Nyatedts score has the first 3 phrases of the Chorale (2 bars, 2 bars, 4 bars...), followed by the deconstruction. You have the whole Chorale, then the deconstruction of the 3 phrases, followed by a reiteration of the whole chorale.
Surely this goes against the whole idea of this piece? Which, to me anyway, seems to be that Bach's original chorale is sung, and then goes rolling endlessly around the universe...
You may have a different version of the score, so accept my apology
sorry, what do you mean?
stxavierboy 10 months ago
@stxavierboy
Nyatedts score has the first 3 phrases of the Chorale (2 bars, 2 bars, 4 bars...), followed by the deconstruction. You have the whole Chorale, then the deconstruction of the 3 phrases, followed by a reiteration of the whole chorale.
Surely this goes against the whole idea of this piece? Which, to me anyway, seems to be that Bach's original chorale is sung, and then goes rolling endlessly around the universe...
You may have a different version of the score, so accept my apology
tbridge001 10 months ago
Why have you changed what Nystedt wrote?
tbridge001 10 months ago
@tbridge001 sorry, what do you mean??
stxavierboy 10 months ago
mola! :)
CharlesBabbageJR 2 years ago