Without you Piano (X japan 攻撃再開 2008 version)

[supernina09]

Bravo por tu gran interpretacion. Sencillamente perfecta.

[VWVWWVV]

ชอบมาก Likely perfect AAA++

[KuroiReaper]

This is beautiful! 

[kristinafaustino]

well,there are 7 idiots around who said they didn`t like this!How can someone not love this cover!!!???Well,i also play piano and keyboard by hearing,since i was 3 years old.I have to say this is absolutely PERFECT!Yoshiki would be proud of you.This is one of the most beautiful songs of X-Japan,anyway.The ones who said they didn`t like this,they don`t know shit.They don`t know what good music is.@benzoki,keep up the good work,you are amazing and a great great talent.

[whyldephaier]

most accurate version!

its hard to pick how to play this. in a music PV he played it in B, then the classical is in C, and live its A sometimes. wow

[mveryo]

ピアノ上手いですね。好きな音です。また、聴きたい！

[trovaoftheucn]

that's amazing, your version is really good, I love this song so much.

would you mind if I use your instrumental version to make a vocal cover?, I don't want to be inconsiderate after all that's your property.

[benzoki]

@trovaoftheucn Thanks! Sure. Remember to send me the link of your finished video!

[DarkMiku01]

Beautiful. 

[egtyo]

great！

[9000mudkipzareinert]

You are a god.

[mrkominatovini24]

これ耳コピですか？

楽譜があるなら教えてください！

[benzoki]

@mrkominatovini24

Yea, I played it by ears. and sorry i don't have the music scores~

[mrkominatovini24]

そうですかー・・・残念・・・

でも、すごくきれいです！とても落ち着きます・・

これからもがんばってくださいね！

僕も耳コピやってみます！

[benzoki]

@mrkominatovini24 ありがとうございます！XとYOSHIKIさん大好きですね！

がんばてくだいさい！　Feel free to chat about the improvisation skill~

[ZupYo]

love it , you play it so well , felling say when listen

[shirelidias2008]

esta muito bom....parabens

[hughito]

Love to cry

[benzoki]

Thanks everyone that like my playing, I appreciate every comments that you leave here!

[solbadgear]

thanks for your hard working :X :X :X :X :X :X :X :X :X

[benzoki]

@solbadgear Thanks!

[solbadgear]

You are awesome :X oh my god, wonderful hands

[quynhanh66]

wow .. I love it .. very well played

[onitsuka123]

Wonderful!

[ff7fanboi]

wow this is truley amazing =) was this song hard to learn??

[TheShingjo]

Almost same as Yoshiki! wonderful!

WE ARE X

[hue1991]

we are x!!!!!!!

i love it

thank u very much!:)

[benzoki]

Thanks a lot!! X Forever!!

[japanlove8]

i love it

your play is awesome :)

[LlylBlu]

That's ... beautiful, and precious.

So nice you put the mp3... Thank you !

[benzoki]

Thanks!! Apppreciate that!

[wwhitney22]

Awesome!! I've been listening to it for a whole day.

I found the classical version on a website, and it contains 20 pages! OMG!!

[muciSAD]

beautiful T_T

[thelalaman]

WE HAVE THE SAME PIANO!!!!!!

And i love playing this song with it LOLOLOL

[MrHobomatic]

I almost bought that keyboard. Sounds great, kinda wish I had. Well played, 5 stars.

[MrJap16]

where can i get the music sheet for x japan songs?

[kamui57]

it is the most beautiful piano version i've heard ! Thanks a lot !

[yu313smile]

im longing for the music sheet,i envy u that u are able to 'listen and play' the song...

[e7en]

i can't see your fingers, i want to follow your fingers,,,,

[annespiker02]

hey uh...can you send me this song....I love it and your link doesn't work

[leon0083]

the link works just fine

[VKneokita]

i've had the scores to it. :P lost the link. lol

[nacia182]

wow... so beautiful...

you're great!

it makes me cry...

[xxclouds008xx]

does anyone have the piano music sheets to this song? T_T

[MD092121]

that's great!!

can you share the musicsheet with me???

[jgaara6969]

HI

Have the score of the song without you?

[MLISZMA]

i'ts beautiful!

can you explain how to play this song?

xx

[liliantai]

It's so beautiful! Can you send me mp3?

[hideki192]

beatiful

[linzhilingiloveu]

美しい歌

[pieces141127]

Domo arogato! Kawai!! ( Thank you very much! Beautiful! )

[ragnor86]

** Dohmo Arigatoh! Kawaii!!

[mastermindVMS]

:')

[localchicken]

This is really good I love yoshiki he is so talented。。。how' did you get the piano score？ I would love to play this。。please help thanks

[abrstargo]

Beautiful. :)

[DahliaXI]

Awesome !

[joelibz]

nice short ahorts

[ata761537]

good!!

[matyren]

great! 5/5

[NatalyandCB]

Beautiful song for beautiful person!

Hide in love*

<3

[recreationday]

Loved this :)

[xavipm1]

great =D

[mattcheung3411]

do you mind telling us the chords you used?

thanks

[mattcheung3411]

which key do you play on?

[XiaoNoodles]

hide is not resting in peace. he's rock n rolling in heaven with god and the angels party all night long !

[Witchblade92]

beautiful !! sniff sniff

R.I.P hide-sama

[dukechen1989422]

hey i really like you music. Can you send me the sheet please. I like your version.

[HanLee889]

waw... this is so good... i wonder if you could send me the sheet pls..... ^.^

[KarinDahlia]

Wonderful^^

[l33thustla]

I've watch the first one, this one is even better! what's your secret! You're the best! more please!

[Xjapanmei]

good job...~!^__^

[XxRustyNailxX]

you play wonderful...

[YukarIXMeatball]

i miss HIDE

beautiful song

i love ^ ^

[DarkPromise]

whoaaaah... it sounds so beautiful...

awesome~

[jgsky]

beautiful!

I kinda learnt it from your playing...tried a bit on the piano...will make it perfect when I have time. Thanks!

[fatzeem]

Could you make a tutorial video? or just put the view on top?

[inserthumanityhere]

very,very good.

I mean like VERY good.

[fung1103]

I got to see you...

[deniseaguilar1]

Very good!! luv it!!!

[LaVieYin]

Maravilhoso! Escuto continuamente e nao me canso. Se o sucesso representar a sensibilizacao num ouvinte apenas, entao já o alcansaste. Parabéns! Saudacoes da Alemanha.

[Jeff59950]

So beautiful.....

Could you make a tutorial vidéo please ?

It would be great....

[InfestedRiche]

just added to my favourites :)

awesome job ^^

[pkrunerlt11]

awesom

[Em0rroidi]

R.I.P Hide <3 :< Miss you!

[yisanatran123]

I NEED MUSIC SHEET!!

[benzoki]

***sorry guys. I don't have music sheet for this song. I play it mainly by ears and improvisation..if you really play this song, you can try looking for the without you(classical version) music sheet***

[yshkx81]

what do u mean by u play it by improvisation?? dont u need a piano score to play the music?

[ryukenb2k]

you dont need music sheet if playing piano is in your heart and plenty of pratice,Im naturally gifted at playing piano but never practice,I remember when I had only five lessons,after 16 years of no playing piano it just comes back as if im being guided?I muslim so we cant play instructments like piano which is a shame as im very good,god knows best.peace to u and family

[yshkx81]

where do u find such piano score?? can i have it?? i want it..

[millyto]

Nice Music!!! The sound is very good!

[savacys]

you are gorgeous

[66neko]

cute!!!!!

realy beautiful!!

n.n

[kfcheungyta]

very nice dynamics

probably the best ive seen in youtube so far.

keep up the gd work...DAMN ive been playing Say Anything these days now i gotta move on !!!

[HJW018]

Amazing!

[supermafiagirl]

hey, this is great!!! do you have a sheet of this song, I play piano to you know and it is realy beautiful!

x

[benzoki]

Thanks! I don't really got the sheets music for this song because I played it mostly by improvisation. You can try to look for the classical version piano score. I think it should help!

[supermafiagirl]

classical version? piano score?

but realy I think that it is great! And especially when you improvised it...

realy I play piano to but I'm realy impressed!

[inserthumanityhere]

Holy crap!! That was so good.

Just what i have been looking for.

[freshesballah]

simply beautifful

[96radster]

nice very nice

[tetsuo925]

素晴らしいです。きれい。

[benzoki]

arigatou!

[kai085]

great cover!

[benzoki]

Thanks!~

[plieny]

Beautiful (L)

[benzoki]

Thanks a lot!^^

[kaze111222]

Woah, KAWAII~! Have you got sheets?

[benzoki]

I don't really got the sheets music for this song because I played it mostly by improvisation. You can try to look for the classical version piano score. I think it should help!

[kurokei]

you're really good!! <3

[kurokei]

and do you mind i put this in my phone?

I really love it. =3

[benzoki]

Thanks! Sure! It is glad that you like it!