Beyond Reality - American Idol 8 Recap 2/25/09

[peaster4]

yall got somethin negative abt mostly all of them lol.

arent yall cool haha 100/5 GJ

[Kultivater]

How could Ryan have something against homosexuality? Didnt you know he IS homosexual?

[dslite804]

Mishavonna Henson should have made this round or at least wild card. i dont see how they didnt like her performance

[ctjazzking]

kai got jipped dont uagree? he was great

[andyelde]

you ROCK i love your critiques, keep going i watch u everyday!

[kellyvk9]

I think Misha, Megan, and Jesse should be brought back over Matt G. who butchered viva la vida.

[sgg107]

You know what's annoying to watch? You too pretending like you're qualified to judge reality tv.

[coolio730]

ITS NOT SUPPOSED TO BE KRIS ALLEN!!! UGGHHH!!!!!

IT WAS SUPPOSED TO BE ALLISON, ADAM, AND MEGAN CORKREY!!!!!!

the judges better bring megan back for wildcard!!!

[coolio730]

sorry, they should bring back megan and/or mishavonna!!!

she has a unique voice!

[CYTcrazy24601]

yah it shouldn't have been Kris........ AND THEN ADAM WOULD HAVE WON

[ScrappIzBaK]

Wow, its like listening to the 4 judges all over again. Cant u guys come up with your own opinions? Iv watched 3 of ur reviews now, and every one you agree with the judges on almost every person. What a waste.

[yaboyy07]

america got it WRONG. it should have been allison, jessie and adam not kris. jesse sang the hell outta bette davis eyes and if she doesn't get a wildcard by the judges i'm gonna be pissed

[xFrequentC]

Nick Mitchell should have gone thru

The second set of 12 Suuuuuuuuuuuucked! (with the exception of Allison Iraheta)

Ricky Braddy was ROBED! He was the best SINGER so far.

[plaisancepleasures]

Adam was Amazing! Im likin you two! I thoroughly enjoyed your recap! Thanks!

[beatleslover1618]

sooooooo boring

[serenitykeeper]

Cool real people commentary and so right on! Adam , Alison and Kris Allen move on. My third pick would have been between Jesse Langseth and Mishavonna Henson ...maybe we'll see one of them in the wildcard round? Very predictable season so far! Thanks for the time and work you have put in to keep us all so well informed from home:) You two are the greatest!

[jonnyskenny3]

I liked allison and of course Norman Gentle was so funny I just can't believe he is on the show, who cares if he makes it it's just funny!!

[JLFROLLTIDE]

aDAM SCREWED UP A GREAT SONG. hE SUCKED

[smdms]

I agree with you. He has a voice for the theatre and he should go back there

[idolrox52]

matt is going to make it because of his fanbase, i like him but not really the performance. NICK/NORMAN SUCKS, the performance was not even funny, he's gone. allison is great.. and mishavonna was amazing! i love adam, too... but i'd love to see him sing something very different..

making it thorugh: adam, allison, and matt.

wildcard options: megan, or mishavonna.

[qtpa2tea]

ADAM WASNT AMAZING!!!!

he sucked

[bookworm186]

My picks for this round are Adam, Megan, and Allison. I really liked Kris, but he's kind of like Ricky Braddy and wasn't seen much. Maybe he has a chance at the Wild Card Round though?

[faitheh72]

i loved Allison (group 2) she rocks hopefully she makes it in the TOP 12

[Masterxazer]

Jasmine and Matt really surprised me, and definitely not in a good way.

Megan was quite decent. I think that if she isn't voted through, she might be a wild card since Simon said he really hoped America would vote for her.

But Adam and Allison are definitely finalists. I think the third one is either Jessie, Kris or Megan.

[Arkansas19852003]

I dont like adam. My Favorite is Kris Allen!

[Epiphany77]

Ryan always makes homosexual comments to Simon because Ryan is a gay man. Simon (and the other judges for that fact) always make comments, so Ryan follows just to make banter. It's all in fun. Trust me, the gay community KNOWS that Ryan has no issue with gays.

[xxxArchieFan4Lifexxx]

My pick for group 2 is:

Adam

Allison

Matt

[rainylandscape]

(continue)

Megan was my favourite from the start, but today was kinda weak, although I love her dearly. And Mishavonna was amazing.

So my choice is:

Matt

Allison

Jesse

wildcard: Megan or Mishavonna.

[rainylandscape]

I really don't see what's the fuss around Adam.

I agree that he can sing, but he is not a singer. Matt Giraud should definitely move on to the next round instead of Adam. I don't hate him, I just think that the hype around him is too much.

I was really excited to see the girls today, because it is the group with all the girls that I love: Megan, Allison, Mishavonna and Jesse.

I think that Allison was incredible and she deserves to go through to the next round, and so does Jesse.

[TomCollinsgirl]

Adam needs to go through.

But i will admit i have watched Norman over and over and over. It was so much fun.

[LadyMatsuyama]

sorry but adam sounds like a 1980;s hair band singer. it was screechy and his movements were very over the top. there are like 5 million singers like that out there.

[maraba90]

you are kind of UGLY to show your faces that often.

[desertrose204]

who ARE you fucking people????

[banananito]

Adam

ALLISON

Norman Gentle

wild card: Kris

[cvaguy]

My pick for group 2 is:

Adam

Allison

Matt or Jessie ( I hope one of them get through wild card )

[Idoljunky32]

My pick for the top 3 and wild card are

Adam: Top Male Votes

Allison: Top Female Votes

Mishavonna: Top Fan Vote

Kai: Wild Card

Much Love Ladies

[whitecaribou23]

i think the 3 should be adam, mishavonna, and allison iraheta. i think kai should then get the wild card. i dont like the new way of how they get the top 12. cuz then people like jasmine who just had 1 bad performance basically have no chance of making it to the top 12. :(

[Poker115]

O and OF COURSE HOMOSEXUALLITY IS WRONG (and disgusting and GROSS). Did u not know that? I'm not sure what u were trying to say about that?

[Poker115]

I'm not sure if u 2 are experts analysts or if you just repeat what the Judges say during the show.

[bakatais]

My fav. was the Alone girl. I liked the tone of her voice.

As for Adam, sheeesh that was completely over the top. Not my cup of tea to be honest.

[yeayea1189]

adam lambert=gorgoues vocalist who has my votes and heart haha

im in love.

[annchan424]

can u quit using "CHOP"??????

[AboutGetClean]

"Pulled her out of menopause!" Classic! :) Agree with most of your comments. Adam & Alison are locks for tonight.

[valleri07]

kris did an awesome job! Too bad they waited until now to show us his talent. Here's hoping for WildCard for Kris!

[jeffregina]

give the title to adam already! he's way above eveyrbody else> i love allison iraheta too! very determined!

[JulianTheGreat01]

Why put Nick thro if we know he's not going to win and if he did win, we can't see him perform on a CD.

You might wanna put him thro to see what else he's got, but he's prett much shown it. NOthing really more.

[hurleygirl593]

hey! can you give me a birthday shoutout? i love your videos! i turn sixteen today :)))) haha thanks! i love u guys!

-Kelsey

[stevenash1386]

my fav was alone

[drdent7]

I thought kris allen was the best for the guys tonight. The 16 yr old red head girl who sang 'Alone' was the best girl. Adam Lambert has a higher vocal range than any of the girls which seems creepy. Plus his tone quality is terrible, but he will propably make it through.

[gumbercules82]

u r wrong stfu lol Adam was the shit go rethink your opinion on music

[drdent7]

Another internet tough guy. Just my opinion. By the way little boy you say that my face and you'll be singing higher than Lambert.

[MrsJasperHale08]

I totally agree with you about Adam

[drdent7]

Excuse my outburst with gumber, I don't think it is necessary to tell someone to 'stfu' just because they disagree with you. Adam will propably be the top vote getter tonight and he is dynamic. But for me he seems over the top but with a range he has I don't think you can hide it.

[MrsJasperHale08]

i think you should tell this t othe other person, not to me cuz I totally agree with oyu about Adam lol <3

[jodalita]

I agree. Why put Nick Mitchell through to the Top 36 and then complain about it? And I can't believe you didn't make fun of Megan's stupid dance during her song. The judges didn't say anything, only Ryan kinda did. Thanks for the recap.

[theSHYkind]

Adam was a bit over the top. Atleast Nick knows he's doing the theatrics. Tonight was horrible.

[MrsJasperHale08]

My family voted 85 times for Matt Giraud!!!! Really hope he makes it!!!!! <3

[JulianTheGreat01]

u keep count?

lol... i just keep pressing redail while i do my homework or something

[MrsJasperHale08]

lol well my family and i were having our own little competition to see who got the most votes in...my dad won he got 38, i got 27, my mom got 14, and my little sister got 6 <3

[JulianTheGreat01]

sounds fun...

but i'm the only one in my family that watches Idol anymore :/. My mom started again, but she's too old to vote :P

[katiekoo215]

adam is going to win!!