Nine Inch Nails at Pemberton: Discipline

[Rikushix]

Pemberton Festival was fucking amazing.

[sexyrigirl]

seeing this in concert was such a rush . i was in the USA great musician and also great with that computer and the graphics in his concerts and videos! another ICON i think

[feckkol]

Without a doubt the best song of the slip, followed by echoplex.

[bojanglesselgnajob]

man i remember being just high and drunk as shit in the mosh pit, just grooving to these beats.......... great times

[V19torrent]

yeah thats sorta what happened to me when I saw them. I just wish I wasnt so drunk so i could actually remember some of that show! haha

[pantherleal]

i fuckin saw them live! they are just simply amazing! i cant wait to see them again!

[briani4735263]

What a guy. I mean seriously.

[dudemangangsta]

i was there

[618Fjk]

This song sounds a lot better live you can really hear the bass

[AenimasEulogy]

they are incredible live. oO

[STE7EN77]

this song sounds better ina gig atmosphere, deadly

[angel4rmhell78]

i love nin there awesome

[Usernamesstink]

yea dude, i just saw them in philly. utterly amazing. I too feel a longing in my heart to be back at a nine inch nails concert

[BobV5467]

Wow I just saw them in Philadelphia and he had a sore throat and couldn't do the high part of this song. It's got to be tough on your throat to scream for that long almost every night for months and for almost two decades. Good to see that he really can sing well though.

[metalmastergirl]

How long was the show, magmazing? speaking only of NIN of course

[officialryan1]

around 2.5 hours

[grambo22]

The Pemberton set was a bit over 90minutes, 9:30-11, ended I think at 11:10.

[CRAZYslowpoke]

just seeing this again on video makes me shiver with excitement. that weekend was so good

[izbo62]

love that song! please robin stays in NIN, Trent is amazing!

[kazer01]

robin stay in NiN and slash returns again a GnR is my dream!!!

[zmatheson]

EVEN A WEEK AFTER THE AFTERMATH OF PEMBERTON, IM STILL GOING THROUGH IT ALL :(

I MISS PEMBERTON SO MUCH

PEMBERTON MUSIC FEST WAS THE BEST WEEKEND OF MY LIFE

IT WAS SO GOOD OF A TIME I STILL HAVE MY 3 WRIST BANDS ON. I Ended up Slicing My HEEL OFF tryna take a swin in that wicked looking water on the Traffic Jam Ride Back Home..

THOSE 5 DAYS IN PEMBERTON

CHEERS

TOO-PHAT

[mrhiway420]

props dude, pemby rocked, but dude ...imagine the egrms and nasty fluids that yer wristbands have accumulated?? especially if they on yer right hand?

[myrkeyjones]

Once again NIN slam dunks it !

[Darin847]

what a crazy light show, I WENT TO PEMBY!

[fergferguson]

fuck i'd say that sounds decent for a live festival proformance.. they're not robots, just close. i was there with plenty of beer in me and i was lovin it ;)

[avelione]

I dunno but this sounds shitty, I'm shocked as I'm adoring fan of NIN :/ maybe because I just had some beer...... but oh come on, or the sound is shitty or I miss some sounds......maybe I miss Aaron? anyway....I wont have any beer before watching NIN show ;p waiy, I had beer in Paris 3 years ago.... at least Trent wont drink alcohol :D

[wondersss15in90]

mann I was 2nd roww.. shitt soo happy i was a apart of this amazingness...

fucking NIN!!

[Brakish33]

Pretty good quality, thanks for uploading.

[MinnowBelcher]

LAME. I saw The Downward Spiral Tour in 95...Trent, no offense, you should have died after that.

[misshazy]

I think you should have died after that.

[patwhite010101]

hmmm, i think you should of died after that tour.

[4n1k8r]

good shit as always but whats up with the woman tabernancle choir supporting our man trent?

[avelione]

I think it's a little attempt to bring in some womenspirit into NIN. He can bring me into NIN allright! I can sing well :D

[falconer24]

unbelievable show. probably among the best live shows i've seen. especially liked the older stuff. "gave up" was the highlite for me. trent is a genius!

[ReginaVayne]

Thx for the vid!

I just don't like Justin's singing...

But as long as Robin's back in NIN, nothing else matters :)

[snewt]

/agree. I was so happy to see Robin back!!

[saeidbah]

I was the security guard at front stage. It was crazy man it was crazy .

We had difficulty to manage drunk guys and wild girls, but over all it was good.

[jo5erock]

you lucky bastard lol. I wish I can do your job and then let people do everything they want, I hate guards because some times are assholes I know you're just doing your job but still man, are you guys hiring? hahaha

[LauraWish]

oh come on, don't tell me you don't know how to handle wild girls ];)

[2504982206]

what a perfect example of an Epic BC party, with the most chillin vibes i`ve ever experianced.

[coastalcat86]

what a fucking show wasnt a big fan but after that im buying some cd's

[zmatheson]

TO ALL THAT WAS THERE on that beautiful weekend of July, 2008 in Beautiful Pemberton, BC :

One of the Some of the Best Days Of My Life

something that any and ever 20 Year Old Should Experience

A Time, a Chance, an Oppurtunity Of a Lifetime

Such A Beautiful Show

- Those 5 Days In Pemberton

Cheers to The 40,000 +

[LauraWish]

the song is great but Justin apparently tried to impersonate a female choir ;D sorry,I couldn't help myself :D don't be mad at me

[Gromklad]

Yeah he did, that is really weird.

I love the Slip though, I basically love all NIN.

[ElizaAlane]

lol I had this playing and wasn't paying attention to the vid, just heard the audio, I totally thought that whoever was shooting this or some chick standing next to the camera was where the female singing was coming from....just realized it was Justin lol

[JLPIII]

Aaron shoulda stayed in NIN. no offense to rob.

[diablecita]

WHY THIS SONG TURNS ME ON???

oh yes, BECAUSE TRENT IS HOTTER THAN HELL WHEN HE SINGS: 'once I stop I cannot stop myself'

[Hackmoune]

Dont get me wrong, i love NIN but the slip sounds a little weak, i still think Year Zero is so much better and original, but anyway,Trent is still a musical god, and no doubt of that.

[kinetiknails]

3:07 - 3:12 interval. sounds like justin sings "once i fart, i cannot stop myself"

[JLPIII]

justin sorta sounds like a girl right around the end.

[42pigs]

who the hell is justin?

[qba95]

he plays bass guitar

[sokmonkey77]

Their bassist

[KkevinkK]

the slip kinda sucks, but they still kick ass overall!

[michealpelletier2]

yeah i think it was one of their worst but id still buy it and see them live when ever i get a chance

[KkevinkK]

I agree! I flew from one side of aus to another last year to see them in Melbourne, was brilliant!!

[DraxZombie]

Well, we all have our opinions. I like The Slip, I think is a pretty decent album.

[areskratos]

love it

[spacespace2]

sad to see what once was a good band turn into some chick band, robin looks like the only 1 half alive on stage,, but just barely. They look very stale.

[MSNOTHING]

omg the septermber show is sooo gonna kick ass

cant wait :D

[Jobana]

are you alowed to bring cameras at nin tour 08 concerts? :/

[djtrixen]

Jobana: Doubtful. However, I sincerely doubt they'll be able do too much about cell phones. :)

[ZeroShado0]

According to a poster at Echoing The Sound, the NIN representative who was handling the presale ticket will call said non-professional cameras and camcorders are alright. However, you should also check out the venue's rules to make sure the venue allows them.

[snaapz]

Awweee come on! Not one shirt being twirled around lol

Ace, man ace .. wicked live

[butjohnnycansing]

or a disco ball

[MorningStardust]

Thank you for uploading. I can't wait to see them in September

[NoiseHead242]

Awesome! thank you for this, I love it!

[livingspiral]

Awesome! Thanks for uploading this. Sound quality is pretty good. :)

[empte77]

fucking awesome!

[benhatesutube]

who might ally be? im a bit curious :p

[empte77]

alessandro cortini

[ufoenthusiast]

Are those chicks singing backup chorus near the end of the song?

[mastergeo7]

It's called a falsetto. And I think it's Ally who is singing that part.

[Killaya]

Ally's falsetto is gorgeous! :D

[djtrixen]

ufoenthusiast: No, that's a dude with a woman's voice. lol ;D

[colinmac87]

AMAZING!!! THANK YOU!!!

[VanityInPerson]

A perfect show, as always.

[U2Stay]

Thanks!

Great to see NIN live, if only on YouTube.

[celticlass73]

sounds tight!

[fran86beta]

hey man U can upload a vid with a lot of cool lcd effects hmmm just cuz NIN will be in my town too, so I wanna persuade some friends to go with me to the concert

thx for your attention and for the vids

[Ynnavoid]

Thanx For the video... great audio!