ABU TALIAB HAD FOUR SONS, TALIB, ALI, AQEEL AND JAFAR. ALI WAS FIRST WHO ACCEPTED ISLAM. LATER JAFAR ACCEPTED ISLAM. WHEN BATTLE OF BADR OCCURED, TALIB AND AQEEL FOUGHT AGAINST MUSLIMS BECAUSE THEY HAD NOT ACCEPTED ISLAM AT THAT TIME. TALIB WAS KILLED (THUS HE DIED IN THE STATE OF KUFR), AQEEL WAS MADE PRISONER. LATER AQEEL ACCEPTED ISLAM ON THE OCCASION OF HUDAIBIYA. AQEEL HAD FIVE SONS AND ONE OF HIS SONS NAME WAS YAZID AND KUNIYAT OF AQEEL WAS ABU YAZID.
the debate is not about we can ask intercession from someone, it's about whether all deads are dead or some deads are alive....y not stick to the subject?!
I request all to gain good knowledge before you make fake statements, u may misguide people in this world, but what will you do in front of Allah, you have to face the punishment and its a good news for those who is non-believers and those who misguide people about ISLAM will burn in hell forever.
Those who died for Islam they called shaheed and are alive, then why people do matam for the one who is alive and in heaven.
There is no one who can help us except Allah and we can only ask for any help in this world is to Allah, the one who died can never help us, Muhammed SAW will be there on the day of judgement and that day he will make dua for umma who were on right path of Quran & hadidth by our prophet Muhammed (SAW).When yakoob A.S sons asked their father Yakoob A.S to pray for them for forgiveness when that time he was alive. This way anyone who is alive can ask each other to make dua for each other
SYED ALI RAZA KAZMI! DO YOU NOT THINK THAT YOU AND YUR FATHER MUST BE IN PAKISTAN TO PREACH PAKI SPEAKER INSTEAD OF LIVING IN EUROPIAN COMFORTS AND CRITICISING TO PAKISTANI ZAKREEN??IS IT JUSTICE? IS IT ADEL?WHITOUT PREACHING YOU PEOPLE CRITICISNG?WHATS PROBLEM TO COME,LIVE, PREACH AND THEN CRETICISE?
Mraliwalay Allah knows eveyrhting.....he knew wut shaitan wud do.....but dont think Ali knew wut wud happen in future....because if u say Ali knew everything about the future.....u r comparing an attribute of Allah to Ali..which itself is the biggest shirk...get your logics right.....ur stupid Shia philosophy is very backward and illogical
Mraliwalay I can say the same...Abu Baker was better than a retarted imam khomeini...only because he was a person Prophet trusted in his life time.....
Mraliwalay If I was an Imam..knowing the future is really miserable for muslims because they will be united under different labels....i wud raise my swords and slit throat cuts of all the kufrs and infidels and unite muslims under 1 banner....but no reality is the beloved Ali didn't create any sect or Shias....it was stupid people and infidels who created another sect and made fabricated hadith of Ali! Remember Prophet said the upcoming 3 generations r the right 1z..n the later 1z will be doomed
Mraliwalay you do regard stupid Imam Khomeini as your ultimate leader...but the problem is you "ONLY" regard him as the ULTIMATE leader because apparently he has divine powers and can see the future...in reality he didn't even knew his own future..the difference between us muslims n u shias is u regard 1 persons ilm or opinion as the final word..where as we take advices from as many scholars as possible..because the ultimate wisdom or in your language ilm...only the Prophets had..passed by ALLAH
Abu Baker Was bad Umar was bad.....but still Ali stayed quite despite knowing the fact that future generations will always be divided. Only because he was a decent man, he thought it is wise to stay silent and let Abu Baker be the successor and let Allah's people remain divided to this day. Only because he was distinguished. Again ridiculous claim.
@qouiou123 Why allah didnt know abt Shaitan he will be missguiding human being till the day of judgement still he set him on liberty, why think of that. U r going into irrational discussion without knowing abt Ali"s charachter. He didnt want to raise the sord just 4the sake of power,in that case people could hv a good excuse to blame prophet and Ali equaly they were doing effort just for the wealth and Ali didnt like that though he agitaed on d behaviour of Abu Bakr.
MrAliwalay Be logical.....you have hadith to support...but you don't have Allah to support your stupid claim of imamate.....perhaps you don't have any logical and factual arguemen which itself shows you have no base at all rather your stupid beliefs are rooted with fabrication and infidelity.
MrAliwalay You believe in Dive Decision despite the fact that Allah never told us that there has to be an Imam always. Allah, the greatest of all, failed to convey this message through his last messenger, isn't that an insult to Allah and his decision?
MrAliwalay No matter what, accept the fact that you regard yourselves as Shias. Isn't it? I believe every Shia calls himself a Shia, or a Momin. Though it is mentioned in Quran, whoever distinguishes himself from Islam and creates his own identity or a sect in Islam, is doomed. Look at yourself, haven't you guys created an identity other than a Muslim for yourselves already??
Again you are just blindly believing less authentic hadith or perhaps manipulating the meaning. At the time of his death, or just before his death, couldn't Prophet Muhammad PBUH, Allah's messenger, get one hint from Allah or Gabriel of what Abu Baker would do after his death? Couldn't Allah give him one message in his entire life time that this man is dangerous to Islam and he will divide muslims into two? Are you kidding? Or you are being ignorant!!
MrAliwalay The fact that you don't care what he was in Prophet's life time itself separates you from Islam. Accept the fact. Learn to trust Prophet and his companions.
MrAliwalay Further, you claim Ali was divinely appointed, why isn't this concept or doctrine mentioned in Quran? The verse 17:71 doesn't really mention anything as Imams being divinely appointed and we should worship them like you do. But as I said, shias maniupulate the meaning of hadith and quran.
MrAliwalay Still you are ignoring the fact that Prophet trusted Abu Baker and the remaining calpihs till his last breath. And I thought in Islam we should trust anything that our Prophet trusts or trusted. But you Shias trust hadith, which can be fabricated.
MrAliwalay Look at your bright side, you regard Imam khomeini as your leader. Did prophet PBUH tell us to regard Imam khomeini and his decendents as our true spiritual leader? Or rather he gave us the Quran and hadith, for all of us to study it deeply and make decisions together logically? If you can't study it, take help from people who studied it, in our terms we call them Scholars. Or is it that Imam Khomeini has some divine power, just like, as you claim without any proof, Imam Ali had?
MrAliwalay For Barack Obama.....let me assure you people who are only lost regard him as a true leader. You are mixing modern day politics with religious history. We trust Abu Bakar, because Prophet trusted him his entire life. And we trust our Prophet blindly, so his trust becomes our trust. Unlike you shias who think Prophet, who had a direct connection with Allah, couldn't really judge one of his closest companion.
@qouiou123 We dont care what Abu Bakr was in the life time of Prophet we care what he did wd his daughter after his death, he did hurt her. So according to prophet's saying he is no more a muslim just dont shy to say he was greedy for wealth and had nothing to do wd Islam.
@qouiou123 And what abt when on a certain occassion prophet said to Abu Bakr; 'the kufr is crawling in u wd the speed of an ant'. Means he was so slow to understand prophet and on most occassion used to doubt in his prophesies.
Rispondi a questo video...Ok if it is so as u say. of course prophet was more able for each and everything, then why prophet didnt mention even once in his life time that this person should b the successor after my death no doubt prophet could c the future same way as he could c the past and such a predictible prophet who informed ab several happinings b4 they could happen, but very important matter remained usolved why? According to shia bilief he mentioned Ali.
Rispondi a questo video...And to proove the authenticty of this claim shia present lot of hadis to support their belief while sunni lack of hadis to proove Abu Bakr'successorship.They always get rid of hvin mentioned oh it was coz people elected him.Remember in the kindom of Allah o subhan o tala publics consent values nothing and believing so is like living in dark and far from the beautiful principals of Islam.
MrAliwalay About Gadir hadith……Shias are keen to manipulate the meaning of hadith according to their sect beliefs. Why don't you read the entire context behind Gadir Hadith. Let's assume he did say Ali is his successor, so do we EVER deny Ali as a successor? Ofcourse we regard him as his successor too, only that historically heat he was the fourth successor. Plus go and read about Abdullah Bin Saba-founder of Shiasm.
@qouiou123 We shia, dont care for public opinion we believe in the decision of dinvine power while it is Allah who appointed him as a successor then no question remain as who should be khalifa or successor. Only those who always doubted in Quran required election and left the dead body of prophet they didnt even bother to attend the last journy of prophet they are ur leader not of those who totaly summit to the will of Allah.
Rispondi a questo video...for ur stupid type of coversation which has got no ground shows ur lack of knowledge. In d begining there were no sunnis or as shias they were only muslims.after that there were shias and then sunnis. it was on Umar who committed blasphemy to prophet and denyed prophet from writing a testament, thats the very time muslims divided into two groups who remained in favour of Ali were called shiane Ali those who remained other side they their shia.
MrAliwalay Prophet PBUH had Abu Baker as his companion for 23 years and in all those years he never mentioned to him even once that Ali is the real leader. Let's assume he told him but still he reverted Prophet's decision. How come Umar and Uthman ALSO further neglected prophet's decision? 3 people did wrong but only 1 was right. That is so illogical and fake.
@qouiou123 Ok according to u sunnis, successor should be choosen by publick opinion then why Omar was nominated by Abu Bakr and not by election,here u should accept it was just to keep Ali detached from Khilafa,coz they knew if election is done Ali would hv won.and for ur information if Ali was even one per cent was like them he could hv raised his sord,but he was distinguished.
MrAliwalay U r like an ignorant hypocrite who claims to be muslim but still worship graves, imams and commit bidah. Moreover, you disrespect the Sahabah of of Prophet PBUH, which proves you don't belong to Islam. You claim Ali to be the first leader, despite the fact that the entire Ummah, including Imam Ali, accepted him as the first leader. And yet you say he was a kid. I guess you are going against your own religion and most of all Imam Ali. Since he accepted, you should accept Abu Bakar too
@qouiou123 Pesident of America is also accepted by entire world including Saudis then why dont u accept Bush or Obama as fifth Khalifa, why, why not?????
@qouiou123 For ur further knowledge pls go read , hadise Ghadir is the proof Ali is first Imam, in Islam there is nothing like khilafa it is imamat and ALI is frst Imam of entire muslims same as prophet mohammed is the prophet for entire world weather they believe or not.In shia Islam prophet can b choosen by faulty majority it should b choose by divine authority And Imam Ali was choosen by prophet mohammed under the command of allahsubhanautala.
This guy is series ill, i mean he cant even transilate the verses properly..he qouted the verse from surah yusuf about yaqub pbuh asking for forgivness for his children..the prophet is alive afcourse he can ask forgivness..no one can intercedes for anybody until day of judgment day when our beloved prophet mohammad pbuh will come farward..only than he can, until than its between you and Allah and thats it..
Who is this guy talking out of context. You may call them fool, no my brother they are very clever. They are very clever in cheating people and deviating innocent ummah from the right track.
All nuts and bolts want to debate with Zakir Naik. He is not free bee to debate with all. You cannot match his caliber. He has said if you can arrange a hall and can bring 200 people then he will debate on the topic of Yazeed on which you created controversy and guess what you planned and Allah planned and more people are coming to true islam. Allahu Akbar. Follow Quran and Sahih-Hadith.
@qouiou123 U r like abu bakr who was always proud to be elder in age to Ali but he was a kid to him while it comes to wisdom this guy is Alim not a sunni wahabi mulla, and remember to get excited in such a way as u exibit from ur words that s the proof u lack solid proofs to ur rubbish belief.
he is kid man he dont know about true islam and where is zakir naik debat and i am 100% sure no one can beat dr zakir naik he is the greatest leader of the world and number of non muslim accept islam in the hand of dr zakir naik .
O believer answer to the call of allah and answer to the call of prophet then you will get life. What means life? The almight god reckon to the life after death not the life on earth. Im always trying to answer the calls of amighty allah and his beloved prophet so I i will never ever die. What a stupidity
THAT IS ABSULETY GOD MADE IT CLEAR IN QURAN THAT EVERY PERSON HAS COME HERE FOR A LIMITED TIME EVEN IF HE A PROPHET OR ANY OTHER PERSON. but shia people is complicated
Anyway this verses doest not have any connection with ya muhammad madad or ya ali madad.
Just gues you are died and you are infront the alimight god allah. and the god ask you 1 question why did you always said ya ali madad or ya muhammad madad. then what will be your reply???
And second if almighty allah ask you. if the muhammad phuh or ali could help, they would have never been died. and if you say they are never been died and the god reply will be, if they never been died, why they were not around you? why didnt you see them face to face like previous people? so then what will be your reply?
When we discuss the verses in the Qur'an we find no problem with Shias but the problem is with the books of Shias which based on fabricated hadth. How do I know because all most all the Imams like Shafi, Hanafi and others say so, so how do they know because the have read hundreds of books and compared with them and devised a very scientific method to verify the truth from falsehood.
voiceofreasoning you are really funny, sunnis have the fabricating hadiths not shia. our rule is simple, if a hadiths goes against quran, its false! ur book full of CRAP! may be you should bother to read em some time. you disrespect ProphetPBUH by putting those hadiths in ur books now u pointing ur finger on shias, nice way hiding ur ugly face munafiq!
This has been flagged as spam show
ABU TALIAB HAD FOUR SONS, TALIB, ALI, AQEEL AND JAFAR. ALI WAS FIRST WHO ACCEPTED ISLAM. LATER JAFAR ACCEPTED ISLAM. WHEN BATTLE OF BADR OCCURED, TALIB AND AQEEL FOUGHT AGAINST MUSLIMS BECAUSE THEY HAD NOT ACCEPTED ISLAM AT THAT TIME. TALIB WAS KILLED (THUS HE DIED IN THE STATE OF KUFR), AQEEL WAS MADE PRISONER. LATER AQEEL ACCEPTED ISLAM ON THE OCCASION OF HUDAIBIYA. AQEEL HAD FIVE SONS AND ONE OF HIS SONS NAME WAS YAZID AND KUNIYAT OF AQEEL WAS ABU YAZID.
Islam1491 5 months ago
the debate is not about we can ask intercession from someone, it's about whether all deads are dead or some deads are alive....y not stick to the subject?!
Parouty 6 months ago
bullshit !! wasted my time i thought zakir naik will be in this debate he is just balbering ..ashole .. misleaded person ..
mrsexyboy001 7 months ago
Dont mislead the innocent People......Plz
rehmatabad 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I request all to gain good knowledge before you make fake statements, u may misguide people in this world, but what will you do in front of Allah, you have to face the punishment and its a good news for those who is non-believers and those who misguide people about ISLAM will burn in hell forever.
Those who died for Islam they called shaheed and are alive, then why people do matam for the one who is alive and in heaven.
Allah hu Akbar..
middleeasttrader 10 months ago
Comment removed
middleeasttrader 10 months ago
There is no one who can help us except Allah and we can only ask for any help in this world is to Allah, the one who died can never help us, Muhammed SAW will be there on the day of judgement and that day he will make dua for umma who were on right path of Quran & hadidth by our prophet Muhammed (SAW).When yakoob A.S sons asked their father Yakoob A.S to pray for them for forgiveness when that time he was alive. This way anyone who is alive can ask each other to make dua for each other
middleeasttrader 10 months ago
misleading! shirk!
a1fiee 11 months ago
misleading!
a1fiee 11 months ago
lol im ur uncle
samtron77v 1 year ago
hah debate... did u shia seen ur face in mirror
karizarb 1 year ago
What is this where is respected Dr.Naik in this debate????????????
MrAsimkhalil 1 year ago
SYED ALI RAZA KAZMI! DO YOU NOT THINK THAT YOU AND YUR FATHER MUST BE IN PAKISTAN TO PREACH PAKI SPEAKER INSTEAD OF LIVING IN EUROPIAN COMFORTS AND CRITICISING TO PAKISTANI ZAKREEN??IS IT JUSTICE? IS IT ADEL?WHITOUT PREACHING YOU PEOPLE CRITICISNG?WHATS PROBLEM TO COME,LIVE, PREACH AND THEN CRETICISE?
NAQVI8 1 year ago 2
BULSHIT!!!!!!!!!!
DESPITE ALL THE ILLOGICAL CLAIMS BY PROVING THE OBJECTIONS RIGHT THROUGH VERSES OF THE QURAN "OUT OF CONTEXT" I AM NOT EVEN 1% CONVINCED -__-
faribad 1 year ago
Mraliwalay Allah knows eveyrhting.....he knew wut shaitan wud do.....but dont think Ali knew wut wud happen in future....because if u say Ali knew everything about the future.....u r comparing an attribute of Allah to Ali..which itself is the biggest shirk...get your logics right.....ur stupid Shia philosophy is very backward and illogical
qouiou123 1 year ago
Mraliwalay I can say the same...Abu Baker was better than a retarted imam khomeini...only because he was a person Prophet trusted in his life time.....
qouiou123 1 year ago
Mraliwalay If I was an Imam..knowing the future is really miserable for muslims because they will be united under different labels....i wud raise my swords and slit throat cuts of all the kufrs and infidels and unite muslims under 1 banner....but no reality is the beloved Ali didn't create any sect or Shias....it was stupid people and infidels who created another sect and made fabricated hadith of Ali! Remember Prophet said the upcoming 3 generations r the right 1z..n the later 1z will be doomed
qouiou123 1 year ago
are you guyz ali´s mother?
oreaper212 1 year ago
Mraliwalay you do regard stupid Imam Khomeini as your ultimate leader...but the problem is you "ONLY" regard him as the ULTIMATE leader because apparently he has divine powers and can see the future...in reality he didn't even knew his own future..the difference between us muslims n u shias is u regard 1 persons ilm or opinion as the final word..where as we take advices from as many scholars as possible..because the ultimate wisdom or in your language ilm...only the Prophets had..passed by ALLAH
qouiou123 1 year ago
@qouiou123 Imam khomeni was better thousand times than Stupid Abu Bakr.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
Abu Baker Was bad Umar was bad.....but still Ali stayed quite despite knowing the fact that future generations will always be divided. Only because he was a decent man, he thought it is wise to stay silent and let Abu Baker be the successor and let Allah's people remain divided to this day. Only because he was distinguished. Again ridiculous claim.
qouiou123 1 year ago
@qouiou123 Why allah didnt know abt Shaitan he will be missguiding human being till the day of judgement still he set him on liberty, why think of that. U r going into irrational discussion without knowing abt Ali"s charachter. He didnt want to raise the sord just 4the sake of power,in that case people could hv a good excuse to blame prophet and Ali equaly they were doing effort just for the wealth and Ali didnt like that though he agitaed on d behaviour of Abu Bakr.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
MrAliwalay Be logical.....you have hadith to support...but you don't have Allah to support your stupid claim of imamate.....perhaps you don't have any logical and factual arguemen which itself shows you have no base at all rather your stupid beliefs are rooted with fabrication and infidelity.
qouiou123 1 year ago
MrAliwalay You believe in Dive Decision despite the fact that Allah never told us that there has to be an Imam always. Allah, the greatest of all, failed to convey this message through his last messenger, isn't that an insult to Allah and his decision?
qouiou123 1 year ago
MrAliwalay No matter what, accept the fact that you regard yourselves as Shias. Isn't it? I believe every Shia calls himself a Shia, or a Momin. Though it is mentioned in Quran, whoever distinguishes himself from Islam and creates his own identity or a sect in Islam, is doomed. Look at yourself, haven't you guys created an identity other than a Muslim for yourselves already??
qouiou123 1 year ago
Again you are just blindly believing less authentic hadith or perhaps manipulating the meaning. At the time of his death, or just before his death, couldn't Prophet Muhammad PBUH, Allah's messenger, get one hint from Allah or Gabriel of what Abu Baker would do after his death? Couldn't Allah give him one message in his entire life time that this man is dangerous to Islam and he will divide muslims into two? Are you kidding? Or you are being ignorant!!
qouiou123 1 year ago
MrAliwalay The fact that you don't care what he was in Prophet's life time itself separates you from Islam. Accept the fact. Learn to trust Prophet and his companions.
qouiou123 1 year ago
MrAliwalay Further, you claim Ali was divinely appointed, why isn't this concept or doctrine mentioned in Quran? The verse 17:71 doesn't really mention anything as Imams being divinely appointed and we should worship them like you do. But as I said, shias maniupulate the meaning of hadith and quran.
qouiou123 1 year ago
MrAliwalay Still you are ignoring the fact that Prophet trusted Abu Baker and the remaining calpihs till his last breath. And I thought in Islam we should trust anything that our Prophet trusts or trusted. But you Shias trust hadith, which can be fabricated.
qouiou123 1 year ago
MrAliwalay Look at your bright side, you regard Imam khomeini as your leader. Did prophet PBUH tell us to regard Imam khomeini and his decendents as our true spiritual leader? Or rather he gave us the Quran and hadith, for all of us to study it deeply and make decisions together logically? If you can't study it, take help from people who studied it, in our terms we call them Scholars. Or is it that Imam Khomeini has some divine power, just like, as you claim without any proof, Imam Ali had?
qouiou123 1 year ago
Comment removed
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
@qouiou123 U r right I dont feel being like an Alim thats y I accept Imam khomeni as a spiritual leader his ilm is azharul minashams, u also know it.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
MrAliwalay For Barack Obama.....let me assure you people who are only lost regard him as a true leader. You are mixing modern day politics with religious history. We trust Abu Bakar, because Prophet trusted him his entire life. And we trust our Prophet blindly, so his trust becomes our trust. Unlike you shias who think Prophet, who had a direct connection with Allah, couldn't really judge one of his closest companion.
qouiou123 1 year ago
@qouiou123 We dont care what Abu Bakr was in the life time of Prophet we care what he did wd his daughter after his death, he did hurt her. So according to prophet's saying he is no more a muslim just dont shy to say he was greedy for wealth and had nothing to do wd Islam.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
@qouiou123 And what abt when on a certain occassion prophet said to Abu Bakr; 'the kufr is crawling in u wd the speed of an ant'. Means he was so slow to understand prophet and on most occassion used to doubt in his prophesies.
To such a person u call rightous successor.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
Rispondi a questo video...Ok if it is so as u say. of course prophet was more able for each and everything, then why prophet didnt mention even once in his life time that this person should b the successor after my death no doubt prophet could c the future same way as he could c the past and such a predictible prophet who informed ab several happinings b4 they could happen, but very important matter remained usolved why? According to shia bilief he mentioned Ali.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
Rispondi a questo video...And to proove the authenticty of this claim shia present lot of hadis to support their belief while sunni lack of hadis to proove Abu Bakr'successorship.They always get rid of hvin mentioned oh it was coz people elected him.Remember in the kindom of Allah o subhan o tala publics consent values nothing and believing so is like living in dark and far from the beautiful principals of Islam.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
MrAliwalay About Gadir hadith……Shias are keen to manipulate the meaning of hadith according to their sect beliefs. Why don't you read the entire context behind Gadir Hadith. Let's assume he did say Ali is his successor, so do we EVER deny Ali as a successor? Ofcourse we regard him as his successor too, only that historically heat he was the fourth successor. Plus go and read about Abdullah Bin Saba-founder of Shiasm.
qouiou123 1 year ago
@qouiou123 We shia, dont care for public opinion we believe in the decision of dinvine power while it is Allah who appointed him as a successor then no question remain as who should be khalifa or successor. Only those who always doubted in Quran required election and left the dead body of prophet they didnt even bother to attend the last journy of prophet they are ur leader not of those who totaly summit to the will of Allah.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
Rispondi a questo video...for ur stupid type of coversation which has got no ground shows ur lack of knowledge. In d begining there were no sunnis or as shias they were only muslims.after that there were shias and then sunnis. it was on Umar who committed blasphemy to prophet and denyed prophet from writing a testament, thats the very time muslims divided into two groups who remained in favour of Ali were called shiane Ali those who remained other side they their shia.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
MrAliwalay Prophet PBUH had Abu Baker as his companion for 23 years and in all those years he never mentioned to him even once that Ali is the real leader. Let's assume he told him but still he reverted Prophet's decision. How come Umar and Uthman ALSO further neglected prophet's decision? 3 people did wrong but only 1 was right. That is so illogical and fake.
qouiou123 1 year ago
@qouiou123 Ok according to u sunnis, successor should be choosen by publick opinion then why Omar was nominated by Abu Bakr and not by election,here u should accept it was just to keep Ali detached from Khilafa,coz they knew if election is done Ali would hv won.and for ur information if Ali was even one per cent was like them he could hv raised his sord,but he was distinguished.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
MrAliwalay U r like an ignorant hypocrite who claims to be muslim but still worship graves, imams and commit bidah. Moreover, you disrespect the Sahabah of of Prophet PBUH, which proves you don't belong to Islam. You claim Ali to be the first leader, despite the fact that the entire Ummah, including Imam Ali, accepted him as the first leader. And yet you say he was a kid. I guess you are going against your own religion and most of all Imam Ali. Since he accepted, you should accept Abu Bakar too
qouiou123 1 year ago
@qouiou123 Pesident of America is also accepted by entire world including Saudis then why dont u accept Bush or Obama as fifth Khalifa, why, why not?????
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
@qouiou123 For ur further knowledge pls go read , hadise Ghadir is the proof Ali is first Imam, in Islam there is nothing like khilafa it is imamat and ALI is frst Imam of entire muslims same as prophet mohammed is the prophet for entire world weather they believe or not.In shia Islam prophet can b choosen by faulty majority it should b choose by divine authority And Imam Ali was choosen by prophet mohammed under the command of allahsubhanautala.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
This guy is series ill, i mean he cant even transilate the verses properly..he qouted the verse from surah yusuf about yaqub pbuh asking for forgivness for his children..the prophet is alive afcourse he can ask forgivness..no one can intercedes for anybody until day of judgment day when our beloved prophet mohammad pbuh will come farward..only than he can, until than its between you and Allah and thats it..
786Nasrat 1 year ago
Who is this guy talking out of context. You may call them fool, no my brother they are very clever. They are very clever in cheating people and deviating innocent ummah from the right track.
plaintruth01 1 year ago
All nuts and bolts want to debate with Zakir Naik. He is not free bee to debate with all. You cannot match his caliber. He has said if you can arrange a hall and can bring 200 people then he will debate on the topic of Yazeed on which you created controversy and guess what you planned and Allah planned and more people are coming to true islam. Allahu Akbar. Follow Quran and Sahih-Hadith.
plaintruth01 1 year ago
i would slap this twisted kid if he ever comes infront of me......stupid idiotic shirk promoter!
qouiou123 1 year ago
@qouiou123 U r like abu bakr who was always proud to be elder in age to Ali but he was a kid to him while it comes to wisdom this guy is Alim not a sunni wahabi mulla, and remember to get excited in such a way as u exibit from ur words that s the proof u lack solid proofs to ur rubbish belief.
MrAliwalay 1 year ago
he is kid man he dont know about true islam and where is zakir naik debat and i am 100% sure no one can beat dr zakir naik he is the greatest leader of the world and number of non muslim accept islam in the hand of dr zakir naik .
littilwood007 1 year ago
this kid is joke
shabirmcbul 1 year ago
@shabirmcbul would you please explain through some logic or evidence any points you have against this?
yaaliali 1 year ago
@yaaliali yes he is manipulating the verses of Quran as well as translating it falsely
he is propgating bida
shabirmcbul 1 year ago
@shabirmcbul WHAT is he translating incorectly verify on the verse?
yaaliali 1 year ago
O believer answer to the call of allah and answer to the call of prophet then you will get life. What means life? The almight god reckon to the life after death not the life on earth. Im always trying to answer the calls of amighty allah and his beloved prophet so I i will never ever die. What a stupidity
THAT IS ABSULETY GOD MADE IT CLEAR IN QURAN THAT EVERY PERSON HAS COME HERE FOR A LIMITED TIME EVEN IF HE A PROPHET OR ANY OTHER PERSON. but shia people is complicated
to be continued
TheGlitterStars1 2 years ago
Anyway this verses doest not have any connection with ya muhammad madad or ya ali madad.
Just gues you are died and you are infront the alimight god allah. and the god ask you 1 question why did you always said ya ali madad or ya muhammad madad. then what will be your reply???
TheGlitterStars1 2 years ago
Comment removed
TheGlitterStars1 2 years ago
Comment removed
TheGlitterStars1 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
And second if almighty allah ask you. if the muhammad phuh or ali could help, they would have never been died. and if you say they are never been died and the god reply will be, if they never been died, why they were not around you? why didnt you see them face to face like previous people? so then what will be your reply?
TheGlitterStars1 2 years ago
@TheGlitterStars1 right said my brother same question i ask to my shia friends
shabirmcbul 1 year ago
well i think here some of the sunni's objection were very nicely explained and he could't say a word against our shia scolar
deshi2008desh 2 years ago
WOW! this young brother is impressive, Alhamdulillah!
FashionBudgetTV 2 years ago
When we discuss the verses in the Qur'an we find no problem with Shias but the problem is with the books of Shias which based on fabricated hadth. How do I know because all most all the Imams like Shafi, Hanafi and others say so, so how do they know because the have read hundreds of books and compared with them and devised a very scientific method to verify the truth from falsehood.
voiceofreasoning 2 years ago
voiceofreasoning you are really funny, sunnis have the fabricating hadiths not shia. our rule is simple, if a hadiths goes against quran, its false! ur book full of CRAP! may be you should bother to read em some time. you disrespect ProphetPBUH by putting those hadiths in ur books now u pointing ur finger on shias, nice way hiding ur ugly face munafiq!
halakukhan 2 years ago
When this debate was taken and where can i watch it?
IJAZZZZ 2 years ago