Added: 5 years ago
From: jre58591
Views: 68,202
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (164)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • will everyone stop making fun of Lang-Lang! idk y nobody likes him becuase he is in fact a very expressive and successful pianist! so unless you can do better, just shove off :P

  • @jigglypugz Actually, I think I can do better and have done better than Lang Lang (even though I don't have his money nor performance engagements). I will continue to bash him. He deserves it.

  • @jre58591 why? bashing other succesful pianists will not make you a better one...

  • @jigglypugz Yeah, but I'm not bashing them to make myself a better one. I'm bashing them to make sure people know how terrible they are (when they are terrible). Internet = free speech.

  • @jre58591 I'm a fan of both Lang Lang and Hamelin, for different reasons.

    Yes, the popularity is unfair, but why is that my problem? These pianists don't need defending.

    You're free to voice your opinion, but that's not the point. The point is, why be an asshole? There's something deeper in you than just them being terrible. There's hatred there, and you're trying to mask it by only saying they're shit.

    Lang Lang's performance of Liszt's 1st P Concerto is pretty good, by the way.

  • @jre58591 if he was truly awful, he would not have so many followers and be so successful....

  • if you are a fan of the OTHER tube, the X one...as I am...it may strike you the way Mr. Hamelin works the piano, I hesitate a bit to call it "plays", gets along with the action at the other place, the threesomes, and so on...really rarely has a pianist's "work" that kind of versatility...certainly Mr. Hamelin has got something going here...

  • Fully agree with Nattino. Great musician but by far underrated. Maybe a wrong agent or bad marketing? For example also seen Anna Ivanova doing Liszt. Why are so many good musicians so hidden?

    Anyhow he is great.!

  • I see it, but I can't believe it ._.

  • Uh... pianist AND COMEDIAN Hamelin? Weird...but wonderful!

  • I love how reaches back and whacks the low a at 3:39. Fabulous Hamelin.

  • he's still playing piano in heaven, i hear it all the time

  • @iBadx3 I don't think he's dead, bro

  • @iBadx3 he's not dead! He's not old at all!

  • I don't think he was satisfied with his performance!

  • Hamelin is an absolute genius!

  • why is it called triple etude? I hear at least 5 of chopin's etudes in his play. sorry if he said that at the beginning, but i can't hear his comments through my laptop speakers.

  • @benji104

    Interesting! Could you name those 5 etudes? This one's primarily based on the 3 a minor etudes, but I guess he included references to others?

  • @twooffour apart from these 3, I hear a bit of 10/5 and 10/12. But after hearing it again, it is certainly not a serious reference. The melody of 10/5 sounds similar to the left hand of 25/11 for me. And the more or less chromatique runs in 10/12 and 25/11 are also similar.

  • Haha, he misses the last note, but it's still perfect! I love this guy. He's an incredible musician and has a great sense of humor. He seems to be a really cool person.

  • @andreenzo U spelt that asshole's name bad YAY!

  • Man I wished Hamelin could come and play at the Walt Disney Concert hall here in LA. But instead I get Bang Bang.

  • @abmsghost :-))

  • lol

  • @nyc11104 And your comment amounts to little more than elitism...

  • Holy cow!!! It sounds like THREE pianists at 2:53!!!

    This guy is amazing!

  • Wow, so modest. If i could play like that i would be insufferable.

  • Just unbelivable 0_0

  • Well hamelin can't ever be as hyped as lang lang or some others, because he won't play those overplayed pieces to the audience. Also the pieces he is playing requires open mind and sometimes lot of musical knowledge before you can understand the complex structure inside the piece, like in this one. As less there are classical musical listeners only small percent of those are willing to hear hamelin. I think this is the highest point of music and let it be like this. Hype will destroy it.

  • @Aul1kki Nowadays he plays more standard repertoire, but he still does it very well.

  • ribadisco: LO AMOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!

  • dude, it's just plain freaky as shit how good Hamelin is.... this is soo beyond me and over my head it's not even freakin funny

  • INGENIOUS & DARING in both CONCEPTION & EXECUTION.  Bravo!

  • Well, this is an ETUDE, and as such it presents severe technical challenges which Hamelin meets with ease. This piece is extremely difficult to play. It i such a pity Hamelin's work is not more widely recognized.

  • i stood up and applauded at my computer

  • @Fuuko0924  LoL

  • I did in my pants...

  • Hamelin is a Master!!! =D!! This etude is very nice =P!! But I like more this one: Chopin Etude "Badinage" by Godowsky.

    /watch?v=s0B_R4iOIIw (Alexander Moutouzkine).

    /watch?v=V8U1s57ror8 (Marc André Hamelin).

  • what concert hall is this at?

  • Vive le Hamelin!

  • why so much attention on fastfingers.nowadays everyone plays a fast clean Schumann toccata and many youngsters do godowsky studies.MANY thousands indeed.but how many would you really care to hear play a Schubert long sonata or even a slow movement.Volodos has both qualities.Liszt was more than fingershe could site read orchestarl scores&maybe hypnotic powers.his students dont sound sogreat except forSauerRosenthal theyhad personalities and thast the wHOLE STORY.NOT FINGERS BUT PERSON!

  • I'm sure Hamelin knows plenty of slow music.

  • @lovesGenet So what's your pernt?

  • Hamelin ist ein Tastenzauberer. Er ist ein Virtuose im besten Sinne.

  • This is really interesting! And funny too. And unbelievable.

  • madoooooooooooooo!!! UN GENIO!!!!!!

  • @flic71 ¡de verdad!

  • Op 25 No 11,Op 10 No 2,but I cant gues what the third one is. any way it must be in A minor too.

  • yeah thats it Op 25 No 4 the key word is A minor..

  • op 25 no. 4

  • Buffoonery? He's probably the most technically gifted musician in the world. Perhaps ever.

  • @Jim341046 The most technically gifted musician currently living, and probably in the last century. But Liszt and Alkan are probably one step above him.

  • uh i don't think Liszt would have taken to Godowsky. I'm quite sure many pianists are as gifted as Liszt now. Don't forget that the range of technique only increases through time. Before Chopin, no one dared to play chromatic scales with 4th and 5th fingers - and Godowsky is even more of a revolution. So.... i guess it's debatable.

  • Love Alkan. Listen to Hamelin play his concerto - unbelievable. Also listen to Alkan 'Le Vent' and my favorite - Prelude in E Minor

  • Never! at the time of Alkan and Liszt the pianos were very soft and light , so, today our pianos are so heavy that a Virtuoso really needs very developed muscles...

  • @henseltetude The keys were also very thing which required extreme precision. And since the keys required barely any strength to get a sound, Liszt and Alkan must have had absolutely great control.

  • @henseltetude

    You are right. I agree with you, anyway. Alkan's Le Chemin de Fer Op. 27, Comme le Vent Op. 39 No. 1, C Major etude Op. 35 No. 1, and Hands Reunited Op. 76 No. 3 are probably MUCH easier to play fast on the pianos of that time. In fact, if you read William Alexander Eddie's book about Alkan, he (Eddie) talks about that.

  • i thought it was "pornographically interpreted version of chopin"... actually try to use some correct grammar before you diss someone :(

  • Care to explain yourself?

  • I love that little; "Im done everyone, you can- oh - (low note) - NOW im done!"

  • The most underrated pianist of our time. In spite of his great ability as a supervirtuoso, and sincere interpretations....most of the hype goes to the likes of Lang lang and others. A few years ago I was privileged to hear Marc-Andre at Alice Tully Hall in NYC, and the hall was not even half full. The sad thing is, it only seats about 1100 people. Who ever missed it...it was their lost.

  • @Naltino Perhaps there are very good reasons why the hall was half-empty, think about it :-)

  • @Bret6464 No one can say why the hall was half empty. It was one of the greatest piano recital I'd ever witnessed. Hamlin is not a showboat. He's a pianist's pianist. Though you may disagree, but that is my opinion. Sadly, I find that musicians who act while playing their instruments attract the most people to their concerts. There is much to learn from Hamlin as a pianist.

  • @Naltino Think it is a question of preference, both Lang Lang and Hamelin are great pianists, but I would not go to either's concert/recital. Sorry about putting both names in the same sentence :-)

  • @Bret6464 Lang Lang is not a "great" pianist. He is merely a pianist with great skill and no musicality that caught a lucky break.

  • @OriginalBasaliskos that's questionable.

  • @Naltino Such a pity. But he seems truly to be a pianist for pianists, like Godowsky, and that an average person wouldn't catch neither the supreme technical achievements nor the musical significance of the Godowsky etudes, so that kind of explains it. Of course, Hamelin is one of those pianists which you almost cannot find an equal, even when we're talking about other first-rate pianists. Not many other people can play the Godowsky, Alkan, Busoni, etc.

  • I'm sorry, I didn't understand... Can somebody tell me - is his "friend of mine" Godovsky? Or this is his piece?

  • For me, this "friend of mine" is simply Hamelin himself - him in the capacity of a composer and arranger, incontrary to him as a piano virtuoso ...

  • Hello! Thank you:) Yes I know he is a composer too, but I know alsow he is a canadian! But on this video he said "one friend of mine...EUROPEAN" And really Godowsky has transcription of these three etudes of Chopin - op.10 #2, op.25 #4 and op.25 #11. But the texture of this piece is not like Godowsky. He loved more variations and to decorate his pieces with many small notes... I don't know:( Maybe he said about Godowsky?

  • I am honored to listen to this guy....

  • A level of coordination between left and right brain that is almost superhuman. For him it is child play, for another it would be a lifelong study. Listen to it repeatedly to get a feel what this involves ...

  • This stunt pianist has some hidden extra fingers. I can´t imagine a stronger technique. In a way Hamelin is underestimated. Why don´t people talk about him as frequently as about Lang Lang?

  • I guess it is a choice, look at his personnality, he is very discreet, composed

  • He makes everything look too easy, doesnt bounce round so much as lang lang, and, overall, isnt hated so much as lang lang :)

  • Marketing.

  • Great Imagination, Staggering Execution!

  • he's amazing

  • This man is an ET ! :O

  • creative, indeed

  • the left hand doing funny stuff.

    bit of jazz there?

  • His use of pedal, dynamics and similar can be improved no doubt but it is great little etude for supervirtuosos.

  • "pedal, dynamics and similar"? Would you like to elaborate? What exactly are you you trying to group, considering that pedal and dynamics are two COMPLETELY different things? Do you know, or are you just a pretentious bullsh*tter?

  • you can change the tone a lot by using the pedals in a tastefull way, you can change the dynamics a lot tooo to make it more interesting

    Horowitz is a great example of a pianist that was a master of that

  • So is Sergei Rachmaninoff and Glenn Gould a good example.

  • what did he do at last

    why were they lughing

  • He crossed himself before playing his etude^^

  • no

    I didn't mean that

    what I wanna know is what they were laughing at end of his playing 3:37 ?

  • He missed the last note while coming to an end and he went back to play the right note. His face was priceless at that moment!

  • Hahahaha thats as funny as ironic!!

  • He plays 3 hard etudes at once... I would be content with the ability playing them in a row...

  • Una pregunta, la ultima nota no le salio la primera vez o es asi la obra?

  • Holy cow ... he can do anything.

  • Thanks piano0989! ... just a typing mistake!

  • I heard "Winter Wind" and the "Chromatique" etude, but what is the third one??

  • 10-2 The ballerina(chromatique)

    25-4

    25-11 Winter Wind

  • some lefties from op.25-4

  • argh this is so insane. i have his complete chopin godowsky but this is just--

    I WANT THE SHEETS

  • Fantastico molto! A brilliant and clever piece of mimicry, with just enough of Hamelin, Godowsky, and of course Chopin. One almost has to listen to it three times to follow each etude's themes as they are put through the transcriber's sieve.

  • What a monster of dexterity...

  • Hamelin seems like a really friendly, down-to-earth guy... unlike Cortot who just looked like a zombie most of the time.

    I love it how he crosses himself before he starts :P

  • We need not to forget that they both lived in different eras...! Everyone looked like zombie in Cortot's time! It's really funny! Picture where no one is smiling because they had to keep the exact same positions for like... 10 minutes!!! Still, I really appreciate both of these pianists!

  • Marc Andre has totally ripped off this piece from Joyce Hatto before her death a year ago.

  • Actually, Joyce Hatto was a fraud. "Her" recordings have been exposed as reissues of other pianists' performances under her name.

    Glenn

  • duh! ever heard of humour?

  • Oh, was that supposed to be funny?

  • Sorry, sarcasm. In a flourish of super human productivity the dotty Joyce Hatto(who no one had heard of or seen perform)in her 70s, cancer ridden and in a wheelchair, put out two CDs of Godowsky Chopin transcriptions. They were ripped off from three other pianists including Marc-André Hamelin.

  • ... actually... Joyce Hatto recording of Godowsky etude IS March-André Hamelin. I own one a her TRUE recording... she's not fantastic at all...! Sorry!

  • Good news, everyone! I won't be playing this anytime soon.

  • hahahaha!

  • Op. 10 n 2

    Op. 25 n 4

    Op. 25 n 11

    All 3 A minor studies

  • I know he mixes in Winterwind and Op. 10 No. 2, but whats the third etude mixed in?

  • op 25 nr 4 -- you can see it for free at imslp DOT org

  • not anymore im afraid

  • Fear not! IMSLP is opening back up in July.

  • Its a shame we cant see his left arm, thats where the real 'action' is.

  • actually, grand pianos are almost always equipped with one. it is uprights that can sometimes either have a practice pedal, nothing, or a "half" una corda pedal (if you know what i mean) in place of a sostenuto pedal.

  • I recently heard for the first time Hamelin. It was his playing of Rzewski's El pueblo unido jamás sera vencido, I never heard that piece before neither. I do not what kind of adjective to uso to express my sensation after I listened to him...Fantastic'? maybe...

  • fantastic would be an understatement, in my opinion.

  • sounds kinda like toccata by prokofiev ..... but it isnt ^^ ..... can anyone please tell me what the middle pedal is for ?

  • what a great artist!

    amazing technique!

  • amazimg piece, amazing player, i just found out that Hamelin has been in my dads car!!! no less!, when he was alot less well known he did a concert somewhere and my dad was on the concert commitee and he gave him a lift back to the station!!

  • Not only the best living pianist, possibly the best that ever lived

  • Hamelin is playing Joke. He has played some more difficult pieces. This is amazing, of course!

    I am inclined to say that Hamelin is the greatest living pianist of the World.

  • your inclination would be correct, for many many reasons.

  • Great Etude.

    AMAZING!!!

  • wow, youre one lucky bastard. what was it like to have a lesson with him??? i want all the details.

  • Oh.My.God.

  • Amazing! The daunting Triple Étude...so many voices running simultaneously... Only a Supervirtuoso like Hamelin could accomplish such a feat! This Étude is even more challenging than the impossible Godowsky Études. Too bad Hamelin never tours in my country (Portugal)... :(

  • yes,but in your country you can see the great Maria Joao Pires,and Ricardo Castro...oh...and Cristiano Ronaldo :))

  • that's insane

  • well,i used to think that he was a psychotic yet outstanding virtuoso who liked to play all the incredibly difficult pieces of the piano repertoire,but no......he is funny too...nice sense of humor.thank you, ire58591

  • hamelin is one of the nicest musicians i have ever met, both pros and non-pros. his nice personality and comedy jsut seems like second-nature. his comical commentaries for his encores are commonplace.

  • so,you 've really met him?in canada i suppose....or not?

  • i met him in san francisco on april 28 (for a lecture) and april 29 (for a concert).

  • i would like to see him one day...but he doesn't perform in europe, does he?

  • he performs in europe more than in the US. you can find his concert schedule here: http://www.giamanagement.com/c­oncertdiary.asp?MusicianID=2

  • oh, thanks a lot! :)

  • amazing!!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more