Gregorian- Comfortably Numb

[TheHippy6969]

they should sing this with pink floyd ,

[mohsabbfull]

PERFECT PERFECT PERFECT......

[Aetila]

26 people feel a bit sick!

[TheKatamata]

MAN I MELTED ON THIS SOLO :ooo

[Aetila]

I don't know who plays the guitar here but he's absolutely awesome!

[MoralInvasion]

Not just a song but something from another dimension, a higher plain, a fleeting glimpse.

[flyonthebed]

Amazing. So fuc*ing amazing. I liked so much this cover.

[Gaia2x]

Yessssssssssssssssssss relaxation relaxation 

[RondoRedux]

Mus'nt joke about arrows; you can put an eye out with one...or a knee, or the neighbor's dog that stays up barking all damn night long...

[Theclaidheamhmor]

@RondoRedux Hahah. I know someone that pinned his neighbors poodle to their door with an arrow. Sick I know

[MokRodrigues]

Yeah, it would be best to do a single voice in the verses, just like in the Carpet Crawlers cover of Genesis. Nice version anyway!

[ClefODonnell]

Absolutely amazing!

[gtk75]

This was surprisingly good. Although I must admit I had to listen to it a bit before I really liked it. The opening (1st verse?) of the song I don't feel like is very good, but it gets better and better further into the song you get :)

[kishanna09]

la cover di Wish You Were Here non mi è piaciuta poi tanto ma trovo che questa Confortably Numb sia da capogiro... bellissima! Anche se bisogna ammettere: il pezzo si presta moltissimo a questo tipo d'arrangiamento.

[ivanattilio]

Lindo, magnífico!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[TheAirgead]

Absolutely brilliant!



[mrbombastickk]

You wanna know what i think? I think the vocals don't fit the song. I know this is Gregorian's style, but in the Verse those choral vocals don't sound right!

[sandfordmerlin]

24 deaf as well as numb - fantastic sound :-)

[MrAccrington123]

i once was in Gregorian intill i took an arrow to the knee

[thgirtruocnairb]

@MrAccrington123 I once joked about getting arrows in to the knee, till I took an arrow to the knee.

[ZachValkyrie]

Awesome!!!

next, Run like Hell? I want to hear how these guys would interpret the roger waters scream

[Aetila]

I find it a slightly better than the original...also the guitar solo here is better in my sharp ears! lol

Nevertheless, such a brilliant piece of music from PF!

[Theclaidheamhmor]

the original is the best but this is still really good.

[spiteribarri876]

22 people are Numb

[Marcao7943]

o solo é melhor q o original!

[420guyonthecouch]

22 people are deaf and cant hear how good they are

[Ashiq6661]

22 peole are Lunatic

[BackToTheBus]

I have been drinking tonight and I too am comfortably numb.

[tompoynton]

what.the.blue.FUCK.is.this.

[gigaman3]

WOW, I can't help but imagine a monk in robes with a hidden face just like the picture in the video, but rockin it with a David Gilmour signature strat. Now that's awesome :)

[Spamazoid]

Least this wasn't a techno version like many of the others, Gregorian should be classical/orchestral not electronic.

Comfortably Numb - voted Top 50 greatest rock solo's and ballads of all time respectively of all time.

this and Shine on you crazy diamond are epic.

[SilvaJrRenato]

Pink Floyd - Início de minha graduação em Geologia - Sentir a música. Grandes lembranças. Parabéns. Boa idéia. Valeu mesmo!

[curingaging00]

Relaxing and serene.

[BuayaGuy]

Good god, this is one of the most epic songs I've ever heard...

[MrGeremia57]

da impazzire di gioia!

[Szeba86]

Godlike!

[emifender]

que mersa q son estos tipos locos.. vayan a escuchar arjona.

[elfuser31]

Divine!!

[PSILOCYBETRIBE]

and rofll, i didn't know monks played guitar

[PSILOCYBETRIBE]

sounds like pink floyd if you go to sound control and set the area to cave and turn the tone on -5

[BrokenDawn]

@texaswhiteman I sincerely hope you were hacked

@4thoftheholytrinity Do us a favor and learn something about Gregorian chant before you make stupid comments. Yeah, it might sound better if they actually split up into chords, but then it couldn't be called chant. Of course, this can't truly be called Gregorian chant for several different reasons, but at least they actually chant it

[neuronmage]

@BrokenDawn That's got to be hacked or just plain a joke. Perhaps insanity.

[paulacesarea]

Me encantan Gregorians: hacen unas versiones que calman el espíritu, al tiempo que los covers con de buenísima calidad... Pero lo más importante para mí es poder escucharles y quedarme dormida por el relax que muchos de sus temas me producen... ¡Son geniales!

[ANALUCIAYMATEO]

PRECIOSA VERSION! HERMOSA, BELLA....

[rancourt420]

wow. i have never heard a cover of Comfortably Numb tht i liked. this i like.

[MrBrumck]

Who would have thought Pink Floyd, sung by monks, WOW!!

[serban031]

if i died right now, i'd die happier

[yurianne07]

kind of like funeral music. only in english and not latin.

[4thoftheholytrinity]

i feel as if they would be alot better if they didnt all sing together barely splitting up to make chords . if they had more people and made the chord progressions broader it would give more of the tingley feeling. it seems as if they just take the music and redo it man your gregorian chanters make it your own and i promise it will be better use your music theory and spend a little time to make broader chords it would help they are still pretty sick tho

[TheKlink]

@4thoftheholytrinity

You're totally right.

[the0US0marine]

This should be on everyone's iPod.

[chrisvdridder]

@the0US0marine it IS on my iPod!!!! Al for so many years! Lov'it!!!!

[ShineOnDude]

omg,.. can't stop laughing, I suppose if they played this at my church, I'd still be going! lol

[lovay]

@ShineOnDude  Same here. LOL

[ramiroz]

This is the worst cover of Comfortably Numb I've ever heard.

[niceonemicky]

@ramiroz its the best

[DrejStinger1986]

@ramiroz Negative vote for bashing one of the best songs on the planet!

[pauloamendes1972]

Beautfullllll

[niceonemicky]

These Guys are prostituting themselves, so whats new in Catholicism.

If I found out all the proceeedes and I mean ALL the procedes of these Gregorian Capitalistic musical exploits was going to starving children in the Horn of Africa I would eat these words with maggot infested Spagetti.

By the way as I was finnishing this the Guitar Solo came on And its BRILLIANT.

[lidiamada]

love it

[sparkimoto]

This kind of sounds like about a dozen overdubs of vocal tracks, each sung by the same person rather than a choir of munks singing.

[stucar7677]

this is great i am not a big pf fan but love this

[marta3t6fox2]

amazing Gregorian, and this very special version, thanks for sharing, congrats!!!

[82cassanova]

you are trully awesome

[Aetila]

It's sooo EPIC; I'm a sinner because I love this version more than the original PF...please forgive me! :-)

[Billium1993]

@Aetila How can you be a sinner for liking a song sung by monks?

[Aetila]

@Billium1993

Oh, YouTube...I always have to explain things.

I was joking; I meant that I may not be a hardcore PF fan liking the singing monks more than PF itself who wrote this excellent song. (PF fans would say that I'm a "sinner" because I like this version more...:-)...hope you get my innocent joke!)

[tracery3811]

WOW!!! LOVE it!!!!!!!!!

[tautisg1]

Holy fucking shitballs. This is amazing !!!!!!!

[TIGERHD1]

Talk about perfecting perfect!!!! Awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!

[usetobefast]

Oh good Lord, I just made it 666 likes!

[marsbz]

The chorus is nice...

[indrakamala]

My late boyfriend would have loved this ;)

[JLSTHERAT]

another song add to my  viking Funeral,,

so awesome song!!

[lovay]

@JLSTHERAT LOL

[glassprisoner417]

i had goosebumps the whole time

[TheDona777]

marvellous 

[Qujo81]

Omg!

[SirLuke3375]

They make so many such covers...

This music comes certainly from Heaven!

[cmd2tuts]

I will now start going to church if they promise to all sing like gregorian

[MSG993011]

Probably one of the best covers I've ever heard to a song...

[zlakerbeetch]

OMFG!!!! bloody awsome!!!

[gmorksapprentice]

wow... that is cool.

[lCSYZEROl]

this actually pretty damn good..

[AirbornePathogen]

Not to jump on the bandwagon, but the only thing that could make this version better is Gilmour's guitar solos.

[USAHavana]

"Far away. Across the field. Tolling on the iron bell. Calls the faithful to their knees. To hear the softly spoken magic spell". ... Pink Floyd is not against the Church, quite the contrary. Lets evolve into faith!

[privatetvtrog1]

@USAHavana Sorry but david is atheist haha

[USAHavana]

@privatetvtrog1 Who the hell said he was Christian or a believer? HAHA? What are you 12? Of course he is an atheist, atheism sells more albums, its been in vogue since the 60's. I am certain that is why YOU like his music. So many armchair morons who think they have solved the mystery of existence. How silly! I said "Pink Floyd is not against the Church", learn to read. LMAO!

[jpg1748]

This is the best I have ever heard of contemporary chant in my life. A little bit of Heaven on Earth!

[USAHavana]

@jpg1748 I TOTALLY AGREE, the BEST of BOTH WORLDS!

[dimon879]

It's really amazing!! Pink Floyd is awesome and this verison is very touching... GREAT!!

[MStowastiqPackapic]

OMG someone found a way to make this song more depressing. I love it.

[7blueblood]

i think david in the bible was ment for david gilmore :)

[DrejStinger1986]

@7blueblood Agreed; David defeated Goliath with his awesome guitar skills.

[NickADTv]

yes dear god David gilmour so neat nice

[snk07]

Dear God

David Gilmour

both start with "D" and "G" ,coincidence?

[chiffmonkey]

@snk07 Dumb git...

[stratocat74]

@chiffmonkey as if you know anything about guitar playing...

[chiffmonkey]

@stratocat74 It's easy to forget that sarcasm doesn't work in text form...

[EFLOG27]

Is NOT A COINCIDENCE, IS THE SAME

[jonauska22]

what the music instrument call on 2:15?

[tcanter64]

@jonauska22

sounds lime a violin or fiddle.

[likeicare2111]

@jonauska22 it's a fiddle. you can tell the differeance by the tone of the insturment. a fiddle is more grovelly than a violin, has more of a earthy fill; while a violin has a more clean, cut prestine fill to its tone imo.

[ZolaMcAdie]

@likeicare2111 A fiddle is a violin. They aren't different instruments. Fiddle is just a specific style of playing.

[likeicare2111]

@ZolaMcAdie okay we're both partly right lol. they are the same instrument, it's the approach or set up with the strings that is different and therefor gives a different sound. some fiddlers will flatten their bridge so that they can play a double-stop with ease (this is when the fiddler plays two stings at once)

apparently Fiddle is also a generic term that refers to any bowed string musical insturment as well o.0 learn something new everyday lol ^.^

[MrDaniel580]

what life or dead =-[

[allpainppd]

Brought me to tears

[GordosMama1111]

just a little pin prick..aaaaaaahhhhhwwwsome

[the0US0marine]

asudfisgj Holy fuck i just jizzed everywhere.

[jerry544]

Ehhhhhhhh..... Good.. I guess... Side by side with Floyd no, but in general its well done...

[TheFranciscolobo]

great song...

[MANNYMONI]

This is just beautiful.:)

[DA192021]

Hermosisima musica y voces, PRECISOOOOO

[graikos1453]

JUST MAGIC.

[dfndnola]

They known this song is about taking heroin right?

[alphacause]

@dfndnola I am sure they do know that this song is about a drug fueled hallucination. In that sense it fits a religious motif quite well, because what is religion, after all, but a form of escapism - much like drug use. The only difference is that one form of escapism, religion, is socially acceptable, while the other, drug use, isn't.

[rucyinski]

@alphacause u're lost, look for way, true and life!

[alphacause]

@rucyinski I am not even sure what you are saying

[MrDaniel580]

yes you are look for way, true and life

[masterorionful]

@alphacause the group called in some doctor, and he gave Gilmore some shot they made him almost instantly well, and he was able to preform the show.

[masterorionful]

@dfndnola The song is not about taking heroin, If you watch the movie you would understand more of what the song is about. The first part of the movie portrays this rock star named Pink, being transformed by society. When this song is played during the movie it is showing the final stage of his transformation. Also when David Gilmour & Roger Waters were writing the song, they took from a real life experience. David Gilmore one night was extremely ill , this was right before a show.

[xuser48]

@dfndnola

David Gilmour wrote this song. He had been taking some strong painkillers because of some illness. This is how he felt.

[theos1logos]

@dfndnola I'm pretty sure they don't care what its about.

[tekubus]

Imagine if Type O Negative had produced it.

[DFireWind008]

@DERFWARTHAWG I'm agree with you... LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

[AisuEnzeru]

This song is just Beautiful. =)

[tabkitchen1983]

WOW that is all I have to say, blew me away, my initial thought was oh here we go again another re-make probably watered down...ok I was WRONG!

[batzenbakia]

from 4:35, just like flying!!

[oscarjaimemx]

Just Incredible. This make me believe in God.

[alphacause]

There is more spirtuality in Pink Floyd than anything I ever heard in church.

[berryola]

@alphacause loling...I am sorry to hear that.

[MsgtRowan420497]

Holy Oh My Fuck. This is great.

[TheTraf11]

Simply brilliant....

[sisko2112]

Wow... not a fan of choir music but... wow...

[DJMusicMadness1]

I never even knew about monks that are masters of the Gregorian Chant doing song covers like this :O I'm shocked in a good way :)

[aassyr1111]

breathtaking

[Ketten11SxR]

Tus labios se mueven pero no puedo oir lo que dicen...

[guyjguitar]

....AMAZING :DI feel like I hear it in the first time

[yinyinkong2559]

great guitar

[drocks159]

wooow!

[Vauek]

The 2nd solo sends shivers down my spine :)

[yinyinkong2559]

@Vauek i want to cry , when i listened 2nd solo , it can take my soul to think about my pain

[TuddersUK]

it is amazing to hear a choir tackling one of the greatest song on earth and really doing it justice...always loved gregorian choirs but, as a metaller, they never really sang songs that I could relate to...if you every read this guys, thank you.

[shadowdemonz1987]

Only 11 people when I posted this comment and only 338 liked it but 135,709 people viewed it counting me. This is a pretty good band that redone this song. I like it is new and something to listen to.

[sandoc]

the guitar riff from 4:30 is heavenly!!

[bleekblock]

Imagine if they recorded this with Gilmour o guitar.

[ildizastro]

@bleekblock Like we aint going cuckoo already!!It would be a straight ticket to Pure Bliss ;)

[tibic]

@bleekblock I like this version's solo. Blends well with the rest.

[AirbornePathogen]

@bleekblock That would be awesome! My personal favorite version of the song is 1991 live performance with Waters, Van Morrisson, and the Band. If only they'd had Gilmour playing the solos for that one...

[AaronMk91]

@bleekblock If he goes on tour again David should take these guys for back-up.

Or do an album with them...

[EFLOG27]

NO LONGER EXIST NOTHING TO BEAT THIS SONG IN ALL THE HISTORY OF MUSIC

[chiffmonkey]

@bleekblock It is Gilmour isn't it?

[14chazz88]

@timwedgin Awesome comment bro!

[fyrkos]

till this day i knew , anyone couldn't make "comfortably numb" cover

[crackerstj]

Totally Awesome!

[maximadave]

Absolutely beautiful version of this classic song!

[eraldogjr]

very very very very very very very very very very very good!

[taysnowman]

Praise Jesus!!!!

[Wandallz]

@taysnowman Why?

[evnz8]

hahaha, this is hilarious! some dork musta spent forever putting this together in his basement

[IamCommando1213]

@evnz8 yeah........Gregorian is a group. So good job.

[IamCommando1213]

@evnz8 yeah........Gregorian is a group. So good job.

[TaraKitaideHunter]

@evnz8 Just as it must have taken you forever to sting together that pathetic excuse for an insult. Hate makes ignorance audible. And remember, if it isn't your cup of tea, do not drink, engage in, comment, or WATCH the fucking tea. There's a reason the internet came with a back button. :) Have a great day.

[archangelwulf]

@TaraKitaideHunter epic reply to that, you do so deserve a reward for that one :)

[evnz8]

@TaraKitaideHunter Thanks, you too!

[14chazz88]

@TaraKitaideHunter Niiiice mate!!!

[DERFWARTHAWG]

Ok I changed my mind.... I will consider going to a church whose choir sings Pink Floyd, Dire Straights and Zepplin! LOL

[JunkGathere]

Beautiful.

[antoinefleuriot2509]

Sounds great

Please see/hear my version

[omidhabibollah]

This is not the best but is tolerable.

[jayded75]

It's not Gregorian. Strictly from a music theory standpoint, some of the intervals and changes would never be heard in a Gregorian church. It's just a mens choir doing a Pink Floyd song. It's not Gregorian music.