You cannot really compare her version with that of Celine's because
1) This is not her native language so she pretty much have to learn all the words. Try imagine Celine singing in Korean. It's probably would be tuned down a couple points.
2) She's singing this while hanging on on the rope. Considering the amount of accident K-pop had in the past, she's got to be at least somewhat scared sitting there + the way one use vocal would be slightly different when in the air. This is awesome.
@Tianx celine's native language is french, and the fact that kpop stans are even trying to argue that she's a better singer than celine makes me want to projectile vomit. the utter delusion is beyond belief
i noticed people talking and comparing and everyone says taeyeon is better.i agree cause you can hear and see her passion for music...but why some of you say she doesnt have powerfull vocals...i think she has so much to show us so i always wish for her to do some solo stuff when they arent promoting cause people like her and her singing is amazing emotionaly and vocally
take into consideration that she was rising up swiftly while only sitting on this hanging swing/chair so her control over her voice is absolutely astounding :)
I actually love Tae's version better than Celine's, and thats not the sone in me- I just like how it sounds better. But in general Celine is magnificent and has a lot on Tae - including experience, which attributes to a lot in music. I love Luna, her voice is amazing- but not breathtaking. Tae sings with true feelings, Luna- not so much, she just sings- she doesn't live the music like Tae and Celine, at least to me. But WHY is this argument EVEN going on? Just enjoy Tae's song people!!
Why are people comparing Taeyeon with Luna and Celine Dion? Luna has a powerful voice but i don't feel any emotions in her singing at all. Taeyeon don't have strong vocals like Luna but she always brings out emotions in a song and I think that is a most important point for a singer. Celine already has both qualities. And she has years of experience far ahead than the 2 girls. Give them (taeyeon and luna) a chance.They still have a long way to learn!
tae's voice is so beautiful and the way she sing is breathtaking and can touch your heart, that's why she is one of the best singer in idol world.Some may have more powerful voice, or better range...But I doubt they can sound this beautiful in every notes like taeyeon. this girl is talented..
after listening o holy night and devils cry all live how dare you to say taeyeon is not one of the best or best korean pop idol singer....even if you dont like snsd you should appreciate their talents and just shut up cause taeyeon has amazing voice and cant show all in snsd performances and i always thought she should have been solo like iu but i now know that she belongs with snsd cause she is strong outside but really insecure and shy inside so girls help her
This song is nothing about how powerful the voice, it's how much the emotion she put into the song, and why you compare her with Celine Dion, everybody know Celine dion have the holy cover of this song, and i like Celine very much,For me Taeyeon's voice is very beautiful and full of emotion that can really touch deeply into my heart. Compare with Luna? Lol, I love Luna too, She have a really powerful voice but to me, Luna doesn't have the best part of a song - a voice that can touch people or m
Plus, Taeyeon is less than half Celine Dion's age. Therefore Dion has twice the experience as Taeng does. Taking that into consideration, Tae's version was although not the best, but arguably amazing none the less. (It was the best for me though, and I'm not saying this easily b/c oh holy night is my favourite Christmas song of all time)
@yennyminniesusu Celine is a worldwide diva. She is lyric soprano, this song should be easy for her to sing. But TaeYeon is another story. TaeYeon is a mezzo-soprano, and her range is not really wide. This song is obviously out of her range. That's why her high notes part is so thin and not that powerful. There are some Youtube vids about TaeYeon's high notes. If you watch it, you can clearly see that if the high notes is in her range, she can sing more powerful than this
@Caramelcoffee1812 i know that but sone always say their taeyeon is queen, angle voice but i think her voice is still young, low level. u can compare her with Luna f(x) u can see!!
@yennyminniesusu Everybody has different taste on music, so I can't say who is better than who. Nevertheless, in my opinion, there are many reasons why Sones say TaeYeon has an angel's voice. And since you mentioned f(x) Luna, I hope you don't mind if I use her as an example compare to TaeYeon. First of all, I have to agree that TaeYeon doesn't have a wide range and can't hit high notes like Luna. But Luna can't absorb herself in the song as deeply as Taeyeon. (Cont)
@yennyminniesusu Can Luna reach high notes? Yes, she can. But she can't bring the emotions of that song while she sings. TaeYeon can do it (e.g: Can you hear me, If, I love you). To many people, TaeYeon does not only sing the song but she also conveys, tells the story through that song. It touches some people hearts. That's one of the reason why people praise TaeYeon for her singing.
@yennyminniesusu Second of all, even though Luna can hit higher notes than TaeYeon, TaeYeon has better technique than Luna. Her control of the song and vibrato is extremely good for an idol singer.
@yennyminniesusu And the last reason in my opinion that Sone say TaeYeon has an angel voice is that her voice really stands out compare to other singers. You can say TaeYeon doesn't have a crystal clear voice or wide range, but she knows how to change her cons into her pros. These days, there are many Kpop singers can reach extremely freaking high notes, but since their voice are crystal clear, some of them may sound pitchy when reaching it.
@yennyminniesusu Yet, for TaeYeon, she may not reach high notes as high as Jessica or Sunny, she may not sing as low as Tiffany, but she uses her husky voice to sing high notes that sounds very soothing to many people ears. Those are the reason why Sone say TaeYeon has an angel voice. A singer doesn't need to sing correct every single note in the song, but the way they put their emotions, the way they can reach somebody's heart is more important :)
@yennyminniesusu Sorry if by any chance I annoyed you with freaking long reply. I just want to point out my opinion, and just remember that your opinion is different than mine. So I do not intend to make you think like the way I do. Have a wonderful night (or day, it depends on your time zone) =)
@Caramelcoffee1812 ok i agree with everything u said, i love the way she sing, her smile but now sone make it go down. she sing well anything famous song and but when she doesnt do it well i just hope her not to do it, when it's really the best, let do it and i will support her! but now i wont. sorry!
This is one of my favorite Christmas songs, and Taeng did such a great job ;_; <3 Also, does anyone know what she's saying in the beginning? My Korean isn't that great yet xD
Amazing voice!!! Love this so much!!
y08189 16 hours ago
@studystrike The French and English languages are not that different as compared to Korean to English.
Not very sure where French comes from, but the Korean language is more Chinese/Japanese than anything else.
sevenrandomthoughts 5 days ago
Guys, why are we comparing in the first place? Just sit back and listen. You won't regret it.
Glovy2 5 days ago
well for European, it's pretty easy to speak or sing in English but for Asian, it's extremely difficult. so it's not sth that we can compare!!!!!
ltvu2308 6 days ago
wow soo good :3
fremy123 1 week ago
lol she sounds so good despite her goofy accent...
dandandamattressman 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
taeyeon so good
taeyeonsun 1 week ago
"Oh hear the angel voices" Exactly what i'm doing now, hearing Taeyeon singing =)
DJEcksDeeJustin 1 week ago 2
she is so pretty....:*) <3
vivi922 1 week ago
Taeyeon unnie, YOU'RE THE BEST!!!!
methebestofsuju 2 weeks ago
wow, just restored my Christmas spirit
blznrayzn 2 weeks ago
she's so beautiful TT taeyeonnnn <3
xSOSHImylovee 2 weeks ago
*_______________*
SHINeeAlly 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh my GODDESS!
there's only one thing i could say...
S-T-U-N-N-I-N-G !!
Taengooyah 2 weeks ago 3
How can this be disliked?
thegreatjedi 2 weeks ago
@thegreatjedi don't mind them... let's just watch the goddess sing...
sakuracard101 2 weeks ago
She's so perfect :O
Fallenbaserunnr4 2 weeks ago
I love u Taeyeon!
koreano2011 2 weeks ago
Beautiful!
07mts 3 weeks ago in playlist 111225 SNSD Christmas Special Show
I heard the angel voice sing...
loveskate97 3 weeks ago
Taengo is like a angel!
tyfanatic01 3 weeks ago
Hitting High Notes while sitting Daebak!
ivanhyuuga589 3 weeks ago
gorgeous taeyeon!!!! totally breathtaking! <3
fantabulous1995 4 weeks ago
Taeyeon Angels Voice .........
O Holy Knight Divine
Sunny67815 1 month ago
See, she really is an angel..
TheShuushh 1 month ago
This is breathtaking.
Invincibleme9 1 month ago
i love her voice
jin12152 1 month ago
You cannot really compare her version with that of Celine's because
1) This is not her native language so she pretty much have to learn all the words. Try imagine Celine singing in Korean. It's probably would be tuned down a couple points.
2) She's singing this while hanging on on the rope. Considering the amount of accident K-pop had in the past, she's got to be at least somewhat scared sitting there + the way one use vocal would be slightly different when in the air. This is awesome.
Tianx 1 month ago 56
Comment removed
callasalive 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Tianx celine's native language is french, and the fact that kpop stans are even trying to argue that she's a better singer than celine makes me want to projectile vomit. the utter delusion is beyond belief
callasalive 1 month ago 4
@callasalive agreed, and it's sad they marked your comment as spam when it's TRUE
michiganisnotsoco 1 month ago 3
@Tianx The language Celine dion sung it is not her native language either.
eternalsilverlight 1 month ago 5
@eternalsilverlight But you have to agree French and English is a far more "closer" language than Korean and English.
Tianx 1 month ago
@Tianx 1 word genius
SuperMUfans 2 weeks ago
@Tianx i'm not taking anything away from her but celine didn't speak any english when she sang my heart will go on.
krapdavid 2 weeks ago
@Tianx but celine's native language is French,
studystrike 1 week ago
So beautiful!! ~~
tIgGeRnPoOh25 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
i noticed people talking and comparing and everyone says taeyeon is better.i agree cause you can hear and see her passion for music...but why some of you say she doesnt have powerfull vocals...i think she has so much to show us so i always wish for her to do some solo stuff when they arent promoting cause people like her and her singing is amazing emotionaly and vocally
tinafreak1991 1 month ago
take into consideration that she was rising up swiftly while only sitting on this hanging swing/chair so her control over her voice is absolutely astounding :)
Inviernoicec 1 month ago
the highest notes is the ''devine'' part(2:31)
junsokute 1 month ago
Comment removed
junsokute 1 month ago
Taengoo No. 1
junsokute 1 month ago 2
Her voice is beyond holy.
jinsheng01 1 month ago
I actually love Tae's version better than Celine's, and thats not the sone in me- I just like how it sounds better. But in general Celine is magnificent and has a lot on Tae - including experience, which attributes to a lot in music. I love Luna, her voice is amazing- but not breathtaking. Tae sings with true feelings, Luna- not so much, she just sings- she doesn't live the music like Tae and Celine, at least to me. But WHY is this argument EVEN going on? Just enjoy Tae's song people!!
CareBears93 1 month ago 9
i love you taenggooo forever !!!
thejazzyblue 1 month ago
HOLY SHIT! SHE MAKES MY NIGHT SO HOLY HAHA!!! HWAITAENG <3
SJkimchiSONE 1 month ago 2
goodness, i still cant get over how amazing this performance is.
TheShuushh 1 month ago 5
Why are people comparing Taeyeon with Luna and Celine Dion? Luna has a powerful voice but i don't feel any emotions in her singing at all. Taeyeon don't have strong vocals like Luna but she always brings out emotions in a song and I think that is a most important point for a singer. Celine already has both qualities. And she has years of experience far ahead than the 2 girls. Give them (taeyeon and luna) a chance.They still have a long way to learn!
AceSeno 1 month ago 2
Taeyeonie Jjang!! <3333
TammieS2TaeTae3927 1 month ago
thanks
jenet17 1 month ago
tae's voice is so beautiful and the way she sing is breathtaking and can touch your heart, that's why she is one of the best singer in idol world.Some may have more powerful voice, or better range...But I doubt they can sound this beautiful in every notes like taeyeon. this girl is talented..
luv u more and more day by day taengie ah <33
basarabest 1 month ago
i love you taeyeon your voice makes me melt like ice in a summer day... that's how warm your voice is saranheyo nuna
MrPahoe92 1 month ago 4
Taeyeon is not a bitch!!! You are the only only one saying that!
meninabr07 1 month ago
after listening o holy night and devils cry all live how dare you to say taeyeon is not one of the best or best korean pop idol singer....even if you dont like snsd you should appreciate their talents and just shut up cause taeyeon has amazing voice and cant show all in snsd performances and i always thought she should have been solo like iu but i now know that she belongs with snsd cause she is strong outside but really insecure and shy inside so girls help her
tinafreak1991 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I like Taeyeon as singer but I heard she's a bitch in real life
drsnowmon 1 month ago
@drsnowmon
really? then taeng is my type of bitch XD.
i kinda heard you're a bitch too btw.Peace out.
03sone 1 month ago 9
@drsnowmon Is that really true? Where did you hear that? I was always a big fan of TaeYeon
gaoshuayang 1 month ago
TAEYEON ~ SOUND OF HEAVEN IS YOU! ♥
iQuEkun 1 month ago
TaeyeonMyWife
NoNamePutLah1234 1 month ago
This song is nothing about how powerful the voice, it's how much the emotion she put into the song, and why you compare her with Celine Dion, everybody know Celine dion have the holy cover of this song, and i like Celine very much,For me Taeyeon's voice is very beautiful and full of emotion that can really touch deeply into my heart. Compare with Luna? Lol, I love Luna too, She have a really powerful voice but to me, Luna doesn't have the best part of a song - a voice that can touch people or m
Taen9oo 1 month ago 5
@yennyminniesusu
Plus, Taeyeon is less than half Celine Dion's age. Therefore Dion has twice the experience as Taeng does. Taking that into consideration, Tae's version was although not the best, but arguably amazing none the less. (It was the best for me though, and I'm not saying this easily b/c oh holy night is my favourite Christmas song of all time)
Clomodd27 1 month ago
@Clomodd27 r u a sone?
yennyminniesusu 1 month ago
What else can I say>?
Daebak~!!!! My Christmas would be always perfect with her voice beside =]
JackyJ2011 1 month ago
IT'S NOMAL, U CAN SEARCH ANOTHER VERSION BY CELINE DION
yennyminniesusu 1 month ago
@yennyminniesusu Celine is a worldwide diva. She is lyric soprano, this song should be easy for her to sing. But TaeYeon is another story. TaeYeon is a mezzo-soprano, and her range is not really wide. This song is obviously out of her range. That's why her high notes part is so thin and not that powerful. There are some Youtube vids about TaeYeon's high notes. If you watch it, you can clearly see that if the high notes is in her range, she can sing more powerful than this
Caramelcoffee1812 1 month ago 2
@Caramelcoffee1812 i know that but sone always say their taeyeon is queen, angle voice but i think her voice is still young, low level. u can compare her with Luna f(x) u can see!!
yennyminniesusu 1 month ago
@yennyminniesusu Everybody has different taste on music, so I can't say who is better than who. Nevertheless, in my opinion, there are many reasons why Sones say TaeYeon has an angel's voice. And since you mentioned f(x) Luna, I hope you don't mind if I use her as an example compare to TaeYeon. First of all, I have to agree that TaeYeon doesn't have a wide range and can't hit high notes like Luna. But Luna can't absorb herself in the song as deeply as Taeyeon. (Cont)
Caramelcoffee1812 1 month ago 5
@yennyminniesusu Can Luna reach high notes? Yes, she can. But she can't bring the emotions of that song while she sings. TaeYeon can do it (e.g: Can you hear me, If, I love you). To many people, TaeYeon does not only sing the song but she also conveys, tells the story through that song. It touches some people hearts. That's one of the reason why people praise TaeYeon for her singing.
Caramelcoffee1812 1 month ago 7
@yennyminniesusu Second of all, even though Luna can hit higher notes than TaeYeon, TaeYeon has better technique than Luna. Her control of the song and vibrato is extremely good for an idol singer.
Caramelcoffee1812 1 month ago 8
@yennyminniesusu And the last reason in my opinion that Sone say TaeYeon has an angel voice is that her voice really stands out compare to other singers. You can say TaeYeon doesn't have a crystal clear voice or wide range, but she knows how to change her cons into her pros. These days, there are many Kpop singers can reach extremely freaking high notes, but since their voice are crystal clear, some of them may sound pitchy when reaching it.
Caramelcoffee1812 1 month ago 27
@Caramelcoffee1812 what?tell me then those singers :P
Tea23blabla 3 days ago
@yennyminniesusu Yet, for TaeYeon, she may not reach high notes as high as Jessica or Sunny, she may not sing as low as Tiffany, but she uses her husky voice to sing high notes that sounds very soothing to many people ears. Those are the reason why Sone say TaeYeon has an angel voice. A singer doesn't need to sing correct every single note in the song, but the way they put their emotions, the way they can reach somebody's heart is more important :)
Caramelcoffee1812 1 month ago 9
@yennyminniesusu Sorry if by any chance I annoyed you with freaking long reply. I just want to point out my opinion, and just remember that your opinion is different than mine. So I do not intend to make you think like the way I do. Have a wonderful night (or day, it depends on your time zone) =)
Caramelcoffee1812 1 month ago 3
@Caramelcoffee1812 The way you explained it, you sound like a TRUE Sone =)) I love You For that. =) I'll Add you in my Hero List =">
officialPaoLAoRtiZ 1 month ago 3
@Caramelcoffee1812 ok i agree with everything u said, i love the way she sing, her smile but now sone make it go down. she sing well anything famous song and but when she doesnt do it well i just hope her not to do it, when it's really the best, let do it and i will support her! but now i wont. sorry!
yennyminniesusu 1 month ago
another night i can't sleep >___< .... TaeYeon TaeYeon TaeYeon TaeYeon TaeYeon TaeYeon <3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3
hoangduy1991 1 month ago
Fany sure is one lucky girl xD
kpopcali 1 month ago
This is one of my favorite Christmas songs, and Taeng did such a great job ;_; <3 Also, does anyone know what she's saying in the beginning? My Korean isn't that great yet xD
IluvKirito 1 month ago
Best solo so far..from taeyeon!
sgpork 1 month ago
Taeyeon makes me melt.. although i'm a girl!!!!!!!!! Taeyeon hwaiting!!!!!!!!!! unnie saranghaeyo<3
selina429cclq 1 month ago
i love her hair!!!
LMirojiC 1 month ago
wow.. an angelic voice!!!
LMirojiC 1 month ago
She's an angel right?
blitztaeyeon 1 month ago
Taeyeon JJANG!!!
nettehardy 1 month ago
angel voice!!!!!!!!!! tae yeon voice is amazing~~
e1wen 1 month ago
taeyeon's voice is absolutely amazing!
and she makes me so touchingTvT
Taengu, I Love You<3
MichaelaWingWing 1 month ago
Jesus gives two thumbs way way up.
ChocoboJr 1 month ago 94
@ChocoboJr that's what she said
potatoQueenie 3 weeks ago
gorgeous!
lydiaohw 1 month ago
Taeyeonnnnnnn <3333
iheartkpop32123 1 month ago
Phew! Goosebumps all over!! Taeyeon was absolutely AMAZING!
mailee0515 2 months ago
Dear Brother, 100 of these views is me replaying for you ;) I shall download this since aslotuss is slow T_T
brittana1812 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
This has been flagged as spam show
Better than her high notes is the "Fall on your knees" part (1:25min.)
I can't find words to describe. I mean, it's amazingly beautiful...♪
GREAT PERFORMANCE, Ms. SO NYUH SHI DAE, KIM TAEYEON
LoiraPampita 2 months ago
Better than her high notes is the "Fall on your knees" part (1:25min.)
I can't find words to describe. I mean, it's amazingly beautiful...♪
GREAT PERFORMANCE, Ms. SO NYUH SHI DAE, KIM TAEYEON
LoiraPampita 2 months ago 65
Taeng's voice is awesome <3 xmas night becomes warmer <3
camatngu99 2 months ago
Her voice....warm...
kienhpv 2 months ago
Angels' voices!
wingowcs 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
goldendisk.kpopwave 請支持 SNSD
sone fighting~~~
SSF1015 2 months ago
Forever my no.1 bias voice. I see halo above her head <3
brittana1812 2 months ago