Added: 4 years ago
From: jme1679
Views: 237,058
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (373)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i thought whitney is houston..

  • What is the dancer doing in 2:04???? LOL!!!!!!!

  • whitney houston ??? FUCK OFF

  • too much vibroatto ....

  • bom

  • Thumbs up if U came here thinking it was Whitney Houston.

  • Of course,No one can beat Beyonce when it comes to this song.. unh unh

  • @MultiGrony stay off the drugs, whoreyonce can't sing like whitney. No comparisons.

  • DON'T READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS.YOU WILL BE KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE.TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE.HOWEVER IF YOU DO NOT POST THIS ON AT LEAST 5 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS.NOW UV STARTED READING THIS DON'T STOP THIS IS SO SCARY.PUT THIS ON AT LEAST 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN YOUR DONE PRESS F6 AND YOUR LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS.THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT

  • That's beautiful ☺

  • This is actually good...Her dancing is great.

  • i hated the dancing

  • You sing it girl!

  • nobody can sing listen more better than beyonce.

    even in acapella she can still sing listen more powerfull and has the feelings of the song!!!!

    even charice!!!!

    beyonce's voice is very powerful.l

  • lis- sun lol

  • that dancers have the worst form I have ever seen....what's with her posture? lolol

  • I like Charice´s voice better...!

  • she is ok and she has talent no doubt.....

  • OK can people please stop comparing her to Beyonce! She clearly isnt trying to be Beyonce, she is trying to make the song her won and singing it slightly different. No one can deny that she can sing so please try to appreciate it th way she is singing it without comparing.

  • okokok!!! the singer on this video.. is very good!! but me myself i do prefer beyonce ... strictly because her voice is alot stronger and shows much more emotion within the lyrics!! but yes thumbs up to the vocalist who is singing in thsi video!! beautiful dancing too!

  • Someone sign that lady up !! Great voice :)

  • she have a great voice too but i think beyonce sing it better !!°^^

  • the dancer look stupid

  • @anyakadi : i think so too

  • good voice. not sure what pirouttes, fouettes, split leaps and retires have to do with the songs content though......

  • The singing is amazing, but the dance is to be desired. I'm very sad to see that they didn't incorporate some new age dance into the routine. So of the fluidic movements are more contemporary, but there is no alternative nature to it.

  • We went from Whitney and Amber to Mariah and Beyonce? What idiot brought it up? And why are y'all still fighting over it?

  • great performance

  • Mariah has ONE distinguishable note. That MAKES her career. Beyoncé is completely well rounded. That BREAKS Mariahs career.

  • she's so good, not perfect at the high parts but the song performance is awesome

  • why isn't she famous?

  • @dan98611155 you know mariah's fame has already end when beyonce was born in this world..mariah should be thankful ,beyonce is only giving her a space if beyonce wants to..she could erase mariah out of her way...and conquer the world of fame but ..she has to pass through with alicia first before she declare herself as the queen of all ..artist ,,,,and not to mention the asia's song bird regine velasques ..she also has the powerful voice and the range that mariah is afraid of .

  • @oOItalianBellaOo Haha oh please, don't make me laugh. Beyonce will always be second-rate as long as Mariah is still breathing. She has NOTHING on Mariah.

  • @dan98611155 you know mariah's fame has already end when beyonce was born in this world..mariah should be thankful ,beyonce is only giving her a space if beyonce wants to..she could erase mariah out of her way...and conquer the world of fame but ..she has to pass through with alicia first before she declare herself as the queen of all ..artist ,,,,and not to mention the asia's song bird regine velasques ..she also has the powerful voice and the range that mariah is afraid of .

  • Girl you can sing

  • nice voice..i liked..congratulations

  • i thought she was blac it was that good!!

  • sheep

  • She has a strong belt and would be fabulous in Musical Theater!! :) Come to NYC!

  • So bad:| Beyonce is the best...Beginning is good...but...

  • killed the song ! nobody can really sing this song only beyonce ! but you were ok i guess

  • OMG..! the voice is really shocking...

  • WOW...thats was amazing!

    The Voice...daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaamn!

    You´ve got the talent to be a world star:)

  • Beautiful!!!

  • Comment removed

  • You got Talent Whitney!! damn!! and pls ppl dnt even strt tryna compare this gal wid Bee I mean really Bee is at an advantage coz shez got years of experience and da tech dis gal did a superb job with this song made it her own didnt even try to sound like Beyonce..way to go gal u cud b da nxt diva!!!

  • thats cool!! really!! nice voice!!

  • i dont like the dancing. It would be much better with just the girl singing. would have been more classy. and what is she wearing...

  • She is ok for a white girl, but B is the BEST.

  • no discrimination dude.

  • they both rock, but why shud it even have to be about her race?? fuq!!!!

  • DAMN GREAT! I never thought that a chick like that could have so much soul in her voice. damn great!!!!!

  • very very very good!

  • brilliant...

  • wow whitney can really sing!!

  • ???????????????

  • che brave

  • this was really good except i think the dancing needed to be harder and more emotional

    but they are both extremelyy TALENTED (((=

  • this is amazing=]

  • Someone get this girl signed up!

    She does need a few masterclasses from the like of Celine or Whitney but she's still one of the best singers I've heard of in a while.

    Remember - shes an amateur singing at a professional level

    She still sounds 100% better than the likes of Christina as she proves she can do it live - If thats how she sounds live she would sound bloody amazing recorded

  • very good!

  • Wow. This is really good. Keep up the good work ladies. Really good. :)

  • Charice made her sound ameteur!

  • A great singer takes the original beyond (and/or re-invents) the most popular version's perameters. Check Aretha's take on Ben E. King's "Spanish Harlem." Or Sam Cooke's take on Nat King Cole's gorgeous, if more traditional reading of "For Sentimental Reasons." Even Faith Hill's version of "Take A Little Piece of My Heart," as opposed to Joplin's (Originated b Aretha's sis, Erma, BTW) shows how true artists are radicals. The ear hears something different; musically heretical. Heart/soul follows.

  • Honestly couldnt have said it better myself...thats a true artist..not just the voice but being able to turn the voice into an instrument and understand its use

  • Beautiful voice, but wtf are you wearing!?

  • This is not whiteney!

  • wow

  • That girl is SOOOOO not 15!!! She's really good.. The dancers a great dancer but the singing and the dancing really don't go together!! =] x

  • Is she singing?? I thought she reading... Juz check out charice version.. 100x better than her... Go Charice.....

  • someone slap that dancer!!!!!!!

  • Nossa ela dança muito !!!!!!

  • With a stupid interpretative ballet, who won't watch with their mouth open? I think the dancer is crazy LOL. Her voice is good but the dancer, very irritating

  • wow amazing...this voice is so amazing...

  • I like Beyonce's voice better...!

  • hahaha I think everyone does!

    she is good though

  • @sranangirl really? beyonce is a world wide superstar, this girl is 15 years old. give her some credit! she has an amazing voice.

  • Don't like Beyonce much.. But THIS is great... U gonna be a Star Whitney... This is Fabolous... Just Awesome... Wish I had your voice... And the dancer is amazing too... This Duett is fantastic... GREAT GREAT compliment to both of you

  • you're an idiot

  • great singer!

  • 1:53 hmmm

  • I would like to see how she does in the original key. This is easier to sing since it's lower.

  • wow you are wonderful :0)

  • its not beyonce s voice, and im happy for it, her voice is more rough, i like it. and the dancer is awsome, i was watching it with my mouth open, cool performance, i would be proud

    didi

  • woooooow O.O

    first i think its beyonces voice..till i saw whitney!

  • she betta sag!!

  • SAANNGG gurl!!!

  • She's great. I love this song.

  • Whitney is singing on stage, it's just not Whitney Houston))

  • Where is Whitney?

  • no soul lol

  • Stunning voice, even more so if she's only 15!

  • the singer is amazing!

    not sure about the dancer though ah!

  • You kept like getting in front of each other it looked very badly choreographed but the singing was quite good x

  • great voice. but old fashioned.

  • wth I was looking 4 Whitney Houston...

  • Decent job singing. Learn how to move on stage tho. You should never walk in front of another performer or turn your back to the audience.

  • MAGNIFIQUE VOIX ;);)

  • is the whitney from antm?

  • The singing part is very very good but the dancing one lacks grace.

  • i thought yall were so good...congrats... the girl singing is awesome!! dont know if i believe the whole 15 and 17 yr old thing but still it was great...good job..best i have heard on here so far...

  • superrrrrrr

  • I think that the person singing is very talented. No one can sing that song as well as beyonce did but that not what she was trying to do. If she gets some lessons she would get better. So do your thing girl. that was great!!!

  • i can sing better than u no offense and im only 12 well i get paid to sing so im not lying :p

  • rite karen ur sooooooo brilliant at dancin wheres ur vid ?!u a busker?

  • i said singing not dancing so dont be offended. srry if dat sounds mean not trying to be

  • This performance is clearly good. So I don't think there was any need for this comment was there? Why would a 12 year old get paid to sing?

  • uhh excuse me then i guess dats how good i am lol jkjkjk =) i m just saying that maybe she should get voice lessons....

  • wow i cant beleive i fell for this

  • SWEETIE YOUR NO BEYONCE ^_^

  • that was very great singing. no need to b rude.

  • Agreed jeeze that was so rude and mean. She is a very talented girl.

  • it was aight. girlie singing needs more practice. she's real pitchy and needs to learn voice control and how to act out a song.

  • yeah

  • cood singin but no good dancing

  • shakky..shakky..

  • Great job, this was so well done!

  • I think that your performance was outstanding and I very much so enjoyed it. Keep on singing and performing. perfect practice makes for perfect performances. You are on the right path for success.

  • ?? I click on this thinkin this was Whitney Houston.. And its not.. LOL.. But your voice is amazing reguardless!! :-)

  • hunny yew sound hella better than beyonce. your very goood!!

    serously

  • verrrry pitchy at some parts. if you cant sing the note how its supposed to be sung..dont even try.

    oh and theres no way shes 15. eeek..

  • sorry she does NOT sound black lol

  • V-GURD :D X

  • You are pretty darn good!!! Keep it up!!!

    -Sheila

  • the 15 year old girl looks like shes 20

  • Girl You have a voice beyond your years

  • I was doing my homework when I listend to this song so I didn't really look to the monitor. I thought the singing girl was a black girl ^^ great donee :D

  • woaaaa goosebumps!! that was so amazing!!

  • wow!!

  • very good. You go girl. You are amazing. Practice makes perfect.

  • whitney needs a lil more work if she wanna/try to sing this song or any of beyonce's songs....she was alright though.

  • no one cares how old she is. what does that have to do with her outfit. I said she was white because guess what she's white. If she was blue I woulda said blue. People are gonna say things regardless so you get a life.

  • Is looking for another singer in the video of another color - what's up with the "white girl" profile? I guess people enjoy saying "nasty" comments about 15 year olds. Get a life!

  • what does that have to do with her outfit?

  • that "white girl" is the 15 year old Whitney houston at a talent contest. =)

  • the dancer ruined it

  • You are both great , excellent performance on both sides.

  • *_* la voce è a dir poco stupenda..il balletto beh ecco risulta un pò ridicolo xD però veramente davvero complimenti e complimenti x la voce *_*

  • well i dont wanna sound mean but Amber is not that great! Im a dancer too. I did ballet for 11 years. and i know whats good and whats not! She's ok. but not great! And Whitney, yes she's good! she sang really good! this song is hard and she did very good ^^ good luck in ur label auditions ^^ I think Amber have skills to get better! just a lil more work! =) bye (and dont take my comment as rude or whatever..im just giving my opinion)

  • she isnt doing ballet shes doing contemporary

  • I know...but still she needs to work a lil more! but she's young so that wont be a problem! she'll get better im sure! =)

  • That dance is funny! But I bet it took a lot of practice! WOW! Nice Vid. :D

    --Watch my show! ;D

  • this is just incredible.. both of them.. and her voice is just.. wow!

  • i like it but HATED the purple outfit.. makes her look fat.

  • this is not whitney!!!

  • How would you know?!

  • sorry i think you mean whitney huston :)

  • what do u mean by that?

  • this is not whitney huston ,right?

  • No, it's not. she's just a teenage girl with amazing talent who i hope gets noticed!! :)

  • :)))

  • beyonce is better but whitney is good too

  • u werent dat good b!!

    :(

  • bad voice but she is pretty

  • WOW! SHE CAN BA-LOW!

  • Wow!!!

    wonderful!!

    ~Treasure MaDonna

  • ambers ok not amazing.

  • i almost shitted myself. i thought whitney houston was singing beyonce's Listen.

    this girl did a pretty good job too, although a little shaky.

  • Great job to both women. I can't dance or sing, so I know how hard it is to do both....

  • wat is with the dancing??? it ruined the entire performance.

  • OMG YOU ARE GREAT...I thought the dancing was kinda of wierd but the singing was AMAZING!!! AWSOME JOB!!!!

  • the singing was ok, the dancing not all that great.

    it was missing the oomph and the extensions sucked. but good singing. :D

  • I WAS THERE!!!!!!!!!

    :)

  • I WAS THERE!!!!!!!!!

    :)

  • me too me tooo omg woooooooooooooooooo

  • wow that dude could sing !!! good work

  • that was great :-)

    well done !

  • I was surprised cause I was exspecting Whitney Houston lol, but of course... it wasn't... but it is good, the dancing was OK but the sing was great!@ :)

  • i got chills, great job!

  • wow amazing well done xx

  • sounds good for a white girl

  • Well,she is OK.

  • This was Amazing,on both parts!.

  • beautiful

  • both are very talented

  • both are very talented

  • O.M.G

    wow

    that was great!!

    =]]