I like this version better I think. The German language definitely makes it sound darker but that's because of it's erieness. I also know much more about the japanese language and how beautiful it is, mostly because asian languages don't have latin roots. Anyway, like the original and like this too.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
NO!!!!! Perfectly ruined! Japanese language can never replace the power of the German language! The thing about japanese language is that they make the speaker or singer sound "cute" but in fact they are just annoying. That's, I think, how you get anime cartoons that are drawn to always look cute and talk cute too....
HATE THIS VIDEO VERY MUCH!!!! The ending sounded like a samurai trying to play the Erl King...
I do not like this version. The japanese language does not put the dramatic emphasis on the ending of the sentences like in German. In the german language there is so much vocal play at minute 2:00 that the japanese language is not taking advantage of. Also, the voice does not seem to place much difference between all the the people that this song has. Something I do like is the overacting. Really, I do lke it.
One might try to appreciate a Japanese version of Erlkönig, but this particular one has nothing do neither with Goethe nor with Schubert. The lady (if it is a woman at all) is a fine actress but she has absolutely no voice to tackle the piece. Her going hysterical doesn't exactly help the matter.
Japanese people are usually fairly successful with European classical music, but not when such travesties are concerned.
I think it is quite demanding to perform "Der Erlkönig" in another language. I really appreciate the japanese performance because it shows the universality of music and thought. No matter where you are from, music is about feelings and thus this video reminds me about it.
Are you people serious? This is just awful, according to the rest of the posts-if they are serious-I must be wrong. Really, this just sucks. I have listened to this 3 times and I cannot understand the praise.
Ich finde, es ist immer noch Schubert, ein bisschen an die Zeit angepasst. Ob es gesanglich gut ist, ist eine andere Frage. Man muss der Dame aber lassen, dass sie die verschiedenen Charaktäre sehr gut differenzieren kann.
@srg2457 how would miking someone change their pitch unless it was going through a voice modifier? And it's not going through one, she's a female tenor.
I wonder how much they had to change the story in Japanese. In german it's downright gruesome...if you know what's really going on. But, I dont' know what to make of this... it just depends on if they are expressing the same story as the german version. I have no knowledge of japanese, so based on her gestures I will assume that the story is pretty close.
音楽中めっちゃ笑いかけたわwwww
めっさあぶなかったww
先生めっちゃおもれぇしwwマジやべぇwww
gottotou0716 2 days ago
午前3時に聴いたらめちゃ怖いよ(´;ω;`)ウッ...
fjst3ts7871 1 week ago
I'm sorry but this plain sucks!
MOZ1175 1 month ago 4
一目でアレは魔王って言い切った坊やがすご
airiAQ 1 month ago
ドイツ語よりも分かりやすい歌詞でいいですね\(^o^)/
batomin2011 1 month ago
これ学校の音楽の時間流れてた・・
マジ怖い
yunyan0617 1 month ago
@ueyann
お父さんが冷静なのは子供を落ち着けるためだそうです。お父さんにも魔王は見えてるらしいですよ。
Rebornlove777 2 months ago
@Rebornlove777 さん どうやら違うらしいですよ子供が病気で幻覚を見ているらしいです。
HAYATON6 1 month ago
今日、音楽の授業でやったけど、、、。宝塚っt3
sani5614 2 months ago
魔王って子供にしか見えてないからお父さんはこんなに冷静なんだよね?
ueyann343 2 months ago
テスト勉強に利用させてもらってます!意味が解るし音楽も楽しめる!
Leon29531 2 months ago
おとうさん!!
きづいてあげて!!
katsuhiron1 2 months ago
宝塚ってこんなにすごいとは・・・。
驚き!
歌唱力がすごすぎるっっ!
rinnrinn4747 2 months ago
Fascinating performance!
10 points!
IlDulcamara 2 months ago
鳥肌立っちゃった(*_*)!
mayuri014 2 months ago 2
学校の授業で習ったのと全然ちがう…
こっちの方が分かりやすい
reoking132 2 months ago
子供パートの時面白い
Guran256 2 months ago
I'm German and i love this interpretation!!
it's by far one of the most sentimental and strongest interpretation i've heard so far
plus i find it really interesting hearing the poem i learned as a child in japanese xD
iGourry 3 months ago 2
鳥肌が…
Leon29531 3 months ago
懐かしいな
rugia111 4 months ago
音声なしでもどの場面か分かる
すごすぎ
bakahakazehikanai 5 months ago
いや~~~~~~すごい
!
bakahakazehikanai 5 months ago
宝塚ですか? 最高です!!
takada55 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
宿題の参考になりますw
2時48分投稿w
はっきり言ったら今日が始業式です。
ヤバイ><w
yuuya7878 5 months ago
吸い込まれてしまう。 すごい。
sohta951012 5 months ago
表情一つ一つ芸術作品だ
表情で歌詞が分かる。
hoje153 5 months ago
that guy looks like a girl with the make up on
TheAce1082 5 months ago
@TheAce1082 Its a girl
Vinvolve 5 months ago
感動・・・
Eimi708 6 months ago
⇩去年習った
好きだわ
1205lav 6 months ago
中学の音楽鑑賞の中で一番印象に残ってる
tanaka358 6 months ago
Lol they translated it!
SecondAgeOfReason 7 months ago
怖い
FUJIQ229FUJIKYU 7 months ago
鳥肌立った・・・
JMSDF0426 7 months ago 3
姿月さん、本当に凄すぎます……
takada55 7 months ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
何かオモロイwwwwwwww
miryumotoki3 7 months ago
何かオモロイwwwwwww
miryumotoki3 7 months ago
懐かしい、中学の音楽で歌ったような・・・。あの時はよくわからなかったが今となっては素晴らしいとおもうばかりです。
0001ks 7 months ago
姿月あさとの歌・・・感動です。凄いの一言
vinvincentjp 7 months ago 2
演技力www
RYO0527XX 7 months ago
子供テラカワイソスw
RYO0527XX 7 months ago
どうしてこんなに聞き取りやすい発音ができるのかしら~
さすがですね
こわかった!
p1nk27 7 months ago
クラシックのドイツ語のしか聴いたことなかったけど
これもすごくいいですね(o^-')b グッ!
otanuko 8 months ago
美しく華麗に息子の発言を流す父親……しつこく誘惑する魔王…
airiAQ 8 months ago
ドイツ語の方がいいな
nao2311sai 8 months ago
下の方の人うけるwめっちゃ笑ってるw
chomoranmamama 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
press 3 constantly for a creepy moment
coryswaycool 8 months ago
Comment removed
coryswaycool 8 months ago
greate interpretacion!
nikolausdesimen 9 months ago
魔王パートと子供パートは迫真
鳥肌がたった
感動ではなく恐怖で
寒いくらいだ
lostota 9 months ago
Everything about this = AMAZING! I want a recording of this.
robbpeppertree 9 months ago
歌ている人の事良く分からないけど凄い。
いい声だと思う。
最初から最後まで聞き入ってしまいました。
057gnb3316sef6 9 months ago
ずんこさん上手過ぎ
魔王の時好き
yukariWnine1 10 months ago
ずんこさん上手過ぎ
yukariWnine1 10 months ago
あさとさんカッコいいなぁ
okvip1 10 months ago
魔王の宝塚ヴァージョン!!
いいかも^^
cdebussy01 10 months ago
宝塚?
NUN0610 10 months ago
メンデルスゾーンすごいな。
hasimoto0 10 months ago
ずんこ素敵
ist6040 10 months ago
歌ってる人すごい。
pikumin1209 10 months ago
Very nice performance. The result is excellent. Asato Shizuki sure is an acomplished musician. She can act and sing with "her" music.
Very beautiful.
Can anyone give me the name of this concert/play whatever? Can i find it on the net?
NightoExorcisto 11 months ago
wow great voice
michaeldmendes 11 months ago
かっこいい!
binibini729 1 year ago
日本語版怖っ
1994929ABE 1 year ago
Really great! Thanks so much for sharing! =) When did sie sing that? That was after her time with the Takarazuka Revue, right?
CaffeineClown 1 year ago
I like this version better I think. The German language definitely makes it sound darker but that's because of it's erieness. I also know much more about the japanese language and how beautiful it is, mostly because asian languages don't have latin roots. Anyway, like the original and like this too.
TheGingaBishounen 1 year ago
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA......wait....wait.....BAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH.
Thank you Japan....thank you for giving me another reason to live.
atrujill3313 1 year ago
Very nice and involving.
DorianLS 1 year ago
この曲の日本語訳いくつか聴いているが、
これがもっともよかった。
姿月あさとの歌唱力にも驚き。
mizuho4107 1 year ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
NO!!!!! Perfectly ruined! Japanese language can never replace the power of the German language! The thing about japanese language is that they make the speaker or singer sound "cute" but in fact they are just annoying. That's, I think, how you get anime cartoons that are drawn to always look cute and talk cute too....
HATE THIS VIDEO VERY MUCH!!!! The ending sounded like a samurai trying to play the Erl King...
sAmfRancIs94 1 year ago
@sAmfRancIs94
At least it's easier for Japanese to understand the meaning of this piece.
057gnb3316sef6 1 year ago
@057gnb3316sef6 True.... : /
sAmfRancIs94 1 year ago
I do not like this version. The japanese language does not put the dramatic emphasis on the ending of the sentences like in German. In the german language there is so much vocal play at minute 2:00 that the japanese language is not taking advantage of. Also, the voice does not seem to place much difference between all the the people that this song has. Something I do like is the overacting. Really, I do lke it.
HemMan3 1 year ago
教科書とCDとほとんど違う
びっくりした
katumakokuhu 1 year ago
発音が大変明瞭で、また役柄により発声をうまくコントロールしていて、ベリーグッド。
tanken615 1 year ago
Perfectly disgusting!
One might try to appreciate a Japanese version of Erlkönig, but this particular one has nothing do neither with Goethe nor with Schubert. The lady (if it is a woman at all) is a fine actress but she has absolutely no voice to tackle the piece. Her going hysterical doesn't exactly help the matter.
Japanese people are usually fairly successful with European classical music, but not when such travesties are concerned.
Spiritakis 1 year ago
@Spiritakis I think this is a good attempt of interpretation. Obviously it is not what many would expect, but I don't think is that bad.
lavm1991 1 year ago
中学校で聴いた日本語版と違う気がする。
minamiaiki05 1 year ago
@minamiaiki05
元はゲーテが書いた詩(外国語)ですので
訳す人によって若干ちがってくるようですよ
yuzawa87 1 year ago
Gerpanese.
CKChardrocka 1 year ago
ふ~、つい見入ってしまったぜ(;゜▽゜)=3
inaba5610 1 year ago 13
小さい息子がいる私、泣いてしまった・・
MrYy09 1 year ago
宝塚?
兵庫の川西にすんでるんで
よくわかる
galtutyaman 1 year ago
@galtutyaman
僕も川西ですw
hisayosi128 1 year ago
I understand that this may be demanding in a different language, but it just doesn't sound good. I want some fwied wice now,
imasharpay66 1 year ago
damn, best performance I've seen.
AchilleDebussy 1 year ago
I think it is quite demanding to perform "Der Erlkönig" in another language. I really appreciate the japanese performance because it shows the universality of music and thought. No matter where you are from, music is about feelings and thus this video reminds me about it.
apoleon2010 1 year ago
not a fan
zachdellinger 1 year ago
姿月あさとさん上手い
KURUMI117 1 year ago
Ewww!
Dunctonsteel 1 year ago
とてもいい曲です。歌詞もいいですがピアノの旋律により子供がどれだけ怖がっているか、 魔王の恐ろしさ・覇気ともいえる堂々とした気配があらわれています。
yamayamakawa1 1 year ago
Oh god...Chills...Nothing like the original but god damn...That woman can freaking SING!!!!!
VKatze 1 year ago
この曲、小学生の時に歌っていました・・・怖い内容ですよ。。
shinpyify 1 year ago
やっぱずんこさん上手い。宝塚出身のなかでも歌唱力はずば抜けてますね。そしてこれで主婦だなんて・・・・・・・
myco63 1 year ago 2
ぼうやもお父さんもかわいそう(ノД`)・゜・。
zackygacky 1 year ago
male or femal???^^
DCADAG 1 year ago
@DCADAG neither, she's femalE
fobulousfl1p 1 year ago
@DCADAG
Good question...
sixstringking6 1 year ago
学校で、やったやつを聞いたらとても、いい曲だなぁって今、おもいました。
sanzou441 1 year ago
i dont like the lyrics... but the rest omg it's amazing!
trabalhosmanuais 1 year ago
It's awful !
RomualdBoluchon 1 year ago
Vocally, she did extremely well. Even through the gestures and acting, which, if you're used to the classical singing style, is a bit much.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm pretty sure this is a Takarazuka or Takarazuka-style performance, where women play every role.
If you don't like the interpretation or the amount of emotion put into the performance, fine. But I don't see, otherwise, what's wrong with it.
insaneforstuff254 1 year ago
This sounds too light-hearted to me.
coldbirth 1 year ago
力が足りない。
masa960115 1 year ago
ストーリーがすごくて好きだなぁ~
最近、授業で習いました!
やっぱ、みなさんも中1でやるんですねぇ~^^
MoMoKa159 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
まんこ
morobaeni 1 year ago
:-/
MaestroINVY 1 year ago
中1の時の授業でこの曲、聴いた・・・!
好きです!
いいよな~((呟き
0517kyokatan 1 year ago
@0517kyokatan
俺も中1の音楽の授業で聞いた!
俺も好きです!
本当にいいですね~w
Mrmeron7 1 year ago
Wow! wunderbar !
natango62 1 year ago
what is this shit?... srlsy, what is it with asians with the overdoing of stuff?
Metalface123 1 year ago
Really terrible. In all honesty, this just shits on Schubert's Erlkönig.
insaneCHILD00 1 year ago
Are you people serious? This is just awful, according to the rest of the posts-if they are serious-I must be wrong. Really, this just sucks. I have listened to this 3 times and I cannot understand the praise.
poopypoopyhead1 1 year ago
Horror!!! :-((((
Is this a parody???
neuefreiheit 1 year ago
Very good she puts alot of emotion in the part where the Erlking told the child he will use force, I LOVE it!
CaptainDickerson 1 year ago
very very interesting! I like it!
Sehr interessante Version...das ist wunderschön..!
Will84ABA 1 year ago
That's a woman?
sixstringking6 1 year ago
@sixstringking6 ...yep
Paigesings 1 year ago
omg orchestral parts are so much more epic than piano... I particularly love 1:48. Also, epic lighting and great recording.
pondrthis 1 year ago
これ学校で歌ったわぁ。。。
tamae1997 1 year ago
掴ぁぁぁんだっ
putyopi13 1 year ago
Grandios !!!!!!!!
MrBenny1967 1 year ago
Love this performance, especially the end.
sumhimreflect 1 year ago
これと同じの学校で声だけの聴いたような気がする。
seiya170 1 year ago
ドイツ語じゃないとしっくりこない
でも日本語も素晴らしい
maryismakyo 1 year ago
日本語だと、吹くw
heisyokokawatomoya 1 year ago 4
これ学校で昨日習ったw
Siranui1000 1 year ago
と聞笑し what
LuiAlbrecht 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what a hell is this shit ? :D
BlackBurnHUN 2 years ago
@BlackBurnHUN
once again the japanese blow us away with their ridiculous transformations of classical music.......i'll never get why
PrinsTan 2 years ago 3
so am i right ?
BlackBurnHUN 2 years ago
すごい!
鳥肌たった。
MsYuka0603 2 years ago 2
「素晴らしい」の一言しか出ません・・・。
meganeclub3 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
この曲面白いですよね^^
中学で習ったんですが楽しかったので・・!
なんていうかシューベルトさんの想像力が羨ましいですw
remu722 2 years ago
WAS QUATSCHT DIE DA??????
Multiruen 2 years ago
懐かしいです!!中学1年の音楽の教科書で!!翻訳は随所やや違っておりますが「風のように馬を駆り~♪・・・」
「坊や一緒においでよ もう料理はとっくに出来ている~♪」30年前の事になってしましました(笑)
zeninohana88 2 years ago
中一のとき、日本語版を音楽の時間に聞いて、みんなで爆笑した思い出があるww
mildseven73 2 years ago 2
It's like watching Bleach the musical. Love.
CrystalFlames 2 years ago
やっぱ
ドイツ語の方がいいな
piyooko3000 2 years ago
すごい!!
kobarutosan 2 years ago 2
ずんこさんうまいっっ
kurokuro307 2 years ago
これって宝塚ですか?
kyouko103 2 years ago
この人うまい!!めっちゃしびれた。
jokerhime 2 years ago
what is this from?
Isaiah90 2 years ago
It's a German lied called "Der Erlkoing" (although these are the japanese lyrics). It's a poem written by Goethe that set to music by Schubert. :)
Offertory 2 years ago 3
デーモン閣下に歌って欲しい
KURENAIDAHH 2 years ago
this is riDICULOUS:D
MirtheP 2 years ago
This is far better than the GERMAN version. Do yo even know what is to adapt a lied from GERMAN to JAPANESE and to make it have that armony???
curutosan 2 years ago
Und das war mal Schubert...
8Eowyn 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@8Eowyn
""Und das war mal Schubert...""
Ich finde, es ist immer noch Schubert, ein bisschen an die Zeit angepasst. Ob es gesanglich gut ist, ist eine andere Frage. Man muss der Dame aber lassen, dass sie die verschiedenen Charaktäre sehr gut differenzieren kann.
scarpia1965 1 year ago
great performance!
nemesis8722 2 years ago 3
en allemand, cela eu été parfait
mais belle voix
tiarca 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
C'est vraiment nul.
princechandy 2 years ago
リアル過ぎて寒気したw
流石プロですね。
gabugabucat 2 years ago 5
Asato Shizuki is so talented. I've never heared a voice with such a big range like hers. Amazing!
DerCaptainIglo 2 years ago 24
her's??good lord...honestly, i thought she was a...guy. Even so, she magnificent
curutosan 2 years ago
@DerCaptainIglo Hard to tell what her real range is given how heavily miked she is.
srg2457 1 year ago
@srg2457 how would miking someone change their pitch unless it was going through a voice modifier? And it's not going through one, she's a female tenor.
dinkydoo46 11 months ago
WTF?!?!?! I didn't think it was possible! It's amazing! Best version I've ever heard! I can't stop listening!!!!!
Thunder00Silence 2 years ago 15
@Thunder00Silence try the version of anne sophie von otter or quasthoff ...
cellotennis 1 year ago
声での描写うまいな
hvjv1 2 years ago 9
Bravi!
chki8 2 years ago 4
子供はこのときひどい病気で熱に浮かされて
幻覚を見てしまうんですね。
arioso104329 2 years ago 2
声の使いわけがうまいな
tarou567 2 years ago 6
ちょっと教科書のとは違うな
atpee 2 years ago 3
先日学校で習ったw
zyonnkonionn 2 years ago
坊やって死んだの?
coccowatanabe 2 years ago
確か原曲の忠実な日本語訳だと
「腕の中の息子は息絶えていた」ってある
017OinA 2 years ago
Omg with all due respect it feels like Erlkönig but with a slight feel for anime and i love it!!!
ROCKGUITARMEM 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
i know all she needs to do now is to grow some cat ears and a monkey tail and she'll be perfect!!! oh wait dont forget a samurai sword
animal03181989 2 years ago
Incredible!
Awesome!
I love it!
Aleera616 2 years ago 2
僕も中一のときにならったけど、日本語バージョンは初めて聞く。すごい。でも違和感もすごい。
me0i0em 2 years ago
wow the ending is soooo much better than the german ending.
LightoYagasamiSan 2 years ago 2
this is downright nasal
HMW 2 years ago
Awesome!! Masterpiece!
forlani 2 years ago
I wonder how much they had to change the story in Japanese. In german it's downright gruesome...if you know what's really going on. But, I dont' know what to make of this... it just depends on if they are expressing the same story as the german version. I have no knowledge of japanese, so based on her gestures I will assume that the story is pretty close.
the81stviewer 2 years ago
Another great,fantastic, job by Zunko...she never gets old...thank you very much for this video
lostlover13 2 years ago 4
Damn... well done!
ROCKGUITARMEM 2 years ago
あたしこれ、中1の時に
音楽で習ったw
cherryblossaom 2 years ago
すごい、怖さが伝わってきました・・・
鳥肌立ちまくりました!
taku0311 2 years ago 5
Very strange and very fascinating!
scarpia1965 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
おとーさんww(爆
超オモロー
akazakikou