I think he has never learned Chayanat because a) he didn't talk about the rag at all b) it's not a chota rag - on the contrary it's a sampurna-sampurna jati rag c) there is nothing small or simple about the rag because of swoops from p to r and vice versa. Also, if one forgets and lays emphasis on r, m in uttarang one can easily end up playing nat instead of chaya nat.
Amazing how a Ustad can make such goof ups. they should know their khayals and raags. Shujaat really disaapointed me. At least when he played the Nat Bihag khayal he should have guesed what he was doing and corrected himself. I have also seen another young musician from this family play Nat Bhairav in front of me on sitar and call it Charukeshi,
Baayia na dharo is charukeshi!! Ustadji I am disappointed....at the best I am turning a deaf ear looking the other way and attributing this as a mistake by DD crew!
Shujat is talking of chayanat and playing the famous bandish in natbihag. Again he is showing a film song based on Charukeshi as Chayanat. Not only that but he mentionsMohe Bhul gaye sawaria as Jogia anf Bhairav where as it is based on Kalingada. Is this ignorance or arrogance? and what is the relevance of that Russian humor ? just great !!
Khansaheb, you speak of Chhayanat, then sing a khayal in Nat Bihag as an example, and finally scan all film music and find a song in Charukeshi to demonstrate Chhayanat on national television. In my opinion, AIR and Doordarshan should ask you to re-audition if you have to maintain your grade.
I think he has never learned Chayanat because a) he didn't talk about the rag at all b) it's not a chota rag - on the contrary it's a sampurna-sampurna jati rag c) there is nothing small or simple about the rag because of swoops from p to r and vice versa. Also, if one forgets and lays emphasis on r, m in uttarang one can easily end up playing nat instead of chaya nat.
r8rdarklord 1 month ago
Amazing how a Ustad can make such goof ups. they should know their khayals and raags. Shujaat really disaapointed me. At least when he played the Nat Bihag khayal he should have guesed what he was doing and corrected himself. I have also seen another young musician from this family play Nat Bhairav in front of me on sitar and call it Charukeshi,
hamidm81 1 month ago
Baayia na dharo is charukeshi!! Ustadji I am disappointed....at the best I am turning a deaf ear looking the other way and attributing this as a mistake by DD crew!
bmukh 3 months ago
Shujat is talking of chayanat and playing the famous bandish in natbihag. Again he is showing a film song based on Charukeshi as Chayanat. Not only that but he mentionsMohe Bhul gaye sawaria as Jogia anf Bhairav where as it is based on Kalingada. Is this ignorance or arrogance? and what is the relevance of that Russian humor ? just great !!
deepakkdad 4 months ago
Khansaheb, you speak of Chhayanat, then sing a khayal in Nat Bihag as an example, and finally scan all film music and find a song in Charukeshi to demonstrate Chhayanat on national television. In my opinion, AIR and Doordarshan should ask you to re-audition if you have to maintain your grade.
SuperNalawade 4 months ago
@SuperNalawade Agree with you !! He has made goof-ups in some other episodes like Bhupali and Jhinjhoti also....
nehal012 4 months ago