曹格@週日狂熱夜2007/02/18-頭髮亂了

[sailorchibimoon1665]

Isn't this a korean song

[jerry19860904]

沒唱出頭髮亂了應該有的狂也感覺。唱的很好!就是聽起來很沒fe­ll!可以去聽學友跟EASON合唱版本!!超狂野，聽到都會跟­著搖擺

[PerfectDiver]

Gary 的假音...好難聽...

[223wychiu]

每個唱都有不同的風格.....Gary小時候就聽Jacky唱­歌, Gary是後輩, 唱前輩的歌, 真的唱得很好....

[NgPunWai]

陳奕迅DUO版本好聽D~

[lau881881]

事實證明，中外歌手，凡有翻唱張學友歌曲的，必然死的很慘，強如­曹格亦然！

[marcogalilei]

果然是金曲歌王！

[jeff51552]

看了回復

真為曹格難過

只是挑了一首歌神的歌就被罵成這樣

。

他唱的歌真的好聽

很多歌手都不及他

。

只是這首歌不適合他

[staneim2008]

嗯.....曹格真的是滿會唱的的一位歌手.但我也覺得他字唱的­太黏了一點,不過也許這是他自己詮釋的方法吧.還有假音的部分真­的是虛了一點@@""

[DalCoolCooLaR]

.....看到回復有點火大 !!!

學友的確是歌神沒錯 !

可是我覺得曹格完完全全有能耐跟學友同台!

9個音廣東歌本來比較難唱 !

學友是香港歌手廣東歌掌握的比較好很正常呀 !

平心而論曹格的歌唱實力就是 _1 線_ !!!!

[klsuperman]

@DalCoolCooLaR

曹格的母語是粵語，國語只是他的第三語言（第二是英語）

[DalCoolCooLaR]

@klsuperman 難道他的英文不是比較強嗎? 還有是問題不在於他母語是什麼!而且母語不代表比較標準或拿手 .我只是想說曹格的歌唱實力在廣東話方面未能完全展露 .

[klsuperman]

@DalCoolCooLaR

他的英語確是比國語更好

我也只是說出事實，沒有說過母語是粵語唱廣東歌會好些

[mikeshinoda555]

@DalCoolCooLaR 對..... 曹格是近代歌壇難得的實力派~~~~

聽過他演唱會就更肯定了......

[yc0615]

假音太差了 根本不能跟学友比!

[35660978]

@yc0615 真音太差了 根本不能跟曹格比!我可以這樣說張學友嗎?你試一下去學下曹格唱­superwoman

[yc0615]

@35660978 曹格的真音更差 还有你拿我和曹格比是不是太跌他的价了？事实上，我唱的的确比他­好。

[joekao0730]

Park Jin Young 唱的比較好

[arbalestshum]

@joekao0730 你這句說的太好~haha

[RightFooted123]

I reckon Gary can sing as good as Jacky if he's at a better condition and his Cantonese is more fluent.

[superwoman5181]

唱這首歌，曹格的確遠及不上張學友，他唱不出學友的那種野性的味­道。不過我覺得曹格的歌路跟學友完全不同，不適宜把兩者作比較。­同意minipolochun 所講，曹格是新一代中，聲綫跟實力算是很不錯的一人，加油吧！！­

[stranger4135]

@superwoman5181

因為他唱得太黏了

到了高音為了維持住共鳴採用比較黏的唱法

[minipolochun]

但曹格這後輩~說真的~在唱歌上~一點也沒有失禮張學友,

[maoren722]

麦嫌别拍啦，搁再嫌就干拿赛啦！！

[chmixin]

這怎麼能跟學友比~差多了~

[signal6688]

兩位歌手都是我不同時期的最愛!!大家滿不滿意其實都對~基本上­兩位歌手唱法不同

[signal6688]

不可否認歌神實力很強 穿透力很夠

曹格的音其實很高 我並不絕的歌神可以唱的上曹格的歌

[signal6688]

況且這次節目曹格唱了很多高音的歌 應該會累~~~倒是對於假音很虛我有點驚訝

[signal6688]

大家可以去聽 superwoman中間有一句強假音很高 就在MV中 女主角摔玻璃杯大喊之後那段 ~~跟這首對照的話 感覺是累了 唱不出來罷了

以上請指教 罵小力一點XDD

[madeye0413]

although i am jacky's fan, i think he is pretty good

[oo79o]

不要雞蛋裏挑骨頭了，唱得不錯啊

[hoyun]

假音部位完全唱不出声，这叫不错？

[cheerupbyebye]

跟學友比下去了....

[xcheeb]

That is where all the exp come into play. You can clearly see the difference between gary and jacky. jacky is so much natural in his performance and very high and able to make the crowd go wild too.

[myacnt8999]

gary definitely does't have the great stage presence like jacky. although i think his voice and singing skill can match jacky's.

[wendy9311]

毛孔都豎起哂~

毛骨悚然~驚嚇~

[pshidden]

佢尾段假音好唔點..好似唱唔到學友咁高音...

[myacnt8999]

i want to see jacky cheung sings bei pan or superwoman, so i can see which one is better singer.lol..for me, both of them are amazing singers in their era.

[078319051]

Nice voice!

[xiaoyu871104]

gary尾音都唱太圆啦，带不出这首歌摇滚的味道。。。

anyway~gary还是很棒的~~

[him118]

轉音跟滑音, 還有廣東話不太流利的問題

[admireruchy]

I like both Jacky and Gary. But frankly speaking Jacky is much more better as he perform this song wihout any stress. But gary seem like very tension especially come to high pitch part.

[4evergodofsinger]

hey 'holykhan' !

be polite okay.!!!

don't say dirty words in net.

that's just ashamed you and ur family and also YOUR COUNTRY..!

poor guy...poor guy...poor guy...

[ksyting]

jacky cheung isnt called 歌神 for nothing... I think gary's performance of 頭髮亂了here is not so good. I thought the one he performed on 娱百 is better. But hay, gary still rox!!

[shineluvslambiel]

Sure, you can say Jacky Cheung is better, has more flares etc.... But you can also say Park JinYoung, the original song writer and artist is better.

It's just a different feel.

Vocal wise, I much prefer Gary's voice to Jacky's, but then I prefer Gary to almost anyone. But I do really like Jacky's characters and the way he interprets music. I love them both.

[him118]

gary's voice is too thick for this song

[bloodypenny666]

youtube. com/watch?v=QeKO3UAy7nU

I think this is better...Jacky Cheung Live version

[bloodypenny666]

I think I will listen back to Jacky Cheung version.........that's all!!!

[lokutube]

it's so clear that in his final high pitch part, he can't manage it well... he has already reach his highest pitch. but for jacky chan, he can manage it easily............. watch my you tube also. search "lokutube"

[jocestevieger]

erm most of the time i couldnt make out what hes singing... but i prefer jacky cheung.. he has more emotions..

[fumble123456]

wow...nice

[silvia616]

喔....太會唱了啦

[JackyCh3ung]

ya jacky cheung is way better in terms of emotions, tone and etc...

[aNXie1y]

Love Gary so much

[baobi]

jacky cheung is wayyy better ><

[WeiweiRose]

How come the tempo is slower than the original?

[steph3lai]

luv garyy.. his canto is soo good !!!