Added: 3 years ago
From: dinz1219
Views: 121,074
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,063)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • tuomas war im disneyland (sekunde 1-3)

  • I prefer Annette live. Tarja, realistically, couldn't pull off her full operatic range every night on a tour.

  • i like anette (L) (Y)

  • Oh no, now it sounds like evanescence

  • @metalangel79 mmm don't know, Amy can go way higher than Anette and doesn't have that "pop style", anyway Anette's a good singer, but shouldn't sing the old songs made for Tarja :/

  • after 3 years im stille enjoying anettes version...while people are still bothered with anette-tarja debate!! move on!!

  • u complain about anette being in the band but i would give so much just to be on such concert, and yes with anette, not Tarja, because get over it, she isnt in the band and she will never be again and this is fine, because listen to the Wishmaster sang by Anette, its as beautiful as Tarja's performance

  • Could someone MUTE Annette? Such beautiful song ruined by her "new kids on the block" voice...

  • @dallyborr Could someone MUTE you. Anette did this song very good!

  • аннет отстой

  • this must be absolutely cover.damn i still cant believe that - Nightwish is pop rock band now !!

  • @fldnkckr I can't believe that you don't understand from music nothing!

  • OMG lol...0:56...higher annete higher! cmooon! xD

  • Annette O. might be a nice person but damn it she cant sing....NW is dead...

  • i hate annette because she don' t sing than TARJA!!

    ! GO OUT ANNETTE!!!

  • @Thesofia148 you hate anette just for this reason?!? Sorry, I can't understand you...that's not a good reason for hating someone...

  • @Thesofia148

    You wouldn't like someone like Tarja either. You'd probably accuse her of copying Tarja.

    GET OVER IT!

  • Is this nightwish or a cover D: i mean she can sing but her voice is not for nightwish, now i beleave, nooo, now im sure, nightwish without tarja isn't nightwish

  • if anyone prefers this version over the original one should kill themselves

  • @chronichappy Nah I'm fine. Although You sound like you might do it to yourself because you're that much of a loser XD

  • @ComaLies225 i just might if she keeps on singing like this

  • @chronichappy Hasta la vista! :)

  • @ComaLies225 Baby ;)

  • Now i can understand the lyrics

  • @Noksvalo Yes it is big +. Anette sing clearly lyrics!

  • @Noksvalo

    omg o_O were you so stupid before that you couldn't see lyrics in the Internet?

  • @deathpetcher naa i just couldn't understand what tarja was saying haha

  • @Noksvalo

    have you've got a bad ear? mb you don't know the opera singers have such a manner of singing. or mb you don't know English? i don't see any other reasons not to understand Tarja's speech.

    and do you understand what this pop-star Annet sings?

  • @deathpetcher No. Opera singers need to be clear and have better diction. Tarja sings in an accent and not many people are too fond of that, ESPECIALLY the snobbery that goes in opera.

  • @ComaLies225

    and you are so modern and so new-directed that you don't like opera, and you think you're so cool, and people visiting opera are dull and stupid? and classical music and classical composers are snobbery? how old are you, baby? you're talking like small perfectionist teenager. what do you understand in opera? have you ever been there? can you sing or play any instrument? no, don't think so. otherwise you'd not say so about opera and people who like it.  don't be so narrow-minded.

  • @deathpetcher Lol what the fuck are you talking about? When did I say I hate opera? Listen child, you're reading too much into my post. I actually like opera and I say that as an avid listener. Opera fans expect the best from performers. Obviously it's you who have never been around, talk about pot calling the kettle black!

  • @ComaLies225

    did you just found my comment to you? after 2 month? lol, baby, go back to where you have been and listen to Bieber (as you were recommended), all knowing opera-fan. and by the way, I sang in opera and I know what I say :P

  • @deathpetcher LOL. I find that hard to believe for someone who supposedly sang opera. Tarja's diction is terrible and she needs to stop with her incessant vibrato. She's a good singer but terrible with her "opera voice." BTW, care to show me your talents since you seem to know so much?

  • @ComaLies

    Tarja's diction is nice enough for NW music.when she sings something from opera she makes good.BTW,I'd like to see your talents and knowledges,you say you know a lot about opera singers' diction,tell us about their norms and rules.you called people that go in opera the snobbery, and now you say you like opera.. paradox. or you are also...O_o omg. and BTW it is not polite to interrupt other people's dialog and to answer for other people, I talked to Noksvalo, not to you.

  • @ComaLies225 haha "snobbery that goes in opera", go back to listen to Justin Bieber and make a favor to us all ;)

  • @CaroCerri cute, how long did it take you to come up with that?

    Don't be such a baby. You've obviously never been around opera fans who expect the best from performers. Like it or not, they will tear at anyone who misses a step and if you don't believe me you can look around youtube. Btw, you listen to Evanescence, like you have any right to talk XD

  • @ComaLies225 I know the ambient of opera is very rigid, I just had gotten a bit pissed b/c I interpreted it as a personal opinion against her, not as a fact. I'm sorry, it was my bad cuz I misunderstood the whole thing. I don't make these kind of comments ever, I'm just too sick of all the hate comments (towards both singers) in every single NW video, it's really tiring. and yeah, Evanescence is getting too pop, but I still like them for Amys old compositions and the whole message of the songs.

  • WTF what a freakin voice, sounds like Donald Duck....this cant be serious

  • @Kintharra

    Relax Mickey, just relax.

  • Fuck Nooo!!!!!!

  • Mi się bardziej podoba Anett niż Tarja. :d według mnie ma fajniejszy głos. może to dlatego, że nie lubię takich operowych głosów

  • Siiiiiiiii, muy buena interpretacion por parte de Nett♥ me gusta que NW haya cambiado de estilo, ahora son mas originales, \m/

    Larga vida a NW♥ que no se muera el sueño solo por que un Diva intento destruir la banda..♥

  • Tomaxzo, Tarja can easily sing Anette's songs cause they are too simple to sing... That's a fact

  • diosss como dañaron esta cancion... anette parece a mi sobrinita de 6 meses tratando de hablar..... q bajo ha caido nightwish.... !!!

  • ME GUSTA ES DIFERENTE PARA VARIAR XD SIIIIIIIII  RULEA XD XOXO

  • Now, they sound like a gay band...pathetic. They should do a project with Justin Gayber too :)

  • @castorel UR THE ON THATS F*

    CKING PATHETIC UR HERE ONLINE WATCHING THERE VIDEOS

  • @WHISHMASTER49

    oh go cut yourself if you are so butthurt.

  • "the spotlight was on her and not the rest of the band " that's exactly why they wanted her out!! they couldn' stand being #2 in the band, that's why they searched for someone like Anette. Tarja has a stunning presence on stage, with or without Nightwish, and they saw that coming. Now with Anette, it's much easier for the band to stand out, don't you think? There was an ego issue, that's all!! Honestly, I'm glad Tarja left the band, she's done such an amazing job by herself!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Anette, my wish..........IS YOU!! I Love you.

  • ¡Pobre chava, no se me hace justo que la pongan a cargar una espada que no puede blandir!

  • @oceanodefuego1 CHINGA TU MADRE WEY

  • her vibrato doesn't make my ears bleed :(

  • She should sing her own songs and not the old Tarja songs. She make the old songs sound bad. Her own songs are very good. But what she is doing with the old songs is a sacrilege

  • ok....here's the thing....i like tarja and anette...i like and enjoy them both for each has a unique voice. however...the thing anette does in her vocals ( 3:37) kind of ruins the line...it's a pity...she can do amazing things with her voice (like in "Sahara")...she has to get more confident while singing old nightwish songs...

  • I don't care about who is better, who is the better match for the band or any of the rest of the shit. One thing I will say is that, as a Tolkien fan, the way she butchers Elbereth's name is a god damned abomination.

  • This is a brilliant song! I love this version as well as the old :D Honestly, you can see the whole of Nightwish looks much happier. Look at the old live videos e.g. End of an Era. The others looks miserable, and now they can't stop smiling and having a good time :D Love Nightwish!

  • @violetfield95 in End of an Era no one of the members look happy because they had already fired Tarja, so they probably didn't care being on stage with her any more... maybe they also wanted to make the audience believe that thay had no chemistry in the shows, but I think that was all made on purpose. all they wanted was not to be in Tarja's shadow any more, she took them away their protagonism and of course they didn't like at all..

  • @julidimarco but in an interview, Tuomas said that Tarja was only in it for the money, so she used it to her advantage.... don't get me wrong im not saying i don't like her cos she is an amazing singer but to be honest the spotlight was on her and not the rest of the band but in this every single band member has the spotlight on them

  • Her voice is okay, but there is no way she fits Nightwish, not even close - Tarja was perfect!

  • @BandaDK except for the part of being a good band member and not being a complete cunt.

  • My god.. her voice sucks ass -.-' no offense but she just can't sing, I wish I could see Tarja back on the stage..

  • Huuuuu q te paso mami? no llegaste a la nota cuando tenias q cantar "Lorihen"?

    sos una hija de puta, no te das cuenta de q no te da la voz? ANDA A HACER ALGUN COVER DE BRITNEY SPEARS PEDAZO DE FORRA! Y DEJA ESTOS TEMAS A LOS CANTANTES LIRICOS!

  • @yanosequemierdaponer QUE MENTE TAN PEQUEÑA TIENES XD PATETICO XOXO

  • @IVIWAY99 mente pequeña? Tarja soprano y esta mina no puede mantener una nota? Se nota q no aprendió ni siquiera a respirar como se debe, ya q no llega a las notas q el tema requiere. So,a mi me parece q vos estas mas sorda q un topo alguien con un poquito, pero un poquito de oído se da cuenta de q la mina no puede hacer ese tipo de música. Pero no te preocupes! los nenes q empezaron a escuchar metal hace dos días se suelen impresionar con este tipo de flagelos, algún día aprenderas :D See you

  • @yanosequemierdaponer MI VIDA SI NO QUIERE NETTIE CANTAR ASI DEJALA ELLA SIGUE Y SEGUIRA EN NIGHTWISH ADEMAS SU VOZ A MEJORADO MUCHO, 2 DIAS DE METAL? XD LLEVO AÑOS Y SI DE VOCES HABLARAMOS TE ENVIARIA MUCHO A LA CHINGADA BYEEEEEEEEE NUEVO CD DE NIGHTWISH YA VIENEEEEEEE *0* XOXO

  • @yanosequemierdaponer jajajaja 2 años? se nota! ahora entiendo todo, disculpa pensé q hablaba con alguien q sabia de musica. Sabes por donde pasa el tema? yo no critique a nadie q haya dicho q le guste esta mina, yo te acepto tu comentario de q te guste, entonces porque no podes respetar el mio? es lo q no entiendo. Si te sentiste tocada, I am sorry. Aprendé a escuchar todas las opiniones. Una cosita: cuando insultas significa q no tenes mas nada inteligente q decir ;) suerte

  • Better as i aspected!

  • come on guys and gals get over it sometime tarja is of the band 5 years ago!annete is the new singer of the band!if you like tarja more follow her in her solo carier!and listen the bullshit she sings now!!!nightwish must move on and annete was the best forward step the band ever made!sory for my english!

  • porke en lugar de llamar a una cantante buena como annette no llaman a otra soprano tan buena como tarja ?

  • anyone else who can't actually hear what she's singing or just me?

  • la mejor canción de nightwish y esta p%t& la arruina de esa manera......... un insulto para todos los fans de nightwish

  • mmm I accept Ever dream and another old songs from Nightwish in Annete´s voice and style...but this...in this songs she sangs horrible. She is not soprano for sing this song.

    Her voice is nice but she hasnt powerfull...Im sorry Annete, this is not your song.

  • canciones como estas deben qedar solo con tarja. 

  • Her voice isn't powerful enough, so she has to scream and yell the lyrics. Not good.

  • She should'nt sing old nightwish stuff.

  • its more a screaming from her, thought they were searching for a "singer"?? oO

  • PURAS HECES SONORAS ¬¬ AGH, NIGHTWISH SIN TARJA NUNCA SERA NIGHTWISH....

  • SIN COMENTARIOS!

    ES HORRIBLE NI TERMINE DE VERLO!!!

    JUJU CHAOOO!!!!

  • Wow yeah where is Anette`s voice?

    I can hear the band (know its not high HD live:p )

  • Sie spricht Deutsch!?

  • this one ain't that bad

  • @sejjtan is right!!!! hahahahahahaha "Hamster...Steven Seagal!! hahahahaha LMAO! But anyway, anette has a great voice but this not convince me at all...better tarja!!! for ever!!!!

  • am i the only one that love more annette than tarja ?? well anyway her voice sounds more ''metal'' than tarja and i love it this way :)

  • @MrLucgauthier Yes, u are. :D.

  • @skumpik666 haha

  • 0:47 looks like there's fire coming out of anette's hands..

    cool ! ^_^

  • Mittlerweile wurden die songs umgeschrieben und auf Annette angepasst und ich als Mega Tarja Fan mags auch hören was sie nun Singt =)

    Daumen Hoch für Annette und NW und Natürlich au ch für tarja <3

  • Tarja cuanta falta haces, nadie igualará tu voz, pero vale el esfuerzo de Anette. Todas las canciones de Nightwish tenían una atmosfera increíble con la voz de Tarja, te llevaban y te hacían sentir la música, ahora es muy distinto. Mejor que saquen más canciones nuevas.

  • This song is AWESOME with Anette!

  • Comment removed

  • better than tarja!!

  • Anette does a really good job with fast paced old NW songs like this and "Wish I Had An Angel" in my opinion. But it's the "prettier" songs like "Ever Dream" and "Nemo" that she needs a little work on.

    I love Tarja AND Anette!!!!

  • I do find it funny that the only people who will call NW for pop is Tarja hardcore fans... don't get me wrong here i love Tarja very very much but i also happn to like Anette. But the point is that i don't understand what's more metal with Tarja's voice than Anette's. If NW is pop now than it most have been opera before.

    Isn't that right?? :P

  • @emil9412 Yeah, you are very very right :D

  • definitly.... NO...

  • anette sucks balls in NW..

  • They should have asked Floor Jansen to sing for NW... ;)

  • What happened to the Oceanborn nightwish..

    Wishmaster is not wishmaster with that pop voice .|.

  • i love the way she sing " this rifle " !!! she sing awesome

  • I don't care if you prefer Tarja over Anette but saying that she sounds like a pop singer just because she doesn't use lyrical style it's so IGNORANT, people grown up!

  • @Himynameistorres So true! and I hear a lot of celtic music and female singer's voices are similar to Anette's, so her style goes perfect for epic music ;)

  • she got a lil beter sisn i see her but sitll not my hit

  • The Music is still Awesome, But to bad they lost the Original singer, This one sounds to pop. Theres no Originality and she hits alot of off notes.. Anette SUCKS !!!

    Tarja Turunen Was Awesome, Original, Great voice, was not pop, but had a style of her own... Miss you Tarja

  • The Music is still Awesome, But to bad they lost the Original singer, This one sounds to pop. Theres no Originality and she hits alot of off notes.. Anette SUCKS !!!

    Tarja Turunen Was Awesome, Original, Great voice, was not pop, but had a style of her own... Miss you Tarja

  • I hate Nightwish since 2005. No Tarja no fun.

  • Anette Olzon Little bit good in this song =D

  • Anette can't sing Tarja, that's a fact.

    Tarja can't sing Anette, that's a fact too.

  • @Tomaxzo Tarja never tried! AND That´s a fact!

  • @Tomaxzo

    thats one fact i think alot of Nightwish fans can't get through their heads is the fact when they hired anette they wanted a new sound. they knew she couldn't sing tarja. and thats why they hired her

    It wasn't like they hired her and was like "oops nightwish fans... we fucked up" no they knew what they were doing

  • @ghostviddebunker Yep. This is what they wanted. And for every fan who does not want the same, they are just not the right band any more. No use bitching and whining, they won't change it back.

  • @ghostviddebunker I don't really mind, Tarja was a bit to opera for me, but Anette is way to poppy to my liking too. WIsh they went with someone more in the style of Sharron or Simone but with a voice of her own.

    Anette is way to generic.

  • @ghostviddebunker yes they might did that but it is only right not to make her sing old songs and royally fuck them up....

  • @ghostviddebunker

    While that may be true it does not change my taste on that songs like wishmaster just sound better with Tarja. No offence but her voice suits those songs so much better. Ofcourse they moved on and so should the fans, Tarja is past. But having an opinion about what sounds better to someone stays

  • @Tomaxzo Your analogy is so correct, Annette would be much better off with her own songs {yet to be composed}. Nightwish must make the necessary corrections because this sad ass nonsense just can't go on as it is. People tossing pictures of Tarja and giving Annette the middle finger all the while she's singing onstage is cruel and aberrant behavior, Tuomas and the others need to find a solution for Annette before something terrible happens. Take care.

  • @Tomaxzo of course Tarja can't be so horrible singer as Anette hahaha,that's imposible

  • @Tomaxzo you don't know a fucking thing about NW. Annete can adopt to sing songs that tarja preformed in opera voice, annete sings in rock voice. And still she has amazing thrillers, great high notes and no falsches like Tarja had. So GTFO u fcking retard and get over this: Tarja is history! This is new Nightwish!

  • @MySteryDzeko What are you talking about? I'm not saying Anette is bad or something. She's good, but different in style.

  • Tattered cat!!  Get away from the scene!!!

  • out of tarjas songs that anette tries to sing but isnt as good by far...this is the best and is almost as good as tarjas

  • wow i'm so glad i fell asleep during their show!

  • For me this is the only song which is too Tarja-ish ,no one else can sing it well.

  • This chick cant stand even in Tarja`s shadow...

  • tarja vs annette

    wniner tarja

  • kralho q merda!!! a tarja sim é vocalista

  • i have to say... she s hot. greetz.

  • I don't think she should sing the old songs. Thous are Tarja's.

    She performs well in the new ones, thay are suited to her voice

  • o.O OMFG poor Nightwish...thank you Tarja!

  • Awesome!

  • Digan lo que digan la voz y la presencia de Tarja hacian de Nightwish una banda realmente sólida, en verdad una voz hecha para el metal, la voz de Annette no es mala pero no es para metal, al menos no para cantar las canciones de los primeros discos. Tarja simplemente la mejor!!!

  • annette's good, I must say that, but this is a song written for tarja's voice, I don't wanna compare them, but I just want to defend her, annette must borrow herself to sing the classics even thou the vocal lines are higher than she can even think....anyway this was a very good performance on a great stange and festival

    hope to see them live in italy

  • the way she sings, the way she moves...it's like see hannah montana

  • @videos99p miley`s better  :/

  • I have no problems with Anette! this not sounds bad but anyways I think she is not a good singer....at least for this kind of music, is a little and screaming voice but Tuomas chose her, the public is becoming less demanding, the truth is that now they only have teenage audience ...

  • @videos99p You've never been to a Nightwish concert. stop talking shit

  • @JimKnopf15 yeah I've never been to a new NW concert because I'm not a teenager :D

  • @videos99p: I told you to stop writing bullshit; in fact there are tons of older people, much more than at any other (Metal-)concert that I've been to.

  • @JimKnopf15 now I can unserstand why you like Anette...pfff bullshit? you have a problem with differents opinions to you

  • @videos99p It's not about opinions. That's why I wrote "in fact" because it IS fact that there was a huge amount of older people (past 30/40) at Nightwish concerts.

    Also I never wrote that I like Anette (I do, though); you're 20 years old but the way you argue and behave is not very grown-up.

  • I never understood why Nightwish doesn't have a second guitarist. They would sound so much fuller. Nevertheless, what an awesome band.

  • well they have to get over it they can't do anything about it if they don't like it they don't have to watch it

  • finally i see coments that are nice she is a good singer this is one of my favorite songs and its good to see there are some people that arent just trying to look for things to hate her even more

  • @14purplecats Its no about hating Anette its about ruinig something some ppl like so much...

  • I really love Anette's voice here, really feel the power.

  • lol :(((

    ppl paying real money to see this performance?

  • no la pongan a cantar esto, no puede, ella tiene otra voz, otro estilo, digamos...más pop...ella NO puede cantar grandes temas como este.

  • @elmeromerohomero ps dicelo a Tuomas

  • Anette totally owns this song, I can always feel the power she has when she is singing!

  • tarja tarja tarja es la mejor

  • @mikey51653 lol no 

  • Emppu is an epic metal elf!

  • she yells too much, maybe she sould do falsetto to achieve higher notes, no?

    still not a bad performance

  • I love it! This version is better than Tarja's!

    And u can understand everything she sings! Anette YES :D

  • Anette canta bien, pero en estudio, en vivo no le llega ni a los talones a Tarja.

    Es una simple opinión, sin ánimos de ofender a nadie.

  • Temos q fazer uma campanha para a volta de Tarja ao Grupo. TODA VES QUE VIRMOS ESSA NOVA CANTORA NO YOU TUBE COLOCAREMOS A SEGUINTE FRASE: "VOLTA TARJA" "VOLTA TARJA" "VOLTA TARJA" "VOLTA TARJA" "VOLTA TARJA" "VOLTA TARJA" "VOLTA TARJA" "VOLTA TARJA" "VOLTA TARJA" "VOLTA TARJA" "VOLTA TARJA" ...
  • @josielmetal Quit spamming. And come on dude, your campaign isn't for gay rights, it isn't for dying childred in africa or rape victims, its for bringing a singer back into a band, get a life.

  • perderam muito com a saída da tarja. nem se compara. ta uma droga!

    ...

  • No way man u can't compare the new singer to Tarja, Tarja rules man.

  • @Ramzykh haha , you cant prove that

  • Fuck everyone who is still bitching about Tarja... Anette is awesome, however, more importantly and usually overlooked, Empuu is fucking flawless as always.

    Awesome performance!

  • @Asinity1984 Finally another smart person who knows when some stupid arguement (or however you spell that xD) is enough, and really, enough. The tarja vs annette thing has been on ever since and it's getting tiresome indeed. Both are good, face it, now shut up. Either way: Awesome live performance yet again! :D

  • Wow, I can understand what Anette sings. I can´t hear "Hamster, a dentist, hard porn, Steven Seagull, warrior, this rifle, in me, the fishmaster "anymore. Keep it up Anette!

  • @Sejjtan LMAO oh god that funny, and whats hilarious is that she can actually sing that and no one would notice.

  • @Sejjtan hahahaha I love you dude LMAO :DDD

  • @Sejjtan no you dont hear that anymore

    instead you just hear noise and not music, nevermind the song Wishmaster...

  • @Sejjtan \o/ It was funny to hear it with Tarja, Anette has more prounonciation

  • @Sejjtan

    BEST. COMMENT. EVER. Made me burst out laughing at work, man! hahaha

  • @Sejjtan it was actually with tarja's version of this song that we were able to understand '' Hamster' a dentis, etc,etc :)

  • @Sejjtan great that u can understand her... ok so she can speak... now tell her to SING :)

  • esa culera no canta bien necesita ayuda de voces del bajista tarja no necesitaba refuerzo su vos es maravillosa y anett no le llega ni alos pies de tarja aguante tarja ereas la mejor

  • I never was a really fan of nightwish, and the truth was coz i really hated tarja, i just hated her personality, but the music and her voice was amazing, and the music band still great and tarja's voice will exist forever im afrad.