Have You Ever?

[Kurolchi]

Here's some food for thought: the song is something no one should ever use with Doctor Who. It just doesn't feel right.

[DoctorAndRose4ever]

Drose 4 ever!

[living6dead6doll]

aw love it great vid and song choice

[darkhuntressamanda]

Bloddy brilliant... efffing fantastic.. wonderfully amazing, and just PERFECT.... U get a million stars!! <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 -^_^-

[topliff12345]

lovely vid, went straight into my doctor who playlist....thanks !

[paigehobo]

god...that episode(doomsday) still gets me. absolutely every time. even now when we know what happens afterwards, it still hits me. cruel, well acted, heart wrenching stuff. I found this video when it was newish and fell in love with it. in fact, it helped me fall in love with the show all the way from canada- it hadn't played yet here. somewhere there is a comment from me elsewhere. but i wanted you to know, that now and then, i honestly keep coming back to this video.  it is that good!

[MKTrny]

gosh this reminds me of and old friend I had.

[erishkigel2012]

great vid about doctor & rose!

my mum sobbed when she saw the sad bits.

[InkyButtercup]

I think I'm going to cry, that was so sad!

Great video.

[slishslash100]

omg this is so amazing thank you!

[Doran345]

If anyone has Billie pipers contact details please get in touch. I have to marry her. k. thanks :)

[irocktvyeah]

i shred a tear and i bow my head david and rose rock socks yeah love you david tennant xxxx

[NatalieB95]

i love billie!! I cried wen she left - came bk and wen she left again!! shes just SO amazing! I LOVE HERR! <3

[DWandBPgirl]

Favorited! I was so close to tears at the end... poor Rose/ Doctor! Thanks for the make!

XXRoseXX

[mcrxloverx92]

woah. very very good.

[vickyroxdam]

i ♥ this song!! xxx

[mcflybabe1991]

amazing!

[Morethanjustaplum]

So sad I cried!!

[sUmmerRain810]

Wow, I absolutely love this one! So beautiful... and the song goes perfectly with the clips you've used! Brilliant done!

[piperandtennantmad]

that was gr8 and it was brilliantly put 2gether, superb! =]

[LearnAboutMe101]

Luv it, luv it, luv it, I HOPE THE DOCTOR AND ROSE SNOG IN THE LAST EP! lol

[Kayeness94]

Waow, love the song and the video. I never thought about that song and Doctor Who together before now! its absolutely brilliant <3

[abbeysimo1994]

thats brill thanks for uploading

[SashaSteps]

wow!!!!

i luv it!!!!

the clios fit perefectly

[TheMasterssidekik]

I've just read all these messages, and it looks like your vid made everything go into 'think-mode'. LOL. XD Anyways, great video, and I don't care how Rose comes back. =D I'm more interested to see how she goes, 2bhonest.

[shimmergirl1800]

i think the doctor and rose being separated television or otherwise, that i've ever seen. over a year later and it still upsets me. the look of agony on his face when the lever slips out of her hands, how he never gets to finish telling her that he loves her, and she never gets to hear it. how a universe separates them and none of it was their choice! it is sooo sad! i miss them so dearly, so thanks again so much! apparently that is talkin about the master who wil cum

[paigehobo]

wow almost all of that comment was cut and pasted right from one that i made a few months ago...glad to see you agree, but isn't that an odd thing to do?

[CassandraMotou]

that is... soul-shredding T_T it physically aches, i tell you. the day she comes back (and its been announced officially, thank you), i will scream for joy, i swear. faved and 5*ed

ps: the audio is a tad bit jarring (i think its the volume. her sucking in a breath sounds rather like static in my headphones) at 2:06, but it works quite well at the end with "Rose Tyler--" *shrugs* ah well, lovely anyway

[nkri2]

whats the name of the song?

[themadonnalover]

Rubbish song listen to real black soul not cheap white imitators

[fizzypop94]

this made me cry-in a sad way :'[

good vid-uve a fab job!!

itz in mi favourites.

xxx

[Aimeetheechidna]

i havnt rated this vid in years so i still think its really sweet

[paigehobo]

i think the doctor and rose being separated has to be one of the saddest pieces of film-television or otherwise, that i've ever seen. over a year later and it still upsets me. the look of agony on his face when the lever slips out of her hands, how he never gets to finish telling her that he loves her, and she never gets to hear it. how a universe separates them and none of it was their choice! it is sooo sad! i miss them so dearly, so thanks again so much!

[Toonsforever]

haven't this in ages and it's one of my favs

[121dancinbeanaho]

very nice vid but gggrrrrrr... s club suck!

[Aimeetheechidna]

love it all great song and vid luvvvv it how cute

[Aimeetheechidna]

Teenys so cuteeeeeeeee his smile is so cute and he has a twinkle

[Aimeetheechidna]

im happy that rose is coming back in the new series

[121dancinbeanaho]

no she's not, donna is then martha's goining in half way

[Aimeetheechidna]

everyones sayin it and i allso looked it up because in the series just gone the doctor crashed the titanic and the first doctor eva said that when he does crash the ship something lost will come back so NUH which is rose

[121dancinbeanaho]

apparently that is talkin about the master who wil cum bak coz of that ring thing lucy picked up... who knows... we cood both b wrong. wil b disappointed if its talkin bout martha coz we already no that she'll b bak.

[Toonsforever]

she gonna be in the next ep

[Toonsforever]

no they don't

[RitsusDarlingGirl]

OMG, tragicness! The whole Doctor/Rose thing is so depressing. And I love every minute of it! Don't get me wrong, I'm sad she's not going to be around anymore and everything, but with the amount of fanfiction their big romantic seperation has spawned, I'm going to be busy for a very, very long time.

[tamjee13]

great video, music really goes and the whole things flows perfectly! well done zombiekitty666!

[TeddyBears2007]

Great video!!

[slutinthetruck]

Their relationship is the best ever shown on T.V and I hope that rumour is true cos he will obviously pick rose yay!!!

[livvylove02]

all i can do is cry when they spilt i hope rose comes back i was told the doc has to choose between rose n martha not sure if its true though

[scouseemo91]

David Tennat- the best yet. Love the vid, it's so sad. I miss Rose, though.

[zcatz]

I didn't see the minor ghost clips. I loved it, I don't really like S Club Seven but you just made the clips make the song sound amazing

[highgirl12]

well done

I hoped u did that in the ending!!

Thanks

It reminds me of my grandpa

Touching song

[justbeen12]

aww still as gd as ever lol gr8 job xxxx

if any1 here likes lost then please check out my videos

thanx xxx

[dwsgurl]

omg, that will always be my fave fan clip video thing. Its so beautiful. i love it. thank u so much for making it.

[proudveggie]

Aww

As a dedicated Dr Who and DT fangirl, I am not ashamed to say that yes, I cried at the end of that series

And yes, I did cry a littl at this video

Gd work...gd choice of song

xxx

[paigehobo]

i truely believe that the end of doomsday (except for the part where donna comes in at the end) is one of the saddest, most heartbreaking moments of television ever. we get to love both characters, and we love that they love eachother, and then they are torn appart and we are left with a crying girl and a broken man...its horrible! but beautiful! thanx for the vid i've watched it an obsene # of times

[billiepipercrazy77]

wat ghost bits?

[zombiekitty666]

at about 2:13/2:14ish there's one - just after the sound clip where the doctor says "You can't" and then it changes to the clip from new earth and i think there's another near one of the world clips...*checks*...yeah, around 2:28 between the clip of the doctor holding out his hand in doomsday and the clip of the earth from the xmas special - Ghost clips are just when a clip has a single frame from a different shot caught in the clip...if that makes any sense

[doctorwhomad4eva]

i miss rose :((( bwi bwi rose wuv wu xxx

[cazzykay23]

i LOVE THIS VIDEO IT SO CUTE LOVE THE SHOW

[CamdenPirate]

omg! that was so sad!

[doctorwhomad4eva]

im crying like mad perfect song gr8 job but upseting

[ral167]

this is upseting

[JJWill]

pretty good

well done

[isaakkk]

TOUCHING

[vickyvicster]

this is another brillant perfomance by the creator..

wow

you make some really nice shit

really nice...

[Brianette]

That vid is SO awesome! I Luv it!

[1luvme2]

omg wot a brilliant song 2 go wiv all the clips - well dun

[torchwood92]

i love the show drwho n i love this song xx

[WiccanBird]

gimme a couple of days and I'll post a video response *rubs hands* i like inspiration lol

[WiccanBird]

oh my god ... I think this is the first music video to ever make me cry *sniffle* thank you so much for making it *hugs*

[TwinkPenny]

omg omg made me cry!

I love the Doctor & Rose man!

I missed the last 2 episodes though :'(

[timewitch]

Where did you get the clips from?

[Phoenyxgold16]

That was beautiful. I can't help but cry.

[alittlemoresonic]

I loved that. What a gorgeous video. I must admit, I was slightly sceptical about the song choice but it worked brilliantly. Nice job.

[ellabella2208]

absoulatly brill made me bring a tear to my eye

luved it

[cazzykay23]

what a tuly sad video it rock and made me caird twic

[TheDoctor10]

Fantastic :D

[PeredhilLover]

It's really cool, but it cuts off after one minute...

[zombiekitty666]

it's a problem with you tube, it's happened to me watching a couple of vids - try refreshing, or it could just need to finish loading maybe

[PeredhilLover]

Okay thanks :D

[TheBritishGothic]

It takes a lot to make me cry...Really. And...I cried...I really wish that they could meet each other again

[NewWhoFan]

That was beautiful and sad at the same time.

[MaskedRomance666]

OMG AMAZING!

[roxzchemical]

you made me cry but thank you for that vid it was beautiful

[cloudsofgreen]

Bravo! =(

[fopsrule]

i love the song and i love the clips but i hate u for making it so sad u made me cry no i loved it i really did thankyou

[mcraider]

In tears! God I'm gonna miss Billie so much. Thank you for sharing

[applegrassdude]

I used to be absolutely MAD about that song...THIS VID IS FANTASTIC =D

[iluvdavidtennent101]

i cried 10 times after rose left dr who cuz ive gt it on dvd but uve made me cry again now

[doctorwhobrothers]

Loved it. Crying here. Can i ask where did you get the clips from?

[laurabatham]

:'(

[laurabatham]

im cryn now :'(

[xoxsibxox]

omg that was so great... I'm in tears :'(

[x0xirishchikadeex0]

*crying* OMG that was so sad

[teamTARDIS]

thats amazing :) really really good

[katecraft]

fab fab video and song. Go Doctor Who! And David is lovely as always- Beth Craft

[iluffdavidtennant]

anything that makes me cry with empathy is ma fave. This is one of them -sobs- I luff david so much!

[animalluva1]

excelllent, my favourite out of them all!

[weeblyone]

I just wastched DT in secret smile - I needed a Dr injection before switching off - thanks just what the Dr ordered!

[katecraft]

Brill video and david looks bery very prettiful as always

[doctorwholoverkenny]

where did you get the clips by the way?

[bloodmoon101]

i love this vid so much. icry every time i watch it. every time i see that last episode i cry and oh when he cries at the end i just cry and go all quiet and just cant beleive she's gone. it's very hard to make go like that. *cries continusly*

[doctorwhobrothers]

Hello, fantastic movie, can I ask where do you get the clips from? TY :-)

[doctorwhobrothers]

Fantastic video... Love it!

[PersianNicole7]

im a fan of S Club 7 and Doctor Who great Combanation!!!

[teleporter101]

very good

[jaynem89]

stunningly beautiful!i love the little wave near the end.excellent choice of music too!

[naomifunky]

Totally agree. Whoever says S Club is out-dated, they should seriously try and find a life lol!!! (No offence to anyone)

[surfergirl797979]

i agree lol beautiful

[tenluver]

I want Rose back with the Doctor! *sobs*

[surfergirl797979]

me too *sobs*

[Jezzeo0o]

does anyone think David Tennent looks prettyful?

[surfergirl797979]

hell yeah lol

[naomifunky]

Just watched it- it's brill!!! And you used some different clips to everyone else. Spot on

[naomifunky]

Yea!! S Club AND Doctor Who!! And this is before I've watched it!!

[thedohctor]

gr8, but gud if u had more clips apart from new eartg, impossible planet, doomsday and the CHILDREN IN NEED )CIN) SPECIAL!!

[zombiekitty666]

um...okay... i did use the clips that I felt went with the lyrics, but apart from Love & Monsters, School Reunion, and possibly Rise Of The Cyberman I've used clips from all the series 2 eps

[Emjola]

On the special edtion single of this, my performing arts group did the backing vocals, loads of schools did.

[Pikkonin14]

that was really good, i feel a bit teary!!!

Theres a vote in the Hello magazine to find the most attractive bloke of the month! Davids in the vote but hes 2nd right now!!!!

heres a link to the vote:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v­=SzYBh3Go97g&NR

Please vote!! Il cry if he doesnt win!!

And if you can...keep this circulating!!

[obsessive123]

great video i know all the words to the song

[brawn777]

exellent music choice one of my favourites and brings back so many memorys for me

[iluvdoctorwho]

lol brilliant n im totally in tears. Bring Rose back! :'(

[Harry4Ginny]

that song was amazingly perfect! i think that is my fave vid here on youtube. the ending of doomsday is the best acting iv ever seen, also the most emotional - using it here made me cry again!

[Charlottelovesyou]

WOW... ='(

[i0love0drose0]

*sob* aaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh! now im cryingm all over again-like i did just after i watched doomsday! its so sad! *goes back to watch again with box of tissue's*

great vid! .....though very sad!

[thedwasteam]

im blubbing now!

[jessnimrod25]

That was absolutely beautiful. I too didn't think the song would go, but it SO did. That was amazing. I've added it to my faves!

[ilovedoctorwho4eva]

aww really sweet vid, the music fitted perfectly

[BroadwayPixie]

OMG....you made me cry!!!

[iluvdoctorwho]

Wow i dont cry that much but the ending of doctor who doomsday n this video is so sad i am in tears lol

[xxkissmequickxx]

thats sooo cute! makes me wanna cry :'( i love it!

[i0love0drose0]

well you made me cry...its sop cute!

[HermioneWeasley02]

Oh my god, that song was perfect and the clips matched it perfectly!! Billiant!! :D

[drwhonerd]

im in tears :[ loved it

[kerry1980]

great video really fitting i love it

[kittenmaia]

if i cried in the ep then guess what i'm doing nw... that was beautiful. i loved it.

[sonicmyscrewdriver]

That was so cute! I didn't think the song would work with Doctor Who, but the lyrics are perfect and it's one of the best Doctor/Rose vids I've watched! *favourites vid*

[tenluver]

oh well done its great, love it :D

[fobofish92]

oh yes, this was completely perfect, the clips were good and went with the music when appropriate!:D:D:D well done!!

[Maggi137]

OMG that's so well done and touching.. Another perfect work. Thanks!

[simpleutopia]

Nice one!

[doggie101171]

love the music

http://threemaindramas.forumup­.co.uk/index.php?mforum=threem­aindramas