嫡傳 尚氏形意拳大全

[DaiBoxer]

Dont mean to be critical. But terribly incorrect!

[rebel9655]

以前、本で見たときには、ホンモノかニセモノか、ちょっと分から­なかった。

その後、呉本人の演武している八卦掌、剣、太極拳、対打を見たと­きに、

はっきり「ニセモノ」と分かった。舞ではあるが武ではない。

[2606keith]

No 'jing'. Posture wrong. No power

[tentousan]

本を読んで覚えた呉ハクエンに習ったのに正当な系統とか言っちゃ­駄目だ。

あと、日本人のくせに中国風の通り名を付けちゃ駄目。

[snowbird1962]

カンフー映画じゃあるまいし、なんで擬音をつける必要があるのか­？

[junlong0107]

I don't see any reason to be angry. Everyone hv the rights of expression to their own style. The Jap dude did reasonably well. All I wish is for martial artists to hv respect for one another as well as respect for various schools. I think it is pathetic to get angry over this video.

[chansk76]

@junlong0107 Yes! I agree with you that everyone has the right of expressing their own style and I agree that martial artists should respect one another as well as respect for various schools. But this video is obviously misguiding everyone's understanding towards 形意拳.

If you can say "The Jap dude did reasonably well", please explain your reason(s). But 1st, 你練過形意拳嗎？你會看形意拳嗎？你會用形意拳嗎？...Eve­n his breathings, postures and footsteps are ridiculously wrong. Are you sure you know anything about 形意拳?

[copperscorpion]

stomp,stomp, that's no way to kill roaches...lol

[aini5buhouhui]

hahah, all i can see is a person with disability who try to make himself looks like a gong fu master. lmao, ps:maybe mentally challenged as well.haha.

[jazzyslip]

A lot of angry comments about this video. Let me just say what I have observed about Chinese and Japanese martiial arts. Chinese martial arts evolve quickly: Kung Fu nowadays is different than 20 years ago. By contrast, Japanese try to keep the forms as they were at the origin of the school: when someone changes or adapt those forms they create a new school. Therefore there might be something valuable to learn from the form presented here: a mirror in the earlier days of Xing Yi maybe...

[yinyangwisdom]

I have read all the comments that you guys posted in Chinese. First I have to say, you guys know nothing about it. The only thing I see is discrimination. This form is lost totally in China. Now I find in Japan. Thank you for posting this video.

[tchovosky]

lol. since u say so, i am glad that u wont be exposed to the real stuff ;)

[wtx203210jy]

我日 這什麽東西啊 不要糟蹋形意拳啊 不要糟蹋中華的國粹

[naaejaejoong]

this is not xingyi, how on earth ppl call this xingyi?

come on plz remove this

[Maskedpsycho]

ほんと、こいつら、インチキくさいわぁ～。

[kenchhhh]

呵呵。请放心。

这个他們的撒謊是已經被識破了的很有名的事件。

在日本中國武術愛好的人们间，

關於過去這個事有爭論，可是,已經終結了。

我想誰都不想真的。

也曾经在日本的有名的投稿網站，

也有成為嘲笑和輕蔑的對象的事。

可是,真奇怪,這個錄像公司还卖着這個錄像。

我觉得很遗憾。

不好汉语,对不起。

[install3kimo]

只能說 日本人已經跟韓國一樣了 能抄襲儘可能抄襲

從網路上不難發覺 他們真是兩個非常會賺錢的國家

不過抄襲的真凶~~不覺得很像韓國 啥都是他們那邊發明的

算了吧~~騙騙外國人賺錢~敢到中國來怎麼被打死都不知道

學學樣子還學的七零八落還敢打中國名師來混

要不是語言不通早就罵死他們了~~有膽來切磋切磋看看

[spxingyi]

此拳非形意拳。请参考国内名家张世杰老师的教材及视频。祝你早日­在形意拳上有所建树。

[janssen0707]

作为一个尚派弟子,算我求求您了,老前辈留下的好东西不是这么糟­蹋的,您把这视频撤了去成吗?

[chansk76]

Is this video a joke? Something is wrong with his breathing!! Is his nose stuck? Are you sure this is 真傳？What does Japanese know about XingYiQuan?

[zhucezhemenan]

看了都想吐，别糟蹋形意拳了

[wckoek]

It was the first time I ever seen this kind of form.

No santishi, and the sounds of the footwork seemed dubbed.

[DuYiZhang]

ew...

[Changxianglong]

This person is performing xingyi as if it were a karate kata. He does not have the body structure of xingyi.

[whatisyournameya]

My name is Hai Yang(杨海) I have some questions:

1, The person(no hair on the head) is a Chinese or Japaness?

2, What is "嫡傳"(the chinese characters you used in the title of this video? Do you really know the MEANING of Di Chuan???

Please do not delete this message otherwise I will post again.

Hai YAng

[windswayinglotus]

rofl 2. just go with that zhuan if you want to break your wrist

[laonong]

rofl!