすと思います。
しかし、しつこくなってしまいますが、今回のこれはチャリティのアルバムであるということをもう少しだけ考えてほしい。
自分には削除を依頼する権利はなにもないのに色々書いてすみません。
manatositesigure 7 months ago
@Milkthief たとえこの動画が消されなかったとしても、同じ意見を述べてくれる人がいてくれてとてもうれしいです。 ありがとうございました
manatositesigure 7 months ago
@Milkthief With all due respect, anyone that wants to support Japan through purchasing this track will do it regardless of whether or not it's hosted on YouTube. Not to mention the description says to download it, like Chaibiss said, it's up to the user and this video in no way affects someone's decision to do so... quite the opposite, as it's alerting people to the cause. I'm a Coaltar of the Deepers fan and I had no idea this song existed until now, so don't undermine its effectiveness.
Renulph 7 months ago 3
このアルバムは日本のために海外のアーティストがたくさん参加してくれているチャリティのアルバムです。１５曲も入っててたった９００円です。この動画の曲はdeepersの曲なので海外アーティストのものではありませんが、収録曲を載せることは日本復興を応援してくれている海外の方々にとても失礼な行為だと思います。投稿動画を見る限り日本のものが多いのでchaibissさんは日本の方だと思いますが、自分の国を応援してくれる人たちの恩を仇で返す気ですか？
色々書いてしまいましたが、悪意で載せたものではないこともわかってますし、もしかしたら販売促進のためにのせたのかもしれませんが、itunesで試聴は１分30秒もできるのでこの動画は消していただきたいです。 今の時代、どんな曲もすぐにネット上に流れてしまい、この曲も他の場所で流れてしまっているかもしれませんが、チャリティが目的の物を流してしまうのはあまりにひどいと思います。 もうたくさん出回ってしまっているかもしれませんが、たまたまこの動画を見つけてしまったので消していただきたいです。 長文失礼しました。
manatositesigure 7 months ago
Thank you for sharing this! I love it.
finstertraum 7 months ago